Prion protein helix1 promotes aggregation but is not converted into beta-sheet

Prion diseases are caused by the aggregation of the native alpha-helical prion protein PrP(C) into its pathological beta-sheet-rich isoform PrP(Sc). In current models of PrP(Sc), helix1 is assumed to be preferentially converted into beta-sheet during aggregation of PrP(C). This was supported by the NMR structure of PrP(C) since, in contrast to the isolated helix1, helix2 and helix3 are connected by a small loop and are additionally stabilized by an interhelical disulfide bond. However, helix1 is extremely hydrophilic and has a high helix propensity. This prompted us to investigate the role of helix1 in prion aggregation using humPrP(23-159) including helix1 (144-156) compared with the C-terminal-truncated isoform humPrP(23-144) corresponding to the pathological human stop mutations Q160Stop and Y145Stop, respectively. Most unexpectedly, humPrP(23-159) aggregated significantly faster compared with the truncated fragment humPrP(23-144), clearly demonstrating that helix1 is involved in the aggregation process. However, helix1 is not resistant to digestion with proteinase K in fibrillar humPrP(23-159), suggesting that helix1 is not converted to beta-sheet. This is confirmed by Fourier transformation infrared spectroscopy since there is almost no difference in beta-sheet content of humPrP(23-159) fibrils compared with humPrP(23-144). In conclusion, we provide strong direct evidence that in contrast to earlier assumptions helix1 is not converted into beta-sheet during aggregation of PrP(C) to PrP(Sc).     

Misfolding pathways of the prion protein probed by molecular dynamics simulations

Although the cellular monomeric form of the benign prion protein is now well characterized, a model for the monomer of the misfolded conformation (PrP(Sc)) remains elusive. PrP(Sc) quickly aggregates into highly insoluble fibrils making experimental structural characterization very difficult. The tendency to aggregation of PrP(Sc) in aqueous solution implies that the monomer fold must be hydrophobic. Here, by using molecular dynamics simulations, we have studied the cellular mouse prion protein and its D178N pathogenic mutant immersed in a hydrophobic environment (solution of CCl4), to reveal conformational changes and/or local structural weaknesses of the prion protein fold in unfavorable structural and thermodynamic conditions. Simulations in water have been also performed. Although observing in general a rather limited conformation activity in the nanosecond timescale, we have detected a significant weakening of the antiparallel beta-sheet of the D178N mutant in CCl4 and to a less extent in water. No weakening is observed for the native prion protein. The increase of beta-structure in the monomer, recently claimed as evidence for misfolding to PrP(Sc), has been also observed in this study irrespective of the thermodynamic or structural conditions, showing that this behavior is very likely an intrinsic characteristic of the prion protein fold.     

Methionine oxidation perturbs the structural core of the prion protein and suggests a generic misfolding pathway

Oxidative stress and misfolding of the prion protein (PrP(C)) are fundamental to prion diseases. We have therefore probed the effect of oxidation on the structure and stability of PrP(C). Urea unfolding studies indicate that H(2)O(2) oxidation reduces the thermodynamic stability of PrP(C) by as much as 9 kJ/mol. (1)H-(15)N NMR studies indicate methionine oxidation perturbs key hydrophobic residues on one face of helix-C as follows: Met-205, Val-209, and Met-212 together with residues Val-160 and Tyr-156. These hydrophobic residues pack together and form the structured core of the protein, stabilizing its ternary structure. Copper-catalyzed oxidation of PrP(C) causes a more significant alteration of the structure, generating a monomeric molten globule species that retains its native helical content. Further copper-catalyzed oxidation promotes extended β-strand structures that lack a cooperative fold. This transition from the helical molten globule to β-conformation has striking similarities to a misfolding intermediate generated at low pH. PrP may therefore share a generic misfolding pathway to amyloid fibers, irrespective of the conditions promoting misfolding. Our observations support the hypothesis that oxidation of PrP destabilizes the native fold of PrP(C), facilitating the transition to PrP(Sc). This study gives a structural and thermodynamic explanation for the high levels of oxidized methionine in scrapie isolates.     

Preventing misfolding of the prion protein by trimethylamine N-oxide

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies are a class of fatal neurodegenerative diseases linked to the prion protein. The prion protein normally exists in a soluble, globular state (PrP(C)) that appears to participate in copper metabolism in the central nervous system and/or signal transduction. Infection or disease occurs when an alternatively folded form of the prion protein (PrP(Sc)) converts soluble and predominantly alpha-helical PrP(C) into aggregates rich in beta-structure. The structurally disordered N-terminus adopts beta-structure upon conversion to PrP(Sc) at low pH. Chemical chaperones, such as trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO), can prevent formation of PrP(Sc) in scrapie-infected mouse neuroblastoma cells [Tatzelt, J., et al. (1996) EMBO J. 15, 6363-6373]. To explore the mechanism of TMAO protection of PrP(C) at the atomic level, molecular dynamics simulations were performed under conditions normally leading to conversion (low pH) with and without 1 M TMAO. In PrP(C) simulations at low pH, the helix content drops and the N-terminus is brought into the small native beta-sheet, yielding a PrP(Sc)-like state. Addition of 1 M TMAO leads to a decreased radius of gyration, a greater number of protein-protein hydrogen bonds, and a greater number of tertiary contacts due to the N-terminus forming an Omega-loop and packing against the structured core of the protein, not due to an increase in the level of extended structure as with the PrP(C) to PrP(Sc) simulation. In simulations beginning with the "PrP(Sc)-like" structure (derived from PrP(C) simulated at low pH in pure water) in 1 M TMAO, similar structural reorganization at the N-terminus occurred, disrupting the extended sheet. The mechanism of protection by TMAO appears to be exclusionary in nature, consistent with previous theoretical and experimental studies. The TMAO-induced N-terminal conformational change prevents residues that are important in the conversion of PrP(C) to PrP(Sc) from assuming extended sheet structure at low pH.     

Exploring structural and thermodynamic stabilities of human prion protein pathogenic mutants D202N, E211Q and Q217R

The central event in the pathogenesis of prion protein (PrP) is a profound conformational change from its α-helical (PrP(C)) to its β-sheet-rich isoform (PrP(Sc)). Many single amino acid mutations of PrP are associated with familial prion diseases, such as D202N, E211Q, and Q217R mutations located at the third native α-helix of human PrP. In order to explore the underlying structural and dynamic effects of these mutations, we performed all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations for the wild-type (WT) PrP and its mutants. The obtained results indicate that these amino acid substitutions have subtle effects on the protein structures, but show large changes of the overall electrostatic potential distributions. We can infer that the changes of PrP electrostatic surface due to the studied mutations may influence the intermolecular interactions during the aggregation process. In addition, the mutations also affect the thermodynamic stabilities of PrP.     

Crystal structure of the human prion protein reveals a mechanism for oligomerization

The pathogenesis of transmissible encephalopathies is associated with the conversion of the cellular prion protein, PrP(C), into a conformationally altered oligomeric form, PrP(Sc). Here we report the crystal structure of the human prion protein in dimer form at 2 A resolution. The dimer results from the three-dimensional swapping of the C-terminal helix 3 and rearrangement of the disulfide bond. An interchain two-stranded antiparallel beta-sheet is formed at the dimer interface by residues that are located in helix 2 in the monomeric NMR structures. Familial prion disease mutations map to the regions directly involved in helix swapping. This crystal structure suggests that oligomerization through 3D domain-swapping may constitute an important step on the pathway of the PrP(C) --> PrP(Sc) conversion.     

The residue 129 polymorphism in human prion protein does not confer susceptibility to Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease by altering the structure or global stability of PrPC

There are two common forms of prion protein (PrP) in humans, with either methionine or valine at position 129. This polymorphism is a powerful determinant of the genetic susceptibility of humans toward both sporadic and acquired forms of prion disease and restricts propagation of particular prion strains. Despite its key role, we have no information on the effect of this mutation on the structure, stability, folding, and dynamics of the cellular form of PrP (PrP(C)). Here, we show that the mutation has no measurable effect on the folding, dynamics, and stability of PrP(C). Our data indicate that the 129M/V polymorphism does not affect prion propagation through its effect on PrP(C); rather, its influence is likely to be downstream in the disease mechanism. We infer that the M/V effect is mediated through the conformation or stability of disease-related PrP (PrP(Sc)) or intermediates or on the kinetics of their formation.     

The effect of disease-associated mutations on the folding pathway of human prion protein

Propagation of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies is believed to involve the conversion of cellular prion protein, PrP(C), into a misfolded oligomeric form, PrP(Sc). An important step toward understanding the mechanism of this conversion is to elucidate the folding pathway(s) of the prion protein. We reported recently (Apetri, A. C., and Surewicz, W. K. (2002) J. Biol. Chem. 277, 44589-44592) that the folding of wild-type prion protein can best be described by a three-state sequential model involving a partially folded intermediate. Here we have performed kinetic stopped-flow studies for a number of recombinant prion protein variants carrying mutations associated with familial forms of prion disease. Analysis of kinetic data clearly demonstrates the presence of partially structured intermediates on the refolding pathway of each PrP variant studied. In each case, the partially folded state is at least one order of magnitude more populated than the fully unfolded state. The present study also reveals that, for the majority of PrP variants tested, mutations linked to familial prion diseases result in a pronounced increase in the thermodynamic stability, and thus the population, of the folding intermediate. These data strongly suggest that partially structured intermediates of PrP may play a crucial role in prion protein conversion, serving as direct precursors of the pathogenic PrP(Sc) isoform.     

Determinants of the in vivo folding of the prion protein. A bipartite function of helix 1 in folding and aggregation

Misfolding of the mammalian prion protein (PrP) is implicated in the pathogenesis of prion diseases. We analyzed wild type PrP in comparison with different PrP mutants and identified determinants of the in vivo folding pathway of PrP. The complete N terminus of PrP including the putative transmembrane domain and the first beta-strand could be deleted without interfering with PrP maturation. Helix 1, however, turned out to be a major determinant of PrP folding. Disruption of helix 1 prevented attachment of the glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI) anchor and the formation of complex N-linked glycans; instead, a high mannose PrP glycoform was secreted into the cell culture supernatant. In the absence of a C-terminal membrane anchor, however, helix 1 induced the formation of unglycosylated and partially protease-resistant PrP aggregates. Moreover, we could show that the C-terminal GPI anchor signal sequence, independent of its role in GPI anchor attachment, mediates core glycosylation of nascent PrP. Interestingly, conversion of high mannose glycans to complex type glycans only occurred when PrP was membrane-anchored. Our study indicates a bipartite function of helix 1 in the maturation and aggregation of PrP and emphasizes a critical role of a membrane anchor in the formation of complex glycosylated PrP.     

Exploring the propensities of helices in PrP(C) to form beta sheet using NMR structures and sequence alignments

Neurodegenerative diseases induced by transmissible spongiform encephalopathies are associated with prions. The most spectacular event in the formation of the infectious scrapie form, referred to as PrP(Sc), is the conformational change from the predominantly alpha-helical conformation of PrP(C) to the PrP(Sc) state that is rich in beta-sheet content. Using sequence alignments and structural analysis of the available nuclear magnetic resonance structures of PrP(C), we explore the propensities of helices in PrP(C) to be in a beta-strand conformation. Comparison of a number of structural characteristics (such as solvent accessible area, distribution of (Phi, Psi) angles, mismatches in hydrogen bonds, nature of residues in local and nonlocal contacts, distribution of regular densities of amino acids, clustering of hydrophobic and hydrophilic residues in helices) between PrP(C) structures and a databank of "normal" proteins shows that the most unusual features are found in helix 2 (H2) (residues 172-194) followed by helix 1 (H1) (residues 144-153). In particular, the C-terminal residues in H2 are frustrated in their helical state. The databank of normal proteins consists of 58 helical proteins, 36 alpha+beta proteins, and 31 beta-sheet proteins. Our conclusions are also substantiated by gapless threading calculations that show that the normalized Z-scores of prion proteins are similar to those of other alpha+beta proteins with low helical content. Application of the recently introduced notion of discordance, namely, incompatibility of the predicted and observed secondary structures, also points to the frustration of H2 not only in the wild type but also in mutants of human PrP(C). This suggests that the instability of PrP(C) proteins may play a role in their being susceptible to the profound conformational change. Our analysis shows that, in addition to the previously proposed role for the segment (90-120) and possibly H1, the C-terminus of H2 and possibly N-terminus may play a role in the alpha-->beta transition. An implication of our results is that the ease of polymerization depends on the unfolding rate of the monomer. Sequence alignments show that helices in avian prion proteins (chicken, duck, crane) are better accommodated in a helical state, which might explain the absence of PrP(Sc) formation over finite time scales in these species. From this analysis, we predict that correlated mutations that reduce the frustration in the second half of helix 2 in mammalian prion proteins could inhibit the formation of PrP(Sc).     

Conformational polymorphism of wild-type and mutant prion proteins: Energy landscape analysis

Conformational transitions are thought to be the prime mechanism of prion diseases. In this study, the energy landscapes of a wild-type prion protein (PrP) and the D178N and E200K mutant proteins were mapped, enabling the characterization of the normal isoforms (PrP(C)) and partially unfolded isoforms (PrP(PU)) of the three prion protein analogs. It was found that the three energy landscapes differ in three respects: (i) the relative stability of the PrP(C) and the PrP(PU) states, (ii) the transition pathways from PrP(C) to PrP(PU), and (iii) the relative stability of the three helices in the PrP(C) state. In particular, it was found that although helix 1 (residues 144-156) is the most stable helix in wild-type PrP, its stability is dramatically reduced by both mutations. This destabilization is due to changes in the charge distribution that affects the internal salt bridges responsible for the greater stability of this helix in wild-type PrP. Although both mutations result in similar destabilization of helix 1, they a have different effect on the overall stability of PrP(C) and of PrP(PU) isoforms and on structural properties. The destabilization of helix 1 by mutations provides additional evidences to the role of this helix in the pathogenic transition from the PrP(C) to the pathogenic isoform PrP(SC).     

Interaction of the cellular prion protein with raft-like lipid membranes

Conversion of the cellular isoform of the prion protein (PrP(C)) into the disease-associated isoform (PrP(Sc)) plays a key role in the development of prion diseases. Within its cellular pathway, PrP(C) undergoes several posttranslational modifications, i.e., the attachment of two N-linked glycans and a glycosyl phosphatidyl inositol (GPI) anchor, by which it is linked to the plasma membrane on the exterior cell surface. To study the interaction of PrP(C) with model membranes, we purified posttranslationally modified PrP(C) from transgenic Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. The mono-, di- and oligomeric states of PrP(C) free in solution were analyzed by analytical ultracentrifugation. The interaction of PrP(C) with model membranes was studied using both lipid vesicles in solution and lipid bilayers bound to a chip surface. The equilibrium and mechanism of PrP(C) association with the model membranes were analyzed by surface plasmon resonance. Depending on the degree of saturation of binding sites, the concentration of PrP(C) released from the membrane into aqueous solution was estimated at between 10(-9) and 10(-7) M. This corresponds to a free energy of the insertion reaction of -48 kJ/mol. Consequences for the conversion of PrP(C) to PrP(Sc) are discussed.     

The key-role of tyrosine 155 in the mechanism of prion transconformation as highlighted by a study of sheep mutant peptides

Prion protein is a strongly conserved and ubiquitous glycoprotein. The conformational conversion of the non-pathogenic cellular prion isoform (PrP(C)) into a pathogenic scrapie isoform (PrP(Sc)) is a fundamental event in the onset of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSE). During this conversion, helix H1 and its two flanking loops are known to undergo a conformational transition into a beta-like structure. In order to understand mechanisms which trigger this transconformation, sheep prion protein synthetic peptides spanning helix 1 and beta-strand 2 (residues 142-166) were studied: (1) the N3 peptide, studied earlier, is known to fold into beta-hairpin-like conformation in phosphate buffer at neutral pH and to adopt a helix H1 conformation when dissolved in trifluoroethanol/phosphate buffer mixture, (2) The R156A mutant (peptide R15) and (3) the Y155A mutant (peptide Y14) of the N3 peptide are studied by circular dichroism and NMR spectroscopy in this article. Structural characterization of these peptides highlights the key role of tyrosine 155 in the stabilization of the beta-hairpin-like conformation of the sheep peptide in phosphate buffer. We propose a model where tyrosine 155 could stabilize the beta-hairpin structure by creating a hydrophobic core in phosphate buffer, necessary to initiate the beta-type structure formation. In the turn, the side chain ionic interaction, E152-R156 described before, seems to play a minor role relative to the hydrophobic packing, as observed with the R156A mutation (peptide R15). Interestingly, homology at amino acid residue 155 could be responsible for the species barrier in TSE.     

Kinetic intermediate in the folding of human prion protein

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies are associated with the conversion of cellular prion protein, PrP(C), into a misfolded oligomeric form, PrP(Sc). Here we have examined the kinetics of folding and unfolding reactions for the recombinant human prion protein C-terminal fragment 90-231 at pH 4.8 and 7.0. The stopped-flow data provide clear evidence for the population of an intermediate on the refolding pathway of the prion protein as indicated by a pronounced curvature in chevron plots and the presence of significant burst phase amplitude in the refolding kinetics. In addition to its role in the normal prion protein folding, this intermediate likely represents a crucial monomeric precursor of the pathogenic PrP(Sc) isoform.     

Rare large scale subdomain motions in prion protein can initiate aggregation

The prion protein is thought to induce prion diseases by changing its conformation from the cellular form, PrP(C), into the infectious Scrapie-form, PrP(Sc). Little is known about the structural and dynamical features of this conformational change. We here introduce a novel concept that involves rare large scale motions between the subdomains beta1-alpha1-beta2 and alpha2-alpha3 in the carboxy-terminal, globular part of PrP. The interface between these two subdomains carries most pathogenic mutations known to be associated with prion diseases. Based on computational simulations as well as experimental results we propose that such a large scale motion subsequently destabilizes large parts of the cellular conformer PrP(C), thus, rendering it prone to structural rearrangements, including aggregation of now partially unfolded parts of the PrP sequence. We hypothesize that such large scale motions occur as a rare event even under equilibrium conditions and that the interaction of such partially destabilized PrP(C)-conformers, which we named PrP(C*), contributes to the formation of pathogenic oligomeric species of the prion protein.     

Chemical chaperones interfere with the formation of scrapie prion protein.

The fundamental event in prion diseases involves a conformational change in one or more of the alpha-helices of the cellular prion protein (PrP(C)) as they are converted into beta-sheets during the formation of the pathogenic isoform (PrP(Sc)). Here, we show that exposure of scrapie-infected mouse neuroblastoma (ScN2a) cells to reagents known to stabilize proteins in their native conformation reduced the rate and extent of PrP(Sc) formation. Such reagents include the cellular osmolytes glycerol and trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO) and the organic solvent dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), which we refer to as 'chemical chaperones' because of their influence on protein folding. Although the chemical chaperones did not appear to affect the existing population of PrP(Sc) molecules in ScN2a cells, they did interfere with the formation of PrP(Sc) from newly synthesized PrP(C). We suggest that the chemical chaperones act to stabilize the alpha-helical conformation of PrP(C) and thereby prevent the protein from undergoing a conformational change to produce PrP(Sc). These observations provide further support for the idea that prions arise due to a change in protein conformation and reveal potential strategies for preventing PrP(Sc) formation.     

The elusive intermediate on the folding pathway of the prion protein

A key molecular event in prion diseases is the conversion of the cellular conformation of the prion protein (PrP(C)) to an altered disease-associated form, generally denoted as scrapie isoform (PrP(Sc)). The molecular details of this conformational transition are not fully understood, but it has been suggested that an intermediate on the folding pathway of PrP(C) may be recruited to form PrP(Sc). In order to investigate the folding pathway of PrP we designed and expressed two mutants, each possessing a single strategically located tryptophan residue. The secondary structure and folding properties of the mutants were examined. Using conventional analyses of folding transition data determined by fluorescence and CD, and novel phase-diagram analyses, we present compelling evidence for the presence of an intermediate species on the folding pathway of PrP. The potential role of this intermediate in prion conversion is discussed.     

Novel heparan mimetics potently inhibit the scrapie prion protein and its endocytosis

During prion diseases the normal prion protein PrP(C) is refolded into an abnormal conformer PrP(Sc). We have studied the PrP(Sc) inhibiting activity of a library of synthetic heparan mimetic (HM) biopolymers. HMs are chemically derived dextrans obtained by successive substitutions with carboxymethyl, benzylamide, and sulfate groups on glucose residues. Some HMs eliminated PrP(Sc) from prion-infected cells after a 5 day course at 100 ng/ml and were 15 x potent than pentosan sulfate in this system. The anti-PrP(Sc) activity of HMs correlated with the degree of sulfation but was increased by benzylamidation. HMs did not reduce the synthesis of PrP(C) nor its attachment to lipid rafts, but instead blocked its conversion into PrP(Sc). The anti-PrP(Sc) HMs also prevented the uptake of prion rods by cultured cells. HMs may thus block the interaction of PrP(Sc) with a putative cellular receptor, possibly heparan sulfate. HMs provide an attractive chemical approach for the synthesis of TSE therapeutic and prophylactic reagents.     

Diverse effects on the native β-sheet of the human prion protein due to disease-associated mutations

Prion diseases are fatal neurodegenerative disorders that involve the conversion of the normal cellular form of the prion protein (PrP(C)) to a misfolded pathogenic form (PrP(Sc)). There are many genetic mutations of PrP associated with human prion diseases. Three of these point mutations are located at the first strand of the native β-sheet in human PrP: G131V, S132I, and A133V. To understand the underlying structural and dynamic effects of these disease-causing mutations on the human PrP, we performed molecular dynamics of wild-type and mutated human PrP. The results indicate that the mutations induced different effects but they were all related to misfolding of the native β-sheet: G131V caused the elongation of the native β-sheet, A133V disrupted the native β-sheet, and S132I converted the native β-sheet to an α-sheet. The observed changes were due to the reorientation of side chain-side chain interactions upon introducing the mutations. In addition, all mutations impaired a structurally conserved water site at the native β-sheet. Our work suggests various misfolding pathways for human PrP in response to mutation.     

Long-time scale fluctuations of human prion protein determined by restrained MD simulations

Cellular prion protein (PrP(C)) has the ability to trigger transmissible lethal diseases after in vivo maturation into a toxic amyloidogenic misfolded form (PrP(Sc)). Here, we use hydrogen exchange protection factors in restrained molecular dynamics simulations to characterize long-time scale fluctuations in human PrP(C). We find that the regions of residues 138-141 and 183-192 form new β-strands in several exchange-competent structures. Moreover, these structural changes are associated with the disruption of native contacts that when tethered prevent fibril formation. Our findings illustrate the structural plasticity of PrP(C) and are valuable for understanding the conversion of PrP(C) to PrP(Sc).