Ultrastructural studies on the collagen of the marine sponge Chondrosia reniformis Nardo

The ultrastructure of isolated fibrils of Chondrosia reniformis sponge collagen was investigated by collecting characteristic data, such as fibril thickness, width, D-band periodicity, and height modulation, using atomic force microscopy (AFM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Therefore an adapted pre-processing of the insoluble collagen into homogeneous suspensions using neutral buffer solutions was essential, and several purification steps have been developed. Fourier transform infrared reflection-absorption spectroscopy (FT-IRAS) of the purified sponge collagen showed remarkable analogy of peak positions and intensities with the spectra of fibrillar calf skin type I collagen, despite the diverse phylogenetic and evolutionary origin. The sponge collagen's morphology is compared with that of other fibrillar collagens, and the typical banding of the separated single fibrils is discussed by comparison of topographical data obtained using AFM and corresponding TEM investigations using common staining methods. As the TEM images of the negatively stained fibrils showed alternating dark and light bands, AFM revealed a characteristic periodicity of protrusions (overlap zones) followed by two equal interband regions (gap zones). AFM and TEM results were correlated and multiperiodicity in Chondrosia collagen's banding is demonstrated. The periodic dark bands observed in TEM images correspond directly to the periodic protrusions seen by AFM. As a result, we provide an improved, updated model of the collagen's structure and organization.     

Molecular packing in type I collagen fibrils. A model with neighbouring collagen molecules aligned in axial register

A detailed stereochemical analysis of intermolecular interactions of collagens made with molecular models and summarized experimental data resulted in a new three-dimensional structural model for collagen fibrils. In this model collagen molecules aligned in axial register form a bunch. The bunches are aligned head to tail and penetrate by 300 A into each other, forming microfibrils; these in turn assemble into fibrils. The new model differs from all the others in that its characteristic axial regularity, with a period of 670 A, results from staggering of the adjacent microfibrils formed by unstaggered molecules rather than from the axial staggering of neighbouring collagen molecules.     

The Self-assembly of a Mini-fibril with Axial Periodicity from a Designed Collagen-mimetic Triple Helix

In this work we describe the self-assembly of a collagen-like periodic mini-fibril from a recombinant triple helix. The triple helix, designated Col108, is expressed in Escherichia coli using an artificial gene and consists of a 378-residue triple helix domain organized into three pseudo-repeating sequence units. The peptide forms a stable triple helix with a melting temperature of 41 °C. Upon increases of pH and temperature, Col108 self-assembles in solution into smooth mini-fibrils with the cross-striated banding pattern typical of fibrillar collagens. The banding pattern is characterized by an axially repeating feature of ∼35 nm as observed by transmission electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy. Both the negatively stained and the positively stained transmission electron microscopy patterns of the Col108 mini-fibrils are consistent with a staggered arrangement of triple helices having a staggering value of 123 residues, a value closely connected to the size of one repeat sequence unit. A mechanism is proposed for the mini-fibril formation of Col108 in which the axial periodicity is instigated by the built-in sequence periodicity and stabilized by the optimized interactions between the triple helices in a 1-unit staggered arrangement. Lacking hydroxyproline residues and telopeptides, two factors implicated in the fibrillogenesis of native collagen, the Col108 mini-fibrils demonstrate that sequence features of the triple helical domain alone are sufficient to “code” for axially repeating periodicity of fibrils. To our knowledge, Col108 is the first designed triple helix to self-assemble into periodic fibrils and offers a unique opportunity to unravel the specific molecular interactions of collagen fibrillogenesis.     

Nanomechanical Mapping of Hydrated Rat Tail Tendon Collagen I Fibrils

Collagen fibrils play an important role in the human body, providing tensile strength to connective tissues. These fibrils are characterized by a banding pattern with a D-period of 67 nm. The proposed origin of the D-period is the internal staggering of tropocollagen molecules within the fibril, leading to gap and overlap regions and a corresponding periodic density fluctuation. Using an atomic force microscope high-resolution modulus maps of collagen fibril segments, up to 80 μm in length, were acquired at indentation speeds around 10⁵ nm/s. The maps revealed a periodic modulation corresponding to the D-period as well as previously undocumented micrometer scale fluctuations. Further analysis revealed a 4/5, gap/overlap, ratio in the measured modulus providing further support for the quarter-staggered model of collagen fibril axial structure. The modulus values obtained at indentation speeds around 10⁵ nm/s are significantly larger than those previously reported. Probing the effect of indentation speed over four decades reveals two distinct logarithmic regimes of the measured modulus and point to the existence of a characteristic molecular relaxation time around 0.1 ms. Furthermore, collagen fibrils exposed to temperatures between 50 and 62°C and cooled back to room temperature show a sharp decrease in modulus and a sharp increase in fibril diameter. This is also associated with a disappearance of the D-period and the appearance of twisted subfibrils with a pitch in the micrometer range. Based on all these data and a similar behavior observed for cross-linked polymer networks below the glass transition temperature, we propose that collagen I fibrils may be in a glassy state while hydrated.     

Nanomechanical Mapping of Hydrated Rat Tail Tendon Collagen I Fibrils

Collagen fibrils play an important role in the human body, providing tensile strength to connective tissues. These fibrils are characterized by a banding pattern with a D-period of 67 nm. The proposed origin of the D-period is the internal staggering of tropocollagen molecules within the fibril, leading to gap and overlap regions and a corresponding periodic density fluctuation. Using an atomic force microscope high-resolution modulus maps of collagen fibril segments, up to 80 μm in length, were acquired at indentation speeds around 10⁵ nm/s. The maps revealed a periodic modulation corresponding to the D-period as well as previously undocumented micrometer scale fluctuations. Further analysis revealed a 4/5, gap/overlap, ratio in the measured modulus providing further support for the quarter-staggered model of collagen fibril axial structure. The modulus values obtained at indentation speeds around 10⁵ nm/s are significantly larger than those previously reported. Probing the effect of indentation speed over four decades reveals two distinct logarithmic regimes of the measured modulus and point to the existence of a characteristic molecular relaxation time around 0.1 ms. Furthermore, collagen fibrils exposed to temperatures between 50 and 62°C and cooled back to room temperature show a sharp decrease in modulus and a sharp increase in fibril diameter. This is also associated with a disappearance of the D-period and the appearance of twisted subfibrils with a pitch in the micrometer range. Based on all these data and a similar behavior observed for cross-linked polymer networks below the glass transition temperature, we propose that collagen I fibrils may be in a glassy state while hydrated.     

To achieve self‐assembled collagen mimetic fibrils using designed peptides

It has proven challenging to obtain collagen‐mimetic fibrils by protein design. We recently reported the self‐assembly of a mini‐fibril showing a 35 nm, D‐period like, axially repeating structure using the designed triple helix Col108. Peptide Col108 was made by bacterial expression using a synthetic gene; its triple helix domain consists of three pseudo‐identical units of amino acid sequence arranged in tandem. It was postulated that the 35 nm d‐period of Col108 mini‐fibrils originates from the periodicity of the Col108 primary structure. A mutual staggering of one sequence unit of the associating Col108 triple helices can maximize the inter‐helical interactions and produce the observed 35 nm d‐period. Based on this unit‐staggered model, a triple helix consisting of only two sequence units is expected to have the potential to form the same d‐periodic mini‐fibrils. Indeed, when such a peptide, peptide 2U108, was made it was found to self‐assemble into mini‐fibrils having the same d‐period of 35 nm. In contrast, no d‐periodic mini‐fibrils were observed for peptide 1U108, which does not have long‐range repeating sequences in its primary structure. The findings of the periodic mini‐fibrils of Col108 and 2U108 suggest a way forward to create collagen‐mimetic fibrils for biomedical and industrial applications.     

Transition metal ions induce cell growth in NRK cells synchronized in G1 by picolinic acid.

Analyses of the way in which the amino acid sequence of the α1 chain of a collagen molecule can specify the Hodge-Petruska staggered fibrilstructure have been unable to show how this sequence can specify the direction as well as the magnitude of stagger between neighbouring molecules. We propose that the role of the α2 chain in non-tissue-specific collagens is to introduce a heterogeneity into the interactions between molecules that enables this direction to be specified. Our proposal is supported by a simple one-dimensional theoretical treatment. We predict that fibrils made up of collagen molecules with three identical chains will not have regular three-dimensional lattices.     

Origins and implications of the D stagger in collagen

Although the distribution of hydrophobic residues in the α1 chain collagen sequence has a D ? 670 Å periodicity, it is dipoles formed by 100 residues occurring in pairs of unlike charge which are responsible for the 1D stagger between molecules. Sheet models based on the Hodge-Petruska model for the axially projected collagen structure require interactions specifying 1D and 4D staggers. We found no evidence for interactions specifying a strong 4D stagger and, therefore, favour the Smith microfibril model which is specified by 1D stagger interactions alone. Two hydroxylysine residues, 234 residues apart, may form a covalent cross-link stabilising the 1D stagger. Gene duplication does not appear to be responsible for the periodicity in the sequence.     

Mineralized collagen fibrils: a mechanical model with a staggered arrangement of mineral particles

Both elastic modulus and fracture stress are known to increase with the amount of mineral deposited within collagen fibrils. Current mechanical models of mineralized fibrils, where mineral platelets are arranged in parallel arrays, reproduce the first effect but fail to predict an increase in fracture stress. Here, we propose a model with a staggered array of platelets that is in better agreement with results on molecular packing in collagen fibrils and that accounts for an increase of both elastic modulus and fracture stress with the amount of mineral in the fibril. Finally, we explore the dependence of the mechanical properties within the model, when the degree of mineralization and the thickness of the platelets as well as their distance varies.     

Hierarchical assembly and the onset of banding in fibrous long spacing collagen revealed by atomic force microscopy.

The mechanism of formation of fibrillar collagen with a banding periodicity much greater than the 67 nm of native collagen, i.e. the so-called fibrous long spacing (FLS) collagen, has been speculated upon, but has not been previously studied experimentally from a detailed structural perspective. In vitro, such fibrils, with banding periodicity of approximately 270 nm, may be produced by dialysis of an acidic solution of type I collagen and alpha(1)-acid glycoprotein against deionized water. FLS collagen assembly was investigated by visualization of assembly intermediates that were formed during the course of dialysis using atomic force microscopy. Below pH 4, thin, curly nonbanded fibrils were formed. When the dialysis solution reached approximately pH 4, thin, filamentous structures that showed protrusions spaced at approximately 270 nm were seen. As the pH increased, these protofibrils appeared to associate loosely into larger fibrils with clear approximately 270 nm banding which increased in diameter and compactness, such that by approximately pH 4.6, mature FLS collagen fibrils begin to be observed with increasing frequency. These results suggest that there are aspects of a stepwise process in the formation of FLS collagen, and that the banding pattern arises quite early and very specifically in this process. It is proposed that typical 4D-period staggered microfibril subunits assemble laterally with minimal stagger between adjacent fibrils. alpha(1)-Acid glycoprotein presumably promotes this otherwise abnormal lateral assembly over native-type self-assembly. Cocoon-like fibrils, which are hundreds of nanometers in diameter and 10-20 microm in length, were found to coexist with mature FLS fibrils.     

Crystalline fibril structure of type II collagen in lamprey notochord sheath

We report here the existence of a crystalline molecular packing of type II collagen in the fibrils of the lamprey notochord sheath. This is the first finding of a crystalline structure in any collagen other than type I.The lamprey notochord sheath has a composition similar to that of cartilage, with type II collagen, a minor collagen component with 1α, 2α and 3α chains, and cartilage-like proteoglycan. The high degree of orientation of fibrils in the notochord makes it possible to use X-ray diffraction to determine collagen fibril organization in this type II-containing tissue. The low angle equatorial scattering shows the fibrils are all about 17 nm in diameter and have an average center-to-center separation of 31 nm. These results are supported by electron microscope observations. A set of broad equatorial diffraction maxima at higher angles represents the sampling of the collagen molecular transform by a limited crystalline lattice, extending over a lateral dimension close to the diameter of one fibril. This indicates that each 17 nm fibril contains a crystalline array of molecules and, although a unit cell is difficult to determine because of the broad overlapping reflections, it is clear that the quasi-hexagonal triclinic unit cell of type I collagen in rat tail tendon is not consistent with the data. The meridional diffraction pattern showed 26 orders with the characteristic 67 nm periodicity found for tendon. However, the intensities of these reflections differ markedly from those found for tendon and cannot be explained by an unmodified gap/ overlap model within each 67 nm period. Both X-ray diffraction and electron microscope data indicate a low degree of contrast along the fibril axis and are consistent with a periodic binding of a non-collagenous component in such a way as to obscure the gap region.     

Type VI collagen in extracellular, 100-nm periodic filaments and fibrils: identification by immunoelectron microscopy

Filaments and fibrils that exhibit a 100-nm axial periodicity and occur in the medium and in the deposited extracellular matrix of chicken embryo and human fibroblast cultures have been tentatively identified with type VI collagen on the basis of their similar structural characteristics (Bruns, R. R., 1984, J. Ultrastruct. Res., 89:136-145). Using indirect immunoelectron microscopy and specific monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies, we now report their positive identification with collagen VI and their distribution in fibroblast cultures and in tendon. Primary human foreskin fibroblast cultures, labeled with anti-type VI antibody and studied by fluorescence microscopy, showed a progressive increase in labeling and changes in distribution with time up to 8 d in culture. With immunoelectron microscopy and monoclonal antibodies to human type VI collagen followed by goat anti-mouse IgG coupled to colloidal gold, they showed in thin sections specific 100-nm periodic labeling on extracellular filaments and fibrils: one monoclonal antibody (3C4) attached to the band region and another (4B10) to the interband region of the filaments and fibrils. Rabbit antiserum to type VI collagen also localized on the band region, but the staining was less well defined. Control experiments with antibodies to fibronectin and to procollagen types I and III labeled other filaments and fibrils, but not those with a 100-nm period. Heavy metal-stained fibrils with the same periodic and structural characteristics also have been found in both adult rat tail tendon and embryonic chicken tendon subjected to prolonged incubation in culture medium or treatment with adenosine 5'-triphosphate at pH 4.6. We conclude that the 100-nm periodic filaments and fibrils represent the native aggregate form of type VI collagen. It is likely that banded fibrils of the same periodicity and appearance, reported by many observers over the years in a wide range of normal and pathological tissues, are at least in part, type VI collagen.     

Invertebrate data predict an early emergence of vertebrate fibrillar collagen clades and an anti-incest model

Fibrillar collagens are involved in the formation of striated fibrils and are present from the first multicellular animals, sponges, to humans. Recently, a new evolutionary model for fibrillar collagens has been suggested (Boot-Handford, R. P., Tuckwell, D. S., Plumb, D. A., Farrington Rock, C., and Poulsom, R. (2003) J. Biol. Chem. 278, 31067-31077). In this model, a rare genomic event leads to the formation of the founder vertebrate fibrillar collagen gene prior to the early vertebrate genome duplications and the radiation of the vertebrate fibrillar collagen clades (A, B, and C). Here, we present the modular structure of the fibrillar collagen chains present in different invertebrates from the protostome Anopheles gambiae to the chordate Ciona intestinalis. From their modular structure and the use of a triple helix instead of C-propeptide sequences in phylogenetic analyses, we were able to show that the divergence of A and B clades arose early during evolution because alpha chains related to these clades are present in protostomes. Moreover, the event leading to the divergence of B and C clades from a founder gene arose before the appearance of vertebrates; altogether these data contradict the Boot-Handford model. Moreover, they indicate that all the key steps required for the formation of fibrils of variable structure and functionality arose step by step during invertebrate evolution.     

When is it safe to use an oversimplified substitution model in tree- making?

The choice of an "optimal" mathematical model for computing evolutionary distances from real sequences is not currently supported by easy-to-use software applicable to large data sets, and an investigator frequently selects one of the simplest models available. Here we study properties of the observed proportion of differences (p- distance) between sequences as an estimator of evolutionary distance for tree-making. We show that p-distances allow for consistent tree- making with any of the popular methods working with evolutionary distances if evolution of sequences obeys a "molecular clock" (more precisely, if it follows a stationary time-reversible Markov model of nucleotide substitution). Next, we show that p-distances seem to be efficient in recovering the correct tree topology under a "molecular clock," but produce "statistically supported" wrong trees when substitutions rates vary among evolutionary lineages. Finally, we outline a practical approach for selecting an "optimal" model of nucleotide substitution in a real data analysis, and obtain a crude estimate of a "prior" distribution of the expected tree branch lengths under the Jukes-Cantor model. We conclude that the use of a model that is obviously oversimplified is inadvisable unless it is justified by a preliminary analysis of the real sequences.      

Interaction of collagen molecules from the aspect of fibril formation: acid-soluble, alkali-treated, and MMP1-digested fragments of type I collagen.

Collagen type I extracted with acid or digested with pepsin forms fibrils under physiological conditions, but this ability is lost when the collagen is treated with alkaline solution or digested with matrix metalloproteinase 1 (MMP1). When acid-soluble collagen was incubated with alkali-treated collagen, the fibril formation of acid-soluble collagen was inhibited. At 37 degrees C, at which alkali-treated collagen is denatured, the lag time was prolonged but the growth rate of fibrils was not affected. At 30 degrees C, at which the triple helical conformation of alkali-treated collagen is retained, the lag time was prolonged and the growth rate reduced. Heat-denatured alkali-treated collagen and MMP1-digested fragments have no inhibitory effect on the fibril formation of acid-soluble collagen. This means that the triple helical conformation and the molecular length are important factors in the interaction of collagen molecules and that alkali-treated collagen acts as a competitive inhibitor for fibril formation of collagen. We found that alkali-treated collagen and MMP1-digested fragments form fibrils that lack the D periodic banding pattern and twisted morphology under acidic conditions at the appropriate ionic strength. We also calculated the relative strengths of hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions between collagen molecules. When the hydrophobic interaction between linear collagen molecules was considered, we found a pattern of periodic maximization of the interactive force including the D period. On the other hand, the electrostatic interaction did not show the periodic pattern, but the overall interaction score affected fibril formation.     

A model for type II collagen fibrils: distinctive D-band patterns in native and reconstituted fibrils compared with sequence data for helix and telopeptide domains

The periodical D-band pattern is generally considered a unique ultrastructural feature shared by all fibril-forming collagens, which correlates with the intrafibril, paracrystalline array of tropocollagen monomers. Distinct band patterns have been reported, however, for collagen stained long-spacing (SLS) crystallites of genetic types I, II, and III. Moreover, D-band patterns of negatively stained, native type II collagen fibrils were found to be not identical to those of type I in our previous research. Because of (a) these distinctive features, (b) tropocollagen heterotrimeric conditions (type I) vs homotrimeric conditions (type II), and (c) different lengths and poor homology between extrahelical telopeptides, the molecular array or telopeptide conformation within the extensively studied type I collagen fibrils could be not the same as those in the very much less intensively studied type II collagen fibrils. In this investigation, a distinctive positive-staining D-band pattern was found for type II collagen fibrils obtained from human cartilages. A fibril model was developed by analyzing actual D-band patterns, and matching them against simulated patterns based on the primary structure of extrahelical and helical domains in human type II tropocollagen. In particular, a more prominent b(1) band was apparent in native type II collagen fibrils than in type I. This distinctive feature was also observed for native-type collagen fibrils reconstituted from purified type II collagen, i.e., free from associated minor type XI collagen. On modeling possible monomer arrays, the best fit between microdensitograms and simulation traces was found for 234 amino acid staggering, as is also the case for type I collagen fibrils. On comparing this model with an analogous one for type I collagen fibrils, there was a higher intraband distribution of charged residues for band b(1), consistent with the higher electrondensity observed for this band in type II collagen fibrils. N- and C-telopeptide displacement in the model corresponded to D-locations of a c(2) subband, which we named c(2.0), and band a(3), respectively. In simulation profiles, c(2.0) -like and a(3) -like peaks mimicked the corresponding peaks in microdensitograms when molecular reversals were adopted at positions 10N-12N, 12C-14C, and 17C-19C for N- and C-telopeptides. Hydrophobic interactions and algorithmic predictions of protein secondary structure, according to Chou and Fasman and Rost and Sander criteria, were consistent with these conformational models, and suggest that an additional molecular reversal may occur at positions 3N-5N. These telopeptide "S-fold" conformations, interpreted as axial projections of tridimensional conformation, may represent starting points for further investigation into the still unresolved tridimensional conformation of telopeptides in monomers arrayed within type II collagen fibrils.     

The positive staining pattern of skin collagen in chronic haemodialysis patients

The positive staining pattern of skin collagen fibrils from chronic haemodialysis patients was studied by measn of electron microscopy. Such staining patterns were compared with those from normal control subjects. These visual comparisons reveal that in chronic haemodialysis, fibrils retain normal banding periodicity. Disturbances of collagen molecular or fibril architecture brought about by chronic haemodialysis are also discussed.     

Growth of Collagen Fibril Seeds from Embryonic Tendon: Fractured Fibril Ends Nucleate New Tip Growth

Collagen fibrils are the principal tensile element of vertebrate tissues where they occur in the extracellular matrix as spatially organised arrays. A major challenge is to understand how the mechanisms of nucleation, growth and remodelling yield fibrils of tissue-specific diameter and length. Here we have developed a seeding system whereby collagen fibrils were isolated from avian embryonic tendon and added to purified collagen solution, in order to characterise fibril surface nucleation and growth mechanisms. Fragmentation of tendon in liquid nitrogen followed by Dounce homogenisation generated fibril length fragments. Most (> 94%) of the fractured ends of fibrils, which show an abrupt square profile, were found to act as nucleation sites for further growth by molecular accretion. The mechanism of this nucleation and growth process was investigated by transmission electron microscopy, atomic force microscopy and scanning transmission electron microscopy mass mapping. Typically, a single growth spur occurred on the N-terminal end of seed fibrils whilst twin spurs frequently formed on the C-terminal end before merging into a single tip projection. The surface nucleation and growth process generated a smoothly tapered tip that achieved maximum diameter when the axial extension reached ∼ 13 μm. Lateral growth also occurred along the entire length of all seed fibrils that contained tip projections. The data support a model of collagen fibril growth in which the broken ends of fibrils are nucleation sites for propagation in opposite axial directions. The observed fibril growth behaviour has direct relevance to tendon matrix remodelling and repair processes that might involve rupture of collagen fibrils.     

Molecular dynamics simulations on networks of heparin and collagen

Synthetic scaffolds containing collagen (Type I) are of increasing interest for bone tissue engineering, especially for highly porous biomaterials in combination with glycosaminoglycans. In experiments the integration of heparin during the fibrillogenesis resulted in different types of collagen fibrils, but models for this aggregation on a molecular scale were only tentative. We conducted molecular dynamic simulations investigating the binding of heparin to collagen and the influence of the telopeptides during collagen aggregation. This aims at explaining experimental findings on a molecular level. Novel structures for N‐ and C‐telopeptides were developed with the TIGER2 replica exchange algorithm and dihedral principle component analysis. We present an extended statistical analysis of the mainly electrostatic interaction between heparin and collagen and identify several binding sites. Finally, we propose a molecular mechanism for the influence of glycosaminoglycans on the morphology of collagen fibrils. Proteins 2017; 85:1119–1130. © 2017 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.