Long-range distance determinations in biomacromolecules by EPR spectroscopy

Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy provides a variety of tools to study structures and structural changes of large biomolecules or complexes thereof. In order to unravel secondary structure elements, domain arrangements or complex formation, continuous wave and pulsed EPR methods capable of measuring the magnetic dipole coupling between two unpaired electrons can be used to obtain long-range distance constraints on the nanometer scale. Such methods yield reliably and precisely distances of up to 80 A, can be applied to biomolecules in aqueous buffer solutions or membranes, and are not size limited. They can be applied either at cryogenic or physiological temperatures and down to amounts of a few nanomoles. Spin centers may be metal ions, metal clusters, cofactor radicals, amino acid radicals, or spin labels. In this review, we discuss the advantages and limitations of the different EPR spectroscopic methods, briefly describe their theoretical background, and summarize important biological applications. The main focus of this article will be on pulsed EPR methods like pulsed electron-electron double resonance (PELDOR) and their applications to spin-labeled biosystems.     

Studying biomolecular complexes with pulsed electron-electron double resonance spectroscopy

The function of biomolecules is intrinsically linked to their structure and the complexes they form during function. Techniques for the determination of structures and dynamics of these nanometre assemblies are therefore important for an understanding on the molecular level. PELDOR (pulsed electron-electron double resonance) is a pulsed EPR method that can be used to reliably and precisely measure distances in the range 1.5-8?nm, to unravel orientations and to determine the number of monomers in complexes. In conjunction with site-directed spin labelling, it can be applied to biomolecules of all sizes in aqueous solutions or membranes. PELDOR is therefore complementary to the methods of X-ray crystallography, NMR and FRET (fluorescence resonance energy transfer) and is becoming a powerful method for structural determination of biomolecules. In the present review, the methods of PELDOR are discussed and examples where PELDOR has been used to obtain structural information on biomolecules are summarized.     

PELDOR analysis of enzyme-induced structural changes in damaged DNA duplexes

PELDOR (pulsed electron-electron double resonance) spectroscopy was applied to determine spin-spin distances in spin-labeled DNA duplexes (13-mer and 17-mer) containing the damaged sites 8-oxoguanine or uncleavable abasic site analogue tetrahydrofuran. The lesions were located in one strand of the DNA, and two nitroxyl spin labels were attached at the 5'- and 3'-ends of the complementary strand. PELDOR data allow us to obtain distances between the two spin labels in DNAs, which turned out to be around 5 nm for the 13-mer DNA and around 6 nm for 17-mer DNA. Results of PELDOR measurements were supported by molecular dynamics calculations. Study of the interaction of DNA fragments with DNA repair enzyme 8-oxoguanine-DNA glycosylase from E. coli (Fpg protein) showed that this interaction leads to a noticeable decrease of the distance between spin labels, which indicates the enzyme-induced bending of the DNA duplex. This bending may be important for the mechanisms of recognition of damaged sites by DNA repair enzymes.     

Pulsed EPR spectroscopy on short-lived intermediates in Photosystem I.

The application of pulsed electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy on short-lived intermediates in Photosystem I is reviewed. The spin polarization in light-induced radical pairs gives rise to a phase shifted 'out-of-phase' electron spin echo signal. This echo signal shows a prominent modulation of its intensity as a function of the spacing between the two microwave pulses. Its modulation frequency is determined by the electron-electron spin couplings within the radical pair. Thereby, the measurement of the dipolar coupling gives direct information about the spin-spin distance and can therefore be used to determine cofactor distances with high precision. Application of this technique to the radical pair P(*+)(700)A(*-)(1) in Photosystem I is discussed. Moreover, if oriented samples (e.g. single crystals) are used, the angular dependence of the dipolar coupling can be used to derive the orientation of the axis connecting donor and acceptor with respect to an external (crystal) axes system. Using out-of-phase electron spin echo envelope modulation spectroscopy, the localization of the secondary acceptor quinone A(1) has become possible.     

Spin labeling of oligonucleotides with the nitroxide TPA and use of PELDOR, a pulse EPR method, to measure intramolecular distances

In this protocol, we describe the facile synthesis of the nitroxide spin-label 2,2,5,5-tetramethyl-pyrrolin-1-oxyl-3-acetylene (TPA) and then its coupling to DNA/RNA through Sonogashira cross-coupling during automated solid-phase synthesis. Subsequently, we explain how to perform distance measurements between two such spin-labels on RNA/DNA using the pulsed electron paramagnetic resonance method pulsed electron double resonance (PELDOR). This combination of methods can be used to study global structure elements of oligonucleotides in frozen solution at RNA/DNA amounts of approximately 10 nmol. We especially focus on the Sonogashira cross-coupling step, the advantages of the ACE chemistry together with the appropriate parameters for the RNA synthesizer and on the PELDOR data analysis. This procedure is applicable to RNA/DNA strands of up to approximately 80 bases in length and PELDOR yields reliably spin-spin distances up to approximately 6.5 nm. The synthesis of TPA takes approximately 5 days and spin labeling together with purification approximately 4 days. The PELDOR measurements usually take approximately 16 h and data analysis from an hour up to several days depending on the extent of analysis.     

Characterization of the solution structure of human serum albumin loaded with a metal porphyrin and fatty acids

The structure of human serum albumin loaded with a metal porphyrin and fatty acids in solution is characterized by orientation-selective double electron-electron resonance (DEER) spectroscopy. Human serum albumin, spin-labeled fatty acids, and Cu(II) protoporphyrin IX—a hemin analog—form a fully self-assembled system that allows obtaining distances and mutual orientations between the paramagnetic guest molecules. We report a simplified analysis for the orientation-selective DEER data which can be applied when the orientation selection of one spin in the spin pair dominates the orientation selection of the other spin. The dipolar spectra reveal a dominant distance of 3.85 nm and a dominant orientation of the spin-spin vectors between Cu(II) protoporphyrin IX and 16-doxyl stearic acid, the electron paramagnetic resonance reporter group of the latter being located near the entry points to the fatty acid binding sites. This observation is in contrast to crystallographic data that suggest an asymmetric distribution of the entry points in the protein and hence the occurrence of various distances. In conjunction with the findings of a recent DEER study, the obtained data are indicative of a symmetric distribution of the binding site entries on the protein's surface. The overall anisotropic shape of the protein is reflected by one spin-spin vector orientation dominating the DEER data.     

Track structure in DNA irradiated with heavy ions

The spatial properties of trapped radicals produced in heavy-ion-irradiated solid DNA at 77 K have been probed using pulsed electron paramagnetic double resonance (PELDOR or DEER) techniques. Salmon testes DNA hydrated to 12 water molecules per nucleotide was irradiated with 40Ar ions of energy 100 MeV/nucleon and LET ranging from 300 to 400 keV/microm. Irradiated samples were maintained at cryogenic temperature at all times. PELDOR measurements were made using a refocused echo detection sequence that allows dipolar interaction between trapped radicals to be observed. The EPR spectrum is attributed to electron loss/gain DNA base radicals and neutral carbon-centered radicals that likely arise from sugar damage. We find a radical concentration of 13.5 x 10(18) cm(-3) in the tracks and a track radius of 6.79 nm. The cross section of these tracks is 144 nm2, yielding a lineal radical density of 2.6 radicals/nm. Based on the yields determined previously for particles having calculated LET values of 300-400 keV/microm and our measured lineal density, we obtain an LET of 270 keV/microm, which is in good agreement with the calculated range of values. These measurements of radical density and spatial extent provide the first direct experimental determination of track characteristics in irradiated DNA.     

Secondary and tertiary structure of bacteriorhodopsin in the SDS denatured state

We characterized the structure of partially unfolded bacteriorhodopsin in sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) micelles and compared it with its in vitro refolded structure after reconstitution with dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine/3-[(3-cholamidopropyl)dimethylammonio]-1-propanesulfonate (DMPC/CHAPS). Intrahelical and interhelical distances were mapped in the protein using strategically located spin-label pairs at helical ends, assayed by pulsed electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy (double electron-electron spin resonance, DEER). We find that in SDS the intrahelical end-to-end distances exhibit broad distributions, suggesting a heterogeneous ensemble of conformations with differing secondary structures. Nevertheless, a majority of the denatured population retains end-to-end distances similar to those in the native state. In contrast, the observed greatly increased interhelical distances, in addition to their very broad distributions, suggest that in the SDS micelles very little of the native tertiary structure remains.     

Structure and interactions of amino acid radicals in class I ribonucleotide reductase studied by ENDOR and high-field EPR spectroscopy

This short review compiles high-field electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) studies on different intermediate amino acid radicals, which emerge in wild-type and mutant class I ribonucleotide reductase (RNR) both in the reaction of protein subunit R2 with molecular oxygen, which generates the essential tyrosyl radical, and in the catalytic reaction, which involves a radical transfer between subunits R2 and R1. Recent examples are presented, how different amino acid radicals (tyrosyl, tryptophan, and different cysteine-based radicals) were identified, assigned to a specific residue, and their interactions, in particular hydrogen bonding, were investigated using high-field EPR and ENDOR spectroscopy. Thereby, unexpected diiron-radical centers, which emerge in mutants of R2 with changed iron coordination, and an important catalytic cysteine-based intermediate in the substrate turnover reaction in R1 were identified and characterized. Experiments on the essential tyrosyl radical in R2 single crystals revealed the so far unknown conformational changes induced by formation of the radical. Interesting structural differences between the tyrosyl radicals of class Ia and Ib enzymes were revealed. Recently accurate distances between the tyrosyl radicals in the protein dimer R2 could be determined using pulsed electron-electron double resonance (PELDOR), providing a new tool for docking studies of protein subunits. These studies show that high-field EPR and ENDOR are important tools for the identification and investigation of radical intermediates, which contributed significantly to the current understanding of the reaction mechanism of class I RNR.     

Structure and interactions of amino acid radicals in class I ribonucleotide reductase studied by ENDOR and high-field EPR spectroscopy

This short review compiles high-field electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) studies on different intermediate amino acid radicals, which emerge in wild-type and mutant class I ribonucleotide reductase (RNR) both in the reaction of protein subunit R2 with molecular oxygen, which generates the essential tyrosyl radical, and in the catalytic reaction, which involves a radical transfer between subunits R2 and R1. Recent examples are presented, how different amino acid radicals (tyrosyl, tryptophan, and different cysteine-based radicals) were identified, assigned to a specific residue, and their interactions, in particular hydrogen bonding, were investigated using high-field EPR and ENDOR spectroscopy. Thereby, unexpected diiron-radical centers, which emerge in mutants of R2 with changed iron coordination, and an important catalytic cysteine-based intermediate in the substrate turnover reaction in R1 were identified and characterized. Experiments on the essential tyrosyl radical in R2 single crystals revealed the so far unknown conformational changes induced by formation of the radical. Interesting structural differences between the tyrosyl radicals of class Ia and Ib enzymes were revealed. Recently accurate distances between the tyrosyl radicals in the protein dimer R2 could be determined using pulsed electron-electron double resonance (PELDOR), providing a new tool for docking studies of protein subunits. These studies show that high-field EPR and ENDOR are important tools for the identification and investigation of radical intermediates, which contributed significantly to the current understanding of the reaction mechanism of class I RNR.     

Determination of interspin distances between spin labels attached to insulin: comparison of electron paramagnetic resonance data with the X-ray structure

A method was developed to determine the interspin distances of two or more nitroxide spin labels attached to specific sites in proteins. This method was applied to different conformations of spin-labeled insulins. The electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) line broadening due to dipolar interaction is determined by fitting simulated EPR powder spectra to experimental data, measured at temperatures below 200 K to freeze the protein motion. The experimental spectra are composed of species with different relative nitroxide orientations and interspin distances because of the flexibility of the spin label side chain and the variety of conformational substates of proteins in frozen solution. Values for the average interspin distance and for the distance distribution width can be determined from the characteristics of the dipolar broadened line shape. The resulting interspin distances determined for crystallized insulins in the R6 and T6 structure agree nicely with structural data obtained by x-ray crystallography and by modeling of the spin-labeled samples. The EPR experiments reveal slight differences between crystal and frozen solution structures of the B-chain amino termini in the R6 and T6 states of hexameric insulins. The study of interspin distances between attached spin labels can be applied to obtain structural information on proteins under conditions where other methods like two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy or x-ray crystallography are not applicable.     

Location and aggregation of the spin-labeled peptide trichogin GA IV in a phospholipid membrane as revealed by pulsed EPR

The lipopeptaibol trichogin GA IV is a 10 amino acid-long residue and alpha-aminoisobutyric acid-rich antibiotic peptide of fungal origin. TOAC (2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxyl-4-amino-4-carboxylic acid) spin-labeled analogs of this membrane active peptide were investigated in hydrated bilayers of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine by electron spin echo envelope modulation (ESEEM) spectroscopy and pulsed electron-electron double resonance (PELDOR). Since, the ESEEM of the spin label appears to be strongly dependent on the presence of water molecules penetrated into the membrane, this phenomenon was used to study the location of this peptide in the membrane. This was achieved by comparing the ESEEM spectra for peptides labeled at different positions along the amino acid sequence with spectra known for lipids with spin labels at different positions along the hydrocarbon chain. To increase the ESEEM amplitude and to distinguish the hydrogen nuclei of water from lipid protons, membranes were hydrated with deuterated water. The PELDOR spectroscopy technique was chosen to study peptide aggregation and to determine the mutual distance distribution of the spin-labeled peptides in the membrane. The location of the peptide in the membrane and its aggregation state were found to be dependent on the peptide concentration. At a low peptide/lipid molar ratio (less than 1:100) the nonaggregated peptide chain of the trichogin molecules lie parallel to the membrane surface, with TOAC at the 4th residue located near the 9th-11th carbon positions of the sn-2 lipid chain. Increasing this ratio up to 1:20 leads to a change in peptide orientation, with the N-terminus of the peptide buried deeper into membrane. Under these conditions peptide aggregates are formed with a mean aggregate number of about N = 2. The aggregates are further characterized by a broad range of intermolecular distances (1.5-4 nm) between the labels at the N-terminal residues. The major population exhibits a distance of approximately 2.5 nm, which is of the same order as the length of the helical peptide. We suggest that the constituting monomers of the dimer are antiparallel oriented.     

Base-specific spin-labeling of RNA for structure determination

To facilitate the measurement of intramolecular distances in solvated RNA systems, a combination of spin-labeling, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR), and molecular dynamics (MD) simulation is presented. The fairly rigid spin label 2,2,5,5-tetramethyl-pyrrolin-1-yloxyl-3-acetylene (TPA) was base and site specifically introduced into RNA through a Sonogashira palladium catalyzed cross-coupling on column. For this purpose 5-iodo-uridine, 5-iodo-cytidine and 2-iodo-adenosine phosphoramidites were synthesized and incorporated into RNA-sequences. Application of the recently developed ACE® chemistry presented the main advantage to limit the reduction of the nitroxide to an amine during the oligonucleotide automated synthesis and thus to increase substantially the reliability of the synthesis and the yield of labeled oligonucleotides. 4-Pulse Electron Double Resonance (PELDOR) was then successfully used to measure the intramolecular spin–spin distances in six doubly labeled RNA-duplexes. Comparison of these results with our previous work on DNA showed that A- and B-Form can be differentiated. Using an all-atom force field with explicit solvent, MD simulations gave results in good agreement with the measured distances and indicated that the RNA A-Form was conserved despite a local destabilization effect of the nitroxide label. The applicability of the method to more complex biological systems is discussed.     

Site-directed spin labeling measurements of nanometer distances in nucleic acids using a sequence-independent nitroxide probe

In site-directed spin labeling (SDSL), local structural and dynamic information is obtained via electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy of a stable nitroxide radical attached site-specifically to a macromolecule. Analysis of electron spin dipolar interactions between pairs of nitroxides yields the inter-nitroxide distance, which provides quantitative structural information. The development of pulse EPR methods has enabled such distance measurements up to 70Å in bio-molecules, thus opening up the possibility of SDSL global structural mapping. This study evaluates SDSL distance measurement using a nitroxide (designated as R5) that can be attached, in an efficient and cost-effective manner, to a phosphorothioate backbone position at arbitrary DNA or RNA sequences. R5 pairs were attached to selected positions of a dodecamer DNA duplex with a known NMR structure, and eight distances, ranging from 20 to 40Å, were measured using double electron-electron resonance (DEER). The measured distances correlated strongly (R² = 0.98) with the predicted values calculated based on a search of sterically allowable R5 conformations in the NMR structure, thus demonstrating accurate distance measurements using R5. Furthermore, distance measurement in a 42 kD DNA was demonstrated. The results establish R5 as a sequence-independent probe for global structural mapping of DNA and DNA–protein complexes.     

Locating a Lipid at the Portal to the Lipoxygenase Active Site

Lipoxygenase enzymes initiate diverse signaling pathways by specifically directing oxygen to different carbons of arachidonate and other polyunsaturated acyl chains, but structural origins of this specificity have remained unclear. We therefore determined the nature of the lipoxygenase interaction with the polar-end of a paramagnetic lipid by electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy. Distances between selected grid points on soybean seed lipoxygenase-1 (SBL1) and a lysolecithin spin-labeled on choline were measured by pulsed (electron) dipolar spectroscopy. The protein grid was designed by structure-based modeling so that five natural side chains were replaced with spin labels. Pairwise distances in 10 doubly spin-labeled mutants were examined by pulsed dipolar spectroscopy, and a fit to the model was optimized. Finally, experimental distances between the lysolecithin spin and each single spin site on SBL1 were also obtained. With these 15 distances, distance geometry localized the polar-end and the spin of the lysolecithin to the region between the two domains in the SBL1 structure, nearest to E236, K260, Q264, and Q544. Mutation of a nearby residue, E256A, relieved the high pH requirement for enzyme activity of SBL1 and allowed lipid binding at pH 7.2. This general approach could be used to locate other flexible molecules in macromolecular complexes.     

Comparative evaluation of spin-label modeling methods for protein structural studies

Site-directed spin-labeling electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy is a powerful technique for the investigation of protein structure and dynamics. Accurate spin-label modeling methods are essential to make full quantitative use of site-directed spin-labeling electron paramagnetic resonance data for protein modeling and model validation. Using a set of double electron-electron resonance data from seven different site pairs on maltodextrin/maltose-binding protein under two different conditions using five different spin labels, we compare the ability of two widely used spin-label modeling methods, based on accessible volume sampling and rotamer libraries, to predict experimental distance distributions. We present a spin-label modeling approach inspired by canonical side-chain modeling methods and compare modeling accuracy with the established methods.     

A novel 5 displacement spin-labeling technique for electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy of RNA.

An RNA spin-labeling technique was developed using the well-characterized interaction between the HIV Rev peptide and the Rev response element (RRE) RNA as a model system. Spin-labeled RNA molecules were prepared by incorporating guanosine monophosphorothioate (GMPS) at the 5' end using T7 RNA polymerase and then covalently attaching a thiol-specific nitroxide spin label. Three different constructs of the RRE RNA were made by strategically displacing the 5' end within the native three-dimensional structure. Nitroxide-to-nitroxide distance measurements were made between the specifically bound RNA and peptide using electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy. The dipolar EPR method can reliably measure distances up to 25 A, the calculation of which is derived from the 1/r3 dependence of the broadening of EPR lines in motionally frozen samples. This RNA-labeling technique, dubbed 5' displacement spin labeling, extends the usefulness of the dipolar EPR method developed for analysis of protein structure. The advantage of this technique is that it is applicable to large RNA systems such as the ribosome, which are difficult to study by other structural methods.     

Protein dynamics and monomer-monomer interactions in AntR activation by electron paramagnetic resonance and double electron-electron resonance

The Anthracis repressor (AntR) is a Mn(II)-activated DNA binding protein that is involved in the regulation of Mn(II) homeostasis in Bacillus anthracis. AntR is structurally and functionally homologous to Mn(II)-activated repressor from Bacillus subtillis (MntR). Our studies on AntR focus on metal-regulated activation of the protein. Line shape analysis of continuous wave electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectra showed that metal binding resulted in a general reduction of backbone dynamics and that there were no further changes in backbone motion upon DNA binding. Double electron-electron resonance (DEER) pulsed EPR spectroscopy was used to measure distances between nitroxide spin labels strategically placed in dimeric AntR. The DEER data were analyzed assuming Gaussian distributions for discrete populations of spins. A structural model for AntR was built from homology to MntR, and the experimentally measured distances were simulated to distinguish between spin label and backbone motions. Together with the computational analysis, the DEER results for apo-AntR indicated relatively narrow conformational distributions for backbone residues at the dimer interface and near the metal binding site. No significant changes were observed on these sites in the presence of metal or DNA. On the other hand, the distribution of the conformers and the distances between the putative DNA binding helices decreased upon metal binding. These results suggest that the DNA binding region of AntR shows large amplitude backbone motions in the absence of metal, which may preclude sequence-specific binding to promoter sites. Metal binding narrows the range of conformations accessible in this region and shortens the mean distance between the DNA binding helices, probably resulting in alignment that optimizes promoter recognition and binding.     

Comparison of electron paramagnetic resonance methods to determine distances between spin labels on human carbonic anhydrase II

Four doubly spin-labeled variants of human carbonic anhydrase II and corresponding singly labeled variants were prepared by site-directed spin labeling. The distances between the spin labels were obtained from continuous-wave electron paramagnetic resonance spectra by analysis of the relative intensity of the half-field transition, Fourier deconvolution of line-shape broadening, and computer simulation of line-shape changes. Distances also were determined by four-pulse double electron-electron resonance. For each variant, at least two methods were applicable and reasonable agreement between methods was obtained. Distances ranged from 7 to 24 A. The doubly spin-labeled samples contained some singly labeled protein due to incomplete labeling. The sensitivity of each of the distance determination methods to the non-interacting component was compared.