Using hydrogen deuterium exchange mass spectrometry to engineer optimized constructs for crystallization of protein complexes: Case study of PI4KIIIβ with Rab11

The ability of proteins to bind and interact with protein partners plays fundamental roles in many cellular contexts. X‐ray crystallography has been a powerful approach to understand protein‐protein interactions; however, a challenge in the crystallization of proteins and their complexes is the presence of intrinsically disordered regions. In this article, we describe an application of hydrogen deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX‐MS) to identify dynamic regions within type III phosphatidylinositol 4 kinase beta (PI4KIIIβ) in complex with the GTPase Rab11. This information was then used to design deletions that allowed for the production of diffraction quality crystals. Importantly, we also used HDX‐MS to verify that the new construct was properly folded, consistent with it being catalytically and functionally active. Structures of PI4KIIIβ in an Apo state and bound to the potent inhibitor BQR695 in complex with both GTPγS and GDP loaded Rab11 were determined. This hybrid HDX‐MS/crystallographic strategy revealed novel aspects of the PI4KIIIβ‐Rab11 complex, as well as the molecular mechanism of potency of a PI4K specific inhibitor (BQR695). This approach is widely applicable to protein‐protein complexes, and is an excellent strategy to optimize constructs for high‐resolution structural approaches.     

New insights into interactions between the nucleotide‐binding domain of CFTR and keratin 8

The intermediate filament protein keratin 8 (K8) interacts with the nucleotide‐binding domain 1 (NBD1) of the cystic fibrosis (CF) transmembrane regulator (CFTR) with phenylalanine 508 deletion (ΔF508), and this interaction hampers the biogenesis of functional ΔF508‐CFTR and its insertion into the plasma membrane. Interruption of this interaction may constitute a new therapeutic target for CF patients bearing the ΔF508 mutation. Here, we aimed to determine the binding surface between these two proteins, to facilitate the design of the interaction inhibitors. To identify the NBD1 fragments perturbed by the ΔF508 mutation, we used hydrogen–deuterium exchange coupled with mass spectrometry (HDX‐MS) on recombinant wild‐type (wt) NBD1 and ΔF508‐NBD1 of CFTR. We then performed the same analysis in the presence of a peptide from the K8 head domain, and extended this investigation using bioinformatics procedures and surface plasmon resonance, which revealed regions affected by the peptide binding in both wt‐NBD1 and ΔF508‐NBD1. Finally, we performed HDX‐MS analysis of the NBD1 molecules and full‐length K8, revealing hydrogen‐bonding network changes accompanying complex formation. In conclusion, we have localized a region in the head segment of K8 that participates in its binding to NBD1. Our data also confirm the stronger binding of K8 to ΔF508‐NBD1, which is supported by an additional binding site located in the vicinity of the ΔF508 mutation in NBD1.     

Epitope characterization of an anti‐PD‐L1 antibody using orthogonal approaches

The binding of programmed death ligand 1 protein (PD‐L1) to its receptor programmed death protein 1 (PD‐1) mediates immunoevasion in cancer and chronic viral infections, presenting an important target for therapeutic intervention. Several monoclonal antibodies targeting the PD‐L1/PD‐1 signaling axis are undergoing clinical trials; however, the epitopes of these antibodies have not been described. We have combined orthogonal approaches to localize and characterize the epitope of a monoclonal antibody directed against PD‐L1 at good resolution and with high confidence. Limited proteolysis and mass spectrometry were applied to reveal that the epitope resides in the first immunoglobulin domain of PD‐L1. Hydrogen–deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX‐MS) was used to identify a conformational epitope comprised of discontinuous strands that fold to form a beta sheet in the native structure. This beta sheet presents an epitope surface that significantly overlaps with the PD‐1 binding interface, consistent with a desired PD‐1 competitive mechanism of action for the antibody. Surface plasmon resonance screening of mutant PD‐L1 variants confirmed that the region identified by HDX‐MS is critical for the antibody interaction and further defined specific residues contributing to the binding energy. Taken together, the results are consistent with the observed inhibitory activity of the antibody on PD‐L1‐mediated immune evasion. This is the first report of an epitope for any antibody targeting PD‐L1 and demonstrates the power of combining orthogonal epitope mapping techniques. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Differential hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry analysis of protein-ligand interactions

Functional regulation of ligand-activated receptors is driven by alterations in the conformational dynamics of the protein upon ligand binding. Differential hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) coupled with mass spectrometry has emerged as a rapid and sensitive approach for characterization of perturbations in conformational dynamics of proteins following ligand binding. While this technique is sensitive to detecting ligand interactions and alterations in receptor dynamics, it also can provide important mechanistic insights into ligand regulation. For example, HDX has been used to determine a novel mechanism of ligand activation of the nuclear receptor peroxisome proliferator activated receptor-γ, perform detailed analyses of binding modes of ligands within the ligand-binding pocket of two estrogen receptor isoforms, providing insight into selectivity, and helped classify different types of estrogen receptor-α ligands by correlating their pharmacology with the way they interact with the receptor based solely on hierarchical clustering of receptor HDX signatures. Beyond small-molecule-receptor interactions, this technique has also been applied to study protein-protein complexes, such as mapping antibody-antigen interactions. In this article, we summarize the current state of the differential HDX approaches and the future outlook. We summarize how HDX analysis of protein-ligand interactions has had an impact on biology and drug discovery.     

Insights into enzyme structure and dynamics elucidated by amide H/D exchange mass spectrometry

Conformational changes and protein dynamics play an important role in the catalytic efficiency of enzymes. Amide H/D exchange mass spectrometry (H/D exchange MS) is emerging as an efficient technique to study the local and global changes in protein structure and dynamics due to ligand binding, protein activation-inactivation by modification, and protein-protein interactions. By monitoring the selective exchange of hydrogen for deuterium along a peptide backbone, this sensitive technique probes protein motions and structural elements that may be relevant to allostery and function. In this report, several applications of H/D exchange MS are presented which demonstrate the unique capability of amide hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry for examining dynamic and structural changes associated with enzyme catalysis.     

Molecular basis of the head‐to‐tail assembly of giant muscle proteins obscurin‐like 1 and titin

Large filament proteins in muscle sarcomeres comprise many immunoglobulin‐like domains that provide a molecular platform for self‐assembly and interactions with heterologous protein partners. We have unravelled the molecular basis for the head‐to‐tail interaction of the carboxyl terminus of titin and the amino‐terminus of obscurin‐like‐1 by X‐ray crystallography. The binary complex is formed by a parallel intermolecular β‐sheet that presents a novel immunoglobulin‐like domain‐mediated assembly mechanism in muscle filament proteins. Complementary binding data show that the assembly is entropy‐driven rather than dominated data by specific polar interactions. The assembly observed leads to a V‐shaped zipper‐like arrangement of the two filament proteins.     

Hydrogen/deuterium exchange reveals distinct agonist/partial agonist receptor dynamics within vitamin D receptor/retinoid X receptor heterodimer

Regulation of nuclear receptor (NR) activity is driven by alterations in the conformational dynamics of the receptor upon ligand binding. Previously, we demonstrated that hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) can be applied to determine novel mechanism of action of PPARγ ligands and in predicting tissue specificity of selective estrogen receptor modulators. Here, we applied HDX to probe the conformational dynamics of the ligand binding domain (LBD) of the vitamin D receptor (VDR) upon binding its natural ligand 1α,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 (1,25D3), and two analogs, alfacalcidol and ED-71. Comparison of HDX profiles from ligands in complex with the LBD with full-length receptor bound to its cognate receptor retinoid X receptor (RXR) revealed unique receptor dynamics that could not be inferred from static crystal structures. These results demonstrate that ligands modulate the dynamics of the heterodimer interface as well as provide insight into the role of AF-2 dynamics in the action of VDR partial agonists.     

A glimpse into the molecular mechanism of integral membrane proteins through hydrogen–deuterium exchange mass spectrometry

Integral membrane proteins (IMPs) control countless fundamental biological processes and constitute the majority of drug targets. For this reason, uncovering their molecular mechanism of action has long been an intense field of research. They are, however, notoriously difficult to work with, mainly due to their localization within the heterogeneous of environment of the biological membrane and the instability once extracted from the lipid bilayer. High‐resolution structures have unveiled many mechanistic aspects of IMPs but also revealed that the elucidation of static pictures has limitations. Hydrogen–deuterium exchange coupled to mass spectrometry (HDX‐MS) has recently emerged as a powerful biophysical tool for interrogating the conformational dynamics of proteins and their interactions with ligands. Its versatility has proven particularly useful to reveal mechanistic aspects of challenging classes of proteins such as IMPs. This review recapitulates the accomplishments of HDX‐MS as it has matured into an essential tool for membrane protein structural biologists.     

Intrinsic local destabilization of the C‐terminus predisposes integrin α1 I domain to a conformational switch induced by collagen binding

Integrin–collagen interactions play a critical role in a myriad of cellular functions that include immune response, and cell development and differentiation, yet their mechanism of binding is poorly understood. There is increasing evidence that conformational flexibility assumes a central role in the molecular mechanisms of protein–protein interactions and here we employ NMR hydrogen–deuterium exchange (HDX) experiments to explore the impact of slower timescale dynamic events. To gain insight into the mechanisms underlying collagen‐induced conformational switches, we have undertaken a comparative study between the wild type integrin α1 I and a gain‐of‐function E317A mutant. NMR HDX results suggest a relationship between regions exhibiting a reduced local stability in the unbound I domain and those that undergo significant conformational changes upon binding. Specifically, the αC and α7 helices within the C‐terminus are at the center of such major perturbations and present reduced local stabilities in the unbound state relative to other structural elements. Complementary isothermal titration calorimetry experiments have been performed to derive complete thermodynamic binding profiles for association of the collagen‐like triple‐helical peptide with wild type α1 I and E317A mutant. The differential energetics observed for E317A are consistent with the HDX experiments and support a model in which intrinsically destabilized regions predispose conformational rearrangement in the integrin I domain. This study highlights the importance of exploring different timescales to delineate allosteric and binding events.     

Dynamics of the Tec‐family tyrosine kinase SH3 domains

The Src Homology 3 (SH3) domain is an important regulatory domain found in many signaling proteins. X‐ray crystallography and NMR structures of SH3 domains are generally conserved but other studies indicate that protein flexibility and dynamics are not. We previously reported that based on hydrogen exchange mass spectrometry (HX MS) studies, there is variable flexibility and dynamics among the SH3 domains of the Src‐family tyrosine kinases and related proteins. Here we have extended our studies to the SH3 domains of the Tec family tyrosine kinases (Itk, Btk, Tec, Txk, Bmx). The SH3 domains of members of this family augment the variety in dynamics observed in previous SH3 domains. Txk and Bmx SH3 were found to be highly dynamic in solution by HX MS and Bmx was unstructured by NMR. Itk and Btk SH3 underwent a clear EX1 cooperative unfolding event, which was localized using pepsin digestion and mass spectrometry after hydrogen exchange labeling. The unfolding was localized to peptide regions that had been previously identified in the Src‐family and related protein SH3 domains, yet the kinetics of unfolding were not. Sequence alignment does not provide an easy explanation for the observed dynamics behavior, yet the similarity of location of EX1 unfolding suggests that higher‐order structural properties may play a role. While the exact reason for such dynamics is not clear, such motions can be exploited in intra‐ and intermolecular binding assays of proteins containing the domains.     

Development of in vivo HDX‐MS with applications to a TonB‐dependent transporter and other proteins

Hydrogen‐deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX‐MS) is a powerful tool that monitors protein dynamics in solution. However, the reversible nature of HDX labels has largely limited the application to in vitro systems. Here, we describe a protocol for measuring HDX‐MS in living Escherichia coli cells applied to BtuB, a TonB‐dependent transporter found in outer membranes (OMs). BtuB is a convenient and biologically interesting system for testing in vivo HDX‐MS due to its controllable HDX behavior and large structural rearrangements that occur during the B12 transport cycle. Our previous HDX‐MS study in native OMs provided evidence for B12 binding and breaking of a salt bridge termed the Ionic Lock, an event that leads to the unfolding of the amino terminus. Although purified OMs provide a more native‐like environment than reconstituted systems, disruption of the cell envelope during lysis perturbs the linkage between BtuB and the TonB complex that drives B12 transport. The in vivo HDX response of BtuB''s plug domain (BtuBp) to B12 binding corroborates our previous in vitro findings that B12 alone is sufficient to break the Ionic Lock. In addition, we still find no evidence of B12 binding‐induced unfolding in other regions of BtuBp that could enable B12 passage. Our protocol was successful in reporting on the HDX of several endogenous E. coli proteins measured in the same measurement. Our success in performing HDX in live cells opens the possibility for future HDX‐MS studies in a native cellular environment.IMPORTANCEWe present a protocol for performing in vivo HDX‐MS, focusing on BtuB, a protein whose native membrane environment is believed to be mechanistically important for B12 transport. The in vivo HDX‐MS data corroborate the conclusions from our previous in vitro HDX‐MS study of the allostery initiated by B12 binding. Our success with BtuB and other proteins opens the possibility for performing additional HDX‐MS studies in a native cellular environment.     

Hydrogen deuterium exchange mass spectrometry applied to chaperones and chaperone-assisted protein folding

Introduction: Hydrogen–deuterium exchange (HDX) mass spectrometry (MS) is ideal for monitoring the protein folding and unfolding. The exchange of a deuterium in solution for an amide hydrogen in a protein can be very different depending on the degree of folding and protection of backbone amide positions. Molecular chaperones that assist with protein folding in vivo are necessary for folding of many substrate (client) proteins. HDX MS provides valuable insight into what chaperones are doing in protein folding and how they are doing it.

Areas covered: Application of HDX MS to the protein folding problem was desirable from the outset of the technique, but technical issues prohibited many studies. In the last 20 years, conformational changes of chaperones themselves (e.g., GroEL/GroES, Hsp70, and Hsp90) have been studied. Studies of interactions between chaperones, co-chaperones, and substrate proteins have revealed binding interfaces, allosteric conformational changes, and remodeling of components during various chaperone cycles. Experiments elucidating how chaperones contribute to and enhance the folding pathway of substrate proteins have been demonstrated.

Expert opinion: Technical issues that once prevented the analysis of chaperones have largely been resolved, permitting exciting comprehensive HDX MS studies of folding pathways during chaperone-assisted protein folding.     

HDX-analyzer: a novel package for statistical analysis of protein structure dynamics

BACKGROUND: HDX mass spectrometry is a powerful platform to probe protein structure dynamics during ligand binding, protein folding, enzyme catalysis, and such. HDX mass spectrometry analysis derives the protein structure dynamics based on the mass increase of a protein of which the backbone protons exchanged with solvent deuterium. Coupled with enzyme digestion and MS/MS analysis, HDX mass spectrometry can be used to study the regional dynamics of protein based on the m/z value or percentage of deuterium incorporation for the digested peptides in the HDX experiments. Various software packages have been developed to analyze HDX mass spectrometry data. Despite the progresses, proper and explicit statistical treatment is still lacking in most of the current HDX mass spectrometry software. In order to address this issue, we have developed the HDXanalyzer for the statistical analysis of HDX mass spectrometry data using R, Python, and RPY2. IMPLEMENTATION AND RESULTS: HDXanalyzer package contains three major modules, the data processing module, the statistical analysis module, and the user interface. RPY2 is employed to enable the connection of these three components, where the data processing module is implemented using Python and the statistical analysis module is implemented with R. RPY2 creates a low-level interface for R and allows the effective integration of statistical module for data processing. The data processing module generates the centroid for the peptides in form of m/z value, and the differences of centroids between the peptides derived from apo and ligand-bound protein allow us to evaluate whether the regions have significant changes in structure dynamics or not. Another option of the software is to calculate the deuterium incorporation rate for the comparison. The two types of statistical analyses are Paired Student's t-test and the linear combination of the intercept for multiple regression and ANCOVA model. The user interface is implemented with wxpython to facilitate the data visualization in graphs and the statistical analysis output presentation. In order to evaluate the software, a previously published xylanase HDX mass spectrometry analysis dataset is processed and presented. The results from the different statistical analysis methods are compared and shown to be similar. The statistical analysis results are overlaid with the three dimensional structure of the protein to highlight the regional structure dynamics changes in the xylanase enzyme. CONCLUSION: Statistical analysis provides crucial evaluation of whether a protein region is significantly protected or unprotected during the HDX mass spectrometry studies. Although there are several other available software programs to process HDX experimental data, HDXanalyzer is the first software program to offer multiple statistical methods to evaluate the changes in protein structure dynamics based on HDX mass spectrometry analysis. Moreover, the statistical analysis can be carried out for both m/z value and deuterium incorporation rate. In addition, the software package can be used for the data generated from a wide range of mass spectrometry instruments.     

Investigating the dynamics and polyanion binding sites of fibroblast growth factor‐1 using hydrogen‐deuterium exchange mass spectrometry

In this study, we examined the local dynamics of acidic fibroblast growth factor (FGF‐1) as well as the binding sites of various polyanions including poly‐sulfates (heparin and low MW heparin) and poly‐phosphates (phytic acid and ATP) using hydrogen‐deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HX‐MS). For local dynamics, results are analyzed at the peptide level as well as in terms of buried amides employing crystallographic B‐factors and compared with a residue level heat map generated from HX‐MS results. Results show that strand 4 and 5 and the turn between them to be the most flexible regions as was previously seen by NMR. On the other hand, the C‐terminal strands 8, 9, and 10 appear to be more rigid which is also consistent with crystallographic B‐factors as well as local dynamics studies conducted by NMR. Crystal structures of FGF‐1 in complex with heparin have shown that heparin binds to N‐terminal Asn18 and to C‐terminal Lys105, Tryp107, Lys112, Lys113, Arg119, Pro121, Arg122, Gln127, and Lys128 indicating electrostatic forces as dominant interactions. Heparin binding as determined by HX‐MS is consistent with crystallography data. Previous studies have also shown that other polyanions including low MW heparin, phytic acid and ATP dramatically increase the thermal stability of FGF‐1. Using HX‐MS, we find other poly anions tested bind in a similar manner to heparin, primarily targeting the turns in the lysine rich C‐terminal region of FGF‐1 along with two distinct N‐terminal regions that contains lysines and arginines/histidines. This confirms the interactions between FGF‐1 and polyanions are primary directed by electrostatics.     

Coarse‐grained and all‐atom modeling of structural states and transitions in hemoglobin

Hemoglobin (Hb), an oxygen‐binding protein composed of four subunits (α1, α2, β1, and β2), is a well‐known example of allosteric proteins that are capable of cooperative ligand binding. Despite decades of studies, the structural basis of its cooperativity remains controversial. In this study, we have integrated coarse‐grained (CG) modeling, all‐atom simulation, and structural data from X‐ray crystallography and wide‐angle X‐ray scattering (WAXS), aiming to probe dynamic properties of the two structural states of Hb (T and R state) and the transitions between them. First, by analyzing the WAXS data of unliganded and liganded Hb, we have found that the structural ensemble of T or R state is dominated by one crystal structure of Hb with small contributions from other crystal structures of Hb. Second, we have used normal mode analysis to identify two distinct quaternary rotations between the α1β1 and α2β2 dimer, which drive the transitions between T and R state. We have also identified the hot‐spot residues whose mutations are predicted to greatly change these quaternary motions. Third, we have generated a CG transition pathway between T and R state, which predicts a clear order of quaternary and tertiary changes involving α and β subunits in Hb. Fourth, we have used the accelerated molecular dynamics to perform an all‐atom simulation starting from the T state of Hb, and we have observed a transition toward the R state of Hb. Further analysis of crystal structural data and the all‐atom simulation trajectory has corroborated the order of quaternary and tertiary changes predicted by CG modeling. Proteins 2013. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Structural characterization of the heme‐based oxygen sensor,AfGcHK, its interactions with the cognate response regulator,and their combined mechanism of action in a bacterial two‐component signaling system

The oxygen sensor histidine kinase AfGcHK from the bacterium Anaeromyxobacter sp. Fw 109‐5 forms a two‐component signal transduction system together with its cognate response regulator (RR). The binding of oxygen to the heme iron of its N‐terminal sensor domain causes the C‐terminal kinase domain of AfGcHK to autophosphorylate at His183 and then transfer this phosphate to Asp52 or Asp169 of the RR protein. Analytical ultracentrifugation revealed that AfGcHK and the RR protein form a complex with 2:1 stoichiometry. Hydrogen‐deuterium exchange coupled to mass spectrometry (HDX‐MS) suggested that the most flexible part of the whole AfGcHK protein is a loop that connects the two domains and that the heme distal side of AfGcHK, which is responsible for oxygen binding, is the only flexible part of the sensor domain. HDX‐MS studies on the AfGcHK:RR complex also showed that the N‐side of the H9 helix in the dimerization domain of the AfGcHK kinase domain interacts with the helix H1 and the β‐strand B2 area of the RR protein's Rec1 domain, and that the C‐side of the H8 helix region in the dimerization domain of the AfGcHK protein interacts mostly with the helix H5 and β‐strand B6 area of the Rec1 domain. The Rec1 domain containing the phosphorylable Asp52 of the RR protein probably has a significantly higher affinity for AfGcHK than the Rec2 domain. We speculate that phosphorylation at Asp52 changes the overall structure of RR such that the Rec2 area containing the second phosphorylation site (Asp169) can also interact with AfGcHK. Proteins 2016; 84:1375–1389. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Conformational dynamics of a membrane transport protein probed by H/D exchange and covalent labeling: the glycerol facilitator

Glycerol facilitator (GF) is a tetrameric membrane protein responsible for the selective permeation of glycerol and water. Each of the four GF subunits forms a transmembrane channel. Every subunit consists of six helices that completely span the lipid bilayer, as well as two half-helices (TM7 and TM3). X-ray crystallography has revealed that the selectivity of GF is due to its unique amphipathic channel interior. To explore the structural dynamics of GF, we employ hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) and oxidative labeling with mass spectrometry (MS). HDX-MS reveals that transmembrane helices are generally more protected than extramembrane segments, consistent with data previously obtained for other membrane proteins. Interestingly, TM7 does not follow this trend. Instead, this half-helix undergoes rapid deuteration, indicative of a highly dynamic local structure. The oxidative labeling behavior of most GF residues is consistent with the static crystal structure. However, the side chains of C134 and M237 undergo labeling although they should be inaccessible according to the X-ray structure. In agreement with our HDX-MS data, this observation attests to the fact that TM7 is only marginally stable. We propose that the highly mobile nature of TM7 aids in the efficient diffusion of guest molecules through the channel ("molecular lubrication"). In the absence of such dynamics, host-guest molecular recognition would favor semipermanent binding of molecules inside the channel, thereby impeding transport. The current work highlights the complementary nature of HDX, covalent labeling, and X-ray crystallography for the characterization of membrane proteins.