Development of Dopant‐Free Organic Hole Transporting Materials for Perovskite Solar Cells

There has been considerable progress over the last decade in development of the perovskite solar cells (PSCs), with reported performances now surpassing 25.2% power conversion efficiency. Both long‐term stability and component costs of PSCs remain to be addressed by the research community, using hole transporting materials (HTMs) such as 2,2′,7,7′‐tetrakis(N,N′‐di‐pmethoxyphenylamino)‐9,9′‐spirbiuorene(Spiro‐OMeTAD) and poly[bis(4‐phenyl)(2,4,6‐trimethylphenyl)amine] (PTAA). HTMs are essential for high‐performance PSC devices. Although effective, these materials require a relatively high degree of doping with additives to improve charge mobility and interlayer/substrate compatibility, introducing doping‐induced stability issues with these HTMs, and further, additional costs and experimental complexity associated with using these doped materials. This article reviews dopant‐free organic HTMs for PSCs, outlining reports of structures with promising properties toward achieving low‐cost, effective, and scalable materials for devices with long‐term stability. It summarizes recent literature reports on non‐doped, alternative, and more stable HTMs used in PSCs as essential components for high‐efficiency cells, categorizing HTMs as reported for different PSC architectures in addition to use of dopant‐free small molecular and polymeric HTMs. Finally, an outlook and critical assessment of dopant‐free organic HTMs toward commercial application and insight into the development of stable PSC devices is provided.     

Less is More: Dopant‐Free Hole Transporting Materials for High‐Efficiency Perovskite Solar Cells

Perovskite solar cells have delivered power conversion efficiency beyond 22% in less than seven years, implying the potential for the paradigm shift of low‐cost photovoltaics with high efficiency and low embedded energy. Besides the “perovskite fever,” the development of new hole transport materials (HTM), especially dopant‐free HTMs, is another research hotspot. This is because the currently used HTMs, such as spiro‐OMeTAD derivatives, require additional chemical doping process to ensure sufficient conductivity and proper ionic potential level for efficient hole transport and collection. However, the commonly used dopants are volatile and hygroscopic which not only increase the complexity and cost of device fabrication but also deteriorate the device stability. So far, there have been several reviews on new HTMs, but review or analysis on dopant‐free HTMs is scarce. In this review, all reported dopant‐free HTMs are categorized into four primary different types and lessons will be learned during the separate discussions. The stability test behavior of all the intrinsic HTMs will be evaluated directly. In the end, the correlations between the properties of the intrinsic HTMs and parameters of the devices will be plotted to shed light on the future direction of development of this field.     

4‐Tert‐butylpyridine Free Organic Hole Transporting Materials for Stable and Efficient Planar Perovskite Solar Cells

4‐Tert ‐butylpyridine (t BP) is an important additive in triarylamine‐based organic hole‐transporting materials (HTMs) for improving the efficiency and steady‐state performance of perovskite solar cells (PVSCs). However, the low boiling point of t BP (196 °C) significantly affects the long‐term stability and device performance of PVSCs. Herein, the design and synthesis of a series of covalently linked Spiro[fluorene‐9,9′‐xanthene] (SFX)‐based organic HTMs and pyridine derivatives to realize efficient and stable planar PVSCs are reported. One of the tailored HTMs, N2,N2,N7,N7‐tetrakis(4‐methoxyphenyl)‐3′,6′‐bis(pyridin‐4‐ylmethoxy) spiro[fluorene‐9,9′‐xanthene]‐2,7‐diamine ( XPP ) with two para‐position substituted pyridines that immobilized on the SFX core unit shows a high power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 17.2% in planar CH₃NH₃PbI₃‐based PVSCs under 100 mW cm^?2 AM 1.5G solar illumination, which is much higher than the efficiency of 5.5% that using the well‐known 2,2′,7,7′‐tetrakis‐(N ,N ‐di‐p ‐methoxy‐phenyl‐amine)9,9′‐spirobifluorene (Spiro‐OMeTAD) as HTM (without t BP) under the same condition. Most importantly, the pyridine‐functionalized HTM‐based PVSCs without t BP as additive show much better long‐term stability than that of the state‐of‐the‐art HTM Spiro‐OMeTAD‐based solar cells that containing t BP as additive. This is the first case that the t BP‐free HTMs are demonstrated in PVSCs with high PCEs and good stability. It paves the way to develop highly efficient and stable t BP‐free HTMs for PVSCs toward commercial applications.     

Dopant‐Free Hole Transporting Polymers for High Efficiency,Environmentally Stable Perovskite Solar Cells

Over the past five years, a rapid progress in organometal‐halide perovskite solar cells has greatly influenced emerging solar energy science and technology. In perovksite solar cells, the overlying hole transporting material (HTM) is critical for achieving high power conversion efficiencies (PCEs) and for protecting the air‐sensitive perovskite active layer. This study reports the synthesis and implementation of a new polymeric HTM series based on semiconducting 4,8‐dithien‐2‐yl‐benzo[1,2‐d;4,5‐d′]bistriazole‐alt‐benzo[1,2‐b:4,5‐b′]dithiophenes (pBBTa‐BDTs), yielding high PCEs and environmentally‐stable perovskite cells. These intrinsic (dopant‐free) HTMs achieve a stabilized PCE of 12.3% in simple planar heterojunction cells—the highest value to date for a polymeric intrinsic HTM. This high performance is attributed to efficient hole extraction/collection (the most efficient pBBTa‐BDT is highly ordered and orients π‐face‐down on the perovskite surface) and balanced electron/hole transport. The smooth, conformal polymer coatings suppress aerobic perovskite film degradation, significantly enhancing the solar cell 85 °C/65% RH PCE stability versus typical molecular HTMs.     

Critical Impact of Hole Transporting Layers and Back Electrode on the Stability of Flexible Organic Photovoltaic Module

Properties of hole transporting layers (HTLs) and back electrode are very critical to the stability of inverted bulk heterojunction organic photovoltaic (OPV) modules. Here, various deposition methods for back electrodes and materials of HTLs are examined by applying to inverted organic solar cells with a structure of indium tin oxide/ZnO/photoactive layer/poly(3,4‐ethylenedioxythiophene):poly(styrenesulfonate) (PEDOT:PSS)/Ag. The experiment is performed on encapsulated modules with flexible barrier films under accelerated conditions. The OPV modules with screen‐printed Ag electrodes are shown to be electrically unstable with a reduction of the current density under damp heat condition at 85 °C/85% RH. Optical images for the active layer/PEDOT:PSS interface reveal that a reaction between the solvent from the Ag electrode and the underlying layers is the major cause for the degradation. In comparison with materials of the HTLs, the PEDOT:PSS layer shows low stability compared to the MoO₃ layer under the accelerated conditions. Unusual chemical changes in the PEDOT:PSS film are observed through X‐ray photoelectron spectroscopy and this is further addressed by correlating the stability of the OPV devices.     

Tetrathienoanthracene and Tetrathienylbenzene Derivatives as Hole‐Transporting Materials for Perovskite Solar Cell

The synthesis and characterization of two related families of star‐shaped thiophene‐containing hole‐transporting materials (HTMs) based on fused tetrathienoanthracene and nonfused tetrathienylbenzene cores are reported. All of them are endowed with four terminal (4,4′‐dimethoxy)diphenylamino groups that are either linked directly to the core or showed a different type of bridges (i.e., thiophene‐phenyl or phenyl rings). The novel HTMs are tested in mixed‐ion perovskite (Cs_0.1FA_0.74MA_0.13PbI_2.48Br_0.39) solar cells, and power conversion efficiencies of up to 18.8% are measured under 1 sun irradiation, comparable with the efficiency obtained for the reference cell using 2,2′,7,7′‐tetrakis(N,N′‐di‐p‐methoxyphenylamine)‐9,9′‐spirobifluorene as an HTM.     

Recent Progress on Hole‐Transporting Materials for Emerging Organometal Halide Perovskite Solar Cells

In less than three years, the photovoltaic community has witnessed a rapid emergence of a new class of solid‐state heterojunction solar cells based on solution‐processable organometal halide perovskite absorbers. The energy conversion efficiency of solid‐state perovskite solar cells (PSCs) has been quickly increased to a certified value of 20.1% by the end of 2014 because of their unique characteristics, such as a broad spectral absorption range, large absorption coefficient, high charge carrier mobility and diffusion length. Here, the focus is specifically on recent developments of hole‐transporting materials (HTMs) in PSCs, which are essential components for achieving high solar cell efficiencies. Some fundamentals with regard to PSCs are first presented, including the history of PSCs, device architectures and general operational principles of PSCs as well as various techniques developed for the fabrications of uniform and dense perovskite complexes. A broad range of the state‐of‐the‐art HTMs being used in PSCs are then discussed in detail. Finally, an outlook on the design of more efficient HTMs for highly efficient PSCs is addressed.     

Toward Long‐Term Stable and Highly Efficient Perovskite Solar Cells via Effective Charge Transporting Materials

Perovskite solar cells (PSCs) have advanced quickly with their power conversion efficiency approaching the record of silicon solar cells. However, there is still a big challenge to obtain both high efficiency and long‐term stability for future commercialization of PSCs. The major instability issue is associated with the decomposition or phase transition of perovskite materials that are believed to be intrinsically unstable under outdoor working conditions. Herein, the authors review the approaches that marked important progress in developing new functional electron/hole transporting materials that enabled highly efficient and stable PSCs. The findings that accelerate charge diffusion and that suppress the irrevocable loss of ions diffusing out of perovskite materials and other diffusion processes are highlighted. In addition, derivative interface engineering methods to control the diffusion process of charges/ions/molecules are also reviewed. Finally, the authors propose key research issues in charge transporting materials and interface engineering with regard to the important diffusion processes that will be one of the keys to realize highly efficient and long‐term stable PSCs.     

Di‐Spiro‐Based Hole‐Transporting Materials for Highly Efficient Perovskite Solar Cells

Hole‐transporting materials (HTMs) are essential for enabling highly efficient perovskite solar cells (PVSCs) to extract and transport the hole carriers. Among numerous HTMs that are studied so far, the single‐spiro‐based compounds are the most frequently used HTMs for achieving highly efficient PVSCs. In fact, all the new spiro‐based HTMs reported so far that render PVSCs over 20% are based on spiro[fluorene‐9,9′‐xanthene] or spiro [cyclopenta [2,1‐b:3,4b′]dithiophene‐4,9′‐fluorene] cores; therefore, there is a need to diversify the design of their structures for further improving their function and performance. In addition, the fundamental understanding of structure–performance relationships for the spiro‐based HTMs is still lagging, for example, how molecular configuration, spiro numbers, and heteroatoms in spiro‐rings impact the efficacy of HTMs. To address these needs, two novel H‐shaped HTMs, G1 and G2 based on the di‐spiro‐rings as the cores are designed and synthesized. The combined good film‐forming properties, better interactions with perovskite, slightly deeper highest occupied molecular orbital, higher mobility and conductivity, as well as more efficient charge transfer for G2 help devices reach a very impressive power conversion efficiency of 20.2% and good stability. This is the first report of demonstrating the feasibility of using di‐spiro‐based HTMs for highly efficient PVSCs.     

Transporting values by technology transfer

The introduction of new medical technologies into a developing country is usually greeted with enthusiasm as the possible benefits become an object of great anticipation and provide new hope for therapy or relief. The prompt utilization of new discoveries and inventions by a medical practitioner serves as a positive indicator of high standing in the professional community.
But the transfer of medical technology also involves a transfer of concomitant values. There is a danger that, in the process of adopting a particular technology, the user takes for granted the general utility and desirability of the implements and procedures under consideration without recognizing the socio-cultural peculiarities of the adopting country. A sensitivity to the social conditions and cultural traditions is important so that the emergence of new values can be examined critically and the transfer of necessary technology can be effected smoothly.
In the Philippines, efforts to boost patronage of transplant technology appear to have overlooked this need for socio-cultural sensitivity. Legislative fiat cannot be used to override deep-seated values.
There is a need to be more sensitive to the possible confrontation of values that the transfer of technology brings in order to avoid the erosion of indigenous socio-cultural values and minimize the intrusiveness of beneficial medical technology.     

Transporting Values by Technology Transfer

The introduction of new medical technologies into a developing country is usually greeted with enthusiasm as the possible benefits become an object of great anticipation and provide new hope for therapy or relief. The prompt utilization of new discoveries and inventions by a medical practitioner serves as a positive indicator of high standing in the professional community.
But the transfer of medical technology also involves a transfer of concomitant values. There is a danger that, in the process of adopting a particular technology, the user takes for granted the general utility and desirability of the implements and procedures under consideration without recognizing the socio-cultural peculiarities of the adopting country. A sensitivity to the social conditions and cultural traditions is important so that the emergence of new values can be examined critically and the transfer of necessary technology can be effected smoothly.
In the Philippines, efforts to boost patronage of transplant technology appear to have overlooked this need for socio-cultural sensitivity. Legislative fiat cannot be used to override deep-seated values.
There is a need to be more sensitive to the possible confrontation of values that the transfer of technology brings in order to avoid the erosion of indigenous socio-cultural values and minimize the intrusiveness of beneficial medical technology.     

Molecularly Engineered Phthalocyanines as Hole‐Transporting Materials in Perovskite Solar Cells Reaching Power Conversion Efficiency of 17.5%

Easily accessible tetra‐5‐hexylthiophene‐, tetra‐5‐hexyl‐2,2′‐bisthiophene‐substituted zinc phthalocyanines (ZnPcs) and tetra‐tert ‐butyl ZnPc are employed as hole‐transporting materials in mixed‐ion perovskite [HC(NH₂)₂]_0.85(CH₃NH₃)_0.15Pb(I_0.85Br_0.15)₃ solar cells, reaching the highest power conversion efficiency (PCE) so far for phthalocyanines. Results confirm that the photovoltaic performance is strongly influenced by both, the individual optoelectronic properties of ZnPcs and the aggregation of these tetrapyrrolic semiconductors in the solid thin film. The optimized devices exhibit PCE of 15.5% when using tetra‐5‐hexyl‐2,2′‐bisthiophene substituted ZnPcs, 13.3% for tetra‐tert ‐butyl ZnPc, and a record 17.5% for tetra‐5‐hexylthiophene‐based analogue under standard global 100 mW cm^?2 AM 1.5G illumination. These results boost up the potential of solution‐processed ZnPc derivatives as stable and economic hole‐transport materials for large‐scale applications, opening new frontiers toward a realistic, efficient, and inexpensive energy production.     

Comparative Ultrastructure of Arthropod Transporting Epithelia

The general organization of arthropod epithelia is comparedto that of vertebrates. It is suggested that although ciliatedepithelia, stratified epithelia and in some cases continuousmuscle sheaths do not occur in arthropods, they have certainanalogous structures which carry out the same functions. Forexample, the arthropod cuticle is compared to the squamous layerof vertebrate stratified epithelia, and complex arthropod basementmembranes are compared to the muscle and connective tissue sheathsof certain vertebrate epithelia. The cellular organization oftransporting epithelial cells is then discussed, with particularreference to elaboration of plasma membranes, and similaritiesand differences between vertebrates and arthropods, and betweeninsects and crustaceans are pointed out. Specializations peculiarto insect cells are described, including the insertion of mitochondriainto apical membrane microvilli, and the presence along thismembrane of small particles called portasomes believed to beinvolved in active transport. Finally, it is shown that in themidgut of theinsect Manduca sexta, distinct ultrastructuralchanges accompany loss of potassium transport activity duringa larval molt and in the prepupal stage. The ultrastructuralchanges which occur include a proliferation of the basementmembrane and muscle tissue underlying the epithelium, and achange in the morphology of the potassium transporting gobletcells. Possible correlations between ultrastructural changesand loss of transport activity are discussed.