Bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) for the real-time detection of protein-protein interactions

A substantial range of protein-protein interactions can be readily monitored in real time using bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET). The procedure involves heterologous coexpression of fusion proteins, which link proteins of interest to a bioluminescent donor enzyme or acceptor fluorophore. Energy transfer between these proteins is then detected. This protocol encompasses BRET1, BRET2 and the recently described eBRET, including selection of the donor, acceptor and substrate combination, fusion construct generation and validation, cell culture, fluorescence and luminescence detection, BRET detection and data analysis. The protocol is particularly suited to studying protein-protein interactions in live cells (adherent or in suspension), but cell extracts and purified proteins can also be used. Furthermore, although the procedure is illustrated with references to mammalian cell culture conditions, this protocol can be readily used for bacterial or plant studies. Once fusion proteins are generated and validated, the procedure typically takes 48-72 h depending on cell culture requirements.     

Illuminating insights into protein-protein interactions using bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET)

Bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) is a straightforward biophysical technique for studying protein-protein interactions. It requires: (1) that proteins of interest and suitable controls be labeled with either a donor or acceptor molecule, (2) placement of these labeled proteins in the desired environment for assessing their potential interaction, and (3) use of suitable detection instrumentation to monitor resultant energy transfer. There are now several possible applications, combinations of donor and acceptor molecules, potential assay environments and detection system perturbations. Therefore, this review aims to demystify and clarify the important aspects of the BRET methodology that should be considered when using this technique.     

Comparison of enhanced bioluminescence energy transfer donors for protease biosensors

Bioluminescence energy transfer (BRET) is a powerful tool for the study of protein-protein interactions and conformational changes within proteins. We directly compared two recently developed variants of Renilla luciferase (RLuc), RLuc2 and RLuc8, as BRET donors using an in vitro thrombin assay. The comparison was carried out by placing a thrombin-specific cleavage sequence between the donor luciferase and a green fluorescent protein (GFP(2)) acceptor. Substitution of native RLuc with the RLuc mutants, RLuc2 and 8, in a BRET(2) fusion protein increased the light output by a factor of ~10. Substitution of native RLuc with either of the RLuc mutants resulted in a decrease in BRET(2) ratio by a factor of ~2 when BRET(2) components were separated by the thrombin cleavage sequence. BRET(2) ratios changed by factors of 18.8±1.2 and 18.2±0.4 for GFP(2)-RG-RLuc2 and GFP(2)-RG-RLuc8 fusion proteins, respectively, on thrombin cleavage compared to 28.8±0.20 for GFP(2)-RG-RLuc. The detection limits for thrombin were 0.23 and 0.26 nM for RLuc2 and RLuc8 BRET(2) systems, respectively, and 15 pM for GFP(2)-RG-RLuc. However, overall, the mutant BRET systems remain more sensitive than FRET and brighter than standard BRET(2).     

Direct comparison of fluorescence- and bioluminescence-based resonance energy transfer methods for real-time monitoring of thrombin-catalysed proteolytic cleavage

In this study, a representative FRET system (CFP donor and YFP acceptor) is compared with the BRET(2) system (Renilla luciferase donor, green fluorescent protein(2) (GFP(2)) acceptor and coelenterazine 400a substrate). Cleavage of a thrombin-protease-sensitive peptide sequence inserted between the donor and acceptor proteins was detected by the RET signal. Complete cleavage by thrombin changed the BRET(2) signal by a factor of 28.9+/-0.2 (R.S.D. (relative standard deviation), n=3) and the FRET signal by a factor of 3.2+/-0.1 (R.S.D., n=3). The BRET(2) technique was 50 times more sensitive than the FRET technique for monitoring thrombin concentrations. Detection limits (blank signal+3sigma(b), where sigma(b)=the standard deviation (S.D.) of the blank signal) were calculated to be 3.05 and 0.22nM thrombin for FRET and BRET(2), respectively. This direct comparison suggests that the BRET(2) technique is more suitable than FRET for use in proximity assays such as protease cleavage assays or protein-protein interaction assays.     

A rigorous experimental framework for detecting protein oligomerization using bioluminescence resonance energy transfer

Bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET), which relies on nonradiative energy transfer between luciferase-coupled donors and GFP-coupled acceptors, is emerging as a useful tool for analyzing the quaternary structures of cell-surface molecules. Conventional BRET analyses are generally done at maximal expression levels and single acceptor/donor ratios. We show that under these conditions substantial energy transfer arises from random interactions within the membrane. The dependence of BRET efficiency on acceptor/donor ratio at fixed surface density, or expression level at a defined acceptor/donor ratio, can nevertheless be used to correctly distinguish between well-characterized monomeric and oligomeric proteins, including a very weak dimer. The pitfalls associated with the nonrigorous treatment of BRET data are illustrated for the case of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) proposed to form homophilic and/or mixed oligomers on the basis of previous, conventional BRET experiments.     

Improved donor/acceptor BRET couples for monitoring β-arrestin recruitment to G protein-coupled receptors

We report highly sensitive bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) assays with optimized donor/acceptor couples. We combined the energy donors Renilla luciferase (Rluc) and the Rluc8 variant with the energy acceptors yellow fluorescent protein, the YPet variant and the Renilla green fluorescent protein (RGFP). Different donor/acceptor couples were tested in well-established assays measuring ligand-induced β-arrestin (βARR) intramolecular rearrangements and recruitment to G protein-coupled receptors. We show increased sensitivity with Rluc8/YPet and Rluc8/RGFP couples and measured previously undetectable BRET signals. These tools improve existing βARR assays and offer new options for the development of future BRET assays.     

Extended bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (eBRET) for monitoring prolonged protein-protein interactions in live cells

Bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) is an increasingly popular technique for studying protein-protein interactions in live cells. It is particularly suitable for real-time monitoring of such interactions, however, the timescale over which assays can be carried out is currently relatively short (minutes) due to substrate instability. We present a new derivation of the BRET technology, termed 'extended BRET' (eBRET), which now enables protein-protein interactions to be monitored in real-time for many hours. This capability has significant benefits for investigating cellular function over extended timescales, as we have illustrated using the agonist-induced G-protein coupled receptor/beta-arrestin interaction. The potential for studying the modulation of such interactions by agonists, antagonists, inhibitors, dominant negative mutants and co-expressed accessory proteins is substantial. Furthermore, the advantages of eBRET have important implications for the development of high-throughput BRET screening systems, an ever-expanding area of interest for the pharmaceutical industry.     

Analysis of in vitro SUMOylation using bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET)

We demonstrated in vitro small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO)-mediated modification (SUMOylation) of RanGTPase activating protein-1 (RanGAP1) by using bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) for studying protein interactions. Renilla luciferase (Rluc) was fused to SUMO, and RanGAP1, the binding partner of SUMO, was fused to enhanced yellow fluorescence protein (EYFP). Upon binding of SUMO and RanGAP1, BRET was observed between EYFP (donor) and Rluc (acceptor) in the presence of E1 (Aos1/Uba2) and E2 (Ubc9) enzymes, whereas mutation (K524A) of RanGAP1 at its SUMO binding site prevented significant energy transfer. Comparing BRET and fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) efficiencies using this in vitro model system, we observed that BRET efficiency was 3-fold higher than FRET efficiency, due to the lower background signal intensity of EYFP in the BRET system. Consequently, BRET system is expected to be useful for in vitro analysis of SUMOylation as well as studying other protein interactions.     

Constitutive and agonist-dependent homo-oligomerization of the thyrotropin-releasing hormone receptor. Detection in living cells using bioluminescence resonance energy transfer

The ability of G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) to interact to form new functional structures, either forming oligomers with themselves or forming associations with other intracellular proteins, has important implications for the regulation of cellular events; however, little is known about how this occurs. Here, we have employed a newly emerging technology, bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET), used to study protein-protein interactions in living cells, to demonstrate that the thyrotropin-releasing hormone receptor (TRHR) forms constitutive homo-oligomers. This formation of TRHR homo-oligomers in the absence of ligand was shown by demonstration of an energy transfer between TRHR molecules fused to either donor, Renilla luciferase (Rluc) or acceptor, enhanced yellow fluorescent protein (EYFP) molecules. This interaction was shown to be specific, since energy transfer was not detected between co-expressed tagged TRHRs and either complementary tagged gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) or beta(2)-adrenergic receptors. Furthermore, generation of a BRET signal between the TRHRs could only be inhibited by co-expression of the wild-type TRHR and not by other GPCRs. Agonist stimulation led to a time- and dose-dependent increase in the amount of energy transfer. Inhibition of receptor internalization by co-expression of dynamin mutant K44A did not affect the interaction between TRHRs, suggesting that clustering of receptors within clathrin-coated pits is not sufficient for energy transfer to occur. BRET also provided evidence for the agonist-induced oligomerization of another GPCR, the GnRH receptor (GnRHR), and the presence of an agonist-induced interaction of the adaptor protein, beta-arrestin, with TRHR and the absence of an interaction of beta-arrestin with GnRHR. This study supports the usefulness of BRET as a powerful tool for studying GPCR aggregations and receptor/protein interactions in general and presents evidence that the functioning unit of TRHRs exists as homomeric complexes.     

Functional complementation of high-efficiency resonance energy transfer: a new tool for the study of protein binding interactions in living cells

Green bioluminescence in Renilla species is generated by a approximately 100% efficient RET (resonance energy transfer) process that is caused by the direct association of a blue-emitting luciferase [Rluc (Renilla luciferase)] and an RGFP (Renilla green fluorescent protein). Despite the high efficiency, such a system has never been evaluated as a potential reporter of protein-protein interactions. To address the question, we compared and analysed in mammalian cells the bioluminescence of Rluc and RGFP co-expressed as free native proteins, or as fused single-chain polypeptides and tethered partners of self-assembling coiled coils. Here, we show that: (i) no spontaneous interactions generating detectable BRET (bioluminescence RET) signals occur between the free native proteins; (ii) high-efficiency BRET similar to that observed in Renilla occurs in both fusion proteins and self-interacting chimaeras, but only if the N-terminal of RGFP is free; (iii) the high-efficiency BRET interaction is associated with a dramatic increase in light output when the luminescent reaction is triggered by low-quantum yield coelenterazine analogues. Here, we propose a new functional complementation assay based on the detection of the high-efficiency BRET signal that is generated when the reporters Rluc and RGFP are brought into close proximity by a pair of interacting proteins to which they are linked. To demonstrate its performance, we implemented the assay to measure the interaction between GPCRs (G-protein-coupled receptors) and beta-arrestins. We show that complementation-induced BRET allows detection of the GPCR-beta-arrestin interaction in a simple luminometric assay with high signal-to-noise ratio, good dynamic range and rapid response.     

Demonstration of improvements to the bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) technology for the monitoring of G protein-coupled receptors in live cells

The bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) technique has become extremely popular for studying protein-protein interactions in living cells and real time. Of particular interest is the ability to monitor interactions between G protein-coupled receptors, such as the thyrotropin-releasing hormone receptor (TRHR), and proteins critical for regulating their function, such as beta-arrestin. Using TRHR/beta-arrestin interactions, we have demonstrated improvements to all 3 generations of BRET (BRET(1), BRET(2), and eBRET) by using the novel forms of luciferase, Rluc2 and Rluc8, developed by the Gambhir laboratory. Furthermore, for the 1st time it was possible to use the BRET2 system to detect ligand-induced G protein-coupled receptor/beta-arrestin interactions over prolonged periods (on the scale of hours rather than seconds) with a very stable signal. As demonstrated by our Z'-factor data, these luciferases increase the sensitivity of BRET to such an extent that they substantially increase the potential applicability of this technology for effective drug discovery high-throughput screening.     

Fusion of Aequorea victoria GFP and aequorin provides their Ca(2+)-induced interaction that results in red shift of GFP absorption and efficient bioluminescence energy transfer

The bioluminescence emitted by Aequorea victoria jellyfish is greenish while its single bioluminescent photoprotein aequorin emits blue light. This phenomenon may be explained by a bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) from aequorin chromophore to green fluorescent protein (GFP) co-localized with it. However, a slight overlapping of the aequorin bioluminescence spectrum with the GFP absorption spectrum and the absence of marked interaction between these proteins in vitro pose a question on the mechanism providing the efficient BRET in A. victoria. Here we report the in vitro study of BRET between homologous Ca(2+)-activated photoproteins, aequorin or obelin (Obelia longissima), as bioluminescence energy donors, and GFP, as an acceptor. The fusions containing donor and acceptor proteins linked by a 19 aa peptide were purified after expressing their genes in Escherichia coli cells. It was shown that the GFP-aequorin fusion has a significantly greater BRET efficiency, compared to the GFP-obelin fusion. Two main factors responsible for the difference in BRET efficiency of these fusions were revealed. First, it is the presence of Ca(2+)-induced interaction between the donor and acceptor in the aequorin-containing fusion and the absence of the interaction in the obelin-containing fusion. Second, it is a red shift of GFP absorption toward better overlapping with aequorin bioluminescence induced by the interaction of aequorin with GFP. Since the connection of the two proteins in vitro mimics their proximity in vivo, Ca(2+)-induced interaction between aequorin and GFP may occur in A. victoria jellyfish providing efficient BRET in this organism.     

Detection of heteromerization of more than two proteins by sequential BRET-FRET

Identification of higher-order oligomers in the plasma membrane is essential to decode the properties of molecular networks controlling intercellular communication. We combined bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) and fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) in a technique called sequential BRET-FRET (SRET) that permits identification of heteromers formed by three different proteins. In SRET, the oxidation of a Renilla luciferase (Rluc) substrate by an Rluc fusion protein triggers acceptor excitation of a second fusion protein by BRET and subsequent FRET to a third fusion protein. We describe two variations of SRET that use different Rluc substrates with appropriately paired acceptor fluorescent proteins. Using SRET, we identified complexes of cannabinoid CB(1), dopamine D(2) and adenosine A(2A) receptors in living cells. SRET is an invaluable technique to identify heteromeric complexes of more than two neurotransmitter receptors, which will allow us to better understand how signals are integrated at the molecular level.     

Biochemical and biophysical characterization of serotonin 5-HT2C receptor homodimers on the plasma membrane of living cells

While many studies have provided evidence of homodimerization and heterodimerization of G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs), few studies have used fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) combined with confocal microscopy to visualize receptor dimerization on the plasma membrane, and there have been no reports demonstrating the expression of serotonin receptor dimers/oligomers on the plasma membrane of living cells. In the study presented here, biochemical and biophysical techniques were used to determine if 5-HT(2C) receptors exist as homodimers on the plasma membrane of living cells. Immunoprecipitation followed by Western blotting revealed the presence of immunoreactive bands the predicted size of 5-HT(2C) receptor monomers and homodimers that were detergent and cross-linker sensitive. Bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) was assessed in HEK293 cells expressing 5-HT(2C) receptors labeled with Renilla luciferase and yellow fluorescent protein. BRET levels were not altered by pretreatment with serotonin. Confocal microscopy provided direct visualization of FRET on the plasma membrane of live cells expressing 5-HT(2C) receptors labeled with cyan (donor) and yellow (acceptor) fluorescent proteins. FRET, assessed by acceptor photobleaching, was dependent on the donor/acceptor ratio and independent of acceptor expression levels, indicating that FRET resulted from receptor clustering and not from overexpression of randomly distributed receptors, providing evidence for GPCR dimers/oligomers in a clustered distribution on the plasma membrane. The results of this study suggest that 5-HT(2C) receptors exist as constitutive homodimers on the plasma membrane of living cells. In addition, a confocal-based FRET method for monitoring receptor dimerization directly on the plasma membrane of living cells is described.     

A new pair for inter- and intra-molecular FRET measurement

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer between mutant green fluorescent proteins provides powerful means to monitor in vivo protein-protein proximity and intracellular signaling. However, the current widely applied FRET pair of this class (CFP/YFP) requires excitation by expensive UV lasers, thereby hindering FRET imaging on many confocal microscopes. Further challenges arise from the large spectral overlap of CFP/YFP emission. Another FRET pair GFP/DsRed could obviate such limitations. However, the use of DsRed as a FRET acceptor is hampered by several critical problems, including a slow and incomplete maturation and obligate tetramerization. A tandem dimer mutant of DsRed (TDimer2) has similar spectral properties as those of DsRed. The rapid maturation and non-oligomerization make TDimer2 a promising substitute for DsRed in FRET experiments. Here, we have explored the possibility of using TDimer2 as a FRET acceptor for the donor EGFP. FRET was demonstrated between the EGFP-TDimer2 chimeric fusion protein. By substituting CFP/YFP in the Ca2+-sensor cameleon with EGFP/TDimer2, dynamic changes in cytosolic free Ca2+ concentrations were observed with 488nm excitation under conventional wide-field microscopy. The EGFP/TDimer2 pair was further successfully employed to monitor inter-molecular interaction between Syntaxin and SNAP25. These results reveal EGFP/TDimer2 as a promising FRET pair in monitoring intra-molecular conformation change as well as inter-molecular interaction.     

Assembly and signaling of CRLR and RAMP1 complexes assessed by BRET

Biochemical and functional evidence suggest that the calcitonin receptor-like receptor (CRLR) interacts with receptor activity-modifying protein-1 (RAMP1) to generate a calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP) receptor. Using bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET), we investigated the oligomeric assembly of the CRLR-RAMP1 signaling complex in living cells. As for their wild-type counterparts, fusion proteins linking CRLR and RAMP1 to the energy donor Renilla luciferase (Rluc) and energy acceptor green fluorescent protein (GFP) reach the cell surface only upon coexpression of CRLR and RAMP1. Radioligand binding and cAMP production assays also confirmed that the fusion proteins retained normal functional properties. BRET titration experiments revealed that CRLR and RAMP1 associate selectively to form heterodimers. This association was preserved for a mutated RAMP1 that cannot reach the cell surface, even in the presence of CRLR, indicating that the deficient targeting resulted from the altered conformation of the complex rather than a lack of heterodimerization. BRET analysis also showed that, in addition to associate with one another, both CRLR and RAMP1 can form homodimers. The homodimerization of the coreceptor was further confirmed by the ability of RAMP1 to prevent cell surface targeting of a truncated RAMP1 that normally exhibits receptor-independent plasma membrane delivery. Although the role of such dimerization remains unknown, BRET experiments clearly demonstrated that CRLR can engage signaling partners, such as G proteins and beta-arrestin, following CGRP stimulation, only in the presence of RAMP1. In addition to shed new light on the CRLR-RAMP1 signaling complex, the BRET assays developed herein offer new biosensors for probing CGRP receptor activity.     

Third-Party Bioluminescence Resonance Energy Transfer Indicates Constitutive Association of Membrane Proteins: Application to Class A G-Protein-Coupled Receptors and G-Proteins

Many of the molecules that mediate G-protein signaling are thought to constitutively associate with each other in variably stable signaling complexes. Much of the evidence for signaling complexes has come from Förster resonance energy transfer and bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) studies. However, detection of constitutive protein association with these methods is hampered by nonspecific energy transfer that occurs when donor and acceptor molecules are in close proximity by chance. We show that chemically-induced recruitment of local third-party BRET donors or acceptors reliably separates nonspecific and specific BRET. We use this method to reexamine the constitutive association of class A G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) with other GPCRs and with heterotrimeric G-proteins. We find that β2 adrenoreceptors constitutively associate with each other and with several other class A GPCRs. In contrast, GPCRs and G-proteins are unlikely to exist in stable constitutive preassembled complexes.     

生物发光共振能量转移技术及其应用

生物发光共振能量转移（BRET）技术是近10年来出现的一种新的检测蛋白质- 蛋白质相互作用的技术.它的最大优势是能在活细胞中实时进行检测,因此能够进行相互作 用动力学的研究.本文系统阐述了BRET的原理和方法,综述了 BRET技术的最新进展,以及该 技术在G蛋白偶联受体（GPCRs）信号转导及药物发现中的应用.