Differential Role of Autophagy in CD4 T Cells and Macrophages during X4 and R5 HIV-1 Infection

Background

HIV-1 can infect and replicate in both CD4 T cells and macrophages. In these cell types, HIV-1 entry is mediated by the binding of envelope glycoproteins (gp120 and gp41, Env) to the receptor CD4 and a coreceptor, principally CCR5 or CXCR4, depending on the viral strain (R5 or X4, respectively). Uninfected CD4 T cells undergo X4 Env-mediated autophagy, leading to their apoptosis, a mechanism now recognized as central to immunodeficiency.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We demonstrate here that autophagy and cell death are also induced in the uninfected CD4 T cells by HIV-1 R5 Env, while autophagy is inhibited in productively X4 or R5-infected CD4 T cells. In contrast, uninfected macrophages, a preserved cell population during HIV-1 infection, do not undergo X4 or R5 Env-mediated autophagy. Autophagosomes, however, are present in macrophages exposed to infectious HIV-1 particles, independently of coreceptor use. Interestingly, we observed two populations of autophagic cells: one highly autophagic and the other weakly autophagic. Surprisingly, viruses could be detected in the weakly autophagic cells but not in the highly autophagic cells. In addition, we show that the triggering of autophagy in macrophages is necessary for viral replication but addition of Bafilomycin A1, which blocks the final stages of autophagy, strongly increases productive infection.

Conclusions/Significance

Taken together, our data suggest that autophagy plays a complex, but essential, role in HIV pathology by regulating both viral replication and the fate of the target cells.     

Role of Autophagy in HIV Pathogenesis and Drug Abuse

Autophagy is a highly regulated process in which excessive cytoplasmic materials are captured and degraded during deprivation conditions. The unique nature of autophagy that clears invasive microorganisms has made it an important cellular defense mechanism in a variety of clinical situations. In recent years, it has become increasingly clear that autophagy is extensively involved in the pathology of HIV-1. To ensure survival of the virus, HIV-1 viral proteins modulate and utilize the autophagy pathway so that biosynthesis of the virus is maximized. At the same time, the abuse of illicit drugs such as methamphetamine, cocaine, morphine, and alcohol is thought to be a significant risk factor for the acquirement and progression of HIV-1. During drug-induced toxicity, autophagic activity has been proved to be altered in various cell types. Here, we review the current literature on the interaction between autophagy, HIV-1, and drug abuse and discuss the complex role of autophagy during HIV-1 pathogenesis in co-exposure to illicit drugs.     

Dysregulation of autophagy by HIV-1 Nef in human astrocytes

Viruses often exploit autophagy, a common cellular process of degradation of damaged proteins, organelles, and pathogens, to avoid destruction. HIV-1 dysregulates this process in several cell types by means of Nef protein. Nef is a small HIV-1 protein which is expressed abundantly in astrocytes of HIV-1-infected brains and has been suggested to have a role in the pathogenesis of HIV-Associated Neurocognitive Disorders (HAND). In order to explore its effect in the CNS with respect to autophagy, HIV-1 Nef was expressed in primary human fetal astrocytes (PHFA) using an adenovirus vector (Ad-Nef). We observed that Nef expression triggered the accumulation of autophagy markers, ATG8/LC3 and p62 (SQSMT1). Similar results were obtained with Bafilomycin A1, an autophagy inhibitor which blocks the fusion of autophagosome to lysosome. Furthermore co-expression of tandem LC3 vector (mRFP-EGFP-LC3) and Ad-Nef in these cells produced mainly yellow puncta (mRFP+, EGFP+) strongly suggesting that autophagosome fusion to lysosome is blocked in PHFA cells in the presence of Nef. Together these data indicate that HIV-1 Nef mimics Bafilomycin A1 and blocks the last step of autophagy thereby helping HIV-1 virus to avoid autophagic degradation in human astrocytes.     

TRIM proteins regulate autophagy: TRIM5 is a selective autophagy receptor mediating HIV-1 restriction

The tripartite motif protein family (TRIM) constitutes a class of immune-regulated proteins with antiviral, immune, cancer, and other properties reminiscent of those ascribed to autophagy. We show that TRIMs have dual roles in autophagy: as regulators and as cargo receptors. As regulators, TRIMs nucleate the core autophagy machinery by acting as platforms that assemble ULK1 and BECN1 into a functional complex in preparation for autophagy. TRIMs also act as novel selective autophagy receptors as exemplified by TRIM5/TRIM5α, a known HIV-1 restriction factor with a hitherto poorly defined mode of action. TRIM5 recognizes and targets HIV-1 for autophagic destruction. TRIM5 interactions with mammalian Atg8 proteins are required for this effector function. This establishes TRIM family members as regulators of autophagy, explains the antiretroviral mechanism of TRIM5, and defines a new basis for selective autophagy.     

TRIM proteins regulate autophagy: TRIM5 is a selective autophagy receptor mediating HIV-1 restriction

The tripartite motif protein family (TRIM) constitutes a class of immune-regulated proteins with antiviral, immune, cancer, and other properties reminiscent of those ascribed to autophagy. We show that TRIMs have dual roles in autophagy: as regulators and as cargo receptors. As regulators, TRIMs nucleate the core autophagy machinery by acting as platforms that assemble ULK1 and BECN1 into a functional complex in preparation for autophagy. TRIMs also act as novel selective autophagy receptors as exemplified by TRIM5/TRIM5α, a known HIV-1 restriction factor with a hitherto poorly defined mode of action. TRIM5 recognizes and targets HIV-1 for autophagic destruction. TRIM5 interactions with mammalian Atg8 proteins are required for this effector function. This establishes TRIM family members as regulators of autophagy, explains the antiretroviral mechanism of TRIM5, and defines a new basis for selective autophagy.     

HIV-1 Tat protein induces glial cell autophagy through enhancement of BAG3 protein levels

BAG3 protein has been described as an anti-apoptotic and pro-autophagic factor in several neoplastic and normal cells. We previously demonstrated that BAG3 expression is elevated upon HIV-1 infection of glial and T lymphocyte cells. Among HIV-1 proteins, Tat is highly involved in regulating host cell response to viral infection. Therefore, we investigated the possible role of Tat protein in modulating BAG3 protein levels and the autophagic process itself. In this report, we show that transfection with Tat raises BAG3 levels in glioblastoma cells. Moreover, BAG3 silencing results in highly reducing Tat- induced levels of LC3-II and increasing the appearance of sub G0/G1 apoptotic cells, in keeping with the reported role of BAG3 in modulating the autophagy/apoptosis balance. These results demonstrate for the first time that Tat protein is able to stimulate autophagy through increasing BAG3 levels in human glial cells.     

HIV-1 Inhibits Autophagy in Bystander Macrophage/Monocytic Cells through Src-Akt and STAT3

Autophagy is a homeostatic mechanism of lysosomal degradation. Defective autophagy has been linked to various disorders such as impaired control of pathogens and neurodegeneration. Autophagy is regulated by a complex array of signaling pathways that act upstream of autophagy proteins. Little is known about the role of altered regulatory signaling in disorders associated with defective autophagy. In particular, it is not known if pathogens inhibit autophagy by modulation of upstream regulatory pathways. Cells infected with HIV-1 blocked rapamycin-induced autophagy and CD40-induced autophagic killing of Toxoplasma gondii in bystander (non-HIV-1 infected) macrophage/monocytic cells. Blockade of autophagy was dependent on Src-Akt and STAT3 triggered by HIV-1 Tat and IL-10. Neutralization of the upstream receptors VEGFR, β-integrin or CXCR4, as well as of HIV-1 Tat or IL-10 restored autophagy in macrophage/monocytic cells exposed to HIV-1-infected cells. Defective autophagic killing of T. gondii was detected in monocyte-derived macrophages from a subset of HIV-1⁺ patients. This defect was also reverted by neutralization of Tat or IL-10. These studies revealed that a pathogen can impair autophagy in non-infected cells by activating counter-regulatory pathways. The fact that pharmacologic manipulation of cell signaling restored autophagy in cells exposed to HIV-1-infected cells raises the possibility of therapeutic manipulation of cell signaling to restore autophagy in HIV-1 infection.     

Anti-HIV-1 activity of an ionically modified porous polypropylene membrane determined by filtration of a viral suspension

We describe here a unique anti-HIV-1 membrane, derived from a chemically modified porous polypropylene (PP) membrane, which lowers viral infectivity upon the filtration of HIV-1 suspension. A cationic polymer, polyethyleneimine (PEI) was graft-polymerized onto the PP filter membrane (PP-PEI), and infectious HIV-1(HTLV-IIIB) derived from MOLT-4/HIV-1(HTLV-IIIB) cells (HIV-1(HTLV-IIIB(MOLT-4)) was applied. When a viral suspension of high titer (10(3.93) TCID50 ml(-1) was filtered, efficient reduction (>99%) of gag p24 antigen levels and infectious titer resulted. In a viral suspension of medium titer (10(2.37) TCID50 ml(-1), a significant decrease in the p24 antigen did not occur, although the titer was markedly reduced (>95%). Electron microscopic observation suggested that PEI induced viral aggregations under high titer conditions, and under medium titer conditions, PEI deprived HIV-1(HTLV-IIIB(MOLT-4)) of its infectivity alone to avoid virus adsorption. In contrast, HIV-1 propagated in human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) such as HIV-1(HTLV-III(PBMC)) was more efficiently trapped by PP-PEI at lower titers as compared with HIV-1(HTLV-IIIB(MOLT-4)) from MOLT-4/HIV-1(HTLV-IIIB) cells. These data suggest host cell modification in the interactions between PP-PEI and HIV-1 strains. Since HIV-1(HTLV-IIIB(MOLT-4)) and HIV-1(HTLV-IIIB(PBMC)) were almost electrically neutral and negative, respectively, we concluded that the divergent effect of PEI on each HIV-1(HTLV-IIIB) resulted from their different electrical characteristics.     

Autophagy and CD4+ T lymphocyte destruction by HIV-1

The first step of HIV-1 infection is mediated by the binding of envelope glycoproteins (Env) to CD4 and two major coreceptors, CCR5 or CXCR4. The HIV-1 strains that use CCR5 are involved in primo-infection whereas those HIV-1 strains that use CXCR4 play a major role in the demise of CD4+ T lymphocytes and a rapid progression toward AIDS. Notably, binding of X4 Env expressed on cells to CXCR4 triggers apoptosis of uninfected CD4+ T cells. We now have just demonstrated that, independently of HIV-1 replication, transfected or HIV-1-infected cells that express X4 Env induce autophagy and accumulation of Beclin 1 in uninfected CD4+ T lymphocytes via CXCR4. Moreover, autophagy is a prerequisite to Env-induced apoptosis in uninfected bystander T cells, and CD4+ T cells still undergo an Env-mediated cell death with autophagic features when apoptosis is inhibited. To the best of our knowledge, these findings represent the first example of autophagy triggered through binding of virus envelope proteins to a cellular receptor, without viral replication, leading to apoptosis. Here, we proposed hypotheses about the significance of Env-induced Beclin 1 accumulation in CD4+ T cell death and about the role of autophagy in HIV-1 infected cells depending on the coreceptor involved.     

Impact of cellular autophagy on viruses: Insights from hepatitis B virus and human retroviruses

Autophagy is a protein degradative process important for normal cellular metabolism. It is apparently used also by cells to eliminate invading pathogens. Interestingly, many pathogens have learned to subvert the cell’s autophagic process. Here, we review the interactions between viruses and cells in regards to cellular autophagy. Using findings from hepatitis B virus and human retroviruses, HIV-1 and HTLV-1, we discuss mechanisms used by viruses to usurp cellular autophagy in ways that benefit viral replication.     

BFRF1 protein is involved in EBV-mediated autophagy manipulation

Viral egress and autophagy are two mechanisms that seem to be strictly connected in Herpesviruses’s biology. Several data suggest that the autophagic machinery facilitates the egress of viral capsids and thus the production of new infectious particles. In the Herpesvirus family, viral nuclear egress is controlled and organized by a well conserved group of proteins named Nuclear Egress Complex (NEC). In the case of EBV, NEC is composed by BFRF1 and BFLF2 proteins, although the alterations of the nuclear host cell architecture are mainly driven by BFRF1, a multifunctional viral protein anchored to the inner nuclear membrane of the host cell. BFRF1 shares a peculiar distribution with several nuclear components and with them it strictly interacts. In this study, we investigated the possible role of BFRF1 in manipulating autophagy, pathway that possibly originates from nucleus, regulating the interplay between autophagy and viral egress.     

The activation of KSHV lytic cycle blocks autophagy in PEL cells

This study confirms that autophagy is activated concomitantly with KSHV lytic cycle induction, and that autophagy inhibition by BECN1 knockdown reduces viral lytic gene expression. In addition, we extend previous observations and show that autophagy is blocked at late steps, during viral replication. This is indicated by the lack of colocalization of autophagosomes and lysosomes and by the LC3-II level that does not increase in the presence of bafilomycin A₁ in primary effusion lymphoma (PEL) cells induced to enter the lytic cycle, either by TPA/sodium butyrate (BC3 and BCBL1) or by doxycycline (TRExBCBL1-Rta). The autophagic block correlates with the downregulation of RAB7, whose silencing with specific siRNA results in an autophagic block in the same cells. Finally, by electron microscopy analysis, we observed viral particles inside autophagic vesicles in the cytoplasm of PEL cells undergoing viral replication, suggesting that they may be involved in viral transport.     

Autophagy: an overlooked mechanism of HIV-1 pathogenesis and neuroAIDS?

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) establishes a persistent infection characterized by progressive depletion of CD4(+) lymphocytes and immunosuppression. Although extensive research has examined the importance of apoptosis as a cause of cell death associated with HIV-1 infection, the role of autophagy has been largely ignored. Our laboratory has examined the autophagic process in HIV-1-infected cells. Following infection of human peripheral blood CD4(+) T-cells or U937 cells with HIV-1 for 48 hours, the autophagy proteins Beclin 1 and LC3-II were found to be markedly decreased. Beclin 1 mRNA expression and autophagosomes were also reduced in HIV-1 infected cells. Thus, our data indicate that HIV-1 infection inhibits autophagy in infected cells in contrast to the previously described induction of autophagy by gp120 in uninfected bystander cells. It is likely that HIV-1 has evolved this mechanism as part of an elaborate attempt to evade the immune system while promoting its own replication. We believe that autophagy is an overlooked mechanism in HIV-1 pathogenesis and plays a particularly important role in the early cognitive impairment and dementia often associated with advanced AIDS. A model is presented that describes the potential role of autophagy in NeuroAIDS.     

Autophagy: An overlooked mechanism of HIV-1 pathogenesis and NeuroAIDS?

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) establishes a persistent infection characterized by progressive depletion of CD4⁺ lymphocytes and immunosuppression. Although extensive research has examined the importance of apoptosis as a cause of cell death associated with HIV-1 infection, the role of autophagy has been largely ignored. Our laboratory has examined the autophagic process in HIV-1-infected cells. Following infection of human peripheral blood CD4+ T-cells or U937 cells with HIV-1 for 48 hours, the autophagy proteins Beclin 1 and LC3-II were found to be markedly decreased. Beclin 1 mRNA expression and autophagosomes were also reduced in HIV-1 infected cells. Thus, our data indicate that HIV-1 infection inhibits autophagy in infected cells in contrast to the previously described induction of autophagy by gp120 in uninfected bystander cells. It is likely that HIV-1 has evolved this mechanism as part of an elaborate attempt to evade the immune system while promoting its own replication. We believe that autophagy is an overlooked mechanism in HIV-1 pathogenesis and plays a particularly important role in the early cognitive impairment and dementia often associated with advanced AIDS. A model is presented that describes the potential role of autophagy in NeuroAIDS.

Addendum to: Zhou D, Spector SA. Human immunodeficiency virus type-1 infection inhibits autophagy. Aids 2008;22:695-9.     

检测HIV-1载量的荧光实时定量PCR技术的建立及其应用

准确测定HIV-1的前病毒载量和病毒载量的技术,在感染者预后和艾滋病患者药物治疗效果的评价以及艾滋病的其它研究方面,都具有十分重要的应用价值。以定量的HIV-1DNA和RNA为标准外参照,利用SYBRGreen荧光染料和GeneAmp5700 Sequence Detection System(5700系统),建立了测定HIV-1的前病毒载量和病毒载量的荧光实时定量PCR技术。以病毒感染细胞和培养上清为材料,测定了三种化合物(AZT,GL和WT)对细胞内的前病毒载量和培养上清中的病毒载量的抑制活性,并与合胞体形成抑制方法测定化合物抗病毒活性的结果进行了比较。根据病毒载量、前病毒载量和合胞体形成计算出的三种化合物的治疗指数均依次变小,提出以荧光实时定量PCR技术测定前病毒载量,会在评价药物在体内外根除或减少存在于CD4休止或记忆T淋巴细胞中的HIV-1前病毒方面有特别的价值。     

Cocaine potentiates HIV-1 replication in human peripheral blood mononuclear cell cocultures. Involvement of transforming growth factor-beta

Cocaine use is an important high risk behavior in the AIDS epidemic. In this study, we tested the hypothesis that cocaine potentiates the replication of HIV-1 in human PBMC. A coculture system was used in which PBMC from healthy donors were incubated in the absence (control) or presence of cocaine before activation with PHA. Cocultures were then constituted with PBMC infected with a clinical isolate of HIV-1. HIV-1 replication, which was assessed by the measurement of HIV-1 p24 antigen levels in coculture supernatants, was significantly increased in a dose-dependent manner by cocaine with maximal stimulation at a concentration of 10(-9) M (965 +/- 196 vs 303 +/- 80 pg p24 Ag/ml in control cocultures). Antibodies to transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) blocked cocaine-enhanced HIV-1 replication and purified TGF-beta stimulated viral replication in a manner similar to that observed with cocaine. Augmentation of HIV-1 replication by TGF-beta was maximal at a concentration of 0.01 ng/ml; however, viral proliferation appeared to be inhibited by concentrations of TGF-beta of 1 ng/ml or greater. Taken together, these results indicate that cocaine augments the replication of HIV-1 in PHA-activated PBMC via a mechanism that appears to involve TGF-beta.     

Poliovirus induces autophagic signaling independent of the ULK1 complex

Poliovirus (PV), like many positive-strand RNA viruses, subverts the macroautophagy/autophagy pathway to promote its own replication. Here, we investigate whether the virus uses the canonical autophagic signaling complex, consisting of the ULK1/2 kinases, ATG13, RB1CC1, and ATG101, to activate autophagy. We find that the virus sends autophagic signals independent of the ULK1 complex, and that the members of the autophagic complex are not required for normal levels of viral replication. We also show that the SQSTM1/p62 receptor protein is not degraded in a conventional manner during infection, but is likely cleaved in a manner similar to that shown for coxsackievirus B3. This means that SQSTM1, normally used to monitor autophagic degradation, cannot be used to accurately monitor degradation during poliovirus infection. In fact, autophagic degradation may be affected by the loss of SQSTM1 at the same time as autophagic signals are being sent. Finally, we demonstrate that ULK1 and ULK2 protein levels are greatly reduced during PV infection, and ATG13, RB1CC1, and ATG101 protein levels are reduced as well. Surprisingly, autophagic signaling appears to increase as ULK1 levels decrease. Overexpression of wild-type or dominant-negative ULK1 constructs does not affect virus replication, indicating that ULK1 degradation may be a side effect of the ULK1-independent signaling mechanism used by PV, inducing complex instability. This demonstration of ULK1-independent autophagic signaling is novel and leads to a model by which the virus is signaling to generate autophagosomes downstream of ULK1, while at the same time, cleaving cargo receptors, which may affect cargo loading and autophagic degradative flux. Our data suggest that PV has a finely-tuned relationship with the autophagic machinery, generating autophagosomes without using the primary autophagy signaling pathway.

Abbreviations: ACTB - actin beta; ATG13 - autophagy related 13; ATG14 - autophagy related 14; ATG101 - autophagy related 101; BECN1 - beclin 1; CVB3 - coxsackievirus B3; DMV - double-membraned vesicles; EM - electron microscopy; EMCV - encephalomyocarditis virus; EV-71 - enterovirus 71; FMDV - foot and mouth disease virus; GFP - green fluorescent protein; MAP1LC3B/LC3B - microtubule associated protein 1 light chain 3 beta; MOI - multiplicity of infection; MTOR - mechanistic target of rapamycin kinase; PIK3C3 - phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase catalytic subunit type 3; PRKAA2 - protein kinase AMP-activated catalytic subunit alpha 2; PSMG1 - proteasome assembly chaperone 1; PSMG2 - proteasome assembly chaperone 2PV - poliovirus; RB1CC1 - RB1 inducible coiled-coil 1; SQSTM1 - sequestosome 1; ULK1 - unc-51 like autophagy activating kinase 1; ULK2 - unc-51 like autophagy activating kinase 2; WIPI1 - WD repeat domain, phosphoinositide interacting 1