Evaluation of the use of chromogenic and fluorogenic substrates in solid-phase enzyme linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA)

Fluorogenic and chromogenic substrates were used in direct and trapping enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA) for the detection of mouse IgG and foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV). The detection limits for both antigens were compared using different combinations of enzymes and substrates. Various times and concentrations of chemicals were used to obtain maximum sensitivity for both systems. Similar sensitivities were found using fluorogenic and chromogenic substrates. Tetramethyl benzidine substrate for horse-radish peroxidase enzyme conjugates was found to attain the highest sensitivity levels for chromogenic assays (0.12 ng IgG/ml and 1.0 ng/ml FMDV respectively), after 10 min incubation. Of the two fluorogenic enzyme/substrates studied, B-galactosidase was the most sensitive but required extended incubation times (2-3 h) as compared with chromogenic systems. Special microplates for fluoro-immunoassay (FIA) were compared with conventional microplates and no advantage was found to justify their use. An alkaline phosphatase anti-guinea-pig conjugate was used to confirm the equivalence of fluorogenic and chromogenic substrates in terms of sensitivity. A comparison of the amount of signal generated using various concentrations of enzyme in the absence of antigen was made for two different alkaline phosphatase conjugates to obtain theoretical sensitivity limits. One possible advantage of fluorogenic substrates is that high binding ratio can improve the confidence in discrimination of positive results.     

N-anthraniloylation converts peptide p-nitroanilides into fluorogenic substrates of proteases without loss of their chromogenic properties

By simple substitution of an N-acyl group for the anthraniloyl(o-aminobenzoyl) group, chromogenic p-nitroanilide substrates are converted into highly sensitive fluorogenic substrates of proteases. The fluorescence of the anthraniloyl group is completely quenched by the p-nitroanilide moiety in the intact substrates and is released during their enzymatic hydrolysis. The approach is exemplified by the synthesis of anthraniloyl-Phe p-nitroanilide, anthraniloyl-Lys p-nitroanilide, and anthraniloyl-Gly-Gly-Phe p-nitroanilide as substrates for chymotrypsin, trypsin, and alkaline mesentericopeptidase, respectively. The kinetic parameters of these substrates are slightly better than those of similar derivatives bearing other acyl groups, suggesting that the enhanced sensitivity is completely due to the method of measurement. Since the conversion does not affect the chromogenic properties of the substrates, the same compounds can be used as usual p-nitroanilide substrates as well.     

Chromogenic and fluorogenic peptide substrates of proteolytic enzymes

The review describes approaches to designing chromogenic and fluorogenic substrates for proteolytic enzymes, mainly for assay of serine proteinases. Principles of substrate polypeptide chain construction and some methods for detection of chromogenic and fluorogenic products of their hydrolysis are considered. The use of these substrates for the study of blood clotting enzymes and for clinical diagnostics is briefly treated. Methodology of chemical synthesis of principal chromogenic and fluorogenic substrates is also discussed.     

Alkyne lipids as substrates for click chemistry-based in vitro enzymatic assays

Click chemistry is evolving as a powerful tool in biological applications because it allows the sensitive and specific detection of compounds with alkyne or azido groups. Here we describe the use of alkyne lipids as substrates for in vitro enzymatic assays of lipid modifying enzymes. The small alkyne moiety is introduced synthetically at the terminus of the hydrocarbon chain of various substrate lipids. After the assay, the label is click-reacted with the azide-bearing fluorogenic dye 3-azido-7-hydroxycoumarin, followed by the separation of the lipid mix by thin-layer chromatography and fluorescence detection, resulting in high sensitivity and wide-range linearity. Kinetic analyses using alkyne-labeled substrates for lysophosphatidic acid acyltransferases, lysophosphatidylcholine acyltransferases, and ceramide synthases resulted in Michaelis-Menten constants similar to those for radiolabeled or natural substrates. We tested additional alkyne substrates for several hydrolases and acyltransferases in lipid metabolism. In this pilot study we establish alkyne lipids as a new class of convenient substrates for in vitro enzymatic assays.     

Development of novel assays for proteolytic enzymes using rhodamine-based fluorogenic substrates

Components within synthetic chemical and natural product extract libraries often interfere with fluorescence-based assays. Fluorescence interference can result when the intrinsic spectral properties of colored compounds overlap with the fluorescent probes. Typically, fluorescence-based protease assays use peptide amidomethylcoumarin derivatives as substrates. However, because many organic compounds absorb in the ultraviolet region, they can interfere with coumarin-based fluorescence assays. Red-shifted fluorescent dyes such as peptidyl rhodamine derivatives are useful because there is generally less interference from organic compounds outside the ultraviolet wavelengths. In this report, rhodamine-based fluorogenic substrates, such as bis-(Leu)(2)-Rhod110 and bis-(Ala-Pro)-Rhod110, were developed for leucine aminopeptidase and dipeptidyl aminopeptidase. Novel, tandem rhodamine substrates such as Ala-Pro-Rhod110-Leu were designed with 2 protease cleavage sites and used to assay 2 proteases in a multiplex format. General endpoint high-throughput screening (HTS) assays were also developed for leucine aminopeptidase, dipeptidyl aminopeptidase, and trypsin that incorporated both amidomethylcoumarin and rhodamine-based fluorogenic substrates into a single screening format. These dual-substrate assays allowed for the successful screening of the LOPAC trade mark collection and natural product extracts despite high levels of fluorescence interference.     

Single-enzyme kinetics with fluorogenic substrates: lessons learnt and future directions

Single-molecule fluorescence techniques have developed into powerful tools for studying the kinetics of biological reactions at the single-molecule level. Using fluorogenic substrates, enzymatic reactions can be observed in real-time with single-turnover resolution. The turnover sequence contains all kinetic information, giving access to reaction substeps and dynamic processes such as fluctuations in the reaction rate. Despite their clearly proven potential, the accuracy of current measurements is limited by the availability of substrates with 1:1 stoichiometry and the signal-to-noise ratio of the measurement. In this review we summarize the state-of-the-art and discuss these limitations using experiments performed with α-chymotrypsin as an example. We are further providing an overview of recent efforts aimed at the improvement of fluorogenic substrates and the development of new detection schemes. These detection schemes utilize nanophotonic structures such as zero mode waveguides or nanoantennas. Nanophotonic approaches reduce the size of the effective detection volume and are a powerful strategy to increase the signal-to-noise ratio. We believe that a combination of improved substrates and novel detection schemes will pave the way for performing accurate single-enzyme experiments in biologically relevant conditions.     

Assay of apical membrane enzymes based on fluorogenic substrates.

A series of enzymatic rate assays are described. The assays are based on coumarin derivatives that are fluorogenic substrates for the enzymes dipeptidase IV, aminopeptidase N, alkaline phosphatase, and gamma-glutamyltransferase. These simple assays are rapid and offer improved sensitivity over established colorimetric methods. The substrates have apparent affinities for the enzymes of 5-250 microM. L-Glutamic acid gamma-(7-amido-4-methylcoumarin) is characterized as a substrate of gamma-glutamyltransferase on the basis of inhibition of enzymatic cleavage when the glycylglycine acceptor molecule is omitted and inhibition of the enzymatic reaction by addition of glycine. Assay conditions for the four enzymes are established such that less than 0.6% of the substrate is consumed, fluorescence is proportional to enzymatic product, and results may be directly compared to established colorimetric assays. Intestinal epithelial cells are used both to establish appropriate assay conditions and to demonstrate the utility of the assays.     

Fluorogenic DNA ligase and base excision repair enzyme assays using substrates labeled with single fluorophores

Continuing our work on fluorogenic substrates labeled with single fluorophores for nucleic acid modifying enzymes, here we describe the development of such substrates for DNA ligases and some base excision repair enzymes. These substrates are hairpin-type synthetic DNA molecules with a single fluorophore located on a base close to the 3′ ends, an arrangement that results in strong fluorescence quenching. When such substrates are subjected to an enzymatic reaction, the position of the dyes relative to that end of the molecules is altered, resulting in significant fluorescence intensity changes. The ligase substrates described here were 5′ phosphorylated and either blunt-ended or carrying short, self-complementary single-stranded 5′ extensions. The ligation reactions resulted in the covalent joining of the ends of the molecules, decreasing the quenching effect of the terminal bases on the dyes. To generate fluorogenic substrates for the base excision repair enzymes formamido–pyrimidine–DNA glycosylase (FPG), human 8-oxo-G DNA glycosylase/AP lyase (hOGG1), endonuclease IV (EndoIV), and apurinic/apyrimidinic endonuclease (APE1), we introduced abasic sites or a modified nucleotide, 8-oxo-dG, at such positions that their enzymatic excision would result in the release of a short fluorescent fragment. This was also accompanied by strong fluorescence increases. Overall fluorescence changes ranged from approximately 4-fold (ligase reactions) to more than 20-fold (base excision repair reactions).     

Comparison of fluorogenic and chromogenic assay systems in the detection of Escherichia coli O157 by a novel polymyxin-based ELISA

AIMS: Different indicator enzymes and fluorogenic or chromogenic substrates were compared as detector systems in a novel polymyxin-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for Escherichia coli O157 lipopolysaccharide (LPS) antigens. METHODS AND RESULTS: An ELISA system was developed using polymyxin immobilized in the wells of a microtitre plate as a high-affinity adsorbent for E. coli O157 LPS antigens, which were immunoenzymatically detected using anti-E. coli O157 antibody-enzyme conjugates. With peroxidase as the indicator enzyme the fluorogenic substrates Amplex Red and QuantaBlu produced only slight improvement in the performance characteristics of the polymyxin-ELISA compared with the use of the chromogenic substrate tetramethylbenzidine (TMB). On the other hand, with alkaline phosphatase as the indicator enzyme a pronounced improvement in assay performance was noted using the fluorogenic substrate Attophos compared with the chromogenic substrate p-nitrophenylphosphate. CONCLUSIONS: The detection system exhibiting the best characteristics with respect to cost, ease of use and overall performance in the detection of E. coli O157 in enrichment cultures from a variety of solid foods was based on the use of peroxidase as the indicator enzyme with the chromogenic substrate TMB. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The polymyxin-ELISA provides a rapid, simple and inexpensive assay system for the detection of E. coli O157 in foods.     

High-throughput screening for biocatalysts

Recent progress in high-throughput enzyme assays includes new examples of fluorogenic and chromogenic substrates, fluorescence resonance energy transfer substrates, and applications of the pH and pM indicator methods. Recent developments of Horeau's pseudo-enantiomer derivatisation method to screen enantioselectivities in high-throughput have also been reported.     

Novel methods for biocatalyst screening

There have been a number of recent advances in catalysis assays applicable for screening biocatalyst libraries in high-throughput format. These include instrumental assays such as high-performance liquid chromatography, mass spectrometry, capillary electrophoresis and IR-thermography, reagent-based assays producing spectroscopic signals (UV/VIS or fluorescence) in response to reaction progress, and assays based on fluorogenic or chromogenic substrates. These fluorogenic substrates enable the assaying of a variety of enzymes in enantioselective and stereoselective manner, including alcohol dehydrogenases, aldolases, lipases, amidases, epoxide hydrolases and phosphatases.     

Kinetic assay of fluorescein mono-beta-D-galactoside hydrolysis by beta-galactosidase: a front-face measurement for strongly absorbing fluorogenic substrates

A novel enzymatic assay method was developed for fluorogenic substrates that have significant intrinsic absorbance and fluorescence under the assay conditions. Fluorescein mono-beta-D-galactoside (FMG) was chosen as the substrate for the fluorescence enzymatic assay because of the high fluorescence of its hydrolytic product (fluorescein) and suitability of being hydrolyzed by beta-galactosidase. The fluorescence-concentration relationships for fluorescein and for FMG in both the right-angle detection mode of a fluorometer and the front-face detection mode of a fluorescence plate reader were exactly established and used to determine the kinetics of the enzyme assay. The results show that only front-face detection in the fluorescence plate reader can overcome the fluorescence concentration quenching that inevitably results from high absorbance by the intrinsically absorbing substrate in the conventional fluorometer, which utilizes right-angle detection. Only with front-face detection was the fluorescent assay of FMG hydrolysis under conditions of high optical density possible. The enzymatic measurements on the fluorescence plate reader were particularly efficient for determination of the enzyme kinetics because of the high rate of data collection. In this assay system, Michaelis-Menten constant Km and enzymatic catalysis rate k2 of FMG were determined as 117.6 microM and 22.7 mumol-(min.mg)-1, respectively. The results and methods described in this paper can be generalized for any assay using a fluorogenic substrate whether or not it has a high background absorbance.     

Chromogenic substrates for horseradish peroxidase

Two new detection systems for horseradish peroxidase (HRP) have been developed for the staining of membranes used in immunoassays. These systems use dimethyl or diethyl analogues of p-phenylenediamine with 4-chloro-1-naphthol to generate a blue product or 3-methyl-2-benzothiazolinone hydrazone with 4-chloro-1-naphthol to generate a red product. These reagents offer increased sensitivity and lower background staining than currently available chromogenic detection substrates. In addition, the incorporation of these substrates increases the sensitivity of HRP labels to be comparable to that of alkaline phosphatase with the 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl phosphate + nitro blue tetrazolium substrate.     

New fluorescent substrates for metalloendopeptidases with internal quenching of fluorescence

p-Nitroanilides of antranyloyltripeptides of the general structure Abz-Ala-Ala-P'1-pNA (P'1 = Phe, Leu, Ile, Val) containing intramolecularly quenched fluorescent groups (Abz is a fluorogenic group and pNA is a quencher of fluorescence) were prepared by combination of chemical and enzymatic methods. Thermolysin and metalloproteinases from Legionella pneumophila and Thermoactinomyces species were shown to hydrolyse Ala-P'1 bond of the peptides with simultaneous 4-7 fold increase in fluorescence. Kinetic parameters for enzymatic hydrolysis of the substrates were determined. Metalloendopeptidases can be assayed in the presence of serine proteinases (of the subtilisin type) using Abz-Ala-Ala-Ile-pNA or Abz-Ala-Ala-Val-pNA.     

Fluorogenic ester substrates to assess proteolytic activity

The synthesis of a new type of fluorogenic ester substrates is described. Prepared from fluorescein in three steps with common commercially available precursors, they all generate bright green fluorescence upon proteolysis. Their particular structure allows the same substrate be used to report enzymatic activity of various proteases from serine and cysteine superfamilies. The substrate cleavage is sensitive to specific protease inhibitors providing a tool for inhibitor screening.     

In-gel protein phosphatase assay using fluorogenic substrates

We developed a method for the detection of phosphatase activity using fluorogenic substrates after polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. When phosphatases such as Ca²⁺/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase phosphatase (CaMKP), protein phosphatase 2C (PP2C), protein phosphatase 5 (PP5), and alkaline phosphatase were resolved by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in the absence of SDS and the gel was incubated with a fluorogenic substrate such as 4-methylumbelliferyl phosphate (MUP), all of these phosphatase activities could be detected in situ. Although 6,8-difluoro-4-methylumbelliferyl phosphate (DiFMUP) as well as MUP could be used as a fluorogenic substrate for an in-gel assay, MUP exhibited lower background fluorescence. Using this procedure, several fluorescent bands that correspond to endogenous phosphatases were observed after electrophoresis of various crude samples. The in-gel phosphatase assay could also be used to detect protein phosphatases resolved by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. In this case, however, the denaturation/renaturation process of resolved proteins was necessary for the detection of phosphatase activity. This procedure could be used for detection of renaturable protein phosphatases such as CaMKP and some other phosphatases expressed in cell extracts. The present fluorescent in-gel phosphatase assay is very useful, since no radioactive compounds or no special apparatus are required.     

Fluorogenic substrates for lipases, esterases, and acylases using a TIM-mechanism for signal release

3-Acyloxyl-2-oxopropyl ethers of umbelliferone were investigated as new fluorogenic substrates for lipases and esterases. The aliphatic primary alcohol-leaving group released the fluorescent product umbelliferone by an enolization/beta-elimination reaction similar to the triose phosphate isomerase (TIM) reaction. A similarly designed phenylacetamide provided a fluorescent probe for penicillin G acylase, whereby the enolization/beta-elimination sequence from the intermediate aminoketone was very fast and spontaneous even under acidic conditions. The corresponding epoxyketone was not fluorogenic with epoxide hydrolases (EH). These substrates represent periodate-free Clips-otrade mark substrates.     

Evaluation of novel beta-ribosidase substrates for the differentiation of Gram-negative bacteria

AIMS: To synthesize novel substrates for the detection of beta-ribosidase and assess their potential for the differentiation of Gram-negative bacteria. METHODS AND RESULTS: Two novel chromogenic substrates, 3',4'-dihydroxyflavone-4'-beta-D-ribofuranoside (DHF-riboside) and 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl-beta-D-ribofuranoside (X-riboside) were evaluated along with a known fluorogenic substrate, 4-methylumbelliferyl-beta-D-ribofuranoside (4MU-riboside). A total of 543 Gram-negative bacilli were cultured on media containing either DHF-riboside or X-riboside. Hydrolysis of DHF-riboside or X-riboside resulted in the formation of clearly distinguishable black or blue-green colonies, respectively. Hydrolysis of 4MU-riboside was evaluated in a liquid medium in microtiter trays and yielded blue fluorescence on hydrolysis which was measured using fluorimetry. beta-Ribosidase activity was widespread with 75% of strains, including 85.6% of Enterobacteriaceae, showing activity with at least one substrate. Genera that demonstrated beta-ribosidase activity included Aeromonas, Citrobacter, Enterobacter, Escherichia, Hafnia, Klebsiella, Morganella, Providencia, Pseudomonas, Salmonella and Shigella. In contrast, strains of Proteus spp., Acinetobacter spp., Yersinia enterocolitica, Vibrio cholerae and Vibrio parahaemolyticus generally failed to demonstrate beta-ribosidase activity. CONCLUSIONS: The novel substrates DHF-riboside and X-riboside are effective for the detection of beta-ribosidase in agar-based media and may be useful for the differentiation and identification of Gram-negative bacteria. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This is the first report describing the application and utility of chromogenic substrates for beta-ribosidase. These substrates could be applied in chromogenic media for differentiation of Gram-negative bacteria.     

Enzyme-amplified lanthanide luminescence for enzyme detection in bioanalytical assays

Enzyme-amplified lanthanide luminescence (EALL) is a new method which has been developed for enzymatically amplified signal detection in ultrasensitive bioanalytical assays where an enzyme is used as label or is itself the analyte of interest. Signal generation is performed by enzymatically transforming a substrate into a product which forms a luminescent lanthanide chelate; the product chelate can then be detected using time-resolved or normal fluorescence methods. Alkaline phosphatase substrates have been developed and demonstrated in a model immunoassay in microwell format. The method has also been demonstrated for detection of a variety of other hydrolytic and oxidative enzymes. Thus the EALL method shows promise for use in a wide variety of bioanalytical applications.