Proton flux through the chloroplast ATP synthase is altered by cleavage of its gamma subunit

Electron transport, the proton gradient and ATP synthesis were determined in thylakoids that had been briefly exposed to a low concentration of trypsin during illumination. This treatment cleaves the γ subunit of the ATP synthase into two large fragments that remain associated with the enzyme. Higher rates of electron transport are required to generate a given value of the proton gradient in the trypsin-treated membranes than in control membranes, indicating that the treated membranes are proton leaky. Since venturicidin restores electron transport and the proton gradient to control levels, the proton leak is through the ATP synthase. Remarkably, the synthesis of ATP by the trypsin-treated membranes at saturating light intensities is only slightly inhibited even though the proton gradient is significantly lower in the treated thylakoids. ATP synthesis and the proton gradient were determined as a function of light intensity in control and trypsin-treated thylakoids. The trypsin-treated membranes synthesized ATP at lower values of the proton gradient than the control membranes. Cleavage of the γ subunit abrogates inhibition of the activity of the chloroplast ATP synthase by the ε subunit. Our results suggest that overcoming inhibition by the ε subunit costs energy.     

ATP Synthase of Chloroplast Thylakoid Membranes: A More in Depth Characterization of Its ATPase Activity

In contrast to everted mitochondrial inner membrane vesicles and eubacterial plasma membrane vesicles, the ATPase activity of chloroplast ATP synthase in thylakoid membranes is extremely low. Several treatments of thylakoids that unmask ATPase activity are known. Illumination of thylakoids that contain reduced ATP synthase (reduced thylakoids) promotes the hydrolysis of ATP in the dark. Incubation of thylakoids with trypsin can also elicit higher rates of ATPase activity. In this paper the properties of the ATPase activity of the ATP synthase in thylakoids treated with trypsin are compared with those of the ATPase activity in reduced thylakoids. The trypsin-treated membranes have significant ATPase activity in the presence of Ca²⁺, whereas the Ca²⁺-ATPase activity of reduced thylakoids is very low. The Mg²⁺-ATPase activity of the trypsinized thylakoids was only partially inhibited by the uncouplers, at concentrations that fully inhibit the ATPase activity of reduced membranes. Incubation of reduced thylakoids with ADP in Tris buffer prior to assay abolishes Mg²⁺-ATPase activity. The Mg²⁺-ATPase activity of trypsin-treated thylakoids was unaffected by incubation with ADP. Trypsin-treated membranes can make ATP at rates that are 75–80% of those of untreated thylakoids. The Mg²⁺-ATPase activity of trypsin-treated thylakoids is coupled to inward proton translocation and 10 mM sulfite stimulates both proton uptake and ATP hydrolysis. It is concluded that cleavage of the γ subunit of the ATP synthase by trypsin prevents inhibition of ATPase activity by the ε subunit, but only partially overcomes inhibition by Mg²⁺ and ADP during assay.     

Molecular evolution of the modulator of chloroplast ATP synthase: origin of the conformational change dependent regulation

Chloroplast ATP synthase synthesizes ATP by utilizing a proton gradient as an energy supply, which is generated by photosynthetic electron transport. The activity of the chloroplast ATP synthase is regulated in several specific ways to avoid futile hydrolysis of ATP under various physiological conditions. Several regulatory signals such as Delta mu H(+), tight binding of ADP and its release, thiol modulation, and inhibition by the intrinsic inhibitory subunit epsilon are sensed by this complex. In this review, we describe the function of two regulatory subunits, gamma and epsilon, of ATP synthase based on their possible conformational changes and discuss the evolutionary origin of these regulation systems.     

The carboxyl terminus of the epsilon subunit of the chloroplast ATP synthase is exposed during illumination

The epsilon subunit of the chloroplast ATP synthase is an inhibitor of activity of the enzyme. Recombinant forms of the epsilon subunit from spinach chloroplasts lacking the last 10, 32, or 45 amino acids were immobilized onto activated Sepharose. A polyclonal antiserum raised against the epsilon subunit was passed over these immobilized protein columns, and the purified antibodies which were not bound recognized the portions of the epsilon subunit missing from the recombinant form present on the column. The full polyclonal antiserum can strip the epsilon subunit from the ATP synthase in illuminated thylakoid membranes [Richter, M. L., and McCarty, R. E. (1987) J. Biol. Chem. 262, 15037-15040]. Exposure of illuminated thylakoid membranes to antibodies recognizing the last 32 amino acids of the epsilon subunit collapses the proton gradient and hinders ATP synthesis with similar efficiency as the full polyclonal preparation. These results indicate that antibodies against the last 32 amino acids of the epsilon subunit are capable of stripping the subunit from the ATP synthase in illuminated membranes. Neither of these effects was seen when the membranes were exposed to the antibodies in the dark. This is direct evidence that the chloroplast ATP synthase undergoes a conformational shift during its activation by the electrochemical proton gradient which specifically alters the conformation of the carboxyl-terminal domain of the epsilon subunit from protected to solvent-exposed. The relation between this shift and activation of the enzyme by the electrochemical proton gradient is discussed.     

Modifications of the gamma subunit of chloroplast coupling factor 1 alter interactions with the inhibitory epsilon subunit.

The treatment of chloroplast coupling factor 1 (CF1) with dithiothreitol or with trypsin modifies the gamma subunit. Reduction of the gamma subunit disulfide bond in CF1 in solution with dithiothreitol enhances the dissociation of epsilon (Duhe, R. J., and Selman, B. R. (1990) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1017, 70-78). The Ca(2+)-ATPase activity of either oxidized or reduced CF1 increases as the enzyme is diluted. Added epsilon subunit inhibits the Ca(2+)-ATPase activity of both forms of the diluted CF1, suggesting that epsilon dissociation is the cause of activation by dilution. Half-maximal activation occurred at much higher concentrations of the reduced CF1, indicating that reduction decreases the affinity for epsilon about 20-fold. Immunoblotting techniques show that there is only one epsilon subunit/CF1 in intact chloroplasts, in thylakoid membranes, and in solution. No epsilon is released from CF1 in thylakoids under conditions of ATP synthesis. The gamma subunit of CF1 in illuminated thylakoids is specifically cleaved by trypsin. CF1 purified from thylakoids treated with trypsin in the light is deficient in epsilon subunit, and has a high rate of ATP hydrolysis. Added epsilon neither inhibits the ATPase activity of, nor binds tightly to the cleaved enzyme.     

Substitutions of the Conserved Gly47 Affect the CF1 Inhibitor and Proton Gate Functions of the Chloroplast ATP Synthase ε Subunit

The conserved residue Gly47 of the chloroplast ATP synthase ε subunit was substituted with Leu, Arg, Ala and Glu by site-directed mutagenesis. This process generated the mutants εG47L, εG47R, εG47A and εG47E, respectively. All the ε variants showed lower inhibitory effects on the soluble CF1(-ε) Ca^2 -ATPase compared with wild-type ε. In reduced conditions, εG47E and εG47R had a lower inhibitory effect on the oxidized CF1(-ε) Ca^2 -ATPase compared with wild-type ε. In contrast, εG47L and εG47Aincreased the Ca^2 -ATPase activity of soluble oxidized CF1(-ε). The replacement of Gly47 significantly impaired the interaction between the subunit ε and γ in an in vitro binding assay. Further study showed that all ε variants were more effective in blocking proton leakage from the thylakoid membranes. This enhanced ATP synthesis of the chloroplast and restored ATP synthesis activity of the reconstituted membranes to a level that was more efficient than that achieved by wild-type ε. These results indicate that the conserved Gly47 residue of the ε subunit is very important for maintaining the structure and function of the ε subunitand may affect the interaction between the ε subunit, β subunit of CF1 and subunit Ⅲ of CF0, therebyregulating the ATP hydrolysis and synthesis, as well as the proton translocation role of the subunit Ⅲ of CF0.     

Stimulation of Photophosphorylation by Ascorbate as a Function of Light Intensity

When isolated, stroma-free thylakoids are illuminated in the presence of ADP and orthophosphate in the absence of any electron acceptor except O2, the addition of ascorbate stimulates electron transport through the formation of the radical monodehydroascorbate and the coupled synthesis of ATP (G. Forti and G. Elli [1995] Plant Physiol 109: 1207-1211). The stimulation is shown here to be higher at low light intensity. These observations are explained in terms of the increase of the electron transport rate by ascorbate, which established a higher value of the steady-state pH gradient, causing activation of ATP synthase, which is known to be dependent on the level of the H+-electrochemical potential difference, and a higher rate of proton flux across the membranes available for utilization by ATP synthesis.     

Catalytic control and coupling efficiency of the Escherichia coli FoF1 ATP synthase: influence of the Fo sector and epsilon subunit on the catalytic transition state

The rate-limiting transition state of steady-state ATP hydrolysis and synthesis reactions in the F(o)F(1) ATP synthase involves the rotation of the gamma, epsilon, and c subunits. To probe the role of the transport and coupling mechanisms in controlling catalysis, kinetic and thermodynamic parameters of ATP hydrolysis were determined for enzymes in the presence of the detergent lauryldimethylamine oxide (LDAO), which uncouples active transport and disables the inhibitory effect of the epsilon subunit. At 5 mM LDAO or greater, the inhibitory effects of epsilon subunit are abrogated in both purified F(1) and membranous F(o)F(1). In these conditions, LDAO solubilized F(o)F(1) has a higher k(cat) for ATP hydrolysis than F(1). These results indicate an influence of F(o) on F(1) even though catalysis is uncoupled from transport. The alpha(3)beta(3)gamma complex free of the epsilon subunit is activated at a lower concentration of 0.5 mM LDAO. Significantly, the gammaY205C mutant enzyme is similarly activated at 0.5 mM LDAO, suggesting that the mutant enzyme lacks epsilon inhibition. The gammaY205C F(o)F(1), which has a k(cat) for ATP hydrolysis 2-fold higher than wild type, has an ATP synthesis rate 3-fold lower than wild type, showing that coupling is inefficient. Arrhenius and isokinetic analyses indicate that enzymes that are free of epsilon subunit inhibition have a different transition-state structure from those under the influence of the epsilon subunit. We propose that the epsilon subunit is one of the factors that determines the proper transition-state structure, which is essential for efficient coupling.     

ATP-dependent rotation of mutant ATP synthases defective in proton transport

During ATP hydrolysis, the gammaepsilon c10 complex (gamma and epsilon subunits and a c subunit ring formed from 10 monomers) of F0F1 ATPase (ATP synthase) rotates relative to the alpha3beta3delta ab2 complex, leading to proton transport through the interface between the a subunit and the c subunit ring. In this study, we replaced the two pertinent residues for proton transport, cAsp-61 and aArg-210 of the c and a subunits, respectively. The mutant enzymes exhibited lower ATPase activities than that of the wild type but exhibited ATP-dependent rotation in planar membranes, in which their original assemblies are maintained. The mutant enzymes were defective in proton transport, as shown previously. These results suggest that proton transport can be separated from rotation in ATP hydrolysis, although rotation ensures continuous proton transport by bringing the cAsp-61 and aArg-210 residues into the correct interacting positions.     

Molecular devices of chloroplast F(1)-ATP synthase for the regulation

In chloroplasts, synthesis of ATP is energetically coupled with the utilization of a proton gradient formed by photosynthetic electron transport. The involved enzyme, the chloroplast ATP synthase, can potentially hydrolyze ATP when the magnitude of the transmembrane electrochemical potential difference of protons (Delta(micro)H(+)) is small, e.g. at low light intensity or in the dark. To prevent this wasteful consumption of ATP, the activity of chloroplast ATP synthase is regulated as the occasion may demand. As regulation systems Delta(micro)H(+) activation, thiol modulation, tight binding of ADP and the role of the intrinsic inhibitory subunit epsilon is well documented. In this article, we discuss recent progress in understanding of the regulation system of the chloroplast ATP synthase at the molecular level.     

Regulation of the F0F1-ATP synthase: the conformation of subunit epsilon might be determined by directionality of subunit gamma rotation

F(0)F(1)-ATP synthase couples ATP synthesis/hydrolysis with transmembrane proton transport. The catalytic mechanism involves rotation of the gamma epsilon c(approximately 10)-subunits complex relative to the rest of the enzyme. In the absence of protonmotive force the enzyme is inactivated by the tight binding of MgADP. Subunit epsilon also modulates the activity: its conformation can change from a contracted to extended form with C-terminus stretched towards F(1). The latter form inhibits ATP hydrolysis (but not synthesis). We propose that the directionality of the coiled-coil subunit gamma rotation determines whether subunit epsilon is in contracted or extended form. Block of rotation by MgADP presumably induces the extended conformation of subunit epsilon. This conformation might serve as a safety lock, stabilizing the ADP-inhibited state upon de-energization and preventing spontaneous re-activation and wasteful ATP hydrolysis. The hypothesis merges the known regulatory effects of ADP, protonmotive force and conformational changes of subunit epsilon into a consistent picture.     

Disulfide linkage of the b and delta subunits does not affect the function of the Escherichia coli ATP synthase

The ATP synthase of Escherichia coli is believed to act through a rotational mechanism in which the b(2)delta subcomplex holds the alphabeta hexamer stationary relative to the rotating gamma and epsilon subunits. We have engineered a disulfide bond between cysteines introduced at position 158 of the delta subunit and at a position just beyond the normal C-terminus of the b subunit. The formation of this disulfide bond verifies that the C-terminal region of b is proximal to residue 158 of delta. The disulfide bond does not affect the ability of the F(1)F(0) complex to hydrolyze ATP, couple ATP hydrolysis to the establishment of a proton gradient, or maintain a proton gradient generated by the electron transport chain. These results are consistent with a permanent association of b(2) with delta as suggested by the rotational model of enzyme function.     

The C-terminal domain of the epsilon subunit of the chloroplast ATP synthase is not required for ATP synthesis

The epsilon subunit of the ATP synthases from chloroplasts and Escherichia coli regulates the activity of the enzyme and is required for ATP synthesis. The epsilon subunit is not required for the binding of the catalytic portion of the chloroplast ATP synthase (CF1) to the membrane-embedded part (CFo). Thylakoid membranes reconstituted with CF1 lacking its epsilon subunit (CF1-epsilon) have high ATPase activity and no ATP synthesis activity, at least in part because the membranes are very leaky to protons. Either native or recombinant epsilon subunit inhibits ATPase activity and restores low proton permeability and ATP synthesis. In this paper we show that recombinant epsilon subunit from which 45 amino acids were deleted from the C-terminus is as active as full-length epsilon subunit in restoring ATP synthesis to membranes containing CF1-epsilon. However, the truncated form of the epsilon subunit was significantly less effective as an inhibitor of the ATPase activity of CF1-epsilon, both in solution and bound to thylakoid membranes. Thus, the C-terminus of the epsilon subunit is more involved in regulation of activity, by inhibiting ATP hydrolysis, than in ATP synthesis.     

Met23Lys mutation in subunit gamma of F(O)F(1)-ATP synthase from Rhodobacter capsulatus impairs the activation of ATP hydrolysis by protonmotive force

H(+)-F(O)F(1)-ATP synthase couples proton flow through its membrane portion, F(O), to the synthesis of ATP in its headpiece, F(1). Upon reversal of the reaction the enzyme functions as a proton pumping ATPase. Even in the simplest bacterial enzyme the ATPase activity is regulated by several mechanisms, involving inhibition by MgADP, conformational transitions of the epsilon subunit, and activation by protonmotive force. Here we report that the Met23Lys mutation in the gamma subunit of the Rhodobacter capsulatus ATP synthase significantly impaired the activation of ATP hydrolysis by protonmotive force. The impairment in the mutant was due to faster enzyme deactivation that was particularly evident at low ATP/ADP ratio. We suggest that the electrostatic interaction of the introduced gammaLys23 with the DELSEED region of subunit beta stabilized the ADP-inhibited state of the enzyme by hindering the rotation of subunit gamma rotation which is necessary for the activation.     

Regulatory interplay between proton motive force, ADP, phosphate, and subunit epsilon in bacterial ATP synthase

ATP synthase couples transmembrane proton transport, driven by the proton motive force (pmf), to the synthesis of ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate (P(i)). In certain bacteria, the reaction is reversed and the enzyme generates pmf, working as a proton-pumping ATPase. The ATPase activity of bacterial enzymes is prone to inhibition by both ADP and the C-terminal domain of subunit epsilon. We studied the effects of ADP, P(i), pmf, and the C-terminal domain of subunit epsilon on the ATPase activity of thermophilic Bacillus PS3 and Escherichia coli ATP synthases. We found that pmf relieved ADP inhibition during steady-state ATP hydrolysis, but only in the presence of P(i). The C-terminal domain of subunit epsilon in the Bacillus PS3 enzyme enhanced ADP inhibition by counteracting the effects of pmf. It appears that these features allow the enzyme to promptly respond to changes in the ATP:ADP ratio and in pmf levels in order to avoid potentially wasteful ATP hydrolysis in vivo.     

Regulatory role of the C-terminus of the epsilon subunit from the chloroplast ATP synthase

The ATP synthases from chloroplasts and Escherichia coli are regulated by several factors, one of which is the epsilon subunit. This small subunit is also required for ATP synthesis. Thylakoid membranes reconstituted with CF1 lacking the epsilon subunit (CF1-epsilon) exhibit no ATP synthesis and very high ATP hydrolysis. Either native or recombinant epsilon restores ATP synthesis and inhibits ATP hydrolysis. Previously, we showed that truncated epsilon, lacking the last 45 C-terminal amino acids, restored ATP synthesis to membranes reconstituted with CF1-epsilon but was not an efficient inhibitor of ATP hydrolysis. In this paper, we show that this truncated epsilon is unable to inhibit ATP hydrolysis when Mg(2+) is the divalent cation present, both for the enzyme in solution and on the thylakoid membrane. In addition, the rate of reduction of the disulfide bond of the gamma subunit by dithiothreitol is not decreased by truncated epsilon, although full-length epsilon greatly impedes reduction. Thylakoid membranes can synthesize ATP at the expense of proton gradients generated by pH transitions in the dark. Our reconstituted membranes are able to produce a limited amount of ATP under these "acid-bath" conditions, with approximately equal amounts produced by the membranes containing wild-type epsilon and those containing truncated epsilon. However, the membranes containing truncated epsilon exhibit much higher background ATP hydrolysis under the same acid-bath conditions, leading to the conclusion that, without the C-terminus of epsilon, the CF1CFo is unable to check unwanted ATP hydrolysis.     

Energy-dependent changes in the conformation of the epsilon subunit of the chloroplast ATP synthase

Rabbit antiserum raised against the isolated native epsilon subunit of the chloroplast coupling factor 1 activated the ATPase activity of coupling factor 1 in solution by removing the epsilon subunit. Incubation of thylakoid membranes with the antiserum in the dark had no effect on photophosphorylation or on the dithiothreitol-induced Mg2+-ATPase activity. Incubation with the antiserum during illumination, however, strongly inhibited both activities and caused the membranes to become leaky to protons. The results indicate that the formation of a proton gradient across the thylakoid membrane induces a change in conformation of the epsilon subunit of the ATP synthase such that it becomes susceptible to attack and removal by the antibodies. This change may be a part of the mechanism that results in energy-dependent activation of the ATP synthase.     

Effects of Diffusion and Topological Factors on the Efficiency of Energy Coupling in Chloroplasts with Heterogeneous Partitioning of Protein Complexes in Thylakoids of Grana and Stroma. A Mathematical Model

In this work, we studied theoretically the effects of diffusion restrictions and topological factors that could influence the efficiency of energy coupling in the heterogeneous lamellar system of higher plant chloroplasts. Our computations are based on a mathematical model for electron and proton transport in chloroplasts coupled to ATP synthesis in chloroplasts that takes into account the nonuniform distribution of electron transport and ATP synthase complexes in the thylakoids of grana and stroma. Numerical experiments allowed the lateral profiles of pH in the thylakoid lumen and in the narrow gap between grana thylakoids to be simulated under different metabolic conditions (in the state of photosynthetic control and under conditions of photophosphorylation). This model also provided an opportunity to simulate the effects of steric constraints (the extent of appression of thylakoids in grana) on the rates of non-cyclic electron transport and ATP synthesis. This model demonstrated that there might be two mechanisms of regulation of electron and proton transport in chloroplasts: 1) slowing down of non-cyclic electron transport due to a decrease in the intra-thylakoid pH, and 2) retardation of plastoquinone reduction due to slow diffusion of protons inside the narrow gap between the thylakoids of grana. Numerical experiments for model systems that differ with respect to the arrangement of thylakoids in grana allowed the effects of osmolarity on the photophosphorylation rate in chloroplasts to be explained.     

The Decay of the ATPase Activity of Light Plus Thiol-Activated Thylakoid Membranes in the Dark

Oxidized ATP synthase of spinach thylakoid membranes catalyzes high rates of ATP synthesis in the light, but very low rates of ATP hydrolysis in the dark. Reduction of the disulfide bond in the γ subunit of the ATP synthase in the light enhances the rate of Mg²⁺-ATP hydrolysis in the dark. The light plus thiol-activated state decays in a few minutes in the dark after illumination in Tris buffer, but not when Tricine was used in place of Tris. In this paper, it is shown that Tris in the assay mixture is an inhibitor of the light plus thiol-activated ATPase activity of thylakoids, but only after the activated membranes had incubated in the dark. Aminopropanediols and diethanolamine, also selectively inhibited ATPase activity of activated membranes after storage in the dark, whereas NH₄Cl and imidazole inhibit the ATPase activity of activated thylakoids almost equally whether they are added directly after the illumination or several minutes later. The fluorescence of 9-amino-6-chloro-2-methoxyacridine (ACMA) is quenched by the establishment of proton gradients by ATP-dependent proton uptake. Addition of ATP to activated membranes results in rapid quenching of ACMA fluorescence. If the activated membranes were incubated in the dark prior to ATP addition, a lag in the ATP-dependent ACMA fluorescence quenching as well as a similar lag in the rate ATP hydrolysis were seen. It is concluded that ADP rebinds to CF1 in the dark following illumination and inhibits the activity of the ATP synthase. Reactivation of the ATP synthase in the dark can occur by the slow generation of proton gradients by ATP hydrolysis in the dark. This reactivation takes place in Tricine buffer, but not in Tris because of its uncoupling action. Whether ADP binding plays a role in the regulation of the activity of the ATP synthase in situ remains to be established.     

The regulator of the F1 motor: inhibition of rotation of cyanobacterial F1-ATPase by the epsilon subunit

The chloroplast-type F(1) ATPase is the key enzyme of energy conversion in chloroplasts, and is regulated by the endogenous inhibitor epsilon, tightly bound ADP, the membrane potential and the redox state of the gamma subunit. In order to understand the molecular mechanism of epsilon inhibition, we constructed an expression system for the alpha(3)beta(3)gamma subcomplex in thermophilic cyanobacteria allowing thorough investigation of epsilon inhibition. epsilon Inhibition was found to be ATP-independent, and different to that observed for bacterial F(1)-ATPase. The role of the additional region on the gamma subunit of chloroplast-type F(1)-ATPase in epsilon inhibition was also determined. By single molecule rotation analysis, we succeeded in assigning the pausing angular position of gamma in epsilon inhibition, which was found to be identical to that observed for ATP hydrolysis, product release and ADP inhibition, but distinctly different from the waiting position for ATP binding. These results suggest that the epsilon subunit of chloroplast-type ATP synthase plays an important regulator for the rotary motor enzyme, thus preventing wasteful ATP hydrolysis.