Immunogold signal amplification: Application of the CARD approach to electron microscopy.

Catalyzed reporter deposition (CARD) is a technique that allows amplification of routine immunolabeling in light microscopy. This procedure takes advantage of the horseradish peroxidase (HRP) from an HRP-avidin complex to catalyze the accumulation of reporter-conjugated tyramine (a phenolic compound) onto a surface displaying biotinylated antigen-antibody complexes. The large amount of labeled tyramine deposited allows the detection of an antigenic site with multiple reporter molecules. In this study we modified this amplification protocol to combine it with the immunogold technique for the ultrastructural localization of antigens in electron microscopy. We constructed various tyramide conjugates that permit the combination of this amplification method with a particulate colloidal gold marker. The new probes yield results of high specificity and enhanced intensity. Assessment of the level of resolution of the labeling has demonstrated that, in spite of the amplification, the resolution remains very good. Therefore, once associated, the immunogold and the CARD techniques lead to specific, high-resolution, sensitive and amplified signals that exhibit the advantages of both approaches.(J Histochem Cytochem 47:421-429, 1999)     

Amplification methods for the immunolocalization of rare molecules in cells and tissues

The needs to precisely assign macromolecules to specific locations and domains within tissues and cells and to reveal antigens which are present in low or even in trace amounts, led to the elaboration of a wide spectrum of immunocytochemical amplification procedures. These arise from the successive improvements of tissue preparation techniques, of antigen retrieval procedures and of immunological or non-immunological detection systems. Improvement of detection systems may be the most active in the development of amplification techniques. Since the early work of Coons, in which by the introduction of the indirect technique has started amplifying the signal, different systems have succeeded in increasing the sensitivity of antigens detection. Indeed, amplification techniques such as the multiple antibody layers, the multiple bridges, the enzyme complexes, the avidin-biotin, the silver intensification, and the numerous variations and combinations among these have increased the sensitivity for the detection of scarce tissue antigens. However, as shown by the recent progress carried out with new approaches such as the catalyzed reporter deposition (CARD) and the enhanced polymer one-step staining (EPOS), more efficient methods are still needed. In electron microscopy, few techniques have reached the resolution afforded by the post-embedding immunogold approach. In spite of this and in order to further increase its sensitivity, new probes and novel approaches are allowing combination of the gold marker with the amplification capacity of enzymes afforded by the CARD technique. Immunogold amplification strategies, such as the multiple incubations with the primary antibody and the use of an anti-protein A antibody have also led to enhanced signals displaying the advantages in terms of resolution and possibilities of quantification inherent to the colloidal gold marker.     

Signal amplification in flow cytometry using biotin tyramine.

BACKGROUND: Catalysed reporter deposition (CARD) has been successfully used as a means of signal amplification in solid-phase immunoassays. The procedure relies on the use of horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-conjugated reagents--normally antibodies-in conjunction with substituted phenolic compounds such as biotin tyramine. The HRP catalyses deposition of biotin tyramine around the site of enzyme activity, and streptavidin-HRP can then be added to generate an amplified HRP signal. The possibility of using this technique for solution-phase amplifications has been suggested but not yet demonstrated. METHODS: This paper describes the application of CARD to signal enhancement in flow cytometry. The specific examples described here are those of anti-human CD4 and anti-human CD36 antibodies binding to either human lymphocytes or mixed mononuclear cells. RESULTS: Optimum biotin tyramine concentrations were evaluated, and a fivefold increase in signal was observed over standard detection of the anti-human CD4 antibody with anti-mouse-fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC). In the example using the anti-CD36 antibody, the biotin tyramine treatment was repeated, resulting in an additional 2.5-fold signal amplification. CONCLUSIONS: The technique described in this report provides a method of amplifying the signals achieved by standard flow cytometry detection reagents.     

Use of anti-horseradish peroxidase antibody-gold complex in the ABC technique.

We report a modification of the avidin-biotin-peroxidase complex (ABC) technique for the light and electron microscopic detection of antigens in tissue sections. An immunological approach was used instead of the DAB reaction to reveal ABC bound to antigen-antibody complexes. Affinity-purified polyclonal antibodies against horseradish peroxidase were complexed to particles of colloidal gold and applied for reaction with the horseradish peroxidase molecules of the ABC. For light microscopic immunolabeling, the signal produced by the anti-horseradish peroxidase antibody-gold complex required silver intensification. The ABC immunogold reaction as compared with the standard ABC technique, in particular with silver intensification of the DAB reaction product, provided superior resolution in paraffin sections. Furthermore, section pre-treatment to block endogenous peroxidase activity could be omitted and no potentially hazardous substrate was used. The ABC immunogold reaction was successfully applied for electron microscopic immunolabeling on Lowicryl K4M thin sections. We propose that the ABC immunogold reaction is a useful alternative to the standard ABC technique and can be equally well applied to light and electron microscopy.     

A practical technique to postfix nanogold-immunolabeled specimens with osmium and to embed them in Epon for electron microscopy.

Nanogold is a tiny gold probe, freely diffusible in cells and tissues, and is suitable for pre-embedding immunohistochemistry. However, it is necessary to develop Nanogold to a larger size so that it can be observed by conventional transmission electron microscopy. Silver enhancement is usually used for visualizing Nanogold, but the silver shell produced is unstable in OsO(4) and often becomes invisible after OsO(4) postfixation, which is necessary for good visualization of ultrastructure. We used silver enhancement with silver acetate, followed by gold toning with chloroauric acid, to replace the silver shell with a more stable gold in order to observe Nanogold after osmium fixation and Epon embedding. This technique is applicable to various intra- and extracellular antigens. For correlative observation of immunolabled specimens by light and electron microscopy, specimens adhered to slideglasses were embedded in Epon under non-adhesive plastic film. By heating the Epon sheets after polymerization, these supports were removed without difficulty and provided easy correlative observation.     

Dual enhancement of double immunofluorescent signals by CARD: participation of ubiquitin during formation of neurofibrillary tangles

Amplification with catalyzed reporter deposition (CARD) greatly enhances peroxidase signals, which has been utilized to amplify immunohistochemical labelings including fluorochromes. Here we describe a strategy to amplify each of two immunofluorescent signals without crosstalk on double-stained histological sections from human autopsied brains with Alzheimer's disease (AD). One of the two primary antibodies (anti-Abeta or anti-PHF-tau) was probed by a species-specific secondary antibody conjugated with horseradish peroxidase (HRP), which was visualized by FITC-labeled tyramide. After inactivation of HRP, the other primary antibody was probed by another species-specific secondary antibody conjugated with HRP. Amplification with biotinylated tyramide was followed by streptavidin-conjugated Cy-5, which specifically labeled the latter epitope. It was found that Abeta and PHF-tau were localized to senile plaques and neurofibrillary tangles (NFTs), respectively, which verified lack of crosstalk on the double-stained section. Localization of ubiquitin and PHF-tau was looked for at higher magnification in NFT-bearing neurons. Although these two epitopes were colocalized in some neurons, ubiquitin was not always present in PHF-tau positive NFTs. Discrepancy between PFH-tau and ubiquitin, verified inter- and intracellularly, may represent different stages of NFT formation. This is the first report of successful CARD amplification of two different fluorescent signals on double-labeling immunohistochemistry, which is now proved to be powerful in detecting epitopes in relation to AD-related lesions. Improved intensity over tenfold of the two fluorescent signals without crosstalk will expand the application of the multilabeling method with fluorochromes.     

Reprint of "On the feasibility of visualizing ultrasmall gold labels in biological specimens by STEM tomography" [J. Struct. Biol. 159 (2007) 507-522

Labeling with heavy atom clusters attached to antibody fragments is an attractive technique for determining the 3D distribution of specific proteins in cells using electron tomography. However, the small size of the labels makes them very difficult to detect by conventional bright-field electron tomography. Here, we evaluate quantitative scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) at a beam voltage of 300 kV for detecting 11-gold atom clusters (Undecagold) and 1.4 nm-diameter nanoparticles (Nanogold) for a variety of specimens and imaging conditions. STEM images as well as tomographic tilt series are simulated by means of the NIST Elastic-Scattering Cross-Section Database for gold clusters embedded in carbon. The simulations indicate that the visibility in 2D of Undecagold clusters in a homogeneous matrix is maximized for low inner collection semi-angles of the STEM annular dark-field detector (15–20 mrad). Furthermore, our calculations show that the visibility of Undecagold in 3D reconstructions is significantly higher than in 2D images for an inhomogeneous matrix corresponding to fluctuations in local density. The measurements demonstrate that it is possible to detect Nanogold particles in plastic sections of tissue freeze-substituted in the presence of osmium. STEM tomography has the potential to localize specific proteins in permeabilized cells using antibody fragments tagged with small heavy atom clusters. Our quantitative analysis provides a framework for determining the detection limits and optimal experimental conditions for localizing these small clusters.     

On the feasibility of visualizing ultrasmall gold labels in biological specimens by STEM tomography

Labeling with heavy atom clusters attached to antibody fragments is an attractive technique for determining the 3D distribution of specific proteins in cells using electron tomography. However, the small size of the labels makes them very difficult to detect by conventional bright-field electron tomography. Here, we evaluate quantitative scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) at a beam voltage of 300 kV for detecting 11-gold atom clusters (Undecagold) and 1.4 nm-diameter nanoparticles (Nanogold) for a variety of specimens and imaging conditions. STEM images as well as tomographic tilt series are simulated by means of the NIST Elastic-Scattering Cross-Section Database for gold clusters embedded in carbon. The simulations indicate that the visibility in 2D of Undecagold clusters in a homogeneous matrix is maximized for low inner collection semi-angles of the STEM annular dark-field detector (15–20 mrad). Furthermore, our calculations show that the visibility of Undecagold in 3D reconstructions is significantly higher than in 2D images for an inhomogeneous matrix corresponding to fluctuations in local density. The measurements demonstrate that it is possible to detect Nanogold particles in plastic sections of tissue freeze-substituted in the presence of osmium. STEM tomography has the potential to localize specific proteins in permeabilized cells using antibody fragments tagged with small heavy atom clusters. Our quantitative analysis provides a framework for determining the detection limits and optimal experimental conditions for localizing these small clusters.     

Gold-FISH: A new approach for the in situ detection of single microbial cells combining fluorescence and scanning electron microscopy

A novel fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) method is presented that allows the combination of epifluorescence and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to identify single microbial cells. First, the rRNA of whole cells is hybridised with horseradish peroxidase-labelled oligonucleotide probes and this is followed by catalysed reporter deposition (CARD) of biotinylated tyramides. This facilitates an amplification of binding sites for streptavidin conjugates covalently labelled with both fluorophores and nanogold particles. The deposition of Alexa Fluor 488 fluoro-nanogold–streptavidin conjugates was confirmed via epifluorescence microscopy and cells could be quantified in a similar way to standard CARD–FISH approaches. To detect cells by SEM, an autometallographic enhancement of the nanogold particles was essential, and allowed the in situ localisation of the target organisms at resolutions beyond light microscopy. Energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) was used to verify the effects of CARD and autometallography on gold deposition in target cells.     

Retrograde tracing of neural pathways with a protein-gold complex

Summary In this study I have used a tracer complex made of wheat germ agglutinin horseradish peroxidase conjugate (WGA*HRP) coupled to colloidal gold for retrograde tracing of neuronal pathways at the light microscopic level. Visualization of the gold was achieved by silver precipitation (the gold silver intensification method) with gold particles acting as specific cores of nucleation. The presence of horseradish peroxidase in the protein conjugate allowed this method to be compared with classical histochemistry using tetramethylbenzidine as a chromogen. The gold silver intensification method proved to be reliable, specific and sensitive. It has been demonstrated to be useful with fixatives containing a high percentage of paraformaldehyde and compatible with histochemical procedures to show projections of transmitter specific pathways.     

Retrograde tracing of neural pathways with a protein-gold complex. I. Light microscopic detection after silver intensification

In this study I have used a tracer complex made of wheat germ agglutinin horseradish peroxidase conjugate (WGA*HRP) coupled to colloidal gold for retrograde tracing of neuronal pathways at the light microscopic level. Visualization of the gold was achieved by silver precipitation (the gold silver intensification method) with gold particles acting as specific cores of nucleation. The presence of horseradish peroxidase in the protein conjugate allowed this method to be compared with classical histochemistry using tetramethylbenzidine as a chromogen. The gold silver intensification method proved to be reliable, specific and sensitive. It has been demonstrated to be useful with fixatives containing a high percentage of paraformaldehyde and compatible with histochemical procedures to show projections of transmitter specific pathways.     

Localization of immunoreactive tyrosine hydroxylase in the goldfish retina with pre-embedding immunolabeling with one-nanometer colloidal gold particles and gold toning.

The goal of this study was to develop an alternative to silver intensification for visualizing small colloidal gold particles by light and electron microscopy. The isolated goldfish retina was labeled with rabbit antiserum to tyrosine hydroxylase and 1-nm colloidal gold-conjugated goat anti-rabbit IgG. The gold particles were enlarged by toning with gold chloride, followed by reduction in oxalic acid. Dopaminergic interplexiform cells were clearly visible by light microscopy and, in lightly-fixed material treated with detergent, they were labeled in their entirety. Labeling was qualitatively similar, although less extensive, in material fixed and processed for electron microscopy. The labeled processes were apparent in ultra-thin sections viewed at low magnification, but the gold-toned particles were not so large that they obscured subcellular structures. The procedure apparently had no deleterious effects on the tissue, since the ultrastructural preservation was comparable to that seen with other pre-embedding immunolabeling methods. The technique was simple, reliable and, since the gold solutions were so dilute, relatively inexpensive.     

Amplification methods to increase the sensitivity of in situ hybridization: play card(s).

In situ hybridization (ISH) has proved to be an invaluable molecular tool in research and diagnosis to visualize nucleic acids in their cellular environment. However, its applicability can be limited by its restricted detection sensitivity. During the past 10 years, several strategies have been developed to improve the threshold levels of nucleic acid detection in situ by amplification of either target nucleic acid sequences before ISH (e.g., in situ PCR) or the detection signals after the hybridization procedures. Here we outline the principles of tyramide signal amplification using the catalyzed reporter deposition (CARD) technique, present practical suggestions to efficiently enhance the sensitivity of ISH with CARD, and discuss some applications and possible future directions of in situ nucleic acid detection using such an amplification strategy.     

Ferrocenemonocarboxylic-HRP@Pt nanoparticles labeled RCA for multiple amplification of electro-immunosensing

A multiple amplification immunoassay was proposed to detect alpha-fetoprotein (AFP), which was based on ferrocenemonocarboxylic-HRP conjugated on Pt nanoparticles as labels for rolling circle amplification (RCA). Firstly, the capture antibody (anti-AFP) was immobilized on glass carbon electrode (GCE) deposited nano-sized gold particles. After a typical immuno-sandwich protocol, primary DNA was immobilized by labeling secondary antibody, which acted as a precursor to initiate RCA. The products of RCA provide large amount of sites to link detection DNAs, which were labeled by signal probes (ferrocenemonocarboxylic) and horseradish peroxidase (HRP). Moreover, the enzymatic amplification signals could be produced by the catalysis of HRP and Pt nanoparticles with the addition of H?O?. These lead to multiple amplification signals monitoring by electrochemical instrument and further resulted in high sensitivity of the immunoassay with the detection limit of 1.7 pg/mL.     

Immunogold–silver staining-on-a-chip biosensor based on cross-flow chromatography

Immunogold–silver staining (IGSS) was adopted in cross-flow chromatographic analysis in which immunological reactions and silver intensification were sequentially conducted in the vertical and horizontal directions, respectively. Factors controlling the performance, except the silver substrate solution, were optimized to increase the signal-to-background ratio in measurements of cardiac troponin I as a model analyte. In generating the signal, the size of colloidal gold catalyst was critical; the smallest size (5-nm diameter) in the selected range yielded the highest colorimetric signal. To maintain the low background, two processes, blocking the remaining surfaces of membrane after antibody immobilization and washing the residual tracer after immunological reaction, were necessary. Self-nucleation of silver ions also caused a background signal and was controlled to some degree by decreasing the hydrodynamic force that arose when the substrate solution was supplied in the horizontal direction. Finally, a new chip (IGSS-on-a-chip; IOC) that allowed for convenient, efficient IGSS was produced by injection molding of plastic. This method enhanced the detection capability by 51-fold compared to the conventional rapid test kit using 30 nm-sized colloidal gold as the tracer. The IOC biosensor results also showed that silver intensification yield via cross flow after immunological reaction was 19% higher than that by traditional incubation.     

Recent advances in catalytic peroxidase histochemistry.

Immunoassays have developed to become an important analytical tool in life sciences for detection of endogenous and exogenous targets. Among the most important enzyme labels horseradish peroxidase (HRP), alkaline phosphatase (AP), and beta-D-galactosidase (GAL) is HRP the smallest enzyme and plays nowadays an outstanding role. The oldest substrates are chromogens widely applied for localization of sites of peroxidase (PO) activity in histochemistry as well as for colorimetric applications. They are represented by a diversity of aromatic amines and phenols. Encouraged by development of light excitation and measuring techniques and the commercial availability of highly sensitive equipment, luminescent labels represent the most sensitive and worthwhile detection tools to date. In contrast to chromogens fluorescent labels for detection PO activity are confined only to a few substrates developed more recently. These substrates are mostly applied in histochemistry at a short time scale due to their frequently high solubility. At the long time scale sole exception is so far the tyramine based fluorochome deposition technique (more general: catalytic reporter deposition, CARD). Despite quite different staining behavior both fluorometric and product deposition related principles are based on 4-hydroxy phenylalkyl substrates. The following article reviews basic principles of peroxidatic substrate degradation processes including chromogenic and fluorescent approaches with emphasis on recent advances in development of chromogens and fluorogens for application in histology. As a result of systematic efforts towards the design of substrates, the range of classical precipitating chromogens as well as fluorescent techniques could be complimented by novel highly sensitive substrates with superior staining capabilities: a) Metal chelating 2-hydroxy benzylamines are derived from classical aniline substrates (two steps) and utilize metal catalytic effects in an efficient intramolecular way. The enzymatically yielded dark colored polycondensation products are applicable in histochemistry, in colorimetry and especially as precipitating electron opaque labels with enhanced osmiophilic properties for light and electron microscopy. b) Fluorescent 4-hydroxy-styryl derivatives are capable of oxidative selfanchoring reactions at the cellular level close to sites of PO activity. In contrast to deposition of tyramine conjugated fluorochromes an altered fluorochrome with improved fluorescence properties is furnished during oxidative crosslinking of the substrate. This results in a highly specific and photostable fluorescence response and an outstanding low background staining. Histochemical and immunohistochemical applications are presented.     

Silver enhancement of protein A-gold probes on resin-embedded ultrathin sections. An electron microscopic localization of mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) antigens

A simple method is described allowing the enhancement of the visibility of small gold probes for the electron microscopy. This method, which allows the silver intensification of gold directly on epon-embedded ultrathin sections, was used for the electron microscopic localization of Mouse Mammary Tumor Virus (MMTV) antigens in cultured cells derived from GR and BALB/cfRIII mouse mammary tumors. After the immunostaining with the preembedding protein A-gold technique, the ultrathin sections, placed on 200 mesh copper grids, were rehydrated and exposed to a photographic developer containing silver nitrate. During this physical development gold particles are incapsulated in growing shells of metallic silver, which gradually become more and more visible. We were able to obtain a heavy labelling of the viral particles, well visible even at low magnification, with a negligeable background staining. The present technique can be useful whenever it is necessary to use the smallest gold probes today available.     

Colloidal gold probes for the identification of virus particles: An appraisal

Electron microscope examination of negatively stained preparations continues to be the method of choice for the diagnosis of virus particles although in some instances an immunological test is necessary. Colloidal gold immunocytochemical probes are becoming increasingly popular for electron microscopy and their suitability for the identification of virus particles is assessed.Virus particles were immunolabelled in situ on plastic/carbon coated electron microscope grids with specific antibody and colloidal gold probes. The labelling obtained was specific, definite and with very little background. The technique is very sensitive, very quick, and since a minimum of preparation is needed it appears to possess considerable potential for virus diagnosis.     

Demonstration of chromosome replication by BrdU antibody technique and electron microscopy

Summary We describe the use of different reporter groups in visualizing replication patterns on metaphase chromosomes after BrdU incorporation by the BrdU antibody technique for the electron microscope. There is an inverse correlation between the density of the label and the size of the reporter particles. This observation alludes to stereo problems interfering with the access of the labeled antibodies into the chromatin. The use of silver enhancement enables easy detection of 1-nm and 5-nm gold particles, which make replication patterns visible in the electron microscope as does the diaminobenzidine/ H₂O₂ reaction. Possible consequences for the demonstration of replication patterns and for nonradioactive DNA in situ hybridization are discussed.     

Silver enhancement of protein A-gold probes on resin-embedded ultrathin sections

Summary A simple method is described allowing the enhancement of the visibility of small gold probes for the electron microscopy.This method, which allows the silver intensification of gold directly on epon-embedded ultrathin sections, was used for the electron microscopic localization of Mouse Mammary Tumor Virus (MMTV) antigens in cultured cells derived from GR and BALB/cfRIII mouse mammary tumors. After the immunostaining with the preembedding protein A-gold technique, the ultrathin sections, placed on 200 mesh copper grids, were rehydrated and exposed to a photographic developer containing silver nitrate. During this physical development gold particles are incapsulated in growing shells of metallic silver, which gradually become more and more visible. We were able to obtain a heavy labelling of the viral particles, well visible even at low magmfication, with a negligeable background staining.The present technique can be useful whenever it is necessary to use the smallest gold probes today available.Supported by contract No. 85.02038.44 from the National Research Council, Rome, Progetto Finalizzato Oncologia