Oxygen Toxicity and the Superoxide Dismutase

Oxygen caused an increase in the amount of superoxide dismutase in Escherichia coli B but not in Bacillus subtilis. E. coli B cells, induced by growth under 100% O(2), were much more resistant to the lethal effects of 20 atm of O(2) than were cells which contained the low uninduced level of this enzyme. In contrast, B. subtilis, which could not respond to O(2) by increasing its content of superoxide dismutase, remained equally sensitive to hyperbaric O(2) whether grown under 100% O(2) or areobically. The catalase in these organisms exhibited a reciprocal response to oxygen. Thus, the catalase of E. coli B was not induced by O(2), whereas that of B. subtilis was so induced. These results are consistent with the view that superoxide dismutase is an important component of the defenses of these organisms against the toxicity of oxygen, whereas their catalases are of secondary importance in this respect. The ability of streptonigrin to generate O(2) (-), by a cycle of reduction followed by spontaneous reoxidation, has been verified in vitro. It is further observed that E. coli B which contain the high induced level of superoxide dismutase were more resistant to the lethality of this antibiotic, in the presence of oxygen, than were E. coli B which contained the low uninduced level of this enzyme. This difference between induced and uninduced cells was eliminated by the removal of O(2). These results are consistent with the proposal that the enhanced lethality of streptonigrin under aerobic conditions may relate to its in vivo generation of O(2) (-) by a cycle of reduction and spontaneous reoxidation. In toto, these observations lend support to the hypothesis that O(2) (-) is an important agent of oxygen toxicity and that superoxide dismutase functions to blunt the threat posed by this reactive radical.     

Intracellular localization of the superoxide dismutases of Escherichia coli: a reevaluation.

All of the superoxide dismutase isozymes of Escherichia coli have been shown to occur in the cell matrix, and none have been found in the periplasm. This was the case with both E. coli B and E. coli K-12, whether grown on a low phosphate medium or on a Trypticase soy-yeast extract medium. Alkaline phosphatase was used as a marker of the periplasm; adenosine deaminase and glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase were used as matrix markers, and consistent results were obtained by osmotic shock, spheroplast formation, and use of a diazonium salt that penetrates the periplasm but cannot cross the plasma membrane. A previous report that the iron-containing superoxide dismutase of E. coli is a periplasmic enzyme is now seen to have been in error.     

Polarographic assay and intracellular distribution of superoxide dismutase in rat liver.

1. A polarographic assay of superoxide (O2--) dismutase (EC 1.15.1.1) activity is described, in which the ability of the enzyme to inhibit O2---dependent sulphite oxidation, initiated by xanthine oxidase activity, is measured. The assay was used in a study of the intracellular distribution of superoxide dismutase in rat liver. Both cyanide-sensitive cupro-zinc dismutase (92% of the total activity) and cyanide-insensitive mangano-dismutase (8%) were measured. 2. Rat liver homogenates contained both particulate (16%y and soluble (84%) dismutase activity. The particulate activity contained both types of dismutase, whereas nearly all the soluble dismutase was a cupro-zinc enzymes. The distribution pattern of mangano-dismutase was similar to that of cytochrome oxidase and glutamate dehydrogenase, indicating that the enzyme was probably present exclusively in the mitochondria. 3. Superoxide dismutase activity in the heavy-mitochondrial (M) fraction was latent and was activated severalfold and largely solubilized by sonication. Treatment of the M fraction with digitonin or a hypo-osmotic suspending medium indicated that most of the cupro-zinc dismutase was located in the mitochondrial intermembrane space, whereas the mangano-enzyme was located in the inner-membrane and matrix space. 4. A small amount of dismutase activity appeared to be present in the nuclei and microsomal fraction, but little or no activity in the lysosomes or peroxisomes. 5. The results are discussed in relation to the intracellular location of known O2---generating enzymes, the possible role of superoxide dismutase activity in intracellular H2O2 formation, and to current views on the physiological function of the enzyme.     

Induction of Superoxide Dismutase by Molecular Oxygen

Oxygen induces superoxide dismutase in Streptococcus faecalis and in Escherichia coli B. S. faecalis grown under 20 atm of O(2) had 16 times more of this enzyme than did anaerobically grown cells. In the case of E. coli, changing the conditions of growth from anaerobic to 5 atm of O(2) caused a 25-fold increase in the level of superoxide dismutase. Induction of this enzyme was a response to O(2) rather than to pressure, since 20 atm of N(2) was without effect. Induction of superoxide dismutase was a rapid process, and half of the maximal level was reached within 90 min after N(2)-grown cells of S. faecalis were exposed to 20 atm of O(2) at 37 C. S. faecalis did not contain perceptible levels of catalase under any of the growth conditions investigated by Stanier, Doudoroff, and Adelberg (23), and the concentration of catalase in E. coli was not affected by the presence of O(2) during growth. S. faecalis, which had been grown under 100% O(2) and which therefore contained an elevated level of superoxide dismutase, was more resistant of 46 atm of O(2) than were cells which had been grown under N(2). E. coli grown under N(2) contained as much superoxide dismutase as did S. faecalis grown under 1 atm of O(2). The E. coli which had been grown under N(2) was as resistant to the deleterious effects of 50 atm of O(2) as was S. faecalis which had been grown under 1 atm of O(2). These results are consistent with the proposal that the peroxide radical is an important agent of the toxicity of oxygen and that superoxide dismutase may be a component of the systems which have been evolved to deal with this potential toxicity.     

Mechanism of the antibiotic action pyocyanine.

Exposure of Escherichia coli growing in a rich medium to pyocyanine resulted in increased intracellular levels of superoxide dismutase and of catalase. When these adaptive enzyme syntheses were prevented by nutritional paucity, the toxic action of pyocyanine was augmented. The antibiotic action of pyocyanine was dependent upon oxygen and was diminished by superoxide dismutase and by catalase, added to the suspending medium. Pyocyanine slightly augmented the respiration of E. coli suspended in a rich medium, but greatly increased the cyanide-resistant respiration. Pyocyanine was able to cause the oxidation of reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide, with O2- production, in the absence of enzymatic catalysis. It is concluded that pyocyanine diverts electron flow and thus increases the production of O2- and H2O2 and that the antibiotic action of this pigment is largely a reflection of the toxicity of these products of oxygen reduction.     

Detection and quantification of superoxide formed within the periplasm of Escherichia coli

Many gram-negative bacteria harbor a copper/zinc-containing superoxide dismutase (CuZnSOD) in their periplasms. In pathogenic bacteria, one role of this enzyme may be to protect periplasmic biomolecules from superoxide that is released by host phagocytic cells. However, the enzyme is also present in many nonpathogens and/or free-living bacteria, including Escherichia coli. In this study we were able to detect superoxide being released into the medium from growing cultures of E. coli. Exponential-phase cells do not normally synthesize CuZnSOD, which is specifically induced in stationary phase. However, the engineered expression of CuZnSOD in growing cells eliminated superoxide release, confirming that this superoxide was formed within the periplasm. The rate of periplasmic superoxide production was surprisingly high and approximated the estimated rate of cytoplasmic superoxide formation when both were normalized to the volume of the compartment. The rate increased in proportion to oxygen concentration, suggesting that the superoxide is generated by the adventitious oxidation of an electron carrier. Mutations that eliminated menaquinone synthesis eradicated the superoxide formation, while mutations in genes encoding respiratory complexes affected it only insofar as they are likely to affect the redox state of menaquinone. We infer that the adventitious autoxidation of dihydromenaquinone in the cytoplasmic membrane releases a steady flux of superoxide into the periplasm of E. coli. This endogenous superoxide may create oxidative stress in that compartment and be a primary substrate of CuZnSOD.     

Enzymatic defenses against the toxicity of oxygen and of streptonigrin in Escherichia coli.

Anaerobically grown Escherichia coli K-12 contain only one superoxide dismutase and that is the iron-containing isozyme found in the periplasmic space. Exposure to oxygen caused the induction of a manganese-containing superoxide dismutase and of another, previously undescribed, superoxide dismutase, as well as of catalase and peroxidase. These inductions differed in their responsiveness towards oxygen. Thus the very low levels of oxygen present in deep, static, aerobic cultures were enough for nearly maximal induction of the manganese-superoxide dismutase. In contrast, induction of the new superoxide dismutase, catalase, and peroxidase required the much higher levels of oxygen achieved in vigorously agitated aerobic cultures. Anaerobically grown cells showed a much greater oxygen enhancement of the lethality of streptonigrin than did aerobically grown cells, in accord with the proposal that streptonigrin can serve as an intracellular source of superoxide. Anaerobically grown cells in which enzyme inductions were prevented by puromycin were damaged by exposure to air. This damage was evidenced both as a decline in viable cell count and as structural abnormalities evident under an electron microscope.     

Superoxide dismutase-rich bacteria. Paradoxical increase in oxidant toxicity

Superoxide dismutase is considered important in protection of aerobes against oxidant damage, and increased tolerance to oxidant stress is associated with induction of this enzyme. However, the importance of superoxide dismutase in this tolerance is not clear because conditions which promote the synthesis of superoxide dismutase likewise affect other antioxidant enzymes and substances. To clarify the role of superoxide dismutase per se in organismal defense against oxidant-generating drugs, we employed Escherichia coli transformed with multiple copies of the gene for bacterial iron superoxide dismutase. These bacteria have greater than ten times the superoxide dismutase activity of wild-type E. coli but, importantly, are normal in other oxidant defense parameters including catalase, peroxidases, glutathione, and glutathione reductase. High superoxide dismutase and control bacteria were exposed to the O2- -generating drug paraquat and to elevated pO2. We find; high superoxide dismutase E. coli are more readily killed by paraquat under aerobic, but not anaerobic, conditions. During exposure to paraquat, high superoxide dismutase E. coli accumulate more H2O2. Coincidentally, the reduced glutathione content of high superoxide dismutase E. coli declines more than in control E. coli. E. coli with high superoxide dismutase activity are also more readily killed by hyperoxia. Interestingly, the susceptibility of the parental and high superoxide dismutase E. coli to killing by exogenous H2O2 is not significantly different. Thus, under these experimental conditions, greatly enhanced superoxide dismutase activity accelerates H2O2 formation. The increased H2O2 probably accounts for the exaggerated sensitivity of high superoxide dismutase bacteria to oxidant-generating drugs. These results support the concept that the product of superoxide dismutase, H2O2, is at least as hazardous as the substrate, O2-. We conclude that effective organismal defense against reactive oxygen species may require balanced increments in antioxidant enzymes and cannot necessarily be improved by increases in the activity of single enzymes.     

Superoxide sensitivity of the Escherichia coli 6-phosphogluconate dehydratase.

The activity of 6-phosphogluconate dehydratase was significantly lower in extracts of aerobically grown Escherichia coli deficient in superoxide dismutase (sodAsodB) and in mutants lacking the inducible manganese-containing superoxide dismutase (sodA), exposed to the redox-cycling agent paraquat, than in the parental strain. Growth of these strains on a gluconate minimal medium was also impaired under these conditions. The enzyme was most susceptible to dioxygen in superoxide dismutase (SOD)-free extracts, and exogenous SOD afforded a concentration-dependent protection against inactivation. The amount of SOD necessary for full protection was comparable to the amount normally present in extracts of aerobic E. coli (7-36 units/mg protein), and the rate of reaction of O2- with the dehydratase was estimated to be approximately 2.0 x 10(8) M-1 s-1. The dehydratase was much less sensitive to O2 or H2O2 than to O2-. The virtual substrate, alpha-glycerophosphate, provided partial protection. Iron chelators, thiol-reactive reagents, and oxidants, including nitrite and diamide, inactivated the enzyme. Fluoride ions stabilized the dehydratase and blocked the effect of oxidants. The O2(-)-sensitive target site is proposed to be an iron-sulfur cluster which is readily destroyed by oxidation.     

Superoxide Dismutase and Oxygen Toxicity in a Eukaryote

Saccharomyces cerevisiae var. ellipsoideus contained 6.5 times more superoxide dismutase and 2.3 times more catalase when grown under 100% O(2) than when grown anaerobically. Growth under oxygen caused equal increases in both the cyanide-sensitive and the cyanide-insensitive superoxide dismutases of this organism. Experience with other eukaryotes has shown that cyanide sensitivity is a property of the cupro-zinc superoxide dismutase of the cytosol, whereas cyanide insensitivity is a property of the corresponding mangani-enzyme found in mitochondria. Cu(2+), which has been shown to increase the radioresistance of yeast, also caused an increase of both of the superoxide dismutases of S. cerevisiae. Yeast which had been grown under 1 atm of O(2) were more resistant toward the lethal effects of 20 atm of O(2) than were yeast which had been grown in the absence of O(2). Escherichia coli K-12 his(-) responded to growth under 1 atm of O(2) by increasing its content of catalase and of peroxidase, but not of superoxide dismutase. This contrasts with E. coli B, which was previously shown to respond to O(2) by a striking increase in superoxide dismutase. E. coli K-12 his(-) did not gain resistance toward 20 atm of O(2) because of having been grown under 1 atm of O(2). Once again, this contrasts with the behavior of E. coli B. These data indicate that, in both prokaryotes and in eukaryotes, superoxide dismutase is an important component of the defenses against oxygen toxicity.     

Periplasmic superoxide dismutase from Desulfovibrio desulfuricans 1388 is an iron protein

It is shown that the genome of the sulfate-reducing bacterium Desulfovibrio desulfuricans 1388 contains a superoxide dismutase (SOD) gene (sod). The gene encodes an export signal peptide characteristic for periplasmic redox proteins. The amino acid sequence showed high homology with iron-containing SODs from other bacteria. Electrophoretically pure SOD was isolated from the periplasmic fraction of bacterial cells by FPLC chromatography. Like other Fe-SODs, D. desulfuricans 1388 superoxide dismutase is inhibited by H2O2 and azide, but not by cyanide.     

A potential role for periplasmic superoxide dismutase in blocking the penetration of external superoxide into the cytosol of Gram-negative bacteria

Superoxide is a key component of the antibacterial weaponry of phagocytes. Presumably, for this reason, strains of Salmonella typhimurium express a periplasmic superoxide dismutase (SOD) that is essential for full virulence. Because most anions cannot easily penetrate lipid membranes, it is thought that the phagosomal superoxide either damages an unknown target on the bacterial surface or reacts with nitric oxide to form peroxynitrite (HOONO), a toxic oxidant that can freely enter bacteria. However, in this study, we tested whether superoxide itself could penetrate membranes. Superoxide that was generated at high pH (>7.5) very slowly reduced cytochrome c that was encapsulated inside lipid vesicles. It did so much more quickly at lower pH (<7). Under the latter conditions, more superoxide was protonated and uncharged (HO2*), and the penetrance of superoxide was proportional to the concentration of this species. The permeability coefficient of HO2* was determined to be 9 x 10(-4) cm sec(-1), just slightly lower than that of water and far higher than the value of the anionic form (O2-, <10(-7) cm sec(-1). When Escherichia coli mutants that lack periplasmic SOD were exposed to super-oxide at pH 6.5, cytosolic fumarase B was damaged. Damage was minimal at higher pH or in strains that contained periplasmic SOD. Thus, in the acidic phagolysosome, superoxide may be able to penetrate and attack cytosolic targets of captive bacteria. This process may contribute to the potency of the oxidative burst. One role of periplasmic SOD may be to avert this damage. In contrast, periplasmic SOD was ineffective at lowering the extracellular super-oxide concentration and, therefore, may have little impact upon HOONO formation.     

Inactivation-reactivation of aconitase in Escherichia coli. A sensitive measure of superoxide radical.

The rapid inactivation of aconitase by O2-, previously seen to occur in vitro, was explored in vivo. A fraction of the aconitase in growing, aerobic, Escherichia coli is inactive at any instant but can be activated by imposition of anaerobic conditions. This reactivation occurred in the absence of protein synthesis and was inhibited by the ferrous chelator alpha,alpha'-dipyridyl. This fraction of inactive, but activatable, aconitase was increased by augmenting O2- production with paraquat, decreased by elevation of superoxide dismutase, and increased by inhibiting reactivation with alpha,alpha'-dipyridyl. The balance between inactive and active aconitase thus represented a pseudoequilibrium between inactivation by O2- and reactivation by restoration of Fe(II), and it provided, for the first time, a measure of the steady-state concentration of O2- within E. coli. On this basis, [O2-] was estimated to be approximately 20-40 pM in aerobic log phase E. coli containing wild type levels of superoxide dismutase and approximately 300 pM in a mutant strain lacking superoxide dismutase.     

Periplasmic competition for zinc uptake between the metallochaperone ZnuA and Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase

We have investigated the availability of zinc in the periplasmic space of Escherichia coli using a mutant Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase whose dimerization is triggered by zinc binding. This mutant enzyme accumulates in the monomeric form when wild type cells are grown in minimal medium, but assembles in the dimeric form when it is produced in the same medium by a mutant strain lacking the periplasmic zinc metallochaperone ZnuA. These results indicate that periplasmic zinc-containing proteins compete for metal binding when bacteria grow in environments where this element is present in traces. The effective ZnuA ability to sequester the available zinc ions from the periplasm suggests that zinc-containing cytoplasmic proteins are more important for bacterial viability than the periplasmic ones.     

Modulation of the fibrinolytic response of cultured human vascular endothelium by extracellularly generated oxygen radicals.

Clinical and experimental data indicate that activated oxygen species interfere with vascular endothelial cell function. Here, the impact of extracellular oxidant injury on the fibrinolytic response of cultured human umbilical vein endothelial (HUVE) cells was investigated at the protein and mRNA levels. Xanthine (50 microM) and xanthine oxidase (100 milliunits), which produces the superoxide anion radical (O2-) and hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), was used to sublethally injure HUVE cells. Following a 15-min exposure, washed cells were incubated for up to 24 h in serum-free culture medium. Tissue-type plasminogen activator (t-PA) antigen, plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 (PAI-1) antigen, and PAI-1 activity were determined in 1.25 ml of conditioned medium and t-PA and PAI-1 mRNA in the cell extracts of 2 x 10(6) HUVE cells. Control cells secreted 3.9 +/- 1.3 ng/ml (mean +/- S.D., n = 12) within 24 h. Treatment with xanthine/xanthine oxidase for 15 min induced a 2.8 +/- 0.4-fold increase (n = 12, p less than 0.05) of t-PA antigen secretion after 24 h. The t-PA antigen was recovered predominantly in complex with PAI-1. The oxidant injury caused a 3.0 +/- 0.8-fold increase (n = 9, p less than 0.05) in t-PA mRNA within 2 h. Total protein synthesis was unaltered by xanthine/xanthine oxidase. The oxidant scavengers superoxide dismutase and catalase, in combination, abolished the effect of xanthine/xanthine oxidase on t-PA secretion and t-PA mRNA synthesis. Xanthine/xanthine oxidase treatment of HUVE cells did not affect the PAI-1 secretion in conditioned medium nor the PAI-1 mRNA levels in cell extracts. Thus extracellular oxidant injury induces t-PA but not PAI-1 synthesis in HUVE cells.     

Carbon tetrachloride toxicity on Escherichia coli exacerbated by superoxide

The effects of carbon tetrachloride (CCl4) and paraquat on the growth of Escherichia coli were investigated. Paraquat at 10 mM caused some inhibition of growth of E. coli in trypticase-soy-yeast extract medium. CCl4 enhanced growth inhibition by paraquat in a concentration-dependent manner. In the absence of paraquat, CCl4 had no effect on growth rate or on surviving cell numbers at stationary phase. CCl4 did not prevent the induction of manganese-superoxide dismutase by paraquat. Under anaerobic conditions, CCl4 and paraquat exhibited no effect on E. coli. In the presence of Mn(II) and paraquat, intracellular superoxide dismutase was markedly induced and protected E. coli against the toxicity of CCl4 and paraquat. The reactive free radical CCl3OO-, which can be formed from the reaction of O2- with CCl4, may cause cell damage. The growth-inhibiting effects of polyhalides in the presence of paraquat followed the order CBrCl3 greater than CCl4 greater than CHCl3 greater than CH2Cl2, which is in accord with that of the reaction rates of these compounds with O2- and with their hepatotoxicities. These results suggest that O2- plays a role in the hepatotoxicity of polyhalides.     

Role of superoxide in endothelial-cell modification of low-density lipoproteins

Cultured endothelial cells and arterial smooth muscle cells have been shown to modify LDL in a way that leads to rapid uptake by macrophages. Previous studies have demonstrated that this modification involves free radical peroxidation of LDL, and that the role of the cells was to accelerate oxidation under conditions where it otherwise would occur slowly. The objective of the present study was to determine whether the modification was mediated by oxygen-derived free radicals, and whether the ability of a given cell type of line to modify LDL was related to its secretion rate of O2- or H2O2. The results showed that modification required the presence of oxygen, and could be specifically inhibited by superoxide dismutase but not by catalase or by mannitol, a hydroxyl radical scavenger. Rabbit aortic endothelial cells, rabbit arterial smooth muscle cells, monkey arterial smooth muscle cells and human skin fibroblasts were all found to modify LDL, and all of these cell types generated more O2- (superoxide dismutase-inhibitable cytochrome c reduction) than a line of bovine aortic endothelial cells that did not modify LDL. The content of superoxide dismutase and catalase was higher in bovine aortic endothelial cells than in the cell lines that modified LDL, but glutathione peroxidase levels were not different. It was concluded that cells that were capable of modifying LDL produced superoxide or a substance that could be converted to superoxide in the medium, and that superoxide was an important, though possibly indirect, mediator of the modification of LDL by cells.     

Superoxide dismutase and O2 lethality in Bacteroides fragilis.

Exposure of midlog Bacteroides fragils (VPI 2393) to 2% O2-98% N2 caused a three- to fivefold increase in superoxide dismutase specific activity within the cells. The increase in specific activity was completed within 90 min after exposure to oxygen and was dependent upon protein synthesis. Cells containing the higher superoxide dismutase level were more resistant to the effects of 5 atm of oxygen tension than were cells containing the lower level of superoxide dismutase but were equally resistant to 5 atm of nitrogen tension. Similar results were observed upon comparing viability experiments with B. fragilis and B. vulgatus. Superoxide dismutase activity in sonic extracts of B. fragilis was rapidly inactivated by exposure to 5 mM H2O2 and was inhibited by 1 mM NaN3 but not 5 mM NaCN. The inhibition pattern is identical to the pattern demonstrated for the purified iron-containing enzyme from Escherichia coli B and suggests that the superoxide dismutase in B. fragilis is an iron enzyme.     

Difference in superoxide toxicity between 4,7-dicyanobenzofurazan and paraquat.

The O2-. production by aerobically cultured Escherichia coli in the presence of benzofurazan (1), 4,7-dimethylbenzofurazan (2), 4,7-dibromobenzofurazan (3), 4-bromo-6-cyanobenzofurazan (4), and 4,7-dicyanobenzofurazan (5) was examined by using the cytochrome c reduction method in order to elucidate the mechanism of cytotoxicity of benzofurazans. Adding compound 5 to E. coli cell suspension caused cytochrome c reduction, which was completely inhibited by superoxide dismutase. The rate of cytochrome c reduction was in the order of 1 = 2 = 3 less than 4 less than 5, which correlates well with that of the reduction potentials of these benzofurazans. Adding glucose to the E. coli cell suspension-compound 5-cytochrome c system accelerated the rate of cytochrome c reduction. The formation of 4,7-dicyanobenzofurazan anion radical in the cell suspension-compound 5-glucose system in the absence of O2 was followed by ESR spectroscopy. The ESR signal of the anion radical disappeared when O2 was added. Compound 5 was shown to have an approximately 10-fold greater increasing effect on the flux of O2-. by E. coli than paraquat (PQ) by the cytochrome c reduction method. The results were confirmed by the electrochemical method with an oxygen electrode. However, compound 5 had a bacteriostatic, but not lethal, effect, while PQ had both effects. The effect of compound 5 and PQ on lethality of E. coli showed a dramatic difference when E. coli was exposed to these two compounds and washed prior to testing the effects of that exposure. This difference probably arose because compound 5 readily leaked from the cells during dilution and plating. Also, the reduced form of compound 5 exits from the cells more readily than the reduced form of PQ and then generates O2-. in the medium by autoxidation. This suggests the importance of the intracellular production of O2-., rather than the extracellular production of O2-., for lethal effect.