The allele-specific synthetic lethality of prlA-prlG double mutants predicts interactive domains of SecY and SecE.

The secretion of proteins from the cytoplasm of Escherichia coli requires the interaction of two integral inner membrane components, SecY and SecE. We have devised a genetic approach to probe the molecular nature of the SecY-SecE interaction. Suppressor alleles of secY and secE, termed prlA and prlG, respectively, were analyzed in pair-wise combinations for synthetic phenotypes. From a total of 115 combinations, we found only seven pairs of alleles that exhibit a synthetic defect when present in combination with one another. The phenotypes observed are not the result of additive defects caused by the prl alleles, nor are they the consequence of multiple suppressors functioning within the same strain. In all cases, the synthetic defect is recessive to wild-type secY or secE provided in trans. The recessive nature argues for a defective interaction between the Prl suppressors. The extreme allele specificity and topological coincidence of the mutations represented by these seven pairs of alleles identify domains of interaction between SecY/PrlA and SecE/PrlG.     

PrlA and PrlG suppressors reduce the requirement for signal sequence recognition.

Selection for suppressors of defects in the signal sequence of secretory proteins has led most commonly to identification of prlA alleles and less often to identification of prlG alleles. These genes, secY/prlA and secE/prlG, encode integral membrane components of the protein translocation system of Escherichia coli. We demonstrate that an outer membrane protein, LamB, that lacks a signal sequence can be exported with reasonable efficiency in both prlA and prlG suppressor strains. Although the signal sequence is not absolutely required for export of LamB, the level of export in the absence of prl suppressor alleles is exceedingly low. Such strains are phenotypically LamB-, and functional LamB can be detected only by using sensitive infectious-center assays. Suppression of the LamB signal sequence deletion is dependent on normal components of the export pathway, indicating that suppression is not occurring through a bypass mechanism. Our results indicate that the majority of the known prlA suppressors function by an identical mechanism and, further, that the prlG suppressors work in a similar fashion. We propose that both PrlA and PrlG suppressors lack a proofreading activity that normally rejects defective precursors from the export pathway.     

Suppressor analysis suggests a multistep, cyclic mechanism for protein secretion in Escherichia coli.

The sec/prl gene products catalyze the translocation of precursor proteins from the cytoplasm of Escherichia coli. Recessive, conditionally lethal mutant alleles of these genes (sec mutations) cause a generalized defect in protein secretion; dominant suppressor mutant alleles (prl mutations) restore export of precursor proteins with altered signal sequences. In prl strains, a precursor protein with a defective signal sequence can be selectively targeted to the suppressor gene product. When a precursor LacZ hybrid protein is used, the targeted prl protein is inactivated by the large, toxic hybrid molecule, a result termed suppressor-directed inactivation (SDI). Using SDI, two different secretion-related complexes can be generated: a pretranslocation complex that contains a hybrid protein with an unprocessed signal sequence, and a translocation complex in which the hybrid protein is jammed in transmembrane orientation with the signal sequence cleaved. Additional Sec proteins that are contained within, and thus sequestered by, each of these complexes can be identified when their functional levels are lowered using the conditional lethal sec mutations. Results of this genetic analysis suggest a multistep pathway for protein secretion in which the translocation machinery assembles on demand.     

A SecE mutation that modulates SecY-SecE translocase assembly,identified as a specific suppressor of SecY defects

The SecY39(Cs) (cold-sensitive) alteration of Arg357 results in a defect of translocation initiation. As a means to dissect the Sec translocation machinery, we isolated mutations that act as suppressors of the secY39 defect. A specific secE mutation, designated secE105, was thus isolated. This mutation proved to be identical with the prlG2 mutation and to suppress a number of cold-sensitive secY mutations. However, other prlG mutations did not effectively suppress the secY defects. Evidence indicates that the Ser105-to-Pro alteration in the C-terminal transmembrane segment of SecE weakens SecY-SecE association. In vitro analyses showed that the SecE(S105P) alteration preferentially stimulates the initial phase of translocation. It is suggested that the S105P alteration affects the SecYEG channel such that it is more prone to open and to accept the translocation initiation domain of a preprotein molecule.     

SecY variants that interfere with Escherichia coli protein export in the presence of normal secY

As an approach for studying how SecY, an integral membrane protein translocation factor of Escherichia coli, interacts with other protein molecules, we isolated a dominant negative mutation, secY-d1, of the gene carried on a plasmid. The mutant plasmid severely inhibited export of maltose-binding protein and less severely of OmpA, when introduced into sec+ cells. It inhibited growth of secY and secE mutant cells, but not of secA and secD mutant cells or wild-type cells. The mutation deletes three amino acids that should be located at the interface of cytoplasmic domain 5 and transmembrane segment 9. We also found that some SecY-PhoA fusion proteins that lacked carboxy-terminal portions of SecY but retain a region from periplasmic domain 3 to transmembrane segment 7 were inhibitory to protein export. We suggest that these SecY variants are severely defective in catalytic function of SecY, which requires cytoplasmic domain 5 and its carboxy-terminal side, but retain the ability to associate with other molecules of the protein export machinery, which requires the central portion of SecY; they probably exert the 'dominant negative' effects by competing with normal SecY for the formation of active Sec complex. These observations should provide a basis for further genetic analysis of the Sec protein complex in the membrane.     

Peculiar properties of DsbA in its export across the Escherichia coli cytoplasmic membrane

Export of DsbA, a protein disulfide bond-introducing enzyme, across the Escherichia coli cytoplasmic membrane was studied with special reference to the effects of various mutations affecting translocation factors. It was noted that both the internalized precursor retaining the signal peptide and the periplasmic mature product fold rapidly into a protease-resistant structure and they exhibited anomalies in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in that the former migrated faster than the latter. The precursor, once accumulated, was not exported posttranslationally. DsbA export depended on the SecY translocon, the SecA ATPase, and Ffh (signal recognition particle), but not on SecB. SecY mutations, such as secY39 and secY205, that severely impair translocation of a number of secretory substrates by interfering with SecA actions only insignificantly impaired the DsbA export. In contrast, secY125, affecting a periplasmic domain and impairing a late step of translocation, exerted strong export inhibition of both classes of proteins. These results suggest that DsbA uses not only the signal recognition particle targeting pathway but also a special route of translocation through the translocon, which is hence suggested to actively discriminate pre-proteins.     

Novel prlA alleles defective in supporting staphylokinase processing in Escherichia coli

A class of prlA (secY) alleles of Escherichia coli (prlA4-1 and prlA401) which specifically block the export of staphylokinase has been identified (T. Iino and T. Sako, J. Biol. Chem. 263:19077-19082, 1988; T. Sako and T. Iino, J. Bacteriol. 170:5389-5391, 1988). To determine more precisely the region in PrlA (SecY) effective for the blockage of processing of the staphylokinase precursor, additional prlA mutants which failed to support processing of the staphylokinase precursor were isolated. Two of the five mutant alleles isolated (secY121 and secY161) complemented the temperature sensitivity of a secY24 strain and had no detectable effect on the processing of endogenous secretory proteins of E. coli. In addition, a staphylokinase mutant having glycine in place of serine at position 17 in its signal sequence relieved the detrimental effect of these mutations. All of these characteristics indicate that these two alleles resemble the prlA4-1 and prlA401 alleles. On the other hand, the remaining three mutant alleles (secY47, secY105, and secY112) had no significant PrlA activity. The mutations of secY121 and secY161 were mapped very close to those of prlA4-1 and prlA401 in the presumed transmembrane segment 7 of PrlA. These results indicate that transmembrane segment 7 of PrlA plays a crucial role in the recognition of the staphylokinase signal sequence.     

Mutations in the Sec61p channel affecting signal sequence recognition and membrane protein topology

The orientation of most single-spanning membrane proteins obeys the "positive-inside rule", i.e. the flanking region of the transmembrane segment that is more positively charged remains in the cytosol. These membrane proteins are integrated by the Sec61/SecY translocon, but how their orientation is achieved is unknown. We have screened for mutations in yeast Sec61p that alter the orientation of single-spanning membrane proteins. We identified a class of mutants that are less efficient in retaining the positively charged flanking region in the cytosol. Surprisingly, these mutations are located at many different sites in the Sec61/SecY molecule, and they do not only involve charged amino acid residues. All these mutants have a prl phenotype that so far have only been seen in bacteria; they allow proteins with defective signal sequences to be translocated, likely because the Sec61p channel opens more easily. A similar correlation between topology defects and prl phenotype was also seen with previously identified yeast Sec61 mutants. Our results suggest a model in which the regulated opening of the translocon is required for the faithful orientation of membrane proteins.     

Mutational analysis of transmembrane regions 3 and 4 of SecY, a central component of protein translocase

The SecYEG heterotrimeric membrane protein complex functions as a channel for protein translocation across the Escherichia coli cytoplasmic membrane. SecY is the central subunit of the SecYEG complex and contains 10 transmembrane segments (TM1 to TM10). Previous mutation studies suggested that TM3 and TM4 are particularly important for SecY function. To further characterize TM3 and TM4, we introduced a series of cysteine-scanning mutations into these segments. With one exception (an unstable product), all the mutant proteins complemented the cold-sensitive growth defect of the secY39 mutant. A combination of this secY mutation and the secG deletion resulted in synthetic lethality, and the TM3 and TM4 SecY cysteine substitution mutations were examined for their ability to complement this lethality. Although they were all positive for complementation, some of the complemented cells exhibited significant retardation of protein export. The substitution-sensitive residues in TM3 can be aligned to one side of the alpha-helix, and those in TM4 revealed a tendency for residues closer to the cytosolic side of the membrane to be more severely affected. Disulfide cross-linking experiments identified a specific contact point for TM3 and SecG TM2 as well as for TM4 and SecG TM1. Thus, although TM3 and TM4 do not contain any single residue that is absolutely required, they include functionally important helix surfaces and specific contact points with SecG. These results are discussed in light of the structural information available for the SecY complex.     

PrlA suppressor mutations cluster in regions corresponding to three distinct topological domains.

The SecY protein of Escherichia coli and its homologues in other organisms, are integral components of the cellular protein translocation machinery. Suppressor mutations that alter SecY (the prlA alleles) broaden the specificity of this machinery and allow secretion of precursor proteins with defective signal sequences. Twenty-five prlA alleles have been characterized. These suppressor mutations were found to cluster in regions corresponding to three distinct topological domains of SecY. Based on the nature and position of the prlA mutations, we propose that transmembrane domain 7 of SecY functions in signal sequence recognition. Results suggest that this interaction may involve a right-handed supercoil of alpha-helices. Suppressor mutations that alter this domain appear to prevent signal sequence recognition, and this novel mechanism of suppression suggests a proofreading function for SecY. We propose that suppressor mutations that alter a second domain of SecY, transmembrane helix 10, also affect this proof-reading function, but indirectly. Based on the synthetic phenotypes exhibited by double mutants, we propose that these mutations strengthen the interaction with another component of the translocation machinery, SecE. Suppressor mutations were also found to cluster in a region corresponding to an amino-terminal periplasmic domain. Possible explanations for this unexpected finding are discussed.     

PrlA (SecY) and PrlG (SecE) interact directly and function sequentially during protein translocation in E. coli

Three strategies for genetic analysis show that two inner membrane components of the export machinery, PrlA (SecY) and PrlG (SecE), interact directly while catalyzing the translocation of secreted proteins across the cytoplasmic membrane of E. coli. The first, suppressor-directed inactivation (SDI), exploits the specific interaction between dominant prl suppressors of signal sequence mutations and mutant LacZ hybrid proteins. The second, Sec titration, extends SDI to allow the identification of various Sec proteins that are present in the translocation complex. The third uses the synthetic lethality of certain double-mutant strains to infer physical interactions between gene products. Biochemical data obtained with SDI strains allow the identification of two different secretory intermediates and indicate that PrlG functions before PrlA in the secretion pathway.     

Superactive SecY variants that fulfill the essential translocation function with a reduced cellular quantity

The fifth and the sixth cytoplasmic regions (C5 and C6) of SecY are important for the SecA-driven preprotein translocation reaction. A cold-sensitive mutation, secY205 (Tyr-429 --> Asp), in C6 impairs the ATP- and precursor-dependent SecA insertion into the membrane. We now identified second site mutations that suppressed the defect. Cis-placement of these mutations proved to suppress mutations at another essential residue (Arg-357) of SecY as well. Thus, they tolerate the otherwise defective SecY alterations in the same molecule. Two alterations (Ile-195 to Ser in TM5 region and Ile-408 to Leu in TM10 region) were found to make the translocation channel more active, because it enabled cells to survive with reduced content of the SecYE complex. These mutations only very weakly suppressed a signal sequence defect of the lambda receptor protein. The mutant SecYEG translocase exhibited higher than normal activity in vitro, being accompanied by striking independence of the proton motive force as well as by stabilization of a bound and active SecA species against urea treatment. These results have been interpreted in terms of balance shifts between channel closing and channel opening alterations in the SecYEG translocase.     

Signal recognition particle-dependent inner membrane targeting of the PulG Pseudopilin component of a type II secretion system

The pseudopilin PulG is an essential component of the pullulanase-specific type II secretion system from Klebsiella oxytoca. PulG is the major subunit of a short, thin-filament pseudopilus, which presumably elongates and retracts in the periplasm, acting as a dynamic piston to promote pullulanase secretion. It has a signal sequence-like N-terminal segment that, according to studies with green and red fluorescent protein chimeras, anchors unassembled PulG in the inner membrane. We analyzed the early steps of PulG inner membrane targeting and insertion in Escherichia coli derivatives defective in different protein targeting and export factors. The beta-galactosidase activity in strains producing a PulG-LacZ hybrid protein increased substantially when the dsbA, dsbB, or all sec genes tested except secB were compromised by mutations. To facilitate analysis of native PulG membrane insertion, a leader peptidase cleavage site was engineered downstream from the N-terminal transmembrane segment (PrePulG*). Unprocessed PrePulG* was detected in strains carrying mutations in secA, secY, secE, and secD genes, including some novel alleles of secY and secD. Furthermore, depletion of the Ffh component of the signal recognition particle (SRP) completely abolished PrePulG* processing, without affecting the Sec-dependent export of periplasmic MalE and RbsB proteins. Thus, PulG is cotranslationally targeted to the inner membrane Sec translocase by SRP.     

Suppressor Analysis Reveals a Role for SecY in the SecA2-Dependent Protein Export Pathway of Mycobacteria

All bacteria use the conserved Sec pathway to transport proteins across the cytoplasmic membrane, with the SecA ATPase playing a central role in the process. Mycobacteria are part of a small group of bacteria that have two SecA proteins: the canonical SecA (SecA1) and a second, specialized SecA (SecA2). The SecA2-dependent pathway exports a small subset of proteins and is required for Mycobacterium tuberculosis virulence. The mechanism by which SecA2 drives export of proteins across the cytoplasmic membrane remains poorly understood. Here we performed suppressor analysis on a dominant negative secA2 mutant (secA2 K129R) of the model mycobacterium Mycobacterium smegmatis to better understand the pathway used by SecA2 to export proteins. Two extragenic suppressor mutations were identified as mapping to the promoter region of secY, which encodes the central component of the canonical Sec export channel. These suppressor mutations increased secY expression, and this effect was sufficient to alleviate the secA2 K129R phenotype. We also discovered that the level of SecY protein was greatly diminished in the secA2 K129R mutant, but at least partially restored in the suppressors. Furthermore, the level of SecY in a suppressor strongly correlated with the degree of suppression. Our findings reveal a detrimental effect of SecA2 K129R on SecY, arguing for an integrated system in which SecA2 works with SecY and the canonical Sec translocase to export proteins.     

Genetic analysis of an essential cytoplasmic domain of Escherichia coli SecY based on resistance to Syd, a SecY-interacting protein

We previously described a dominant negative secY ^-d 1 allele in Escherichia coli, whose product interferes with protein export, presumably by sequestering SecE, the stabilizing partner of SecY. Syd is the product of a multicopy suppressor of the secY ^-d 1 phenotype, and its overproduction preferentially stabilizes the wild-type SecY protein. In contrast, overproduction of Syd is toxic to the secY24 mutant, which shows a partial defect in SecY-SecE interaction. We isolated Syd-resistant revertants from the secY24 mutant. Pseudo-reversions mapped to sites at or near the secY24 mutation site (Gly240→Asp). The secY249 mutation (Ala249→Val) intragenically suppressed Syd sensitivity, but not the temperature-sensitive Sec phenotype of the secY24 mutation. The SecY249 mutant protein shows a reduced capacity to be stabilized by Syd, suggesting that the mutation weakens the SecY-Syd interaction. The other two mutations changed residue 240 (the site of the secY24 alteration) to Asn (secY245) or Ala (secY241) and restored the ability of the cell to export protein. Although the secY245 mutant retained some sensitivity?to Syd overproduction, the secY241 mutant was completely Syd-resistant. Furthermore, the secY241 mutation seemed to represent a “hyper reversion” with respect to the SecY-SecE interaction. Protein export in this mutant was no longer sensitive to SecY^-d1. When the secY ^-d 1 mutation was combined intragenically with secY241, the resulting double mutant gene (secY ^-d 1–241) showed an increased ability to interfere with protein export. On the basis of our model for SecY^-d1, these results suggest that the secY241 alteration enhances SecY-SecE interaction. These results indicate that residue 240 of SecY is crucial for the interaction between the cytosolic domains of SecY and SecE required for the establishment of the translocase complex.     

Export of maltose-binding protein species with altered charge distribution surrounding the signal peptide hydrophobic core in Escherichia coli cells harboring prl suppressor mutations.

It is believed that one or more basic residues at the extreme amino terminus of precursor proteins and the lack of a net positive charge immediately following the signal peptide act as topological determinants that promote the insertion of the signal peptide hydrophobic core into the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli cells with the correct orientation required to initiate the protein export process. The export efficiency of precursor maltose-binding protein (pre-MBP) was found to decrease progressively as the net charge in the early mature region was increased systematically from 0 to +4. This inhibitory effect could be further exacerbated by reducing the net charge in the signal peptide to below 0. One such MBP species, designated MBP-3/+3 and having a net charge of -3 in the signal peptide and +3 in the early mature region, was totally export defective. Revertants in which MBP-3/+3 export was restored were found to harbor mutations in the prlA (secY) gene, encoding a key component of the E. coli protein export machinery. One such mutation, prlA666, was extensively characterized and shown to be a particularly strong suppressor of a variety of MBP export defects. Export of MBP-3/+3 and other MBP species with charge alterations in the early mature region also was substantially improved in E. coli cells harboring certain other prlA mutations originally selected as extragenic suppressors of signal sequence mutations altering the hydrophobic core of the LamB or MBP signal peptide. In addition, the enzymatic activity of alkaline phosphatase (PhoA) fused to a predicted cytoplasmic domain of an integral membrane protein (UhpT) increased significantly in cells harboring prlA666. These results suggest a role for PrlA/SecY in determining the orientation of signal peptides and possibly other membrane-spanning protein domains in the cytoplasmic membrane.     

SecY and SecA interact to allow SecA insertion and protein translocation across the Escherichia coli plasma membrane.

SecA, the preprotein-driving ATPase in Escherichia coli, was shown previously to insert deeply into the plasma membrane in the presence of ATP and a preprotein; this movement of SecA was proposed to be mechanistically coupled with preprotein translocation. We now address the role played by SecY, the central subunit of the membrane-embedded heterotrimeric complex, in the SecA insertion reaction. We identified a secY mutation (secY205), affecting the most carboxyterminal cytoplasmic domain, that did not allow ATP and preprotein-dependent productive SecA insertion, while allowing idling insertion without the preprotein. Thus, the secY205 mutation might affect the SecYEG 'channel' structure in accepting the preprotein-SecA complex or its opening by the complex. We isolated secA mutations that allele-specifically suppressed the secY205 translocation defect in vivo. One mutant protein, SecA36, with an amino acid alteration near the high-affinity ATP-binding site, was purified and suppressed the in vitro translocation defect of the inverted membrane vesicles carrying the SecY205 protein. The SecA36 protein could also insert into the mutant membrane vesicles in vitro. These results provide genetic evidence that SecA and SecY specifically interact, and show that SecY plays an essential role in insertion of SecA in response to a preprotein and ATP and suggest that SecA drives protein translocation by inserting into the membrane in vivo.     

SecE-dependent overproduction of SecY in Escherichia coli. Evidence for interaction between two components of the secretory machinery

The secY and secE genes were individually cloned and placed under the control of the tac promoter on plasmids. Induction with isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactopyranoside resulted in the overproduction of SecE, but not that of SecY. The simultaneous induced expression of both genes in the same cells resulted in the overproduction of SecY together with that of SecE. SecY and SecE thus overproduced were localized in the cytoplasmic membrane as those expressed at the normal levels were. It is suggested that SecY and SecE interact with each other in the cytoplasmic membrane. The numbers of the SecY and SecE molecules per cell were estimated.     

SecF stabilizes SecD and SecY, components of the protein translocation machinery of the Escherichia coli cytoplasmic membrane.

The effect of the overproduction of SecF encoded by the tac-secF gene on a plasmid on the synthesis of other Sec proteins was studied in Escherichia coli. SecF overproduction resulted in the simultaneous overproduction of SecD encoded by the tac-secD gene on a plasmid. Deletion of the orf6 gene, located downstream of the secF gene, had no effect on SecD overproduction. A pulse-chase experiment revealed that the overproduction was due to stabilization of SecD with SecF. SecF overproduction also resulted in the overproduction of SecY encoded by the tac-secY gene on a plasmid as well. SecF overproduction also enhanced the level of SecY expressed by the chromosomal secY gene. This SecF effect was not due to its effect on SecD or SecE, since SecF overproduction did not affect the levels of SecD and SecE expressed by the chromosomal secD and secE genes, respectively. SecE-dependent overproduction of SecY has already been demonstrated. It is suggested that SecF interacts with both SecD and SecY. SecE-SecY interaction has been demonstrated. It is likely, therefore, that all Sec proteins in the cytoplasmic membrane interact with each other.