Ionizing radiation and genetic risks. III. Nature of spontaneous and radiation-induced mutations in mammalian in vitro systems and mechanisms of induction of mutations by radiation

This paper (1) presents an analysis of published data on the molecular nature of spontaneously arising and radiation-induced mutations in mammalian somatic cell systems and (2) examines whether the molecular nature and mechanisms of origin of radiation-induced mutations, in mammalian in vivo and in vitro systems, as currently understood, are consistent with expectations based on the biophysical and microdosimetric properties of ionizing radiation. Depending on the test system (CHO cells, human T lymphocytes and human lymphoid cell line TK6), 80-97% of spontaneous HPRT mutations show normal Southern patterns; the remainder is due to gross changes, predominantly partial (intragenic) deletions. Total gene deletions at the HPRT locus are rare except in the TK6 cell line. At the APRT locus in CHO cells, 80-97% of spontaneous mutations are due to base-pair changes, the remainder being, mostly, partial deletions. The latter can extend upstream in the 5' direction but not beyond the APRT gene in the 3' direction. At the human HLA-A locus (T lymphocytes), the percentage of mutations with normal Southern patterns is lower than that for HPRT, and in the range of 50-60%. At the HLA-A locus, mitotic recombination contributes substantially to the mutation spectrum (approximately 30% of mutations recovered) and this is likely to be true of the TK locus in the TK6 cell line as well. With a few exceptions, most of the radiation-induced mutations show altered Southern patterns and are consistent with their being deletions and/or other gross changes (HPRT, 70-90% (CHO); 50-85% (TK6); 50-75% (T lymphocytes); TK, 60-80% (TK6); HLA-A, 80% (T lymphocytes); DHFR, 100% (CHO]. The exceptions are APRT mutations in CHO cells (16-20% of mutants with deletions or other changes) and HPRT mutations in T lymphocytes from A-bomb survivors (15-25%); the latter finding is consistent with the occurrence of in vivo selection against HPRT mutant cells. In cases of HPRT intragenic deletions analyzed (CHO cells and V79 Chinese hamster cells), there is evidence for a non-random distribution of breakpoints. The spontaneous mutation frequencies vary widely, from about 0.04/10(6) cells (sickle cell mutations at the human HBB locus) to 30.8/10(6) cells (HLA-A mutations in T lymphocytes) and are dependent on the locus, the system employed and a number of other factors. Those for the other loci fall between these limits.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Genetic transformation of somatic cells. VIII. The effect of the DNA methylation inhibitor 5-azacytidine on the stability of thymidine kinase-negative and -positive phenotypes of transformant clone cells

A study was made of the effect of an DNA methylation inhibitor 5-azacytidine (azaC) on the frequency of reversion to a thymidine kinase-positive (TK+) phenotype in 5-bromodeoxy-uridine (BrdU)-resistant subclones obtained from clones of Chinese hamster cells transformed by thymidine kinase gene (tk-gene) of Herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV1). It is shown that in 8 of 15 BrdU-resistant subclones azaC increases 2-1000-fold the frequency of reversion to TK+ phenotype. Variations in the inducibility of reversions to TK+ phenotype indicate that the DNA methylation associated with TK- phenotype affects but differently tk gene of HSV1. Cultivation of TK+ cells of transformant clones in the presence of azaC may lead to stabilization (or decrease in the rate of the loss) of TK+ phenotype, or may not influence the stability of transformant phenotype. The reaction of TK+ cells of transformant clones depends both on genetically determined rate of the loss of TK+ phenotype, and on the structure of transforming DNA introduced to cells. A conclusion is drawn that the TK- phenotype of transformant clone cells arises due to processes which are not associated with methylation of tk gene of HSV1 in spite of the fact that such a methylation may later stabilize significantly the TK- phenotype.     

UV mutagenesis, cytotoxicity and split-dose recovery in a human-CHO cell hybrid having intermediate (6-4) photoproduct repair

Somatic cell hybrids constructed between UV-hypersensitive Chinese hamster ovary cell line UV20 and human lymphocytes were used to examine the influence of a human DNA repair gene, ERCC1, on UV photoproduct repair, mutability at several drug-resistance loci, UV cytotoxicity and UV split-dose recovery. In hybrid cell line 20HL21-4, which contains human chromosome 19, UV-induced mutagenesis at the APRT, HPRT and Na+/K+-ATPase loci was comparable to that in repair-proficient CHO AA8 cells, whereas cell line 20HL21-7, a reduced human-CHO hybrid not containing human chromosome 19, exhibited a hypermutable phenotype at all 3 loci indistinguishable from that of UV20 cells. The response of 20HL21-4 cells to UV cytotoxicity reflected substantial but incomplete restoration of wild-type UV cytotoxic response, whereas responses of UV20 and 20HL21-7 cell lines to UV cytotoxicity were essentially the same, reflecting several-fold UV hypersensitivity. Repair of UV-induced (5-6) cyclobutane dimers and (6-4) photoproducts was examined by radioimmunoassay; (6-4) photoproduct repair was deficient in UV20 and 20HL21-7 cell lines, and intermediate in 20HL21-4 cells relative to wild-type CHO AA8 cells. UV split-dose recovery in 20HL21-4 cells was also intermediate relative to AA8 cells. These results show that the human ERCC1 gene on chromosome 19 is responsible for substantial restoration of UV survival and mutation responses in repair-deficient UV20 cells, but only partially restores (6-4) UV photoproduct repair and UV split-dose recovery.     

Genotoxicity of 3'-azido-3'-deoxythymidine in the human lymphoblastoid cell line, TK6: relationships between DNA incorporation, mutant frequency, and spectrum of deletion mutations in HPRT.

Perinatal treatment with 3'-azido-3'-deoxythymidine (AZT) has been found to reduce the rate of maternal-infant transmission of HIV; however, AZT is genotoxic in mammalian cells in vitro and induces tumors in the offspring of mice treated in utero. The purpose of the present study was to investigate the relationships between incorporation of AZT into DNA, and the frequency and spectrum of mutations at the HPRT locus of the human lymphoblastoid cell line, TK6, following in vitro exposures to AZT. Cells were cultured in medium containing 0 or 300 microM AZT for 1, 3, or 6 day(s) (n = 5/group). The effects of exposure duration on incorporation of AZT into DNA and HPRT mutant frequency were determined using an AZT radioimmunoassay and a cell cloning assay, respectively. AZT accumulated in DNA in a supralinear manner, approaching a plateau at 6 days of treatment (101.9 +/- 14.7 molecules AZT/10(6) nucleotides). After 3 days of AZT exposure, HPRT mutant frequency was significantly increased (1.8-fold, p = 0.016) compared to background (mutant frequency = 3.78 x 10(-6)). Multiplex PCR amplification of genomic DNA was used to determine the frequency of exon deletions in HPRT mutant clones from untreated cells versus AZT-treated cells. Molecular analyses of AZT-induced mutations revealed a significant difference in the frequency of total gene deletions (44/120 vs. 18/114 in controls, p = 0.004 by the Mann-Whitney U-statistic). In fact, the Chi-square test of homogeneity demonstrate that the differences between the control and AZT-treatment groups is attributed mainly to this increase in total gene deletion mutations (p = 0.00001). These data indicate that the primary mechanism of AZT mutagenicity in human TK6 cells is through the production of large deletions which occur as a result of AZT incorporation into DNA and subsequent chain termination. The data imply that perinatal chemoprophylaxis with AZT may put children of HIV-infected women at potential risk for genetic damage.     

Cotransfer of syntenic human genes into mouse cells using isolated metaphase chromosomes or cellular DNA

Summary Chromosome-mediated gene transfer (CMGT) of the human genes for hypoxanthine phosphoribosyl transferase (HPRT) and cytosol thymidine kinase (TK1) into HPRT deficient mouse A9 cells or TK deficient Swiss mouse 3T3TK^– cells was found to occur at frequencies at least one order of magnitude higher than DNA-mediated gene transfer (DMGT). The frequency of CMGT into 3T3TK^– cells was reduced by more than an order of magnitude by a posttreatment of the recipient cells with dimethyl sulphoxide (DMSO). After CMGT, expression of the non-selected genes coding for galactokinase (GALK) and acid alpha-glucosidase (GAA), both syntenic with TK1, was observed in a number of transformants. From the pattern of cotransfer, a tentative gene ordering of CENTROMERE-GALK-TK1-GAA on human chromosome 17 was deduced. Chromosome-mediated cotransfer of X-linked human phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) with HPRT was observed in two out of 33 A9 transformants analysed. DNA-mediated cotransfer of a syntenic gene was only observed for GALK, cotransferred with TK1 in two out of 18 TK⁺ transformants of mouse LTK^– cells. Therefore, with murine cells as recipients of human donor genetic material, CMGT results in a higher frequency of transfer and a higher incidence of cotransfer of syntenic genes than DMGT using cellular DNA in the same cell system.     

Transfer of genes to Chinese hamster ovary cells by DNA-mediated transformation

We have transferred DNa to Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells by DNA-mediated transformation. CHO tk- cells were transformed with the clones gene for herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (HSV-tk) and were found to have a 50-fold lower frequency of transformation than mouse Ltk- cells at the same DNA dosage. By altering the amount of tk gene and carrier DNA present, frequencies of up to 5 x 10(-5) were obtained. CHO HSV-tk+ transformants were very stable, and in several clones the HSV-tk gene copies integrated in higher-molecular-weight DNA. These cells also exhibited cotransformation for unselected markers. CHO lines were also transformed at a frequency of 10(-4) with the bacterial gene Ecogpt in a SV40-pBR322 vector. CHO tk-cells could be transformed at a frequency of 10(-7) with cellular DNA isolated from CHO tk+ cells. CHO cells offer a well-defined genetic system within which to transfer either cloned or whole cellular DNAs.     

Quantitative and molecular analyses of radiation-induced mutation in AS52 cells

pSV2gpt-Transformed and wild-type Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell lines have been used to study radiation-induced mutation at the molecular level. The transformant, designated AS52, was constructed from a hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (HPRT)-deficient CHO cell line and contains a single, functional copy of the Escherichia coli xanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (XPRT) gene (gpt) stably integrated into the Chinese hamster genome. AS52 and wild-type CHO-K1-BH4 cells exhibit similar cytotoxic responses to uv light and X rays; however, significant differences occur in mutation induction at the gpt and hprt loci. A number of HPRT and XPRT mutants which arose following irradiation were analyzed by Southern-blot hybridization. Most XPRT (21/26) and all HPRT (23/23) mutants induced by uv light exhibited hybridization patterns indistinguishable from their parental cell lines. In contrast, all XPRT (26/26) and most HPRT mutants (15/21) induced by X irradiation contained deletion mutations affecting some or all of the gpt and hprt loci, respectively. These results indicate that X rays induce predominantly deletion mutations, while uv light is likely to induce point mutations at both loci.     

Mutagenicity and clastogenicity of proflavin in L5178Y/TK +/- -3.7.2.C cells

We evaluated the ability of proflavin to induce specific-locus mutations at the heterozygous thymidine kinase (tk) locus of L5178Y/TK +/- -3.7.2C mouse lymphoma cells, which appears to permit the recovery of mutants due to single-gene and chromosomal mutations. Proflavin was highly mutagenic at the tk locus, producing 724-965 TK mutants/10(6) survivors (background = 56-85/10(6); survival = 29-32%). Most of the mutants were small colonies, which suggested that proflavin may induce chromosomal mutations. The potent clastogenicity of proflavin was confirmed by cytogenetic analysis for chromosomal aberrations. At the highest dose analyzed (1.5 micrograms/ml), proflavin produced 82 aberrations/100 metaphaes (background = 2/100). The large-colony TK mutant frequency produced by proflavin (48-109/10(6) survivors; background = 23/10(6); survival = 57-61%) was similar to published HPRT mutant frequencies produces by proflavin in L5178Y and CHO cells (50-100/10(6) survivors; background = 2-50/10(6); survival = 50-62%). These results lead to the conclusion that proflavin is a potent clastogen and induces a high frequency of small-colony TK mutants; however, it induces a low frequency of HPRT mutants and a low frequency of large-colony TK mutants.     

Differential activation of the hprt gene on the inactive X chromosome in primary and transformed Chinese hamster cells.

We have investigated the genetic activation of the hprt (hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase) gene located on the inactive X chromosome in primary and transformed female diploid Chinese hamster cells after treatment with the DNA methylation inhibitor 5-azacytidine (5azaCR). Mutants deficient in HPRT were first selected by growth in 6-thioguanine from two primary fibroblast cell lines and from transformed lines derived from them. These HPRT- mutants were then treated with 5azaCR and plated in HAT (hypoxanthine-methotrexate-thymidine) medium to select for cells that had reexpressed the hprt gene on the inactive X chromosome. Contrary to previous results with primary human cells, 5azaCR was effective in activating the hprt gene in primary Chinese hamster fibroblasts at a low but reproducible frequency of 2 x 10(-6) to 7 x 10(-6). In comparison, the frequency in independently derived transformed lines varied from 1 x 10(-5) to 5 x 10(-3), consistently higher than in the nontransformed cells. This increase remained significant when the difference in growth rates between the primary and transformed lines was taken into account. Treatment with 5azaCR was also found to induce transformation in the primary cell lines but at a low frequency of 4 x 10(-7) to 8 x 10(-7), inconsistent with a two-step model of transformation followed by gene activation to explain the derepression of hprt in primary cells. Thus, these results indicate that upon transformation, the hprt gene on the inactive Chinese hamster X chromosome is rendered more susceptible to action by 5azaCR, consistent with a generalized DNA demethylation associated with the transformation event or with an increase in the instability of an underlying primary mechanism of X inactivation.     

Chromosome-mediated gene transfer with the Chinese hamster ovary cell line

Using an improved method of chromosome-mediated gene transfer, we have investigated transfer of the codominantly expressed methotrexate-resistant dihydrofolate reductase (MtxRIIIdhfr) gene into Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell recipients. The frequency of dhfr gene transfer with CHO cells varied considerably from clone to clone, ranging from 4 X 10(-7) to 5 X 10(-5). Using appropriate cell recipients we were able to test for linkage of several genetic markers available in the CHO cell line. For example, the mutation resulting in the auxotrophic glyB-CHO cell line has been reported by others to be linked to the dhfr gene. However, we could not demonstrate cotransfer of these two markers when glyB- recipient cells were treated with MtxRIII chromosomes and transformant clones were selected for either methotrexate-resistance (MtxR) or glycine prototrophy. We conclude that these two genes are not closely linked in the hamster genome. However, the genes for thymidine kinase (tk) and galactokinase (gk), which are known to be linked in mammalian genomes, were found to cotransfer into CHO recipients with a frequency of about 50%.     

用人DNA介导的基因转移修复中国仓鼠细胞的HPRT缺陷

 中国仓鼠卵巢细胞(CHO-K1)经N-甲基-N'-硝基-N-亚硝基胍(MNNG)诱变和6-巯基鸟嘌呤(6-TG)选择,得到稳定的次黄嘌呤磷酸核糖转移酶(HPRT)缺陷细胞株,酶活性仅为野生型的6.5％。用磷酸钙共沉淀法和电脉冲法向HPRT-细胞转移人宫颈癌细胞(HeLaS_3)基因组DNA,纠正了CHO细胞的HPRT缺陷。酶活性提高了6.9倍,达到野生型的45％。用Alu序列探针进行分子杂交,证实经过基因转移并连续传代15次以上的受体细胞中含人DNA序列。表明人的有关基因已稳定地整合到CHO细胞的染色体中。     

Genetic transformation of somatic cells. VII. The loss of the transformant phenotype is accompanied by both stable and unstable changes in DNA

From 6 clones of Chinese hamster cells varying in the rate of the loss of transformant phenotype and containing a thymidine kinase gene (tk-gene) of Herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV1), 25 subclones negative in thymidine kinase (TK-) were isolated on a medium with 50 micrograms/ml 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU). A study was made of the frequency of spontaneous reversions to the TK+ phenotype in cell populations of BrdU-resistant subclones, and of the transforming activity (upon transformation of TK- cells of A238 clone to the TK+ phenotype) of DNA preparations from a row BrdU-resistant subclones. In 7 of 11 BrdU-resistant subclones the TK- phenotype is associated with changes reducing significantly the transforming activity of DNA. Some of these alterations are stable and undergo no spontaneous reversion, while the other ones are unstable, being reversed or suppressed at a high frequency. BrdU-resistant subclones produced from clones more stable in transformant phenotype are on the whole more stable in the TK- phenotype than BrdU-resistant subclones from the clones with the high rate of the loss of the TK+ phenotype.     

Genetic transformation of somatic cells. V. Inheritability of the rate of loss of the trait and the stabilization of the transformant phenotype

Subclones were isolated both on selective and nonselective medium from the Chinese hamster cells transformed by thymidine kinase gene (TK-gene) of Herpes simplex virus (HSV-1) and varying in the rate of the loss of transformant phenotype. The study of the stability of thymidine kinase-positive (TK+) phenotype in cell populations the subclones shows that the nonstability and the rate of the loss of transformant phenotype are the characters that are inherited in the cell generations. Durable cultivation on a HAT-selective medium may lead to a complete or partial (expressed as a reduced rate of the loss of the character) stabilization of TK+-phenotype of the cells of transformant clones. The rate of stabilization of TK+-phenotype may differ depending on the structure of transforming DNA introduced into cells of transformant clones.     

人体胸苷激酶(TK)基因在共转染过程中结构改变的研究

用磷酸钙沉淀法,我们把带有人体TK基因片段的重组噬菌体DNA共转染小鼠Ltk~-细胞,得到TK~+转化细胞克隆。同时用HeLa细胞DNA转染Ltk~-细胞,得到第一代TK~+转化细胞,再进行第二轮、第三轮转染,得到第二代、第三代TK~+转化细胞。比较其转化效率,结果基因组DNA转化率大于基因两个片段的共转化率,更大于不加携带者DNA的共转化率。限制性内切酶消化各种TK~+转化细胞的DNA,与TK基因探针作Southern印迹杂交,结果表明两个TK基因片段共转染Ltk~-细胞时,它们可以在受体细胞里重建成一个具有完整功能的遗传单位,但在连接过程中结构可以发生改变。当用HeLa纽胞DNA转染Ltk~-细胞时,虽然连续三代转染,每一代TK~+转化细胞中人TK基因的结构未发现变化。但也不能排除基因结构改变的频率很低未能有效检出的可能性。     

Genetic transformation of somatic cells. IV. The rate of loss of transformant phenotype depends on the structure of the transforming DNA and changes when the cells are treated with the tumor promotor 12-o-tetradecanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate

Analysis was made of the phenotype stability of some clones of thymidine kinase deficient (TK-) Chinese hamster cells transformed by thymidine kinase gene (TK-gene) of Herpes simplex virus type (HSV 1). The presence of a fragment of human satellite DNA III in the plasmid DNA carrying the TK-gene of HSV 1 reduced notably the rate of the loss of TK+-phenotype, and the treatment of the cells with a tumour promoter--12-o-tetradecanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate--immediately after transformation destabilizes TK+-phenotype of transformant clones. Removal of the eukaryotic carrier DNA for the plasmid DNA without the TK-gene of HSV 1 destabilizes the clone transformant phenotype. Changes in the structure of the plasmid DNA containing no TK-gene of HSV 1 and introduced into cells simultaneously with TK-gene containing plasmids affects the rate of the loss of TK+-phenotype transformed cells.     

DNA-mediated gene transfer without carrier DNA

DNA-mediated gene transfer is a procedure which uses purified DNA to introduce new genetic elements into cells in culture. The standard DNA-mediated gene transfer procedure involves the use of whole cell DNA as carrier DNA for the transfer. We have modified the standard DNA-mediated gene transfer procedure to transfer the Herpes simplex virus type 1 thymidine kinase gene (TK) into TK- murine recipient cells in the absence of whole cell carrier DNA. The majority (8/10) of carrier-free transformant lines expressed the TK+ phenotype stably, in sharp contrast to our results with carrier-containing DNA-mediated gene transfer. There was a wide range in donor DNA content among independent transformants. Further analysis on one transformant line using DNA restriction digests and in situ hybridization provided evidence that, in the absence of whole cell carrier DNA, multiple donor DNA sequences became integrated at a single chromosomal site.     

Evidence for allelic exclusion in Chinese hamster ovary cells.

Earlier results suggested that the functional hemizygosity of genes in pseudodiploid Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells is due to the silencing of one allele by DNA methylation. From this one could make a strong prediction that we have now been able to confirm by genetic experiments, using thymidine kinase (TK) alleles. TK- mutants induced by ethylmethane sulphonate (EMS) were all revertible to TK+ at high frequency by the demethylating agent 5-azacytidine (5-aza-CR). This revertibility was due to reactivation of a silent nonmutant TK allele. Further mutagenesis by EMS yielded TK- derivatives that were no longer revertible by 5-aza-CR; these are assumed to have mutations in both alleles. TK- cells were also transfected with equine herpes virus TK+ DNA, and the TK+ derivatives were shown to be markedly less stable than cells with the normal TK+ gene. CHO cells lack metallothionein activity (sensitive to cadmium), and also require proline for growth, because genes have become silenced during the establishment of the cell line. In both cases 5-aza-CR reactivates these genes to give the cadmium resistant and proline independent phenotypes. Long-term experiments with reactivants in the absence of selection showed that the genes become silent, presumably as a result of de novo methylation. A strain resistant to cytosine arabinoside (araCR) was also resistant to 5-azadeoxycytidine (5-aza-CdR), but not to 5-aza-CR, which would be expected if the araCR strain lacked deoxycytidine kinase.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Characterization of pyrimidine deoxyribonucleoside kinase (thymidine kinase) and thymidylate kinase as a multifunctional enzyme in cells transformed by herpes simplex virus type 1 and in cells infected with mutant strains of herpes simplex virus.

Pyrimidine deoxyribonucleoside kinase (thymidine kinase [TK]) was purified from two herpes simplex virus type 1 (HVS-1)-transformed TK-deficient mouse (LMTK-) cell lines and from LMTK- cells infected with HSV-1 mutant viruses coding for variant TK enzymes. These preparations exhibited normal or variant virus-induced thymidylate kinase activities correlating with their relative TK activities. Neither virus-induced activity was detected in LMTK- cells infected with an HSV-1 TK-deficient mutant. These results suggest that HSV-1 thymidylate kinase activity and TK activity are mediated by the same protein.     

Genetic transformation of somatic cells. VI. Transfer of the trait of the rate of loss of transformant phenotype by means of DNA from cells containing the thymidine kinase gene of the herpes simplex virus

Using dot-hybridization with thymidine kinase gene (tk gene) of Herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV 1) of DNA preparations obtained from isolated metaphase chromosomes and lysate fractions of metaphase cells, which presumably contain smaller particles compared to metaphase chromosomes, it has been shown that the tk gene of HSV 1 is localized in chromosomes of cells of transformant clones unstable in TK+-phenotype. The DNA isolated from the metaphase chromosomes from cells of transformant clones is 1.5- or 2-fold more efficient in transforming TK-Chinese hamster cells than is the total high molecular weight DNA from the same cells. Upon transformation of TK- cells by the high molecular weight DNA from the tk gene of HSV 1-containing clones, varying in the rate of the loss of TK+-phenotypes, the character "rate of the loss of transformant phenotype" is transferred together with the tk gene of HSV 1 in 22% of cases. Cells of rerevertant clones, produced from TK- subclones of transformant clones, display the rate of the loss of transformant phenotype characteristic of cells of parental TK+-clones. A comparison of the results allows a conclusion that DNA sequences, determining the character "rate of the loss of transformant phenotype", are linked tightly with the transforming DNA proper containing the tk gene of HSV 1, but are not localized inside such a DNA.     

Stability of the transformants obtained by phage particle-mediated gene transfer

Recombinant lambda phage DNA, encapsulated in phage particles and coprecipitated with calcium phosphate, efficiently transforms cultured mammalian cells without a requirement for carrier DNA. The present paper analyzes the stability of the transformants obtained by the phage transfer method. lambda phage particles containing recombinant DNA that includes the thymidine kinase (TK) gene of herpes simplex virus type 1 as a selective marker were introduced into Ltk- cells deficient in TK activity, and TK+ transformants were selected in HAT medium. To test the stability of the TK+ phenotype of the transformants, seven individual transformant clones were isolated, cultured in HAT selective medium and then in non-selective medium for various lengths of time. After such culture, transformants were allowed to develop colonies in both selective and non-selective medium. For all seven transformant clones, the numbers of colonies obtained in the two types of medium were almost identical, irrespective of whether or not each transformant clone had been previously cultured for 15 to 50 days in non-selective medium. This result suggests that most transformants obtained by the phage transfer method maintain the TK+ phenotype stably, for at least 50 days, when grown in non-selective medium.