Study of differential collagen synthesis during development of the chick embryo by immunofluorescence: II. Localization of type I and type II collagen during long bone development

The transition of type I and type II collagens during cartilage and bone development in the chick embryo was studied by immunofluorescence using antibodies against type I or type II collagens. Type II collagen was found in all cartilaginous structures which showed metachromatic staining. Type I collagen appeared in the perichondrium of the tibia at stage 28 and was also found in osteoid, periosteal and enchondral bone after decalcification, periosteum, and tendons, ligaments, and capsules.Using the immunohistological method it was possible to identify specific collagen types in areas undergoing rapid proliferation and collagen transition, such as diaphyseal and epiphyseal perichondrium, or in enchondral osteogenesis. During enchondral ossification type I collagen is deposited onto the eroded surface of cartilage. It partially diffuses into the cartilage matrix forming a “hybrid” collagen matrix with type II collagen, which is a site for subsequent ossification. During appositional growth of diaphyseal cartilage and differentiation of epiphyseal perichondrium into articular cartilage, perichondral cells switch from type I to type II collagen synthesis when differentiating into chondroblasts. In the transition zones, chondroblasts are imbedded in a “hybrid” matrix consisting of a mixture of type I and type II collagens.     

Immunolocalization of type X collagen before and after mineralization of human thyroid cartilage

In this study the distribution of type X collagen in thyroid cartilages of various ages is described. Fetal and juvenile thyroid cartilage was negative for type X collagen, but showed a strong staining reaction for type II collagen. Type X collagen and calcium deposition were first detected in thyroid cartilage of 18-to 21-year-old adults. Type X collagen was restricted to large chondrocytes near or in mineralized cartilage, confirming the notion that type X collagen precedes mineralization. From these observations it was concluded that chondrocytes in thyroid cartilage undergo differentiation steps that are similar, but much slower, compared to cells in growth plate and sternal cartilage. Some type X collagen-positive areas also showed staining for type I collagen, suggesting that there is a further differentiation of chondrocytes to cells which are characterized by the simultaneous synthesis of type X and I collagen. However, a dedifferentiation process during aging of thyroid cartilage where cells switch from synthesis of type II to type I collagen cannot be excluded.     

Quantitative analysis of type X-collagen biosynthesis by embryonic-chick sternal cartilage.

We have performed a quantitative analysis of the various collagens biosynthesized by organ cultures of whole embryonic-chick sternum and its separate anatomical regions corresponding to the zones of permanent hyaline and presumptive-calcification cartilages. Our studies demonstrated that embryonic-chick sternum devotes a large portion of its biosynthetic commitment towards production of Type X collagen, which represented approx. 18% of the total newly synthesized collagen. Comparison of the collagens biosynthesized by the permanent hyaline cartilage and by the cartilage from the presumptive-calcification zone demonstrated that Type X-collagen production was strictly confined to the presumptive-calcification region. Sequential extraction of the newly synthesized Type X collagen demonstrated the existence of two separate populations. One population (approx. 20%) was composed of easily extractable molecules that were solubilized with 1.0 m-NaCl/50 mM-Tris/HCI buffer, pH 7.4. The second population was composed of molecules that were not extractable even after repeated pepsin digestion, but became completely solubilized after treatment with 20 mM-dithiothreitol/0.15 M-NaCl buffer at neutral pH. These results suggest that most of the Type X collagen normally exists in the tissue as part of a pepsin-resistant molecular aggregate that may be stabilized by disulphide bonds. Quantitative analysis of the proportion of Type X collagen relative to the other collagens synthesized in the cultures indicated that this collagen was a major biosynthetic product of the presumptive-calcification cartilage, since it represented about 35% of the total collagen synthesized by this tissue. In contrast, the permanent hyaline cartilage did not display any detectable synthesis of Type X collagen. When compared on a per-cell basis, the chondrocytes from the presumptive-calcification zone synthesized approx. 33% more Type X collagen than the amount of Type II collagen synthesized by the chondrocytes from the permanent-hyaline-cartilage zone. Subsequently, it was demonstrated that Type X collagen is a structural component of chick sternum matrix, since quantitative amounts could be extracted from the region of presumptive calcification of 17-day-old chick-embryo sterna and from the calcified portion of adult-chick sterna. The strict topographic distribution in the expression of Type X collagen biosynthesis to the zone of presumptive calcification suggests that this collagen may play an important role in initiation or progression of tissue calcification.     

Coordinate regulation of type IX and type II collagen synthesis during growth of chick chondrocytes in retinoic acid or 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine

Chondrocytes isolated from 15-day-old embryonic chick sterna were cultured as monolayers for 7 days in control medium or in medium supplemented with retinoic acid or 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine. Control cells exhibited characteristic polygonal morphology and maintained the synthesis of cartilage-specific collagens, i.e. type II, type IX, 1 alpha, 2 alpha, and 3 alpha chains, and 45 K (presumptive type X). Type IX was the second most prevalent collagen and represented 12-15% of the phenotype. When exposed to retinoic acid, chrondrocytes displayed a fibroblast-like morphology and decreased collagen synthesis by day 2. The synthesis of collagen types II and IX declined in parallel along with that of the other cartilage collagens and ceased by day 7. During the same period, the synthesis of collagen types I, III, and V and two unidentified collagen chains was initiated and stimulated. Similar changes in collagen expression were caused by 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine but were delayed, beginning after day 4. Type III collagen, however, was never detected in 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine or control cultures. Because two different agents and two rates of modulation produced parallel changes in the synthesis of collagen types II and IX, these collagens appear to be coordinately regulated.     

Comparative analysis of collagens solubilized from human foetal, and normal and osteoarthritic adult articular cartilage, with emphasis on type VI collagen

The different collagen types were extracted sequentially, by 4 M guanidinium chloride and pepsin, from human foetal and normal and osteoarthritic adult articular cartilage. They were characterized by electrophoresis and immunoblotting. Most of the collagenous proteins present in articular cartilage from young human foetuses were solubilized: almost 40% of the total collagen was extracted in the native form with 4 M guanidinium chloride. Type VI collagen was detected in this fraction as high-molecular-mass chains (185-220 kDa) and a low-molecular-mass chain (140 kDa). Type II, IX and XI collagens were also present, but were extracted more extensively by pepsin digestion. Comparative analysis of normal and osteoarthritic cartilage from adults reveals some major differences: an increase in the solubility of the collagen and modifications of soluble collagen types in osteoarthritic cartilage. Furthermore, type VI collagen was present at a higher concentration in guanidinium chloride extracts of osteoarthritic cartilage than those of normal tissue. This finding was corroborated by electron microscopic observations of the same samples: abundant (100 nm) periodic fibrils were observed in the disorganized pericellular capsule of cloned cells in osteoarthritic cartilage. In normal tissues the pericellular zone was more compact and contained only a few such banded fibrils. The differences in the collagen types solubilized from normal and osteoarthritic cartilage, although corresponding to a minor proportion of the total collagen, demonstrate that important modifications in chondrocyte metabolism and in the collagenous network do occur in degenerated cartilage.     

Interaction between proteoglycan subunit and type II collagen from bovine nasal cartilage, and the preferential binding of proteoglycan subunit to type I collagen.

We studied the interaction of proteoglycan subunit with both types I and II collagen. All three molecular species were isolated from the ox. Type II collagen, prepared from papain-digested bovine nasal cartilage, was characterized by gel electrophoresis, amino acid analysis and CM-cellulose chromatography. By comparison of type I collagen, prepared from papain-digested calf skin, with native calf skin acid-soluble tropocollagen, we concluded that the papain treatment left the collagen molecules intact. Interactions were carried out at 4 degrees C in 0.06 M-sodium acetate, pH 4.8, and the results were studied by two slightly different methods involving CM-cellulose chromatography and polyacrylamide-gel electrophoresis. It was demonstrated that proteoglycan subunit, from bovine nasal cartilage, bound to cartilage collagen. Competitive-interaction experiments showed that, in the presence of equal amounts of calf skin acid-soluble tropocollagen (type I) and bovine nasal cartilage collagen (type II), proteoglycan subunit bound preferentially to the type I collagen. We suggest from these results that, although not measured under physiological conditions, it is unlikely that the binding in vivo between type II collagen and proteoglycan is appreciably stronger than that between type I collagen and proteoglycan.     

Study of differential collagen synthesis during development of the chick embryo by immunofluorescence. I. Preparation of collagen type I and type II specific antibodies and their application to early stages of the chick embryo.

The aim of this work was to prepare specific antibodies against skin and bone collagen (type I) and cartilage collagen (type II) for the study of differential collagen synthesis during development of the chick embryo by immunofluorescence. Antibodies against native type I collagen from chick cranial bone, and native pepsin-extracted type II collagen from chick sternal cartilage were raised in rabbits, rats, and guinea pigs. The antibodies, purified by cross-absorption on the heterologous collagen type, followed by absorption and elution from the homologous collagen type, were specific according to passive hemagglutination tests and indirect immunofluorescence staining of chick bone and cartilage tissues. Antibodies specific to type I collagen labeled bone trabeculae from tibia and perichondrium from sternal cartilage. Antibodies specific to type II collagen stained chondrocytes of sternal and epiphyseal cartilage, whereas fluorescence with intercellular cartilage collagen was obtained only after treatment with hyaluronidase. Applying type II collagen antibodies to sections of chick embryos, the earliest cartilage collagen found was in the notochord, at stage 15, followed by vertebral collagen secreted by sclerotome cells adjacent to the notochord from stage 25 onwards. Type I collagen was found in the dermatomal myotomal plate and presumptive dermis at stage 17, in limb mesenchyme at stage 24, and in the perichondrium of tibiae at stage 31.     

Analysis of type II collagen RNA localization in chick wing buds by in situ hybridization

Type II collagen is a major component of cartilage extracellular matrix. Differentiation of mesenchyme into cartilage involves the cessation of type I collagen synthesis and the onset of type II collagen synthesis. Solution hybridization of mRNA isolated from chick limb buds with a cDNA probe to type II collagen mRNA showed the presence of small amounts of type II collagen message in mesenchymal chick limbs. We have examined the localization of type II collagen mRNA in mesenchymal chick wing buds by in situ hybridization using single stranded RNA probes. Our results show a small but detectable amount of type II collagen RNA distributed uniformly in early limbs until the first precartilage condensations form at stage 22. This is interesting because it is known that mesenchyme isolated from chick wing buds has the capacity to undergo chondrogenesis in culture, even if taken from nonchondrogenic areas of the limb. At stage 23, type II collagen mRNA is found at significantly increased levels in the cells of the precartilage condensation when compared to the other limb cells. As chondrogenesis proceeds, the amount of type II collagen RNA increases even more in cells of the cartilage elements. The signal in the peripheral tissue is indistinguishable from background. These results show that type II collagen message exists at low levels in cells throughout the mesenchymal chick wing bud, until the formation of the condensation results in an elevation of type II mRNA in the prechondrogenic cells found in the core of the limb.     

Type II achondrogenesis-hypochondrogenesis: identification of abnormal type II collagen.

We have extended the study of a mild case of type II achondrogenesis-hypochondrogenesis to include biochemical analyses of cartilage, bone, and the collagens produced by dermal fibroblasts. Type I collagen extracted from bone and types I and III collagen produced by dermal fibroblasts were normal, as was the hexosamine ratio of cartilage proteoglycans. Hyaline cartilage, however, contained approximately equal amounts of types I and II collagen and decreased amounts of type XI collagen. Unlike the normal SDS-PAGE mobility. Two-dimensional SDS-PAGE revealed extensive overmodification of all type II cyanogen bromide peptides in a pattern consistent with heterozygosity for an abnormal pro alpha 1(II) chain which impaired the assembly and/or folding of type II collagen. This interpretation implies that dominant mutations of the COL2A1 gene may cause type II achondrogenesis-hypochondrogenesis. More generally, emerging data implicating defects of type II collagen in the type II achondrogenesis-hypochondrogenesis-spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia congenita spectrum and in the Kniest-Stickler syndrome spectrum suggest that diverse mutations of this gene may be associated with widely differing phenotypic outcome.     

Collagen synthesis by regenerating rabbit ear tissue

The principal collagen types synthesized during two distinct phases of regeneration in rabbit ears have been investigated, in order to relate altered phenotypic expression in connective tissue cells to regeneration of cartilage. To do this, radioactively labeled collagens synthesized in short-term culture by selected regenerating ear tissues were analyzed by ion-exchange chromatography and SDS-gel electrophoresis of the intact collagens and of the cyanogen bromide peptides derived from them. Prior to the appearance of cartilage, rabbit ear holes are filled by an outgrowth of mesenchyme-like cells derived locally from adjacent tissues. These cells produce a mixture of collagens including type I, [α1(I)]₂α2, and the type I trimer, [α1(I)]₃, but not type II collagen. Trimer production represents about one-fourth of the collagen synthesized in either a 4-, 10-, or a 24-hr incubation. Trimer is not made by tissues from healing skin wounds nor is it present in normal, uninjured ear tissues. Type II collagen synthesis was detected in tissues taken from late regenerates containing histologically recognizable cartilage, and direct analysis of regenerated cartilage confirmed the presence of type II collagen in the matrix. Thus, regenerated cartilage in the rabbit ear system contains the normal cartilage collagen, type II, while the proliferating cell mass from which the cartilage develops synthesizes the unusual collagen, [α1(I)]₃.     

Involvement of HMGB1 and HMGB2 proteins in exogenous DNA integration reaction into the genome of HeLa S3 cells

Electrophoretic and Western blot studies were conducted on collagen fractions extracted from Sepia officinalis (cuttlefish) cartilage using a modified salt precipitation method developed for the isolation of vertebrate collagens. The antibodies used had been raised in rabbit against the following types of collagen: Sepia I-like; fish I; human I; chicken I, II, and IX; rat V; and calf IX and XI. The main finding was that various types of collagen are present in Sepia cartilage, as they are in vertebrate hyaline cartilage. However, the main component of Sepia cartilage is a heterochain collagen similar to vertebrate type I, and this is associated with minor forms similar to type V/XI and type IX. The cephalopod type I-like heterochain collagen can be considered a first step toward the evolutionary development of a collagen analogous to the typical collagen of vertebrate cartilage (type II homochain). The type V/XI collagen present in molluscs, and indeed all phyla from the Porifera upwards, may represent an ancestral collagen molecule conserved relatively unchanged throughout evolution. Type IX-like collagen seems to be essential for the formation of cartilaginous tissue.     

Type X collagen alterations in rachitic chick epiphyseal growth cartilage

We examined collagens of both normal and vitamin D-deficient chick epiphyseal growth cartilage. Special emphasis was placed on the study of Type X collagen, a recently described product of hypertrophic chondrocytes. Scanning electron microscopy of the epiphyseal growth cartilage of vitamin D-deficient chickens showed an enlarged growth cartilage with a disorganized extracellular matrix. The cartilage collagens were solubilized by proteolytic digestion and disulfide bond reduction of both normal and rachitic growth tissues. Sequential extraction with neutral salt and acetic acid buffers followed by pepsin digestion at 4 degrees C solubilized about 12% of normal tissues and about 7% of collagen from rachitic growth cartilage. Treatment of the pepsin-resistant collagens with neutral salt-dithiothreitol buffer under nondenaturing conditions and a subsequent pepsin digestion increased the yield of solubilized collagen to greater than 95% of the total tissue collagen. Results of the biochemical studies showed a marked increase in the relative proportion of Type X collagen (from 5.6 to 27.9%), a corresponding decrease in the proportions of Types II and IX collagens, and a moderate increase in Type XI collagen in rachitic cartilage. Amino acid analysis indicated that there were no differences in the Types II and X collagens of normal and rachitic cartilage. However, an abnormality in the relative proportions of the CNBr peptides of Type X collagen was detected in the rachitic cartilage. We suggest that the increase in collagen in the rachitic state may reflect increased levels of Type X collagen synthesis by cells in the hypertrophic region. It is likely that in rickets the overproduction of Type X collagen may be a compensatory mechanism by which the hypertrophic chondrocyte attempts to provide a maximum area of calcifiable matrix for the calcium-depleted serum.     

Changes in type of collagen synthesized by chick fibroblasts in vitro in the presence of 5-bromodeoxyuridine.

Chick embryo fibroblasts cease to synthesize their normal collagen product when grown in the presence of the thymidine analogue, 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU). The drug causes an alteration of synthesis from the normal Type I collagen (alpha1 (I)2alpha2) to a mixture of Type I and Type I trimer (alpha1(I)3). While the significance of the synthesis of Type I trimer is unclear, it has been noted that chondrocytes synthesize this collagen type following in vitro senescence and in the presence of BrdU. Since BrdU may cause a switching in the temporal pattern of collagen biosynthesis in chondrocytes and in fibroblasts it is proposed that BrdU may alter the normal regulatory controls acquired by the cells during the course of their differentiation. The synthesis of type I trimer might provide a marker for such a break-down in a wide variety of cell types.     

Immunochemical and mechanical characterization of cartilage subtypes in rabbit.

Cartilage is categorized into three general subgroups, hyaline, elastic, and fibrocartilage, based primarily on morphologic criteria and secondarily on collagen (Types I and II) and elastin content. To more precisely define the different cartilage subtypes, rabbit cartilage isolated from joint, nose, auricle, epiglottis, and meniscus was characterized by immunohistochemical (IHC) localization of elastin and of collagen Types I, II, V, VI, and X, by biochemical analysis of total glycosaminoglycan (GAG) content, and by biomechanical indentation assay. Toluidine blue staining and safranin-O staining were used for morphological assessment of the cartilage subtypes. IHC staining of the cartilage samples showed a characteristic pattern of staining for the collagen antibodies that varied in both location and intensity. Auricular cartilage is discriminated from other subtypes by interterritorial elastin staining and no staining for Type VI collagen. Epiglottal cartilage is characterized by positive elastin staining and intense staining for Type VI collagen. The unique pattern for nasal cartilage is intense staining for Type V collagen and collagen X, whereas articular cartilage is negative for elastin (interterritorially) and only weakly positive for collagen Types V and VI. Meniscal cartilage shows the greatest intensity of staining for Type I collagen, weak staining for collagens V and VI, and no staining with antibody to collagen Type X. Matching cartilage samples were categorized by total GAG content, which showed increasing total GAG content from elastic cartilage (auricle, epiglottis) to fibrocartilage (meniscus) to hyaline cartilage (nose, knee joint). Analysis of aggregate modulus showed nasal and auricular cartilage to have the greatest stiffness, epiglottal and meniscal tissue the lowest, and articular cartilage intermediate. This study illustrates the differences and identifies unique characteristics of the different cartilage subtypes in rabbits. The results provide a baseline of data for generating and evaluating engineered repair cartilage tissue synthesized in vitro or for post-implantation analysis.     

Electrophoretic and immunochemical study of collagens from Sepia officinalis cartilage

Electrophoretic and Western blot studies were conducted on collagen fractions extracted from Sepia officinalis (cuttlefish) cartilage using a modified salt precipitation method developed for the isolation of vertebrate collagens. The antibodies used had been raised in rabbit against the following types of collagen: Sepia I-like; fish I; human I; chicken I, II, and IX; rat V; and calf IX and XI. The main finding was that various types of collagen are present in Sepia cartilage, as they are in vertebrate hyaline cartilage. However, the main component of Sepia cartilage is a heterochain collagen similar to vertebrate type I, and this is associated with minor forms similar to type V/XI and type IX. The cephalopod type I-like heterochain collagen can be considered a first step toward the evolutionary development of a collagen analogous to the typical collagen of vertebrate cartilage (type II homochain). The type V/XI collagen present in molluscs, and indeed all phyla from the Porifera upwards, may represent an ancestral collagen molecule conserved relatively unchanged throughout evolution. Type IX-like collagen seems to be essential for the formation of cartilaginous tissue.     

Tissues formed during distraction osteogenesis in the rabbit are determined by the distraction rate: localization of the cells that express the mRNAs and the distribution of types I and II collagens

An experimental model of leg lengthening was used to study the morphology of, the collagenous proteins present, and the collagen genes expressed in the regenerating tissue following 20% lengthening at four different distraction rates. At a distraction rate of 0.3 mm/day (8 weeks distraction), the regenerate consists of intramembranous bone and localized areas of fibrocartilage. At rates of 0.7 (4 weeks) and 1.3 mm/day (2 weeks), the bone that grows from the cut ends of the cortical bone is separated by fibrous tissue and cartilage is present. At 2.7 mm/day (1 week), only fibrous tissue and sparse bone are present. Type I collagen is present in the matrices around the cells expressing its mRNA and similarly, type II collagen is located around the chondrocytes. Type I collagen mRNA is expressed predominantly by the fibroblasts in the fibrous tissue, the bone surface cells and to a reduced extent by the osteocytes. Type II collagen mRNA is expressed by chondrocytes. The results suggest that osteoblasts and chondrocytes within the regenerate originate from the same pool of progenitor cells, and the differentiation of these cells and the expression of types I and II collagen genes are altered by different rates of distraction. These observations suggest that the optimal rate of distraction in the model is 0.7 mm/day.     

The distribution of type VI collagen in the developing tissues of the bovine femoral head

Type VI collagen appears central to the maintenance of tissue integrity. In adult articular cartilage, type VI collagen is preferentially localised in the chondron where it may be involved in cell attachment. In actively remodelling developing cartilage, the distribution is less certain. We have used confocal immunohistochemistry and in situ hybridisation to investigate type VI collagen distribution in third trimester bovine proximal femoral epiphyses. In general, type VI collagen immunofluorescence was concentrated in the chondrocyte pericellular matrix, with staining intensity strongest in regions which persist to maturity and weakest in regions that remodel during development. Type VI collagen was also present in cartilage canals. In the growth plate and around the secondary centre of ossification, the intensity of type VI collagen stain rapidly decreased with chondrocyte maturation and was absent at hypertrophy, except where canal branches penetrated the growth plate and stain was retained around the adjacent chondrocytes. In situ hybridisation confirmed the presence of type VI collagen mRNA in cartilage canal mesenchymal cells but the signal was low in chondrocytes, suggesting minimal levels of synthesis and turnover. The results are consistent with a role for type VI collagen in stabilising the extracellular matrix during development.     

Expression of type X collagen mRNA levels in embryonic chick sternum during development

Embryonic chick sternum cartilage exhibits profound spatial and temporal changes in Type X collagen biosynthesis during development. Production of this collagen is confined to the presumptive calcification region and its expression is not acquired until stage 43. To examine the mechanisms responsible for regulation of developmental changes in biosynthetic expression of Type X collagen, we determined the levels of translatable Type X procollagen mRNA employing a cell-free translation system. We found that mRNA capable of directing Type X collagen synthesis was present exclusively in cartilage destined to undergo calcification and that its levels were nearly equivalent at all stages of development. These findings suggest that expression of Type X collagen in embryonic chick sternum is determined at the translational level.