Amino acid replacements of the evolutionarily invariant tryptophan at position 64 in mutant forms of iso-1-cytochrome c from Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Tryptophan located at position 59 in vertebrate cytochromes c and at position 64 in yeast iso-1-cytochrome c is an evolutionarily invariant residue that is believed to be essential to the operation of the cytochrome c molecule. We show that this residue is replaced in at least partially functional iso-1-cytochromes c from cyc1 revertants of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Tryptophan, tyrosine and leucine are found at position 64 in the revertants from the cyc1-84 mutant, confirming the genetic evidence (Sherman et al., 1974) that the mutant contains an UAG nonsense codon and establishing that the site of the mutation corresponds to the normal tryptophan 64. In a revertant from the cyc1.189 mutant, position 64 is occupied by a residue of phenylalanine. All three altered proteins are unstable, implying that tryptophan 64 has an essential and unique role for maintaining the normal structure of the cytochrome c molecule. In addition the iso-1-cytochrome c with leucine 64 and tyrosine 64 have greatly reduced biological activities, while iso-1-cytochrome c with the phenylalanine replacement has at least 20% of the wild-type activity or more. It remains uncertain whether the reduced specific activities are due to distorted tertiary structures or due to the specific lack of the tryptophan residue that may also have a direct functional role.     

Isolation and Characterization of Amber Suppressors in Yeast

Nonsense suppressors were obtained in a haploid yeast strain containing eight nutritional mutations, that are assumed to be amber or ochre, and the cyc1-179 amber mutation that has a UAG codon corresponding to position 9 in iso-1-cytochrome c. Previous studies established that the biosynthesis and function of iso-1-cytochrome c is compatible with replacements at position 9 of amino acids having widely different structures (Stewart and Sherman 1972). UV-induced revertants, selected on media requiring the reversion of one or two of the amber nutritional markers, were presumed to contain a suppressor if there was the unselected reversion of at least one other marker. The 1088 suppressors that were isolated could be divided into 78 phenotypic classes. Only 43 suppressors of three classes caused the production of more than 50% of the normal amount of iso-1-cytochrome c in the cyc1-179 strain. Genetic analyses indicated that all of these highly efficient amber suppressors are allelic to one or another of the eight suppressors which cause the insertion of tyrosine at ochre (UAA) codons (Gilmore, Stewart and Sherman 1971). Furthermore, only tyrosine has been identified at position 9 in iso-1-cytochrome c in cyc1-179 strains suppressed with these efficient amber suppressors.     

Structural gene for yeast iso-2-cytochrome c.

Protein analysis and genetic studies have led to the identification of the structural genes of iso-1-cytochrome c and iso-2-cytochrome c, which constitute, respectively, 95% and 5% of the total amount of cytochrome c in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The structural gene CYC1 for iso-1-cytochrome c was previously identified by Sherman et al. (1966) and the structural gene CYC7 for iso-2-cytochrome c is identified in this investigation. A series of the following mutations were selected by appropriate procedures and shown by genetic tests to be allelic: CYC7+ →CYC7-1 →cyc7-1-1 →CYC7-1-1-A, etc., where CYC7 + denotes the wild-type allele determining iso-2-cytochrome c; CYC7-1 denotes a dominant mutant allele causing an approximately 30-fold increase of iso-2-cytochrome c with a normal sequence, and was used as an aid in selecting deficient mutants; cyc7-1-1 denotes a recessive mutant allele causing complete deficiency of iso-2-cytochrome c; and CYC7-1-1-A denotes an intragenic revertant having an altered iso-2-cytochrome c at the same level as iso-2-cytochrome c in the CYC7-1 strains. The suppression of cyc7-1-1 with the known amber suppressor SUP7-a indicated that the defect in cyc7-1-1 was an amber (UAG) nonsense codon. Sequencing revealed a single amino acid replacement of a tyrosine residue for the normal glutamine residue at position 24 in iso-2-cytochrome c from the suppressed cyc7-1-1 strain and also in five revertants of cyc7-1-1, of which three were due to extragenic suppression and two to intragenic reversion. The nature of the mutation that elevated the level of normal iso-2-cytochrome c in the CYC7-1 strain was not identified, although it occurred at or very near the CYC7 locus but outside the translated portion of the gene and it may be associated with a chromosomal aberration. Genetic studies demonstrated that CYC7 is not linked to CYC1, the structural gene for iso-1-cytochrome c.     

Substitution of serine caused by a recessive lethal suppressor in yeast.

The SUP-RL1 suppressor in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae causes lethality in haploid strains but not in diploid or aneuploid strains that are heterozygous for the suppressor locus. This recessive lethal suppressor acts on amber (UAG) nutritional markers, and can cause the production of approximately 50% of the normal amount of iso-1-cytochrome c in disomic strains that are heterozygous for the SUP-RL1 suppressor, and that contain the cyc1-179 allele which has an amber codon corresponding to amino acid position 9. The suppressed iso-1-cytochrome c contains a residue of serine at the position that corresponds to the site of the amber codon. SUP-RL1 was found to lie between thr4 and MAL2 on chromosome III, approximately 30 map units from the mating-type locus. It is suggested that the gene product of SUP-RL1 may be a species of serine transfer RNA that normally reads the serine codon UCG, and that is represented only once in the haploid genome.     

Specific induction of transitions and transversions of G-C base pairs by 4-nitroquinoline-1-oxide in iso-1-cytochrome c mutants of yeast

The base-pair changes induced by the highly carcinogenic agent, 4-nitroquinoline-1-oxide, have been determined from the reversion rates of defined tester strains and from the amino acid replacements of revertant iso-1-cytochromes c. The mutant codons and the base-pair changes of reverse mutations of 14 cyc1 mutants were previously determined from alterations of iso-1-cytochromes c in intragenic revertants. These 14 cyc1 mutants, which were used as tester strains, included nine mutants with altered AUG initiation codons, an ochre (UAA) mutant, an amber (UAG) mutant and three frameshift mutants (Stewart et al., 1971,1972; Stewart &; Sherman, 1972,1974; Sherman &; Stewart, 1973). NQO² induced a high rate of reversion in the initiation mutant cyc1-131, the only mutant in the group which reverts to normal iso-1-cytochrome c by a G · C → A · T transition. In addition, NQO produces a significant rate of reversion of all cyc1 mutants which revert by G · C transversions, e.g. the amber (UAG) mutant and the initiation mutants containing AGG, and probably CUG mutant codons. It did not revert the ochre mutant which contains no G · C base pairs. Ten NQO-induced revertants of the amber mutant cyc1-179 contained the expected replacements of residues of tyrosine, and ten NQO-induced revertants of each of the cyc1-131 and cyc1-133 initiation mutants all contained the expected normal iso-1-cytochrome c. The structures of these iso-1-cytochromes c and the pattern of reversion of the tester strains indicate that base-pair substitutions arise at G · C base pairs which are the site of NQO attack. Thus NQO induces G · C → A · T transitions, G · C → T · A transversions and possibly G · C → C · G transversions. Because of its mode of action, NQO may be useful in less-defined systems for identifying G · C base pairs in mutant codons.     

Mutants of yeast initiating translation of Iso-1-cytochrome c within a region spanning 37 nucleotides

We used a specially constructed strain, cyc1–345, of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae to isolate revertants that initiated translation of iso-1-cytochrome c at various sites along an extended region of the mRNA. Normal amounts of iso-1-cytochrome c occurred when translation initiated at the abnormal sites corresponding to amino acid positions ?3, ?2, 3 and 5, as well as the normal position ?1; 20% of the normal amounts occurred when translation initiated at the abnormal position 9. These results with cyc1–345 revertants indicate that translation of iso-1-cytochrome c can initiate with the normal efficiency at any site within the region spanning 25 nucleotides. Furthermore, because the lower amount of the short iso-1-cytochrome c in the mutant initiating at position 9 may not necessarily reflect an inefficiency of translation, we believe that translation can initiate with normal or near-normal efficiencies at any site within a 37 nucleotide region, and presumably at any site preceding and following that of the normal initiation codon. These results establish that there is no absolute requirement for a particular sequence 5′ to the initiation codon, and are consistent with our previous suggestion that translation starts at the AUG codon closest to the 5′ end of the mRNA.     

Confirmation of UAG as a nonsense codon in bakers' yeast by amino acid replacements of glutamic acid 71 in iso-1-cytochrome c

The yeast mutant cy1–76 is more than 99% deficient in iso-1-cytochrome c. Twelve intragenic revertants of cy1–76 have approximately normal amounts of iso-1-cytochromes c, which are altered by replacement of glutamic acid 71 with either tryptophan, leucine, tyrosine, serine, glutamine or lysine. It is concluded that position 71 in functioning iso-1-cytochrome c can be radically varied, and that the defect in cy1–76 is a nonsense codon, UAG, corresponding to position 71.Tryptophan is the replacement in 4 of the 12 revertants of cy1–76. Tryptophan is similarly abundant as a replacement of lysine 9 in the previously studied 42 revertants ofcy1–179, but is not a replacement in the 45 previously studied revertants of cyl-9. Since amino acid replacements indicate that either UAA or UAG nonsense mutations occur in all three mutants, these new results confirm the previously recognized distinction between the two nonsense codons: one, evidently UAG, can be reverted to a tryptophan codon, while the other, apparently UAA, cannot; apparently UGA does not encode tryptophan in yeast.     

Tyrosine substitutions resulting from suppression of amber mutants of iso-1-cytochrome c in yeast

The suppressors SUP6-2 and SUP7-2 can cause the production of approxi- mately 25 to 60% of the normal amount of iso-1-cytochrome c when they are coupled to the amber (UAG) mutants cy1–179 and cy1–76. The iso-1-cytochromes c contain residues of tyrosine at the positions which correspond to the sites of the amber codons. SUP6-2 and SUP7-2 do not suppress ochre (UAA) mutants. The SUP6-2 and the SUP7-2 genes are apparently alleles of the SUP6-1 and SUP7-1 genes, respectively, which cause the insertion of tyrosine at ochre (UAA) codons (ochre-specific suppressors). It is suggested that the gene products of the allelic amber suppressors and ochre-specific suppressors (the SUP6-1 and SUP6-2 suppressors and theSUP7-1 andSUP7-2 suppressors) are two differently altered forms of the same tyrosine tRNA.     

Serine insertion caused by the ribosomal suppressor SUP46 in yeast

The ribosomal suppressor SUP46 isolated from the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae suppresses a broad range of mutations, including at least some UAA, UAG and UGA alleles. The SUP46 suppressor causes the insertion of serine into iso-1-cytochrome c at the site of the UAA mutation in the cyc1-72 allele. It is believed that the altered ribosomes in the SUP46 suppressor allow a serine tRNA to misread UAA codons.     

Yeast UAA suppressors effective in psi+ strains: leucine-inserting suppressors.

We have previously reported the isolation and characterization of UAA suppressors from a haploid strain of yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae containing the ψ⁺ non-Mendelian determinant which increases the efficiency of action of certain suppressors (Ono et al., 1979). Most of the suppressors caused the insertion of either tyrosine or serine. In contrast, the pattern of suppression of nutritional markers suggested that the rare suppressor, SUP26, inserted in an amino acid other than tyrosine or serine. In this investigation we report the characterization of additional suppressors, similar to SUP26, that were isolated on a medium lacking uracil and containing canavanine; this medium is expected to exclude serine-inserting suppressors because they do not suppress the ura4-1 marker, and to exclude tyrosine-inserting suppressors because they suppress the can1-100 marker. The total of 155 revertants similar to the SUP26 suppressor were analyzed genetically and these could be assigned to one or another of the six distinct loci SUP26, SUP27, SUP28, SUP29, SUP32 and SUP33. The SUP26, SUP27 and SUP29 loci mapped on chromosomes XII, IV and X, respectively. The detailed map position of the SUP29 suppressor suggests that it may be allelic to the SUP30 suppressor reported by Hawthorne &; Mortimer (1968). These six suppressors had the same pattern of suppression of UAA nutritional markers and all of them had a similar low efficiency of action on the iso-1-cytochrome c mutation cyc1-72. The efficiency of each of these suppressors was increased by a chromosomal allo-suppressor, sal. Each of the six suppressors caused the insertion of leucine in iso-1-cytochrome c at the UAA site of the cyc1-72 mutation. It is suggested that the gene products of these suppressors are redundant forms of the same leucine transfer RNA.     

Yeast mutants defective in iso-2-cytochrome c.

The structural gene CYC7 for yeast iso-2-cytochrome c was previously identified by isolating a mutant, cyc7-1-1, totally lacking iso-2-cytochrome c and demonstrating that revertants of this mutant contained iso-2-cytochrome c with an altered primary structure (Downie et al., 1977). In this paper we describe a variety of different types of mutants that completely or partially lack iso-2-cytochrome c due to mutations in either the structural gene, CYC7, or unlinked “regulatory” genes. The iso-2-cytochrome c-deficient mutants were isolated by benzidine staining of over 3 × 10⁵ colonies from ?^? strains (cytoplasmic petites) that lacked iso-1-cytochrome c due to the deletion cyc1-1 and that contain abnormally high levels of iso-2-cytochrome c due to a chromosomal translocation, CYC7-1, adjacent to the normal structural gene CYC7 +. The cytochrome c content of mutants not staining with the benzidine reagents was estimated by low temperature spectroscopy, and 139 mutants containing significantly decreased levels of iso-2-cytochrome c were analyzed genetically by complementation with previously identified cyc mutants. In this way 50 mutants at the cyc2 and cyc3 loci were identified along with a group of 62 mutants of the structural gene cyc7. The different types of mutants of the structural gene which were uncovered and which were more or less anticipated included those that completely lacked iso-2-cytochrome c, those that were suppressible by UAA or UAG suppressors, those that lacked iso-2-cytochrome c but had increased levels after growth at lower temperatures, and those that exhibited visibly altered c_a absorption bands of iso-2-cytochrome c. Iso-2-cytochrome c mutants with altered primary structures were obtained from intragenic revertants of several of these mutants, confirming our earlier conclusion that cyc7 is the structural gene. In addition we observed an unexpected class of mutants that lacked iso-2-cytochrome c when in the ?^? state but contained approximately the CYC7-1 parental level when in the ?⁺ state. Two of these mutants, cyc7-1-47 and cyc7-1-49, were shown to contain altered iso-2-cytochromes c. The different contents of the abnormal iso-2cytochromes c suggest that cytochrome c has different environments in ?⁺ and ?^? mitochondria and that the ?⁺ condition may stabilize certain altered proteins.     

Transposition of the gene cluster CYC1-OSM1-RAD7 in yeast

A mutant of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae contains an increased amount of iso-1-cytochrome c because two copies of a segment, denoted COR, were transposed to a new position on chromosome VII, while the original COR region was retained at the normal position on chromosome X; this COR segment encompasses the CYC1, OSM1 and RAD7 loci which determine, respectively, iso-1-cytochrome c, osmotic sensitivity and ultraviolet light sensitivity. The analysis of genomic DNA with cloned probes indicates that the length of the COR segment is approximately 12,000 base-pairs. We suggest that certain normal strains of yeast, which possibly may contain reiterated sequences, can produce extended transpositions similar to prokaryotes.     

Demonstration of several independent loci involved in the synthesis of iso-2-cytochrome c in yeast

Summary This study concerns the chromosomal genes controlling the synthesis of cytochrome c in yeast. In the wild type there are two molecular species of cytochrome c : iso-1 (major from) and iso-2 (minor form) which differ in many positions of their amino-acid sequence. A mutation, CY1cy1-1, in the structural gene for iso-1, leads to iso-1 deficiency, while retaining a normal albeit small amount of iso-2-cytochrome c.The cyI-1 mutant does not grow on DL-lactate as sole carbon source, while the wild type does. This property was used for selecting cytochrome c rich revertants (CYT) from cytochrome c deficient strains cy1-1; ca 200 revertants were isolated after extensive nitrous acid mutagenesis from a haploid cy1-1 strain or from a diploid cy1-1/cy1-1 strain and ca 30 of them were analyzed genetically and biochemically. The cytochrome c of seven (CYT) revertants was extracted and characterized; none of them contained iso-1-cytochrome c, but all contained large amount of iso-2-cytochrome csufficient to compensate for the deficiency. It was concluded that none of the revertants resulted from back mutation of cy1-1 and that the cy1-1 mutation is a deletion or some other irreversible aberration. These conclusions were corroborated by genetic analysis. It was shown that every reversion is due to a chromosomal mutation segregating as a single gene. Five unlinked gene loci, CY2A, CY2B, CY2C, CY2D, CY2E, were uncovered in this way. None of them were linked to the CY1 locus. Revertants selected in the diploid strain were dominant or semi-dominant while those selected in the haploid strain were recessive. To the first class belong alleles at loci CY2A, CY2B, CY2C, while to the latter belong alleles at loci CY2D and CY2E.Five unlinked loci are implicated in iso-2-cytochrome c synthesis. Mutations selected at these loci act as suppressors of cytochrome c deficiency caused by a deletion of the CY1 locus. In fact the muations do not restore the synthesis of the deficient protein (iso-1-cytochrome c), but increase the synthesis of an another protein, structurally alike (iso-2-cytochrome c), and having very similar if not identical physiological activity. We propose the term of compensator genes to define this type of mutations. We discuss some possible mechanisms to explain the rarity of compensator mutations and the hypothesis that the locus CY2A could correspond not only to the regulatory gene for iso-2-cytochrome c but also to the structural one.     

Altered absorption spectra of iso-1-cytochromes c from mutants of yeast.

Low temperature (-190 degrees) spectrophotometric recordings were made of mutant strains of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae containing various altered sequences of iso-1-cytochromes c. All mutants with replacements of the tryptophan 64 residue had abnormal Calpha-bands, in which the alpha2-peaks were accentuated to various degrees by being more separated from the major alpha1-peaks and by making up a larger portion of the total Calpha-peak. The altered iso-1-cytochromes c included those having the normal tryptophan 64 replaced by phenylalanine, leucine, tyrosine, cysteine, serine, or glycine as well as those having replacements at position 64 and additional replacements at other sites. Tryptophan 64 in iso-1-cytochrome c, which corresponds to tryptophan 59 in vertebrate cytochromes c, appears to be an important residue for preserving the electronic environment of the heme group. It is uncertain, however, whether altered spectra are due specifically to the abnormal residues at position 64 or due to distorted tertiary structures caused by the replacements.     

Formation of composite iso-cytochromes c by recombination between non-allelic genes of yeast

We present evidence that two non-allelic genes, located on two non-homologous chromosomes in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, recombine and in this process generate new composite genes containing portions of both genes. The two genes CYC1 and CYC7 encode, respectively, iso-1-cytochrome c and iso-2-cytochrome c; CYC1 is located on the right arm of chromosome X and CYC7 is located on the left arm of chromosome V. The coding regions of CYC1 and CYC7 and the corresponding iso-1-cytochrome c and iso-2-cytochrome c are approximately 80% homologous. Composite genes were uncovered among revertants of certain but not all cyc1 mutants lacking iso-1-cytochrome c; composite genes were observed in most revertants from the low-reverting strains cyc1-11, cyc1-136 and cyc1-158, and in low proportions of the revertants from the typically reverting strains cyc1-94 and cyc1-156. Protein analysis of 14 composite iso-cytochromes c and DNA sequencing of five composite genes indicated that recombinational events produced replacements of central portions of the cyc1 gene with a corresponding segment from the wild-type CYC7⁺ gene. The replacements varied in length from 13% to 61% of the translated portion of the CYC1 locus. The formation of composite genes occurred spontaneously at very low frequencies and at low but enhanced frequencies after treatments with mutagens including ultraviolet light, ethylmethane sulfonate, methylmethane sulfonate and nitrous acid. Genetic tests indicated that composite genes are formed mitotically by a conversion-like event in which the wild-type CYC1⁺ allele remains intact. Recombination between non-allelic genes can lead to identical sequences at different loci and to diverse composite genes. These results support the indirect evidence from other eukaryotic systems that non-allelic genes with extensive but not complete homology recombine during evolution.     

Variation of Mutagenic Action on Nonsense Mutants at Different Sites in the Iso-1-Cytochrome c Gene of Yeast

Three ochre and two amber mutants in yeast have been definitively identified by the amino acid replacements in iso-1-cytochromes c from intragenic revertants. Except for rare and sometimes unusual changes, all of the replacements were single amino acids whose codons differed from UAA or UAG by one base. These assignments, which were based on the absence of tryptophan replacements in ochre revertants, could be corroborated from the studies of two groups of suppressors that were shown to act on either the ochre or amber mutants. All five nonsense mutants are located at different sites in the cyc1 gene and all are at sites that can be occupied by amino acids having a wide range of structures. The relative frequencies of the amino acid replacements indicate that identical codons located at different sites may respond differently to a mutagenic agent. Notably glutamine replacements occurred almost exclusively in UV-induced revertants of only one ochre mutant cyc1–9, but not at all or at reduced proportions in the others. Similarly, lysine replacements occurred almost exclusively in the NA-induced revertants of only the ochre mutant cyc1–72, but not at all in the others. These and other results reveal that mutation of A·T base pairs by UV and nitrous acid are dependent upon the location of the codon within the gene as well as the location of the base pair within the codon. From these findings, it appears as if the type of base-pair changes induced by UV and nitrous acid are strongly influenced by adjacent nucleotide sequences.     

Compressing the free energy range of substructure stabilities in iso‐1‐cytochrome c

Evolutionary conservation of substructure architecture between yeast iso-1-cytochrome c and the well-characterized horse cytochrome c is studied with limited proteolysis, the alkaline conformational transition and global unfolding with guanidine-HCl. Mass spectral analysis of limited proteolysis cleavage products for iso-1-cytochrome c show that its least stable substructure is the same as horse cytochrome c. The limited proteolysis data yield a free energy of 3.8 ± 0.4 kcal mol⁻¹ to unfold the least stable substructure compared with 5.05 ± 0.30 kcal mol⁻¹ for global unfolding of iso-1-cytochrome c. Thus, substructure stabilities of iso-1-cytochrome c span only ∼1.2 kcal mol⁻¹ compared with ∼8 kcal mol⁻¹ for horse cytochrome c. Consistent with the less cooperative folding thus expected for the horse protein, the guanidine-HCl m-values are ∼3 kcal mol⁻¹M⁻¹ versus ∼4.5 kcal mol⁻¹M⁻¹ for horse versus yeast cytochrome c. The tight free energy spacing of the yeast cytochrome c substructures suggests that its folding has more branch points than for horse cytochrome c. Studies on a variant of iso-1-cytochrome c with an H26N mutation indicate that the least and most stable substructures unfold sequentially and the two least stable substructures unfold independently as for horse cytochrome c. Thus, important aspects of the substructure architecture of horse cytochrome c, albeit compressed energetically, are preserved evolutionally in yeast iso-1-cytochrome c.     

Enhanced stability in vivo of a thermodynamically stable mutant form of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c

Previous work has established that the N57I amino acid replacement in iso-1-cytochrome c from the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae causes an unprecedented increase in thermodynamic stability of the protein in vitro, whereas the N57G replacement diminishes stability. Spectrophotometric measurements of intact cells revealed that the N57I iso-l-cytochrome c is present at higher than normal levels in vivo. Although iso-1-cytochrome c turnover is negligible during aerobic growth, transfer of fully derepressed, aerobically grown cells to anaerobic growth conditions leads to reduction in the levels of all of the cytochromes. Pulsechase experiments carried out under these anaerobic conditions demonstrated that the N57I iso-l-cytochrome c has a longer half-life than the normal protein. This is the first report of enhanced stability in vivo of a mutant form of a protein that has an enhanced thermodynamic stability in vitro. Although the N57I protein concentration is higher than the normal level, reduced growth in lactate medium indicated that the specific activity of this iso-l-cytochrome c in vivo is diminished relative to wild-type. On the other hand, the level of the thermodynamically labile N57G iso-1-cytochrome c was below normal. The in vivo levels of the N57I and N57G iso-l-cytochrome c suggest that proteins in the mitochondrial intermembrane space can be subjected to degradation, and that this degradation may play a role in controlling their normal levels.