共查询到20条相似文献,搜索用时 0 毫秒
2.
PurposeOrganic agriculture (OA) has gained widespread popularity due to its view as a more sustainable method of farming. Yet OA and conventional agriculture (CA) can be found to have similar or varying environmental performance using tools such as life cycle assessment (LCA). However, the current state of LCA does not accurately reflect the effects of OA; thus the aim of the present study was to identify gaps in the inventory stage and suggest improvements. MethodsThis article presents for the first time a critical analysis of the life cycle inventory (LCI) of state-of-the-art organic crop LCIs from current and recommended LCA databases ecoinvent and AGRIBALYSE®. The effects of these limitations on LCA results were analyzed and detailed ways to improve upon them were proposed. Results and discussionThrough this analysis, unrepresentative plant protection product (PPP) manufacturing and organic fertilizer treatment inventories were found to be the main limitations in background processes, due to either the lack of available usage statistics, exclusion from the study, or use of unrepresentative proxies. Many organic crop LCIs used synthetic pesticide or mineral fertilizer proxies, which may indirectly contain OA prohibited chemicals. The effect of using these proxies can contribute between 4–78% to resource and energy-related impact categories. In a foreground analysis, the fertilizer and PPP emission models utilized by ecoinvent and AGRIBALYSE® were not well adapted to organic-authorized inputs and used simplified modeling assumptions. These critical aspects can be transferred to respective LCAs that use this data, potentially yielding unrepresentative results for relevant categories. To improve accuracy and to contribute novel data to the scientific community, new manufacturing LCIs were created for a few of the missing PPPs, as well as recommendations for fertilizer treatment LCIs and more precise emission models for PPPs and fertilizers. ConclusionsThe findings in the present article add much needed transparency regarding the limitations of available OA LCIs, offers guidance on how to make OA LCIs more representative, allow for more accurate comparisons between conventional and OA, and help practitioners to better adapt LCA methodology to OA systems. 相似文献
4.
Life Cycle Assessment is becoming an important tool for guiding environmental design improvements in the automotive industry.
This paper reports the life cycle inventory profiles for two fuel tank systems based on a collaborative effort between the
National Pollution Prevention Center at the University of Michigan, General Motors Research and Development, and the National
Risk Management Research Laboratory of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Two 31 gallon functionally equivalent fuel
tank systems used on a 1996 light duty vehicle were investigated: a multi-layer HDPE tank with a steel shield and PVC coated
steel straps, and a steel tank with a HDPE shield and painted steel straps. Overall, the HDPE fuel tank system is environmentally
preferable to the steel tank system based on the set of inventory results presented in this investigation. The Life Cycle
Inventory analysis indicated lower energy burdens for the HDPE tank system and comparable solid waste burdens for both systems.
The total life cycle energy consumption for the steel and HDPE tank systems were 4.9 GJ and 3.6 GJ per tank, respectively.
The energy consumption and most of the air pollutants inventoried occurred as a consequence of the use phase. The solid wastes
were generated primatily during the material production phase for the steel tank (13 kg) and during the end-of-life management
phase for the HDPE tank (14 kg). This study also highlights data analysis and modeling challenges, including manufacturing
and use phase allocation methods. 相似文献
5.
Purpose Topsoil erosion due to land use has been characterised as one of the most damaging problems from the perspective of soil-resource depletion, changes in soil fertility and net soil productivity and damage to aquatic ecosystems. On-site environmental damage to topsoil by water erosion has begun to be considered in Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) within the context of ecosystem services. However, a framework for modelling soil erosion by water, addressing off-site deposition in surface water systems, to support life cycle inventory (LCI) modelling is still lacking. The objectives of this paper are to conduct an overview of existing methods addressing topsoil erosion issues in LCA and to develop a framework to support LCI modelling of topsoil erosion, transport and deposition in surface water systems, to establish a procedure for assessing the environmental damage from topsoil erosion on water ecosystems. Methods The main features of existing methods addressing topsoil erosion issues in LCA are analysed, particularly with respect to LCI and Life Cycle Impact Assessment methodologies. An overview of nine topsoil erosion models is performed to estimate topsoil erosion by water, soil particle transport through the landscape and its in-stream deposition. The type of erosion evaluated by each of the models, as well as their applicable spatial scale, level of input data requirements and operational complexity issues are considered. The WATEM-SEDEM model is proposed as the most adequate to perform LCI erosion analysis. Results and discussion The definition of land use type, the area of assessment, spatial location and system boundaries are the main elements discussed. Depending on the defined system boundaries and the inherent routing network of the detached soil particles to the water systems, the solving of the multifunctionality of the system assumes particular relevance. Simplifications related to the spatial variability of the input data parameters are recommended. Finally, a sensitivity analysis is recommended to evaluate the effects of the transport capacity coefficient in the LCI results. Conclusions The published LCA methods focus only on the changes of soil properties due to topsoil erosion by water. This study provides a simplified framework to perform an LCI of topsoil erosion by considering off-site deposition of eroded particles in surface water systems. The widespread use of the proposed framework would require the development of LCI erosion databases. The issues of topsoil erosion impact on aquatic biodiversity, including the development of characterisation factors, are now the subject of on-going research. 相似文献
6.
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to enhance the mathematical and physical understanding of practitioners of uncertainty analysis
of life cycle inventory (LCI), on the application of possibility theory. The main questions dealt with are (1) clear definition
of the terms—“necessity–possibility,” “probability,” “belief–plausibility,” and of their mutual relationships; (2) what justifies
the substitution of classical probability for possibility; (3) mutual comparison of, and transformations in both senses between
probability and possibility uncertainty measures; (4) how to construct meaningful input possibility measures from available
probabilistic/statistic information; and (5) comparative analysis of the solutions of the problem of data uncertainty propagation
in LCI, afforded, respectively, by probabilistic Monte Carlo simulation and possibilistic fuzzy interval arithmetic. 相似文献
8.
Reliability of Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) results depends on the availability and quality of Life Cycle Inventory (LCI) data.
In order to provide high-quality LCI data for background systems in LCA and to make it applicable to a wider range of fields,
harmonization strategies for already existing datasets and databases are required. In view of the high significance of LCI
data as a basis of major fields of action within a sustainability strategy, the German Helmholtz Association (HGF), under
the leadership of the Forschungszentrum Karlsruhe (FZK) has taken up this issue in its research programme. In 2002, the FZK
conducted a preliminary study on ‘Quality Assurance and User-oriented Supply of a Life Cycle Inventory Data’ funded by the
Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF). Within the framework of this study, a long-term concept for improving the
scientific fundamentals and practical use of LCI data was developed in association with external experts. The focus is on
establishing a permanent German ‘Network on Life Cycle Inventory Data’ which will serve as the German information and cooperation
platform for all scientific and non-scientific actors in the field of life cycle analysis. This network will integrate expertise
on LCA in Germany, harmonise methodology and data, and use the comprehensive expert panel as an efficient basis for further
scientific development and practical use of LCA. At the same time, this network will serve as a platform for cooperation on
an international level. Current developments address methodological definitions for the initial information infrastructure.
As a novel element, user needs are differentiated in parallel according to the broad application fields of LCI-data from product
declaration to process design. Case studies will be used to define tailored interfaces for the database, since different data
quality levels will be encountered. 相似文献
9.
Goal, Scope and Background A methodological approach for representing agricultural products in terms of life cycle inventory is suggested in this paper.
This approach was developed during the conduction of an LCA study for two perennial crops of important Brazilian exportation
products: green coffee and orange juice, which included tillage cultivation by commercial farms, harvest, as well as product
processing when pertinent.
The published papers on agricultural products LCA usually discuss the final results in terms of LCIA, being not very clear
what methodology or principles were applied on the LCI phase. The aim of this paper is to present a simple methodology that
would be employed by different stakeholders as farmers, environment managers and decision makers for evaluating the environmental
performance of their products.
In recent years, many researchers have tried to make a worldwide effort in order to reach comparable results of LCA studies
developed in different countries. So, the proposed methodology has also the aim of isolating the site-dependency of the results
that are not strictly related to the agricultural production. The time coverage suggested is the period can be considered
as an average for the specific tillage under evaluation, usually two crops, since there is a large variation on the inputs
in every other crop, including the higher and subsequent lower productive periods.
Method The functional unit recommended is 1,000 kg of the specific product, being recommended to distinguish the energy used for
the cultivation from that used by the processing stage. There are several specific considerations to transform the data collected
through the questionnaires in an inventory data set of fertilizers (macro and micro nutrients), correctives, fillers and pesticides
further detailed. Water used for chemicals preparation, in the cleaning and processing stages of the harvested crop is also
considered. Land use refers to the area used land for cultivation divided by the medium life period of the tillage.
The stoichiometric balance is performed based on the elementary composition of the products. An average carbohydrate formula
is established for the products considering the relationship among the carbon, hydrogen and oxygen contents of them. The carbohydrate
formula (output) is balanced with carbon dioxide and water (inputs) according to the basic principles of the photosynthesis
reaction. The differences among the mineral composition of the products and the total content of these elements (N, P, K,
Ca, Mg and micronutrients elements) for all the crop inputs (fertilizers, pesticides, correctives) are allocated as outputs
of the system. The pesticides is counted in two forms: grouped in classes (herbicide, fungicide, acaricide, bactericide and
inseticide) and specified by the chemical name of the active ingredient.
Results and Discussion A simplified inventory useful for different purposes is generated with the principles described in this paper. The exact fate
of each pesticide, fertilizer or corrective or assumptions can be further associated to impact categories as nutriphication,
human health, natural resources depletion, ecological toxicity, etc. In this approach the mass balance was focused in the
grain or fruit growth and not in the plant or tree as a whole, considering basically the elementary composition of the product
and the photosynthesis principle. Despite agricultural LCAs performed in different countries have been published, neither
of them considers the carbon capture by the agricultural products during their growth.
Conclusions This method is based on well accepted universal principles of stoichiometry applied to the grain or fruit growth. Minimum
estimations were introduced in this approach, which produces ‘clean inventories’, with comparable results between different
studies. The generated inventory can be gradually improved as the understanding about each emission fate is known, producing
a valid methodology for actual and future knowledge about the fate of tillage emissions. The inventory results of this method
can be employed by different stakeholders as farmers, environment managers, decision makers and traders, with valuable environmental
parameters for evaluating the environmental performance of their products and also for introducing improvements on their systems,
without however to exhibit any particular data. 相似文献
10.
PurposeIn the near future, the products of Thai industries and companies mainly producing parts and products for export to the European Union (EU) will require the Product Environmental Footprint (PEF) to assess the environmental performance and resource efficiency of products by using a life cycle perspective. The potential generic (often used interchangeably with background data) data have to be modified and improved for mandatory use in the product-specific and country-specific PEF database.MethodsPEF is used as a tool for assessing the environmental burden of products and services for export to the EU. It requires both specific data from primary sources and generic data to fulfill assessment requirement. Accordingly, the Thai national life cycle inventory (LCI) database plays a key role in generic data that was used to evaluate the environmental performance of products. This paper presents the perspective of Thai data readiness for PEF in which the quality of LCI is the main issue of concern. The current situation of the Thai national LCI database was reviewed. Then, the gaps of data were addressed, and the gaps were also filled. Non-representative data and untreated waste are the selected issues that were presented in this paper.Results and discussionMany gaps were revealed for the Thai national LCI database because this database was developed based on ISO 14040/44, which may not be compliant with the PEF guide. The issues that have been selected for improvement are non-representative data and untreated waste because these gaps can offer inaccuracy concerning the environmental burden of products potentially leading to the reliability of products for export to the EU. However, the Thai national LCI database has not achieved the data quality aspects of the PEF, continuously improving the quality of data to meet the requirements of the PEF.ConclusionsThe lessons learned from the real-world situation of data quality development based on PEF requirements were extracted. The practical procedure and recommendations were transparent for drivers and researchers who would like to start with data quality issues and prepare for the EU single market. 相似文献
11.
PurposeLife cycle assessment (LCA) software packages have proliferated and evolved as LCA has developed and grown. There are now a multitude of LCA software packages that must be critically evaluated by users. Prior to conducting a comparative LCA study on different concrete materials, it is necessary to examine a variety of software packages for this specific purpose. The paper evaluates five LCA tools in the context of the LCA of seven concrete mix designs (conventional concrete, concrete with fly ash, slag, silica fume or limestone as cement replacement, recycled aggregate concrete, and photocatalytic concrete).MethodsThree key evaluation criteria required to assess the quality of analysis are adequate flexibility, sophistication and complexity of analysis, and usefulness of outputs. The quality of life cycle inventory (LCI) data included in each software package is also assessed for its reliability, completeness, and correlation to the scope of LCA of concrete products in Canada. A questionnaire is developed for evaluating LCA software packages and is applied to five LCA tools.Results and discussionThe result is the selection of a software package for the specific context of LCA of concrete materials in Canada, which will be used to complete a full LCA study. The software package with the highest score is software package C (SP-C), with 44 out of a possible 48 points. Its main advantage is that it allows for the user to have a high level of control over the system being modeled and the calculation methods used.ConclusionsThis comparative study highlights the importance of selecting a software package that is appropriate for a specific research project. The ability to accurately model the chosen functional unit and system boundary is an important selection criterion. This study demonstrates a method to enable a critical and rigorous comparison without excessive and redundant duplication of efforts. 相似文献
12.
Modelling data uncertainty is not common practice in life cycle inventories (LCI), although different techniques are available
for estimating and expressing uncertainties, and for propagating the uncertainties to the final model results. To clarify
and stimulate the use of data uncertainty assessments in common LCI practice, the SETAC working group ‘Data Availability and
Quality’ presents a framework for data uncertainty assessment in LCI. Data uncertainty is divided in two categories: (1) lack
of data, further specified as complete lack of data (data gaps) and a lack of representative data, and (2) data inaccuracy.
Filling data gaps can be done by input-output modelling, using information for similar products or the main ingredients of
a product, and applying the law of mass conservation. Lack of temporal, geographical and further technological correlation
between the data used and needed may be accounted for by applying uncertainty factors to the non-representative data. Stochastic
modelling, which can be performed by Monte Carlo simulation, is a promising technique to deal with data inaccuracy in LCIs. 相似文献
14.
The data quality matrix for product life cycle inventory data proposed in Whdkma & Wlsnaus (J. Cleaner Prod. (1996), 4: 167-174) was subjected to a multi-user test, in which 7 persons scored the same 10 datasets representing 10 different processes. Deviations among scores were listed, and the causes for deviations were determined and grouped into a limited number of well-defined classes. For the majority of the scores, the different test persons arrived at the same score. Deviations occur most often among neighbouring scores. Only a smaller number of the deviations (less than 10% of all scores) affect the overall assessment of the data quality and/or uncertainty of the corresponding dataset. Based on the analysis of the causes of the deviations, improvements to the matrix and its accompanying explanations were suggested and implemented (reported in the appendix to this paper). The average time consumption for the scoring by the different test persons was less than 10 minutes per data set. It is concluded that the time consumption and the number of deviating scores can be kept at an acceptable level for the pedigree matrix to be recommended for internal data quality management and for comprehensive communication of quality assessments of large amounts of data. 相似文献
15.
Background, Goal and Scope The research presented here represents one part of GlaxoSmithKline’s (GSK) efforts to identify and improve the life cycle
impact profile of pharmaceutical products. The main goal of this work was to identify and analyze the cradle-to-gate environmental
impacts in the synthesis of a typical Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient (API). A cradle-to-gate life cycle assessment of a
commercial pharmaceutical product is presented as a case study.
Methods Life cycle inventory data were obtained using a modular gate-to-gate methodology developed in partnership with North Carolina
State University (NCSU) while the impact assessment was performed utilizing GSK’s sustainability metrics methodology.
Results and Discussion Major contributors to the environmental footprint of a typical pharmaceutical product were identified. The results of this
study indicate that solvent use accounts for a majority of the potential cradle-to-gate impacts associated with the manufacture
of the commercial pharmaceutical product under study. If spent solvent is incinerated instead of recovered the life-cycle
profile and impacts are considerably increased.
Conclusions This case study provided GSK with key insights into the life-cycle impacts of pharmaceutical products. It also helped to establish
a well-documented approach to using life cycle within GSK and fostered the development of a practical methodology that is
applicable to strategic decision making, internal business processes and other processes and tools. 相似文献
16.
The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment - Toxicity impacts of chemicals have only been covered to a minor extent in LCA studies of textile products. The two main reasons for this... 相似文献
17.
Background, aim, and scope Life cycle analyses (LCA) approaches require adaptation to reflect the increasing delocalization of production to emerging
countries. This work addresses this challenge by establishing a country-level, spatially explicit life cycle inventory (LCI).
This study comprises three separate dimensions. The first dimension is spatial: processes and emissions are allocated to the
country in which they take place and modeled to take into account local factors. Emerging economies China and India are the
location of production, the consumption occurs in Germany, an Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development country.
The second dimension is the product level: we consider two distinct textile garments, a cotton T-shirt and a polyester jacket,
in order to highlight potential differences in the production and use phases. The third dimension is the inventory composition:
we track CO 2, SO 2, NO
x
, and particulates, four major atmospheric pollutants, as well as energy use. This third dimension enriches the analysis of
the spatial differentiation (first dimension) and distinct products (second dimension).
Materials and methods We describe the textile production and use processes and define a functional unit for a garment. We then model important processes
using a hierarchy of preferential data sources. We place special emphasis on the modeling of the principal local energy processes:
electricity and transport in emerging countries.
Results The spatially explicit inventory is disaggregated by country of location of the emissions and analyzed according to the dimensions
of the study: location, product, and pollutant. The inventory shows striking differences between the two products considered
as well as between the different pollutants considered. For the T-shirt, over 70% of the energy use and CO 2 emissions occur in the consuming country, whereas for the jacket, more than 70% occur in the producing country. This reversal
of proportions is due to differences in the use phase of the garments. For SO 2, in contrast, over two thirds of the emissions occur in the country of production for both T-shirt and jacket. The difference
in emission patterns between CO 2 and SO 2 is due to local electricity processes, justifying our emphasis on local energy infrastructure.
Discussion The complexity of considering differences in location, product, and pollutant is rewarded by a much richer understanding of
a global production–consumption chain. The inclusion of two different products in the LCI highlights the importance of the
definition of a product's functional unit in the analysis and implications of results. Several use-phase scenarios demonstrate
the importance of consumer behavior over equipment efficiency. The spatial emission patterns of the different pollutants allow
us to understand the role of various energy infrastructure elements. The emission patterns furthermore inform the debate on
the Environmental Kuznets Curve, which applies only to pollutants which can be easily filtered and does not take into account
the effects of production displacement. We also discuss the appropriateness and limitations of applying the LCA methodology
in a global context, especially in developing countries.
Conclusions Our spatial LCI method yields important insights in the quantity and pattern of emissions due to different product life cycle
stages, dependent on the local technology, emphasizing the importance of consumer behavior. From a life cycle perspective,
consumer education promoting air-drying and cool washing is more important than efficient appliances.
Recommendations and perspectives Spatial LCI with country-specific data is a promising method, necessary for the challenges of globalized production–consumption
chains. We recommend inventory reporting of final energy forms, such as electricity, and modular LCA databases, which would
allow the easy modification of underlying energy infrastructure.
Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. 相似文献
18.
Background, aims and scope Most life cycle inventory data for crops do not include the ultimate (marginal) land use induced by crop consumption. The
aims of this study were to present, document and discuss a method which can solve this problem and, furthermore, to present
concrete examples for wheat consumption in Brazil, China, Denmark and the USA. A global scope is applied and the simulated
adaptation to increased wheat demand corresponds to a long-term temporal scope under present market conditions with present
technology. 相似文献
19.
Background, Aims and Scope The actual land use consequences of crop consumption are not very well reflected in existing life cycle inventories. The state
of the art is that such inventories typically include data from crop production in the country in which the crop is produced,
and consequently the inventories do not necessarily consider the land ultimately affected in the systems being studied. The
aims of this study are to analyse the mechanisms influencing the long-term land use consequences of changes in crop demand
and to propose a methodological framework for identifying these consequences within a global scope. 相似文献
20.
Purpose Life cycle inventory (LCI) data are region-specific because energy fuel mixtures and methods of production often differ from region to region. LCI database examples include US LCI, Ecoinvent v.2, and NIST, each of which is country-specific. Thus, the main aim of this study is to show that Egypt is in need of an Egyptian National LCI (ENLCI) database and to focus on the means of developing a database specific to Egypt. Methods Arab countries have thus far engaged in virtually no life cycle assessment (LCA) studies, and a significant neglect of this matter is in evidence for the continent of Africa and, in particular, Egypt. Thus, this study suggests an organizational and managerial framework for the development of a national LCI database and sheds light on the required LCI database categories and data quality for practical solutions reflecting who is equipped to do what in order to keep pace with the world. Results The results from this review are useful to standardize the study of the life cycle assessment concept in Egypt; to form a foundation for development of an Egyptian database for facilitating a cleaner environment; to encourage stakeholders, such as the environmental agencies, Egyptian Housing and Building Research Center, and the Ministry of Industry; to propose an organizational framework in which they play a central role; and to provide investment to initiate development. Conclusions The analysis indicates that the development of a LCI database specific to Egypt is difficult because Egypt has various technical and organizational challenges, but a roadmap of actions to be taken to move ahead is provided. The success of this roadmap depends on the capacity for developing the necessary technical and financial support and on strong partnerships with industry, government, LCA professionals, and academia. 相似文献
|