Arabidopsis ATG6 is required to limit the pathogen-associated cell death response

To begin to understand the interplay between autophagy and the hypersensitive response (HR), a type of programmed cell death (PCD) induced during plant innate immunity, we generated ATG6 antisense plants in the genetically tractable Arabidopsis thaliana system. AtATG6 antisense (AtATG6-AS) plants senesce early and are sensitive to nutrient starvation, suggestive of impairment of autophagic function in these plants. Additionally, these plants exhibited multiple developmental abnormalities, a phenomenon not observed in other AtATG mutants. AtATG6-AS plants produced fewer Monodansylcadaverine (MDC) and LysoTracker (LT) stained-autolysosomes in response to carbon and nitrogen starvation indicating that AtATG6 plays a role in the autophagic pathway in Arabidopsis. Interestingly, the level of AtATG6 mRNA in wild type Col-0 Arabidopsis plants is increased during the early phase of virulent and avirulent Pseudomonas syringae pv tomato (Pst) DC3000 infection suggesting that AtATG6 plays an important role during pathogen infection. In AtATG6-AS plants, HR-PCD induced upon infection with avirulent Pst DC3000 carrying the AvrRpm1 effector protein is not able to be contained at the infection site and spreads into uninfected tissue. Additionally, the disease-associated cell death induced by the infection of virulent Pst DC3000 bacteria is also partially misregulated in AtATG6-AS plants. Therefore, the AtATG6 antisense plants characterized here provide an excellent genetic model system to elucidate the molecular mechanisms by which autophagy regulates pathogen-induced cell death.     

Self-consuming innate immunity in Arabidopsis

Programmed cell death (PCD) associated with the pathogen-induced hypersensitive response (HR) is a hallmark of plant innate immunity. HR PCD is triggered upon recognition of pathogen effector molecules by host immune receptors either directly or indirectly via effector modulation of host targets. However, it has been unclear by which molecular mechanisms plants execute PCD during innate immune responses. We recently examined HR PCD in autophagy-deficient Arabidopsis knockout mutants (atg) and find that PCD conditioned by one class of plant innate immune receptors is suppressed in atg mutants. Intriguingly, HR triggered by another class of immune receptors with different genetic requirements is not compromised, indicating that only a specific subset of immune receptors engage the autophagy pathway for HR execution. Thus, our work provides a primary example of autophagic cell death associated with innate immune responses in eukaryotes as well as of pro-death functions for the autophagy pathway in plants.     

EDS1-mediated activation of autophagy regulates <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pst</Emphasis> DC3000 (<Emphasis Type="Italic">AvrRps4</Emphasis>)-induced programmed cell death in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis</Emphasis>

Autophagy is a conserved intracellular process through which cytoplasmic components are degraded and recycled under stress conditions. In the innate immunity of higher plants, autophagy has either pro-survival or pro-death functions in pathogen-induced programmed cell death (PCD). In aged leaves, autophagy negatively regulates PCD by eliminating redundant salicylic acid. However, in young leaves, the specific pro-death mechanisms of autophagy and signaling pathways related to the autophagic process have not been elucidated. Here, we demonstrate that enhanced disease susceptibility 1 (EDS1) mediated the activation of autophagy and played a key role in the pro-death mechanism of autophagy during avirulent Pst DC3000 (AvrRps4) infection. The path through which autophagosomes enter the vacuole was blocked. Additionally, formation of the ATG12–ATG5 complex and the level of enzymatic activity associated with ATG8 cleavage decreased in eds1 mutants. The expression of EDS1 in atg5 mutants was also much lower than that in wild-type plants during pathogen-triggered PCD. These findings implied that EDS1 may regulate autophagy by affecting the activities of the two ubiquitin-like protein-conjugating pathways. Moreover, autophagy may regulate immunity-related PCD by affecting the expression of EDS1 in young plants. Our results provide important insights into the mechanisms of EDS1 in autophagy during infection with avirulent Pst DC3000 (AvrRps4) in Arabidopsis.     

ATG5 is required to limit cell death induced by <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pseudomonas syringae</Emphasis> in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis</Emphasis> and may be mediated by the salicylic acid pathway

Autophagy can be regarded as a protection mechanism to restrict programmed cell death (PCD) induced by pathogen infection during plant innate immunity in the early stages. Autophagy related 5 (ATG5) plays an important role in autophagy in Arabidopsis. We investigated the function of ATG5 in Arabidopsis in the hypersensitive response (HR)-PCD elicited by both virulent and avirulent strains of Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato bacteria DC3000. Results show that ATG5 plays a vital role in limiting HR induced by P. syringae strains and colocalizes with autophagic bodies during the early phase of bacterial infection. In addition, the P. syringae-induced response is mediated by the salicylic acid (SA) signaling pathway. In summary, ATG5 is required for limiting HR-PCD induced in Arabidopsis by P. syringae strains and may be mediated by SA signaling.     

Autophagy in the control of programmed cell death

Programmed cell death (PCD) is essential for plant development and immunity. Localized PCD is associated with the hypersensitive response (HR), which is a constituent of a successful plant innate immune response. Plants have developed mechanisms to meticulously prevent HR-PCD lesions from spreading. Our understanding of these mechanisms is still in its incipient stages. A recent study demonstrated that autophagy, a universally conserved process of macromolecule turnover, plays a pivotal role in controlling HR-PCD. The molecular identity of the mediators between the PCD and HR pathways is still obscure, but recent work has begun to shed light on the relationship between HR-PCD and autophagy and to suggest possible mechanisms for the regulation of these pathways.     

An Arabidopsis homolog of yeast ATG6/VPS30 is essential for pollen germination

Yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) Atg6/Vps30 is required for autophagy and the sorting of vacuolar hydrolases, such as carboxypeptidase Y. In higher eukaryotes, however, roles for ATG6/VPS30 homologs in vesicle sorting have remained obscure. Here, we show that AtATG6, an Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) homolog of yeast ATG6/VPS30, restored both autophagy and vacuolar sorting of carboxypeptidase Y in a yeast atg6/vps30 mutant. In Arabidopsis cells, green fluorescent protein-AtAtg6 protein localized to punctate structures and colocalized with AtAtg8, a marker protein of the preautophagosomal structure. Disruption of AtATG6 by T-DNA insertion resulted in male sterility that was confirmed by reciprocal crossing experiments. Microscopic analyses of AtATG6 heterozygous plants (AtATG6/atatg6) crossed with the quartet mutant revealed that AtATG6-deficient pollen developed normally, but did not germinate. Because other atatg mutants are fertile, AtAtg6 likely mediates pollen germination in a manner independent of autophagy. We propose that Arabidopsis Atg6/Vps30 functions not only in autophagy, but also plays a pivotal role in pollen germination.     

Macroautophagy occurs in distal TMV-uninfected root tip tissue of tomato taking place systemic PCD

Autophagy is an important mechanism for recycling cell materials upon encountering stress conditions. Our previous studies had shown that TMV infection could lead to systemic PCD in the distal uninfected tissues, including root tip and shoot tip tissues. But it is not clear whether there is autophagy in the distal apical meristem of TMV-induced plants. To better understand the autophagy process during systemic PCD, here we investigated the formation and type of autophagy in the root meristem cells occurring PCD. Transmission electron microscopy assay revealed that the autophagic structures formed by the fusion of vesicles, containing the sequestered cytoplasm, multilamellar bodies, and degraded mitochondria. In the PCD progress, many mitochondria appeared degradation with blurred inner membrane structure. And the endoplasmic reticulum was broke into small fragments. Finally, the damaged mitochodria were engulfed and degraded by the autophagosomes. These results indicated that during the systemic PCD process of root tip cells, the classical macroautophagy occurred, and the cell contents and damaged organelles (mitochondria) would be self-digested by autophagy.     

Oncogene-induced autophagy and the Goldilocks principle

Although several oncogenes enhance autophagic flux, the molecular mechanism and consequences of oncogene-induced autophagy remain to be clarified. We have recently shown that expression of oncogenic H-Ras (V12) promotes autophagy through upregulation of Beclin 1 and the BH3-only protein Noxa. H-Ras-expressing cells undergo autophagic cell death as a result of Noxa-mediated displacement of Mcl-1 and Bcl-xL from Beclin 1. Oncogenic H-Ras-induced death is attenuated through knockdown of BECLIN 1, ATG5, or ATG7, or through overexpression of Mcl-1, Bcl-2, Bcl-xL and their close relatives. These observations suggest that high-intensity oncogene activation may be selected against by promoting excessive autophagy, leading to cell death. Consequently, such oncogenes may select for cells with a reduced capacity for autophagy, either through loss of a BECLIN 1 allele or through upregulation of negative regulators of Beclin 1, such as Bcl-2 family members.     

Autophagy differentially controls plant basal immunity to biotrophic and necrotrophic pathogens

In plants, autophagy has been assigned 'pro-death' and 'pro-survival' roles in controlling programmed cell death associated with microbial effector-triggered immunity. The role of autophagy in basal immunity to virulent pathogens has not been addressed systematically, however. Using several autophagy-deficient (atg) genotypes, we determined the function of autophagy in basal plant immunity. Arabidopsis mutants lacking ATG5, ATG10 and ATG18a develop spreading necrosis upon infection with the necrotrophic fungal pathogen, Alternaria brassicicola, which is accompanied by the production of reactive oxygen intermediates and by enhanced hyphal growth. Likewise, treatment with the fungal toxin fumonisin B1 causes spreading lesion formation in atg mutant genotypes. We suggest that autophagy constitutes a 'pro-survival' mechanism that controls the containment of host tissue-destructive microbial infections. In contrast, atg plants do not show spreading necrosis, but exhibit marked resistance against the virulent biotrophic phytopathogen, Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato. Inducible defenses associated with basal plant immunity, such as callose production or mitogen-activated protein kinase activation, were unaltered in atg genotypes. However, phytohormone analysis revealed that salicylic acid (SA) levels in non-infected and bacteria-infected atg plants were slightly higher than those in Col-0 plants, and were accompanied by elevated SA-dependent gene expression and camalexin production. This suggests that previously undetected moderate infection-induced rises in SA result in measurably enhanced bacterial resistance, and that autophagy negatively controls SA-dependent defenses and basal immunity to bacterial infection. We infer that the way in which autophagy contributes to plant immunity to different pathogens is mechanistically diverse, and thus resembles the complex role of this process in animal innate immunity.     

Autophagy controls plant basal immunity in a pathogenic lifestyle-dependent manner

Plant genomes harbor autophagy-related (ATG) genes that encode major components of the eukaryotic autophagic machinery. Autophagy in plants has been functionally linked to senescence, oxidative stress adaptation and the nutrient starvation response. In addition, plant autophagy has been assigned negative ('anti-death') and positive ('pro-death') regulatory functions in controlling cell death programs that establish sufficient immunity to microbial infection. The role of autophagy in plant disease and basal immunity to microbial infection has, however, not been studied in detail. We have employed a series of autophagy-deficient genotypes of the genetic model plant Arabidopsis thaliana in various infection systems. Genotypes lacking ATG5, ATG10 or ATG18a develop spreading necrosis and enhanced disease susceptibility upon infection with toxin-producing pathogens preferring a necrotrophic lifestyle. These findings suggest that autophagy positively controls the containment of host tissue integrity upon infections by host-destructive microbes. In contrast, autophagy-deficient genotypes exhibit markedly increased immunity to infections by biotrophic pathogens through altered homeostasis of the plant hormone salicylic acid, thus suggesting an additional negative regulatory role of autophagy in plant basal immunity. In sum, our findings suggest that the role of plant autophagy in immunity cannot be generalized, and depends critically on the lifestyle and infection strategy of invading microbes.     

Defects in autophagy favour adherent-invasive Escherichia coli persistence within macrophages leading to increased pro-inflammatory response

Ileal lesions in Crohn's disease (CD) patients are abnormally colonized by pathogenic adherent-invasive Escherichia coli (AIEC). AIEC bacteria are able to replicate within epithelial cells after lysis of the endocytic vacuole and within macrophages in a large vacuole. CD-associated polymorphisms in NOD2, ATG16L1 and IRGM affect bacterial autophagy, a crucial innate immunity mechanism. We previously determined that defects in autophagy impaired the ability of epithelial cells to control AIEC replication. AIEC behave differently within epithelial cells and macrophages and so we investigated the impact of defects in autophagy on AIEC intramacrophagic replication and pro-inflammatory cytokine response. AIEC bacteria induced the recruitment of the autophagy machinery at the site of phagocytosis, and functional autophagy limited AIEC intramacrophagic replication. Impaired ATG16L1, IRGM or NOD2 expression induced increased intramacrophagic AIEC and increased secretion of IL-6 and TNF-α in response to AIEC infection. In contrast, forced induction of autophagy decreased the numbers of intramacrophagic AIEC and pro-inflammatory cytokine release, even in a NOD2-deficient context. On the basis of our findings, we speculate that stimulating autophagy in CD patients would be a powerful therapeutic strategy to concomitantly restrain intracellular AIEC replication and slow down the inflammatory response.     

Autophagy and plant innate immunity

Plant innate immunity is often associated with specialized programmed cell death at or near the site of pathogen infection. Despite the isolation of several lesion mimic mutants, the molecular mechanisms that regulate cell death during an immune response remain obscure. Recently, autophagy, an evolutionarily conserved process of bulk protein and organelle turnover, was shown to play an important role in limiting cell death initiated during plant innate immune responses. Consistent with its role in plants, several studies in animals also demonstrate that the autophagic machinery is involved in innate as well as adaptive immunities. Here, we review the role of autophagy in plant innate immunity. Because autophagy is observed in healthy and dying plant cells, we will also examine whether autophagy plays a protective or a destructive role during an immune response.     

The BRI1-associated kinase 1, BAK1, has a brassinolide-independent role in plant cell-death control

Programmed cell death (PCD) is a common host response to microbial infection [1-3]. In plants, PCD is associated with immunity to biotrophic pathogens, but it can also promote disease upon infection by necrotrophic pathogens [4]. Therefore, plant cell-suicide programs must be strictly controlled. Here we demonstrate that the Arabidopsis thaliana Brassinosteroid Insensitive 1 (BRI1)-associated receptor Kinase 1 (BAK1), which operates as a coreceptor of BRI1 in brassinolide (BL)-dependent plant development, also regulates the containment of microbial infection-induced cell death. BAK1-deficient plants develop spreading necrosis upon infection. This is accompanied by production of reactive oxygen intermediates and results in enhanced susceptibility to necrotrophic fungal pathogens. The exogenous application of BL rescues growth defects of bak1 mutants but fails to restore immunity to fungal infection. Moreover, BL-insensitive and -deficient mutants do not exhibit spreading necrosis or enhanced susceptibility to fungal infections. Together, these findings suggest that plant steroid-hormone signaling is dispensable for the containment of infection-induced PCD. We propose a novel, BL-independent function of BAK1 in plant cell-death control that is distinct from its BL-dependent role in plant development.     

Oncogene-induced autophagy and the Goldilocks principle

Although several oncogenes enhance autophagic flux, the molecular mechanism and consequences of oncogene-induced autophagy remain to be clarified. We have recently shown that expression of oncogenic H-Ras^V12 promotes autophagy through upregulation of Beclin 1 and the BH3-only protein Noxa. H-Ras-expressing cells undergo autophagic cell death as a result of Noxa-mediated displacement of Mcl-1 and Bcl-xL from Beclin 1. Oncogenic H-Ras-induced death is attenuated through knockdown of BECLIN 1, ATG5, or ATG7, or through overexpression of Mcl-1, Bcl-2, Bcl-xL and their close relatives. These observations suggest that high-intensity oncogene activation may be selected against by promoting excessive autophagy, leading to cell death. Consequently, such oncogenes may select for cells with a reduced capacity for autophagy, either through loss of a BECLIN 1 allele or through upregulation of negative regulators of Beclin 1, such as Bcl-2 family members.     

Autophagy is required for gamete differentiation in the moss Physcomitrella patens

Autophagy, a major catabolic process in eukaryotes, was initially related to cell tolerance to nutrient depletion. In plants autophagy has also been widely related to tolerance to biotic and abiotic stresses (through the induction or repression of programmed cell death, PCD) as well as to promotion of developmentally regulated PCD, starch degradation or caloric restriction important for life span. Much less is known regarding its role in plant cell differentiation. Here we show that macroautophagy, the autophagy pathway driven by engulfment of cytoplasmic components by autophagosomes and its subsequent degradation in vacuoles, is highly active during germ cell differentiation in the early diverging land plant Physcomitrella patens. Our data provide evidence that suppression of ATG5-mediated autophagy results in reduced density of the egg cell-mediated mucilage that surrounds the mature egg, pointing toward a potential role of autophagy in extracellular mucilage formation. In addition, we found that ATG5- and ATG7-mediated autophagy is essential for the differentiation and cytoplasmic reduction of the flagellated motile sperm and hence for sperm fertility. The similarities between the need of macroautophagy for sperm differentiation in moss and mouse are striking, strongly pointing toward an ancestral function of autophagy not only as a protector against nutrient stress, but also in gamete differentiation.     

Autophagy controls plant basal immunity in a pathogenic lifestyle-dependent manner

Plant genomes harbor autophagy-related (ATG) genes that encode major components of the eukaryotic autophagic machinery. Autophagy in plants has been functionally linked to senescence, oxidative stress adaptation and the nutrient starvation response. In addition, plant autophagy has been assigned negative (‘anti-death’) and positive (‘pro-death’) regulatory functions in controlling cell death programs that establish sufficient immunity to microbial infection. The role of autophagy in plant disease and basal immunity to microbial infection has, however, not been studied in detail. We have employed a series of autophagy-deficient genotypes of the genetic model plant Arabidopsis thaliana in various infection systems. Genotypes lacking ATG5, ATG10 or ATG18a develop spreading necrosis and enhanced disease susceptibility upon infection with toxin-producing pathogens preferring a necrotrophic lifestyle. These findings suggest that autophagy positively controls the containment of host tissue integrity upon infections by host-destructive microbes. In contrast, autophagy-deficient genotypes exhibit markedly increased immunity to infections by biotrophic pathogens through altered homeostasis of the plant hormone salicylic acid, thus suggesting an additional negative regulatory role of autophagy in plant basal immunity. In sum, our findings suggest that the role of plant autophagy in immunity cannot be generalized, and depends critically on the lifestyle and infection strategy of invading microbes.     

ATG7 deficiency suppresses apoptosis and cell death induced by lysosomal photodamage

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) involves photosensitizing agents that, in the presence of oxygen and light, initiate formation of cytotoxic reactive oxygen species (ROS). PDT commonly induces both apoptosis and autophagy. Previous studies with murine hepatoma 1c1c7 cells indicated that loss of autophagy-related protein 7 (ATG7) inhibited autophagy and enhanced the cytotoxicity of photosensitizers that mediate photodamage to mitochondria or the endoplasmic reticulum. In this study, we examined two photosensitizing agents that target lysosomes: the chlorin NPe6 and the palladium bacteriopheophorbide WST11. Irradiation of wild-type 1c1c7 cultures loaded with either photosensitizer induced apoptosis and autophagy, with a blockage of autophagic flux. An ATG7- or ATG5-deficiency suppressed the induction of autophagy in PDT protocols using either photosensitizer. Whereas ATG5-deficient cells were quantitatively similar to wild-type cultures in their response to NPe6 and WST11 PDT, an ATG7-deficiency suppressed the apoptotic response (as monitored by analyses of chromatin condensation and procaspase-3/7 activation) and increased the LD₅₀ light dose by > 5-fold (as monitored by colony-forming assays). An ATG7-deficiency did not prevent immediate lysosomal photodamage, as indicated by loss of the lysosomal pH gradient. However, unlike wild-type and ATG5-deficient cells, the lysosomes of ATG7-deficient cells recovered this gradient within 4 h of irradiation, and never underwent permeabilization (monitored as release of endocytosed 10-kDa dextran polymers). We propose that the efficacy of lysosomal photosensitizers is in part due to both promotion of autophagic stress and suppression of autophagic prosurvival functions. In addition, an effect of ATG7 unrelated to autophagy appears to modulate lysosomal photodamage.     

Autophagy in plants

Autophagy is a highly conserved processing mechanism in eukaryotes whereby cytoplasmic components are engulfed in double-membrane vesicles called autophagosomes and are delivered into organelles such as lysosomes (mammal) or vacuoles (yeast/plant) for degradation and recycling of the resulting molecules. Isolation of yeastAUTOPHAGY (ATG) genes has facilitated the identification of correspondingArabidopsis ATG genes based on sequence similarity. Genetic and molecular analyses using knockout and/or knockdown mutants of those genes have unraveled the biological functions of autophagy during plant development, nutrient recycling, and environmental stress responses. Additional roles for autophagy have been suggested in the degradation of oxidized proteins during oxidative stress and the regulation of hypersensitive response (HR)-programmed cell death (PCD) during innate immunity. Our review summarizes knowledge about the structure and function of autophagic pathways andATG components, and the biological roles of autophagy in plants.