Turnover of actin in Chlamydomonas flagella detected by fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP)

Recent indirect observations have suggested that various axonemal proteins in cilia and flagella of live cells undergo turnover independently of shortening or elongation of the axoneme. To gain direct evidence, here we examined using a FRAP (fluorescence recovery after photobleaching) technique whether actin, a subunit of inner arm dynein, is being turned over in Chlamydomonas flagella. Fluorescently labeled rabbit actin was introduced by electroporation into the cells of ida5oda1, a double mutant between oda1 lacking outer arm dynein and ida5 lacking several species of inner arm dyneins due to the absence of a conventional-type actin. In actin-loaded cells, flagella became motile and fluorescent due to incorporation of inner-arm dyneins containing the labeled actin. Cells were sandwiched between an agar layer and a coverslip so as to restrict flagellar movement. After a small portion of a flagellum was photobleached, the fluorescence intensity in the bleached area was monitored with a sensitive video camera. The fluorescence intensity in the photobleached region was found to recover 10-40% of the original level over several tens of minutes without changing its position. The time course and extent of the recovery varied greatly from one cell to another, suggesting that the turnover depends on cellular conditions. Western blot analysis indicated that 70-80% of flagellar actin was associated with the axoneme. Hence this experiment provides direct evidence that an axonemal component undergoes dynamic exchange in stationary flagella.     

Association between actin and light chains in Chlamydomonas flagellar inner-arm dyneins

Inner dynein arms in cilia and flagella contain actin as a subunit; however, the function of this actin is totally unknown. Here we performed chemical crosslinking experiments to examine the interaction of actin with other subunits. Six of the seven Chlamydomonas inner-arm dynein species separated by anion-exchange chromatography contain actin and either one of the two previously identified light chains, p28 and centrin, in a mutually exclusive manner. Western blotting of chemically crosslinked dyneins indicated that actin is directly associated with p28 and centrin but not with the dynein heavy chains (HCs). In contrast, p28 and centrin both appeared to interact directly with the N-terminal half of the HCs. Thus it is likely that actin is associated with the heavy chains through p28/centrin. These light chains may well function in the assembly or targeting of the inner arm to the correct axonemal location.     

A novel subunit of axonemal dynein conserved among lower and higher eukaryotes

To elucidate the subunit composition of axonemal inner-arm dynein, we examined a 38 kDa protein (p38) co-purified with a Chlamydomonas inner arm subspecies, dynein d. We found it is a novel protein conserved among a variety of organisms with motile cilia and flagella. Immunoprecipitation using specific antibody verified its association with a heavy chain, actin and a previously identified light chain (p28). Unexpectedly, mutant axonemes lacking dynein d and other dyneins retained reduced amounts of p38. This finding suggests that p38 is involved in the docking of dynein d to specific loci.     

Rescue of a Chlamydomonas inner-arm-dynein-deficient mutant by electroporation-mediated delivery of recombinant p28 light chain

We have recently shown that rabbit actin can be introduced by electroporation into the Chlamydomonas ida5 mutant lacking conventional actin and rescue its mutant phenotype [Hayashi et al., 2001: Cell Motil. Cytoskeleton 49:146-153]. In this study, we explored the possibility of using electroporation for functional assay of a recombinant protein. The p28 light chain of inner-arm dyneins was expressed in Escherichia coli, purified to homogeneity, and introduced by electroporation into a non-motile mutant ida4oda6 that lacks it. Because this protein was insoluble in the low ionic strength solution used in the previous study, electroporation was performed at physiological ionic strength in the presence of Ca(2+). Most cells shed their flagella after electroporation. Reflagellation took place within 3 h and up to 30% of the cells became motile, indicating that the introduced p28 retained its functional activity. Fluorescently-labeled p28 was equally effective; in this case fluorescence was observed along the flagella. The presence of Ca(2+) and deflagellation appeared to be important for efficient protein delivery, because a triple mutant with the fa1 mutation deficient in the flagellar shedding mechanism recovered motility only very poorly. Similar results were obtained with other combinations of recombinant proteins and mutants. This study thus demonstrates the feasibility of using electroporation for activity assays of recombinant proteins.     

Two-headed outer- and inner-arm dyneins of Leishmania sp bear conserved IQ-like motifs

Dyneins are high molecular weight microtubule based motor proteins responsible for beating of the flagellum. The flagellum is important for the viability of trypanosomes like Leishmania. However, very little is known about dynein and its role in flagellar motility in such trypanosomatid species. Here, we have identified genes in five species of Leishmania that code for outer-arm dynein (OAD) heavy chains α and β, and inner-arm dynein (IAD) heavy chains 1α and 1β using BLAST and MSA. Our sequence analysis indicates that unlike the three-headed outer-arm dyneins of Chlamydomonas and Tetrahymena, the outer-arm dyneins of the genus Leishmania are two-headed, lacking the γ chain like that of metazoans. N-terminal sequence analysis revealed a conserved IQ-like calmodulin binding motif in the outer-arm α and inner-arm 1α dynein heavy chain in the five species of Leishmania similar to Chlamydomonas reinhardtii outer-arm γ. It was predicted that both motifs were incapable of binding calmodulin. Phosphorylation site prediction revealed conserved serine and threonine residues in outer-arm dynein α and inner-arm 1α as putative phosphorylation sites exclusive to Leishmania but not in Trypanosoma brucei suggesting that regulation of dynein activity might be via phosphorylation of these IQ-like motifs in Leishmania sp.     

ADP-dependent microtubule translocation by flagellar inner-arm dyneins

Previous studies have shown that the motility of flagellar and ciliary axonemes in many organisms are influenced by the concentration of both ATP and ADP. Detergent-extracted cell models of Chlamydomonas oda1, a mutant lacking flagellar outer-arm dynein, displayed slightly lower flagellar beating frequencies when reactivated with ATP in the presence of an ATP-regenerating system, composed of creatine phosphate and creatine phosphokinase, than when reactivated with ATP alone. Thus, presence of a low concentration of ADP may somehow stimulate axonemal motility. To see if this motility stimulation is due to a direct effect on dynein, we analyzed the effect of ADP on the in vitro microtubule translocation caused by isolated inner-arm dyneins in the presence of ATP. Of the seven inner-arm dyneins (species a-g) fractionated by ion-exchange chromatography, most species translocated microtubules at faster speed in the presence of 0.1 mM ATP and 0.1 mM ADP than in the presence of 0.1 mM ATP alone. Most notably, species a and e did not translocate microtubules at all in the presence of the ATP-regenerating system, indicating that a trace amount of ADP is necessary for their motility. This regulation may be effected through binding of ADP to some of the four nucleotide binding sites in each dynein heavy chain.     

Ratchetlike Properties of In Vitro Microtubule Translocation by a Chlamydomonas Inner-Arm Dynein Species c in the Presence of Flow

To investigate the force generation properties of Chlamydomonas axonemal inner-arm dyneins in response to external force, we analyzed microtubule gliding on dynein-coated surfaces under shear flow. When inner-arm dynein c was used, microtubule translocation in the downstream direction accelerated with increasing flow speed in a manner that depended on the dynein density and ATP concentration. In contrast, the microtubule translocation velocity in the upstream direction was unaffected by the flow speed. The number of microtubules on the glass surface was almost constant with and without flow, suggesting that gliding acceleration was not simply caused by weakened dynein-microtubule binding. With other inner-arm dynein species, the microtubule gliding velocity was unaffected by the flow regardless of the flow direction or nucleotide concentration. The flow-generated force acting on a single dynein was estimated to be as small as ∼0.03 pN/dynein. These results indicate that dynein c possesses a ratchetlike property that allows acceleration only in one direction by a very small external force. This property should be important for slow- and fast-moving dyneins to function simultaneously within the axoneme.     

Novel 44-kilodalton subunit of axonemal Dynein conserved from chlamydomonas to mammals

Cilia and flagella have multiple dyneins in their inner and outer arms. Chlamydomonas inner-arm dynein contains at least seven major subspecies (dynein a to dynein g), of which all but dynein f (also called dynein I1) are the single-headed type that are composed of a single heavy chain, actin, and either centrin or a 28-kDa protein (p28). Dynein d was found to associate with two additional proteins of 38 kDa (p38) and 44 kDa (p44). Following the characterization of the p38 protein (R. Yamamoto, H. A. Yanagisawa, T. Yagi, and R. Kamiya, FEBS Lett. 580:6357-6360, 2006), we have identified p44 as a novel component of dynein d by using an immunoprecipitation approach. p44 is present along the length of the axonemes and is diminished, but not absent, in the ida4 and ida5 mutants, both lacking this dynein. In the ida5 axoneme, p44 and p38 appear to form a complex, suggesting that they constitute the docking site of dynein d on the outer doublet. p44 has potential homologues in other ciliated organisms. For example, the mouse homologue of p44, NYD-SP14, was found to be strongly expressed in tissues with motile cilia and flagella. These results suggest that inner-arm dynein d and its subunit organization are widely conserved.     

A tektin homologue is decreased in chlamydomonas mutants lacking an axonemal inner-arm dynein

In ciliary and flagellar axonemes, various discrete structures such as inner and outer dynein arms are regularly arranged on the outer doublet microtubules. Little is known about the basis for their regular arrangement. In this study, proteins involved in the attachment of inner-arm dyneins were searched by a microtubule overlay assay on Chlamydomonas mutant axonemes. A 58-kDa protein (p58) was found approximately 80% diminished in the mutants ida6 and pf3, both lacking one (species e) of the seven inner-arm species (a-g). Analysis of its cDNA indicated that p58 is homologous to tektin, a protein that was originally found in sea urchin and thought to be crucial for the longitudinal periodicity of the doublet microtubule. Unlike sea urchin tektin, which is a component of protofilament ribbons that occur after Sarkosyl treatment of axonemes, p58 was not contained in similar Sarkosyl-resistant ribbons from Chlamydomonas axonemes. Immunofluorescence microscopy showed that p58 was localized uniformly along the axoneme and on the basal body. The p58 signal was reduced in ida6 and pf3. These results suggest that a reduced amount of p58 is sufficient for the production of outer doublets, whereas an additional amount of it is involved in inner-arm dynein attachment.     

Clockwise translocation of microtubules by flagellar inner-arm dyneins in vitro

Cilia and flagella are equipped with multiple species of dyneins that have diverse motor properties. To assess the properties of various axonemal dyneins of Chlamydomonas, in vitro microtubule translocation by isolated dyneins was examined with and without flow of the medium. With one inner-arm dynein species, dynein c, most microtubules became aligned parallel to the flow and translocated downstream after the onset of flow. When the flow was stopped, the gliding direction was gradually randomized. In contrast, with inner-arm dyneins d and g, microtubules tended to translocate at a shallow right angle to the flow. When the flow was stopped, each microtubule turned to the right, making a curved track. The clockwise translocation was not accompanied by lateral displacement, indicating that these dyneins generate torque that bends the microtubule. The torque generated by these dyneins in the axoneme may modulate the relative orientation between adjacent doublet microtubules and lead to more efficient functioning of total dyneins.     

Ciliary motility: the components and cytoplasmic preassembly mechanisms of the axonemal dyneins

Motile cilia and flagella are organelles, which function in cell motility and in the transport of fluids over the surface of cells. Motility defects often result in a rare human disease, primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD). Cell motility depends on axonemal dynein, a molecular motor that drives the beating of cilia and flagella. The dyneins are composed of multiple subunits, which are thought to be preassembled in the cytoplasm before they are transported into cilia and flagella. Axonemal dyneins have been extensively studied in Chlamydomonas. In addition, analyses of human PCDs over the past decade, together with studies in other model animals, have identified the conserved components required for dynein assembly. Recently also, the first cytoplasmic component of dynein assembly, kintoun (ktu), was elucidated through the analysis of a medaka mutant in combination with human genetics and cell biology and biochemical studies of Chlamydomonas. The components of dynein and the proteins involved in its cytoplasmic assembly process are discussed.     

Molecular architecture of inner dynein arms in situ in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii flagella

The inner dynein arm regulates axonemal bending motion in eukaryotes. We used cryo-electron tomography to reconstruct the three-dimensional structure of inner dynein arms from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. All the eight different heavy chains were identified in one 96-nm periodic repeat, as expected from previous biochemical studies. Based on mutants, we identified the positions of the AAA rings and the N-terminal tails of all the eight heavy chains. The dynein f dimer is located close to the surface of the A-microtubule, whereas the other six heavy chain rings are roughly colinear at a larger distance to form three dyads. Each dyad consists of two heavy chains and has a corresponding radial spoke or a similar feature. In each of the six heavy chains (dynein a, b, c, d, e, and g), the N-terminal tail extends from the distal side of the ring. To interact with the B-microtubule through stalks, the inner-arm dyneins must have either different handedness or, more probably, the opposite orientation of the AAA rings compared with the outer-arm dyneins.     

Dyneins across eukaryotes: a comparative genomic analysis

Dyneins are large minus-end-directed microtubule motors. Each dynein contains at least one dynein heavy chain (DHC) and a variable number of intermediate chains (IC), light intermediate chains (LIC) and light chains (LC). Here, we used genome sequence data from 24 diverse eukaryotes to assess the distribution of DHCs, ICs, LICs and LCs across Eukaryota. Phylogenetic inference identified nine DHC families (two cytoplasmic and seven axonemal) and six IC families (one cytoplasmic). We confirm that dyneins have been lost from higher plants and show that this is most likely because of a single loss of cytoplasmic dynein 1 from the ancestor of Rhodophyta and Viridiplantae, followed by lineage-specific losses of other families. Independent losses in Entamoeba mean that at least three extant eukaryotic lineages are entirely devoid of dyneins. Cytoplasmic dynein 2 is associated with intraflagellar transport (IFT), but in two chromalveolate organisms, we find an IFT footprint without the retrograde motor. The distribution of one family of outer-arm dyneins accounts for 2-headed or 3-headed outer-arm ultrastructures observed in different organisms. One diatom species builds motile axonemes without any inner-arm dyneins (IAD), and the unexpected conservation of IAD I1 in non-flagellate algae and LC8 (DYNLL1/2) in all lineages reveals a surprising fluidity to dynein function.     

ODA16p, a Chlamydomonas flagellar protein needed for dynein assembly

Dynein motors of cilia and flagella function in the context of the axoneme, a very large network of microtubules and associated proteins. To understand how dyneins assemble and attach to this network, we characterized two Chlamydomonas outer arm dynein assembly (oda) mutants at a new locus, ODA16. Both oda16 mutants display a reduced beat frequency and altered swimming behavior, similar to previously characterized oda mutants, but only a partial loss of axonemal dyneins as shown by both electron microscopy and immunoblots. Motility studies suggest that the remaining outer arm dyneins on oda16 axonemes are functional. The ODA16 locus encodes a 49-kDa WD-repeat domain protein. Homologues were found in mammalian and fly databases, but not in yeast or nematode databases, implying that this protein is only needed in organisms with motile cilia or flagella. The Chlamydomonas ODA16 protein shares 62% identity with its human homologue. Western blot analysis localizes more than 90% of ODA16p to the flagellar matrix. Because wild-type axonemes retain little ODA16p but can be reactivated to a normal beat in vitro, we hypothesize that ODA16p is not an essential dynein subunit, but a protein necessary for dynein transport into the flagellar compartment or assembly onto the axoneme.     

Functional binding of inner-arm dyneins with demembranated flagella of Chlamydomonas mutants

Experiments were carried out to see if isolated inner arm dyneins could functionally combine with axonemes lacking them. High-salt extract from the axoneme of Chlamydomonas oda1 mutant lacking outer-arm dynein was added to the demembranated cell models of ida1oda1 lacking inner arm dynein f (dynein I1) and outer arm dynein. After incubation, the originally paralyzed ida1oda1 axonemes recovered the ability to beat in the presence of ATP. A similar good motility recovery after incubation with crude oda1 extract was observed in ida9oda2 lacking outer arm and inner arm dynein c, and partial recovery in ida4oda1 lacking outer arm and inner arm species a, c, and d. These observations indicate that dynein f and dynein c can functionally bind with mutant axonemes lacking them. A method for combining isolated inner arm dyneins with axonemes in a functionally active manner should provide a powerful experimental tool with which to study the mechanism of beating.     

Regulation of outer-arm-dynein activity by phosphorylation and control of ciliary beat frequency

Summary Ciliary beating is empowered by a mechanochemical enzyme, dynein, which appears as two rows of projections on doublet microtubules. While inner-arm dyneins modulate beat form, outer-arm dynein empowers ciliary beat and sets beat frequency. Beat frequency is controlled via phosphorylation of outer-arm dynein. UsingParamecium tetraurelia as model system, we have previously identified a regulatory light chain of outer-arm dynein (22S dynein), M_r29 (p29), whose phosphorylation is cAMP-dependent. The phosphorylation state of the p29 in 22 S dynein determines in vitro microtubule translocation velocity. Although in vitro phosphorylation of p29 takes place in a short time, the percent change ist significantly less than the percent change in dynein activation, or in ciliary beat frequency. A potential mechanism that explains how a few activated dyneins can change ciliary beating is discussed.     

Slow ADP-dependent acceleration of microtubule translocation produced by an axonemal dynein

Dynein has four nucleotide binding sites, of which the functional significance is unknown except for the single catalytic site. To obtain clues to the function of non-catalytic nucleotide binding, we examined the effect of ADP on the in vitro motility of Chlamydomonas inner-arm dynein species 'a'. Upon continuous perfusion with ATP and ADP, microtubules glided on a dynein-coated glass surface with a velocity that gradually increased over a few minutes. The velocity increased faster at higher ADP concentrations. These results suggest that this dynein is activated by nucleotide binding to regulatory site(s) through an extremely slow process.     

Differential light chain assembly influences outer arm dynein motor function

Tctex1 and Tctex2 were originally described as potential distorters/sterility factors in the non-Mendelian transmission of t-haplotypes in mice. These proteins have since been identified as subunits of cytoplasmic and/or axonemal dyneins. Within the Chlamydomonas flagellum, Tctex1 is a subunit of inner arm I1. We have now identified a second Tctex1-related protein (here termed LC9) in Chlamydomonas. LC9 copurifies with outer arm dynein in sucrose density gradients and is missing only in those strains completely lacking this motor. Zero-length cross-linking of purified outer arm dynein indicates that LC9 interacts directly with both the IC1 and IC2 intermediate chains. Immunoblot analysis revealed that LC2, LC6, and LC9 are missing in an IC2 mutant strain (oda6-r88) that can assemble outer arms but exhibits significantly reduced flagellar beat frequency. This defect is unlikely to be due to lack of LC6, because an LC6 null mutant (oda13) exhibits only a minor swimming abnormality. Using an LC2 null mutant (oda12-1), we find that although some outer arm dynein components assemble in the absence of LC2, they are nonfunctional. In contrast, dyneins from oda6-r88, which also lack LC2, retain some activity. Furthermore, we observed a synthetic assembly defect in an oda6-r88 oda12-1 double mutant. These data suggest that LC2, LC6, and LC9 have different roles in outer arm assembly and are required for wild-type motor function in the Chlamydomonas flagellum.     

Impaired flagellar regeneration due to uncoordinated expression of two divergent actin genes in Chlamydomonas

Chlamydomonas has two actin genes: one encoding a conventional actin (90% amino acid identity with mammalian actin) and the other a highly divergent actin (NAP; 64% identity). The expression of the two genes is regulated in a mutually exclusive manner. Thus, ida5, a mutant that lacks the conventional actin (CrA) gene, expresses NAP abundantly, whereas wild-type cells express NAP only negligibly under normal conditions. To explore the physiological significance of the two actins, chimeric genes with the 5' upstream region of one gene replaced by that of the other were constructed and used to transform ida5. The transformant (TF5) with a chimeric clone comprising the 5'-untranslated region from the NAP gene and the CrA-encoding sequence recovered the dyneins missing in ida5 and showed almost normal motility. After deflagellation of this transformant, however, only about 30% of cells grew flagella, unlike wild-type cells, >80% of which displayed reflagellation. Transformant TF10, which contains the CrA upstream region and NAP coding region, underwent reflagellation normally, as did the parent strain, ida5. In TF5, the mRNA level of both CrA and NAP was increased greatly during reflagellation. In light of the recent finding that NAP mRNA is expressed transiently upon reflagellation in wild-type cells, the described results suggest that 1) the expression of NAP mRNA is indispensable for flagellation and 2) robust expression of CrA may inhibit proper flagellation by interfering with the function of NAP in the early stages of reflagellation.     

Two types of Chlamydomonas flagellar mutants missing different components of inner-arm dynein

Two types of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii flagellar mutants (idaA and idaB) lacking partial components of the inner-arm dynein were isolated by screening mutations that produce paralyzed phenotypes when present in a mutant missing outer-arm dynein. Of the currently identified three inner-arm subspecies I1, I2, and I3, each containing two heterologous heavy chains (Piperno, G., Z. Ramanis, E. F. Smith, and W. S. Sale. 1990. J. Cell Biol. 110:379-389), idaA and idaB lacked I1 and I2, respectively. The 13 idA isolates comprised three genetically different groups (ida1, ida2, ida3) and the two idaB isolates comprised a single group (ida4). In averaged cross-section electron micrographs, inner dynein arms in wild-type axonemes appeared to have two projections pointing to discrete directions. In ida1-3 and ida4 axonemes, on the other hand, either one of them was missing or greatly diminished. Both projections were weak in the double mutant ida1-3 x ida4. These observations suggest that the inner dynein arms in Chlamydomonas axonemes are aligned not in a single straight row, but in a staggered row or two discrete rows. Both ida1-3 and ida4 swam at reduced speed. Thus, the inner-arm subspecies missing in these mutants are not necessary for flagellar motility. However, the double mutants ida1-3 x ida4 were nonmotile, suggesting that axonemes with significant defects in inner arms cannot function. The inner-arm dynein should be important for the generation of axonemal beating.