Sugar ratios, glutathione redox status and phenols in the resurrection species Haberlea rhodopensis and the closely related non-resurrection species Chirita eberhardtii

Because of their unique tolerance to desiccation, the so‐called resurrection plants can be considered as excellent models for extensive research on plant reactions to environmental stresses. The vegetative tissues of these species are able to withstand long dry periods and to recover very rapidly upon re‐watering. This study follows the dynamics of key components involved in leaf tissue antioxidant systems under desiccation in the resurrection plant Haberlea rhodopensis and the related non‐resurrection species Chirita eberhardtii. In H. rhodopensis these parameters were also followed during recovery after full drying. A well‐defined test system was developed to characterise the different responses of the two species under drought stress. Results show that levels of H₂O₂ decreased significantly both in H. rhodopensis and C. eberhardtii, but that accumulation of malondialdehyde was much more pronounced in the desiccation‐tolerant H. rhodopensis than in the non‐resurrection C. eberhardtii. A putative protective role could be attributed to accumulation of total phenols in H. rhodopensis during the late stages of drying. The total glutathione concentration and GSSG/GSH ratio increased upon complete dehydration of H. rhodopensis. Our data on soluble sugars suggest that sugar ratios might be important for plant desiccation tolerance. An array of different adaptations could thus be responsible for the resurrection phenotype of H. rhodopensis.     

Dynamics of Endogenous Phytohormones during Desiccation and Recovery of the Resurrection Plant Species Haberlea rhodopensis

Drought is one of the most significant threats to world agriculture and hampers the supply of food and energy. The mechanisms of drought responses can be studied using resurrection plants that are able to survive extreme dehydration. As plant hormones function in an intensive cross-talk, playing important regulatory roles in the perception and response to unfavorable environments, the dynamics of phytohormones was followed in the resurrection plant Haberlea rhodopensis Friv. during desiccation and subsequent recovery. Analysis of both leaves and roots revealed that jasmonic acid, along with and even earlier than abscisic acid, serves as a signal triggering the response of the resurrection plants to desiccation. The steady high levels of salicylic acid could be considered an integral part of the specific set of parameters that prime H. rhodopensis desiccation tolerance. The dynamic changes of cytokinins and auxins suggest that these hormones actively participate in the dehydration response and development of desiccation tolerance in the resurrection plants. Our data contribute to the elucidation of a global complex picture of the resurrection plant’s ability to withstand desiccation, which might be successfully utilized in crop improvement.     

The role of antioxidant defense in freezing tolerance of resurrection plant Haberlea rhodopensis

Haberlea rhodopensis Friv. is unique with its ability to survive two extreme environmental stresses—desiccation to air-dry state and subzero temperatures. In contrast to desiccation tolerance, the mechanisms of freezing tolerance of resurrection plants are scarcely investigated. In the present study, the role of antioxidant defense in the acquisition of cold acclimation and freezing tolerance in this resurrection plant was investigated comparing the results of two sets of experiments—short term freezing stress after cold acclimation in controlled conditions and long term freezing stress as a part of seasonal temperature fluctuations in an outdoor ex situ experiment. Significant enhancement in flavonoids and anthocyanin content was observed only as a result of freezing-induced desiccation. The total amount of polyphenols increased upon cold acclimation and it was similar to the control in post freezing stress and freezing-induced desiccation. The main role of phenylethanoid glucoside, myconoside and hispidulin 8-C-(2-O-syringoyl-b-glucopyranoside) in cold acclimation and freezing tolerance was elucidated. The treatments under controlled conditions in a growth chamber showed enhancement in antioxidant enzymes activity upon cold acclimation but it declined after subsequent exposure to −10 °C. Although it varied under ex situ conditions, the activity of antioxidant enzymes was high, indicating their important role in overcoming oxidative stress under all treatments. In addition, the activity of specific isoenzymes was upregulated as compared to the control plants, which could be more useful for stress counteraction compared to changes in the total enzyme activity, due to the action of these isoforms in the specific cellular compartments.Supplementary informationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s12298-021-00998-0.     

Comparison of thylakoid structure and organization in sun and shade Haberlea rhodopensis populations under desiccation and rehydration

The resurrection plant, Haberlea rhodopensis can survive nearly total desiccation only in its usual low irradiation environment. However, populations with similar capacity to recover were discovered recently in several sunny habitats. To reveal what kind of morphological, structural and thylakoid-level alterations play a role in the acclimation of this low-light adapted species to high-light environment and how do they contribute to the desiccation tolerance mechanisms, the structure of the photosynthetic apparatus, the most sensitive component of the chlorophyll-retaining resurrection plants, was analyzed by transmission electron microscopy, steady state low-temperature fluorescence and two-dimensional Blue-Native/SDS PAGE under desiccation and rehydration.     

Prompt response of superoxide dismutase and peroxidase to dehydration and rehydration of the resurrection plant <Emphasis Type="Italic">Haberlea rhodopensis</Emphasis>

The relic endemic nature of Haberlea rhodopensis, which grows in Balkan Peninsula, in combination with its high vegetative desiccation-tolerance, makes this species a good model to study mechanisms behind plant adaptation to severe drought stress. The aim of this study was to evaluate the antioxidant protection provided by Superoxide dismutase (SOD) and Peroxidase (PO) in H. rhodopensis after exposure to and recovery from dehydration at different developmental stages. During dehydration the electrolyte leakage from leaf tissue increased more significantly in post-flowering plants than in flowering plants, while upon subsequent rehydration this parameter showed a very fast decrease to the basic value of fresh leaves and did not depend on developmental stage. Like other higher plant species, SOD and PO demonstrated in H. rhodopensis an ability to adjust their activity very promptly to changing water supply. In addition, the leaves of this resurrection species retained significant activities of SOD and PO even in air-dried state, considered as the most severe form of water stress. The enhanced activity of antioxidant enzymes may either enable the scavenging of the active oxygen species produced at very severe water deficit, and/or carry a potential for resurrection on subsequent rehydration. Upon stress treatment total activities of both enzymes were higher in flowering than post-flowering plants which reveals that developmental stage might be a factor affecting plant stress tolerance. This work identified for the first time SOD isoforms of H. rhodopensis. Native PAGE showed at least six multiple isoforms in the protein extract from leaf tissue of flowering plants, and the differential visualization revealed that four of them were Cu, Zn-SOD isoforms, one was Mn-SOD and one Fe-SOD. These findings provide a good starting point for future study of the SOD gene family of this rare resurrection plant at the molecular level.     

Regulation of CAM and Respiratory Recycling by Water Supply in Higher Poikilohydric Plants — Haberlea rhodopensis Friv. and Ramonda serbica Panč, at Transition from Biosis to Anabiosis and Vice Versa

In this paper the expression of C₃ and CAM in the resurrection plants Haberlea rhodopensis Friv. and Ramonda serbica Pan?, during the transition from biosis to anabiosis and Wee versa is reported for the first time. The transition from predominantly C₃ metabolism to net dark fixation of CO₂ occurred in leaves of R.serbica during desiccation. Desiccated plants of H. rhodopensis react by reducing light assimilation of CO₂. When watering was resumed night time fixation of CO₂ by R. serbica was observed within 24 hours. The recovery of CO₂ fixation by H. rhodopensis was not seen until the 8 th day. Desiccated and rehydrated plants of H. rhodopensis recapture a higher proportion of respiratory CO₂ than well-watered plants. Since both species have little capacity for water conservation in their tissues, the early onset of high recycling of CO₂ following drought could be an important mechanism for potentially saving water.     

Desiccation‐induced alterations in surface topography of thylakoids from resurrection plant Haberlea rhodopensis studied by atomic force microscopy,electrokinetic and optical measurements

With their ability to survive complete desiccation, resurrection plants are a suitable model system for studying the mechanisms of drought tolerance. In the present study, we investigated desiccation‐induced alterations in surface topography of thylakoids isolated from well‐hydrated, moderately dehydrated, severely desiccated and rehydrated Haberlea rhodopensis plants by means of atomic force microscopy (AFM), electrokinetic and optical measurements. According to our knowledge, so far, there were no reports on the characterization of surface topography and polydispersity of thylakoid membranes from resurrection plants using AFM and dynamic light scattering. To study the physicochemical properties of thylakoids from well‐hydrated H. rhodopensis plants, we used spinach thylakoids for comparison as a classical model from higher plants. The thylakoids from well‐hydrated H. rhodopensis had a grainy surface, significantly different from the well‐structured spinach thylakoids with distinct grana and lamella, they had twice smaller cross‐sectional area and were 1.5 times less voluminous than that of spinach. Significant differences in their physicochemical properties were observed. The dehydration and subsequent rehydration of plants affected the size, shape, morphology, roughness and therefore the structure of the studied thylakoids. Drought resulted in significant enhancement of negative charges on the outer surface of thylakoid membranes which correlated with the increased roughness of thylakoid surface. This enhancement in surface charge density could be due to the partial unstacking of thylakoids exposing more negatively charged groups from protein complexes on the membrane surface that prevent from possible aggregation upon drought stress.     

The use of aeroponics to investigate antioxidant activity in the roots of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Xerophyta viscosa</Emphasis>

In order to ultimately understand the whole plant mechanism of attaining desiccation tolerance, we undertook to investigate the root tissues of the resurrection plant Xerophyta viscosa, as previous work has only been conducted on the leaf tissues of resurrection plants. An aeroponic plant growth system was designed and optimised to observe the root’s response to desiccation without the restrictions of a soil medium, allowing easy access to roots. Successful culture of both X.viscosa and the control, Zea mays, was achieved and dehydration stress was implemented through reduction of nutrient solution spraying of the roots. After drying to the air dry state (achieved after 7 days for roots and 10 days for shoots), rehydration was achieved by resumption of root spraying. X.viscosa plants survived desiccation and recovered but Z. mays did not. The activity of the antioxidant enzymes superoxide dismutase, catalase, ascorbate peroxidase and glutathione reductase and quantities of ascorbate and glutathione were determined during root desiccation. There was an initial decline in activity in all enzymes upon drying to 80% RWC, but activity thereafter remained constant, at rates indicative of potential metabolic activity, to the air-dry state. This data suggests that these enzymes are not denatured by desiccation of the root tissue. Ascorbate and glutathione content remained constant at concentrations of 70 and 100 μM, respectively during drying. Thus root tissues appear to retain antioxidant potential during drying, for use in recovery upon rehydration, as has been reported for leaf tissues of this and other resurrection plants.     

Desiccation of the resurrection plant <Emphasis Type="Italic">Haberlea rhodopensis</Emphasis> at high temperature

Haberlea rhodopensis plants, growing under low irradiance in their natural habitat, were desiccated to air-dry state at a similar light intensity (about 30 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹) under optimal (23/20°C, day/night) or high (38/30°C) temperature. Dehydration of plants at high temperature increased the rate of water loss threefold and had a more detrimental effect than either drought or high temperature alone. Water deficit decreased the photochemical activity of PSII and PSI and the rate of photosynthetic oxygen evolution, and these effects were stronger when desiccation was carried out at 38°C. Some reduction in the amount of the main PSI and PSII proteins was observed especially in severely desiccated Haberlea leaves. The results clearly showed that desiccation of the homoiochlorophyllous poikilohydric plant Haberlea rhodopensis at high temperature had more damaging effects than desiccation at optimal temperature and in addition recovery was slower. Increased thermal energy dissipation together with higher proline and carotenoid content in the course of desiccation at 38°C compared to desiccation at 23°C probably helped in overcoming the stress.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">In vitro</Emphasis> culture of the resurrection plant <Emphasis Type="Italic">Haberlea rhodopensis</Emphasis>

The small group of resurrection plants is a unique model which could help us in further understanding of abiotic stress tolerance. The most frequently used approach for investigations on gene functions in plant systems is genetic transformation. In this respect, the establishment of in vitro systems for regeneration and micro propagation is necessary. On the other hand, in vitro cultures of such rare plants could preserve their natural populations. Here, we present our procedure for in vitro regeneration and propagation of Haberlea rhodopensis – a resurrection plant species, endemic for the Balkan region.     

Leaf photosynthesis of Haberlea rhodopensis before and during drought

Haberlea rhodopensis is a homoiochlorophyllous resurrection plant that shows a low rate of leaf net CO₂ uptake (4–6 μmol m^?2 s^?1) under saturating photosynthetic photon flux densities in air (21% O₂ and about 390 ppm CO₂). However, leaf net CO₂ uptake reaches values of 17–18 μmol m^?2 s^?1 under saturating CO₂ and light. H. rhodopensis leaves have a very low mesophyll CO₂ conductance that can partly explain the low rate of leaf net CO₂ uptake in normal air. Experimental evidences suggest that mesophyll conductance is not sensitive to temperature in the 20–35 °C range. In addition, it is shown that the (1) transpiration rate of H. rhodopensis is nearly linearly related to the vapour pressure difference between the leaf and the ambient air within the interval from 0.5 kPa to 2.5 kPa at a leaf temperature of 25 °C and (2) leaf net CO₂ uptake in normal air under saturating light does not change much with leaf temperature (between 20 °C and 30 °C). At a leaf relative water content of between 90% and 30%, the decrease of leaf net CO₂ assimilation during drought can be explained by a decrease of leaf CO₂ diffusional conductance. Accordingly the non-photochemical chlorophyll fluorescence quenching decreases only at relative water contents lower than 20%, indicating that photosynthetic activity maintains a trans-thylakoidal proton gradient over a wide range of leaf water contents. Moreover, PSII photochemistry (as estimated by the Fv/Fm ratio and the thermoluminescence B band intensity) is only affected at leaf relative water contents lower than about 20%, thus confirming that primary photosynthetic reactions are resistant to drought. Interestingly, the effect of leaf desiccation on photosynthetic capacity, measured at very high ambient CO₂ molar ratios under saturating PPFD, is identical to that observed for three non-resurrection C₃ mesophytes. This demonstrates that the photosynthetic apparatus of H. rhodopensis is not more resistant to desiccation when compared to other C₃ plants. Since the leaf area decreases by more than 50% when the leaf relative water content is reduced to about 40% during drought it is supposed, following Farrant et al. [Farrant, J.M., Vander, W.C., Lofell, D.A., Bartsch, S., Whittaker, A., 2003. An investigation into the role of light during desiccation of three angiosperms resurrection plants. Plant Cell Environ. 26, 1275–1286], that H. rhodopensis leaf cells avoid mechanical stress.     

Gas Exchange and Malate Accumulation in Haberlea Rhodopensis Grown Under Different Irradiances

Diurnal patterns of CO₂ exchange and fluctuations of tissue malic acid concentrations were investigated in the resurrection angiosperm Haberlea rhodopensis Friv. grown under irradiances of 30 or 300 μmol(photon) m^-2 s^-1 at transition from biosis to anabiosis and vice versa. Different degree of CAM-cycling were exhibited under well-watered conditions and extreme desiccation under both irradiances. The CAM-cycling was proved as efficient mechanism of saving water. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

A Putative LEA Protein,but no Trehalose,is Present in Anhydrobiotic Bdelloid Rotifers

Some eukaryotes, including bdelloid rotifer species, are able to withstand desiccation by entering a state of suspended animation. In this ametabolic condition, known as anhydrobiosis, they can remain viable for extended periods, perhaps decades, but resume normal activities on rehydration. Anhydrobiosis is thought to require accumulation of the non-reducing disaccharides trehalose (in animals and fungi) or sucrose (in plant seeds and resurrection plants), which may protect proteins and membranes by acting as water replacement molecules and vitrifying agents. However, in clone cultures of bdelloid rotifers Philodina roseola and Adineta vaga, we were unable to detect trehalose or other disaccharides in either control or dehydrating animals, as determined by gas chromatography. Indeed, trehalose synthase genes (tps) were not detected in these rotifer genomes, suggesting that bdelloids might not have the capacity to produce trehalose under any circumstances. This is in sharp contrast to other anhydrobiotic animals such as nematodes and brine shrimp cysts, where trehalose is present during desiccation. Instead, we suggest that adaptations involving proteins might be more important than those involving small biochemicals in rotifer anhydrobiosis: on dehydration, P. roseola upregulates a hydrophilic protein related to the late embryogenesis abundant (LEA) proteins associated with desiccation tolerance in plants. Since LEA-like proteins have also been implicated in the desiccation tolerance of nematodes and micro-organisms, it seems that hydrophilic protein biosynthesis represents a common element of anhydrobiosis across several biological kingdoms.     

Protection of thylakoids against combined light and drought by a lumenal substance in the resurrection plant Haberlea rhodopensis

Background and Aims

Haberlea rhodopensis is a perennial, herbaceous, saxicolous, poikilohydric flowering plant that is able to survive desiccation to air-dried state under irradiance below 30 µmol m⁻² s⁻¹. However, desiccation at irradiance of 350 µmol m⁻² s⁻¹ induced irreversible changes in the photosynthetic apparatus, and mature leaves did not recover after rehydration. The aim here was to establish the causes and mechanisms of irreversible damage of the photosynthetic apparatus due to dehydration at high irradiance, and to elucidate the mechanisms determining recovery.

Methods

Changes in chloroplast structure, CO₂ assimilation, chlorophyll fluorescence parameters, fluorescence imaging and the polypeptide patterns during desiccation of Haberlea under medium (100 µmol m⁻² s⁻¹; ML) irradiance were compared with those under low (30 µmol m⁻² s⁻¹; LL) irradiance.

Key Results

Well-watered plants (control) at 100 µmol m⁻² s⁻¹ were not damaged. Plants desiccated at LL or ML had similar rates of water loss. Dehydration at ML decreased the quantum efficiency of photosystem II photochemistry, and particularly the CO₂ assimilation rate, more rapidly than at LL. Dehydration induced accumulation of stress proteins in leaves under both LL and ML. Photosynthetic activity and polypeptide composition were completely restored in LL plants after 1 week of rehydration, but changes persisted under ML conditions. Electron microscopy of structural changes in the chloroplast showed that the thylakoid lumen is filled with an electron-dense substance (dense luminal substance, DLS), while the thylakoid membranes are lightly stained. Upon dehydration and rehydration the DLS thinned and disappeared, the time course largely depending on the illumination: whereas DLS persisted during desiccation and started to disappear during late recovery under LL, it disappeared from the onset of dehydration and later was completely lost under ML.

Conclusions

Accumulation of DLS (possibly phenolics) in the thylakoid lumen is demonstrated and is proposed as a mechanism protecting the thylakoid membranes of H. rhodopensis during desiccation and recovery under LL. Disappearance of DLS during desiccation in ML could leave the thylakoid membranes without protection, allowing oxidative damage during dehydration and the initial rehydration, thus preventing recovery of photosynthesis.Key words: Haberlea rhodopensis, resurrection plant, electron microscopy, blue–green fluorescence, chlorophyll fluorescence     

Insights into the cellular mechanisms of desiccation tolerance among angiosperm resurrection plant species

Water is a major limiting factor in growth and reproduction in plants. The ability of tissues to survive desiccation is commonly found in seeds or pollen but rarely present in vegetative tissues. Resurrection plants are remarkable as they can tolerate almost complete water loss from their vegetative tissues such as leaves and roots. Metabolism is shut down as they dehydrate and the plants become apparently lifeless. Upon rehydration these plants recover full metabolic competence and ‘resurrect’. In order to cope with desiccation, resurrection plants have to overcome a number of stresses as water is lost from the cells, among them oxidative stress, destabilization or loss of membrane integrity and mechanical stress. This review will mainly focus on the effect of dehydration in angiosperm resurrection plants and some of the strategies developed by these plants to tolerate desiccation. Resurrection plants are important experimental models and understanding the physiological and molecular aspects of their desiccation tolerance is of great interest for developing drought‐tolerant crop species adapted to semi‐arid areas.     

Simultaneous in vivo recording of prompt and delayed fluorescence and 820-nm reflection changes during drying and after rehydration of the resurrection plant Haberlea rhodopensis

A new instrument (M-PEA), which measures simultaneously kinetics of prompt fluorescence (PF), delayed fluorescence (DF) and modulated light reflection at 820 nm (MR), was used to screen dark-adapted leaves of the resurrection plant Haberlea rhodopensis during their progressive drying, down to 1% relative water content (RWC), and after their re-watering. This is the first investigation using M-PEA, which employs alternations of actinic light (627-nm peak, 5000 μmol photons m^? 2 s^? 1) and dark intervals, where PF-MR and DF kinetics are respectively recorded, with the added advantages: (a) all kinetics are recorded with high time resolution (starting from 0.01 ms), (b) the dark intervals' duration can be as short as 0.1 ms, (c) actinic illumination can be interrupted at different times during the PF transient (recorded up to 300 s), with the earliest interruption at 0.3 ms. Analysis of the simultaneous measurements at different water-content-states of H. rhodopensis leaves allowed the comparison and correlation of complementary information on the structure/function of the photosynthetic machinery, which is not destroyed but only inactivated (reversibly) at different degrees; the comparison and correlation helped also to test current interpretations of each signal and advance their understanding. Our results suggest that the desiccation tolerance of the photosynthetic machinery in H. rhodopensis is mainly based on mechanism(s) that lead to inactivation of photosystem II reaction centres (transformation to heat sinks), triggered already by a small RWC decrease.     

Changes in some thylakoid membrane proteins and pigments upon desiccation of the resurrection plant Haberlea rhodopensis

The changes in some proteins involved in the light reactions of photosynthesis of the resurrection plant Haberlea rhodopensis were examined in connection with desiccation. Fully hydrated (control) and completely desiccated plants (relative water content (RWC) 6.5%) were used for thylakoid preparations. The chlorophyll (Chl) a to Chl b ratios of thylakoids isolated from control and desiccated leaves were very similar, which was also confirmed by measuring their absorption spectra. HPLC analysis revealed that β-carotene content was only slightly enhanced in desiccated leaves compared with the control, but the zeaxanthin level was strongly increased. Desiccation of H. rhodopensis to an air-dried state at very low light irradiance led to a little decrease in the level of D1, D2, PsbS and PsaA/B proteins in thylakoids, but a relative increase in LHC polypeptides. To further elucidate whether the composition of the protein complexes of the thylakoid membranes had changed, we performed a separation of solubilized thylakoids on sucrose density gradients. In contrast to spinach, Haberlea thylakoids appeared to be much more resistant to the same solubilization procedure, i.e. complexes were not separated completely and complexes of higher density were found. However, the fractions analyzed provided clear evidence for a move of part of the antenna complexes from PSII to PSI when plants became desiccated. This move was also confirmed by low temperature emission spectra of thylakoids.Overall, the photosynthetic proteins remained comparatively stable in dried Haberlea leaves when plants were desiccated under conditions similar to their natural habitat. Low light during desiccation was enough to induce a rise in the xanthophyll zeaxanthin and β-carotene. Together with the extensive leaf shrinkage and some leaf folding, increased zeaxanthin content and the observed shift in antenna proteins from PSII to PSI during desiccation of Haberlea contributed to the integrity of the photosynthetic apparatus, which is important for rapid recovery after rehydration.