Suppression of lymphokine production: II. Macrophage-dependent inhibition of production of macrophage activating factor

The ability of different populations of macrophages to affect the production of macrophage activating factor (MAF) by stimulated T lymphocytes was investigated. We found that activated macrophages, infiltrating MSV-induced regressing tumors or macrophages recovered from the peritoneum of mice injected with Corynebacterium parvum, were able to actively suppress the production of MAF. MAF production by antigen-stimulated MSV-immune or -alloimmune spleen cells and by normal spleen cells stimulated by Con A was susceptible to macrophage-dependent suppression to a similar extent. In contrast, resident macrophages or those elicited by light mineral oil or proteose-peptone did not affect MAF production. While suppressor macrophages added at the time of the lymphocyte stimulation inhibited MAF production, the same cells added 4–6 hr after stimulation were ineffective. Therefore, it seems that the macrophages suppressed the early events of lymphocyte activation leading to MAF production. Suppressor macrophages, by inhibiting MAF production, may limit the expansion of the cytotoxic activity. This regulation of macrophage functions, mediated by the effects of suppressor macrophages on T lymphocytes, could be responsible for an insufficient antitumor cytotoxic response by macrophages.     

Desensitization V: Suppression of MIF production by lymphokine-activated macrophages

The systemic injection of high doses of antigen into a previously immunized animal results in a state of transient anergy with respect to cell-mediated immune reactions. This phenomenon is known as desensitization. We have previously shown that desensitization is a multistage process. The initial 24-hr period is characterized by excessive lymphokine production with a failure to express delayed hypersensitivity reactions due to abolition of local chemotactic gradients. Subsequent stages of desensitization involve failure of lymphokine production in vivo. The results presented here demonstrate that lymphocytes obtained from immunized and desensitized animals later than 24 hr after desensitization are markedly suppressed in their ability to produce MIF. In addition, it was found that lymphokine-activated macrophages can suppress in vitro MIF production by lymphocytes from immune, nondesensitized animals. In vitro and in vivo activation of macrophages were equally effective. Thus, it is likely that at least one mechanism for the inhibition of lymphokine production in the post-24-hr period of desensitization, involves activation of a population of suppressor macrophages by lymphokines produced during the initial 24-hr period.     

Macrophage migration stimulation factor, migration inhibition factor and the role of suppressor cells in their production.

Guinea pig lymph node lymphocytes and human peripheral blood lymphocytes when stimulated by specific antigen or mitogen will release factors that affect in vitro macrophage migration. Migration inhibition factor production appears to be under the control of suppressor cells which are T lymphocytes. When suppressor cells are generated by stimulation with Con A for 4 days, migration stimulation factor (M.St.F.) activity is found. In other situations where M.St.F. is found this is thought to be due to increased suppressor cell activity. For example, young adults produce this lymphokine when stimulated with Con A, whereas aged individuals produce MIF. Concanavalin A appears to be the mitogen of choice for M.St.F. production, and phytohemagglutinin for MIF production. The release of this putative factor M.St.F. from suppressor T cells helps to explain some of the difficulties that have existed in studies of macrophage migration inhibition.     

The role of divalent cations in interactions between lymphokines and macrophages

The divalent cation requirements of lymphokine-mediated alterations in macrophage function (activation and inhibition of migration) were examined. Normal rabbit alveolar macrophages exposed to incubation supernatants of antigen-stimulated sensitized lymphocytes (lymphokine) were activated, manifested by increased adherence and enhanced bactericidal activity, as compared with control cells. This lymphokine-mediated activation was dependent upon the presence of extracellular Mg²⁺ (but not Ca²⁺). Our data from both current and previous studies suggest that Mg²⁺ influx is necessary for initiation or support of the macrophage activation process. The divalent cation requirements for lymphokine (MIF)-induced inhibition of macrophage migration differed from that of the activation phenomenon. Specifically, both Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ were required for expression of MIF activity. Adsorption experiments indicate that these cations are needed for binding of MIF to the macrophage surface.     

Mechanism of lymphocyte activation. II. Requirements for macromolecular synthesis in the production of lymphokines

Reversible inhibitors of protein synthesis, cycloheximide and puromycin, and an irreversible inhibitor of RNA synthesis, actinomycin D, were employed to study the kinetics and types of macromolecular synthetic events required for the production of migration inhibitory factor (MIF) and macrophage activating factor (MAF) by Con A-stimulated lymphocytes. Reversible inhibition of protein synthesis during the first 2 hr of stimulation completely inhibited MIF and MAF production. The same treatment, performed 4 hr after the beginning of the stimulation, had no effect. When the inhibitors of protein synthesis were left in the cultures, a block of lymphokine production was observed when the drugs were added at 6 hr as well as at time 0. In contrast, irreversible inhibition of RNA synthesis at 6 hr was ineffective and only treatment at the beginning of culture blocked lymphokine production. These data suggest that a critical protein is synthesized during the first few hours of stimulation, which is required for subsequent production of lymphokines. After this special early requirement, however, continued protein synthesis is needed for lymphokine production. In contrast, the RNA required for MIF and MAF production seemed to be completely synthesized within 4 to 6 hr of stimulation. The possibility that suppressor macrophages inhibit lymphokine production via modulation of macromolecular synthesis is discussed.     

Activation of alveolar macrophages after lower respiratory tract infection.

Alveolar macrophage function has been studied in relation to bacterial infection of the lower respiratory tract. First, LRT macrophages were examined after exposure of rabbits to Listeria monocytogenes aerosols. Macrophages obtained from the LRT of animals 10 to 48 days after infection were activated, as evidenced by greater adherence to culture dishes and increased ability to ingest and kill both the original infecting organism and unrelated organisms, when compared to normal alveolar macrophages. Next, the in vitro effects on normal alveolar macrophages of incubation supernatants of control and antigen-stimulated lymphocytes (LRT and lymph node) from animals infected with L. monocytogenes or Streptococcus pneumoniae were evaluated. As manifested by increased adherence and phagocytosis, and an enhanced nonspecific bactericidal activity, alveolar macrophages were activated by the antigen-stimulated supernatants. These stimulated lymphocyte supernatants contain lymphokines (MIF), but the exact nature of the alveolar macrophage activating factor(s) remains to be determined. These observations, together with recent evidence that alveolar macrophages respond to lymphokines (MIF), suggest that the effector mechanism for cell-mediated immunity in the LRT is intact.     

Stimulation of mouse migration inhibitory factor (MIF) production form MSV-immune lymphocytes by soluble tumor-associated antigen: requirement for histocompatible macrophages.

Spleen cells from C57BL/6 mice immunized with murine sarcoma virus (MSV) are capable of producing migration inhibition factor (MIF) in response to stimulation with a specific tumor-associated antigen prepared by solubilization with 3 M KCL. We have previously demonstrated that this response is T cell-dependent. Further investigations into the effector cells involved in the production of MIF have revealed that spleen cells from mice immunized with MSV cannot produce MIF when stimulated with tumor extract if the population has been previously depleted of macrophages. However, the response can be restored by adding nonimmune syngeneic macrophages but not by allogeneic macrophages. The inability of allogeneic macrophages to provide this function was not due to their increased suppressor activity since in mixing experiments they did not interfere with the ability of immune spleen cells to produce MIF. Furthermore, they were not defective since they could supply this "cooperative function" to appropriate F1 mice. The results indicate that macrophages are required for stimulation of MIF by soluble tumor antigens and that for efficient interaction the macrophages and lymphocytes must share some genetic similarities.     

Macrophage regulation of DNA synthesis in lymphoid cells: effects of a soluble factor from macrophages

Addition of rat peritoneal macrophages to nonadherent rat spleen cells in culture results in enhancement or suppression of DNA synthesis depending on the ratio of macrophages to lymphocytes. At high ratios of macrophages to lymphocytes (1:5), suppression can be observed as early as four hours. Macrophages suppress incorporation of thymidine (TdR) by nonadherent spleen, thymus and bone marrow cells, in most instances, to less than 5% of that observed in culture to which macrophages were not added. In the presence of macrophages, incorporation of [³H]uridine and [¹⁴C] amino acids by spleen cells was also moderately suppressed. Based on ⁵¹Chromium release and dye exclusion assays, it appears that suppression is not due to cytotoxicity. Furthermore, suppression of [³H]TdR incorporation by nonadherent spleen cells is reversible, in the presence of an antigenic stimulus, following removal of the macrophages from the cultures. The suppressive effects are not elicited by extracts of macrophages, freeze-thawed or heated macrophages, but appear to be due to a low molecular weight, heat stable factor released into the macrophage culture fluid.     

Radiation leukemia virus-transformed immunocompetent T cells. II. Antigen-induced macrophage migration inhibition factor and leukocyte migration inhibition factor production

OVA-specific T cells were immortalized by infection with radiation leukemia virus (RadLV). Some clones derived from such population were shown to exhibit helper activity. We then tested clones without such function and found among them some that secreted macrophage migration inhibition factor (MIF) and leukocyte migration inhibition factor (LIF) upon exposure to the antigen in vitro. The lymphokine-producing clones, which were Thy-1+, Ly-1+ and Ly-2-, did not secrete MIF and LIF constitutively. Like other antigen-specific T cells, the immortalized clones could not be stimulated by free soluble antigen but required macrophages for presentation and for triggering the lymphokine production. The antigen-activated clones exclusively produced MIF and LIF, but not interleukin 2 or colony-stimulating factor. They neither provided helper activity nor induced delayed-type hypersensitivity. The data suggest that the T-cell clones carry the antigen receptors and that their antigen-inducible biological function is restricted to the migration inhibitory factor production.     

Role of lymphokines in regulation of macrophage differentiation

The regulatory mechanism of guinea pig lymphokines was investigated in regard to differentiation of myeloid cells to macrophages. The Ml-cell line, established from a myeloid leukemia of an SL-strain mouse, was induced to differentiate in vitro into mature macrophages possessing Fc receptors and the ability to phagocytize latex particles by treatment with crude lymphokines. Both concanavalin A- and antigen-induced lymphokines showed the differentiation-inducing factor (D factor) activity. However, macrophage migration inhibitory factor/ macrophage activation factor (MIF/MAF) purified by an immunoadsorbent column with anti-MIF antibody had no such an activity. The D-factor activity was detected in the lymphokine preparation that was not retained on the immunoadsorbent column. In contrast, colony-stimulating factor (CSF) was adsorbed to the immunoadsorbent column, and could be recovered in the purified MIF/MAF preparation. These findings suggest that the molecular entity of D factor is distinct from MIF/ MAF and CSF. A culture supernatant of guinea pig peritoneal macrophages activated with MIF/ MAF (CSF) exhibited strong D-factor activity. However, the supernatant possessed rather reduced CSF activity as compared to that of the original MIF/MAF (CSF) preparation. Thus, MIF/MAF may play an important role in macrophage differentiation by regulating the production of D factor or CSF from macrophages.     

Changes in macrophage status in vivo during infection with and immunity to Leishmania enriettii

The changing status of peritoneal macrophages in guinea pigs infected with Leishmania enriettii has been examined. It was possible to demonstrate that, at certain times during a primary infection and following attempted reinfection of immune animals, the response of peritoneal macrophages to lymphokine contact in vitro was altered. At these times the harvested cells appeared to behave in vitro as if they had been at least partially activated in vivo before removal. They were unresponsive to lymphokine in the migration inhibition assay, and contact with lymphokine in culture caused a rapid increase in the level of glucose oxidation in these cells. It is suggested that changes in the response of macrophages to lymphokine in vitro may be one way of monitoring activation in vivo.     

Macrophages as effector cells of protective immunity in murine schistosomiasis: IV. Coincident induction of macrophage activation for extracellular killing of schistosomula and tumor cells

Peritoneal macrophages from Schistosoma mansoni-infected mice are activated both for nonspecific tumor cytotoxicity and for killing of skin-stage schistosomula in vitro. In the current study, mechanisms for induction of macrophage tumoricidal and schistosomulacidal activity have been compared. Examination of macrophages activated in vivo by BCG infection or C. parvum treatment, or in vitro by exposure to lymphokine prepared from antigen-stimulated BCG-immune spleen cells, showed that these effector functions were closely linked. Indeed, fractionation of lymphokine-rich supernatant fluids by Sephadex G-100 gel filtraction showed that activities responsible for induction of schistomula killing by inflammatory macrophages and for induction of tumoricidal activity cochromatographed as a single peak in the 50,000 MW region. Thus, development of macrophage-mediated cytotoxicity against these two extracellular (tumor cell or helminth) targets was coincident in several cell populations activated in vivo or in vitro. However, activation for tumoricidal and schistosomulacidal capacity appeared to be quantitatively dissociated in macrophages from mice with chronic schistosomiasis; those cells demonstrated low, yet significant, levels of larval killing ($\text{1}\text{3}$ to $\text{1}\text{5}$ those of BCG or lymphokine-activated cells) but maximal levels of tumor cell cytotoxicity. Furthermore, cytotoxicity by peritoneal cells from S. mansoni-infected mice was not increased in vitro by exposure to lymphokine. Identification of this functional alteration in S. mansoni-activated cells may help to clarify the role of macrophages in the partial immunity against challenge infection which is demonstrated by mice with chronic primary S. mansoni infection.     

Antigen-nonspecific and specific suppression of lymphokine production in desensitized guinea pigs

Doubly immunized guinea pigs may be desensitized with respect to delayed hypersensitivity reactions against both antigens (anergy) by injection of large doses of either one. This anergic response therefore has both a specific and nonspecific component. The specific component of desensitization persists longer than the nonspecific one. In the present study, we have explored the mechanism of both antigen-specific and antigen-nonspecific suppression during the later stages of desensitization. Guinea pigs immunized with two antigens, DNP-KLH and DNP-EA, were desensitized with DNP-EA. The lymph node cells obtained from the animals 1 day after desensitization were unable to produce MIF in the presence of either antigen. The cells obtained 3, 5, and 7 days after desensitization were able to generate MIF when stimulated with the non-specific antigen (DNP-KLH), but not with specific antigen (DNP-EA). It was shown that both T- and non-T-cell fractions obtained 1 day after desensitization had the capacity to antigen-nonspecifically suppress MIF production. In contrast, if the cells were obtained 3 or 5 days after desensitization, T cells could inhibit only the antigen-specific production of MIF, while non-T cells were still capable of suppressing antigen-specific and nonspecific MIF production. Interestingly, when these two populations were mixed back again, it was now only suppressive to the specific antigen-induced MIF production. This latter observation indicates that nonspecific suppressor non-T cells may themselves be regulated by suppressor T cells. Furthermore, antigen-specific suppressor T cells were shown to produce soluble factor(s) which inhibited the production of MIF.     

Lymphokine maintains macrophage activation for tumor cell killing by interfering with the negative regulatory effect of prostaglandin E2

Mouse resident peritoneal macrophages activated with bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS) rapidly lost their ability to kill tumor cells in vitro. Such loss of killing has previously been attributed to the effects of prostaglandin E (PGE) produced by the LPS-stimulated macrophages. Macrophages exposed in the current study to both LPS and partially purified lymphokine did not lose cytolytic activity, in spite of the fact that these cells produced undiminished amounts of PGE, compared to controls. Cytolytic activity was shown to be retained under these conditions because lymphokine decreased the sensitivity of activated macrophages to the negative regulatory effects of PGE. The mechanism responsible for the lymphokine effect is not known; however, generalized inhibition of macrophage responsiveness to the hormone does not appear to be involved because lymphokine did not reduce the cyclic AMP response of macrophages, measured on a whole cell basis, after they were exposed to PGE.     

The immunoregulatory role of bone marrow. I. Suppression of the induction of antibody responses to T-dependent and T-independent antigens by cells in the bone marrow.

Bone marrow cells (BMC) from normal mice suppressed the in vitro IgM, but not the IgG, antibody (Ab) response of spleen cells. BMC were inhibitory only when added during the first 24 hr of culture, and inhibition was not due to an induced shift in the kinetics of the response. Addition of specifically activated T cells or nonspecific T-cell-replacing factors to normal or T-depleted spleen cell cultures did not abrogate suppression while the response to the T-independent antigen DNP-polymerized flagellin or lipopolysaccharide was also suppressed. BMC did not inhibit background Ab synthesis by normal or primed cells in the absence of antigen and did not inhibit, but stimulated, DNA synthesis in normal spleen cell cultures. In addition, high-avidity Ab synthesis was preferentially suppressed. A possible role for the bone marrow suppressor cell in the induction of B cell tolerance is discussed.     

Induction of protective immunity against Schistosoma mansoni by a nonliving vaccine. III. Correlation of resistance with induction of activated larvacidal macrophages

Mice protected against Schistosoma mansoni infection by intradermal (i.d.) immunization with nonliving larval or adult worm antigens plus bacterial adjuvant developed 24-hr skin test responsiveness to schistosome antigens with the histologic features of delayed hypersensitivity. Intraperitoneal antigen injection elicited a mononuclear cell-enriched exudative population containing macrophages activated for direct cytotoxicity against schistosomula and tumor cell targets. This was likely to be due to in vivo exposure to macrophage-activating lymphokines, since these cells were unresponsive to further lymphokine stimulation in vitro and splenocytes from immunized mice reacted to specific in vitro antigen challenge by production of lymphokines capable of conferring larvacidal activity upon control macrophages. In contrast, mice treated with schistosome antigens by i.v. injection, which were not protected against challenge infection, failed to develop delayed hypersensitivity or activated macrophages in response to specific antigen challenge in vivo, and the titers of macrophage-activating lymphokine produced by in vitro antigen-stimulated splenocytes from these mice were threefold to fourfold lower than those produced by cells from animals immunized by the i.d. route. Thus, sensitization for cell-mediated immune responses including lymphokine production and macrophage activation correlated with induction of resistance to S. mansoni in this model of vaccination.     

Cellular requirements for production and release of the lymphocyte costimulator

The lymphocyte costimulator (CoS) is a lymphokine required for the activation of T cell responses to H-2 alloantigens or mitogen, CoS activity is found in the supernatant medium of Concanavalin A (Con A) stimulated spleen cells, In this paper we investigate the cellular requirements for CoS production by Con A-activated mouse spleen cells. Maximal lymphokine production in response to Con A depends on a co-operative interaction between T cells and a nylon wool-adherent cell present in the spleen of nude mice. T cells appear to be the major producers of CoS activity, doing so only in response to an initial inductive stimulus supplied by nude spleen cells. The inductive stimulus is found as a soluble factor in the supernatant of Con A-activated spleen cells, and can also be provided by stimulatory (S+), but not by non-stimulatory (S-), tumour cells H-2 identical with the responding T cells. The activation of lymphokine-producing T cells is thus a two-signal process, requiring both mitogen and an additional inductive signal. Once activated, homogeneous populations of T cells will release lymphokine in response to mitogen alone.     

Regulatory cells in human bone marrow: Suppression of an in vitro primary antibody response

Human bone marrow (BMC) contains regulatory cells that can suppress the in vitro primary PFC response of normal allogeneic spleen or tonsillar cells and autologous peripheral blood cells. Suppression is dependent upon the dose of BMC added, but is not due to cell crowding nor to excessive cytotoxicity, and requires the presence of viable, metabolically active BMC. BMC are maximally inhibitory when added during the first 24 hr of culture and do not cause an induced shift in the kinetics of the response. Thus, suppression reflects inhibition of early inductive events in the antibody response. The target of suppression is the non-T cell, with either polyclonal activator or Ag being required for maximal suppression. DNA synthesis of normal tonsillar cells is not inhibited by BMC. Characterization of the human bone marrow-suppressor cell has shown it to be radiosensitive, E-rosette negative, Fc receptor positive, and to reside in the large, weakly adherent cell population after velocity sedimentation and in the lymphocyte-depleted fraction after sucrose density gradient separation. Pretreatment of the bone marrow-suppressor cell with anti-human thymocyte serum does not abrogate suppression. We speculate on a possible physiologic role for this cell.     

The production of T-cell growth factor (TCGF) in vivo in sheep

Lymph and supernatants derived from efferent lymphocytes leaving the popliteal lymph nodes of sheep responding to human red cells or dinitrophenylated bovine serum albumin were examined for the presence of T-cell growth factor (TCGF). Efferent cells from normal sheep, but not from antigen-stimulated sheep, were found to release low levels of TCGF when incubated in medium for 12 hr in the absence of any exogenous stimulus. High levels of TCGF were found in normal lymph and also in immune lymph collected from sheep during the first 6 hr of immune responses. There were no detectable levels of TCGF in lymph collected later in the response. The lymphokine appeared to be a single molecular species of 10,000–20,000 molecular weight as assessed by exclusion chromatography. Efferent cells expressing receptors for TCGF were found in efferent lymph during the first 12 hr of the response. The results demonstrate for the first time that TCGF is produced in vivo and that asynchrony exists between TCGF production and expression of receptors for TCGF on efferent cells released by the stimulated node. Based on the known kinetics of previously reported synergistic factors, mitogenic factors, and T-cell-replacing factors in sheep efferent lymph and their physical characteristics it was concluded that the TCGF detected in lymph is distinct from these factors.     

Antigen-specific inhibition of immune interferon production by suppressor cells of autoimmune encephalomyelitis

Previous work from this laboratory has revealed that spleen and/or lymph node cells from Lewis rats, that have recovered from an acute episode of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), suppress the development of EAE when injected into syngeneic recipients subsequently challenged with myelin basic protein (MBP) in CFA. In an effort to understand the mechanism of this suppression, we measured the production of immune IFN-gamma, which may be required for the induction of an immune response, by EAE effector T cells (which transfer disease) and EAE suppressor cells when cultured in vitro with MBP. We now report that EAE effector T cells produce IFN-gamma when cultured in vitro with MBP. In contrast, spleen cells from recovered rats (which manifest suppressor activity in vivo) do not produce IFN-gamma. Moreover, in cell mixing experiments, these suppressor spleen cells inhibited the production of IFN-gamma by EAE effector cells. This inhibition was not eliminated by the removal of macrophages nor by the inhibition of PG synthesis by indomethacin. Furthermore, the inhibition was shown to be Ag-specific and mediated by nylon-adherent, radiation-sensitive splenic T cells. The findings suggest that suppressor cells regulate EAE by inhibiting IFN-gamma production by effector cells. This inhibition may result in the down-regulation of IFN-gamma-induced expression of class II major histocompatibility Ag on cells of the central nervous system, thus reducing the presentation of tissue-specific Ag (i.e., MBP) to autoreactive lymphocytes.