Evaluation of an in vitro coculture model for the blood-brain barrier: Comparison of human umbilical vein endothelial cells (ECV304) and rat glioma cells (C6) from two commercial sources

Summary Cocultures of human umbilical vein endothelial cells (ECV304) and rat glioma cells (C6) from two commercial sources, American Type Culture Collection and European Collection of Animal Cell Cultures, were evaluated as an in vitro model for the blood-brain barrier. Monolayers of endothelial cells grown in the presence or absence of glial cells were examined for transendothelial electrical resistance, sucrose permeability, morphology, multidrug resistance-associated protein expression, and P-glycoprotein expression and function. Coculture of glial cells with endothelial cells increased electrical resistance and decreased sucrose permeability across European endothelial cell monolayers, but had no effect on American endothelial cells. Coculture of European glial cells with endothelial cells caused cell flattening and decreased cell stacking with both European and American endothelial cells. No P-glycoprotein or multidrug resistance-associated protein was immunodetected in endothelial cells grown in glial cell-conditioned medium. Functional P-glycoprotein was demonstrated in American endothelial cells selected in vinblastine-containing medium over eight passages, but these cells did not form a tight endothelium. In conclusion, while European glial cells confer blood-brain barrier-like morphology and barrier integrity to European endothelial cells in coculture, the European endothelial-glial cell coculture model does not express P-glycoprotein, normally found at the blood-brain barrier. Further, the response of endothelial cells to glial factors was dependent on cell source, implying heterogeneity among cell populations. On the basis of these observations, the umbilical vein endothelial cell-glial cell coculture model does not appear to be a viable model for predicting blood-brain barrier penetration of drug molecules.     

Preliminary Characterization of Glial-Secreted Factors Responsible for the Induction of High Electrical Resistances Across Endothelial Monolayers in a Blood-Brain Barrier Model

Factors secreted by C6 glioma cells which induce electrical resistances across endothelial monolayers in an in vitro blood-brain barrier model have been partially characterised for the first time. These transendothelial electrical resistances (TEERs) were only evident when cell-free conditioned medium derived from C6 glioma cells was applied to the basolateral surfaces of confluent ECV304 or ECV304-9 cells which are both human umbilical vein endothelial cell lines (HUVEC). Electrical resistance values as high as 600 ohm. sq cm were obtained with this blood-brain barrier model and ultrafiltration techniques suggest that any factor(s) in the conditioned medium responsible for these TEERs have molecular masses of less than 1000 Da. Enzymic proteolysis and heat treatment carried out on the conditioned medium failed to inhibit its effect on the HUVEC monolayers suggesting that these C6 cell-secreted factors are unlikely to be proteins.     

Peroxynitrite Mediates Nitric Oxide–Induced Blood–Brain Barrier Damage

Using the in vitro blood-brain barrier (BBB) model ECV304/C6, which consists of cocultures of human umbilical vein endothelial-like cells (ECV304) and rat glioma cells (C6), the role of peroxynitrite (OONO-) in nitric oxide (NO*)-mediated BBB disruption was evaluated. Endothelial cell cultures were exposed to NO* gas, in the presence or absence of the OONO- blocker FeTPPS. Separate exposure to NO* and OONO- resulted in endothelial cell cytotoxicity and a decline in barrier integrity. Unfortunately, FeTPPS induced significant detrimental effects on model BBB integrity at a concentration of 300 microM and above. At 250 microM (the highest concentration usable), FeTPPS displayed a trend toward prevention of NO* elicited perturbation of barrier integrity. Dichlorofluorescein diacetate is oxidized to fluorescent dichlorofluorescein by OONO- but only marginally by NO* or O2*-. We observed large and rapid increases in fluorescence in ECV304 preloaded cells following NO* exposure, which were blocked by FeTPPS. Furthermore, using an antinitrotyrosine antibody we detected the nitration of endothelial cell proteins following NO* exposure and conclude that NO*-mediated BBB dysfunction is predominantly elicited by OONO- and not NO*. Proposed mechanisms of NO*-mediated OONO- elicited barrier dysfunction and damage are discussed.     

Involvement of Glial Cells in Cyclosporine-Increased Permeability of Brain Endothelial Cells

SUMMARY 1. To test whether astrocytes participate in cyclosporine-induced dysfunction of the blood-brain barrier, we examined the effects of cyclosporine on the permeability of the mouse brain endothelial (MBEC4) cells cocultured with C6 glioma cells, each cell layer placed on the top and bottom of the insert membrane, respectively.2. The presence of C6 cells remarkably aggravated cyclosporine-increased permeability of MBEC4 cells to sodium fluorescein.3. In light of these findings, the possibility that astroglial cells could contribute to the occurrence of cyclosporine-induced dysfunction of the blood-brain barrier triggering neurotoxicity should be considered.     

Regulation of gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase and alkaline phosphatase activities in immortalized rat brain microvessel endothelial cells

Rat brain microvessel endothelial cells were immortalized by transfection with a plasmid containing the E1A adenovirus gene. One clone, called RBE4, was further characterized. These cells display a nontransformed phenotype and express typical endothelial markers, Factor VIII-related antigen and Bandeiraea simplicifolia binding sites. When RBE4 cells were grown in the presence of bFGF and on collagen-coated dishes, confluent cultures developed sprouts that extend above the monolayer and organized into three-dimensional structures. The activity of the blood-brain barrier-associated enzyme, gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase (γGTP), was expressed in these structures, not in the surrounding monolayer. Similar results were obtained with the microvessel-related enzyme alkaline phosphatase (ALP). Addition of agents that elevate intracellular cAMP reduced the formation of three-dimensional structures, but every cell inside the aggregates still expressed γCTP and ALP activities. Such structures, associated with high levels of γCTP and ALP activities, were also induced by astroglial factors, including (1) plasma membranes from newborn rat primary astrocytes or rat glioma C6 cells, (2) C6 conditioned media, or (3) diffusible factors produced by primary astrocytes grown in the presence of, but not in contact with RBE4 cells. RBE4 cells thus remain sensitive to angiogenic and astroglial factors for the expression of the blood-brain barrier-related γCTP activity, as well as for ALP activity, and could constitute the basis of a valuable in vitro model of the blood-brain barrier. © 1994 wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Transendothelial permeability changes induced by free radicals in an in vitro model of the blood-brain barrier.

In the present study, we investigated the changes in blood-brain barrier (BBB) permeability following brain endothelial cell exposure to different xenobiotics able to promote free radical generation during their metabolism. Our in vitro BBB model consisted of confluent monolayers of immortalized rat brain capillary endothelial cells (RBE4) grown on collagen-coated filters in the presence of C6 glioma cells grown in the lower compartment. We have recently shown that a range of xenobiotics, including menadione, nitrofurazone, and methylviologen (paraquat) may undergo monoelectronic redox cycling in isolated brain capillaries, giving rise to reactive oxygen species. In this study, addition of 100 microM menadione to the culture medium for 30 min significantly increased the permeability of endothelial cell monolayers to radiolabeled sucrose. The effect on endothelial permeability induced by menadione was dose-dependent and reversible. These permeability changes preceded the onset of cell death, as assessed by the Trypan blue exclusion method. Pre-incubation with superoxide dismutase and catalase blocked changes in sucrose permeability to control levels in a dose-dependent manner, suggesting the involvement of reactive oxygen species in menadione-induced BBB opening.     

Immortalized mouse brain endothelial cells are ultrastructurally similar to endothelial cells and respond to astrocyte-conditioned medium

Summary Studies of brain microvessel endothelial cell physiology and blood-brain barrier properties are often hampered by the requirement of repeatedly producing and characterizing primary endothelial cell cultures. The use of viral oncogenes to produce several immortalized brain microvessel cell lines has been reported. The resulting cell lines express many properties of the blood-brain barrier phenotype but do not completely mimic primary endothelial cells in culture. As immortalized brain microvessel endothelial cell lines have not yet been produced from mice, we transformed mouse brain endothelial cells with the adenovirus E1A gene using a retroviral vector (DOL). Eight of 11 clones produced exhibited an endothelial-like cobblestone morphology and were characterized as endothelial with a panel of antibodies, lectins, and ultrastructural criteria. These cells are endothelial in origin and share ultrastructural features with primary cultures of endothelial cells. Examination of freeze fracture and transmission electron micrographs show adherens junctions exist between the transformed cells, and culture in astrocyte-conditioned medium induces the formation of gap junctions. This is one indication that responses to astrocyte-derived factors are retained by the transformed cell lines.     

Butyric acid mediated induction of enhanced transendothelial resistance in an in vitro model blood-brain barrier system.

Previously we reported that the co-culture of non-brain vascular endothelial cells with glioma cells leads to the induction of a more differentiated endothelial cell phenotype which exhibits important properties of the blood-brain barrier (BBB). Recognising the potential for improving the model barrier system with agents known to modify the growth and differentiation of cells in culture we examined the effects of four differentiating agents (butyric acid, dexamethasone, retinoic acid, and dimethyl sulfoxide) on barrier function. Of these agents only butyric acid and dexamethasone resulted in an enhancement (depending on the dose used) of transendothelial electrical resistance (barrier function). The greatest effect was observed with butyric acid in a dose-dependent manner and was slow in onset and only occurred in the endothelial/glial cell co-cultures. These data indicate that butyric acid may be a beneficial agent in optimising conditions necessary for induction of BBB properties in in vitro barrier systems.     

Hyperammonemia induces transport of taurine and creatine and suppresses claudin-12 gene expression in brain capillary endothelial cells in vitro

Ammonia is a key neurotoxin involved in the neurological complications of acute liver failure. The present study was undertaken to study the effects of exposure to pathophysiologically relevant concentrations of ammonium chloride on cultured brain capillary endothelial cells in order to identify mechanisms by which ammonia may alter blood-brain barrier function. Conditionally immortalized mouse brain capillary endothelial cells (TM-BBB) were used as an in vitro model of the blood-brain barrier. Gene expression of a series of blood-brain barrier transporters and tight junction proteins was assessed by quantitative real time PCR analysis. Exposure to ammonia (5mM for 72h) resulted in significant increases in mRNA levels of taurine transporter (TAUT; 2.0-fold increase) as well as creatine transporter (CRT; 1.9-fold increase) whereas claudin-12 mRNA expression was significantly reduced to 67.7% of control levels. Furthermore, [(3)H]taurine and [(14)C]creatine uptake were concomitantly increased following exposure to ammonia, suggesting that up-regulation of both TAUT and CRT under hyperammonemic conditions results in an increased function of these two transporters in TM-BBB cells. TAUT and CRT are respectively involved in osmoregulation and energy buffering in the brain, two systems that are thought to be affected in acute liver failure. Furthermore, claudin-12 down-regulation suggests that hyperammonemia may also affect tight junction integrity. Our results provide evidence that ammonia can alter brain capillary endothelial cell gene expression and transporter function. These findings may be relevant to pathological situations involving hyperammonemia, such as liver disease.     

Synergistic stimulation of gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase and alkaline phosphatase activities by retinoic acid and astroglial factors in immortalized rat brain microvessel endothelial cells

The immortalized rat brain microvessel endothelial cell line RBE4 was used to investigate the in vitro regulation of two blood-brain barrier specific enzymes, gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase (GTP) and alkaline phosphatase (ALP). The effects of bFGF, astroglial factors, and retinoic acid (a cell differentiation agent) on GTP and ALP activities were separately or simultaneously studied in order to define optimal culture conditions for induction of these two specific enzymes of the blood-brain barrier. In the present study, a phenotypically distinct subpopulation of endothelial cells has been shown to develop from confluent cobblestone monolayers of RBE4 immortalized cerebral endothelial cells. These distinct cells were present within multicellular aggregates and specifically exhibited GTP and ALP activities. Addition of bFGF, astroglial factors, or retinoic acid induced the formation of these three-dimensional structures and in consequence an increase in GTP and ALP activities. For retinoic acid and astroglial factors, this increase could also be explained by the stimulation of either GTP or ALP expression in the phenotypically distinct positive cells associated with aggregates. Simultaneous treatment with retinoic acid and astroglial factors had a synergistic effect on GTP and ALP expression and thus may allow these distinct cells to evolve toward a more differentiated state. Since such results were also obtained with physiological concentrations of retinoic acid, we suggest that addition of this agent might contribute to greater differentiation of cells in in vitro blood-brain barrier models where endothelial cells are cocultured with astrocytes. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Alterations in Transendothelial Electrical Resistance by Vasoactive Agonists and Cyclic AMP in a Blood-Brain Barrier Model System

We have previously reported that the co-culture of endothelial and glioma cell lines provides an in vitro model for investigating properties of the blood-brain barrier (BBB). To characterise the model system further we have investigated the effects of vasoactive substances implicated in increases in BBB permeability. Additionally, we have also examined whether activation of cyclic AMP signalling pathways, which elevate cerebral endothelial cell barrier function, similarly modulate our model system. ATP, histamine, bradykinin, and serotonin significantly decreased model BBB transendothelial electrical resistance and manipulations which elevate cyclic AMP enhanced culture resistance. These data indicate that our model BBB system responds in a manner characteristic of cerebral microvascular endothelial cells and the BBB in vivo. These data further emphasize the usefulness of our model system.     

Lipids in blood-brain barrier models in vitro II: Influence of glial cells on lipid classes and lipid fatty acids

Lipids of brain tissue and brain microvascular endothelial cells contain high proportions of long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (long PUFAs). The blood-brain barrier (BBB) is formed by the brain endothelial cells under the inductive influence of brain cells, especially perivascular glia, and coculture of endothelial cells and glial cells has been used to examine this induction. The objective of this study was to investigate whether C6 glioma cells are able to influence the lipid composition and shift the fatty acid (FA) patterns of the BBB model cell lines RBE4 and ECV304 toward the in vivo situation. Lipid classes of the three cell lines were analyzed by thin-layer chromatography and lipid FA patterns by high-performance liquid chromatography. Only ECV304 cells showed altered lipid composition in coculture with C6 cells. The fractions of triglycerides and cholesteryl esters (depending on the support filter) were about twice as high in coculture as when the cells were grown alone. Triglyceride fractions reached 13 to 15% of total lipids in coculture. The three cell lines showed an increase in the percentage of long PUFAs with respect to unsaturated FAs, mainly because of an increase in the percentages of arachidonic acid, all cis-7,10,13,16-docosatetraenoic acid, and all cis-7,10,13,16,19-docosapentaenoic acid. It is concluded that glioma C6 cells are able to induce a more in vivo-like FA pattern in BBB cell culture models. However, changes were not significant for the individual PUFAs, and their levels did not reach in vivo values.     

Cilostazol Strengthens Barrier Integrity in Brain Endothelial Cells

We studied the effect of cilostazol, a selective inhibitor of phosphodiesterase 3, on barrier functions of blood–brain barrier (BBB)-related endothelial cells, primary rat brain capillary endothelial cells (RBEC), and the immortalized human brain endothelial cell line hCMEC/D3. The pharmacological potency of cilostazol was also evaluated on ischemia-related BBB dysfunction using a triple co-culture BBB model (BBB Kit?) subjected to 6-h oxygen glucose deprivation (OGD) and 3-h reoxygenation. There was expression of phosphodiesterase 3B mRNA in RBEC, and a significant increase in intracellular cyclic AMP (cAMP) content was detected in RBEC treated with both 1 and 10 μM cilostazol. Cilostazol increased the transendothelial electrical resistance (TEER), an index of barrier tightness of interendothelial tight junctions (TJs), and decreased the endothelial permeability of sodium fluorescein through the RBEC monolayer. The effects on these barrier functions were significantly reduced in the presence of protein kinase A (PKA) inhibitor H-89. Microscopic observation revealed smooth and even localization of occludin immunostaining at TJs and F-actin fibers at the cell borders in cilostazol-treated RBEC. In hCMEC/D3 cells treated with 1 and 10 μM cilostazol for 24 and 96 h, P-glycoprotein transporter activity was increased, as assessed by rhodamine 123 accumulation. Cilostazol improved the TEER in our triple co-culture BBB model with 6-h OGD and 3-h reoxygenation. As cilostazol stabilized barrier integrity in BBB-related endothelial cells, probably via cAMP/PKA signaling, the possibility that cilostazol acts as a BBB-protective drug against cerebral ischemic insults to neurons has to be considered.     

Permeability of bovine brain microvessel endothelial cells in vitro: barrier tightening by a factor released from astroglioma cells.

It has been shown both in vivo and in culture that astrocytes communicate with brain microvessel endothelial cells (BMECs) to induce many of the blood-brain barrier characteristics attributed to these unique cells. However, the results using cultured cells are conflicting as to whether this communication is dependent upon cell-cell contact. In this study we used primary cultures of bovine BMECs grown as monolayers on polycarbonate filters to study the formation of the barrier in vitro and examine its modulation by rat C6 glioma cells. Effects were examined by treating postconfluent BMEC monolayers with medium conditioned continually by C6 cells from the basolateral side to mimic the in vivo orientation. Cell monolayer integrity was assessed using electrical resistance and by measuring diffusion of uncharged molecules. BMEC monolayers form a functionally polarized and leaky barrier, with maximal resistance of 160 omega . cm2 and significant flux of molecules of molecular weight less than 350 Da. Treatment with rat or human astroglioma cells rather than pericytoma cells or transformed fibroblasts results in a concentration-dependent 200-440% increase in electrical resistance and a coincident 50% decrease in permeability to sucrose and dextran (70 kDa). The decrease in passive diffusion is most likely due to a change in tight junctions and not to transcellular vesicular traffic. The findings support that astroglioma cells release one or more signals that are required for cultured BMECs to express a "differentiated" phenotype associated with a tighter barrier, increased gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase activity, and decreased pinocytic activity. The relative ease and quickness of this culture system makes it amenable to studies on cell-cell interaction and regulation of barrier maintenance.     

Activation of AMP-activated protein kinase alleviates High-glucose-induced dysfunction of brain microvascular endothelial cell tight-junction dynamics

The blood-brain barrier, formed by specialized brain endothelial cells that are interconnected by tight junctions, strictly regulates paracellular permeability to maintain an optimal extracellular environment for brain homeostasis. Diabetes is known to compromise the blood-brain barrier, although the underlying mechanism remains unknown. The aim of this study was to elucidate the molecular mechanisms underlying disruption of the blood-brain barrier in diabetes and to determine whether activation of AMP-activated protein kinase prevents diabetes-induced blood-brain barrier dysfunction. Exposure of human brain microvascular endothelial cells to high glucose (25mmol/L d-glucose), but not to high osmotic conditions (20mmol/L l-glucose plus 5mmol/L d-glucose), for 2h to 1 week significantly increased the permeability of the blood-brain barrier in parallel with lowered expression levels of zonula occludens-1, occludin, and claudin-5, three proteins that are essential to maintaining endothelial cell tight junctions. In addition, high glucose significantly increased the generation of superoxide anions. Adenoviral overexpression of superoxide dismutase or catalase significantly attenuated the high-glucose-induced reduction of endothelial cell tight-junction proteins. Furthermore, administration of apocynin reversed the effects of high glucose on endothelial cell tight-junction proteins. Finally, activation of AMP-activated protein kinase with 5-amino-4-imidazole carboxamide riboside or adenoviral overexpression of constitutively active AMP-activated protein kinase mutants abolished both the induction of NAD(P)H oxidase-derived superoxide anions and the tight-junction protein degradation induced by high glucose. We conclude that high glucose increases blood-brain barrier dysfunction in diabetes through induction of superoxide anions and that the activation of AMP-activated protein kinase protects the integrity of the blood-brain barrier by suppressing the induction of NAD(P)H oxidase-derived superoxide anions.     

Drug metabolizing enzymes in cerebrovascular endothelial cells afford a metabolic protection to the brain.

The brain is partially protected from chemical insults by a physical barrier mainly formed by the cerebral microvasculature, which prevents penetration of hydrophilic molecules in the cerebral extracellular space. This results from the presence of tight junctions joining endothelial cells, and from a low transcytotic activity in endothelial cells, inducing selective permeability properties of cerebral microvessels that characterize the blood-brain barrier. The endothelial cells provide also, as a result of their drug-metabolizing enzymes activities, a metabolic barrier against potentially penetrating lipophilic substances. It has been established that in cerebrovascular endothelial cells, several families of enzymes metabolize potentially toxic lipophilic substrates from both endogenous and exogenous origin to polar metabolites, which may not be able to penetrate further across the blood-brain barrier. Enzymes of drug metabolism present at brain interfaces devoid of blood-brain barrier, like circumventricular organs, pineal gland, and hypophysis, that are potential sites of entry for xenobiotics, display higher activities than in cerebrovascular endothelial cells, and conjugation activities are very high in the choroid plexus. Finally, xenobiotic metabolism normally results in detoxication, but also in some cases in the formation of pharmacologically active or neurotoxic products, possibly altering some blood-brain barrier properties.     

Effect of astroglial cells on hypoxia-induced permeability in PBMEC cells

An in vitro model of the blood-brain barrier (BBB),consisting of porcine brain-derived microvascular endothelial cells(PBMEC), was used to evaluate the effect of astrocytes in theBBB disruption during hypoxia. Hypoxia-induced hyperpermeability wasdecreased significantly in a coculture model of astroglia cells, either astrocytes or C6 glioma cells, with PBMEC and, to the same extent, whenglia cell-conditioned medium was used. Corresponding to effects onhypoxia-induced hyperpermeability, astrocyte- and C6 cell-conditioned medium diminished hypoxia-induced vascular endothelial growth factor(VEGF) mRNA and protein expression, which recently was shown to beresponsible for hypoxia-induced permeability changes in vitro. Theeffect on hypoxia-induced hyperpermeability and VEGF expression wasspecific for astroglia cells because conditioned medium from bovinesmooth muscle cells (BSMC) did not show any effect. Immunocytochemistryrevealed that 24 h of hypoxia disrupted the continuity of thetight junction protein, zonula occludens-1 (ZO-1), which lines thecytoplasmic face of intact tight junctions. These changes wereprevented when hypoxia was performed in glia cell-conditioned medium.Results suggest that astrocytes protect the BBB from hypoxia-inducedparacellular permeability changes by decreasing hypoxia-induced VEGFexpression in microvascular endothelial cells.