Impacts of recreational trampling on sub-alpine vegetation and soils in Northwest Yunnan, China

Controlled trampling experiments were undertaken to assess impacts of recreation in a sub-alpine environment in an upper-Mekong mountainous protected area in China. Hiking and recreational horse-riding were applied at different trampling intensity to two typical, widespread vegetation types (Carex grassland and low Rhododendron shrubland) and trampling effects were assessed to study vegetation resistance and soil compaction. The results indicate: (1) low shrub vegetation is highly vulnerable to trampling damage while the graminoids-dominated grassland is more resistant; (2) dry soil with low organic matter, which often is found in the shrubland, is more susceptible to compaction than wet soil and (3) horses cause substantially more damage than hikers at equivalent trampling levels. These data are useful to develop a visitor’s management strategy that allows to minimize the impact from recreation on the vegetation.     

Impacts of recreational trampling on sub-alpine vegetation and soils in Northwest Yunnan, China

Controlled trampling experiments were undertaken to assess impacts of recreation in a sub-alpine environment in an upper-Mekong mountainous protected area in China. Hiking and recreational horse-riding were applied at different trampling intensity to two typical, widespread vegetation types (Carex grassland and low Rhododendron shrubland) and trampling effects were assessed to study vegetation resistance and soil compaction. The results indicate: (1) low shrub vegetation is highly vulnerable to trampling damage while the graminoids-dominated grassland is more resistant; (2) dry soil with low organic matter, which often is found in the shrubland, is more susceptible to compaction than wet soil and (3) horses cause substantially more damage than hikers at equivalent trampling levels. These data are useful to develop a visitor’s management strategy that allows to minimize the impact from recreation on the vegetation.     

Experimental assessment of initial revegetation on abandoned paths in temperate deciduous forest

Question: Do soil treatments and addition of seed facilitate rapid vegetation restoration on forest paths excluded from trampling? Location: Six mesophilic mixed deciduous Querco‐Fagetea forests in Flanders, northern Belgium. Methods: Enclosures on paths were excluded from trampling by fencing. In a full factorial design, plots were subjected to seeding, soil scarification, addition of organic material and inoculum. The following two years, seedling establishment and growth were sampled during spring and summer. Soil treatments and seeding effect was tested and seedling occurrence was analysed in relation to species' origin. Results: Spontaneous re vegetation was significant in all plots since fencing. Throughout the observation period seedling cover and height continued to increase. Seeding had an overall effect on seedling density, cover and height. Some soil treatment interactions significantly enhance re vegetation, although each individual soil treatment had no significant effect. Regardless of the seeded individuals, invading species mostly originated from the surrounding area and the seed bank. Conclusion: The preliminary results of this experiment imply that seeding is the only treatment which has a positive effect on re vegetation success in all circumstances, provided that the exclusion from trampling is effective.     

Effects of trampling and vegetation removal on species diversity and micro-environment under different shade conditions

Abstract. The effects of disturbance by trampling and vegetation removal on herbaceous communities and their micro-environments were examined at two sites with different levels of shade. The dominant species of the original vegetation were the perennial herb Artemisia princeps at the sunny site and the dwarf-bamboo Pleioblastus chino at the shady site. With no disturbance and marked dominance of these species, diversity was low. After vegetation removal there was a rapid recovery, leading to a more diverse vegetation with many more species, each with a lower dominance. Continuous trampling induced a short vegetation while the light intensity under the foliage was increased. At the sunny site, species richness was depressed by trampling because the soil water potential decreased markedly during summer and only the stress-tolerant annual Digitaria adscendens grew vigorously. Thus, the lowest species diversity was observed in the heavily trampled vegetation in late summer. At the shady site, soil water availability was not affected by trampling. This allowed the survival of many species and prevented a strong decline in diversity. The results suggest that the pattern of change in diversity in communities subjected to various disturbances, was always determined by the original environments.     

The impact of trampling by tourists on a high altitudinal grassland in the Tyrolean Alps,Austria

The long term effect of tourist trampling on a high altitudinal grassland (Caricion curvulae) in the Tyrolean Alps was investigated.Even under slight trampling the frequency of sensitive species decreases. The most sensitive species were found to be fruticose lichens, followed by mosses, some forbs and broadleaved grasses. Tolerant to trampling are the dominant species Carex curvula, and Ligusticum mutellina, which do not disappear completely even at a tourist frequency of 150 tourists per metre per day. Trampling increases soil bulk density moderately but has no marked effect on the soil water content.Comparison with high alpine sedge heath vegetation in North America shows a surprising uniformity of this vegetation type in response to trampling and also indicates that the common generalisation that alpine ecosystems are fragile and sensitive to disturbance does not hold true in this context. Furthermore these results represent evidence against the theory that ecosystems with low diversity are much more sensitive to arteficial impact than ecosystems with high diversity. However, if even the most resistant plants which are the dominant sedges are destroyed completely the rate of recovery is very low and may last for a long time. In the case of Carex curvula this is supported by the fact that it has very low seed production and grows mainly vegetatively. The rate of spread of the rhizome system of this species is 8 mm in 10 years. Similar figures may apply for the sedge species dominating in the alpine vegetation of North America. Thus fragility of this vegetation in regard to trampling does not mean low tolerance but low regeneration.Nomenclature of species follows Ehrendorfer (1973) for vascular plants and Poelt (1974) for lichens.The PCA calculations were done at the Computer laboratory of the University of Wales during a post doctoral stay at the School of Plant Biology in Bangor, U.K. I would like to record my thanks to Prof. Dr. P. Greig-Smith for fruitful discussions and reading the draft.     

Vegetation dynamics following trampling in grassland and heathland in Sølendet Nature Reserve, a boreal upland area in Central Norway

Trampling is recognised as a cause of disturbance in grassland and heathland vegetation along two public nature trails in Sølendet nature reserve in central Norway. The effects of trampling by visitors and of controlled trampling were monitored over a period of 5–7 years in permanent plots. A retrogressive development was recorded as vegetation cover and height were reduced and a substantial loss of species richness and biomass took place. Some species, mainly graminoids such as Agrostis capillaris and Carex vaginata , initially appeared to be more tolerant, but were eventually reduced as well. Low, geophytic and prostrate habits of growth and hardy leaf tissues seemed to be beneficial for tolerance to trampling. Moist grassland and lichen-dominated heathland were more vulnerable to trampling than dry grassland. Even though 350–1500 visitors walked through the permanent plots along the trails each summer, effects on the soil surface remained moderate and only a minor furrow was visible on the ground.     

Cattle grazing, raptor abundance and small mammal communities in Mediterranean grasslands

Abundance and diversity of small mammals are usually affected strongly by grazing either due to decreased food availability or quality, decreased suitability of soil for building burrow systems due to trampling and/or due to increased predation risk in the structurally simpler grazed areas. We estimated the effects of grazing-induced changes in vegetation and soil and of increased predation on small mammals in a Mediterranean grassland landscape. We measured vegetation structure, soil compaction and small mammal abundance and species composition in 22 plots of 8 Sherman live traps each, arranged according to an unbalanced two-way ANOVA design with two grazing levels (grazed areas and cattle exclosures) and two predator abundance levels (increased densities of Eurasian kestrels Falco tinnunculus by means of nest boxes and control). Plots were sampled during 2 consecutive years in early summer and early fall. Exclosure from cattle increased significantly vegetation height and volume and decreased soil compaction. Grazing-induced changes in vegetation height and volume and in soil compaction produced strong effects on small mammal abundance and species richness. Increased kestrel densities did not have significant additive or interactive effects, with the effects of grazing-induced vegetation and soil gradients on abundance or richness of small mammals. Our results suggest that the effects of grazing on small mammal communities in Mediterranean montane grasslands were mainly due to reduced food availability and by negative effects of trampling on the suitability of soils for building burrow systems. Decreased food quality and increased predation in grazed areas seemed to play a minor role, if any. Reductions in stock densities would then favor generalist predator populations in Mediterranean grasslands through the expected positive effects of such reductions on the availability of food and burrows for small mammals.     

Disturbance of suburban Fagus forests by recreational activities: Effects on soil characteristics,above‐ground vegetation and seed bank

Questions: How does recreational disturbance (human trampling) affect soil characteristics, the performance of the understorey vegetation, and the density and species composition of the soil seed bank in Fagus sylvatica forests? Location: Suburban forests near Basel, northwestern Switzerland. Methods: We compared various soil characteristics and the performance of the understorey vegetation in six beech forest areas frequently disturbed by recreational activities with those in six undisturbed control areas, in spring 2003. In the same forest areas, the soil seed bank was investigated using the seedling emergence method. Samples were obtained from soil cores in January 2003. Results: We found substantial changes in soil compaction, above‐ground vegetation and in the soil seed bank due to recreational activities. In frequently visited areas, soil compaction was enhanced which caused a decrease in cover, height and species richness of both herb and shrub layers. Compared with control areas, the number of trampling‐tolerant species of the seed bank was significantly higher in disturbed areas, and total species richness tended to be higher in disturbed than in control areas. Furthermore, the similarity in species composition between the above‐ground vegetation and seed bank was significant lower in disturbed than in control areas. Conclusions: The intensive use of suburban forests for recreational activities, mainly picnicking, affects the vegetation of natural beech forests. Our study indicates that a restoration of degraded forest areas from the soil seed bank would result in a substantial change of the vegetation composition.     

水源圈研究进展

在干旱、半干旱区草场上,由于饮水的需求导致牲畜经常性地集中在水源点周围,从而使草地生态系统以水源点为中心呈梯度退化,形成水源圈.按照放牧影响程度的大小,以水源点为中心由内向外可将水源圈划分为“牺牲带”、过渡带和自然带3部分,水源圈内的植被、土壤等对放牧的响应也呈梯度变化.由于水源圈内存在着“天然的放牧梯度”,使其成为研究放牧对植被、土壤的影响和自然资源保护及其可持续利用的绝佳场所.本文对水源圈的概念、研究的发展历程和研究方法等进行了综述,并对国内研究现状进行了评述,以促进干旱、半干旱区草场的科学管理和可持续利用.     

践踏干扰对碧塔海高寒草甸植被茎叶性状、物种多样性和功能多样性的影响

高寒草甸具有重要的生态服务功能,然而固有脆弱性使其极易遭受气候变化和人为干扰等多重因素的影响。作为滇西北旅游资源中重要的组分之一,高寒草甸吸引了大批游客前往开展徒步旅行活动,但伴随着的践踏干扰作用会不可避免地对高寒草甸生态系统带来负面影响。然而,目前关注践踏干扰对滇西北高寒草甸植被的影响,特别是植被功能性状和功能多样性如何发生变化方面的研究还十分欠缺。以云南省香格里拉市碧塔海自然保护区内的典型高寒草甸生态系统为研究对象,采用实验践踏的方式(一共5种不同强度的践踏处理)来模拟旅游活动对草甸植被的干扰作用,并以草甸植被的茎叶性状特征为切入点,重点探讨践踏干扰对茎叶性状的平均大小和变异程度的影响,以及物种丰富度(以物种形态分类为基础)和功能丰富度(以功能性状为基础)之间的关系。研究结果显示,随着践踏强度的增加,植株高度和叶片大小的平均值,而不是茎叶性状的变异程度,出现明显下降趋势。此外,物种丰富度和功能丰富度均随践踏强度的增强而减小,且两者之间呈现显著正相关关系。然而,较之轻度践踏实验组,重度践踏实验组中的功能均匀度和功能分离度水平均有所增加,表明践踏干扰可能会在短期内打破优势种对资源的绝对占有格局和减少物种间的生态位重叠程度。尽管高寒草甸对人类践踏活动有一定的承受能力,但气候变化和人为干扰等多重因素势必会改变和影响高寒草甸群落的结构和功能可持续性,这也对高寒草甸的保护与管理工作提出了更加紧迫的要求。     

The effects of habitat edges and trampling on understorey vegetation in urban forests in Helsinki,Finland

Question: How do habitat edges and trampling affect mesic (Myrtillus type) understorey vegetation in fragmented urban forests, and what are the relative strengths and spatial extent of these effects? Location: The city of Helsinki, southern Finland. Methods: Vegetation sample plots were placed at different distances from the forest edge. At each distance we selected plots on, next to and away from paths of different levels of wear, and the covers and frequencies of plant species were sampled. We used generalized linear mixed models and ordination techniques to test our hypotheses. Results: The effect of the edge penetrated up to 50 m into the forest interior. Only light effects of trampling were found in seemingly untrampled areas, in addition to the direct effects of trampling on the paths. Both trampling and edge effects changed the forest understorey species composition. Trampling changed plant species composition locally on paths, and provided opportunities for new species to establish in previously unbroken forest vegetation. Urban forest edges were characterised by species better adapted to sunny, warm and dry conditions. These species, such as grasses, replaced more sensitive forest species, such as dwarf shrubs and mosses. We observed a large number of light demanding deciduous trees at the edges, which may be one of the factors increasing soil fertility and consequently promoting the high abundance of fast growing species, such as grasses and herbs related to more fertile site types. Conclusions: We recommend that urban forest fragments left within urban development should be at least 2–3 ha in size and that the shape of the patch and the number of potential recreational users should be taken into account when preserving true forest understorey vegetation from the effects of edges and trampling.     

Grazing changes topography-controlled topsoil properties and their interaction on different spatial scales in a semi-arid grassland of Inner Mongolia, P.R. China

Semiarid steppe ecosystems account for large terrestrial areas and are considered as large carbon (C) sinks. However, fundamental information on topsoil sensitivity to grazing is lacking across different spatial scales including the effects of topography. Our interdisciplinary approach considering soil chemical, physical, and vegetation properties included investigations on pit scale (square-metre scale), plot scale (hectare scale), and the scale of a landscape section (several hectares). Five different sites, representing a grazing intensity gradient, ranging from a long-term grazing exclosure to a heavily grazed site were used. On the pit scale, data about aggregate size distribution, quantity of different soil organic carbon (SOC) pools, SOC mineralisation, hydraulic conductivity and shear strength was available for topsoil samples from representative soil profiles. Spatial variability of topographical parameters, topsoil texture, bulk density, SOC, water repellency, and vegetation cover was analysed on the basis of regular, orthogonal grids in differently grazed treatments by using two different grid sizes on the plot scale and landscape section. On the pit scale, intensive grazing clearly decreased soil aggregation and the amount of fresh, litter-like particulate organic matter (POM). The weak aggregation in combination with animal trampling led to an enhanced mineralisation of SOC, higher topsoil bulk densities, lower infiltration rates, and subsequently to a higher risk of soil erosion. On the plot scale, the effects of soil structure disruption due to grazing are enhanced by the degradation of vegetation patches and resulted in a texture-controlled wettability of the soil surface. In contrast, topsoils of grazing exclosures were characterised by advantageous mechanical topsoil characteristics and SOC-controlled wettability due to higher POM contents. A combined geostatistical and General Linear Model approach identified topography as the fundamental factor creating the spatial distribution of texture fractions and related soil parameters on the scale of a landscape section. Grazing strongly interfered with the topography-controlled particle relocation processes in the landscape and showed strongest effects on the aboveground biomass production and biomass-related soil properties like SOC stocks. We conclude that interdisciplinary multi-scale analyses are essential (i) to differentiate between topography- and grazing-controlled spatial patterns of topsoil and vegetation properties, and (ii) to identify the main grazing-sensitive processes on small scales that are interacting with the spatial distribution and relocation processes on larger scales.     

水源圈研究进展

在干旱、半干旱区草场上,由于饮水的需求导致牲畜经常性地集中在水源点周围,从而使草地生态系统以水源点为中心呈梯度退化,形成水源圈.按照放牧影响程度的大小,以水源点为中心由内向外可将水源圈划分为“牺牲带”、过渡带和自然带3部分,水源圈内的植被、土壤等对放牧的响应也呈梯度变化.由于水源圈内存在着“天然的放牧梯度”,使其成为研究放牧对植被、土壤的影响和自然资源保护及其可持续利用的绝佳场所.本文对水源圈的概念、研究的发展历程和研究方法等进行了综述,并对国内研究现状进行了评述,以促进干旱、半干旱区草场的科学管理和可持续利用.     

Vertical seed distribution in the soil constrains regeneration of Bromus pictus in a Patagonian steppe

Question: What is the effect of vertical seed distribution (i.e. seeds on soil surface or buried) and the relative importance of vertical and horizontal seed distribution (i.e. seeds near established vegetation or near bare soil) for seedling emergence? Location: Patagonian arid steppe. Methods: To evaluate the effect of vertical seed distribution on seedling emergence, four sowing treatments were used in field and greenhouse experiments. Vertical vs. horizontal seed distribution and the occurrence of seedlings were analysed in the field. Effects of trampling and mechanical drilling on seedling emergence were investigated experimentally in the field. Results: In field and glasshouse experiments buried seeds showed a higher emergence and larger seedling size than seeds lying on the soil surface. The observational field study indicated that natural emergence was not associated with particular microsites or plant cover (horizontal distribution), but that most seedlings emerged from buried positions (vertical distribution). Buried seeds represented less than 10% of the sampled seed cohort but account for almost 60% of the seedlings. The trampling/drilling experiment showed that sheep trampling and mechanical drilling increased seedling emergence compared to non‐treated controls. Conclusions: The population dynamics of Bromus pictus is strongly constrained by the vertical position of seeds, which largely affects emergence, and seed horizontal distribution, which largely affects seedling survival. Our results showed that sheep trampling after seed dispersal may be a low‐input technique for increasing grass recruitment.     

五大连池药泉山大型土壤动物对旅游踩踏的响应

以黑龙江省五大连池世界地质公园的药泉山为研究对象,按照距离游道的远近分为重度踩踏区,轻度踩踏区和非踩踏区3种踩踏干扰强度,分析大型土壤动物数量,群落组成,多样性对旅游踩踏干扰的响应。研究结果表明不同干扰区之间大型土壤动物类群数量差异显著(P0.001),重度踩踏区显著低于轻度踩踏区和非踩踏区。不同干扰区大型土壤动物个体数差异明显(P0.001),其中轻度踩踏区个体密度最大(68头/m~2),重度踩踏区个体密度最小(10头/m~2)。不同踩踏强度干扰区H'指数差异明显(P0.05),轻度踩踏区及非踩踏区的多样性显著高于严重踩踏区。典型对应分析表明旅游踩踏主要通过改变土壤理化特性而影响大型土壤动物的组成及其多样性,重度踩踏区、轻度踩踏区和非踩踏区对大型土壤动物影响最显著的因子分别为土壤全氮含量,土壤含水率和土壤全磷含量。     

Disturbance of forest by trampling: Effects on mycorrhizal roots of seedlings and mature trees of Fagus sylvatica

The effects of disturbance by recreational activities (trampling) on changes in soil organic matter (SOM) and on mycorrhizal roots of seedlings and mature trees were studied in four stands of a beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) forest near Basel, Switzerland. At each site, comparable disturbed and undisturbed plots were selected. Disturbance reduced ground cover vegetation and leaf litter. Beech seedlings had lower biomass after disturbance. Ergosterol concentration in seedling roots, an indicator of mycorrhizal fungi, was lower in two of the four disturbed plots compared to undisturbed plots; these two disturbed sites had especially low litter levels. Based on ergosterol measurements, mycorrhizas of mature trees did not appear to be negatively affected by trampling. Total fine roots and SOM were higher in the disturbed than in the undisturbed plots at three sites. At the fourth site, fine roots and SOM in the disturbed areas were lower than in the undisturbed areas most probably due to nutrient input following picnic activities. Principal component analysis revealed a close correlation between SOM and fine roots of mature trees as well as litter and seedling biomass. Trampling due to recreational activities caused considerable damage to the vegetation layer and in particular to the beech seedlings and their mycorrhizal fine roots, whereas, roots of mature trees were apparently resilient to trampling.     

Effects of wear and above ground forest site type characteristics on the soil microbial community structure in an urban setting

We studied the effects of wear on the understorey vegetation and the soil microbial community structure (phospholipid fatty acid pattern) in urban forests of medium fertility and of varying size in the capital area of Finland, Helsinki. These forests are important sites of recreation for a large number of residents. Consequently, the cover of understorey vegetation is affected by trampling. In the study, the cover of ground layer plant species (mosses) was found to be lower than in rural reference areas. We found that microbial activity, measured as soil respiration, was lower in the most worn forest patches as compared to less worn sites. Further, the microbial community structure of the humus layer changed due to the effects of wear. By comparing the PLFA pattern in trampled and un-trampled forest patches, we found out that the most important factors affecting the structure of microbial community were the dominant tree species (the proportion of broad-leaved tree species in relation to conifers), and the composition of the understorey vegetation. Thus, we could conclude that wear affects the microbial community structure through changes in vegetation, in the quality of litter shed, and through resultant changes in the humus pH, rather than only through soil compaction.     

黄土高原封禁林地藓结皮呼吸速率对放牧踩踏干扰强度的响应

放牧踩踏造成的土壤属性变化是引起土壤呼吸速率和碳固排波动的重要原因,但目前有关不同强度放牧踩踏对生物结皮呼吸的影响尚不明确。本研究针对黄土高原风沙土发育的藓结皮,以未干扰为对照,分别进行强度为10%、30%、50%和70%的模拟放牧踩踏干扰,连续测定了藓结皮呼吸速率的变化,分析了藓结皮呼吸速率对不同干扰强度的响应规律。结果表明: 1)适度干扰会激发藓结皮呼吸速率,而重度干扰则会抑制其呼吸速率。与未干扰相比,干扰10%和30%的藓结皮呼吸速率分别增加了41.1%和22.2%,而干扰50%和70%的藓结皮呼吸速率则分别降低了8.9%和15.3%。2)踩踏干扰显著改变了土壤温度,但对土壤含水量的影响不显著。与未干扰相比,干扰10%和30%的土壤温度分别显著降低了0.4和1.2 ℃,干扰50%和70%则分别显著增加了1.1和1.0 ℃。3)不同干扰强度下藓结皮呼吸速率与土壤温度和含水量分别呈显著指数和线性正相关关系,但与藓结皮基本特性无显著相关关系,土壤温度和水分可分别解释藓结皮呼吸速率动态变化的70.6%～96.3%和49.1%～70.0%。综上,放牧踩踏显著影响了藓结皮呼吸速率,短期适度放牧踩踏会激发藓结皮呼吸速率,而过度放牧踩踏则会抑制其呼吸速率。因此,在未来黄土高原地区土壤碳收支平衡研究中应考虑不同强度放牧踩踏对生物结皮呼吸的影响。     

The Importance of Coprophagous Macrodetritivores for the Maintenance of Vegetation Heterogeneity in an African Savannah

Grazing ecosystems are often characterized by dynamic vegetation structure mosaics of short grazing lawns and tall grass vegetation that are important for the biodiversity and functioning of these ecosystems. Grazing-induced trampling, causing soil compaction and reduced water infiltration, has been shown to be an important mechanism for lawn grass formation. However, insights in reverse bioturbation mechanisms were mostly lacking, especially how tall vegetation persists under continuous grazing by herbivores. In this study, we explore if defecation by large herbivores in combination with different groups of coprophagous macrodetritivores can locally convert compacted grazing lawn patches back to tall bunch grasslands with a more loose soil. Across a rainfall gradient in an African savannah, we separated the potential roles in this process between dung beetles versus earthworms and termites. We placed different mesh sizes under dung piles and studied the consequences for soil, vegetation, and hydrological properties. We found that soil water infiltration rate, soil organic matter content, electrical conductivity, bunch grass cover, and bunch grass biomass were significantly promoted by dung addition, irrespective of position along the rainfall gradient. In addition, the presence of tunneling dung beetles significantly increased water infiltration rate and biomass of bunch grasses, pointing at a new mechanism whereby macrodetritivores affect the structure and diversity of plant communities. We conclude that coprophagous macrodetritivores interact with large herbivores in contributing to the maintenance of structural heterogeneity in the vegetation of grazing ecosystems, with a special role played by soil-tunneling dung beetles.