Interaction of high mobility group proteins HMG 1 and HMG 2 with nucleosomes studied by gel electrophoresis

The binding of isolated high mobility group proteins HMG (1+2) with nucleosomes was studied using gel electrophoresis. The interaction of HMG (1+2) with mononucleosomes could be detected as a new discrete electrophoretic band with a decreased mobility only after cross-linking of HMG (1+2)-nucleosome complex by formaldehyde. Approximately two molecules of the large HMG proteins were bound per nucleosomal particle of a DNA length of 185 base pairs, lacking histones H1 and H5. Using the same techniques, no binding was observed with core particles of a DNA length of 145 base pairs.     

Nonhistone nuclear high mobility group proteins 14 and 17 stabilize nucleosome core particles

Nucleosome core particles form well defined complexes with the nuclear nonhistone proteins HMG 14 or 17. The binding of HMG 14 or 17 to nucleosomes results in greater stability of the nucleosomal DNA as shown by circular dichroism and thermal denaturation. Under appropriate conditions the binding is cooperative, and cooperativity is ionic strength dependent. The specificity and cooperative transitions of high mobility group (HMG) binding are preserved in 1 M urea. Specificity is lost in 4 M urea. Thermal denaturation and circular dichroism show a dramatic reversal of the effects of urea on nucleosomes when HMG 14 or 17 is bound, indicating stabilization of the nucleosome by HMG proteins. Complexes formed between reconstructed nucleosomes containing purified inner histones plus poly(dA-dT) and HMG 14 or 17 demonstrate that the HMG binding site requires only DNA and histones. Electron microscopy reveals no major structural alterations in the nucleosome upon binding of HMG 14 or 17. Cross-linking the nucleosome extensively with formaldehyde under cooperative HMG binding conditions does not prevent the ionic strength-dependent shift to noncooperative binding. This suggests mechanisms other than internal nucleosome conformational changes may be involved in cooperative HMG binding.     

Primary organization of nucleosomes. Interaction of non-histone high mobility group proteins 14 and 17 with nucleosomes, as revealed by DNA-protein crosslinking and immunoaffinity isolation

The binding sites for histones and high mobility group proteins (HMG) 14 and 17 have been located on DNA in the nucleosomal cores and H1/H5-containing nucleosomes. The nucleosomes were specifically associated with two molecules of the non-histone proteins HMG 14 and/or HMG 17 when followed by DNA-protein crosslinking and immunoaffinity isolation of the crosslinked HMG-DNA complexes. HMGs 14 and 17 were shown to be crosslinked in a similar manner to each core DNA strand at four sites: to both 3' and 5' DNA ends and also at distances of about 25 and 125 nucleotides from the 5' termini of the DNA. These sites are designated as HMG(143), (0), (25) and (125). The site HMG(125) is located at the place where no significant histone-DNA crosslinking was observed. The HMG(125) and HMG(25) sites lie opposite one another on the complementary DNA strands across the minor DNA groove and are placed, similarly to histones, on the inner side of the DNA superhelix in the nucleosome. The crosslinking of HMG 17 to the 3' ends of the DNA is much weaker than that of HMG 14. These data indicate that each of two molecules of HMG 14 and/or HMG 17 is bound to the double-stranded core DNA at two discrete sites: to the 3' and 5' ends of the DNA and at a distance of 20 to 25 base-pairs from each DNA terminus inside the nucleosome on a histone-free DNA region. Binding of HMG 14 or 17 does not induce any detectable rearrangement of histones on DNA and both HMGs seem to choose the same sites for attachment in nucleosomal cores and H1/H5-containing nucleosomes.     

Effect of HMG protein 17 on the thermal stability of control and acetylated HeLa oligonucleosomes.

Many studies have implicated histone acetylation and HMG proteins 14 and 17 in the structure of active chromatin. Studies of the binding of HMG 14 and 17 to chromatin core particles have shown that there are two binding sites for HMG 14 or 17 located within 20-25 bp of the DNA ends of the core particles [13-15]. Such binding sites may result from the free DNA ends in the core particle being available for the binding of HMG 14 and 17. We have studied the effects of the binding of HMG 17 on the thermal denaturation of DNA in mono, di and trinucleosomes. In each case the binding of 1 HMG 17 molecule per nucleosome reduces the DNA premelt region by 50%, while the binding of 2 HMG 17 molecules per nucleosome abolishes the premelt region. From this it is concluded that there are two HMG 17 binding sites per nucleosome which are located between the entry and exit points to the nucleosome and the strongly complexed central DNA region. Highly acetylated mono, di and trinucleosomes have been isolated from butyrate treated HeLa S3 cells. For this series of acetylated oligonucleosomes, it has been found that there are also two HMG 17 binding sites per acetylated nucleosome.     

Interactions between HMG proteins and the core sequence of DNaseI hypersensitive site 2 in the locus control region (LCR) of the human β-like globin gene cluster

HMG proteins are abundant chromosomal non-histone proteins. It has been suggested that the HMG proteins may play an important role in the structure and function of chromatin. In the present study, the binding of HMG proteins (HMG1/2 and HMG14/17) to the core DNA sequence of DNaseI hypersensitive site 2 (HS2core DNA sequence, -10681--10970 bp) in the locus control region (LCR) of the human b-like globin gene cluster has been examined by using both the in vitro nucleosome reconstitution and the gel mobility shift assays. Here we show that HMG1/2 can bind to the naked HS2core DNA sequence, however, HMG14/17 cannot. Using the in vitro nucleosome reconstitution we demonstrate that HMG14/17 can bind to the HS2core DNA sequence which is assembled into nucleosomes with the core histone octamer transferred from chicken erythrocytes. In contrast, HMG1/2 cannot bind to the nucleosomes reconstituted in vitro with the HS2core DNA sequence. These results indicate that the binding patterns between HMG proteins and the HS2core DNA sequence which exists in different states (the naked DNA or the in vitro reconstituted nucleosomal DNA) are quite different. We speculate that HMG proteins might play a critical role in the regulation of the human β-like globin gene's expression.     

Modulation of histone H5-nucleosome interactions by H5 phosphorylation

In nucleosomal particles of 180 base pairs, part of the histone H5 binding site is preserved. After fluorescein labelling of H5 from chicken erythrocytes comparative equilibrium binding studies have been performed and on these particle as well as on core particles (140 base pairs) and on free DNA (180 base pairs). While nucleosomal particles can accommodate about the same number of H5 molecules as the free DNA derived from it, affinities are decreased by a factor of 3. A further decrease by factors of 3–4 is the consequence of phosphorylating three of the H5 serines: hence phosphorylation should facilitate thermodynamically controlled complexing of red cell chromatin during erythropoiesis. The most dramatic effect of an H5 phosphorylation is a reduction in the binding sites from 56 to 36 nucleotides (free DNA) and an even more pronounced effect upon interacting with nucleosomes which should make the H5-chromatin association sterically favourable. Related studies with protamines from herring are included for comparison.     

Interactions between HMG proteins and the core sequence of DNaseI hypersensitive site 2 in the locus control region (LCR) of the human β-like globin gene cluster

HMG proteins are abundant chromosomal non-histone proteins. It has been suggested that the HMG proteins may play an important role in the structure and function of chromatin. In the present study, the binding of HMG proteins (HMG1/2 and HMG14/17) to the core DNA sequence of DNaseI hypersensitive site 2 (HS2core DNA sequence, -10681-10970 bp) in the locus control region (LCR) of the human β-like globin gene cluster has been examined by using both thein vitro nucleosome reconstitution and the gel mobility shift assays. Here we show that HMG1/2 can bind to the naked HS2core DNA sequence, however, HMG14/17 cannot. Using thein vitro nucleosome reconstitution we demonstrate that HMG14/17 can bind to the HS2core DNA sequence which is assembled into nucleosomes with the core histone octamer transferred from chicken erythrocytes. In contrast, HMG1/2 cannot bind to the nucleosomes reconstitutedin vitro with the HS2core DNA sequence. These results indicate that the binding patterns between HMG proteins and the HS2core DNA sequence which exists in different states (the naked DNA or thein vitro reconstituted nucleosomal DNA) are quite different. We speculate that HMG proteins might play a critical role in the regulation of the human β-like globin gene’s expression.     

Interactions between HMG proteins and the core sequence of DNaseI hypersensitive site 2 in the locus control region (LCR) of the human β-like globin gene cluster

HMG proteins are abundant chromosomal non-histone proteins. It has been suggested that the HMG proteins may play an important role in the structure and function of chromatin. In the present study, the binding of HMG proteins (HMG1/2 and HMG14/17) to the core DNA sequence of DNaseI hypersensitive site 2 (HS2core DNA sequence, -10681-10970 bp) in the locus control region (LCR) of the human β-like globin gene cluster has been examined by using both thein vitro nucleosome reconstitution and the gel mobility shift assays. Here we show that HMG1/2 can bind to the naked HS2core DNA sequence, however, HMG14/17 cannot. Using thein vitro nucleosome reconstitution we demonstrate that HMG14/17 can bind to the HS2core DNA sequence which is assembled into nucleosomes with the core histone octamer transferred from chicken erythrocytes. In contrast, HMG1/2 cannot bind to the nucleosomes reconstitutedin vitro with the HS2core DNA sequence. These results indicate that the binding patterns between HMG proteins and the HS2core DNA sequence which exists in different states (the naked DNA or thein vitro reconstituted nucleosomal DNA) are quite different. We speculate that HMG proteins might play a critical role in the regulation of the human β-like globin gene’s expression.     

Nonhistone proteins HMG1 and HMG2 unwind DNA double helix.

In a previous communication we have shown that both HMG1 and HMG2 nonhistone proteins change the DNA helical structure and the binding of HMG1 and HMG2 to DNA induces a net unwinding equivalent of DNA double helix (Javaherian, K., Liu, L. F. and Wang, J. C. (1978) Science, 199, 1345-1346). Employing melting absorption technique, we now show that in the presence of salt HMG1 and HMG2 destabilize DNA whereas in the absence of salt, they both stabilize DNA molecules. Consequently the folded structure of HMG must play an important role in melting DNA. Furthermore, by measuring topological winding number using competition unwinding experiments, we conclude that HMG1 has a higher affinity for a single-stranded DNA relative to double-stranded DNA. These results together suggest that HMG1 and HMG2 unwind DNA double helix by local denaturation of the DNA base pairs. The net unwinding angles have been measured to be 22 degrees and 26 degrees per molecule of HMG1 and HMG2 respectively.     

Preferential in vitro binding of high mobility group proteins 14 and 17 to nucleosomes containing active and DNase I sensitive single-copy genes

High mobility group (HMG) proteins 14 and 17 bind to mononucleosomes in vitro, but the exact nature of this binding has not been clearly established. A new method was developed to allow direct membrane transfer of DNA from HMG 14/17 bound and unbound nucleosomes, which have been separated by acrylamide gel electrophoresis. Hybridization analysis of membranes obtained by this method revealed that the HMG 14/17 bound nucleosomes of avian erythrocytes and rat hepatic tumor (HTC) cells were enriched, about 2-fold, in actively transcribed genes and also inactive but DNase I sensitive genes. Nucleosomes containing inactive, DNase I resistant genes were bound by HMG 14/17, but not preferentially. Several factors that have been reported to greatly influence the binding of HMG 14/17 to nucleosomes in vitro were tested and shown to not account for the preferential binding to DNase I sensitive chromatin. These factors include nucleosomal linker DNA length, single-stranded DNA nicks, and DNA bulk hypomethylation. An additional factor, histone acetylation, was preferentially associated with the HMG 14/17 bound chromatin fraction of avian erythrocytes, but it was not associated with the HMG 14/17 bound chromatin fraction of metabolically active HTC cells. The latter finding was true for all kinetic forms of histone acetylation.     

The interaction of high mobility proteins HMG14 and 17 with nucleosomes.

The interaction of the high mobility group proteins, HMG14 and HMG17, with nucleosome core particles has been studied. The results show that two molecules of HMG14/17 can be bound tightly but reversibly to each core particle and that their affinity for core particles is greater than their affinity for histone-free DNA of core size. Thermal denaturation and nuclease digestion studies suggest that major sites of interaction are located near the ends of the nucleosome core DNA. When nucleosome preparations from chicken erythrocyte nuclei stripped of HMG proteins are partially titrated with HMG14/17, the nucleosome-HMG complex fraction is enriched in beta-globin gene sequences.     

Binding of high-mobility-group proteins HMG 14 and HMG 17 to DNA and histone H1 as influenced by phosphorylation

We have used affinity chromatography to study the effects of phosphorylation of calf thymus high-mobility-group proteins HMG 14 and HMG 17 on their binding properties towards calf thymus single- and double-stranded DNA and histone H1. Without in vitro phosphorylation, HMG 14 and HMG17 eluted from doble-stranded DNA-columns at 200 mM NaCl. HMG 14 was released from single-stranded DNA-column at 300 mM NaCl and from H1-column at 130 mM NaCl, whereas the corresponding values for HMG 17 were 230 mM and 20 mM, respectively. Phosphorylation of HMG 14 and HMG 17 by cAMP-dependent protein kinase (A-kinase) decreased markedly their affinity (270 mM and 200 mM NaCl, respectively) for single-stranded DNA, whereas HMG 14 phosphorylated by nuclear protein kinase II (NII-kinase) eluted only slightly (290 mM NaCl) ahead of the unphosphorylated protein. HMG 14 phosphorylated by both A-kinase and NII-kinase eluted from double-stranded DNA-columns almost identically (190 mM NaCl) with the unphosphorylated protein. Interestingly, phosphorylation of HMG 14 by NII-kinase increased considerably its affinity for histone H1 and the phosphorylated protein eluted at 200 mM NaCl. Phosphorylation of HMG 14 by A-kinase did not alter its interaction towards histone H1. These results indicate that modification of HMG 14 by phosphorylation at specific sites may have profound effects on its binding properties towards DNA and histone H1, and that HMG 17 has much weaker affinity for single-stranded DNA and histone H1 than HMG 14.     

Protein distribution amongst chromatin particles following DNAse II digestion

When active chromatin is released as a Mg-soluble fraction following digestion of nuclei with DNAse II, as concomitant release of HMG proteins, and hnRNP particles occurs. Release of HMG 14 and 17 is dependent on active chromatin release, whereas HMG 1 and 2, and hnRNP particles are released in an independent process. The Mg-soluble fraction comprises a heterogenous mixture of particles of less compact conformation than normal nucleosomes, and prone to protein-induced aggregation. Histone H1, and HMG 14 and 17 appear to be associated with these particles in a reversible manner, whereas HMG 1 and 2 are unbound.     

Binding of wheat and chicken high mobility group chromosomal proteins to DNA and to wheat and chicken mononucleosomes

We have used an electrophoretic retardation assay to investigate the interactions of wheat high mobility group (HMG) proteins with DNA and with isolated trimmed mononucleosomes (complexes which contain a histone octamer and approximately 146 base pairs of DNA). In order to characterize these interactions, we have compared the binding of each of the wheat HMG proteins, HMGa, b, c, and d, with those of the low molecular weight chicken HMG proteins HMG14 and 17. These vertebrate animal HMG proteins have previously been shown to occupy two specific binding sites on animal nucleosomes and to have a greater affinity for nucleosomes than for naked DNA (Mardian, J. K. W., Paton, A. E., Bunick, G. J., and Olins, D. E. (1980) Science 209, 1534-1536; Sandeen, G., Wood, W. I., and Felsenfeld, G. (1980) Nucleic Acids Res. 8, 3757-3778). As a criterion for "specific binding," we have used the property of HMG14 and 17 binding of causing a discontinuous shift of nucleosomes to a distinct band of lower electrophoretic mobility. According to this criterion, wheat HMGb, c, and d do not bind nucleosomes specifically. These HMG proteins have approximately the same affinity for nucleosomes and naked DNA. Wheat HMGa does bind nucleosomes specifically by this criterion, but other aspects of the binding are reminiscent of histone H1-nucleosome binding. We present evidence that trimmed mononucleosomes of wheat are conformationally distinct from their animal counterparts. Despite the conformational differences, competition studies indicate that chicken and wheat mononucleosomes have essentially identical affinity for the low molecular weight animal HMG proteins.     

Nonhistone chromosomal protein HMG 1 interactions with DNA. Fluorescence and thermal denaturation studies

The interaction of high mobility group protein 1 (HMG 1) isolated from chicken erythrocytes with DNA has been characterized using the intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence of the protein as a probe. It was found that the fluorescence is quenched approximately 30% upon binding to either single- or double-stranded DNA. Fluorescent titrations indicate that the physical site size for HMG 1 binding on native DNA is approximately 14 base pairs (or 14 bases for binding to single-stranded DNA). Binding to single-stranded poly(dA) is only slightly dependent on ionic strength, although the affinity for double-stranded DNA is strongly ionic strength-dependent and has an optimum at approximately 100-120 mM Na+. Above this range, binding to native DNA is virtually all electrostatic in nature. Although the affinity of HMG 1 for single-stranded DNA is higher than that for double-stranded DNA at the extremes of the ionic range studied, no clear evidence for a helix-destabilizing activity was obtained. At low ionic strength, the protein actually stabilized DNA against thermal denaturation, while at high ionic strength, HMG 1 appears to undergo denaturation below the Tm of the DNA. Studies of the environment of the tryptophan fluorophores using collisional quenchers iodide, cesium, and acrylamide suggest that the predominant fluorophore is relatively exposed but constrained in a rigid, positively charged environment.