The grateful dead: calcium and cell death in plant innate immunity

Plant cells sensing pathogenic microorganisms evoke defence systems that can confer resistance to infection. This innate immune reaction can include triggering of basal defence responses as well as programmed cell death, or hypersensitive response (HR). In both cases (basal defence and HR), pathogen perception is translated into elevated cytosolic Ca(2+) (mediated by plasma membrane and intracellular channels) as an early step in a signalling cascade. Cyclic nucleotide-gated channels contribute to this influx of Ca(2+) into the cell. The molecular nature of other transport proteins contributing to the Ca(2+) elevation is unclear. Pathogen recognition occurs at two levels: the perception of pathogen-associated molecular pattern (PAMP) molecules widely present in microorganisms, and an interaction between pathogen avirulence gene products (if present) and corresponding plant R (resistance) gene products. The Ca(2+) elevation occurring in response to PAMP perception or R gene interactions could occur due to phosphorylation events, G-protein signalling and/or an increase in cyclic nucleotides. Downstream from the initial Ca(2+) rise, the signalling cascade includes: activation of calmodulin and protein kinases, and nitric oxide and reactive oxygen species generation. Some of these downstream events amplify the Ca(2+) signal by further activation of Ca(2+) transporters.     

Innate immunity signaling: cytosolic Ca2+ elevation is linked to downstream nitric oxide generation through the action of calmodulin or a calmodulin-like protein

Ca²⁺ rise and nitric oxide (NO) generation are essential early steps in plant innate immunity and initiate the hypersensitive response (HR) to avirulent pathogens. Previous work from this laboratory has demonstrated that a loss-of-function mutation of an Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) plasma membrane Ca²⁺-permeable inwardly conducting ion channel impairs HR and that this phenotype could be rescued by the application of a NO donor. At present, the mechanism linking cytosolic Ca²⁺ rise to NO generation during pathogen response signaling in plants is still unclear. Animal nitric oxide synthase (NOS) activation is Ca²⁺/calmodulin (CaM) dependent. Here, we present biochemical and genetic evidence consistent with a similar regulatory mechanism in plants: a pathogen-induced Ca²⁺ signal leads to CaM and/or a CaM-like protein (CML) activation of NOS. In wild-type Arabidopsis plants, the use of a CaM antagonist prevents NO generation and the HR. Application of a CaM antagonist does not prevent pathogen-induced cytosolic Ca²⁺ elevation, excluding the possibility of CaM acting upstream from Ca²⁺. The CaM antagonist and Ca²⁺ chelation abolish NO generation in wild-type Arabidopsis leaf protein extracts as well, suggesting that plant NOS activity is Ca²⁺/CaM dependent in vitro. The CaM-like protein CML24 has been previously associated with NO-related phenotypes in Arabidopsis. Here, we find that innate immune response phenotypes (HR and [avirulent] pathogen-induced NO elevation in leaves) are inhibited in loss-of-function cml24-4 mutant plants. Pathogen-associated molecular pattern-mediated NO generation in cells of cml24-4 mutants is impaired as well. Our work suggests that the initial pathogen recognition signal of Ca²⁺ influx into the cytosol activates CaM and/or a CML, which then acts to induce downstream NO synthesis as intermediary steps in a pathogen perception signaling cascade, leading to innate immune responses, including the HR.     

Cyclic Nucleotide Gated Channels and Ca2+-Mediated Signal Transduction During Plant Innate Immune Response to Pathogens

Transitory perturbations in the level of cytosolic Ca²⁺ are well known to be involved in numerous cell signaling pathways in both plant and animal systems. However, not much is known at present about the molecular identity of plant plasma membrane Ca²⁺ conducting ion channels or their specific roles in signal transduction cascades. A recent study employing genetic approaches as well as patch clamp electrophysiological analysis of channel currents has provided the first such direct evidence linking a specific gene product with inward Ca²⁺ currents across the plant cell membrane. This work identified Ca²⁺ permeation through (Arabidopsis) cyclic nucleotide gated channel isoform 2 (CNGC2) as contributing to the plant innate immunity signaling cascade initiated upon perception of a pathogen. Here, we expand on the implications of CNGC2 mediated cytosolic Ca²⁺ elevations associated with plant cell response to pathogen recognition, and propose some additional steps that may be involved in the innate immunity signal cascade.Key Words: calcium, CNGC, hypersensitive response, nitric oxide, plant innate immunity, plant ion channel, reactive oxygen species     

HLM1, an essential signaling component in the hypersensitive response,is a member of the cyclic nucleotide-gated channel ion channel family

The hypersensitive response (HR) in plants is a programmed cell death that is commonly associated with disease resistance. A novel mutation in Arabidopsis, hlm1, which causes aberrant regulation of cell death, manifested by a lesion-mimic phenotype and an altered HR, segregated as a single recessive allele. Broad-spectrum defense mechanisms remained functional or were constitutive in the mutant plants, which also exhibited increased resistance to a virulent strain of Pseudomonas syringae pv tomato. In response to avirulent strains of the same pathogen, the hlm1 mutant showed differential abilities to restrict bacterial growth, depending on the avirulence gene expressed by the pathogen. The HLM1 gene encodes a cyclic nucleotide-gated channel, CNGC4. Preliminary study of the HLM1/CNGC4 gene pro-duct in Xenopus oocytes (inside-out patch-clamp technique) showed that CNGC4 is permeable to both K(+) and Na(+) and is activated by both cGMP and cAMP. HLM1 gene expression is induced in response to pathogen infection and some pathogen-related signals. Thus, HLM1 might constitute a common downstream component of the signaling pathways leading to HR/resistance.     

Cross-talk between calcium-calmodulin and nitric oxide in abscisic acid signaling in leaves of maize plants

Using pharmacological and biochemical approaches, the signaling pathways between hydrogen peroxide （H2O2）, calcium （Ca^2＋）-calmodulin （CAM）, and nitric oxide （NO） in abscisic acid （ABA）-induced antioxidant defense were investigated in leaves of maize （Zea mays L.） plants. Treatments with ABA, H2O2, and CaCl2 induced increases in the generation of NO in maize mesophyll cells and the activity of nitric oxide synthase （NOS） in the cytosolic and microsomal fractions of maize leaves. However, such increases were blocked by the pretreatments with Ca^2＋ inhibitors and CaM antagonists. Meanwhile, pretreatments with two NOS inhibitors also suppressed the Ca^2＋-induced increase in the production of NO. On the other hand, treatments with ABA and the NO donor sodium nitroprusside （SNP） also led to increases in the concentration of cytosolic Ca^2＋ in protoplasts of mesophyll cells and in the expression of calmodulin 1 （CaM1） gene and the contents of CaM in leaves of maize plants, and the increases induced by ABA were reduced by the pretreatments with a NO scavenger and a NOS inhibitor. Moreover, SNP-induced increases in the expression of the antioxidant genes superoxide dismutase 4 （SOD4）, cytosolic ascorbate peroxidase （cAPX）, and glutathione reductase 1 （GR1） and the activities of the chloroplastic and cytosolic antioxidant enzymes were arrested by the pretreatments with Ca^2＋ inhibitors and CaM antagonists. Our results suggest that Ca^2＋-CaM functions both upstream and downstream of NO production, which is mainly from NOS, in ABA- and H2O2-induced antioxidant defense in leaves of maize plants.     

IQGAP1 integrates Ca2+/calmodulin and B-Raf signaling

Ca(2+) and calmodulin modulate numerous cellular functions, ranging from muscle contraction to the cell cycle. Accumulating evidence indicates that Ca(2+) and calmodulin regulate the MAPK signaling pathway at multiple positions in the cascade, but the molecular mechanism underlying these observations is poorly defined. We previously documented that IQGAP1 is a scaffold in the MAPK cascade. IQGAP1 binds to and regulates the activities of ERK, MEK, and B-Raf. Here we demonstrate that IQGAP1 integrates Ca(2+) and calmodulin with B-Raf signaling. In vitro analysis reveals that Ca(2+) promotes the direct binding of IQGAP1 to B-Raf. This interaction is inhibited by calmodulin in a Ca(2+)-regulated manner. Epidermal growth factor (EGF) is unable to stimulate B-Raf activity in fibroblasts treated with the Ca(2+) ionophore A23187. In contrast, chelation of intracellular free Ca(2+) concentrations ([Ca(2+)](i)) significantly enhances EGF-stimulated B-Raf activity, an effect that is dependent on IQGAP1. Incubation of cells with EGF augments the association of B-Raf with IQGAP1. Moreover, Ca(2+) regulates the association of B-Raf with IQGAP1 in cells. Increasing [Ca(2+)](i) with Ca(2+) ionophores significantly reduces co-immunoprecipitation of B-Raf and IQGAP1, whereas chelation of Ca(2+) enhances the interaction. Consistent with these findings, increasing and decreasing [Ca(2+)](i) increase and decrease, respectively, co-immunoprecipitation of calmodulin with IQGAP1. Collectively, our data identify a previously unrecognized mechanism in which the scaffold protein IQGAP1 couples Ca(2+) and calmodulin signaling to B-Raf function.     

Oxidative burst and NO generation as initial response to ischemia in flow-adapted endothelial cells

Shear stress modulates endothelial physiology, yet the effect(s) of flow cessation is poorly understood. The initial metabolic responses of flow-adapted bovine pulmonary artery endothelial cells to the abrupt cessation of flow (simulated ischemia) was evaluated using a perfusion chamber designed for continuous spectroscopy. Plasma membrane potential, production of reactive O2 species (ROS), and intracellular Ca(2+) and nitric oxide (NO) levels were measured with fluorescent probes. Within 15 s after flow cessation, flow-adapted cells, but not cells cultured under static conditions, showed plasma membrane depolarization and an oxidative burst with generation of ROS that was inhibited by diphenyleneiodonium. EGTA-inhibitable elevation of intracellular Ca(2+) and NO were observed at approximately 30 and 60 s after flow cessation, respectively. NO generation was decreased in the presence of inhibitors of NO synthase and calmodulin. Thus flow-adapted endothelial cells sense the altered hemodynamics associated with flow cessation and respond by plasma membrane depolarization, activation of NADPH oxidase, Ca(2+) influx, and activation of Ca(2+)/calmodulin-dependent NO synthase. This signaling response is unrelated to cellular anoxia.     

Ca(2+)-regulated nitric oxide generation in rabbit parotid acinar cells.

In rabbit parotid acinar cells, the muscarinic cholinergic agonist methacholine induced an increase in the intracellular Ca(2+) concentration and provoked nitric oxide (NO) generation. Ca(2+)-mobilizing reagents such as thapsigargin and the Ca(2+) ionophore A23187 mimicked the effect of methacholine on NO generation. Methacholine-induced NO generation was inhibited by the removal of extracellular Ca(2+). Immunoblot analysis indicated that the antibody against the neuronal type of nitric oxide synthase (NOS) cross-reacted with NOS in the cytosol of rabbit parotid gland cells. Immunofluorescence testing showed that neuronal NOS is present in the cytosol of acinar cells but less in the ductal cells. NOS was purified approximately 8100-fold from the cytosolic fraction of rabbit parotid glands by chromatography on Sephacryl S-200, DEAE-Sephacel, and 29,59-ADP-Sepharose. The purified NOS was a NADPH- and tetrahydroxybiopterin-dependent enzyme and was activated by Ca(2+) within the physiological range in the presence of calmodulin. These results suggest that NO is generated by the activation of the neuronal type of NOS, which is regulated in rabbit parotid acinar cells by the increase in intracellular Ca(2+) levels induced by the activation of muscarinic receptors.     

Ca2+- and phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase-dependent nitric oxide generation in lung endothelial cells in situ with ischemia

Endothelial cells generate nitric oxide (NO) in response to agonist stimulation or increased shear stress. In this study, we evaluated the effects of abrupt cessation of shear stress on pulmonary endothelial NO generation and its relationship to changes in intracellular Ca(2+). In situ endothelial generation of NO and changes in intracellular Ca(2+) in isolated, intact rat lungs were evaluated using fluorescence microscopy with diaminofluorescein diacetate, an NO probe, and Fluo-3, a Ca(2+) probe. The onset of increased NO generation in endothelial cells of subpleural microvessels in situ occurred between 30 and 90 s after onset of ischemia and was preceded by an increase in intracellular Ca(2+) due to both influx of extracellular Ca(2+) and release from intracellular stores. Flow cessation-induced NO generation in endothelial cells in situ was Ca(2+)-, calmodulin-, and PI3-kinase-dependent. The similarity of endothelial cell response (increased NO generation) to either increased flow or cessation of flow suggests that cells respond to an imposed alteration from a state of adaptation. This response to flow cessation may constitute a compensatory vasodilatatory mechanism and may play a role in signaling for cell proliferation and vascular remodeling.     

Mitochondrial Ca2+ and the heart

It is now well established that mitochondria accumulate Ca(2+) ions during cytosolic Ca(2+) ([Ca(2+)](i)) elevations in a variety of cell types including cardiomyocytes. Elevations in intramitochondrial Ca(2+) ([Ca(2+)](m)) activate several key enzymes in the mitochondrial matrix to enhance ATP production, alter the spatial and temporal profile of intracellular Ca(2+) signaling, and play an important role in the initiation of cell death pathways. Moreover, mitochondrial Ca(2+) uptake stimulates nitric oxide (NO) production by mitochondria, which modulates oxygen consumption, ATP production, reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation, and in turn provides negative feedback for the regulation of mitochondrial Ca(2+) accumulation. Controversy remains, however, whether in cardiac myocytes mitochondrial Ca(2+) transport mechanisms allow beat-to-beat transmission of fast cytosolic [Ca(2+)](i) oscillations into oscillatory changes in mitochondrial matrix [Ca(2+)](m). This review critically summarizes the recent experimental work in this field.     

Paclitaxel affects cytosolic calcium signals by opening the mitochondrial permeability transition pore.

We have characterized the effects of the antimitotic drug paclitaxel (Taxol(TM)) on the Ca(2+) signaling cascade of terminally differentiated mouse pancreatic acinar cells. Using single cell fluorescence techniques and whole-cell patch clamping to record cytosolic Ca(2+) and plasma membrane Ca(2+)-dependent Cl(-) currents, we find that paclitaxel abolishes cytosolic Ca(2+) oscillations and in more than half of the cells it also induces a rapid, transient cytosolic Ca(2+) response. This response is not affected by removal of extracellular Ca(2+) indicating that paclitaxel releases Ca(2+) from an intracellular Ca(2+) store. Using saponin-permeabilized cells, we show that paclitaxel does not affect Ca(2+) release from an inositol trisphosphate-sensitive store. Furthermore, up to 15 min after paclitaxel application, there is no significant effect on either microtubule organization or on endoplasmic reticulum organization. The data suggest a non-endoplasmic reticulum source for the intracellular Ca(2+) response. Using the mitochondrial fluorescent dyes, JC-1 and Rhod-2, we show that paclitaxel evoked a rapid decline in the mitochondrial membrane potential and a loss of mitochondrial Ca(2+). Cyclosporin A, a blocker of the mitochondrial permeability transition pore, blocked both the paclitaxel-induced loss of mitochondrial Ca(2+) and the effect on Ca(2+) spikes. We conclude that paclitaxel exerts rapid effects on the cytosolic Ca(2+) signal via the opening of the mitochondrial permeability transition pore. This work indicates that some of the more rapidly developing side effects of chemotherapy might be due to an action of antimitotic drugs on mitochondrial function and an interference with the Ca(2+) signal cascade.     

Extracellular calmodulin-induced stomatal closure is mediated by heterotrimeric G protein and H2O2

Extracellular calmodulin (ExtCaM) exerts multiple functions in animals and plants, but the mode of ExtCaM action is not well understood. In this paper, we provide evidence that ExtCaM stimulates a cascade of intracellular signaling events to regulate stomatal movement. Analysis of the changes of cytosolic free Ca2+ ([Ca2+]cyt) and H2O2 in Vicia faba guard cells combined with epidermal strip bioassay suggests that ExtCaM induces an increase in both H2O2 levels and [Ca2+]cyt, leading to a reduction in stomatal aperture. Pharmacological studies implicate heterotrimeric G protein in transmitting the ExtCaM signal, acting upstream of [Ca2+]cyt elevation, and generating H2O2 in guard cell responses. To further test the role of heterotrimeric G protein in ExtCaM signaling in stomatal closure, we checked guard cell responses in the Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) Galpha-subunit-null gpa1 mutants and cGalpha overexpression lines. We found that gpa1 mutants were insensitive to ExtCaM stimulation of stomatal closure, whereas cGalpha overexpression enhanced the guard cell response to ExtCaM. Furthermore, gpa1 mutants are impaired in ExtCaM induction of H2O2 generation in guard cells. Taken together, our results strongly suggest that ExtCaM activates an intracellular signaling pathway involving activation of a heterotrimeric G protein, H2O2 generation, and changes in [Ca2+]cyt in the regulation of stomatal movements.     

Phosphorylation of endothelial nitric-oxide synthase regulates superoxide generation from the enzyme

In the vasculature, nitric oxide (NO) is generated by endothelial NO synthase (eNOS) in a calcium/calmodulin-dependent reaction. With oxidative stress, the critical cofactor BH(4) is depleted, and NADPH oxidation is uncoupled from NO generation, leading to production of (O(2)*). Although phosphorylation of eNOS regulates in vivo NO generation, the effects of phosphorylation on eNOS coupling and O(2)* generation are unknown. Therefore, we phosphorylated recombinant BH(4)-free eNOS in vitro using native kinases and determined O(2)* generation using EPR spin trapping. Phosphorylation of Ser-1177 by Akt led to an increase (>50%) in maximal O(2)* generation from eNOS. Moreover, Ser-1177 phosphorylation greatly altered the Ca(2+) sensitivity of eNOS, such that O(2)* generation became largely Ca(2+)-independent. In contrast, phosphorylation of eNOS at Thr-495 by protein kinase Calpha (PKCalpha) had no effect on maximum activity or calcium sensitivity but decreased calmodulin binding and increased association with caveolin. In endothelial cells, eNOS-dependent O(2)* generation was stimulated by vascular endothelial growth factor that induced phosphorylation of Ser-1177. With PKC activation that led to phosphorylation of Thr-495, no inhibition of O(2)* generation occurred. As such, phosphorylation of eNOS at Ser-1177 is pivotal in the direct regulation of O(2)* and NO generation, altering both the Ca(2+) sensitivity of the enzyme and rate of product formation, whereas phosphorylation of Thr-495 indirectly affects this process through regulation of the calmodulin and caveolin interaction. Thus, Akt-mediated phosphorylation modulates eNOS uncoupling and greatly increases O(2)* generation from the enzyme at low Ca(2+) concentrations, and PKCalpha-mediated phosphorylation alters the sensitivity of the enzyme to other negative regulatory signals.     

Emerging complexity and new roles for the RIG-I-like receptors in innate antiviral immunity

Innate immunity is critical for the control of virus infection and operates to restrict viral susceptibility and direct antiviral immunity for protection from acute or chronic viral-associated diseases including cancer. RIG-I like receptors (RLRs) are cytosolic RNA helicases that function as pathogen recognition receptors to detect RNA pathogen associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) of virus infection. The RLRs include RIG-I, MDA5, and LGP2. They function to recognize and bind to PAMP motifs within viral RNA in a process that directs the RLR to trigger downstream signaling cascades that induce innate immunity that controls viral replication and spread. Products of RLR signaling also serve to modulate the adaptive immune response to infection. Recent studies have additionally connected RLRs to signaling cascades that impart inflammatory and apoptotic responses to virus infection. Viral evasion of RLR signaling supports viral outgrowth and pathogenesis, including the onset of viral-associated cancer.     

Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent translocation of sphingosine kinase: role in plasma membrane relocation but not activation

Activation of sphingosine kinase (SPHK), thereby increasing cellular levels of sphingosine 1-phosphate (S1P), may be involved in a variety of intracellular responses including Ca(2+) signaling. This study uses mammalian SPHK1a, tagged with enhanced green fluorescent protein (eGFP), to examine whether translocation of this enzyme is linked with Ca(2+)-mobilizing responses. Real-time confocal imaging of SPHK1a-eGFP in human SH-SY5Y neuroblastoma cells visualized a relocation of the enzyme from the cytosol to the plasma membrane in response to Ca(2+)-mobilizing stimuli (muscarinic M(3)- or lysophosphatidic acid receptor activation, and thapsigargin-mediated store release). This redistribution was preceded by a transient increase in cytosolic SPHK1a-eGFP levels due to liberation of SPHK from localized higher intensity regions. Translocation was dependent on Ca(2+) mobilization from intracellular stores, and was prevented by pretreatment with the Ca(2+)/calmodulin inhibitor W-7, but not W-5 or KN-62. In functional studies, pretreatment with W-7 lowered basal and M(3)-receptor-mediated cellular S1P production. However, this pretreatment did not alter agonist-mediated Ca(2+) responses, and SPHK1a-eGFP activity itself appeared insensitive to Ca(2+)/calmodulin and W-7. These data suggest a role for Ca(2+)/calmodulin in controlling the subcellular distribution but not the activity of SPHK1a.