The Specificity of the Feulgen Reaction for Thymonucleic Acid

The results of experiments on the specificity of the Feulgen reaction for thymonucleic acid do not substantiate the observations of Carr. The staining is not localized in the nucleus because of the destruction of cytoplasmic constituents following acid hydrolysis or because of the absorbing power of chromatin, since the cytoplasm and nucleolus can still be stained by numerous dyes. The effects of factors such as the acid hydrolysis and sulfurous acid washing baths upon the cytologic distribution of dye were studied on tissues stained with (1) fuchsin-sulfurous-acid (Feulgen) reagent, (2) fuchsin-sulfurous-acid reagent colorized by the addition of formaldehyde, (3) basic fuchsin in one-tenth normal HCl, and (4) basic fuchsin in distilled water. Under comparable conditions, important differences between these stains were found in the effects of preliminary hydrolysis; rapidity of staining and destaining; extractability of dye from tissues by water, alcohol, and sulfurous acid solution; rate of fading from exposure to light; localization of stain in tissues; and differences in hue. After treating tissues with desoxyribonuclease, an enzyme which acts only upon thymonucleic acid, cells do not stain with the Feulgen technic. Following removal of nucleic acid from chromatin by hydrolysis, attempts to demonstrate an absorption of thymonucleic acid upon the residual nuclear protein were unsuccessful.

The evidence for and against the specificity is discussed. In agreement with most other investigators, on the basis of the evidence in the literature as well as these experiments, it is concluded that when properly controlled the Feulgen reaction is relatively specific for thymonucleic acid.     

Nonspecific ("pseudo-plasmal") dye-binding in the Feulgen nuclear stain and its blocking by azocarmin G

In Feulgen nuclear staining nonspecific dye-binding due to the "pseudo-plasmal reaction" is intensified in isolated cells with intact cytoplasm, and cannot be eliminated by the post-irradiation method. Fluorescence intensity in the cytoplasm sometimes exceeds that of specific nuclear fluorescence, especially in brain and heart muscle cells, and it was almost impossible to perform cytofluorometric DNA quantification on such specimens. Various kinds of aldehyde-blocking agents such as sodium borohydride, 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine, aniline, and sodium pyrosulfite were effective in reducing the "pseudo-plasmal reaction". But the blocking effects were not complete because of additional release of reactive aldehyde groups during subsequent Feulgen hydrolysis. Acidic azocarmin G produced a complete block of all "pseudo-plasmal reaction" in acriflavine-Feulgen nuclear staining, allowing accurate DNA-cytofluorometry to be carried out.     

Feulgen hydrolysis and chromosome banding in Chilocorus (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae).

Prolonged Feulgen hydrolysis of chromosomes of Chilocorus orbus Csy. and C. stigma Say produces banding patterns that are the reverse of those revealed with quinacrine; brightly fluorescing regions are unstained, but nonfluorescent regions remain relatively darkly stained. This differential reactivity at hydrolysis times that otherwise yield intense Feulgen staining confirms the need for caution in the determination of DNA values with the Feulgen reaction in material with well-defined quinacrine bands. The coincidence of DNA-specific Feulgen bands with Q-, G-, and C-bands supports the view that, in Chilocorus at least, bands reflect differences in DNA composition along the chromosome.     

Feulgen Reaction for Thymonucleic Acid

The importance of thymonucleic acid in tissues is discussed briefly. The technic of the Feulgen reaction which has been employed in photometric histochemical observations in tumors is described. The evidence for the specificity of the Feulgen reaction is reviewed and additional experimental observations are reported. The staining of tissues by the Feulgen reaction is compared with that of hematoxylin, basic fuchsia, and fuchsin-sulfurous-acid reagent in which the color had been developed by the addition of formaldehyde. The stains were compared with respect to (1) the selective staining of the cytologic components of the tissues, (2) the staining of tissues following varying intervals of acid hydrolysis and (3) the photometric determination of the fading of the stained tissue by a carbon arc light. The photometric apparatus employed is suitable for the study of many problems on the staining of tissues. Staining by the Feulgen reaction is different from that of both the basic fuchsin from which the fuchsin-sulfurous-acid was prepared and from that of the product of the fuchsin-sulfurous-acid which had reacted with an aldehyde. Under carefully controlled conditions, the Feulgen technic is a relatively specific histochemical reaction for thymonucleic acid.     

Quantitative cytochemical determination of desoxyribonucleic acid with the Feulgen nucleal reaction

The possibility of using the Feulgen nucleal reaction for a quantitative cytochemical estimation of desoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) was investigated. The intensity of the reaction in nuclei was determined by absorption measurements with the microscope. The accuracy of such measurements was tested by comparison with measurements on the same material with a Beckman spectrophotometer. The values obtained with the microscope agreed within a few per cent with those obtained with the Beckman spectrophotometer. Furthermore, the errors introduced by uneven distribution of absorbing material, by variations in the numerical aperture of the system, and by variation in the area used on the phototube were investigated empirically. The following variables were studied with regard to their effect on the intensity of the Feulgen reaction: type of fixation, time of hydrolysis after acetic acid-alcohol and formalin fixation, time of staining in leucobasic fuchsin, method of preparation of leucobasic fuchsin. The intensity of the Feulgen reaction in liver and erythrocyte nuclei of various vertebrates, fixed in acetic acid-alcohol, was then compared with the DNA content of these nuclei as determined by chemical analysis on a known number of nuclei. The intensity of the reaction was found to be proportional to the DNA content of the nuclei, if nuclei of similar structure and DNA concentration were compared. In nuclei of different structure and DNA concentration (i.e. liver and erythrocyte nuclei), fixed in acetic acid-alcohol, the intensity of the Feulgen reaction was, however, not proportional to the DNA content. This difficulty was overcome by isolating nuclei in sucrose and by fixing them in formalin. Uniform distribution of DNA and therefore uniform coloring after the Feulgen reaction were thus obtained. In such nuclei with uniform distribution of absorbing material the Feulgen reaction was found to be proportional to the DNA content of nuclei, even if they differed greatly in their DNA concentration. The Feulgen nucleal reaction is not quantitative in an absolute sense. For absolute determinations nuclei of known DNA content must be treated together with the unknown material to serve as standard. From these data it therefore appears possible to determine cytochemically relative amounts of DNA in cellular structures by measuring their absorption after treatment with the Feulgen nucleal reaction.     

Quantitative cytochemical aspects of a combined Feulgen-Naphthol Yellow S staining procedure for the simultaneous determination of nuclear and cytoplasmic proteins and DNA in mammalian cells

The simultaneous cytophotometric determination of nuclear and cytoplasmic proteins and DNA by means of a combined Feulgen-Naphthol Yellow S (NYS) staining procedure was investigated. According to this procedure Feulgen staining is performed prior to NYS staining. The following main results were obtained:

1. 1. After NYS staining alone, the amount of NYS bound to the cell was found to be closely correlated to the cellular dry mass. The correlation coefficient was 0.99 in ethanol-acetone fixed cells and 0.95 in formaldehyde-fixed cells. This close correlation was not significantly altered by the Feulgen staining procedure and was 0.92 in ethanol-acetone and 0.94 in formaldehyde-fixed cells. However, the absolute amount of NYS bound per unit dry mass was affected by the method of fixation and type of Feulgen hydrolysis.

2. 2. The cells lose material during the Feulgen procedure, particularly during the acid hydrolysis stage. The type of hydrolysis most suitable for the Feulgen procedure (5 N HCl, 22 °C, 60 min) resulted in a considerable loss of dry mass in ethanol-acetone fixed cells. This loss was smaller in formaldehyde-fixed cells (15%) and was in addition closely correlated (correlation coefficient 0.99) to the dry mass of the cells prior to hydrolysis. In formaldehyde-fixed cells the dry mass after the Feulgen procedure is thus a good measure of the true cellular dry mass of the fixed cells. This is further demonstrated by the close correlation between NYS binding to Feulgenstained cells and the dry mass of these cells prior to the Feulgen procedure (correlation coefficient 0.95).

3. 3. When using the combined Feulgen-NYS staining procedure under standardized conditions (formaldehyde fixation and acid hydrolysis in 5 N HCl, 22 °C, 60 min) a constant amount of NYS was found to be bound per unit dry weight to nuclear and cytoplasmic proteins in various types of mammalian cells with different proliferative activity.

4. 4. The Feulgen DNA determination was not found to be quantitatively affected by the subsequent NYS staining.

From the results of the present study it seems that, under standardized conditions, the combined Feulgen-NYS staining procedure can be used as a reliable quantitative method for the determination of nuclear and cytoplasmic proteins and DNA in mammalian cells.     

Staining Chromosomes in Sections of Germinal Vesicles of Sarcoptid Mites by a Schiff Reagent

Chromosomes of oocytes, especially early prophase I stages, of Acaridae and Anoetidae species are difficult to stain by procedures using hematoxylin, Feulgen and aceto-orcein. Hematoxylin stains are intensely polychromatic in oocytes; the standard Feulgen procedure is negative with chromosomes during diffuse prophase stages. Satisfactory staining can be obtained with a supersensitive Schiff reagent (Tobie, W. C., Ind. Eng. Chem., Anal. Ed., 14: 405—406, 1942) made by reducing basic fuchsin with gaseous SO₂. Routinely prepared paraffin sections of mites fixed in Carnoy's 6:3:1 mixture were hydrolysed 5-8 min in 1 N HCl, washed well, and stained in this reagent: 1-2 hr for prophase oocytes, 10-20 min for condensed chromosomes. A second staining in a 0.5% aqueous solution of toluidine blue 0, adjusted to pH 5.3-5.5 with a citrate buffer, served to darken the original Feulgen stain. Counterstaining with 0.1-0.2% fast green FCF in the last fluid of the dehydrating series enhanced contrast between chromosomes and cytoplasm. This staining technic is also suitable for preparing whole mounts of mites.     

HISTONES AND ALKALINE FAST GREEN STAINING OF ONION ROOTS

Onion root tips were freeze killed or fixed in 12 different chemical fixatives to determine the possible effects of such treatments on subsequent staining with alkaline Fast green (pH 8.0-8.1) to reveal the presence of histones. Ethanol, methanol, neutral formalin, and a mixture of methanolchloroform-acetic acid produced nearly comparable results. Subsequent to fixation or freeze drying the sections were treated with hot 5% trichloroacetic acid (TCA) to remove nucleic acids prior to Fast green staining. Staining of histones does not occur in chemically fixed material if TCA hydrolysis is omitted. Nuclei, chromosomes during mitosis, and cytoplasm (to varying degrees) were stainable after TCA treatment. Positive staining occurs in nuclei, nucleoli, and cytoplasm in freeze-dried material with or without prior TCA treatment. Comparisons are made with chemical fixations. The use of ribonuclease instead of TCA permits staining of the cytoplasm and of chromosomes during mitosis. Discussions are included on the stainability of nucleoli and the possibility that native histone is associated with ribonucleic acid (RNA).     

Standardization of the Feulgen reaction: the influence of chromatin condensation on the kinetics of acid hydrolysis.

The purpose of the present study was to investigate the influence of chromatin compactness on the kinetics of acid hydrolysis in the Feulgen reaction in cytology. Tissue imprints of rabbit liver, of human bronchial carcinoma and of human blood smears, fixed with alcohol, formaldehyde or with B?hm's solution with and without prior air drying, were stained with a standardized pararosanilin-Feulgen reagent. The time for hydrolysis varied between 7.5 and 120 min. The integrated optical density (IOD) of the cell nuclei was measured with an image analyzer (IBAS 2000). Cells with condensed chromatin (lymphocytes, small cell carcinoma, formaldehyde fixed cells) showed a slow increase of staining intensity and late plateau phase as compared with cells with decondensed chromatin. DNA in condensed nuclei was less susceptible to acid hydrolysis. The degree of chromatin compactness which determines the sensitivity of DNA to hydrolysis is influenced by the type of fixation, cell type and by the functional status of the cell. The conclusion is that Feulgen staining intensities of cells with different degrees of chromatin compactness cannot be compared unless measured in the respective plateau phases of the relevant hydrolysis curves which must be determined individually for each cell type.     

The Feulgen banded karyotype of the mouse: analysis of the mechanisms of banding

The chromosomes of the mouse have been identified by specific banding patterns revealed by the Feulgen stain. Comparison of the patterns of the Feulgen-stained karyotype with those of acetic-saline-Giemsa stain and quinacrinemustard-fluorescence demonstrates a high order of similarity among the three, with the localization of Feulgen dense bands and regions closely paralleling that of Giemsa dark and fluorescence bright bands. Since the stained substrate of the Feulgen reaction is known to be DNA, it is suggested that all three banding methods reveal the distribution of DNA or of some moiety that closely follows DNA distribution in metaphase chromosomes. The preparative procedure of the Feulgen banding method consists of a 15 to 20 minute exposure to PO₄ buffer at pH 10 and a prolonged (60–72 hrs) exposure to 12xSSC. Omission or curtailment of either step results in preparations with chromosome sets that are not karyotypable, although some stain differentiation is produced. HCl extraction prior to the preparative treatment blocks banding, but acid extraction following the preparative treatment, either that of the HCl hydrolysis of the Feulgen reaction of that of an almost fourfold extension of the standard hydrolysis time, does not obliterate bands already formed. By extrapolation from biochemical studies of chromatin, it is postulated that the localization of Feulgen dark and light stain, representing relative DNA densities, reflects the regional protein association of the DNA; the Feulgen dense regions may result from aggregation of a specific class of histones by the alkaline buffer with consequent condensation of the DNA bound to those histones; the Feulgen pale or negative regions may represent those in which non-aggregated proteins, histone and non-histone, have been solubilized in the saline incubation, rendering the DNA of those regions subject to diffusion or vulnerable to fragmentation in the Feulgen hydrolysis.     

Hot hydrochloric acid hydrolysis and UV Feulgen staining of rat liver sections fixed in CRAF and CRAF-like fixative.

Sections of rat liver fixed in CRAF III and Nawaschin's fixative in Dutt's modification were subjected to hydrolysis in 1N HCl at 60 degrees C for different periods of time and to Schiff's staining according to the UV Feulgen technique. The study showed that Feulgen reaction intensity depends upon time of hydrolysis, optimum coloration being possible only after 10-15 min of hydrolysis. Prolongation of hydrolysis beyond this time produced decreased staining intensity which is retained for further 35 min of hydrolysis thus forming a plateau. Further prolongation of hydrolysis results in gradual deterioration of the staining intensity which culminates in utterly pale coloration of the nuclei after one hour's hydrolysis. A possible explanation for this phenomena is suggested.     

The Feulgen reaction 75 years on

 The Feulgen reaction proposed by Feulgen and Rossenbeck 75 years ago is one of the cytohistochemical reactions most widely used in biology and medicine. It allows DNA in situ to be specifically stained based on the reaction of Schiff or Schiff-like reagents with aldehyde groups engendered in the deoxyribose molecules by HCl hydrolysis. The staining intensity is proportional to the DNA concentration. Current applications of the Feulgen reaction are mainly concerned with DNA quantification in cell nuclei by image cytometry for ploidy evaluation in tumor pathology. From the morphological point of view, specific demonstration of DNA in cell structures at the light microscopic level is very little used nowadays. On the other hand, application of the Feulgen principles to electron microscopy have recently allowed specific DNA-staining procedures to be developed for the study of the structural organization of DNA in situ. Accepted: 13 January 1999     

Rapid method to obtain high quality nuclear and chromosome images directly from living cells in the Characeae

This study focused on a method based on the capacity of cationic dyes to stain only the nucleus and chromosomes in cells subjected to either acid or alkaline hydrolysis. The method and the squash were optimized for the Characeae and were described in detail. Nuclei from vegetative shoot apices and antheridial filament cells of unfixed, fixed and herbarium material of Nitella opaca were investigated using the Azure A or Toulidine Blue stains. Comparisons with some other staining methods, used in the previous studies, were also reported. The Azure A/Toulidine Blue method is useful to obtain clear images of chromosome morphology comparable or higher to that obtained with Feulgen or Aceto‐Orcein. It requires little time and a less complicated procedure in comparison with other staining methods.     

Improved Histology for the Chick-Quail Chimera

A simple modification of nuclear staining after acid hydrolysis has been made which provides easy identification of quail nuclear markings in a chick-quail chimera. This method also improves the histologic detail normally seen with hematoxylin and eosin when compared to the more commonly used Feulgen reaction. Embryonic tissues can be fixed in Zenker's or Helly's solution and the sections obtained are hydrolyzed in acid (3.5 N HCl at 37 C for 40-50 min). After acid hydrolysis the sections are stained with hematoxylin and eosin rather than Schiff reagent and fast green. The interphase nuclei of chick cells show homogeneous or mottled purplish blue staining, while quail nuclei contain a dark blue spot. This staining corresponds to the reddish purple staining of the quail's heterochromatin seen adjacent to the nucleolus in the standard Feulgen stain. This new technique facilitates identification of quail cell types in the chick host and provides superior histology of the chick tissues by demonstrating cytoplasmic detail.     

Cytochemical studies on the chromatin elimination in solenobia (Lepidoptera)

Summary The chemical nature of the elimination chromatin in the first maturation division ofSolenobia was investigated with the Feulgen reaction, by staining with methyl green-pyronin. with toluidine blue before and after treatment with ribonuclease and cold perchloric acid, with the Hotchkiss periodic acid-Schiff test, and the Millon reaction.The Feulgen reaction and Hotchkiss test for polysaccharides turned out, to be negative while the tests for ribonucleic acid and protein were positive. The elimination chromatin is therefore essentially ribonucleoprotein.The elimination process is considered to be one way by which chromosomes rich in ribonucleoprotein typically present in metabolically active cells, are stripping themselves from material that may have become superfluous. Such visible shedding of material from chromosomes, though less spectacular than in the maturation division of eggs in Lepidoptera and few other insects, may be more common than is generally thought and it is suggested that the interzonal fibers found in many mitoses fall into this category.     

Temperature and acid concentration in the search for optimum Feulgen hydrolysis conditions.

Exposure and removal of aldehyde groups during Feulgen acid hydrolysis were studied at a wide range of temperature and acid concentrations. Temperatures between 9 and 75degreesC were found to influence only the rate of the hydrolysis reaction over the entire range from high (6 M) to low (0.05 M) HCl concentrations. The temperature dependence was high, and around +5degreesC was sufficient to double the reaction rate. The influence of acid concentrations between 0.02 and 6 M was studied, and the extraction rates that determine the peak values of the Feulgen hydrolysis curve were found to depend in the same way on the (H+) concentration. A diagram is given that makes it possible to determine the time to reach the point during hydrolysis where the maximum amount of aldehyde groups are developed for a wide range of temperatures and acid concentrations. Temperatures slightly above room temperature in combination with high acid concentration is recommended for Feulgen hydrolysis.     

Feulgen staining of rat liver fixed in different fixatives.

In the present study rat liver pieces fixed in 1) 10 per cent buffered neutral formalin, 2) 4 per cent glutaraldehyde, 3) Heidenhain's-Susa fixative and 4) Flemming's fluid, and following hydrolysis in 1-0 N HC1 at 60degreesC for varying time periods have been stained with the UV Feulgen procedure. The results of this study reveal that following hydrolysis for different time periods the tissue material fixed in formalin show the same staining pattern as those fixed in glutaraldehyde. The material fixed in Heidenhain's-Susa displays an intense Feulgen staining after two different times of hydrolysis, and that fixed in Flemming's fluid shows particular staining intensity for a prolonged time period thus indicating better preservation of DNA than in the materials fixed in the other three fixtatives.     

QFH banding and DNA distribution in the macrochromosomes of the chicken Gallus domesticus

Chromosomes of Gallus domesticus were stained with rivanolum-SO2 (fluorescence Feulgen reaction) and by Hoechst 33258. Fluorescence photography was performed on a 35 mm film KN-3(KN-3) "Svema". The negatives were analyzed with the microdensitometer. The Feulgen (Fr--) and the Hoechst 3358 (H--) densitometric profiles of chromosomes showed light and dark segments along the metaphase chromosomes. The amount of DNA, as determined by the fluorescence Feulgen reaction, is not constant along the chromosome arms. Consequently, the base composition is not the only factor influencing the fluorescence of Hoechst 33258 along the chromosomes. The comparative analysis of densitometric profiles of the Hoechst 33258 and rivanolum-SO2 stained chromosomes shows that the Iq telomere band consists of GC-rich DNA (about 70% GC). The variation of DNA contents along the metaphase chromosome arms can be realized at both chromoneme and/or subchromoneme levels.     

BUFFERED OSMIUM TETROXIDE (OsO4) FIXATION FOR CYTOLOGICAL AND FEULGEN MICROSPECTROPHOTOMETRIC STUDIES OF HUMAN RECTAL POLYPS

Evidence has been presented that when human rectal mucosa and polyps are fixed with buffered OsO₄ according to the method of Palade, staining of paraffin sections by basic and acidic dyes results in a distinct color difference between chromatin and cytoplasm. Furthermore, the Feulgen reaction also can be carried out successfully and such OsO₄-fixed Feulgen-stained sections are especially suitable for microspectrophotometric determinations of DNA in individual nuclei.     

Immunocytochemical detection of sulphonylated DNA in tissue sections. An alternative to Feulgen staining of DNA

We report here on a new sensitive and highly specific DNA staining technique which we have called sulpho-DNA staining. DNA staining is based on a sulphonylation reaction of 2'-deoxycytidine or cytidine that takes place in the 6th position of cytosine with ensuing immunodetection of the sulphonylated DNA. The specificity of DNA staining is introduced by the use of an antibody recognizing only modified DNA but not modified RNA, by recourse to an additional acid hydrolysis step which destroys RNA but not DNA. We describe here the optimal conditions for the sulphonylation of DNA using O-methylhydroxylamine and metabisulphite as reactants. The new DNA stain labels all nuclei in either normal human tissue or in tumor cells. For nuclear DNA the staining signal is higher for the sulpho-DNA staining than for the Feulgen staining for nuclear DNA. This new DNA staining technique is suitable for use on tissue sections as well as on cytosmears.