Engineering of betaine biosynthesis and transport for abiotic stress tolerance in plants

Drought and salinity are the major factors that decrease crop yield. Organisms thriving in osmotic stress environments need adaptive mechanisms for adjusting their intracellular environment to external osmotic stress conditions. One such mechanism, to prevent water loss from the cells is to accumulate large amounts of low molecular weight organic compatible solutes such as proline, betaine and polyols to balance internal osmolarity of the cells. Accumulation of compatible solutes can be achieved by enhanced synthesis and/or reduced catabolism. Certain plants synthesize betaine in chloroplasts via a two-step oxidation of choline and betaine accumulation is associated with enhanced stress tolerance. Many important crop plants have low levels of betaine or none at all. Hence, betaine biosynthetic pathway is a target for metabolic engineering to enhance stress tolerance in crops. Introduction of betaine synthesis pathway into betaine non-accumulating plants has often improved stress tolerance. However, betaine levels of the engineered plants were generally low. To further enhance the betaine accumulation levels, we need to diagnose factors limitng betaine accumulation in engineered plants. Here we discuss recent progress on metabolic engineering of choline precursors for abiotic stress tolerance in plants.     

Osmoregulation in the model organismEscherichia coli: genes governing the synthesis of glycine betaine and trehalose and their use in metabolic engineering of stress tolerance

Glycine betaine is known to be the preferred osmoprotectant in many bacteria, and glycine betaine accumulation has also been correlated with increased cold tolerance. Trehalose is often a minor osmoprotectant in bacteria and it is a major determinant for desiccation tolerance in many so-called anhydrobiotic organisms such as baker's yeast(Saccharomyces cerevisiae). Escherichia coli has two pathways for synthesis of these protective molecules; i.e., a two-step conversion of UDP-glucose and glucose-6-phosphate to trehalose and a two-step oxidation of externally-supplied choline to glycine betaine. The genes governing the choline-to-glycine betaine pathway have been studied inE. coli and several other bacteria and higher plants. The genes governing UDP-glucose-dependent trehalose synthesis have been studied inE. coli andS. cerevisiae. Because of their well-documented function in stress protection, glycine betaine and trehalose have been identified as targets for metabolic engineering of stress tolerance. Examples of this experimental approach include the expression of theE. coli betA andArthrobacter globiformis codA genes for glycine betaine synthesis in plants and distantly related bacteria, and the expression of theE. coli otsA and yeastTPS1 genes for trehalose synthesis in plants. The published data show that glycine betaine synthesis protects transgenic plants and phototrophic bacteria against stress caused by salt and cold. Trehalose synthesis has been reported to confer increased drought tolerance in transgenic plants, but it causes negative side effects which is of concern. Thus, the much-used model organismE. coli has now become a gene resource for metabolic engineering of stress tolerance.     

Glycine betaine: a versatile compound with great potential for gene pyramiding to improve crop plant performance against environmental stresses

Plants are frequently exposed to a plethora of environmental stresses. Being sessile creatures, they have to tolerate any stresses by altering their metabolism. To achieve tolerance, plants synthesize compatible compounds such as glycine betaine (GB). Continuous research over the years has increased our understanding about the mechanisms of stress protection by GB, which range from an osmolyte to a chaperone and from maintenance of reactive oxygen species to gene expression inducer. Various crop plants have also been transformed to synthesize GB along with model plants by introducing bacterial or plant genes. The GB-synthesizing crop plants exhibit enhanced tolerance to various abiotic stresses and out-yield wild-type plants in stressful conditions. GB has also been utilized to improve enhanced stress tolerance by utilizing it in gene stacking experiments due to its synergistic and stabilizing effects. It is reviewed here (along with comparative analysis of GB synthesis pathways and its mechanism to improve tolerance) showing that gene stacking by using GB as one component provides substantial protection. This synergistic role of GB leads us to hypothesize that it can be utilized in virtually any kind of gene stacking experiments to develop crop plants to be grown in arable and marginal lands for better tolerance to ever-changing environmental conditions and to ensure food security in underdeveloped regions of the world.     

Genetic engineering of polyamine and carbohydrate metabolism for osmotic stress tolerance in higher plants

Plant growth and productivity are greatly affected by various stress factors. The molecular mechanisms of stress tolerance in plant species have been well established. Metabolic pathways involving the synthesis of metabolites such as polyamines, carbohydrates, proline and glycine betaine have been shown to be associated with stress tolerance. Introduction of the stress-induced genes involved in these pathways from tolerant species to sensitive plants seems to be a promising approach to confer stress tolerance in plants. In cases where single gene is not enough to confer tolerance, metabolic engineering necessitates the introduction of multiple transgenes in plants.     

Compatible solute accumulation and stress-mitigating effects in barley genotypes contrasting in their salt tolerance

The accumulation of compatible solutes is often regarded as a basic strategy for the protection and survival of plants under abiotic stress conditions, including both salinity and oxidative stress. In this work, a possible causal link between the ability of contrasting barley genotypes to accumulate/synthesize compatible solutes and their salinity stress tolerance was investigated. The impact of H(2)O(2) (one of the components of salt stress) on K(+) flux (a measure of stress 'severity') and the mitigating effects of glycine betaine and proline on NaCl-induced K(+) efflux were found to be significantly higher in salt-sensitive barley genotypes. At the same time, a 2-fold higher accumulation of leaf and root proline and leaf glycine betaine was found in salt-sensitive cultivars. The total amino acid content was also less affected by salinity in salt-tolerant cultivars. In these, potassium was found to be the main contributor to cytoplasmic osmolality, while in salt-sensitive genotypes, glycine betaine and proline contributed substantially to cell osmolality, compensating for reduced cytosolic K(+). Significant negative correlations (r= -0.89 and -0.94) were observed between Na(+)-induced K(+) efflux (an indicator of salt tolerance) and leaf glycine betaine and proline. These results indicate that hyperaccumulation of known major compatible solutes in barley does not appear to play a major role in salt-tolerance, but rather, may be a symptom of salt-susceptibility.     

Dissecting the roles of osmolyte accumulation during stress

Many plants accumulate organic osmolytes in response to the imposition of environmental stresses that cause cellular dehydration. Although an adaptive role for these compounds in mediating osmotic adjustment and protecting subcellular structure has become a central dogma in stress physiology, the evidence in favour of this hypothesis is largely correlative. Transgenic plants engineered to accumulate proline, mannitol, fructans, trehalose, glycine betaine or ononitol exhibit marginal improvements in salt and/or drought tolerance. While these studies do not dismiss causative relationships between osmolyte levels and stress tolerance, the absolute osmolyte concentrations in these plants are unlikely to mediate osmotic adjustment. Metabolic benefits of osmolyte accumulation may augment the classically accepted roles of these compounds. In re-assessing the functional significance of compatible solute accumulation, it is suggested that proline and glycine betaine synthesis may buffer cellular redox potential. Disturbances in hexose sensing in transgenic plants engineered to produce trehalose, fructans or mannitol may be an important contributory factor to the stress-tolerant phenotypes observed. Associated effects on photoassimilate allocation between root and shoot tissues may also be involved. Whether or not osmolyte transport between subcellular compartments or different organs represents a bottleneck that limits stress tolerance at the whole-plant level is presently unclear. None the less, if osmolyte metabolism impinges on hexose or redox signalling, then it may be important in long-range signal transmission throughout the plant.     

Enhancement of tolerance of abiotic stress by metabolic engineering of betaines and other compatible solutes

The accumulation of compatible solutes, such as betaines, proline and sugar alcohols, is a widespread response that may protect plants against environmental stress. It is not yet fully understood how these compounds are involved in the stress tolerance of whole plants. Some plants have been genetically engineered to express enzymes that catalyze the synthesis of various compatible solutes. Some interventions have increased the tolerance of some crop plants to abiotic stress. Furthermore, analysis of such transgenic plants has begun to clarify the roles of compatible solutes in stress tolerance.     

Glycine betaine involvement in freezing tolerance and water stress in Arabidopsis thaliana

Levels of endogenous glycine betaine in the leaves were measured in response to cold acclimation, water stress and exogenous ABA application in Arabidopsis thaliana. The endogenous glycine betaine level in the leaves increased sharply during cold acclimation treatment as plants gained freezing tolerance. When glycine betaine (10 mM) was applied exogenously to the plants as a foliar spray, the freezing tolerance increased from -3.1 to -4.5 degrees C. In addition, when ABA (1 mM) was applied exogenously, the endogenous glycine betaine level and the freezing tolerance in the leaves increased. However, the increase in the leaf glycine betaine level induced by ABA was only about half of that by the cold acclimation treatment. Furthermore, when plants were subjected to water stress (leaf water potential of approximately -1.6 MPa), the endogenous leaf glycine betaine level increased by about 18-fold over that in the control plants. Water stress lead to significant increase in the freezing tolerance, which was slightly less than that induced by the cold acclimation treatment. The results suggest that glycine betaine is involved in the induction of freezing tolerance in response to cold acclimation, ABA, and water stress in Arabidopsis plants.     

Betaine aldehyde dehydrogenase in plants

Plant betaine aldehyde dehydrogenases (BADHs) have been the target of substantial research, especially during the last 20 years. Initial characterisation of BADH as an enzyme involved in the production of glycine betaine (GB) has led to detailed studies of the role of BADH in the response of plants to abiotic stress in vivo , and the potential for transgenic expression of BADH to improve abiotic stress tolerance. These studies have, in turn, yielded significant information regarding BADH and GB function. Recent research has identified the potential for BADH as an antibiotic-free marker for selection of transgenic plants, and a major role for BADH in 2-acetyl-1-pyrroline-based fragrance associated with jasmine and basmati style aromatic rice varieties.     

Compatible solute biosynthesis in cyanobacteria

Compatible solutes are a functional group of small, highly soluble organic molecules that demonstrate compatibility in high amounts with cellular metabolism. The accumulation of compatible solutes is often observed during the acclimation of organisms to adverse environmental conditions, particularly to salt and drought stress. Among cyanobacteria, sucrose, trehalose, glucosylglycerol and glycine betaine are used as major compatible solutes. Interestingly, a close correlation has been discovered between the final salt tolerance limit and the primary compatible solute in these organisms. In addition to the dominant compatible solutes, many strains accumulate mixtures of these compounds, including minor compounds such as glucosylglycerate or proline as secondary or tertiary solutes. In particular, the accumulation of sucrose and trehalose results in an increase in tolerance to general stresses such as desiccation and high temperatures. During recent years, the biochemical and molecular basis of compatible solute accumulation has been characterized using cyanobacterial model strains that comprise different salt tolerance groups. Based on these data, the distribution of genes involved in compatible solute synthesis among sequenced cyanobacterial genomes is reviewed, and thereby, the major compatible solutes and potential salt tolerance of these strains can be predicted. Knowledge regarding cyanobacterial salt tolerance is not only useful to characterize strain-specific adaptations to ecological niches, but it can also be used to generate cells with increased tolerance to adverse environmental conditions for biotechnological purposes.     

Extreme halophiles synthesize betaine from glycine by methylation

Glycine betaine is a compatible solute, which is able to restore and maintain osmotic balance of living cells. It is synthesized and accumulated in response to abiotic stress. Betaine acts also as a methyl group donor and has a number of important applications including its use as a feed additive. The known biosynthetic pathways of betaine are universal and very well characterized. A number of enzymes catalyzing the two-step oxidation of choline to betaine have been isolated. In this work we have studied a novel betaine biosynthetic pathway in two phylogenically distant extreme halophiles, Actinopolyspora halophila and Ectothiorhodospira halochloris. We have identified a three-step series of methylation reactions from glycine to betaine, which is catalyzed by two methyltransferases, glycine sarcosine methyltransferase and sarcosine dimethylglycine methyltransferase, with partially overlapping substrate specificity. The methyltransferases from the two organisms show high sequence homology. E. halochloris methyltransferase genes were successfully expressed in Escherichia coli, and betaine accumulation and improved salt tolerance were demonstrated.     

Improved tolerance to salinity and low temperature in transgenic tobacco producing glycine betaine

Glycine betaine is an osmoprotectant found in many organisms, including bacteria and higher plants. The bacterium Escherichia coli produces glycine betaine by a two-step pathway where choline dehydrogenase (CDH), encoded by betA, oxidizes choline to betaine aldehyde which is further oxidized to glycine betaine by the same enzyme. The second step, conversion of betaine aldehyde into glycine betaine, can also be performed by the second enzyme in the pathway, betaine aldehyde dehydrogenase (BADH), encoded by betB. Transformation of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum), a species not accumulating glycine betaine, with the E. coli genes for glycine betaine biosynthesis, resulted in transgenic plants accumulating glycine betaine. Plants producing CDH were found to accumulate glycine betaine as did F1 progeny from crosses between CDH- and BADH-producing lines. Plants producing both CDH and BADH generally accumulated higher amounts of glycine betaine than plants producing CDH alone, as determined by 1H NMR analysis. Transgenic tobacco lines accumulating glycine betaine exhibited increased tolerance to salt stress as measured by biomass production of greenhouse-grown intact plants. Furthermore, experiments conducted with leaf discs from glycine betaine-accumulating plants indicated enhanced recovery from photoinhibition caused by high light and salt stress as well as improved tolerance to photoinhibition under low temperature conditions. In conclusion, introduction of glycine betaine production into tobacco is associated with increased stress tolerance probably partly due to improved protection of the photosynthetic apparatus.     

The role of glycine betaine in the protection of plants from stress: clues from transgenic plants

The acclimation of a plant to a constantly changing environment involves the accumulation of certain organic compounds of low molecular mass, known collectively as compatible solutes, in the cytoplasm. The evidence from numerous investigations of the physiology, genetics, biophysics and biochemistry of plants strongly suggests that glycine betaine (GB), an amphoteric quaternary amine, plays an important role as a compatible solute in plants under various types of environmental stress, such as high levels of salts and low temperature. Plant species vary in their capacity to synthesize GB and some plants, such as spinach and barley, accumulate relatively high levels of GB in their chloroplasts while others, such as Arabidopsis and tobacco, do not synthesize this compound. Genetic engineering has allowed the introduction into GB-deficient species of biosynthetic pathways to GB from both micro-organisms and higher plants; this approach has facilitated investigations of the importance of GB in stress protection. In this review, we summarize recent progress in the genetic manipulation of the synthesis of GB, with special emphasis on the relationship between the protective effects of GB in vivo and those documented in vitro.     

Characterization of a Snorhizobium meliloti ATP-binding cassette histidine transporter also involved in betaine and proline uptake

The symbiotic soil bacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti uses the compatible solutes glycine betaine and proline betaine for both protection against osmotic stress and, at low osmolarities, as an energy source. A PCR strategy based on conserved domains in components of the glycine betaine uptake systems from Escherichia coli (ProU) and Bacillus subtilis (OpuA and OpuC) allowed us to identify a highly homologous ATP-binding cassette (ABC) binding protein-dependent transporter in S. meliloti. This system was encoded by three genes (hutXWV) of an operon which also contained a fourth gene (hutH2) encoding a putative histidase, which is an enzyme involved in the first step of histidine catabolism. Site-directed mutagenesis of the gene encoding the periplasmic binding protein (hutX) and of the gene encoding the cytoplasmic ATPase (hutV) was done to study the substrate specificity of this transporter and its contribution in betaine uptake. These mutants showed a 50% reduction in high-affinity uptake of histidine, proline, and proline betaine and about a 30% reduction in low-affinity glycine betaine transport. When histidine was used as a nitrogen source, a 30% inhibition of growth was observed in hut mutants (hutX and hutH2). Expression analysis of the hut operon determined using a hutX-lacZ fusion revealed induction by histidine, but not by salt stress, suggesting this uptake system has a catabolic role rather than being involved in osmoprotection. To our knowledge, Hut is the first characterized histidine ABC transporter also involved in proline and betaine uptake.     

Metabolic engineering for betaine accumulation in microbes and plants

Plants accumulate a variety of osmoprotectants that improve their ability to combat abiotic stresses. Among them, betaine appears to play an important role in conferring resistance to stresses. Betaine is synthesized via either choline oxidation or glycine methylation. An increased betaine level in transgenic plants is one of the potential strategies to generate stress-tolerant crop plants. Here, we showed that an exogenous supply of serine or glycine to a halotolerant cyanobacterium Aphanothece halophytica, which synthesizes betaine from glycine by a three-step methylation, elevated intracellular accumulation of betaine under salt stress. The gene encoding 3-phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase (PGDH), which catalyzes the first step of the phosphorylated pathway of serine biosynthesis, was isolated from A. halophytica. Expression of the Aphanothece PGDH gene in Escherichia coli caused an increase in levels of betaine as well as glycine and serine. Expression of the Aphanothece PGDH gene in Arabidopsis plants, in which the betaine synthetic pathway was introduced via glycine methylation, further increased betaine levels and improved the stress tolerance. These results demonstrate that PGDH enhances the levels of betaine by providing the precursor serine for both choline oxidation and glycine methylation pathways.     

Effect of pre-treatment with ethanolamine on the response of Helianthus annuus L. to salt stress

The accumulation of compatible solutes is one of the strategies that plants have developed to tolerate salt stress. Proline and betaine are the main metabolites that accumulate in various species of higher plants in response to salt stress. In Helianthus annuus L., pre-treatment of seeds with ethanolamine led to enhanced seedling tolerance to conditions of saline stress during germination, as evidenced by the greater growth of pretreated seedlings (EAS group) versus untreated seedlings (S group), evaluated through such parameters as length, water and chlorophyll content. During the germination period, a considerable increase was observed in proline levels (up to 300%) in seedlings subjected to saline stress, whereas in the EAS group, the proline increment was much smaller (20%). Starting from the fourth day of germination, betaine levels in seedlings pretreated with ethanolamine and then with water (EAW group) and in EAS showed a significant increase versus C (control) and S seedlings, possibly because such a precursor promotes betaine biosynthesis. This could be responsible for the enhanced growth observed in EAS versus S seedlings, as well as for preventing the decrease in chlorophyll content in the EAS group. The accumulation of betaine seems to correlate with the greater tolerance of these seedlings against stress induced by sodium chloride.     

Protection of Bacillus subtilis against cold stress via compatible-solute acquisition

Accumulation of compatible solutes is a strategy widely employed by bacteria to achieve cellular protection against high osmolarity. These compounds are also used in some microorganisms as thermostress protectants. We found that Bacillus subtilis uses the compatible solute glycine betaine as an effective cold stress protectant. Glycine betaine strongly stimulated growth at 15°C and permitted cell proliferation at the growth-inhibiting temperature of 13°C. Initial uptake of glycine betaine at 15°C was low but led eventually to the buildup of an intracellular pool whose size was double that found in cells grown at 35°C. Each of the three glycine betaine transporters (OpuA, OpuC, and OpuD) contributed to glycine betaine accumulation in the cold. Protection against cold stress was also accomplished when glycine betaine was synthesized from its precursor choline. Growth of a mutant defective in the osmoadaptive biosynthesis for the compatible solute proline was not impaired at low temperature (15°C). In addition to glycine betaine, the compatible solutes and osmoprotectants l-carnitine, crotonobetaine, butyrobetaine, homobetaine, dimethylsulfonioactetate, and proline betaine all served as cold stress protectants as well and were accumulated via known Opu transport systems. In contrast, the compatible solutes and osmoprotectants choline-O-sulfate, ectoine, proline, and glutamate were not cold protective. Our data highlight an underappreciated facet of the acclimatization of B. subtilis to cold environments and allow a comparison of the characteristics of compatible solutes with respect to their osmotic, heat, and cold stress-protective properties for B. subtilis cells.