Structural and mechanistic basis of porphyrin metallation by ferrochelatase

Ferrochelatase, the enzyme catalyzing metallation of protoporphyrin IX at the terminal step of heme biosynthesis, was co-crystallized with an isomer mixture of the potent inhibitor N-methylmesoporphyrin (N-MeMP). The X-ray structure revealed the active site of the enzyme, to which only one of the isomers was bound, and for the first time allowed characterization of the mode of porphyrin macrocycle distortion by ferrochelatase. Crystallization of ferrochelatase and N-MeMP in the presence of Cu(2+) leads to metallation and demethylation of N-MeMP. A mechanism of porphyrin distortion is proposed, which assumes that the enzyme holds pyrrole rings B, C and D in a vice-like grip and forces a 36 degrees tilt on ring A.     

High-valent transition metal corrolazines

High-valent metalloporphyrin intermediates have been implicated as key players in numerous mechanistic proposals for both biological (e.g., heme protein) and synthetic porphyrin mediated transformations. However, the direct observation of these species is quite challenging because of the inherently short lifetimes of many of these metalloporphyrin intermediates. This review focuses on our own efforts to synthesize and study a new class of porphyrinoid compounds called corrolazines, which are designed to stabilize high-valent species for direct analysis. These compounds are related to corroles, which also exhibit the unusual ability to stabilize high oxidation states, and the reactivity and physical properties of relevant corrole and porphyrin analogs are compared with the appropriate corrolazines. The chemistry of Cu, Co, V, and Mn are highlighted, with a particular emphasis on the reactivity of high-valent manganese-oxo complexes.     

Denaturation and renaturation of myeloperoxidase. Consequences for the nature of the prosthetic group.

The effects of the chaotropic agent, guanidine HCl, on the chlorinating activity, optical absorption, EPR, and resonance Raman spectra of myeloperoxidase have been studied. In the presence of the agent the Soret optical absorption of the reduced enzyme (lambda max = 474 nm) is blue shifted to 448 nm, a position similar to heme alpha-containing enzymes. The chlorinating activity of the enzyme disappears, and EPR spectra show a loss of intensity of the rhombic high spin heme signals (gx = 6.9; gy = 5.4) and the appearance of a more axial high spin signal (gx = gy = 6.0). Surprisingly the effects of guanidine HCl are partly reversible. Upon decreasing the concentration of the chaotropic agents by dilution, both the chlorinating activity and the original optical spectrum of native reduced enzyme (lambda max = 474 nm) are partly restored. The resonance Raman spectra of denatured cyanomyeloperoxidase are less complicated than those of native myeloperoxidase, which have been interpreted previously to suggest an iron chlorin chromophore. The multiple lines in the oxidation state marker region are not seen in the spectra of the denatured species. The changes suggest that upon denaturation the macrocycle is converted into a more symmetric structure. Since the effects on the optical absorption spectrum are reversible we speculate that, in the native enzyme, an apparent porphyrin macrocycle undergoes a reversible interaction with amino acid residues in the protein which creates an asymmetry in the electronic distribution of the macrocycle. Comparison of the Raman spectra of denatured cyanomyeloperoxidase with those of analogous heme alpha model complexes suggests the presence of a formyl group in the denatured species; our data, however, demonstrate that the chromophore structure is not identical to heme alpha and may contain a different C beta substitution on the ring macrocycle.     

Resonance Raman investigation of lysine and N-acetylmethionine complexes of ferric and ferrous microperoxidase

In order to evaluate the steric and electronic effects of mixed axial ligations on the heme c structure, lysine (Lys) and N-acetylmethionine (AcMet) complexes of ferric and ferrous microperoxidase-8 (MP8(III) and MP8(II), respectively) are characterized by absorption and resonance Raman (RR) spectroscopies. Spectrophotometric titrations establish that MP8(III) binds one molecule of exogenous ligand while MP8(II) forms mono(ligated) and bis(ligated) compounds. The Soret-excited RR spectra of the six-coordinated low-spin MP8(III) complexes show that the macrocycle can adopt different structures between planar and ruffled conformations. The ferriheme c conformation is primarily determined by the ionization state of the His side chain of MP8(III) and, secondarily, by the bonding and nonbonding heme-ligand interactions. As far as the RR spectra of the MP8(II) complexes are concerned, they permit us to conclude that the mixed His/Lys and His/AcMet coordinations induce a nonplanar heme conformation, the extent of deformation again depending on the ionization state of the endogenous His ligand. In contrast, the RR spectra of the bis(Lys) and bis(AcMet) compounds are associated with a planar heme structure. When the His of MP8 is bound to heme c, the stabilization of distorted heme conformations is thus associated with constraints exerted by the Cys-Ala-Gln-Cys-His-peptide on the porphyrin macrocycle. More generally, the spectroscopic data obtained in this study can be used to predict both the axial coordination and the structure of heme in c-type cytochromes. Received: 19 January 1998 / Revised version: 23 March 1998 / Accepted: 27 March 1998     

A new thioether-ligated iron porphyrin as a model of a protonated form of P450 active site

Thioether-ligated iron porphyrin (complex 1) was synthesized as a model of the protonated form of P450 to explore the possible involvement of the protonated form in the catalytic cycle, and ether-ligated iron porphyrin (complex 2) was also synthesized for comparison. The thioether and ether ligands enhanced heterolytic O-O bond cleavage of peroxy acid-iron porphyrin complex even in highly hydrophobic media without the assistance of acid or base, using mCPPAA as an oxidant. Competitive oxidation of cyclooctane/cyclooctene catalyzed by iron porphyrins showed that complexes 1 and 2 are less effective than heme thiolate (P450 and a synthetic heme thiolate (SR complex)) in oxidizing alkane. The possibility that thiol-ligated heme, which is a protonated form of heme thiolate, is not involved in the active intermediate structure of P450 is indicated by this result. This is the first report concerning the oxidizing ability of a thioether-ligated iron porphyrin.     

Distance metrics for heme protein electron tunneling

There is no doubt that distance is the principal parameter that sets the order of magnitude for electron-tunneling rates in proteins. However, there continue to be varying ways to measure electron-tunneling distances in proteins. This distance uncertainty blurs the issue of whether the intervening protein medium has been naturally selected to speed or slow any particular electron-tunneling reaction. For redox cofactors lacking metals, an edge of the cofactor can be defined that approximates the extent in space that includes most of the wavefunction associated with its tunneling electron. Beyond this edge, the wavefunction tails off much more dramatically in space. The conjugated porphyrin ring seems a reasonable edge for the metal-free pheophytins and bacteriopheophytins of photosynthesis. For a metal containing redox cofactor such as heme, an appropriate cofactor edge is more ambiguous. Electron-tunneling distance may be measured from the conjugated heme macrocycle edge or from the metal, which can be up to 4.8 A longer. In a typical protein medium, such a distance difference normally corresponds to a approximately 1000 fold decrease in tunneling rate. To address this ambiguity, we consider both natural heme protein electron transfer and light-activated electron transfer in ruthenated heme proteins. We find that the edge of the conjugated heme macrocycle provides a reliable and useful tunneling distance definition consistent with other biological electron-tunneling reactions. Furthermore, with this distance metric, heme axially- and edge-oriented electron transfers appear similar and equally well described by a simple square barrier tunneling model. This is in contrast to recent reports for metal-to-metal metrics that require exceptionally poor donor/acceptor couplings to explain heme axially-oriented electron transfers.     

Valence-tautomerism in high-valent iron and manganese porphyrins

Iron and manganese hemes are "high-valent" when the valence state of the metal exceeds III. Redox chemistry of the high valent metal complexes involves redistribution of holes and electrons over the metal ion and the porphyrin and axial ligands, defined as valence tautomerism. Thus, catalytic pathways of heme-containing biomolecules such as peroxidases, catalases and cytochromes P450 involve valence tautomerism, as do pathways of biomimetic oxygen transfer catalysis by manganese porphyrins, robust catalysts with potential commercial value. Determinants of the site of electron abstraction are key to understanding valence tautomerism. In model systems, metal-centered oxidation is supported by hard anionic axial ligands that are also strongly pi-donating, such as oxo, aryl, bix-methoxy and bis-fluoro groups. Manganese(IV) is more stable than iron(IV) and metal-centered one-electron oxidations occur with weaker pi-donating axial ligands such as bisazido, -isocyanato, -hypochlorito and bis chloro groups. Virtually all known high-valent iron porphyrin complexes oxidized by two-electrons above the ferric state are coordinated by the strongly pi-donating oxo or nitrido ligands. In all well-characterized oxo complexes, iron is in the ferryl state and the second oxidizing equivalent resides on the porphyrin. Complexes with iron(V) have not been definitively characterized. One-electron oxidation of oxomanganese(IV) porphyrin complexes gives the oxomanganese(IV) porphyrin pi-cation redicals. In aqueous solution, oxidation of Mn(III) complexes of tetra cationic N-methylpyridiniumylporphyrin isomers by monooxygen donors yields a transient oxomanganese(V) species.     

Studies on the magneto-optical rotation of porphyrins, hemins and methemoglobin compounds]

Using the method of magneto-optical rotation (MOR) various porphyrin derivatives, hemin and heme compounds, and a number of methemoglobin complexes were investigated. The spectra were recorded from 450-600 nm; with methemoglobin also in the Soret region. 1. The metalfree porphyrin derivatives (deutero-, meso-, hemato- and protoporphyrins) were measured in strongly acidic aqueous solution. The derivatives thus present as di-cations yield highly resolved MORspectra, where the Q-bands (Oo leads to; Oo leads to 1) originated from the pi-pi transitions of the porphyrin display the curve shape characteristic of an A-term, this proving the presence of the D4h symmetry. An exception is the protoporphyrin, in which the pi-electron system of the porphyrin is perturbed by the influence of pi-electrons of the vinyl group, causing poor resolution, line broadening, and shift of the Q-bands into the lower-energy spectral region. 2. With iron porphyrins (hemin, heme and their complexes) the charge of the iron and the nature of axial ligands determine the position and intensity of the O-bands in the MOR spectrum. Low-spin complexes have a higher symmetry than the high-spin complexes. Whereas with hemin (S = 5/2), the iron located outside the heme plane strongly disturbs the porphyrin pi-system, the high symmetry of porphyrin is greatly retained in the case of heme. This can be explained by the enhanced binding distance between the bivalent iron and the porphyrin to great for a strong coupling between the microsymmetry of the iron and the macrosymmetry of the porphyrin pi-system.     

High-valent intermediates of heme proteins and model compounds

Recent computational and experimental probes of high-valent intermediates in heme proteins and model compounds reveal a rich spectrum of chemical behavior that is dependent on the nature of the proximal ligand, metal center, distal- and proximal-binding site environment, porphyrin macrocycle architecture, and consequent electronic structure. The results of such studies reveal an underlying complexity, which is simply understood once one is cognizant of the 'chameleon'-like behavior of such intermediates is determined by the high-valent intermediate environment.     

Protein influences on porphyrin structure in cytochrome c: evidence from Raman difference spectroscopy

To probe the details of protein heme interactions, we have developed a Raman difference spectroscopic technique, which allows reliable detection of very small, approximately equal to 0.01 cm-1, frequency differences. When this technique is applied to heme proteins, structural differences in the protein which perturb the porphyrin macrocycle may be examined by obtaining Raman difference data on the porphyrin vibrational modes which are strongly enhanced in the Raman spectrum produced with visible laser excitation. We report here Raman difference spectroscopic data on cytochromes c from 24 species. The differences in the Raman spectrum of the porphyrin between the cytochromes c of any two species are small, confirming that all of the cytochromes we have examined have the same "cytochrome fold". However, many small (0.02-2 cm-1) but systematic differences were detected which indicate structural differences among these proteins. These differences could be classified into three different groups and interpreted in terms of different types of structural variations resulting from specific differences in the amino acid sequences. First, direct interactions between near-heme residues and the porphyrin influence the electron density in the pi orbitals of the porphyrin macrocycle. Second, variation in the residue at position 92, far removed from the heme, affects the frequency of the core-size marker line at 1584 cm-1. Third, the conformation near cysteine 14 affects the shape of the Raman mode which is sensitive to the pyrrole ring substituents (approximately 1313 cm-1). From these data we conclude that there are several ways in which the protein amino acid sequence may regulate the oxidation-reduction potential and several ways in which the sequence can modify the binding site between cytochrome c and its redox partners.     

An Escherichia coli expression-based method for heme substitution

Heme reconstitution with porphyrin analogs is a powerful approach toward understanding the molecular function of heme proteins; present methods, however, have not proven to be generally useful. Here we describe the development and application of an expression-based method for introducing modified porphyrins. The approach allows efficient incorporation of heme analogs using a widely available bacterial strain and offers an attractive alternative to present reconstitution methods that subject proteins to harsh, denaturing conditions.     

Relative orientation of the hemes of the cytochrome bc(1) complexes from Rhodobacter sphaeroides, Rhodospirillum rubrum, and beef heart mitochondria. A linear dichroism study

The orientation of the chromophores in the cytochrome bc(1) of Rhodospirillum rubrum, Rhodobacter sphaeroides, and beef heart mitochondria is reported. The combination of redox-resolved absorption spectrophotometry and linear dichroism experiments at low temperature allows the determination of the orientation of the three hemes with respect to the membrane plane. The orientations of the b(H)-and b(L)-hemes of the R. sphaeroides and beef heart mitochondrial complexes are similar to those determined by crystallographic studies of the mitochondrial cytochrome bc(1). On the other hand the orientations of the b-hemes of the R. rubrum complex lead to the conclusion that the b(H)-heme is more perpendicular to the membrane plane than the b(L)-heme. This could be explained by a specific organization of the b-hemes due to subunit composition of the complex or, alternatively, to a different spatial position of the heme transitions with respect to the porphyrin macrocycle compared with the other complexes. Moreover, our results demonstrate a different orientation of the heme c(1) of the three studied complexes in comparison to crystallographic studies. This difference may arise from the above hypothesis on the transitions of the heme or from flexibility of this subunit in function of its redox state.     

Identification of the Mitochondrial Heme Metabolism Complex

Heme is an essential cofactor for most organisms and all metazoans. While the individual enzymes involved in synthesis and utilization of heme are fairly well known, less is known about the intracellular trafficking of porphyrins and heme, or regulation of heme biosynthesis via protein complexes. To better understand this process we have undertaken a study of macromolecular assemblies associated with heme synthesis. Herein we have utilized mass spectrometry with coimmunoprecipitation of tagged enzymes of the heme biosynthetic pathway in a developing erythroid cell culture model to identify putative protein partners. The validity of these data obtained in the tagged protein system is confirmed by normal porphyrin/heme production by the engineered cells. Data obtained are consistent with the presence of a mitochondrial heme metabolism complex which minimally consists of ferrochelatase, protoporphyrinogen oxidase and aminolevulinic acid synthase-2. Additional proteins involved in iron and intermediary metabolism as well as mitochondrial transporters were identified as potential partners in this complex. The data are consistent with the known location of protein components and support a model of transient protein-protein interactions within a dynamic protein complex.     

On the reaction of ferric heme proteins with nitrite and sulfite

Optical and EPR spectroscopy of ferric heme proteins of the porphyrin, oxyporphyrin, and isobacteriochlorin classes has indicated that nitrite reacts with these proteins at the heme iron. Sulfite has been conclusively proven to react only with proteins containing the isobacteriochlorin macrocycle. Quantitative EPR spectroscopy of these nitrite and sulfite adducts showed that most contained a substantial quantity of undetectable heme. It is suggested that protein-induced autoreduction of nitrite (but not sulfite) and a strained and/or uniaxial g-tensor are the principal ways by which the silent state is produced.     

Photochemically modified myeloperoxidase, with optical spectral properties analogous to those of lactoperoxidase, retains its original catalytic activity

During the course of a reducing reaction using ketyl radicals generated from ketone photoreduction with ultraviolet light, a photoinduced chemical modification of the chromophore group in myeloperoxidase has been found. Light absorption and resonance Raman spectra for this modified enzyme indicated an iron porphyrin chromophore group. The alkaline pyridine hemochrome of the modified enzyme exhibited an optical spectrum closely related to that of iron protoporphyrin IX. The chromophore group of the modified myeloperoxidase was cleaved from the protein by methoxide. Proton magnetic resonance of the diamagnetic bis(cyanide) compound of the extracted heme group showed the presence of two vinyl and three methyl side chains associated with a porphyrin macrocycle. These data provide further insight into the structure of the active site in myeloperoxidase. The EPR spectral properties and enzymatic activities of the native myeloperoxidase are essentially conserved in the modified enzyme. Our present results indicate that the heme peripheral substituent is modified while the stereochemical structure surrounding the chromophore group is not altered by the photochemical modification.     

Evidence for a crosslink between c-heme and a lysine residue in cytochrome P460 of Nitrosomonas europaea

Cytochrome P460 and hydroxylamine oxidoreductase (HAO) of Nitrosomonas europaea catalyze the oxidation of hydroxylamine. Cytochrome P460 contains an unidentified heme-like chromophore whose distinctive spectroscopic properties are similar to those for the P460 heme found in HAO. The heme P460 of HAO has previously been shown by protein chemistry and NMR structural analysis to be a c-heme with an additional covalent crosslink between the C2 ring carbon of a tyrosine residue of the polypeptide chain and a meso carbon of the porphyrin [Arciero, D.M. et al. (1993) Biochemistry 32, 9370–9378]. The recent determination of the gene sequence for cytochrome P460 [Bergmann, D.J. and Hooper, A.B. (1994) FEBS Lett. 353, 324–326] indicates that the heme in this protein also possesses a c-heme binding site and provides the basis for determining whether an HAO-like crosslink exists to the porphyrin.Sequence analysis of a purified heme-containing tryptic chromopeptide from cytochrome P460 revealed two predominant amino acid residues per cycle. Two peptides present in the chromopeptide with the sequences NLPTAEXAAXHK and DGTVTVXELVSV. Comparison of the data to the gene sequence for the protein revealed that the gaps in the first peptide (indicated by X's) code for C residues, confirming the prediction of a c-heme binding motif. The gap in the sequence in the second peptide at cycle 7 is predicted by the gene sequence to be a K. The results suggest that the lysine residue is crosslinked in some manner to the porphyrin macrocycle, possibly mimicking the tyrosine crosslink found for the heme P460 of HAO. While a common role for the crosslinked residues in HAO and cytochrome P460 is difficult to ascertain due to the dissimilarities in side chain structure, it may be related to the similar pK_a values for lysine and tyrosine.     

Halogenation in a series of metallocomplexes of porphyrin

We found that thionyl chloride can chlorinate porphyrin complexes with transient metals (Pd, Ni, or Cu) at the free beta- and meso-positions of the porphyrin macrocycle. A more prolonged or rigorous treatment also causes the chlorination of side alkyl substituents, mainly, methyl groups.     

A pi-helix switch selective for porphyrin deprotonation and product release in human ferrochelatase

Ferrochelatase (protoheme ferrolyase, EC 4.99.1.1) is the terminal enzyme in heme biosynthesis and catalyzes the insertion of ferrous iron into protoporphyrin IX to form protoheme IX (heme). Due to the many critical roles of heme, synthesis of heme is required by the vast majority of organisms. Despite significant investigation of both the microbial and eukaryotic enzyme, details of metal chelation remain unidentified. Here we present the first structure of the wild-type human enzyme, a lead-inhibited intermediate of the wild-type enzyme with bound metallated porphyrin macrocycle, the product bound form of the enzyme, and a higher resolution model for the substrate-bound form of the E343K variant. These data paint a picture of an enzyme that undergoes significant changes in secondary structure during the catalytic cycle. The role that these structural alterations play in overall catalysis and potential protein-protein interactions with other proteins, as well as the possible molecular basis for these changes, is discussed. The atomic details and structural rearrangements presented herein significantly advance our understanding of the substrate binding mode of ferrochelatase and reveal new conformational changes in a structurally conserved pi-helix that is predicted to have a central role in product release.     

Models for ferrous cytochrome b5: Sign inversions in the magnetic circular dichroism spectra of bis-imidazole ferrous porphyrin systems

The magnetic circular dichroism (MCD) spectrum of bis-imidazole ferrous tetraphenylporphyrin in the Soret region is nearly the mirror image of the spectrum of ferrous cytochrome b₅, a bis-imidazole (histidine)-ligated hemoprotein. Based on previous MCD studies of model and protein heme systems, a sign inversion in the spectra of two heme chromophores having essentially the same coordination structure is unexpected. To investigate whether the nature of the porphyrin itself could account for the observed spectral discrepancy, two additional model complexes, bis-imidazole ferrous protoporphyrin IX dimethylester and bis-imidazole ferrous octaethylporphyrin, whose peripheral porphyrin substituent patterns more closely match that of the protein- bound porphyrin, have been prepared and their MCD spectra measured. In these cases, the band pattern of the ferrous protein in the Soret region is successfully reproduced. It therefore appears that the anomalous MCD spectrum of the tetraphenylporphyrin complex can be attributed to the nature and positioning of the peripheral substituents on the porphyrin ring. Although iron tetraphenylporphyrin complexes are frequently used as models for protoporphyrin- containing hemoproteins, one should be aware that such differences in the peripheral porphyrin substituents may significantly affect the spectral properties of the model complex.     

Flavin and heme structures in lactate:cytochrome c oxidoreductase: a resonance Raman study

Resonance Raman spectra of Hansenula anomala L-lactate:cytochrome c oxidoreductase (or flavocytochrome b2), of its cytochrome b2 core, and of a bis(imidazole) iron-protoporphyrin complex were obtained at the Soret preresonance from the oxidized and reduced forms. Raman contributions from both the isoalloxazine ring of flavin mononucleotide (FMN) and the heme b2 were observed in the spectra of oxidized flavocytochrome b2. Raman diagrams showing frequency differences of selected FMN modes between aqueous and proteic environments were drawn for various flavoproteins. These diagrams were closely similar for flavocytochrome b2 and for flavodoxins. This showed that the FMN structure must be very similar in both types of proteins, despite their very different proteic pockets. However, the electron density at this macrocycle was found to be higher in flavocytochrome b2 than in these electron transferases. No significant difference was observed between the heme structures in flavocytochrome b2 and in cytochrome b2 core. The porphyrin center-N(pyrrole) distances in the oxidized and reduced heme b2 were estimated to be 1.990 and 2.022 A from frequencies of porphyrin skeletal modes, respectively. The frequency of the vinyl stretching mode of protoporphyrin was found to be very affected in resonance Raman spectra of flavocytochrome b2 and of cytochrome b2 core (1634-1636 cm-1) relative to those observed in the spectra of iron-protoporphyrin [bis(imidazole)] complexes (1620 cm-1). These specificities were interpreted as reflecting a near coplanarity of the vinyl groups of heme b2 with the pyrrole rings to which they are attached. The low-frequency regions of resonance Raman indicated that the iron atoms of the four hemes b2 are in the porphyrin plane whatever their oxidation state. The histidine-Fe-histidine symmetric stretching mode was located at 205 cm-1 in the spectra of flavocytochrome b2 and of cytochrome b2 core. It was insensitive to the iron oxidation state and indicated strong Fe-His bonds in both states.