Mutagens that are not carcinogens: faulty theory or faulty tests?

In the National Toxicology Program database of 172 chemicals that were judged non-carcinogenic or equivocal in 2 year rodent studies in both sexes of rats and mice, there are 38 chemicals that were mutagenic in Salmonella. All but two of the chemicals had structural alerts for mutagenicity. The largest proportion of the mutagenic non-carcinogens were benzeneamines and substituted benzeneamines. In all, 12 of the mutagenic non-carcinogens had mutagenic carcinogen analogues, and for two chemicals, the carcinogenic analogues were not mutagenic. Non-carcinogens that were mutagenic in Salmonella also tended to be mutagenic and clastogenic in mammalian in vitro tests. The mutagenic responses are discussed and explanations offered for the mutagenicity and lack of carcinogenic activity of these chemicals.     

Potential genotoxic,mutagenic and antimutagenic effects of coffee: A review

Coffee and caffeine are mutagenic to bacteria and fungi, and in high concentrations they are also mutagenic to mammalian cells in culture. However, the mutagenic effects of coffee disappear when bacteria or mammalian cells are cultured in the presence of liver extracts which contain detoxifying enzymes. In vivo, coffee and caffeine are devoid of mutagenic effects. Coffee and caffeine are able to interact with many other mutagens and their effects are synergistic with X-rays, ultraviolet light and some chemical agents. Caffeine seems to potentiate rather than to induce chromosomal aberrations and also to transform sublethal damage of mutagenic agents into lethal damage. Conversely, coffee and caffeine are also able to inhibit the mutagenic effects of numerous chemicals. These antimutagenic effects depend on the time of administration of coffee as compared to the acting time of the mutagenic agent. In that case, caffeine seems to be able to restore the normal cycle of mitosis and phosphorylation in irradiated cells. Finally, the potential genotoxic and mutagenic effects of the most important constituents of coffee are reviewed. Mutagenicity of caffeine is mainly attributed to chemically reactive components such as aliphatic dicarbonyls. The latter compounds, formed during the roasting process, are mutagenic to bacteria but less to mammalian cells. Hydrogen peroxide is not very active but seems to considerably enhance mutagenic properties of methylglyoxal. Phenolic compounds are not mutagenic but rather anticarcinogenic. Benzopyrene and mutagens formed during pyrolysis are not mutagenic whereas roasting of coffee beans at high temperature generates mutagenic heterocyclic amines. In conclusion, the mutagenic potential of coffee and caffeine has been demonstrated in lower organisms, but usually at doses several orders of magnitude greater than the estimated lethal dose for caffeine in humans. Therefore, the chances of coffee and caffeine consumption in moderate to normal amounts to induce mutagenic effects in humans are almost nonexistent.     

Mutagenicity of benzidine and benzidine-congener dyes and selected monoazo dyes in a modified Salmonella assay

We have evaluated the mutagenic activity of a series of diazo compounds derived from benzidine and its congeners o-tolidine, o-dianisidine and 3,3'-dichlorobenzidine as well as several monoazo compounds. The test system used was a modification of the standard Ames Salmonella assay in which FMN, hamster liver S9 and a preincubation step are used to facilitate azo reduction and detection of the resulting mutagenic aromatic amines. All of the benzidine and o-tolidine dyes tested were clearly mutagenic. The o-dianisidine dyes except for Direct Blue 218 were also mutagenic. Direct Blue 218 is a copper complex of the mutagenic o-dianisidine dye Direct Blue 15. Pigment Yellow 12, which is derived from 3,3'-dichlorobenzidine, could not be detected as mutagenic, presumably because of its lack of solubility in the test reaction mixture. Of the monoazo dyes tested, methyl orange was clearly mutagenic, while C.I. Acid Red 26 and Acid Dye (C.I. 16155; often referred to as Ponceau 3R) had marginal to weak mutagenic activity. Several commercial dye samples had greater mutagenic activity with the modified test protocol than did equimolar quantities of their mutagenic aromatic amine reduction products. Investigation of this phenomenon for Direct Black 38 and trypan blue showed that it was due to the presence of mutagenic impurities in these samples. The modified method used appears to be suitable for testing the mutagenicity of azo dyes, and it may also be useful for monitoring the presence of mutagenic or potentially carcinogenic impurities in otherwise nonmutagenic azo dyes.     

Mutagenic activity and structure-activity relationships of short-chain dialkyl N-nitrosamines in a hamster hepatocyte V79 cell-mediated system

A series of 19 short chain dialkyl N-nitrosamines was studied for mutagenic activity in an uninduced hamster hepatocyte V79 cell-mediated mutagenesis system. Ouabain was used as the selective agent to quantitatively analyze for chemically induced mutants. None of the nitrosamines was mutagenic in the absence of hamster hepatocyte activation. The relative mutagenic activities of the nitrosamines at an equimolar dose are presented. The results of the study indicated that: (a) increasing alkyl chain length decreased mutagenic activity; (b) oxidation of the carbon position to a carbonyl group increased the mutagenic activity of symmetrical and asymmetrical nitrosamines, whereas oxidation to a hydroxyl group only increased the mutagenic activity of the asymmetrical nitrosamines tested and (c) the carbon position at which oxidation occurred was important in determining mutagenic activity. The relationships between structure, metabolic activation, and mechanisms of mutagenic activity are discussed.     

Mutagenicities of N-nitrosamines on Salmonella.

The mutagenic activities of 11 N-nitrosamines were tested using Salmonella typhimurium TA100 and TA98. All the carcinogenic N-nitrosamines were mutagenic on TA100 with a drug-activating system from the rat liver, whereas N,N-diphenylnitrosamine, a non-carcinogen, was not mutagenic. None of the N-nitrosamines was mutagenic on TA98, except N,N-diethylnitrosamine which was weakly mutagenic. To detect the mutagenicity of N,N-dimethylnitrosamine, the pre-incubation of bacteria and N,N-dimethylnitrosamine with S-9 Mix before if was poured onto plates was obligatorily required. Dimethyl sulfoxide inhibited the mutagenic effect of N,N-dimethylnitrosamine.     

Ames test: mutagenic activity of airborne particles collected on airconditioner filters during the fire at a Sandoz storehouse in Schweizerhalle on November 1, 1986

The mutagenic activity of methanol extracts from airconditioner filters was tested using the standard plate-incorporation procedure for the Ames test and the strains Salmonella typhimurium TA97, TA98 and TA100 as test organisms. In a first set of experiments filters from 4 buildings were investigated. For each building the mutagenic activity of a filter which was in use during the fire (fire-exposed) was compared with the mutagenic activity of a filter which was exposed for a similar time span to normal urban air (non-exposed). While for 1 pair of filters the non-exposed extract was more mutagenic than the fire-exposed material, the opposite was found for 2 other filter pairs, and in 1 case there was hardly any difference in the mutagenic activities of the fire-exposed and the non-exposed filter extracts. Overall differences by factors up to 100 were observed in the mutants/m3 air values of the most and the least mutagenic filter extracts. The second group of experiments was performed to investigate the variations in mutagenic activity of filter extracts occurring due to changes in the weather conditions. Airborne particles were collected for 3 consecutive periods of 10-11 days at the 2 buildings where the extracts of the fire-exposed filters had been found to be more mutagenic than the corresponding control materials. The differences between the strongest and the weakest mutagenic filter extracts of these series were similar to the differences observed previously between the fire-exposed filters and the non-exposed filter materials. The highest mutagenic activities found in the second group of experiments was similar, at both sites, to the mutagenic activities measured in the fire-exposed extracts from these 2 buildings. Since the differences in the mutagenic activities of filters exposed to urban air during the different meteorological conditions were similar to the differences observed between fire-exposed and non-exposed materials, it is not possible to state whether the fire led to the distribution of mutagenic chemicals, although it is theoretically possible. However, based on the observation that the maximal mutagenic activities of the fire-exposed and the non-exposed extracts were similar, the present study allows the conclusion that the mutagenic burden for the population of the area of Basel was not significantly increased by the fire in Schweizerhalle on November 1, 1986.     

Structural Requirements for Mutagenic Activities of N-Heterocyclic Bases in the Salmonella Test System

The mutagenic activities of quinoline, isoquinoline, phenanthridine, benzo(f)quinoline, benzo(h)quinoline and their α-amino derivatives were compared in relation to the effect of structural changes using the Salmonella typhimurium test system. All mutagenic compounds tested require the liver microsomal fraction for their mutagenic activity. Phenanthridine, two benzoquinolines and quinoline were mutagenic. α-Amination of two benzoquinolines and quinoline resulted to increase their mutagenic activity intensively. Addition of a benzene ring to the benzene moiety of 2-aminoquinoline, so that two carbon atoms are shared, affected distinctly the increase in the mutagenic activity. The co-existence of benzoquinoline series with 2-aminobenzo(f)quinoline showed the clear synergistic action.     

Enhanced mutagenicity of anisidine isomers in bacterial strains containing elevated N-acetyltransferase activity.

In previous studies on the mutagenicity of anisidine isomers, the ortho isomer was considered to be mutagenic towards standard Ames tester strains, while the para isomer gave equivocal results. In the present study we show that both para- and ortho-anisidine isomers are mutagenic in a Salmonella typhimurium tester strain containing elevated levels of N-acetyltransferase (YG1029). p-Anisidine gave a positive mutagenic response using either hamster S9 or ram seminal vesicle microsomes (RSVM) as an activating system, while o-anisidine gave a positive response only with the hamster S9 fraction. The mutagenic response from p-anisidine was greater than with o-anisidine in each case. In tests with p-anisidine and RSVM, the addition of arachidonic acid was not necessary to observe a mutagenic response. Catalase produced a dose-dependent decrease in the mutagenic response with p-anisidine and RSVM; this indicates that endogenous hydrogen peroxide from the bacteria acts as a substrate for the peroxidase activity of RSVM prostaglandin H synthase. These results demonstrate that both anisidine isomers are mutagenic and that N-acetyltransferase enzymes play an important role in their metabolism to mutagenic species.     

Mutagenicity of aliphatic nitrosamines in Salmonella typhimurium.

25 aliphatic nitrosamines were examined in the Ames assay for bacterial mutagens, using rat liver "S-9" for activation. Of them, 8 carcinogens were mutagenic and 5 non-carcinogens were not mutagenic. However, 2 compounds not carcinogenic in rats were mutagenic and 9 carcinogens were not mutagenic, including 6 that are liver carcinogens in rats.     

Mutagenic profile of rubber dust and fume exposure in two rubber tire companies

The aim of this study was to evaluate current mutagenic activity of ambient rubber dust and fume exposure in the mixing and curing departments of two rubber tire companies situated in The Netherlands and Sweden. Salmonella typhimurium strains YG1021, YG1024 and YG1041 were used to study the possible presence of mutagenic nitroarenes and aromatic amines. A large difference in mutagenic activity was found between the two companies. While the rubber tire company situated in The Netherlands revealed overall high mutagenic activity of rubber dust and fumes in the mixing and curing departments, respectively, 430 and 279 rev/m(3) (YG1041), the Swedish company showed almost no mutagenic activity, respectively, 18 and 54 rev/m(3) (YG1041). Further identification of the mutagenic profile showed that mutagenic activity was exclusively observed in S. typhimurium strains with elevated levels of O-acetyltransferase activity (YG1041 and YG1024) in the presence of a metabolic active liver S9 fraction, possibly indicating the presence of indirect mutagenic aromatic amines. These results show that although production processes and lay-out within rubber tire companies are comparable, differences in rubber chemicals used and overall level of control measures (e.g., good housekeeping, cleanliness) are likely to result in substantial differences in mutagenic exposure levels between companies.     

Mutagenic activity of south Indian food items.

Dietary components and food dishes commonly consumed in South India were screened for their mutagenic activity. Kesari powder, calamus oil, palm drink, toddy and Kewra essence were found to be strongly mutagenic; garlic, palm oil, arrack, onion and pyrolysed portions of bread toast, chicory powder were weakly mutagenic, while tamarind and turmeric were not. Certain salted, sundried and oil fried food items were also mutagenic. Cissus quadrangularis was mutagenic, while 'decoctions' of cumin seeds, aniseeds and ginger were not. Several perfumes, essential oils and colouring agents, which are commonly used were also screened and many of them exhibited their mutagenic potential by inducing the 'reverse mutation' in Salmonella typhimurium tester strains.     

Mutagenicity of 22 N-nitrosamides and related compounds for Salmonella typhimurium TA1535.

Twenty-two N-nitrosamides and related compounds, including 14 nitrosoureas, 5 nitrosocarbamates, and one nitrosocyanamide, were tested at various concentrations for mutagenic activity towards Salmonella typhimurium TA1535 without the use of microsomes. The ether-water partition coefficient, solubility in water, and half-life in aqueous solution were also measured. Twenty compounds were mutagenic, with "standard mutagenic concentrations" (i.e. those producing 100 mutants/dish) of 0.0024--6500 micron. Standard mutagenic concentration was negatively correlated with the partition coefficient. Three compounds (ethyl 2-acetoxyethylnitrosocarbamate, nitrosocarbaryl, and methylnitrosobenzamide) were more active than the classic mutagen methylnitrosonitroguanidine. Nitrosocarbamates were at least 50 times more mutagenic than the corresponding nitrosoureas. Nitrosodihydrouracil and propylene-nitrosourea were more active than related compounds. Ethylnitrosocyanamide was 730 times more mutagenic than ethylnitrosourea. Fifteen of the test compounds (of which 14 were mutagenic) had previously been assayed in rats for carcinogenicity, all with positive results.     

Mutagenicity of some commercially available nitro compounds for Salmonella typhimurium.

Benzoyl chloride and 53 commercially available aromatic heterocyclic and aliphatic nitro compounds were tested for mutagenicity in Salmonella typhimurium TA98 and TA100. 34 of 53 nitro compounds (64%) were mutagenic, 4 in TA100 only, 15 in TA98 only, and 15 in both strains. 13 of the heterocyclic derivatives of pyridine, indole, indazole, quinoline, and benzimidazole were mutagenic. 21 of 34 mutagenic nitro compounds were bactericidal. Nitromethane was the only aliphatic tested and was not mutagenic. Benzoyl chloride, a human carcinogen, was mutagenic for TA98.     

Mutagenicity in Salmonella typhimurium tester strains of XAD-2-ether extract, recovered from Katsura River water in Kyoto City, and its fractions

The mutagenic activity of XAD-2-ether extracts recovered from Katsura River water at monthly intervals during September to December 1980 was tested on S. typhimurium TA1538, TA1535, TA98 and TA100. The extracts showed strong mutagenic activity towards TA1538 nd TA98, especially in the presence of S9 mix. They were more active to TA1538 than to TA98. Some of each of the XAD-2-ether extracts were pooled and separated into neutral, basic and acidic fractions, and their mutagenic activities were tested on TA1538 and TA98 to determine their contribution to the total mutagenic activity of the parent extract. The neutral fraction was responsible for most of the total mutagenic activity of the parent extract. Although the basic fraction was only 5.4% by weight of the parent extract, it was much more mutagenic than any other fraction. Its contribution to the total mutagenic activity was higher than the acidic fraction which was 30.5% by weight of the parent extract.     

Mutagenicity studies on coffee. The influence of different factors on the mutagenic activity in the Salmonella/mammalian microsome assay

Recently, mutagenic activity on several strains of Salmonella typhimurium has been found in many heat-processed foodstuffs. The previously reported direct-acting mutagenic activity of coffee in Salmonella typhimurium TA100 (Ames assay) was confirmed in our study. In addition to TA100, a mutagenic effect of coffee was also found by using the newly developed strain TA102. The mutagenic activity was abolished by the addition of rat-liver homogenate. 10% S9 mix completely eliminated the mutagenic activity of 30 mg of coffee per plate. The addition of reduced glutathione to active S9 further decreased the mutagenic activity and also reduced the mutagenicity together with inactivated S9. The compound or compounds responsible for this inactivation are heat-labile and seem to be located in the cytosol fraction of the S9. Part of the mutagenicity of coffee was also lost spontaneously upon incubation at temperatures between 0 degrees and 50 degrees C. The loss of activity was dependent on temperature, being more pronounced at 50 degrees C compared to 0 degrees C (at 50 degrees C approximately 50% of the mutagenic activity was lost after 6 h). As anaerobic conditions prevented this loss of mutagenicity almost totally, oxidative processes are probably responsible for the inactivation. The stability of the mutagen was not influenced by incubation at low pH values (pH 1-3), with or without the addition of pepsinogen. The mutagenic properties of methylglyoxal, which to some extent could be responsible for the mutagenic activity of coffee, were compared with those of coffee. Methylglyoxal was strongly mutagenic towards Salmonella typhimurium TA100 and TA102. Its mutagenic activity was partially inactivated by the addition of 10% S9. Glyoxalase I and II together with reduced glutathione abolished the mutagenic activity of methylglyoxal but reduced the mutagenicity of coffee by only 80%. Since these enzymes occur in mammalian cells, the mutagenic compound(s) of coffee could also be degraded in vivo. This conclusion is supported by the fact that a long-term carcinogenicity study with rats was negative. These results clearly demonstrate that the effects observed in vitro do not necessarily also occur in vivo, but that in vitro experiments may contribute to the understanding of fundamental mechanisms of chemical carcinogenesis.     

The release of mutagens from airborne particles in the presence of physiological fluids

Airborne particulates collected indoors in residences and outdoors were extracted by soxhlet extraction and sonication with methanol. In a comparative study in which mutagenic activity was evaluated in the Salmonella typhimurium reversion assay both soxhlet extraction and sonication proved to be suitable extraction methods. First, the residue, obtained by sonication of loaded filters with methanol followed by evaporation to dryness (tar), was sonicated with newborn calf serum and lung lavage fluid from pigs. All serum extracts of the tar were mutagenic to Salmonella typhimurium TA98, and contained direct- and indirect-acting mutagens. However, the mutagenic activity recovered by serum was only about half of the total mutagenic activity of the tar. The other part of the mutagenic activity remained in the tar. Lung lavage fluid was only able to remove 5-10% of direct-acting mutagens from the tar of all samples. About 20% of indirect-acting mutagens from indoor air were recovered in lung lavage fluid, while the lung lavage fluid extract from outdoor air did not show indirect mutagenic activity. Second, mutagenic activity recovered by direct sonication of the filters with physiological fluids was comparable with the recovery obtained by sonication of the tar. However, after sonication of the filter with lung lavage fluid hardly any mutagenic activity remained on the filter, whereas after sonication of the tar a clear mutagenic activity was observed in the non-soluble residue.     

Mutagenicity of substituted phenanthrenes in Salmonella typhimurium

An extensive series of alkylated phenanthrenes was assayed for mutagenic activity in Salmonella typhimurium TA98 and TA100. Among the alkylated phenanthrenes assayed, 1-methylphenanthrene, 9-methylphenanthrene, 1,4-dimethylphenanthrene and 4,10-dimethylphenanthrene were active as mutagens. These studies suggest that the structural requirements favoring mutagenic activity among alkylated phenanthrenes are inhibition of 9,10-dihydrodiol formation and the presence of an unsubstituted angular ring adjacent to a free peri position. The mutagenic activities of 9-fluoro-, 9-chloro-, and 9-bromo-phenanthrene were also evaluated. The positive mutagenic response of these halogenated phenanthrenes further supports the observation that inhibition of 9,10-dihydrodiol formation among substituted phenanthrenes favors mutagenic activity.     

Induction of 6-thioguanine-resistant mutants by hyperoxia and gamma-irradiation: effect of compromising cellular antioxidant systems

Hyperoxia and gamma-irradiation were found to be mutagenic in a transformed Syrian hamster cell line in a dose-dependent manner. The frequency of resistance to 6-thioguanine increased from 10 per 10(6) survivors after 48 h of growth in 70% O2 to 32.6 (highly significant) after 75 h. Increasing the oxygen tension to 95% resulted in a significant mutagenic response in only 44 h. At equitoxic doses, gamma-irradiation was 4 times more mutagenic than 70% O2. After growth in hyperoxia, the cells showed an enhancement of catalase activity, glutathione peroxidase activity and glutathione levels but there was little effect on superoxide dismutase activity. Diethyldithiocarbamate (3 mM, 1.5 h) was mutagenic in normoxia and potentiated the mutagenic activity of both gamma-irradiation and hyperoxia. Cells thus treated showed an 855 reduction in superoxide dismutase activity. When diethyldithiocarbamate was used in conjunction with a direct-acting alkylating agent, the mutagenic response was only additive. Depletion of cellular glutathione with buthionine sulfoximine (0.2 mM) or inhibition of catalase activity with aminotriazole (100 mM) was also effective in potentiating the mutagenic response of gamma-irradiation and hyperoxia. The data demonstrates that endogenously produced activated oxygen species are mutagenic to hamster cells in culture and suggest that aerobic organisms are subject to an unavoidable background risk due to living in an oxygen atmosphere.     

Mutagenic cholesterol preparations.

Naturally air-aged commercial samples of USP or reagent-grade cholesterol contain components which are mutagenic towards Salmonella typhimurium strains TA1537, TA1538 and TA98. These mutagenic components are associated with the polar cholesterol autoxidation products, but identity of the mutagenic components has not been achieved. Pure crystalline nonmutagenic cholestrol free from autoxidation products becomes mutagenic towards these strains upon heating at 70 degrees in air or following exposure to 60 Co gamma-radiation.     

Mutagenic activity of nine N,N-disubstituted hydrazines in the Salmonella/mammalian microsome assay.

The mutagenic activity of N,N-dimethyl-, N,N-diethyl-, N,N-dibutyl-, N,N-diisobutyl-, N,N-di(p-tolyl)-, N-ethyl-N-phenyl-, N,N-dibenzyl-, N,N-diphenyl- and N,N-diisopropylhydrazine was examined in the Salmonella/mammalian microsome assay using the strains TA1535, TA1537, TA97, TA98, TA100, TA102 and TA1530. All nine hydrazines were mutagenic in at least one tester strain, although of borderline significance for some of the compounds. The mutagenic potencies of the hydrazines varied 2-3 orders of magnitude, from very weak to moderate mutagenic activity. In general, the addition of S9 resulted in a lowering of the mutagenic activity and a lowering of the toxic properties of the hydrazines. The test results were relatively difficult to evaluate due to toxic effects of many of the test compounds on the test bacteria which may have resulted in an underestimation of the mutagenic potencies of some of the compounds. The pattern of mutagenic activity of the hydrazines in the different tester strains indicates that more than one mechanism of action may be involved in the mutagenicity.