Calpain mutants with increased Ca2+ sensitivity and implications for the role of the C(2)-like domain

The ubiquitous calpain isoforms (mu- and m-calpain) are Ca(2+)-dependent cysteine proteases that require surprisingly high Ca(2+) concentrations for activation in vitro ( approximately 50 and approximately 300 microm, respectively). The molecular basis of such a high requirement for Ca(2+) in vitro is not known. In this study, we substantially reduced the concentration of Ca(2+) required for the activation of m-calpain in vitro through the specific disruption of interdomain interactions by structure-guided site-directed mutagenesis. Several interdomain electrostatic interactions involving lysine residues in domain II and acidic residues in the C(2)-like domain III were disrupted, and the effects of these mutations on activity and Ca(2+) sensitivity were analyzed. The mutation to serine of Glu-504, a residue that is conserved in both mu- and m-calpain and interacts most notably with Lys-234, reduced the in vitro Ca(2+) requirement for activity by almost 50%. The mutation of Lys-234 to serine or glutamic acid resulted in a similar reduction. These are the first reported cases in which point mutations have been able to reduce the Ca(2+) requirement of calpain. The structures of the mutants in the absence of Ca(2+) were shown by x-ray crystallography to be unchanged from the wild type, demonstrating that the increase in Ca(2+) sensitivity was not attributable to conformational change prior to activation. The conservation of sequence between mu-calpain, m-calpain, and calpain 3 in this region suggests that the results can be extended to all of these isoforms. Whereas the primary Ca(2+) binding is assumed to occur at EF-hands in domains IV and VI, these results show that domain II-domain III salt bridges are important in the process of the Ca(2+)-induced activation of calpain and that they influence the overall Ca(2+) requirement of the enzyme.     

Functional consequences of glutamate, aspartate, glutamine, and asparagine mutations in the stalk sector of the Ca2+-ATPase of sarcoplasmic reticulum

Nucleotides encoding glutamate, glutamine, aspartate, or asparagine residues within the stalk sector of the sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca2+-ATPase were altered by oligonucleotide-directed site-specific mutagenesis. The mutant cDNAs were expressed in COS-1 cells, and mutant Ca2+-ATPases were assayed for Ca2+ transport function and phosphoenzyme formation. Multiple mutations introduced into stalks, 1, 2, and 3 resulted in partial loss of Ca2+ transport function. In most cases, subsequent mutation of individual amino acids in the cluster had no effect on Ca2+ transport activity. In one cluster, however, it was possible to assign the reduction in Ca2+ transport activity to alterations of Asn111 and Asn114. The mutant Asn114 to alanine retained about 50% activity, whereas the change Asn111 to alanine retained only 10% activity. None of the mutations affected phosphorylation of the enzyme by ATP in the presence of Ca2+ or by inorganic phosphate in the absence of Ca2+. The combined experiments suggest that the reduced Ca2+ uptake observed in the Asn111 and Asn114 mutants was not due to a defect in enzyme activation by Ca2+ or in formation of the phosphorylated enzyme intermediate but rather to incompetent handling of the bound Ca2+ following ATP utilization. These results demonstrate that the acidic and amidated residues within the stalk region do not constitute the high affinity Ca2+-binding sites whose occupancy is required for enzyme activation. They may, however, act to sequester cytoplasmic Ca2+ and to channel it to domains that are involved in enzyme activation and cation translocation. Simultaneous mutation of 4 glutamate residues to alanine in the lumenal loop between transmembrane sequences M1 and M2 did not affect Ca2+ transport activity, indicating that acidic residues in this lumenal loop do not play an essential role in Ca2+ transport. Similarly, mutation of Glu192 and Asp196 in the beta-strand domain between stalk helices 2 and 3 did not affect Ca2+ transport activity, although mutation of Asp196 did diminish expression of the protein.     

Domain III of calpain is a ca2+-regulated phospholipid-binding domain

The X-ray structure of m-calpain shows that domain III of the large subunit is structurally related to C2 domains, Ca2+-regulated lipid binding modules in many enzymes. To address whether this structural similarity entails functional analogy, we have characterized recombinant domain III from rat micro- and m-calpain and Drosophila CALPB. In a Ca2+ overlay assay domain III displays a large capacity for Ca2+ binding, commensurable with that of domain IV, the principal Ca2+-binding domain of calpains. The amount of Ca2+ bound to domain III increases 2- to 10-fold upon the addition of liposomes containing 20-40% di- and triphosphoinositides. Conversely, phospholipid-binding in spin-column size-exclusion chromatography is significantly promoted by Ca2+, in a manner similar to known C2 domains. These results suggest that domain III might be the primary lipid binding site of calpain and may play a decisive role in orchestrating Ca2+- and lipid activation of the enzyme.     

Mu-calpain binds to lipid bilayers via the exposed hydrophobic surface of its Ca2+-activated conformation

Mu- and m-calpain are cysteine proteases requiring micro- and millimolar Ca2+ concentrations for their activation in vitro. Among other mechanisms, interaction of calpains with membrane phospholipids has been proposed to facilitate their activation by nanomolar [Ca2+] in living cells. Here the interaction of non-autolysing, C115A active-site mutated heterodimeric human mu-calpain with phospholipid bilayers was studied in vitro using protein-to-lipid fluorescence resonance energy transfer and surface plasmon resonance. Binding to liposomes was Ca2+-dependent, but not selective for specific phospholipid head groups. [Ca2+]0.5 for association with lipid bilayers was not lower than that required for the exposure of hydrophobic surface (detected by TNS fluorescence) or for enzyme activity in the absence of lipids. Deletion of domain V reduced the lipid affinity of the isolated small subunit (600-fold) and of the heterodimer (10- to 15-fold), thus confirming the proposed role of domain V for membrane binding. Unexpectedly, mutations in the acidic loop of the 'C2-like' domain III, a putative Ca2+ and phospholipid-binding site, did not affect lipid affinity. Taken together, these results support the hypothesis that in vitro membrane binding of mu-calpain is due to the exposed hydrophobic surface of the active conformation and does not reduce the Ca2+ requirement for activation.     

Effect of Ca2+ on binding of the calpains to calpastatin

Autolyzed mu-calpain, unautolyzed mu-calpain, autolyzed m-calpain, and unautolyzed m-calpain (mu-calpain is the micromolar Ca2+-requiring proteinase, m-calpain is the millimolar Ca2+-requiring proteinase) were passed through a calpastatin-affinity column at different free Ca2+ concentrations, and binding of the calpains to calpastatin was compared with proteolytic activity of that calpain at each Ca2+ concentration. Unautolyzed m-calpain, autolyzed m-calpain, and autolyzed mu-calpain required less Ca2+ for half-maximal binding to calpastatin than for half-maximal activity. Unautolyzed mu-calpain, however, required slightly more Ca2+ for half-maximal binding to calpastatin than for half-maximal activity. Half-maximal binding of oxidatively inactivated mu- or m-calpain to calpastatin required approximately the same Ca2+ concentrations as half-maximal binding of unautolyzed mu- or m-calpain, respectively, to calpastatin. Binding of unautolyzed m-calpain and autolyzed mu-calpain to calpastatin occurred over a wide range of Ca2+ concentrations, and it seems likely that two or more Ca2+-binding sites with different Ca2+-binding constants are involved in binding of the calpains to calpastatin. Proteolytic activity occurs at different Ca2+ concentrations than calpastatin binding, suggesting a second set of Ca2+-binding sites associated with proteolytic activity. Third and fourth sets of Ca2+-binding sites may be involved in autolysis and in binding to phosphatidylinositol or cell membranes; these four Ca2+-dependent properties of the calpains may require the eight potential Ca2+-binding sites that amino acid sequences predict are present in the calpain molecules.     

Residues 110-126 in the A1 domain of factor VIII contain a Ca2+ binding site required for cofactor activity

Generation of factor VIII cofactor activity requires divalent metal ions such as Ca2+ or Mn2+. Evaluation of cofactor reconstitution from isolated factor VIIIa subunits revealed the presence of a functional Ca2+ binding site within the A1 subunit. Isothermal titration calorimetry demonstrated at least two Ca2+ binding sites of similar affinity (K(d) = 0.74 microm) within the A1 subunit. Mutagenesis of an acidic residue-rich region in the A1 domain (residues 110-126) homologous to a putative Ca2+ binding site in factor V (Zeibdawi, A. R., and Pryzdial, E. L. (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 19929-19936) and expression of B-domainless factor VIII molecules yielded reagents to probe Ca2+ and Mn2+ binding in a functional assay. Basal activity observed for wild type factor VIII in a metal ion-free buffer was enhanced approximately 2-fold with saturating Ca2+ or Mn2+ and yielded functional K(d) values of 1.2 and 1.40 microm, respectively. Ca2+ binding affinity was greatly reduced (or lost) in several mutants including E110A, E110D, D116A, E122A, D125A, and D126A. Alternatively, E113A, D115A, and E124A showed wild type-like activity with little or no reduction in Ca2+ affinity. However, Mn2+ affinity was minimally altered except for mutant D125A (and D116A). These results are consistent with region 110-126 serving a critical role for Ca2+ coordination with selected residues capable of contributing to a partially overlapping site for Mn2+, and that occupancy of either site is required for maximal cofactor activity.     

Crystal structure of a micro-like calpain reveals a partially activated conformation with low Ca2+ requirement

The two Ca2+-dependent cysteine proteases, micro- and m-calpain, are involved in various Ca2+-linked signal pathways but differ markedly in their Ca2+ requirements for activation. We have determined the structure of a micro-like calpain, which has 85% micro-calpain sequence (the first 48 and the last 62 residues of the large subunit are those from m-calpain) and a low Ca2+ requirement. This construct was used because micro-calpain itself is too poorly expressed. The structure of micro-like calpain is very similar in overall fold to that of m-calpain as expected, but differs significantly in two aspects. In comparison with m-calpain, the catalytic triad residues in micro-like calpain, His and Cys, are much closer together in the absence of Ca2+, and significant portions of the Ca2+ binding EF-hand motifs are disordered and more flexible. These structural differences imply that Ca2+-free micro-calpain may represent a partially activated structure, requiring lower Ca2+ concentration to trigger its activation.     

Calcium-dependent catalytic activity of a novel phytase from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens DS11

The thermostable phytase from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens DS11 hydrolyzes phytate (myo-inositol hexakisphosphate, IP6) to less phosphorylated myo-inositol phosphates in the presence of Ca2+. In this report, we discuss the unique Ca2+-dependent catalytic properties of the phytase and its specific substrate requirement. Initial rate kinetic studies of the phytase indicate that the enzyme activity follows a rapid equilibrium ordered mechanism in which binding of Ca2+ to the active site is necessary for the essential activation of the enzyme. Ca2+ turned out to be also required for the substrate because the phytase is only able to hydrolyze the calcium-phytate complex. In fact, both an excess amount of free Ca2+ and an excess of free phytate, which is not complexed with each other, can act as competitive inhibitors. The Ca2+-dependent catalytic activity of the enzyme was further confirmed, and the critical amino acid residues for the binding of Ca2+ and substrate were identified by site-specific mutagenesis studies. Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) was used to understand if the decreased enzymatic activity was related to poor Ca2+ binding. The pH dependence of the Vmax and Vmax/Km consistently supported these observations by demonstrating that the enzyme activity is dependent on the ionization of amino acid residues that are important for the binding of Ca2+ and the substrate. The Ca2+-dependent activation of enzyme and substrate was found to be different from other histidine acid phytases that hydrolyze metal-free phytate.     

Structural model of a synthetic Ca2+ channel with bound Ca2+ ions and dihydropyridine ligand.

Grove et al. have demonstrated L-type Ca2+ channel activity of a synthetic channel peptide (SCP) composed of four helices (sequence: DPWNVFDFLI10VIGSIIDVIL20SE) tethered by their C-termini to a nanopeptide template. We sought to obtain the optimal conformations of SCP and locate the binding sites for Ca2+ and for the dihydropyridine ligand nifedipine. Eight Ca2+ ions were added to neutralize the 16 acidic residues in the helices. Eight patterns of the salt bridges between Ca2+ ions and pairs of the acidic residues were calculated by the Monte Carlo-with-energy-minimization (MCM) protocol. In the energetically optimal conformation, two Ca2+ ions were bound to Asp-1 residues at the intracellular side of SCP, and six Ca2+ ions were arrayed in two files at the diametrically opposite sides of the pore, implying a Ca2+ relay mechanism. Nine modes of nifedipine binding to SCP were simulated by the MCM calculations. In the energetically optimal mode, the ligand fits snugly in the pore. The complex is stabilized by Ca2+ bound between two Asp-17 residues and hydrophilic groups of the ligand. The latter substitute water molecules adjacent to Ca2+ in the ligand-free pore and thus do not obstruct Ca2+ relay. The ligand-binding site is proximal to a hydrophobic bracelet of Ile-10 residues whose rotation is sterically hindered. In some conformations, the bracelet is narrow enough to block the permeation of the hydrated Ca2+ ions. The bracelet may thus act as a "gate" in SCP. Nifedipine and (R)-Bay K 8644, which act as blockers of the SCP, extend a side-chain hydrophobic moiety toward the Ile-10 residues. This would stabilize the pore-closing conformation of the gate. In contrast, the channel activator (S)-Bay K 8644 exposes a hydrophilic moiety toward the Ile-10 residues, thus destabilizing the pore-closing conformation of the gate.     

Domain II of m-calpain is a Ca(2+)-dependent cysteine protease

Calpain, a Ca(2+)-dependent cytosolic cysteine protease, proteolytically modulates specific substrates involved in Ca(2+)-mediated intracellular events, such as signal transduction, cell cycle, differentiation, and apoptosis. The 3D structure of m-calpain, in the absence of Ca(2+), revealed that the two subdomains (domains IIa and IIb) of the protease domain (II) have an 'open' conformation, probably due to interactions with other domains. Although the presence of an EF-hand structure was once predicted in the protease domain, no explicit Ca(2+)-binding structure was identified in the 3D structure. Therefore, it is predicted that if the protease domain is excised from the calpain molecule, it will have a Ca(2+)-independent protease activity. In this study, we have characterized a truncated human m-calpain that consists of only the protease domain. Unexpectedly, the proteolytic activity was Ca(2+)-dependent, very weak, and not effectively inhibited by calpastatin, a calpain inhibitor. Ca(2+)-dependent modification of the protease domain by the cysteine protease inhibitor, E-64c, was clearly observed as a SDS-PAGE migration change, indicating that the conformational changes of this domain are a result of Ca(2+) binding. These results suggest that the Ca(2+) binding to domain II, as well as to domains III, IV, and VI, is critical in the process of complete activation of calpain.     

Single Point Mutations in the Small Cytoplasmic Loop of ACA8, a Plasma Membrane Ca2+-ATPase of Arabidopsis thaliana, Generate Partially Deregulated Pumps

ACA8 is a type 2B Ca²⁺-ATPase having a regulatory N terminus whose auto-inhibitory action can be suppressed by binding of calmodulin (CaM) or of acidic phospholipids. ACA8 N terminus is able to interact with a region of the small cytoplasmic loop connecting transmembrane domains 2 and 3. To determine the role of this interaction in auto-inhibition we analyzed single point mutants produced by mutagenesis of ACA8 Glu²⁵² to Asn³⁴⁵ sequence. Mutation to Ala of any of six tested acidic residues (Glu²⁵², Asp²⁷³, Asp²⁹¹, Asp³⁰³, Glu³⁰², or Asp³³²) renders an enzyme that is less dependent on CaM for activity. These results highlight the relevance in ACA8 auto-inhibition of a negative charge of the surface area of the small cytoplasmic loop. The most deregulated of these mutants is D291A ACA8, which is less activated by controlled proteolysis or by acidic phospholipids; the D291A mutant has an apparent affinity for CaM higher than wild-type ACA8. Moreover, its phenotype is stronger than that of D291N ACA8, suggesting a more direct involvement of this residue in the mechanism of auto-inhibition. Among the other produced mutants (I284A, N286A, P289A, P322A, V344A, and N345A), only P322A ACA8 is less dependent on CaM for activity than the wild type. The results reported in this study provide the first evidence that the small cytoplasmic loop of a type 2B Ca²⁺-ATPase plays a role in the attainment of the auto-inhibited state.     

Changes in Ca2+ affinity upon activation of Agkistrodon piscivorus piscivorus phospholipase A2

Changes in the affinity of calcium for phospholipase A2 from Agkistrodon piscivorus piscivorus during activation of the enzyme on the surface of phosphatidylcholine vesicles have been investigated by site-directed mutagenesis and fluorescence spectroscopy. Changes in fluorescence that occur during lipid binding and subsequent activation have been ascribed to each of the three individual Trp residues in the protein. This was accomplished by generating a panel of mutant proteins, each of which lacks one or more Trp residues. Both Trp21, which is found in the interfacial binding region, and Trp119 show changes in fluorescence upon protein binding to small unilamellar zwitterionic vesicles or large unilamellar vesicles containing sufficient anionic lipid. Trp31, which is near the Ca2+ binding loop, exhibits little change in fluorescence upon lipid bilayer binding. A change in the fluorescence of the protein also occurs during activation of the enzyme. These changes arise from residue Trp31 as well as residues Trp21 and Trp119. The calcium dependence of the fluorescence change of Trp31 indicates that the affinity of the enzyme for calcium increases at least 3 orders of magnitude upon activation. These studies suggest either that a change in conformation of the enzyme occurs upon activation or that the increase in calcium affinity reflects formation of a ternary complex of calcium, enzyme, and substrate.     

Acidic/IQ motif regulator of calmodulin

The small IQ motif proteins PEP-19 (62 amino acids) and RC3 (78 amino acids) greatly accelerate the rates of Ca(2+) binding to sites III and IV in the C-domain of calmodulin (CaM). We show here that PEP-19 decreases the degree of cooperativity of Ca(2+) binding to sites III and IV, and we present a model showing that this could increase Ca(2+) binding rate constants. Comparative sequence analysis showed that residues 28 to 58 from PEP-19 are conserved in other proteins. This region includes the IQ motif (amino acids 39-62), and an adjacent acidic cluster of amino acids (amino acids 28-40). A synthetic peptide spanning residues 28-62 faithfully mimics intact PEP-19 with respect to increasing the rates of Ca(2+) association and dissociation, as well as binding preferentially to the C-domain of CaM. In contrast, a peptide encoding only the core IQ motif does not modulate Ca(2+) binding, and binds to multiple sites on CaM. A peptide that includes only the acidic region does not bind to CaM. These results show that PEP-19 has a novel acidic/IQ CaM regulatory motif in which the IQ sequence provides a targeting function that allows binding of PEP-19 to CaM, whereas the acidic residues modify the nature of this interaction, and are essential for modulating Ca(2+) binding to the C-domain of CaM.     

In vitro Proteolytic Degradation of Bovine Brain Calcineurin by m-Calpain

A major cause of neuronal dysfunction is due to altered Ca2+ regulation. An increase in Ca2+ influx can activate Ca2+-dependent enzymes including calpains, causing the proteolysis of its specific substrates. In the present study, calcineurin (CaN) was found to be proteolysed by a Ca2+-dependent cysteine protease, m-calpain. In the presence of Ca2+, the 60 kDa subunit (CaN A) was degraded to a 46 kDa immunoreactive fragment, whereas in the presence of Ca2+ /calmodulin (CaM) immunoreactive fragments of 48 and 54 kDa were observed. The beta-subunit (CaN B) was not proteolysed in either condition. The proteolysis of CaN A increased its phosphatase activity and rendered it totally CaM-independent after 10 min of proteolysis. The molecular weight of the proteolytic fragments suggested that the m-calpain cleaved CaN A in the CaN B binding domain. A CaM-overlay experiment revealed that the CaM-binding site was present only in the 54 kDa fragment produced by CaN A proteolysis in the presence of Ca2+ /CaM. Thus, the increase in CaN A phosphatase activity observed in many neuronal disorders, may be due to the action of calpain.     

Conserved residues of liquefying alpha-amylases are concentrated in the vicinity of active site

Three dimensional structure of three liquefying type Bacillus alpha-amylases were modeled based on sequence analyses and refined structure of Aspergillus oryzae enzyme. The models suggest that the overall folding motif of alpha-amylases is conserved. The active site, substrate binding and stabilizing calcium binding residues are conserved and concentrated in a cleft between two domains. They constitute the core of alpha-amylases to which other, less conserved regions are attached. The bacterial enzymes have a loop of about 45 residues near the active site and Ca2+ binding region. The loop may be important for the liquefying function of these enzymes.     

Effect of substrate on Ca2(+)-concentration required for activity of the Ca2(+)-dependent proteinases, mu- and m-calpain

The Ca2+ concentrations required for half-maximal activity of mu- and m-calpain purified from bovine skeletal muscle were tested using four different protein substrates and three different synthetic peptide substrates. Hammersten casein, the commonly used substrate for measuring mu- and m-calpain activity, required 2.5 microM Ca2+ for half-maximal activity of mu-calpain and 290 microM Ca2+ for half-maximal activity of m-calpain. When Hammersten casein was dialyzed against 8 M urea and 10 mM EDTA to remove all endogenous Ca2+, it required 1.9 and 290 microM Ca2+ for half-maximal activity of mu- and m-calpain, respectively. Rabbit skeletal muscle myofibrils and rabbit skeletal muscle troponin required 65 microM and 24 microM Ca2+ for half-maximal activity of mu-calpain and 380 microM and 580 microM Ca2+ for half-maximal activity of m-calpain, respectively. The three synthetic substrates tested, Suc-Leu-Tyr-MCA, Boc-Leu-Thr-Arg-MCA, and Suc-Leu-Leu-Val-Tyr-MCA, required 1.6 microM to 3.7 microM Ca2+ for half-maximal activity of mu-calpain and 200 to 560 microM Ca2+ for half-maximal activity of m-calpain.     

Structural requirements for N-trimethylation of lysine 115 of calmodulin

Calmodulin is trimethylated at lysine 115 by a highly specific methyltransferase that utilizes S-adenosylmethionine as a co-substrate. Lysine 115 is found within a highly conserved six-amino acid loop (LGEKLT) that forms a 90 degrees turn between EF-hand III and EF-hand IV in the carboxyl-terminal lobe. In the present work a mutagenesis approach was used to investigate the structural features of the carboxyl-terminal lobe that lead to the specificity of calmodulin methylation. Three structural regions within the carboxyl-terminal lobe appear to be involved in methyltransferase recognition: the highly conserved six-amino acid loop-turn region that contains lysine 115 as well as the adjacent alpha-helices (helix 6 and helix 7) from EF-hands III and IV. Site-directed mutagenesis of residues in the loop show that three residues, glycine 113, glutamate 114, and leucine 116 are essential for methylation. In addition, subdomain (individual helix or Ca(2+) binding loop) exchange mutants show that the substitutions of either helix 6 (EF-hand III) with helix 2 (EF-hand I) or helix 7 (EF-hand IV) with helix 3 (EF-hand II) compromises methylation. Charge-to-alanine mutations in helix 7 show that substitution of conserved charged residues at positions 118, 120, 122, 126, and 127 reduced lysine 115 methylation rates, suggesting possible electrostatic interactions between this helix and the methyltransferase. Single substitutions in helix 6 did not affect calmodulin methylation, suggesting this region may play a more indirect role in stabilizing the conformation of the methyltransferase recognition sequence.     

Dissociation of m-calpain subunits occurs after autolysis of the N-terminus of the catalytic subunit, and is not required for activation.

Calpain is a heterodimeric, intracellular Ca(2+)-dependent, "bio-modulator" that alters the properties of substrates through site-specific proteolysis. It has been proposed that calpains are activated by autolysis of the N-terminus of the large subunit and/or its dissociation into the subunits. It is, however, unclear whether the dissociation into subunits is required for the expression of protease activity and/or for in vivo function. Recently, the crystal structure of m-calpain in the absence of Ca(2+) has been resolved. The 3D structure clearly shows that the N-terminus of the m-calpain large subunit (mCL) makes contact with the 30K subunit, suggesting that autolysis of the N-terminus of mCL changes the interaction of both subunits. To examine the relationship between autolysis, dissociation, and activation, we made and analysed a series of N-terminal mutants of mCL that mimic the autolysed forms or have substituted amino acid residue(s) interacting with 30K. As a result, the mutant m-calpains, which are incapable of autolysis, did not dissociate into subunits, whereas those lacking the N-terminal 19 residues (Delta 19), but not those lacking only nine residues (Delta 9), dissociated into subunits even in the absence of Ca(2+). Moreover, both Delta 9 and Delta 19 mutants showed an equivalent reduced Ca(2+) requirement for protease activity. These results indicate that autolysis is necessary for the dissociation of the m-calpain subunits, and that the dissociation occurs after, but is not necessary for, activation.     

Comparison of terbium (III) luminescence enhancement in mutants of EF hand calcium binding proteins.

The luminescent isomorphous Ca2+ analogue, Tb3+, can be bound in the 12-amino acid metal binding sites of proteins of the EF hand family, and its luminescence can be enhanced by energy transfer from a nearby aromatic amino acid. Tb3+ can be used as a sensitive luminescent probe of the structure and function of these proteins. The effect of changing the molecular environment around Tb3+ on its luminescence was studied using native Cod III parvalbumin and site-directed mutants of both oncomodulin and calmodulin. Titrations of these proteins showed stoichiometries of fill corresponding to the number of Ca2+ binding loops present. Tryptophan in binding loop position 7 best enhanced Tb3+ luminescence in the oncomodulin mutant Y57W, as well as VU-9 (F99W) and VU-32 (T26W) calmodulin. Excitation spectra of Y57F, F102W, Y65W oncomodulin, and Cod III parvalbumin revealed that the principal Tb3+ luminescence donor residues were phenylalanine or tyrosine located in position 7 of a loop, despite the presence of other nearby donors, including tryptophan. Spectra also revealed conformational differences between the Ca2+- and Tb(3+)-bound forms. An alternate binding loop, based on Tb3+ binding to model peptides, was inserted into the CD loop of oncomodulin by cassette mutagenesis. The order of fill of Tb3+ in this protein reversed, with the mutated loop binding Tb3+ first. This indicates a much higher affinity for the consensus-based mutant loop. The mutant loop inserted into oncomodulin had 32 times more Tb3+ luminescence than the identical synthetic peptide, despite having the same donor tryptophan and metal binding ligands. In this paper, a ranking of sensitivity of luminescence of bound Tb3+ is made among this subset of calcium binding proteins. This ranking is interpreted in light of the structural differences affecting Tb3+ luminescence enhancement intensity. The mechanism of energy transfer from an aromatic amino acid to Tb3+ is consistent with a short-range process involving the donor triplet state as described by Dexter (Dexter, D. L. (1953) J. Chem. Phys. 21, 836). This cautions against the use of the F?rster equation in approximating distances in these systems.