Aluminum speciation studies in biological fluids. Part 6. Quantitative investigation of aluminum(III)-tartrate complex equilibria and their potential implications for aluminum metabolism and toxicity

Recent epidemiological studies have confirmed the existence of a correlation between aluminum level in low-silica drinking water and prevalence of Alzheimer's disease. Also, oral aluminum-based phosphate binders and antacids may induce acute aluminum toxicity. Whatever the source of the metal ingested, its bioavailability is a function of the chemical forms under which it occurs in the gastrointestinal tract, i.e. of the ligands with which the Al3+ ion may associate. Dietary acids in particular can favor the bioavailability of aluminum in different ways: by increasing its solubility, by complexing it into neutral species, and/or by acting indirectly on its absorption process. Among these, tartaric acid is commonly found in fruits and in industrial foods and drinks, and may therefore be ingested together with environmental or/and therapeutic aluminum. The present work examines its potential influence on aluminum bioavailability. Firstly, Al(III)-tartrate complex formation constants have been determined under physiological conditions (37 degrees C, 0.15 M NaCl). Then these constants have been used to simulate the influence of tartrate on aluminum speciation in different gastrointestinal situations in which phosphate was also taken into account. Under normal conditions of aluminum contamination, tartrate is expected to keep the metal soluble throughout the whole pH range of the small intestine, which is likely to enhance its bioavailability. Even at low concentrations, tartrate also gives rise to two neutral complexes that span over the 1.5-7.5 pH interval, a phenomenon that is aggravated by increased aluminum levels as may result from aluminum hydroxide therapy. The co-occurrence of dietary phosphate reduces the fraction of aluminum neutralized by tartrate under normal conditions, but this effect quickly decreases with increasing aluminum doses. Even the therapeutic use of aluminum phosphate is not expected to be totally safe in the presence of tartaric acid. As plasma simulations show that no aluminum mobilization can be expected from tartrate that could enhance aluminum excretion, avoiding ingestion of tartaric acid during any form of aluminum-based therapy appears advisable.     

Aluminum speciation studies in biological fluids. Part 9. A quantitative investigation of aluminum(III)-glutamate complex equilibria and their potential implications for aluminum metabolism and toxicity

As a nonessential element, aluminum is likely to be toxic both at low usual dietary levels in the long run (chronic toxicity) and at high therapeutic levels in shorter periods of time (acute toxicity). In both situations, aluminum toxicity is a direct function of aluminum bioavailability, which is itself dependent on Al(3+) solubility and charge neutralization. Dietary acids, by their intrinsic acidity and coordinating capacity, can extend the pH range, thus the section of the gastrointestinal tract, within which the Al(3+) ion remains soluble, and also help Al(3+) diffusion across the intestinal epithelium through the formation of neutral complex species. The present work examines the impact of glutamic acid, an essential amino acid also widely used in industrial food and drinks, on aluminum speciation in the gastrointestinal tract and blood plasma. Complex formation between the Al(3+) ion and glutamate has first been investigated through potentiometric titrations, complex stoichiometries being then checked by ESI mass spectrometry and NMR measurements. A series of mono- and polynuclear species has been characterized, whose influence on aluminum distribution in vivo has been assessed by computer simulation. The capacity of glutamate to maintain Al(3+) ions in solution under normal dietary conditions is predicted to be intermediate between glycine-like amino acids and succinate on the one hand, and tartrate and malate on the other hand, its Al(3+) neutralization effect being similar to that of succinate, tartrate and malate. These results, which point to a potential aggravating role of glutamate on aluminum gastrointestinal absorption, substantiate recent observations made on rats. In spite of the moderate effect expected from glutamate on aluminum bioavailability under most aluminum-based therapies investigated, attention is therefore called to the risk of glutamic acid ingestion simultaneously to any aluminum therapeutic form. Incidentally, the former implication of 'the' aluminum glutamate complex in the transfer of aluminum through the blood-brain barrier of aluminum loaded rats may effectively be attributed to one of the species characterized here, but is of no significance at all to aluminum contamination in humans, even at most extreme levels.     

Bioavailability and intestinal absorption of aluminum in rats

In the present investigation, the deposition of aluminum in intestinal fragment and the appearance in blood were studied in a perfused rat intestine in situ for 1 h with several aluminum forms (16 mM). We observed that aluminum absorption was positively correlated with the theoretic affinity of aluminum and the functional groups of the chelating agent. The absorption of aluminum after ingestion of organic compounds is more important than after ingestion of mineral compounds, with the following order: Al citrate > Al tartrate, Al gluconate, Al lactate > Al glutamate, Al chloride, Al sulfate, Al nitrate. Absorption depends on the nature of the ligands associated with the Al3+ ion in the gastrointestinal fluid. The higher the aluminum retention in intestinal fragment, the lower the absorption and appearance in blood. However, the higher aluminum concentration is always in the jejunal fragment because of the influence of pH variation on this fragment. Another objective of the present study was to determine the influence of several parameters on aluminum citrate absorption: with or without 0.1 mmol dinitrophenol/L, with aluminum concentration from 3.2, 16, 32, and 48, to 64 mmol/L, media containing 0, 3, or 6 mmol Ca/L, with or without phosphorus or glucose. It is concluded that aluminum is absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract by (1) a paracellular energy independent and nonsaturable route, mainly used for high aluminum concentration, which is modified by extracellular calcium, and (2) a transcellular and saturable route, the aluminum level was not modified with enhancement of aluminum quantity in intestinal lumen. This pathway can be similar with calcium transfer through the intestine and is energy dependent because of a decrease of aluminum absorption that follows the removal of glucose and phosphorus.     

Aluminum speciation studies in biological fluids. Part 2. Quantitative investigation of aluminum-citrate complexes and appraisal of their potential significance in vivo

Because of the recent implications of aluminum in the pathogenesis of various disease states, its in vivo chemistry has been receiving growing attention from bioinorganic chemists over the last few years. In this context, the elucidation of the main factors that govern aluminum bioavailability constitutes an urgent objective. Clearly, prevention measures require that mechanisms of aluminum absorption be definitely characterized, whereas specific sequestering agents are needed to detoxify patients with high-aluminum-body burdens. In particular, speciation studies are necessary to discriminate among the chemical forms under which aluminum predominates in vivo. Low molecular weight (LMW) species, which are the most active in terms of bioavailability, cannot be assessed by analytical techniques, and so computer simulations must be used. In recent clinical studies as well as in preliminary simulations dealing with aluminum distribution in blood plasma, citrate has been recognized as the most important LMW ligand of aluminum. The present paper thus reports a quantitative investigation of aluminum-citrate equilibria, carried out at 37 degrees C in NaCl 0.15 mol dm-3 in accordance with the experimental protocol defined in our previous study on aluminum hydrolysis. The ML, MLH, ML2, M3L3H-4, M2L2H-2, ML2H-1, and ML2H-2 species have been characterized over the whole physiological pH range using as large reactant concentration ratios as possible. Corresponding formation constants have then been used to investigate the role of citrate towards aluminum bioavailability. Blood plasma simulations reveal that citrate can promote aluminum urinary excretion, which substantiates recent clinical observations made on mice. However, the higher plasma aluminum concentrations are, the less effective citrate is to be expected. Gastrointestinal simulations confirm that the electrically neutral ML complex does represent an important risk of aluminum absorption in the upper region of the gastrointestinal tract at usual therapeutic doses. At moderate- and low-aluminum concentrations, citrate is also capable of dissolving the aluminum trihydroxide precipitate, which may combine with the capacity of other ligands to complex Al3+ into absorbable complexes at less acidic pH.     

Secretion of an aluminum chelator, 2-isopropylmalic acid, by the budding yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae

An aluminum(III)-binding substance (ABS), that solubilizes Al(III) at neutral pH, was found to be secreted by Saccharomyces cerevisiae. A combination of anion exchange chromatography and preparative high performance liquid chromatography using an octadecylsilane (ODS) column separated ABS from the medium. The structure determination of ABS was performed using 1H and 13C NMR spectroscopy and heteronuclear multiple-bond correlation (HMBC) spectroscopy, and ABS was identified to be 2-isopropylmalic acid (2-iPMA). The structure was further confirmed using high resolution electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. Solubilization of otherwise sparingly soluble Al(III) by 2-iPMA at neutral pH indicated the binding of the compound with Al(III). This is supported by 27Al NMR spectrometry for a solution containing 10 mM Al(III) and 20 mM 2-iPMA at pH 6.6, where four Al(III) species were evident. Although the function of this compound is unclear, it might play a key role in Al detoxification.     

A QM/MM study of the complexes formed by aluminum and iron with serum transferrin at neutral and acidic pH

Serum transferrin (sTf) transports iron in serum and internalizes in cells via receptor mediated endocytosis. Additionally, sTf has been identified as the predominant aluminum carrier in serum. Some questions remain unclear about the exact mechanism for the metal release or whether the aluminum and iron show the same binding mode during the entire process. In the present work, simulation techniques at quantum and atomic levels have been employed in order to gain access into a molecular level understanding of the metal-bound sTf complex, and to describe the binding of Al(III) and Fe(III) ions to sTf. First, hybrid quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were carried out in order to analyze the dynamics of the aluminum-loaded complex, taking into account the different pH conditions in blood and into the cell. Moreover, the complexes formed by transferrin with Al(III) and Fe(III) were optimized with high level density functional theory (DFT)/MM methods. All these results indicate that the interaction mode of Al(III) and Fe(III) with sTf change upon different pH conditions, and that the coordination of Al(III) and Fe(III) is not equivalent during the metal intake, transport and release processes. Our results emphasize the importance of the pH on the metal binding and release mechanism and suggest that Al(III) can follow the iron pathway to get access into cells, although once there, it may show a different binding mode, leading to a different mechanism for its release.     

Phosphorus deficiency enhances aluminum tolerance of rice (Oryza sativa) by changing the physicochemical characteristics of root plasma membranes and cell walls

The negative charge at the root surface is mainly derived from the phosphate group of phospholipids in plasma membranes (PMs) and the carboxyl group of pectins in cell walls, which are usually neutralized by calcium (Ca) ions contributing to maintain the root integrity. The major toxic effect of aluminum (Al) in plants is the inhibition of root elongation due to Al binding tightly to these negative sites in exchange for Ca. Because phospholipid and pectin concentrations decrease in roots of some plant species under phosphorus (P)-limiting conditions, we hypothesized that rice (Oryza sativa L.) seedlings grown under P-limiting conditions would demonstrate enhanced Al tolerance because of their fewer sites on their roots. For pretreatment, rice seedlings were grown in a culture solution with (+P) or without (−P) P. Thereafter, the seedlings were transferred to a solution with or without Al, and the lipid, pectin, hemicellulose, and mineral concentrations as well as Al tolerance were then determined. Furthermore, the low-Ca tolerance of P-pretreated seedlings was investigated under different pH conditions. The concentrations of phospholipids and pectins in the roots of rice receiving −P pretreatment were lower than those receiving +P pretreatment. As expected, seedlings receiving the −P pretreatment showed enhanced Al tolerance, accompanied by the decrease in Al accumulation in their roots and shoots. This low P-induced enhanced Al tolerance was not explained by enhanced antioxidant activities or organic acid secretion from roots but by the decrease in phospholipid and pectin concentrations in the roots. In addition, low-Ca tolerance of the roots was enhanced by the −P pretreatment under low pH conditions. This low P-induced enhancement of low-Ca tolerance may be related to the lower Ca requirement to maintain PM and cell wall structures in roots of rice with fewer phospholipids and pectins.     

Complexation of aluminum with DNA

The extent of complexation of aluminum(III) with DNA (Calf thymus, Sigma type I) was estimated by means of two experimental techniques: potentiometric titration with a fluoride selective indicator electrode and dialysis followed by aluminum determination by graphite furnace AAS. Both types of experiments indicate that aluminum(III) is bound to DNA. The data are treated by assuming an ion exchange reaction with the phosphate diester groups. Using Rt to denote the concentration of these groups the values of log [AlMn-3R]/(Rt-3[AlMn-3R])[Al3+] decrease from approx. 7.6 to 5.6 when the concentration of sodium chloride is increased from 1 to 100 mM. In the pH range 4.5-5.5 the ion exchange constant increases approximately 0.5 log units. Dialysis gives lower values for the complex formation constant than potentiometry.     

Novel properties of the wheat aluminum tolerance organic acid transporter (TaALMT1) revealed by electrophysiological characterization in Xenopus Oocytes: functional and structural implications

Many plant species avoid the phytotoxic effects of aluminum (Al) by exuding dicarboxylic and tricarboxylic acids that chelate and immobilize Al(3+) at the root surface, thus preventing it from entering root cells. Several novel genes that encode membrane transporters from the ALMT and MATE families recently were cloned and implicated in mediating the organic acid transport underlying this Al tolerance response. Given our limited understanding of the functional properties of ALMTs, in this study a detailed characterization of the transport properties of TaALMT1 (formerly named ALMT1) from wheat (Triticum aestivum) expressed in Xenopus laevis oocytes was conducted. The electrophysiological findings are as follows. Although the activity of TaALMT1 is highly dependent on the presence of extracellular Al(3+) (K(m1/2) of approximately 5 microm Al(3+) activity), TaALMT1 is functionally active and can mediate ion transport in the absence of extracellular Al(3+). The lack of change in the reversal potential (E(rev)) upon exposure to Al(3+) suggests that the "enhancement" of TaALMT1 malate transport by Al is not due to alteration in the transporter's selectivity properties but is solely due to increases in its anion permeability. The consistent shift in the direction of the E(rev) as the intracellular malate activity increases indicates that TaALMT1 is selective for the transport of malate over other anions. The estimated permeability ratio between malate and chloride varied between 1 and 30. However, the complex behavior of the E(rev) as the extracellular Cl(-) activity was varied indicates that this estimate can only be used as a general guide to understanding the relative affinity of TaALMT1 for malate, representing only an approximation of those expected under physiologically relevant ionic conditions. TaALMT1 can also mediate a large anion influx (i.e. outward currents). TaALMT1 is permeable not only to malate but also to other physiologically relevant anions such as Cl(-), NO(3)(-), and SO(4)(2-) (to a lesser degree).     

Impaired renal function and aluminum metabolism

The consequences of renal functional impairment on aluminum (Al) excretion are not clear inasmuch as little is known about its glomerular filtration, tubular reabsorption, or secretion. The association of Al and the etiology of the dialysis encephalopathy syndrome and osteomalacia among patients with uremia suggests that renal functional impairment is a prerequisite for increased body Al stores. However, considerable evidence argues against the concept that tissue Al accumulation occurs as a simple consequence of renal failure. Many dialysis patients have high parathyroid hormone (PTH) concentrations that have been associated with neurologic abnormalities, bone disease, and anemia. The toxicity of PTH could be either direct or indirect by influencing the metabolism of potentially toxic substances such as Al. Our studies in normal rats suggest that gastrointestinal Al absorption and specific tissue burdens are enhanced by PTH, but not irreversibly, because the withdrawal of PTH resulted in Al egress. Dialysis patients are often treated with vitamin D analogs to prevent or control consequences of hyperparathyroidism and impaired 1,25-dihydroxycholecalciferol synthesis. Although some reports suggest that high bone Al in osteomalacia may be responsible for vitamin D resistance, our studies with normal rats suggest that its metabolites may also increase tissue Al burdens independent of PTH action. Thus, several factors operative in uremia other than impaired renal function may contribute to altered Al metabolism and, consequently, to its toxicity.     

Aluminum speciation studies in biological fluids. Part 3. Quantitative investigation of aluminum-phosphate complexes and assessment of their potential significance in vivo

Following the discovery that specific health disorders affecting patients with renal disease were due to their excessive body accumulation of aluminum, it was established that aluminum toxicity was mainly due to the ingestion of aluminum-containing phosphate binders. Suspicion of toxicity was thus cast on aluminum-containing antacids, and subsequent tests held on healthy subjects did reveal that aluminum hydroxide gels were also potential oral sources of aluminum, especially in the presence of citric acid. Nevertheless, authors of these tests concluded that there was only marginal absorption of aluminum phosphate. In contrast with these clinical conclusions, it has recently been contended on theoretical grounds that aluminum phosphate represents a serious health hazard. To help elucidate this issue, this paper first deals with a quantitative investigation of aluminum-phosphate equilibria under physiological conditions. Then appropriate computer simulations based on corresponding results are used to assess the actual extent to which phosphate can influence aluminum bioavailability. These simulations confirm that aluminum phosphate is not expected to induce absorption of high amounts of aluminum when administered by itself. Nevertheless, this result may no longer apply in the presence of food, whose various acidic components are likely to modify the involved chemical equilibria. Moreover, it is shown that rising blood plasma phosphate levels should tend to increase aluminum tissue penetration and hence favor its potential toxicity.     

A promoter-swap strategy between the AtALMT and AtMATE genes increased Arabidopsis aluminum resistance and improved carbon-use efficiency for aluminum resistance

The primary mechanism of Arabidopsis aluminum (Al) resistance is based on root Al exclusion, resulting from Al-activated root exudation of the Al(3+) -chelating organic acids, malate and citrate. Root malate exudation is the major contributor to Arabidopsis Al resistance, and is conferred by expression of AtALMT1, which encodes the root malate transporter. Root citrate exudation plays a smaller but still significant role in Arabidopsis Al resistance, and is conferred by expression of AtMATE, which encodes the root citrate transporter. In this study, we demonstrate that levels of Al-activated root organic acid exudation are closely correlated with expression of the organic acid transporter genes AtALMT1 and AtMATE. We also found that the AtALMT1 promoter confers a significantly higher level of gene expression than the AtMATE promoter. Analysis of AtALMT1 and AtMATE tissue- and cell-specific expression based on stable expression of promoter-reporter gene constructs showed that the two genes are expressed in complementary root regions: AtALMT1 is expressed in the root apices, while AtMATE is expressed in the mature portions of the roots. As citrate is a much more effective chelator of Al(3+) than malate, we used a promoter-swap strategy to test whether root tip-localized expression of the AtMATE coding region driven by the stronger AtALMT1 promoter (AtALMT1(P)::AtMATE) resulted in increased Arabidopsis Al resistance. Our results indicate that expression of AtALMT1(P)::AtMATE not only significantly increased Al resistance of the transgenic plants, but also enhanced carbon-use efficiency for Al resistance.     

Urine levels of aluminum after drinking tea

A microwave-assisted acid digestion procedure coupled with a graphite furnace atomic absorption method has been applied in the determination of aluminum (Al) in urine to verify the correlation of free forms of Al in tea infusions and urinary excretion of Al. Significant urinary Al excretion has been found in 24-h urine of four volunteers after tea drinking. However, the difference in amount of Al excretion in urine between the consumption of Oolong (black tea) and Long-Jin (green tea), each of them with unique Al contents and species, was not significant. These findings indicated that the high levels of free Al species in tea infusions did not result in significant change in urinary excretion of the metal, possibly owing to the transformation by ligands present in food and the gastrointestinal tract (GIT). However, it could not be assumed that there was no big difference in absorption of the metal in the human body if fractions of consumed Al retained in the body or excreted by bile or feces were considered.     

Nonequivalence of the metal binding sites of conalbumin. Calorimetric and spectrophotometric studies of aluminum binding.

Differential scanning calorimetric experiments show that addition of Al(III) to conalbumin increases its denaturation temperature by 5 degrees, from 60 to 68 degrees. Only one Al(III) bound per conalbumin molecule produces this change in heat stability; additional bound Al(III) does not affect the heat stability. Since Al(III) displaces both Cu(II) bound at the metal binding sites of conalbumin, binding of aluminum takes place at the same metal binding sites. The binding constant for the second Al(III) is at least 100-fold less than that for the binding of the first Al(III), and both are displaced by added iron. The order of increasing heat stability of the metal ion complexes of conalbumin, Cu(II), Al(III), Fe(III), is the order of increasing binding constant for these metal ions.     

Solid phase extraction-spectrophotometric determination of dissolved aluminum in soil extracts and ground waters

An on-line solid-phase extraction (SPE) technique, linked to spectrophotometry, has been developed to overcome the problem of high matrix concentration, which is thought to interfere with the determination of low levels of aluminum (Al) in environmental samples. Tiron modified resin was prepared and used as a SPE absorbent, which can quantitatively adsorb Al(III) at pH 4-6 with an adsorption capacity of 5.6 mg g(-1) resin. The main advantages of this novel method are: (1) a much higher sensitivity has been obtained by SPE technology; and (2) a large amount of Na(+), K(+), Ca(2+) and Mg(2+) can be removed and the interference of Fe(III), Mn(II) and F(-) can be efficiently eliminated by eluting with 0.25 mol l(-1) NaOH. It is a highly selective and sensitive method for simple and quick determination of dissolved Al in soil extracts and ground waters, particularly suitable for the analysis of complex environmental samples.     

Lipid bilayer permeation by neutral aluminum citrate and by three alpha-hydroxy carboxylic acids

Several groups have proposed that aluminum (Al) may permeate biological membranes as a neutral complex with citrate. We tested this hypothesis by measuring aluminum citrate flux across unilamellar phospholipid vesicles (liposomes). Results from two independent procedures show that lipid bilayer permeation by the neutral aluminum-citrate complex is slow (P approximately equal to 1 x 10(-11) cm.s-1). We then compared aluminum-citrate permeation with permeation by a series of alpha-hydroxy carboxylic acids and by trimethylcitrate. This comparison showed that the aluminum-citrate flux is limited by diffusion across the water/lipid interface. This is due to hydrogen bonding between water and the citrate carboxyl groups, and by hydration of the bound metal in the aqueous phase. By analogy with citric acid, steric hindrance of diffusion within the bilayer does not affect the permeation rate of aluminum citrate. Elevated tissue levels of Al in subjects fed a diet supplemented with citric acid and Al(OH)3 cannot be explained by lipid bilayer permeation of the neutral complex.     

Multiple Aluminum-Resistance Mechanisms in Wheat (Roles of Root Apical Phosphate and Malate Exudation)

Although it is well known that aluminum (Al) resistance in wheat (Triticum aestivum) is multigenic, physiological evidence for multiple mechanisms of Al resistance has not yet been documented. The role of root apical phosphate and malate exudation in Al resistance was investigated in two wheat cultivars (Al-resistant Atlas and Al-sensitive Scout) and two near-isogenic lines (Al-resistant ET3 and Al-sensitive ES3). In Atlas Al resistance is multigenic, whereas in ET3 resistance is conditioned by the single Alt1 locus. Based on root- growth experiments, Atlas was found to be 3-fold more resistant in 20 [mu]M Al than ET3. Root-exudation experiments were conducted under sterile conditions; a large malate efflux localized to the root apex was observed only in Atlas and in ET3 and only in the presence of Al (5 and 20 [mu]M). Furthermore, the more Al-resistant Atlas exhibited a constitutive phosphate release localized to the root apex. As predicted from the formation constants for the Al-malate and Al-phosphate complexes, the addition of either ligand to the root bathing solution alleviated Al inhibition of root growth in Al-sensitive Scout. These results provide physiological evidence that Al resistance in Atlas is conditioned by at least two genes. In addition to the alt locus that controls Al-induced malate release from the root apex, other genetic loci appear to control constitutive phosphate release from the apex. We suggest that both exudation processes act in concert to enhance Al exclusion and Al resistance in Atlas.     

Kinetic and equilibrium studies of incorporation of di-sulfonated aluminum phthalocyanine into unilamellar vesicles.

The interactions of cis-di-sulfonated aluminum phthalocyanine (PcS(2)Al) with dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) unilamellar vesicles have been investigated by fluorescence spectroscopy. At pH 7.0, PcS(2)Al incorporates into the vesicles with a high affinity constant (2.7x10(6) M(-1), in terms of phospholipid concentration). The fluorescence changes following rapid mixing of PcS(2)Al with vesicles are biphasic. The first phase is attributed to the entry of PcS(2)Al into the vesicles, as deduced from the linear dependence of the rate upon lipid concentration. More surprisingly, this rate is strongly pH dependent with a marked maximum around pH 7.3, a result interpreted in terms of the coordination state of the aluminum ion in aqueous solutions. At this pH, a hydroxide ion neutralizes the residual positive charge of the metal ion that remains unbalanced after coordination by the phthalocyanine cycle. A water molecule is likely to complete the metal coordination sphere. Only this form, PcAl(+)(OH(-))(OH(2)), with an uncharged core is quickly incorporated into the vesicles. The protonation of OH(-) or the deprotonation of the coordinated H(2)O leading to a positively or negatively charged core, respectively, account for the observed pH effect. Studies on the effect of cholesterol addition and exchange of PcS(2)Al between vesicles and albumin all indicate the absence of transfer of the phthalocyanine between the vesicle hemileaflets, a result expected from the presence of the two negatively charged sulfonated groups at the ring periphery. Instead, the slower kinetic phase is likely due to the movement of the phthalocyanine becoming more buried within the outer leaflet upon the loss of the water molecule coordinated to the aluminum ion.