INFRAFRONTIER: a European resource for studying the functional basis of human disease

Ageing research and more generally the study of the functional basis of human diseases profit enormously from the large-scale approaches and resources in mouse functional genomics: systematic targeted mutation of the mouse genome, systemic phenotyping in mouse clinics, and the archiving and distribution of the mouse resources in public repositories. INFRAFRONTIER, the European research infrastructure for the development, systemic phenotyping, archiving and distribution of mammalian models, offers access to sustainable mouse resources for biomedical research. INFRAFRONTIER promotes the global sharing of high-quality resources and data and thus contributes to data reproducibility and animal welfare. INFRAFRONTIER puts great effort into international standardisation and quality control and into technology development to improve and expand experimental protocols, reduce the use of animals in research and increase the reproducibility of results. In concert with the research community and the International Mouse Phenotyping Consortium (IMPC), INFRAFRONTIER is currently developing new pilot platforms and services for the research on ageing and age-related diseases.     

Intercalibration of ecotoxicity testing protocols with Artemia franciscana

The brine shrimp, Artemia spp., is widely used in ecotoxicology as a target biological model. Although several protocols were available in the early 1980s, only the 24-h acute mortality toxicity test was evaluated in a European intercalibration exercise during that period. Nevertheless, documentation of standard methods serving to provide specifications, guidelines or detailed characteristics of the 24-h protocol is still unavailable. This paper present the results of an intercalibration study of three toxicity-testing protocols using Artemia franciscana: (a) the 24-h static acute mortality test, (b) the 48-h static hatching test and (c) the 14-d static-renewal long-term mortality test. A first tier of experiments was conducted by a reference laboratory, which investigated the repeatability of the three methods. The feasibility and reproducibility of these protocols were then investigated by an intercomparison exercise involving 11 participants for the acute mortality test, seven for the acute hatching test and nine for the long-term mortality test. Protocols were tested on reference toxicants (copper sulphate pentahydrate and sodium dodecyl sulphate). The coefficients of variation were <20% and <50% for intra- and interlaboratory activities, respectively. These results encourage the standardization of the proposed methods and their use as regulatory procedures.     

Optimizing Staining Protocols for Laser Microdissection of Specific Cell Types from the Testis Including Carcinoma In Situ

Microarray and RT-PCR based methods are important tools for analysis of gene expression; however, in tissues containing many different cells types, such as the testis, characterization of gene expression in specific cell types can be severely hampered by noise from other cells. The laser microdissection technology allows for enrichment of specific cell types. However, when the cells are not morphologically distinguishable, it is necessary to use a specific staining method for the target cells. In this study we have tested different fixatives, storage conditions for frozen sections and staining protocols, and present two staining protocols for frozen sections, one for fast and specific staining of fetal germ cells, testicular carcinoma in situ cells, and other cells with embryonic stem cell-like properties that express the alkaline phosphatase, and one for specific staining of lipid droplet-containing cells, which is useful for isolation of the androgen-producing Leydig cells. Both protocols retain a morphology that is compatible with laser microdissection and yield RNA of a quality suitable for PCR and microarray analysis.     

Submicroscopic malaria parasite carriage: how reproducible are polymerase chain reaction-based methods?

The polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based methods for the diagnosis of malaria infection are expected to accurately identify submicroscopic parasite carriers. Although a significant number of PCR protocols have been described, few studies have addressed the performance of PCR amplification in cases of field samples with submicroscopic malaria infection. Here, the reproducibility of two well-established PCR protocols (nested-PCR and real-time PCR for the Plasmodium 18 small subunit rRNA gene) were evaluated in a panel of 34 blood field samples from individuals that are potential reservoirs of malaria infection, but were negative for malaria by optical microscopy. Regardless of the PCR protocol, a large variation between the PCR replicates was observed, leading to alternating positive and negative results in 38% (13 out of 34) of the samples. These findings were quite different from those obtained from the microscopy-positive patients or the unexposed individuals; the diagnosis of these individuals could be confirmed based on the high reproducibility and specificity of the PCR-based protocols. The limitation of PCR amplification was restricted to the field samples with very low levels of parasitaemia because titrations of the DNA templates were able to detect < 3 parasites/µL in the blood. In conclusion, conventional PCR protocols require careful interpretation in cases of submicroscopic malaria infection, as inconsistent and false-negative results can occur.     

Precision of nanoindentation protocols for measurement of viscoelasticity in cortical and trabecular bone

Nanoindentation has recently gained attention as a characterization technique for mechanical properties of biological tissues, such as bone, on the sub-micron level. However, optimal methods to characterize viscoelastic properties of bones are yet to be established. This study aimed to compare the time-dependent viscoelastic properties of bone tissue obtained with different nanoindentation methods. Bovine cortical and trabecular bone samples (n=8) from the distal femur and proximal tibia were dehydrated, embedded and polished. The material properties determined using nanoindentation were hardness and reduced modulus, as well as time-dependent parameters based on creep, loading-rate, dissipated energy and semi-dynamic testing under load control. Each loading protocol was repeated 160 times and the reproducibility was assessed based on the coefficient of variation (CV). Additionally, three well-characterized polymers were tested and CV values were calculated for reference.The employed methods were able to characterize time-dependent viscoelastic properties of bone. However, their reproducibility varied highly (CV 9–40%). The creep constant increased with increasing dwell time. The reproducibility was best with a 30 s creep period (CV 18%). The dissipated energy was stable after three repeated load cycles, and the reproducibility improved with each cycle (CV 23%). The viscoelastic properties determined with semi-dynamic test increased with increase in frequency. These measurements were most reproducible at high frequencies (CV 9–10%). Our results indicate that several methods are feasible for the determination of viscoelastic properties of bone material. The high frequency semi-dynamic test showed the highest precision within the tested nanoindentation protocols.     

Towards robust and repeatable sampling methods in eDNA‐based studies

DNA‐based techniques are increasingly used for measuring the biodiversity (species presence, identity, abundance and community composition) of terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems. While there are numerous reviews of molecular methods and bioinformatic steps, there has been little consideration of the methods used to collect samples upon which these later steps are based. This represents a critical knowledge gap, as methodologically sound field sampling is the foundation for subsequent analyses. We reviewed field sampling methods used for metabarcoding studies of both terrestrial and freshwater ecosystem biodiversity over a nearly three‐year period (n = 75). We found that 95% (n = 71) of these studies used subjective sampling methods and inappropriate field methods and/or failed to provide critical methodological information. It would be possible for researchers to replicate only 5% of the metabarcoding studies in our sample, a poorer level of reproducibility than for ecological studies in general. Our findings suggest greater attention to field sampling methods, and reporting is necessary in eDNA‐based studies of biodiversity to ensure robust outcomes and future reproducibility. Methods must be fully and accurately reported, and protocols developed that minimize subjectivity. Standardization of sampling protocols would be one way to help to improve reproducibility and have additional benefits in allowing compilation and comparison of data from across studies.     

On the re-calibration process in radiochromic film dosimetry

PurposeThe accuracy and precision of the dose estimates obtained with radiochromic film dosimetry are investigated in a clinical environment. The improvement in the accuracy of dose estimates reached with corrective methods is analyzed. Two novel re-calibration algorithms for radiochromic film dosimetry are presented.MethodsTwo different EBT3 lots are evaluated in two different centres. They are calibrated in Varian linacs and read in two different EPSON scaners. Once the lots are calibrated, three films per lot are considered and divided into stripes that are exposed to known doses. Several dosimetry protocols usually employed in radiochromic film dosimetry are used to convert film responses to absorbed doses. These protocols are characterized by different choices of the film responses or different sensitometric curves. Finally, the accuracy and reproducibility of the dose estimates is investigated with and without the corrective methods.Results and ConclusionsThe variabilities that affect radiochromic film dosimetry, such as intra-lot variability, inter-scan variability, post-exposure time and film autodevelopment may give rise to inaccuracies in the dose estimates. However, the implementation of re-calibration methods leads to more accurate dose estimates. All the investigated protocols showed more accurate and reproducible results when the re-calibrated methods were employed. So, the novel re-calibration methods may be applied in order to improve the accuracy and reproducibility of radiochromic film dosimetry.     

Proboscidean DNA from Museum and Fossil Specimens: An Assessment of Ancient DNA Extraction and Amplification Techniques

Applications of reliable DNA extraction and amplification techniques to postmortem samples are critical to ancient DNA research. Commonly used methods for isolating DNA from ancient material were tested and compared using both soft tissue and bones from fossil and contemporary museum proboscideans. DNAs isolated using three principal methods served as templates in subsequent PCR amplifications, and the PCR products were directly sequenced. Authentication of the ancient origin of obtained nucleotide sequences was established by demonstrating reproducibility under a blind testing system and by phylogenetic analysis. Our results indicate that ancient samples may respond differently to extraction buffers or purification procedures, and no single method was universally successful. A CTAB buffer method, modified from plant DNA extraction protocols, was found to have the highest success rate. Nested PCR was shown to be a reliable approach to amplify ancient DNA templates that failed in primary amplification.     

Detection of the hip center in computer-assisted surgery: An in vitro assessment study

The HKA i.e. the angle between the hip, knee and ankle centers is a clinical parameter widely used in orthopedic surgery. It can be intraoperatively assessed with computer-assisted surgery navigation systems by computing the 3D location of these joint centers. The hip center is computed using functional methods but is defined by the experts as the anatomical center of the femoral head. The aim of this in vitro study is therefore to assess, first, the accuracy of these functional methods for the determination of the HKA and, second, their reproducibility. We have analyzed on six cadaveric lower limbs the accuracy and the reproducibility of functional methods and their impact on the HKA values. The anatomical hip center has been used as the reference value. The reproducibility is 5.2 mm for the determination of the functional hip centers. The average impact on the HKA is 1.2° (4° max). Despite a lack of reproducibility of the functional methods, the impact on the HKA is limited. The accuracy of the functional methods on the HKA can therefore be enough for some clinical applications.     

Prokaryotic RNA preparation methods useful for high density array analysis: comparison of two approaches

High density oligonucleotide arrays have been used extensively for expression studies of eukaryotic organisms. We have designed a prokaryotic high density oligonucleotide array using the complete Escherichia coli genome sequence to monitor expression levels of all genes and intergenic regions in the genome. Because previously described methods for preparing labeled target nucleic acids are not useful for prokaryotic cell analysis using such arrays, a mRNA enrichment and direct labeling protocol was developed together with a cDNA synthesis protocol. The reproducibility of each labeling method was determined using high density oligonucleotide probe arrays as a read-out methodology and the expression results from direct labeling were compared to the expression results from the cDNA synthesis. About 50% of all annotated E.coli open reading frames are observed to be transcribed, as measured by both protocols, when the cells were grown in rich LB medium. Each labeling method individually showed a high degree of concordance in replica experiments (95 and 99%, respectively), but when each sample preparation method was compared to the other, ~32% of the genes observed to be expressed were discordant. However, both labeling methods can detect the same relative gene expression changes when RNA from IPTG-induced cells was labeled and compared to RNA from uninduced E.coli cells.     

Optimal molecular profiling of tissue and tissue components

Isolation of well-preserved pure cell populations is a prerequisite for sound studies of the molecular basis of any tissue-based biological phenomenon. This article reviews current methods for obtaining anatomically specific signals from molecules isolated from tissues, a basic requirement for productive linking of phenotype and genotype. The quality of samples isolated from tissue and used for molecular analysis is often glossed over or omitted from publications, making interpretation and replication of data difficult or impossible. Fortunately, recently developed techniques allow life scientists to better document and control the quality of samples used for a given assay, creating a foundation for improvement in this area. Tissue processing for molecular studies usually involves some or all of the following steps: tissue collection, gross dissection/identification, fixation, processing/embedding, storage/archiving, sectioning, staining, microdissection/annotation, and pure analyte labeling/identification and quantification. We provide a detailed comparison of some current tissue microdissection technologies, and provide detailed example protocols for tissue component handling upstream and downstream from microdissection. We also discuss some of the physical and chemical issues related to optimal tissue processing, and include methods specific to cytology specimens. We encourage each laboratory to use these as a starting point for optimization of their overall process of moving from collected tissue to high quality, appropriately anatomically tagged scientific results. In optimized protocols is a source of inefficiency in current life science research. Improvement in this area will significantly increase life science quality and productivity. The article is divided into introduction, materials, protocols, and notes sections. Because many protocols are covered in each of these sections, information relating to a single protocol is not contiguous. To get the greatest benefit from this article, readers are advised to read through the entire article first, identify protocols appropriate to their laboratory for each step in their workflow, and then reread entries in each section pertaining to each of these single protocols.     

Automated whole mount localisation techniques for plant seedlings

Plant biology is currently experiencing a growing demand for easy and reliable mRNA and protein localisation techniques. Here, we present novel whole mount in situ hybridisation and immunolocalisation protocols, suitable to localise mRNAs and proteins in Arabidopsis seedlings. We demonstrate that these methods can be used in different organs of Arabidopsis seedlings as well as in other plant species. In order to achieve better reproducibility and higher throughput, we modified these protocols for automation to be performed by a liquid handling robot. In addition, we show that other procedures such as reporter enzyme assays and tissue clearing can be similarly automated. We present examples of application of our protocols including mRNA localisation and proteins and epitope tag (co)localisations which demonstrate that these methods provide reliable and versatile tools for expression, localisation and anatomical studies in plants.     

Double trouble—Buffer selection and His-tag presence may be responsible for nonreproducibility of biomedical experiments

The availability of purified and active protein is the starting point for the majority of in vitro biomedical, biochemical, and drug discovery experiments. The use of polyhistidine affinity tags has resulted in great increases of the efficiency of the protein purification process, but can negatively affect structure and/or activity measurements. Similarly, buffer molecules may perturb the conformational stability of a protein or its activity. During the determination of the structure of a Gcn5-related N-acetyltransferase (GNAT) from Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PA4794), we found that both HEPES and the polyhistidine affinity tag bind (separately) in the substrate-binding site. In the case of HEPES, the molecule induces conformational changes in the active site, but does not significantly affect enzyme activity. In contrast, the uncleaved His-tag does not induce major conformational changes but acts as a weak competitive inhibitor of peptide substrate. In two other GNAT enzymes, we observed that the presence of the His-tag had a strong influence on the activity of these proteins. The influence of protein preparation on functional studies may affect the reproducibility of experiments in other laboratories, even when changes between protocols seem at first glance to be insignificant. Moreover, the results presented here show how critical it is to adjust the experimental conditions for each protein or family of proteins, and investigate the influence of these factors on protein activity and structure, as they may significantly alter the effectiveness of functional characterization and screening methods. Thus, we show that a polyhistidine tag and the buffer molecule HEPES bind in the substrate-binding site and influence the conformation of the active site and the activity of GNAT acetyltransferases. We believe that such discrepancies can influence the reproducibility of some experiments and therefore could have a significant “ripple effect” on subsequent studies.     

Multivariate assessment of activated sludge stability in lab-scale experiments

In wastewater research, the transfer of activated sludge from large-scale plants to lab-scale reactors induces a transient period. It is crucial to quantitatively assess the stability of activated sludge before starting any experimental procedure. Otherwise, the transient interferes with the experimental results, jeopardizing reproducibility and accuracy. This paper presents a novel multivariate technique to assess activated sludge stability based on the combination of principal component analysis (PCA) with the squared prediction error (SPE) statistic. The proposed method allows for a more accurate estimation of activated sludge stability than existing univariate methods and also eliminates the need to establish thresholds for every single variable. The procedure is validated on experimental data obtained by Van den Broeck et al. [1].     

Systemic lupus erythematosus and C1q: A quantitative ELISA for determining C1q levels in serum

C1q is of interest in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) research due to deficiencies in its activity being associated with the disease. Current published protocols for measuring C1q vary greatly in their results and ease of reproducibility. Due to this, average C1q concentrations have been reported between 56 and 276 μg/mL in non-SLE serum. We present an improved method for quantifying C1q concentrations, which employs a sandwich ELISA. This method has improved precision, cost efficiency, up-scaling, reproducibility, and uses significantly lesser volumes of serum sample when compared to RID and other methods for quantifying C1q. We report an average concentration of 113 ± 40 μg/mL for C1q in non-SLE serum. The assay designed here will be useful in the high-throughput measurement of serum C1q in SLE cases.     

肠道微生物测序研究中不同实验来源差异的综合评价以及应用

肠道微生物测序研究具有将微生物结果转化为人类健康的巨大潜力。16S扩增子测序和宏基因组鸟枪测序(whole-metagenome shotgun, WMS)是微生物组研究中的两大主要方法,各具优势。然而,研究样品的异质性、测序仪和文库制备方法的差异如何影响肠道微生物测序结果的可重复性仍有待深入研究。该研究旨在通过比较粪便样本中微生物组成的差异,为测序技术的选择提供参考标准。3种广泛采用的测序仪的结果显示,WMS法中技术重复相关性(r=0.94)较高,而生物学重复相关性(r=0.69)较低。Bray-Curtis距离表明,生物学重复的差异大于技术重复(P<0.001)。此外,16S和WMS数据集间具有明显的分类学图谱差异。研究结果表明,同质化是样品DNA提取前的一个必要步骤;测序仪对分类学变异的贡献小于文库制备方法。我们开发了经验贝叶斯方法,即在计算中“借用信息”,利用标准化数据和(非)参数先验分布分析批次效应参数,提高了16S和WMS之间的群体可比性,为进一步应用于融合分析已发表的16S和微生物数据集提供了依据。