Determination of the aggregation number of detergent micelles using steady-state fluorescence quenching.

The development of a simple, reliable method for determination of detergent micelle aggregation number that relies solely on measurement of steady-state fluorescence quenching is presented. The degree of steady-state fluorescence quenching of a micelle-solubilized fluorophore (pyrene) by a quencher that partitions greatly into the micelles (coumarin 153) is dependent on the micelle concentration, which can therefore be determined. The aggregation number is calculated as the micelle concentration/detergent monomer concentration (the total detergent concentration above the critical micelle concentration). For the determination to be accurate, the partition coefficient of the quencher into the micelle phase is determined and used to calculate the micellar concentration of quencher. Also, the quenching of pyrene by a coumarin 153 molecule within the same micelle must be complete, and this was confirmed by time-resolved fluorescence measurements. Aggregation numbers were determined for one cationic and several nonionic detergents and were found to be consistent with literature values. The approach presented is an improvement on a previous luminescence quenching technique (Turro, N.J., and A. Yekta. 1978. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 100:5951-5952) and can be used on cationic, anionic, and nonionic detergents with micelles ranging greatly in size and under varying conditions, such as detergent concentration, ionic strength, or temperature.     

Molecular organization of pheophytin a in aqueous solutions of detergents

Absorption, fluorescence and excitation fluorescence spectra of pheophytin a have been measured in aqueous solutions of nonionic (Triton X-100), anionic (sodium lauryl sulphate) and cationic (Cetyl pyridinium chloride) detergents at different concentrations and pH after system relaxation. By measuring the second derivative and differential spectra, it has been shown, that if detergent concentrations are lower than critical micelles concentration, or if the detergent is completely absent, the pigment forms conglomerates containing both dimeric and monomeric forms with an efficient energy transfer between them. If detergent concentrations are higher than critical micelles concentration, pheophytin a localizes in detergent micelle in monomeric form at neutral and acidic pH, and allomerizes at alkaline pH. The spectral characteristics of pheophytin a dimers in the conglomerate and its monomers in micelles poorly (if at all) depend on the sign of the detergent molecule charge.     

Characterization of the solubilization of lipid bilayers by surfactants

This communication addresses the state of aggregation of lipid-detergent mixed dispersions. Analysis of recently published data suggest that for any given detergent-lipid mixture the most important factor in determining the type of aggregates (mixed vesicles or mixed micelles) and the size of the aggregate is the detergent to lipid molar ratio in these aggregates, herein denoted the effective ratio, Re. For mixed bilayers this effective ratio has been previously shown to be a function of the lipid and detergent concentrations and of an equilibrium partition coefficient, K, which describes the distribution of the detergent between the bilayers and the aqueous phase. We show that, similar to mixed bilayers, the size of mixed micelles is also a function of the effective ratio, but for these dispersions the distribution of detergent between the mixed micelles and the aqueous medium obeys a much higher partition coefficient. In practical terms, the detergent concentration in the mixed micelles is equal to the difference between the total detergent concentration and the critical micelle concentration (cmc). Thus, the effective ratio is equal to this difference divided by the lipid concentration. Transformation of mixed bilayers to mixed micelles, commonly denoted solubilization, occurs when the surfactant to lipid effective ratio reaches a critical value. Experimental evaluation of this critical ratio can be based on the linear dependence of detergent concentration, required for solubilization, on the lipid concentration. According to the 'equilibrium partition model', the dependence of the 'solubilizing detergent concentration' on the lipid concentration intersects with the lipid axis at -1/K, while the slope of this dependence is the critical effective ratio. On the other hand, assuming that when solubilization occurs the detergent concentration in the aqueous phase is approximately equal to the critical micelle concentration, implies that the above dependence intersects with the detergent axis at the critical micelle concentration, while its slope, again, is equal to the critical effective ratio. Analysis of existing data suggests that within experimental error both these distinctively different approaches are valid, indicating that the critical effective ratio at which solubilization occurs is approximately equal to the product of the critical micelle concentration and the distribution coefficient K. Since the nature of detergent affects K and the critical micelle concentration in opposite directions, the critical ('solubilizing') effective ratio depends upon the nature of detergent less than any of these two factors.     

Refractive index-based determination of detergent concentration and its application to the study of membrane proteins

The concentration of detergent in membrane protein preparations can have a critical role on protein stability, function, and the potential for crystallization. Unfortunately, dialysis or protein concentration can lead to an unknown amount of detergent in the final membrane protein preparations. Here we present a method for the determination of detergent concentration based on refractive index of the detergent solution. This method was applied to quantitate the amount of detergent remaining in solution after concentration in various concentrators. We found that the ability of the tested detergents to pass through the molecular weight cutoff membrane correlates well with detergent micelle size. Therefore, the micelle size can be used as a rough guide to estimate the retention of a given detergent in various molecular weight cutoff concentrators. The refractive index method is exceptionally informative when coupled with size exclusion chromatography and light scattering, and can be used to determine the oligomeric state of the membrane protein, the size of a protein-associated micelle, as well as the amount and size of the unbound detergent micelle.     

Characterization of the solubilization of lipid bilayers by surfactants

This communication addresses the state of aggregation of lipid-detergent mixed dispersions. Analysis of recently published data suggest that for any given detergent-lipid mixture the most important factor in determining the type of aggregates (mixed vesicles or mixed micelles) and the size of the aggregate is the detergent to lipid molar ratio in these aggregates, herein denoted the effective ratio, R_e. For mixed bilayers this effective ratio has been previously shown to be a function of the lipid and detergent concentrations and of an equilibrium partition coefficient, K, which describes the distribution of the detergent between the bilayers and the aqueous phase. We show that, similar to mixed bilayers, the size of mixed micelles is also a function of the effective ratio, but for these dispersions the distribution of detergent between the mixed micelles and the aqueous medium obeys a much higher partition coefficient. In practical terms, the detergent concentration in the mixed micelles is equal to the difference between the total detergent concentration and the critical micelle concentration (cmc). Thus, the effective ratio is equal to this difference divided by the lipid concentration. Transformation of mixed bilayers to mixed micelles, commonly denoted solubilization, occurs when the surfactant to lipid effective ratio reaches a critical value. Experimental evaluation of this critical ratio can be based on the linear dependence of detergent concentration, required for solubilization, on the lipid concentration. According to the ‘equilibrium partition model’, the dependence of the ‘solubilizing detergent concentration’ on the lipid concentration intersects with the lipid axis at −1/K, while the slope of this dependence is the critical effective ratio. On the other hand, assuming that when solubilization occurs the detergent concentration in the aqueous phase is approximately equal to the critical micelle concentration, implies that the above dependence intersects with the detergent axis at the critical micelle concentration, while its slope, again, is equal to the critical effective ratio. Analysis of existing data suggests that within experimental error both these distinctively different approaches are valid, indicating that the critical effective ratio at which solubilization occurs is approximately equal to the product of the critical micelle concentration and the distribution coefficient K. Since the nature of detergent affects K and the critical micelle concentration in opposite directions, the critical (‘solubilizing’) effective ratio depends upon the nature of detergent less than any of these two factors.     

Detergent effects on enzyme activity and solubilization of lipid bilayer membranes

Over 50 detergents were tested to establish which would be most effective in releasing proteins from membrane-bounded compartments without denaturating them. Various concentrations of each detergent were tested for two activities: (1) solubilization of egg phospholipid liposomes as measured by reduction of turbidity and (2) effect of detergent concentration on the activities of soluble, hydrolytic enzymes. Those detergents must effective in solubilizing 0.2% lipid and least detrimental to enzymes were five pure, synthetic compounds recently introduced: CHAPS, CHAPSO, Zwittergents 310 and 312, and octylglucoside. Industrial detergents were generally much inferior, insofar as they solubilized membranes inefficiently and/or inactivated certain hydrolytic enzymes readily. The five detergents were characterized by (a) an unusually high critical micelle concentration and (b) a preference for forming mixed micelles with lipids instead of forming pure micelles, as indicated by an ability to solubilize lipid at concentrations of detergent significantly below the critical micelle concentration. This characteristic permits solubilization of high concentrations of membrane below the critical micelle concentration of the detergent so that protein denaturation is minimized. A generally applicable guideline that emerged from this study is that detergents should be used at approximately their critical micelle concentration which should not be exceeded by the concentration of membrane. Similar considerations should apply to the use of detergents in purifying and reconstituting intrinsic membrane proteins.     

Mapping the antagonist binding site of the serotonin type 3 receptor by fluorescence resonance energy transfer

We have measured fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between a fluorescent antagonist, bound to the purified detergent-solubilized serotonin type 3 receptor, and a lipophilic acceptor probe partitioned into the micelle surrounding the detergent-solubilized receptor. The experimentally observed FRET efficiency was evaluated on the basis of the characteristic dimensions of the receptor-micelle complex and the average number of acceptor molecules in such micelles. The binding site was determined to be 5.4 +/- 0.9 nm above the center of the detergent micelle. The experiments were performed below the critical micellar concentration of the detergent (C(12)E(9)) used to solubilize the receptor, under which conditions it was demonstrated that the ligand binding activity was fully preserved. This reduces considerably the fluorescence background arising from probes not associated with the receptor, allowing a precise determination of the transfer efficiency.     

Characterization of Phospholipid Mixed Micelles by Translational Diffusion

The concentration dependence of the translational self diffusion rate, D (s), has been measured for a range of micelle and mixed micelle systems. Use of bipolar gradient pulse pairs in the longitudinal eddy current delay experiment minimizes NOE attenuation and is found critical for optimizing sensitivity of the translational diffusion measurement of macromolecules and aggregates. For low volume fractions Phi (Phi\\ le 15% v/v) of the micelles, experimental measurement of the concentration dependence, combined with use of the D (s)= D (o)(1-3.2lambdaPhi) relationship, yields the hydrodynamic volume. For proteins, the hydrodynamic volume, derived from D (s) at infinitely dilute concentration, is found to be about 2.6 times the unhydrated molecular volume. Using the data collected for hen egg white lysozyme as a reference, diffusion data for dihexanoyl phosphatidylcholine (DHPC) micelles indicate approximately 27 molecules per micelle, and a critical micelle concentration of 14 mM. Differences in translational diffusion rates for detergent and long chain phospholipids in mixed micelles are attributed to rapid exchange between free and micelle-bound detergent. This difference permits determination of the free detergent concentration, which, for a high detergent to long chain phospholipid molar ratio, is found to depend strongly on this ratio. The hydrodynamic volume of DHPC/POPC bicelles, loaded with an M2 channel peptide homolog, derived from translational diffusion, predicts a rotational correlation time that slightly exceeds the value obtained from peptide (15)N relaxation data.     

Use of the hydrophobic probe Nile red for the fluorescent staining of protein bands in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels.

In a previous work (J.-R. Daban, M. Samsó, and S. Bartolomé, Anal. Biochem. 199, 162-168, 1991) we observed that, in the presence of the detergent sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), diverse types of proteins produced a high increase in the fluorescence intensity of the hydrophobic probe 9-diethylamino-5H-benzo[alpha]-phenoxazine-5-one (Nile red). This enhancement of Nile red fluorescence was observed at SDS concentrations lower than the critical micelle concentration (CMC) of this detergent in the buffer (0.025 M Tris and 0.192 M glycine, pH 8.3) currently used in SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. This observation led us to introduce a modification in the typical (U. K. Laemmli, Nature 227, 680-685, 1970) SDS-polyacrylamide gels, in which the SDS concentration in the gel after electrophoresis is lower than the CMC of this detergent but high enough to maintain the stability of the protein-SDS complexes in the bands. The staining of these modified gels with Nile red produces very high fluorescence in the protein-SDS bands and low background fluorescence. The Nile red staining method described in this paper is very rapid (i.e., the bands can be visualized and photographed within 6 min after the electrophoretic separation) and has a high sensitivity, similar to that obtained with the covalent fluorophores rhodamine B isothiocyanate and carboxytetramethyl-rhodamine succinimidyl ester also investigated in this work. Furthermore, our quantitative estimates indicate that most of the protein bands stained with Nile red show similar values of the fluorescence intensity per unit mass.     

Continuous recording of long-chain acyl-coenzyme a synthetase activity using fluorescently labeled bovine serum albumin

The fluorescence-based long-chain fatty acid probe BSA-HCA (bovine serum albumin labeled with 7-hydroxycoumarin-4-acetic acid) is shown to respond to binding of long-chain acyl-CoA thioesters by quenching of the 450 nm fluorescence emission. As determined by spectrofluorometric titration, binding affinities for palmitoyl-, stearoyl-, and oleoyl-CoA (Kd = 0.2-0.4 microM) are 5-10 times lower than those for the corresponding nonesterified fatty acids. In the presence of detergent (Chaps, Triton X-100, n-octylglucoside) above the critical micelle concentration, acyl-CoA partitions from BSA-HCA and into the detergent micelles. This allows BSA-HCA to be used as a fluorescent probe for continuous recording of fatty acid concentrations in detergent solution with little interference from acyl-CoA. Using a calibration of the fluorescence signal with fatty acids in the C14 to C20 chain-length range, fatty acid consumption by Pseudomonas fragi and rat liver microsomal acyl-CoA synthetase activities are measured down to 0.05 microM/min with a data sampling rate of 10 points per second. This new method provides a very promising spectrofluorometric approach to the study of acyl-CoA synthetase reaction kinetics at physiologically relevant (nM) aqueous phase concentrations of fatty acid substrates and at a time resolution that cannot be obtained in isotopic sampling or enzyme-coupled assays.     

The effect of detergent Triton X=100 on the light induced changes in the fluorescence yield of chloroplasts]

It is shown that light induced changes of the fluorescence yield (delta F) of isolated chloroplasts are affected by Triton X-100. delta F value descreases with the increase of the detergent concentration from 0 to 0.03%, increases in the range of 0.03--0.05% and is irreversibly blocked at concentrations more than 0.08--0.1%. The same dependence of delta F on the detergent concentration is obtained for "digitonin" fragments of chloroplasts enriched in the photosystem 2, but not for fragments enriched in the photosystem 1. Light induced delta F of chloroplasts treated by detergent were activated by hydroxylamine and saturated at lower light intensities than delta F of untreated chloroplasts. Addition of 0.01% Triton resulted in an activation of light induced delta F of chloroplasts with damaged donor part of photosystem 2. It is suggested that the complex dependence of delta F of chloroplasts on the Triton concentration is due to superposition of several effects: the uncoupling of photophosphorylation, inactivation of the electron transport chain in the donor and acceptor parts of photosystem 2, and changes of acting concentration of Triton X-100 within the range of critical micelle concentration.     

Use of nile red as a fluorescent probe for the study of the hydrophobic properties of protein-sodium dodecyl sulfate complexes in solution.

Our results show that the noncovalent dye 9-diethylamino-5H-benzo[alpha]phenoxazine-5-one (Nile red) can be used as a fluorescent probe to study the hydrophobic properties of proteins associated with the anionic detergent sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS). Nile red can interact with both SDS micelles and protein-SDS complexes. The enhancement of Nile red fluorescence observed with diverse types of proteins occurs at SDS concentrations lower than the critical micelle concentration of this detergent. This is also observed using the covalent fluorophore rhodamine B isothiocyanate. Additional results obtained in studies in solution show that the fluorescence intensity and the spectral characteristics of Nile red associated with different proteins complexed with SDS are very similar. These spectroscopic similarities are probably related to the equivalent synchrotron X-ray scattering results found for various protein-SDS complexes in solution. The scattering results suggest that SDS induces the formation of complexes in which the basic structural properties are independent of the different initial structures of native proteins. We speculate that Nile red is bound to regions with equivalent hydrophobic characteristics located in the uniform structures produced by the association of SDS with proteins.     

Critical micelle concentration and hemolytic activity--a correlation suggested by the marine sterol, halistanol trisulfate.

The marine natural product, halistanol trisulfate, has a relatively low critical micelle concentration of 0.001% m/v (14.5 microM) and strong hemolytic potency with an EC50 of 0.00046% m/v (6.67 microM). As expected of a detergent, it inhibits the growth of gram-positive but not gram-negative bacteria. The hemolytic activity of halistanol trisulfate and other detergents has been shown to correlate with critical micelle concentration. This correlation may have important implications in the mechanism of membranolytic bioactivity.     

Micelle formation in the presence of photosystem I

The correlation between membrane protein solubilisation and detergent aggregation in aqueous solution is studied for a series of n-alkyl-β-d-maltosides (C_xG₂ with x = 10, 11, 12 being the number of carbon atoms in the alkyl chain) using the trimeric photosystem I core complex (PSIcc) of oxygenic photosynthesis from Thermosynechococcus elongatus as model protein. While protein solubilisation is monitored via the turbidity of the solution, the aggregation behavior of the detergent is probed via the fluorescence spectrum of the polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon pyrene. In addition, changes of the fluorescence spectrum of PSIcc in response to formation of the detergent belt surrounding its hydrophobic surface are investigated. Solubilisation of PSIcc and aggregation of detergent into micelles or belts are found to be strictly correlated. Both processes are complete at the critical solubilisation concentration (CSC) of the detergent, at which the belts are formed. The CSC depends on the concentration of the membrane protein, [prot], and is related to the critical micelle concentration (CMC) by the empirical law ln(CSC/CMC) = n¯₀ [prot], where the constant n¯₀ = (2.0 ± 0.3) μM⁻¹ is independent of the alkyl chain length x. Formation of protein-free micelles below the CSC is not observed even for x = 10, where a significant excess of detergent is present at the CSC. This finding indicates an influence of PSIcc on micelle formation that is independent of the binding of detergent to the hydrophobic protein surface. The role of the CSC in the optimisation of membrane protein crystallisation is discussed.     

Interaction of nonionic detergents with phospholipids in hepatic microsomes at subsolubilizing concentrations as studied by 31P-NMR

The effect of low concentrations of nonionic detergents with different critical micelle concentrations such as Triton X-100, Brij 35 and octylglucoside on rabbit liver microsomes is studied by means of ³¹P-NMR, ¹H-NMR, dynamic light scattering and functional investigations. Hexane phosphonic acid diethyl ester was used as a phosphorus membrane probe molecule to monitor the interaction of detergent molecules with microsomal phospholipids by ³¹P-NMR. This method is more sensitive than ³¹P-NMR of phospholipids alone and permitted the estimation of the maximum number of detergent molecules which can be incorporated in microsomes without the formation of mixed micelles outside the membrane. These membrane saturation concentrations were determined to be 0.07 (Brij 35), 0.1 (Triton X-100) and 0.4 (octylglucoside) (molar ratio of detergent/total phospholipids). Above these detergent concentrations, mixed micelles consisting of detergent and membrane constituents are formed, coexisting with the microsomes up to the membrane solubilization concentration. The results indicate a dependence of the membrane saturation concentration on the critical micelle concentration of the detergent and a preferential removal of phosphatidylcholine over phosphatidylethanolamine from the microsomes by all detergents studied.     

Chlorophyll fluorescence quenching in isolated light harvesting complexes induced by zeaxanthin

Non-photochemical quenching of chlorophyll fluorescence in plants occurs in the light harvesting antenna of photosystem II and is regulated by the xanthophyll cycle. A new in vitro model for this process has been developed. Purified light harvesting complexes above the detergent critical micelle concentration have a stable high fluorescence yield but a rapidly inducible fluorescence quenching occurs upon addition of zeaxanthin. Violaxanthin was without effect, lutein and antheraxanthin induced a marginal response, whereas the violaxanthin analogue, auroxanthin, induced strong quenching. Quenching was not caused by aggregation of the complexes but was accompanied by a spectral broadening and red shift, indicating a zeaxanthin-dependent alteration in the chlorophyll environment.     

Quantitative determination by derivative spectrophotometry of Triton X-100 in solubilized preparations of membrane proteins

The amount of the nonionic detergent Triton X-100 in protein preparations cannot be determined spectrophotometrically from the normal spectrum because the spectral bands of the detergent and proteins overlap, but it was found that the detergent could be determined accurately by 4th-derivative spectrophotometry. The intensity of the derivative absorbance difference between the positive and negative peaks at about 277.5 and 281 nm, respectively, increased linearly with increase in the detergent concentration at more than its critical micelle concentration (about 0.03%). Proteins had little effect on these spectral bands of the detergent. This method is very simple and accurate for determination of the concentration of Triton X-100 in solubilized preparations of membrane proteins.     

5-Dodecanoylaminofluorescein as a probe for the determination of critical micelle concentration of detergents using fluorescence anisotropy

A method for determining the critical micelle concentration (CMC) of various detergents based on fluorescence polarization (anisotropy) of the lipophilic probe 5-dodecanoylaminofluorescein is presented. Nonionic, cationic, anionic, and steroid-based detergents can all be evaluated by this method and the determined CMC values of selected detergents agree well with those reported in the literature. In addition, we report the CMC of domiphen bromide, whose CMC value has not previously been described. In the case of ionic detergents, the method described is particularly sensitive at discerning changes in the CMC with increasing ionic strength of the medium and can discriminate detergent CMCs in 5 mM versus 25 mM buffering components. The described fluorescence polarization technique allows very low (submicromolar) concentrations of probe to be employed, thus minimizing the perturbation of micelle formation by 5-dodecanoylaminofluorescein insertion.     

Variations in the activity of microsomal palmitoyl-CoA hydrolase in mixed micelle solutions of palmitoyl-CoA and non-ionic detergents of the triton X series

The kinetics of palmitoyl-CoA hydrolase were influenced by both the availability of the substrate and formation of micelles. At palmitoyl-CoA concentrations below the critical micelle concentration, addition of non-ionic detergent increased the activity until the critical micelle concentration of the mixed micelles was reached. At palmitoyl-CoA concentrations above the critical micelle concentration, inhibitor of the activity was observed, but addition of detergents of the Triton X series reversed the inhibition. Maximum palmitoyl-CoA hydrolase activity was found when the ratios (w/v) of palmitoyl-CoA: Triton X-100 and palmitoyl-CoA: Triton X-405 were approximately 0.35 and 0.05, respectively. At these above the mixed critical micelle concentration. The results indicate that monomer palmitoyl-CoA is the substrate and that monomer forms of the non-ionic detergents of the Triton X series activate the enzyme. Isolated microsomal lipids activated the microsomal palmitoyl-CoA hydrolase, suggesting that a hydrophobic environment is advantageous for interaction between enzyme and substrate in vivo. The maximum activity in the presence of mixed micelles is discussed in relation to a model where mixed micelles are regarded as artificial membranes to which the enzyme may adhere in an equilibrium with the monomer substrate and detergent in the monomer form. It is suggested that intracellular membranes may resemble mixed micelles in equilibrium with detergent-active substrates such as palmitoyl-CoA.     

Stability of Rhodopsin in Detergent Solutions

The thermal stability of lipid-free rhodopsin in solutions of a homologous series of alkyltrimethylammonium bromide detergents and one nonionic detergent, dodecyl-β-maltoside, has been studied as a function of detergent concentration. Rhodopsin thermal stability increases with increasing chain length within the homologous series of ionic detergents, and for chain lengths greater than 10 carbon atoms increases with increasing detergent concentration up to a “critical” concentration that depends on the chain length. Stability also increases with increasing detergent concentration for rhodopsin in solutions of the nonionic detergent. These results may be rationalized in terms of the dependence of micelle packing density on the detergent chain length, head group, and concentration.