Insights into virus evolution and membrane biogenesis from the structure of the marine lipid-containing bacteriophage PM2

Recent, primarily structural observations indicate that related viruses, harboring no sequence similarity, infect hosts of different domains of life. One such clade of viruses, defined by common capsid architecture and coat protein fold, is the so-called PRD1-adenovirus lineage. Here we report the structure of the marine lipid-containing bacteriophage PM2 determined by crystallographic analyses of the entire approximately 45 MDa virion and of the outer coat proteins P1 and P2, revealing PM2 to be a primeval member of the PRD1-adenovirus lineage with an icosahedral shell and canonical double beta barrel major coat protein. The view of the lipid bilayer, richly decorated with membrane proteins, constitutes a rare visualization of an in vivo membrane. The viral membrane proteins P3 and P6 are organized into a lattice, suggesting a possible assembly pathway to produce the mature virus.     

In vitro DNA packaging of PRD1: a common mechanism for internal-membrane viruses

PRD1 is the type virus of the Tectiviridae family. Its linear double-stranded DNA genome has covalently attached terminal proteins and is surrounded by a membrane, which is further enclosed within an icosahedral protein capsid. Similar to tailed bacteriophages, PRD1 packages its DNA into a preformed procapsid. The PRD1 putative packaging ATPase P9 is a structural protein located at a unique vertex of the capsid. An in vitro system for packaging DNA into preformed empty procapsids was developed. The system uses cell extracts of overexpressed P9 protein and empty procapsids from a P9-deficient mutant virus infection and PRD1 DNA containing a LacZalpha-insert. The in vitro packaged virions produce distinctly blue plaques when plated on a suitable host. This is the first time that a viral genome is packaged in vitro into a membrane vesicle. Comparison of PRD1 P9 with putative packaging ATPase sequences from bacterial, archaeal and eukaryotic viruses revealed a new packaging ATPase-specific motif. Surprisingly the viruses having this packaging ATPase motif, and thus considered to be related, were the same as those recently grouped together using the coat protein fold and virion architecture. Our finding here strongly supports the idea that all these viruses infecting hosts in all domains of life had a common ancestor.     

Combined EM/X-ray imaging yields a quasi-atomic model of the adenovirus-related bacteriophage PRD1 and shows key capsid and membrane interactions

BACKGROUND: The dsDNA bacteriophage PRD1 has a membrane inside its icosahedral capsid. While its large size (66 MDa) hinders the study of the complete virion at atomic resolution, a 1.65-A crystallographic structure of its major coat protein, P3, is available. Cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) and three-dimensional reconstruction have shown the capsid at 20-28 A resolution. Striking architectural similarities between PRD1 and the mammalian adenovirus indicate a common ancestor. RESULTS: The P3 atomic structure has been fitted into improved cryo-EM reconstructions for three types of PRD1 particles: the wild-type virion, a packaging mutant without DNA, and a P3-shell lacking the membrane and the vertices. Establishing the absolute EM scale was crucial for an accurate match. The resulting "quasi-atomic" models of the capsid define the residues involved in the major P3 interactions, within the quasi-equivalent interfaces and with the membrane, and show how these are altered upon DNA packaging. CONCLUSIONS: The new cryo-EM reconstructions reveal the structure of the PRD1 vertex and the concentric packing of DNA. The capsid is essentially unchanged upon DNA packaging, with alterations limited to those P3 residues involved in membrane contacts. These are restricted to a few of the N termini along the icosahedral edges in the empty particle; DNA packaging leads to a 4-fold increase in the number of contacts, including almost all copies of the N terminus and the loop between the two beta barrels. Analysis of the P3 residues in each quasi-equivalent interface suggests two sites for minor proteins in the capsid edges, analogous to those in adenovirus.     

Bacteriophage PM2 has a protein capsid surrounding a spherical proteinaceous lipid core

The marine double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) bacteriophage PM2, studied since 1968, is the type organism of the family Corticoviridae, infecting two gram-negative Pseudoalteromonas species. The virion contains a membrane underneath an icosahedral protein capsid composed of two structural proteins. The purified major capsid protein, P2, appears as a trimer, and the receptor binding protein, P1, appears as a monomer. The C-terminal part of P1 is distal and is responsible for receptor binding activity. The rest of the structural proteins are associated with the internal phospholipid membrane enclosing the viral genome. This internal particle is designated the lipid core. The overall structural organization of phage PM2 resembles that of dsDNA bacteriophage PRD1, the type organism of the family TECTIVIRIDAE:     

A Structural Model of the Genome Packaging Process in a Membrane-Containing Double Stranded DNA Virus

Two crucial steps in the virus life cycle are genome encapsidation to form an infective virion and genome exit to infect the next host cell. In most icosahedral double-stranded (ds) DNA viruses, the viral genome enters and exits the capsid through a unique vertex. Internal membrane-containing viruses possess additional complexity as the genome must be translocated through the viral membrane bilayer. Here, we report the structure of the genome packaging complex with a membrane conduit essential for viral genome encapsidation in the tailless icosahedral membrane-containing bacteriophage PRD1. We utilize single particle electron cryo-microscopy (cryo-EM) and symmetry-free image reconstruction to determine structures of PRD1 virion, procapsid, and packaging deficient mutant particles. At the unique vertex of PRD1, the packaging complex replaces the regular 5-fold structure and crosses the lipid bilayer. These structures reveal that the packaging ATPase P9 and the packaging efficiency factor P6 form a dodecameric portal complex external to the membrane moiety, surrounded by ten major capsid protein P3 trimers. The viral transmembrane density at the special vertex is assigned to be a hexamer of heterodimer of proteins P20 and P22. The hexamer functions as a membrane conduit for the DNA and as a nucleating site for the unique vertex assembly. Our structures show a conformational alteration in the lipid membrane after the P9 and P6 are recruited to the virion. The P8-genome complex is then packaged into the procapsid through the unique vertex while the genome terminal protein P8 functions as a valve that closes the channel once the genome is inside. Comparing mature virion, procapsid, and mutant particle structures led us to propose an assembly pathway for the genome packaging apparatus in the PRD1 virion.     

Phage phi X174 probed by laser Raman spectroscopy: evidence for capsid-imposed constraint on DNA secondary structure

The Raman spectrum of the isometric bacteriophage phi X174 contains a number of well-resolved bands which have been assigned unambiguously to proteins of the capsid or to the single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) genome. Additional Raman bands of protein and DNA, which are partially overlapped in the spectrum of virus, have been resolution enhanced by Fourier deconvolution to permit improved semiquantitative measurement of spectral intensities and frequencies for structural conclusions. Raman conformation markers indicate that the ssDNA molecule within the capsid contains nucleosides of C2'-endo sugar pucker and anti-glycoside bond orientation, but the nucleic acid backbone lacks the geometry characteristic of B-form DNA. The Raman profile of encapsidated phi X DNA indicates a backbone more similar to heat-denatured DNA than to DNA containing hairpinlike secondary structure. This finding suggests limited interbase interactions in the packaged genome, which is presumably the result of constraints imposed by the viral capsid. Thus, the extensive pairing and stacking of bases indicated by Raman profiles from ssRNA viruses are not evident for the phi X174 chromosome. Overall, the proteins of the virion contain extensive beta-sheet and irregular secondary structures. Fourier deconvolution of the Raman amide I band provides an estimate of the percentage of total beta-sheet structure (approximately 60%) in all proteins of the virion. The amide III region of the spectrum confirms that beta-sheet and irregular domains are the predominant protein secondary structures. Samples of phi X174 concentrated for Raman spectroscopy by either ultracentrifugation or ultrafiltration exhibit nearly identical Raman spectra, indicating that either method can be employed to prepare intact virus without significant loss of DNA or protein components.     

The small viral membrane-associated protein P32 is involved in bacteriophage PRD1 DNA entry

The lipid-containing bacteriophage PRD1 infects a variety of gram-negative cells by injecting its linear double-stranded DNA genome into the host cell cytoplasm, while the protein capsid is left outside. The virus membrane and several structural proteins are involved in phage DNA entry. In this work we identified a new infectivity protein of PRD1. Disruption of gene XXXII resulted in a mutant phenotype defective in phage reproduction. The absence of the protein P32 did not compromise the particle assembly but led to a defect in phage DNA injection. In P32-deficient particles the phage membrane is unable to undergo a structural transformation from a spherical to a tubular form. Since P32(-) particles are able to increase the permeability of the host cell envelope to a degree comparable to that found with wild-type particles, we suggest that the tail-tube formation is needed to eject the DNA from the phage particle rather than to reach the host cell interior.     

Stable Packaging of Phage PRD1 DNA Requires Adsorption Protein P2, Which Binds to the IncP Plasmid-Encoded Conjugative Transfer Complex

The double-stranded DNA bacteriophage PRD1 uses an IncP plasmid-encoded conjugal transfer complex as a receptor. Plasmid functions in the PRD1 life cycle are restricted to phage adsorption and DNA entry. A single phage structural protein, P2, located at the fivefold capsid vertices, is responsible for PRD1 attachment to its host. The purified recombinant adsorption protein was judged to be monomeric by gel filtration, rate zonal centrifugation, analytical ultracentrifugation, and chemical cross-linking. It binds to its receptor with an apparent K(d) of 0.20 nM, and this binding prevents phage adsorption. P2-deficient particles are unstable and spontaneously release the DNA with concomitant formation of the tail-like structure originating from the phage membrane. We envisage the DNA to be packaged through one vertex, but the presence of P2 on the other vertices suggests a mechanism whereby the injection vertex is determined by P2 binding to the receptor.     

Minor proteins,mobile arms and membrane-capsid interactions in the bacteriophage PRD1 capsid

Bacteriophage PRD1 shares many structural and functional similarities with adenovirus. A major difference is the PRD1 internal membrane, which acts in concert with vertex proteins to translocate the phage genome into the host. Multiresolution models of the PRD1 capsid, together with genetic analyses, provide fine details of the molecular interactions associated with particle stability and membrane dynamics. The N- and C-termini of the major coat protein (P3), which are required for capsid assembly, act as conformational switches bridging capsid to membrane and linking P3 trimers. Electrostatic P3-membrane interactions increase virion stability upon DNA packaging. Newly revealed proteins suggest how the metastable vertex works and how the capsid edges are stabilized.     

Solution structure of bacteriophage PRD1 vertex complex

Bacteriophage PRD1 is a prototype of viruses with an internal membrane. The icosahedral capsid and major coat protein share structural similarity with the corresponding structures of adenovirus. The present study further explores similarities between these viruses, considering the 5-fold vertex assemblies. The vertex structure of bacteriophage PRD1 consists of proteins P2, P5, and P31. The vertex complex mediates host cell binding and controls double-stranded DNA delivery. Quaternary structures and interactions of purified spike proteins were studied by synchrotron radiation x-ray solution scattering. Low resolution models of the vertex proteins P5, P2, and P31 were reconstructed ab initio from the scattering data. Protein P5 is a long trimer that resembles the adenovirus spike protein pIV. The receptor-binding protein P2 is a 15.5-nm long, thin monomer and does not have an adenovirus counterpart. P31 forms a pentameric base with a maximum diameter of 8.5 nm, which is thinner than the adenovirus penton pIII. P5 further polymerize into a nonameric form ((P5(3))(3)). In the presence of P31, P5 associates into a P5(6):P31 complex. The constructed models of these assemblies provided support for a model of vertex assembly onto the virion. Although similar in overall architecture, clear differences between PRD1 and adenovirus spike assemblies have been revealed.     

Efficient DNA packaging of bacteriophage PRD1 requires the unique vertex protein P6

The assembly of bacteriophage PRD1 proceeds via formation of empty procapsids containing an internal lipid membrane, into which the linear double-stranded DNA genome is subsequently packaged. The packaging ATPase P9 and other putative packaging proteins have been shown to be located at a unique vertex of the PRD1 capsid. Here, we describe the isolation and characterization of a suppressor-sensitive PRD1 mutant deficient in the unique vertex protein P6. Protein P6 was found to be an essential part of the PRD1 packaging machinery; its absence leads to greatly reduced packaging efficiency. Lack of P6 was not found to affect particle assembly, because in the P6-deficient mutant infection, wild-type (wt) amounts of particles were produced, although most were empty. P6 was determined not to be a specificity factor, as the few filled particles seen in the P6-deficient infection contained only PRD1-specific DNA. The presence of P6 was not necessary for retention of DNA in the capsid once packaging had occurred, and P6-deficient DNA-containing particles were found to be stable and infectious, albeit not as infectious as wt PRD1 virions. A packaging model for bacteriophage PRD1, based on previous results and those obtained in this study, is presented.     

The entry mechanism of membrane-containing phage Bam35 infecting Bacillus thuringiensis

The temperate double-stranded DNA bacteriophage Bam35 infects gram-positive Bacillus thuringiensis cells. Bam35 has an icosahedral protein coat surrounding the viral membrane that encloses the linear 15-kbp DNA genome. The protein coat of Bam35 uses the same assembly principle as that of PRD1, a lytic bacteriophage infecting gram-negative hosts. In this study, we dissected the process of Bam35 entry into discrete steps: receptor binding, peptidoglycan penetration, and interaction with the plasma membrane (PM). Bam35 very rapidly adsorbs to the cell surface, and N-acetyl-muramic acid is essential for Bam35 binding. Zymogram analysis demonstrated that peptidoglycan-hydrolyzing activity is associated with the Bam35 virion. We showed that the penetration of Bam35 through the PM is a divalent-cation-dependent process, whereas adsorption and peptidoglycan digestion are not.     

DNA packaging orders the membrane of bacteriophage PRD1.

Bacteriophage PRD1 contains a linear dsDNA genome enclosed by a lipid membrane lying within a protein coat. Determination of the structure of the detergent-treated particle to 2 nm by cryo-electron microscopy and three-dimensional reconstruction has defined the position of the major coat protein P3. The coat contains 240 copies of trimeric P3 packed into positions of local 6-fold symmetry on a T = 25 lattice. The three-dimensional structures of the PRD1 virion and a DNA packaging mutant to a resolution of 2.8 nm have revealed specific interactions between the coat and the underlying membrane. The membrane is clearly visible as two leaflets separated by 2 nm and spanned by transmembrane density. The size of the coat does not change upon DNA packaging. Instead, the number of interactions seen between the protein shell and the membrane and the order of the membrane components increase. Thus the membrane of PRD1 plays a role in assembly which is akin to that played by the nucleocapsid in other membrane viruses.     

Secondary structure and interactions of the packaged dsDNA genome of bacteriophage P22 investigated by Raman difference spectroscopy.

Vibrational spectra of the double-stranded DNA genome of bacteriophage P22 in packaged and unpackaged states are compared by digital difference Raman spectroscopy. The difference Raman spectrum, which is sensitive to structural changes at the level of < 2% of a given nucleotide type, reveals the effects of packaging upon sugar pucker, glycosyl orientation, phosphodiester geometry, base pairing, base stacking, and the electrostatic environment of DNA phosphate groups. For both packaged and unpackaged states, the experiments were performed on aqueous solutions at 25 degrees C containing effective P22 DNA concentrations of 30-50 mg/mL in 200 mM NaCl + 10 mM MgCl2 + 10 mM Tris at pH 7.5. At the experimental conditions employed, the B-form secondary structure of unpackaged P22 DNA is minimally perturbed by packaging the viral genome in the virion capsid. However, the electrostatic environment of DNA phosphates is dramatically altered with packaging. Specifically, we find the following: (1) C2'-endo sugar pucker and anti glycosyl orientations are conserved for all nucleosides. (2) Watson-Crick base pairing is essentially completely retained. (3) Alternative secondary structures, whether right- (A or C form) or left-handed (Z form), are not evident in either the packaged or unpackaged viral genome. (4) Small Raman hyperchromic effects (< 10%) observed for certain marker bands of dG, dA, and dT in the packaged state of P22 DNA suggest slightly reduced base-stacking interactions with packaging. These are consistent with previously reported UV hyperchromic effects, but the Raman spectrum shows that they are not associated with either base unpairing or strand separation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Bacteriophage P22 portal protein is part of the gauge that regulates packing density of intravirion DNA.

The complex double-stranded DNA bacteriophages assemble DNA-free protein shells (procapsids) that subsequently package DNA. In the case of several double-stranded DNA bacteriophages, including P22, packaging is associated with cutting of DNA from the concatemeric molecule that results from replication. The mature intravirion P22 DNA has both non-unique (circularly permuted) ends and a length that is determined by the procapsid. In all known cases, procapsids consist of an outer coat protein, an interior scaffolding protein that assists in the assembly of the coat protein shell, and a ring of 12 identical portal protein subunits through which the DNA is presumed to enter the procapsid. To investigate the role of the portal protein in cutting permuted DNA from concatemers, we have characterized P22 portal protein mutants. The effects of several single amino acid changes in the P22 portal protein on the length of the DNA packaged, the density to which DNA is condensed within the virion, and the outer radius of the capsid have been determined. The results obtained with one mutant (NT5/1a) indicate no change (+/- 0.5%) in the radius of the capsid, but mature DNA that is 4.7% longer and a packing density that is commensurately higher than those of wild-type P22. Thus, the portal protein is part of the gauge that regulates the length and packaging density of DNA in bacteriophage P22. We argue that these findings make models for DNA packaging less likely in which the packing density is a property solely of the coat protein shell or of the DNA itself.     

The Lytic Enzyme of Bacteriophage PRD1 Is Associated with the Viral Membrane

Bacteriophage PRD1 encodes two proteins (P7 and P15) that are associated with a muralytic activity. Protein P15 is a soluble beta-1,4-N-acetylmuramidase that causes phage-induced host cell lysis. We demonstrate here that P15 is also a structural component of the PRD1 virion and that it is connected to the phage membrane. Small viral membrane proteins P20 and P22 modulate incorporation of P15 into the virion and may connect it to the phage membrane. The principal muralytic protein involved in PRD1 DNA entry seems to be the putative lytic transglycosylase protein P7, as the absence of protein P15 did not delay initiation of phage DNA replication in the virus-host system used. The incorporation of two different lytic enzymes into virions may reflect the broad host range of bacteriophage PRD1.     

The structure of the bacteriophage PRD1 spike sheds light on the evolution of viral capsid architecture

Comparisons of bacteriophage PRD1 and adenovirus protein structures and virion architectures have been instrumental in unraveling an evolutionary relationship and have led to a proposal of a phylogeny-based virus classification. The structure of the PRD1 spike protein P5 provides further insight into the evolution of viral proteins. The crystallized P5 fragment comprises two structural domains: a globular knob and a fibrous shaft. The head folds into a ten-stranded jelly roll beta barrel, which is structurally related to the tumor necrosis factor (TNF) and the PRD1 coat protein domains. The shaft domain is a structural counterpart to the adenovirus spike shaft. The structural relationships between PRD1, TNF, and adenovirus proteins suggest that the vertex proteins may have originated from an ancestral TNF-like jelly roll coat protein via a combination of gene duplication and deletion.     

Viral evolution revealed by bacteriophage PRD1 and human adenovirus coat protein structures.

The unusual bacteriophage PRD1 features a membrane beneath its icosahedral protein coat. The crystal structure of the major coat protein, P3, at 1.85 A resolution reveals a molecule with three interlocking subunits, each with two eight-stranded viral jelly rolls normal to the viral capsid, and putative membrane-interacting regions. Surprisingly, the P3 molecule closely resembles hexon, the equivalent protein in human adenovirus. Both viruses also have similar overall architecture, with identical capsid lattices and attachment proteins at their vertices. Although these two dsDNA viruses infect hosts from very different kingdoms, their striking similarities, from major coat protein through capsid architecture, strongly suggest their evolutionary relationship.     

Membrane-containing viruses with icosahedrally symmetric capsids

Viruses with an icosahedrally symmetric protein capsid and a membrane infect hosts from all three domains of life. Similar architectural principles are shared by different viral families, as exemplified by double-stranded DNA viruses such as PRD1 and STIV. During virus assembly, the membrane lipids are selectively acquired from the host cell. The X-ray structure of bacteriophage PRD1 revealed that the lipids are asymmetrically distributed between the two leaflets and facet length is controlled by a tape-measure protein. In most membrane-containing viruses, viral and host membranes fuse during viral entry. In the best-understood systems of the alphaviruses, flaviviruses and herpes viruses, fusion is mediated by viral glycoproteins. Recent structural advances reveal how very different protein architectures can be used to form trimeric extensions that extend into the target cell membrane and then fold back to mediate fusion of the target and viral membranes.     

Bacteriophage PRD1 contains a labile receptor-binding structure at each vertex.

Bacteriophage PRD1 is a membrane-containing virus with an unexpected similarity to adenovirus. We mutagenized unassigned PRD1 genes to identify minor capsid proteins that could be structural or functional analogs to adenovirus proteins.We report here the identification of an amber mutant, sus525, in an essential PRD1 gene XXXI. The gene was cloned and the gene product was overexpressed and purified to near homogeneity. Analytical ultracentrifugation and gel filtration showed that P31 is a homopentamer of about 70 kDa. The protein was shown to be accessible on the virion surface and its absence in the sus525 particles led to the deficiency of two other viral coat proteins, protein P5 and the adsorption protein P2. Cryo-electron microscopy and image reconstruction of the sus525 particles indicate that these proteins are located on the capsid vertices, because in these particles the entire vertex structure was missing along with the peripentonal major capsid protein P3 trimers. Sus525 particles package DNA effectively but loose it upon purification.All of the PRD1 vertex structures are labile and potentially capable of mediating DNA delivery; this is in contrast to other dsDNA phages which employ a single vertex for packaging and delivery. We propose that this arises from a symmetry mismatch between protein P2 and the pentameric P31 in analogy to that between the adenovirus penton base and the receptor-binding spike.