Diversity in immune-cell interactions: states and functions of the immunological synapse

The contact-dependent exchange of signals between epithelial and neuronal cells results from close membrane-membrane appositions, which are stabilized for years by polarized adhesion, cytoskeletal assemblies and extracellular scaffold proteins. By contrast, owing to a lack of scaffold proteins, interactions between immune cells such as T lymphocytes and antigen-presenting cells (APCs) comprise a spectrum of structurally diverse and short-lived interaction modes that last from minutes to hours. Signals exchanged between T cells and APCs are generated in a specific contact region, termed the "immunological synapse", that coordinates cytoskeletal dynamics with the T-cell receptor (TCR), the engagement of accessory receptors and membrane-proximal signaling. Recent data shed light on the different physical and molecular interaction modes that occur between T cells and APCs, including their dynamics and transition stages, and their consequences for signaling, activation and T-cell effector function.     

CD28 interaction with filamin-A controls lipid raft accumulation at the T-cell immunological synapse

During physiological T-cell stimulation by antigen presenting cells (APCs), a major T-cell membrane rearrangement is known to occur leading to the organization of 'supramolecular activation clusters' at the immunological synapse. A possible role for the synapse is the generation of membrane compartments where signalling may be organized and propagated. Thus, engagement of the costimulatory molecule CD28 at the immunological synapse promotes the organization of a signalling compartment by inducing cytoskeletal changes and lipid raft accumulation. We identified the actin-binding protein Filamin-A (FLNa) as a novel molecular partner of CD28. We found that, after physiological stimulation, CD28 associated with and recruited FLNa into the immunological synapse, where FLNa organized CD28 signalling. FLNa knockdown by short interfering RNA (siRNA) inhibited CD28-mediated raft accumulation at the immunological synapse and T-cell costimulation. Together, our data indicate that CD28 binding to FLNa is required to induce the T-cell cytoskeletal rearrangements leading to recruitment of lipid microdomains and signalling mediators into the immunological synapse.     

The insider's guide to leukocyte integrin signalling and function

The activation of leukocyte integrins through diverse receptors results in transformation of the integrin from a bent, resting form to an extended conformation, which has at least two states of ligand-binding activity. This highly regulated activation process is essential for T cell migration and the formation of an immunological synapse. The signalling events that drive integrin activation are complex. Some key players have been well-characterized, but other aspects of the signalling mechanisms involved are still unclear. This Review focuses on the integrin lymphocyte function-associated antigen 1 (LFA1; also known as αLβ2 integrin), which is expressed by T cells, and explores how disparate signalling pathways synergize to regulate LFA1 activity.     

Ezrin tunes T‐cell activation by controlling Dlg1 and microtubule positioning at the immunological synapse

T‐cell receptor (TCR) signalling is triggered and tuned at immunological synapses by the generation of signalling complexes that associate into dynamic microclusters. Microcluster movement is necessary to tune TCR signalling, but the molecular mechanism involved remains poorly known. We show here that the membrane‐microfilament linker ezrin has an important function in microcluster dynamics and in TCR signalling through its ability to set the microtubule network organization at the immunological synapse. Importantly, ezrin and microtubules are important to down‐regulate signalling events leading to Erk1/2 activation. In addition, ezrin is required for appropriate NF‐AT activation through p38 MAP kinase. Our data strongly support the notion that ezrin regulates immune synapse architecture and T‐cell activation through its interaction with the scaffold protein Dlg1. These results uncover a crucial function for ezrin, Dlg1 and microtubules in the organization of the immune synapse and TCR signal down‐regulation. Moreover, they underscore the importance of ezrin and Dlg1 in the regulation of NF‐AT activation through p38.     

High plasma membrane lipid order imaged at the immunological synapse periphery in live T cells

Abstract

Cholesterol- and glycosphingolipid-enriched membrane lipid microdomains, frequently called lipid rafts, are thought to play an important role in the spatial and temporal organization of immunological synapses. Higher ordering of lipid acyl chains was suggested for these entities and imaging of membrane order in living cells during activation can therefore help to understand the mechanisms responsible for the supramolecular organization of molecules involved in the activation of T cells. Here, we employ the phase-sensitive membrane dye di-4-ANEPPDHQ together with a variety of spectrally-resolved microscopy techniques, including 2-channel ratiometric TIRF microscopy and fluorescence lifetime imaging, to characterize membrane order at the T cell immunological synapse at high spatial and temporal resolution in live cells at physiological temperature. We find that higher membrane order resides at the immunological synapse periphery where proximal signalling through the immunoreceptors and accessory proteins in microclusters has previously been shown to take place. The observed spatial patterning of membrane order in the immunological synapse depends on active receptor signalling.     

Immunological synapses: breaking up may be good to do

Activated T cells form stable immunological synapses with antigen-presenting cells whereas na?ve T cells initially engage in more transient interactions. Sims et al. (2007) demonstrate that these transient interactions are due to the kinase PKCtheta, which serves to destabilize the synapse thereby permitting T cells to migrate elsewhere. They also show that re-establishment of a synapse involves the actin regulator WASp.     

Masters of manipulation: Viral modulation of the immunological synapse

In order to thrive, viruses have evolved to manipulate host cell machinery for their own benefit. One major obstacle faced by pathogens is the immunological synapse. To enable efficient replication and latency in immune cells, viruses have developed a range of strategies to manipulate cellular processes involved in immunological synapse formation to evade immune detection and control T‐cell activation. In vitro, viruses such as human immunodeficiency virus 1 and human T‐lymphotropic virus type 1 utilise structures known as virological synapses to aid transmission of viral particles from cell to cell in a process termed trans‐infection. The formation of the virological synapse provides a gateway for virus to be transferred between cells avoiding the extracellular space, preventing antibody neutralisation or recognition by complement. This review looks at how viruses are able to subvert intracellular signalling to modulate immune function to their advantage and explores the role synapse formation has in viral persistence and cell‐to‐cell transmission.     

Microtubule dynamics and signal transduction at the immunological synapse: new partners and new connections

EMBO J (2012) 31 21, 4140–4152 doi:10.1038/emboj.2012.242; published online August242012Antigen recognition induces T cells to polarize towards antigen presenting cells (APC) generating an organized cell interface named the immunological synapse. T-cell microtubules (MTs) reorient the MT-organizing centre (MTOC) to the immunological synapse central region, while MT irradiate towards the synapse periphery. Martín-Cófreces et al (2012) describe in this issue that the MT plus-end-binding protein 1 (EB1) interacts with TCR cytosolic regions and mediate the organization of an immunological synapse fully functional to transduce activation signals.The pioneer work of Kupfer and Singer (1989) established that T-cell MTs rearrange in response to specific TCR engagement by APCs, resulting in MTOC orientation to the APC contact site in helper and cytotoxic T cells. MTOC reorientation was shown to be the result of a MT polymerization dynamic process involving MT posttranslational modifications (Kuhn and Poenie, 2002; Serrador et al, 2004). MT reorganization during T-cell antigen recognition is functionally linked to T-cell effector functions, like the polarized secretion of helper cytokines to B cells (Kupfer et al, 1991; Huse et al, 2006), or cytotoxic granules to target cells (Stinchcombe et al, 2006). MTs also transport TCR-carrying endosomes during synapse formation (Das et al, 2004) and TCR signalling complexes at the immunological synapse (Lasserre et al, 2010; Hashimoto-Tane et al, 2011). Altogether, these findings show that the dynamic reorganization of MTs and its related molecular transport are critical for the organization and function of the immunological synapse.Martín-Cófreces et al (2012) present here interesting new insights, unveiling a link between EB1 and the TCR complex. EB1 is one of a series of MT plus-end-associated proteins critical for MT polymerization dynamics (Slep, 2010). The first important finding initially issued from a two-hybrid screening was that EB1 could directly interact with TCR complex cytosolic regions. By GST pull-down and co-immunoprecipitation experiments, the authors narrowed down this interaction to two of the TCR complex subunits, ζ and ɛ, in their ITAM (immuno-receptor tyrosine-based activation motif)-containing regions, and within the C-terminal 82 amino-acid region on EB1. In T cells, EB1–TCR interaction could occur without TCR stimulation, suggesting that EB1 plays a role in TCR dynamics previous to TCR engagement. The authors then investigated EB1 localization and its involvement in synapse organization and function. Live cell imaging showed intense EB1 movement in the synapse area, with MTs growing from the MTOC to the synapse periphery, leading to an apparent concentration of EB1 at the T cell–APC interface. To analyse the relationship between MT dynamics and intracellular transport, the authors followed EB1–GFP and TCRζ–Cherry by total internal reflection fluorescence (TIRF) microscopy in synapses formed on anti-CD3-coated cover slips. They observed transient coincident spots between EB1 and TCRζ+ vesicles, suggesting that growing MTs transport TCRζ-carrying vesicles towards the immunological synapse. Consistently, EB1-silenced cells displayed altered TCRζ vesicle dynamics and TCRζ clustering at the synapse. Likewise, vesicle transport to the synapse of the signalling scaffold molecule LAT and its clustering at the synapse were altered. Finally, they observed transient encounters between TCRζ- and LAT-carrying vesicles inhibited by EB1 silencing. These observations point out to a crucial role of EB1 and MT dynamics in the organization of the immunological synapse.Immunological synapse organization has been related with its capacity to regulate TCR signal transduction. Therefore, Martín-Cófreces et al (2012) investigated how EB1 silencing impacted TCR signalling. EB1-silenced cells were indeed impaired in key TCR signalling events, like LAT tyrosine phosphorylation, which allows LAT interaction with activation effectors, like the phospholipase C (PLC)γ, promoting TCR signal propagation. Consistently, PLCγ activation was impaired in EB1-silenced cells. However, upstream activation events, like tyrosine phosphorylation of TCRζ and of its associated protein tyrosine kinase ZAP70, were not altered. This suggests that MT-dependent LAT vesicle traffic is key for LAT phosphorylation and the generation of TCR signalling complexes.Altogether, Martín-Cófreces'' findings reinforce the idea that polarized vesicle transport via organized MT networks is key to set up the immunological synapse as a signal transduction platform. EB1 interaction with two TCR subunits may link the TCR complex with MTs dynamics. It remains unanswered, however, whether EB1 also interacts with LAT, facilitating the merging at the synapse of distinct TCRζ- and LAT-carrying vesicles.Vesicle traffic on MTs generally occurs via molecular motors from the dynein and kinesin families. The former are associated with minus end-oriented transport, whereas the later mostly ensures plus-end-associated transport. The immunological synapse may use both types of transport. Thus, cytotoxic granule delivery to the synapse may mainly involve dynein-mediated vesicle traffic, since the MTOC translocates very close to the immunological synapse (Stinchcombe et al, 2006). Likewise, centripetal movements of signalling microclusters at the synapse involve dynein (Hashimoto-Tane et al, 2011). Martín-Cófreces et al (2012) show that TCRζ- and LAT-carrying vesicles are transported towards MT plus ends in an EB1-dependent manner. It remains uncertain whether EB1 could play a direct transport role at the immunological synapse, helping the attachment of TCRζ vesicles to growing MT plus ends. Alternatively, EB1 could mediate MT interactions with TCR complexes present at the plasma membrane. Initial TCR clustering at the synapse would help capturing EB1-positive MT plus ends, orienting MTs and MT-mediated traffic of TCRζ- and LAT-carrying vesicles to the synapse by a kinesin-based transport (Figure 1), and promoting TCRζ and LAT encountering and clustering at the synapse. EB1 silencing would perturb MT–plasma membrane interactions impairing this MT orientation and transport loop. MT polymerization kinetic studies on immunological synapses formed by EB1-silenced versus control T cells may help to clarify this mechanism. Although further studies will be necessary to elucidate the detailed mechanism, the work by Martín-Cófreces et al (2012) already highlights the importance of MT dynamics and vesicle traffic in the formation of a functional immunological synapse, raising novel and interesting questions on how the MT network helps to set up complex signal transduction machineries.Open in a separate windowFigure 1Model of the role of EB1 in MT dynamics and TCR signal transduction at the immunological synapse. (A) Initial T cell–APC contact. TCR initial clustering would favour the capture of EB1-containing MT plus ends at the T cell–APC contact. (B) Immune synapse formation. The increase capture of MTs plus ends by TCR clusters would promote the arrival of TCRζ- and LAT-carrying vesicles leading to increase TCR and LAT clustering and encountering at the synapse. Alternatively, EB1 interaction with TCR could also be directly involved in TCRζ vesicle transport to the synapse. In turn, increase TCR clustering would promote additional MT and capture, building an amplification loop for MT dynamics and vesicle transport. (C) Established immunological synapse. A structured MT network would facilitate the continuous arrival of TCRζ- and LAT-carrying vesicles through the MT plus ends at the immunological synapse periphery. Then the centripetal movement of TCR signalling complexes towards the MT minus end at the MTOC close to the synapse centre would bring signalling complexes to signal extinction sites (i.e., endosomes). The right panel in C represents a xy section of the immunological synapse, as it is observed on stimulatory cover slips.     

Differences in signaling molecule organization between naive and memory CD4+ T lymphocytes

The immunological synapse is a highly organized complex formed at the junction between Ag-specific T cells and APCs as a prelude to cell activation. Although its exact role in modulating T cell signaling is unknown, it is commonly believed that the immunological synapse is the site of cross-talk between the T cell and APC (or target). We have examined the synapses formed by naive and memory CD4 cells during Ag-specific cognate interactions with APCs. We show that the mature immunological synapse forms more quickly during memory T cell activation. We further show that the composition of the synapse found in naive or memory cell conjugates with APCs is distinct with the tyrosine phosphatase, CD45, being a more integral component of the mature synapses formed by memory cells. Finally, we show that signaling molecules, including CD45, are preassociated in discrete, lipid-raft microdomains in resting memory cells but not in naive cells. Thus, enhanced memory cell responses may be due to intrinsic properties of signaling molecule organization.     

Roles for glycosylation of cell surface receptors involved in cellular immune recognition.

The majority of cell surface receptors involved in antigen recognition by T cells and in the orchestration of the subsequent cell signalling events are glycoproteins. The length of a typical N-linked sugar is comparable with that of an immunoglobulin domain (30 A). Thus, by virtue of their size alone, oligosaccharides may be expected to play a significant role in the functions and properties of the cell surface proteins to which they are attached. A databank of oligosaccharide structures has been constructed from NMR and crystallographic data to aid in the interpretation of crystal structures of glycoproteins. As unambiguous electron density can usually only be assigned to the glycan cores, the remainder of the sugar is then modelled into the crystal lattice by superimposing the appropriate oligosaccharide from the database. This approach provides insights into the roles that glycosylation might play in cell surface receptors, by providing models that delineate potential close packing interactions on the cell surface. It has been proposed that the specific recognition of antigen by T cells results in the formation of an immunological synapse between the T cell and the antigen-presenting cell. The cell adhesion glycoproteins, such as CD2 and CD48, help to form a cell junction, providing a molecular spacer between opposing cells. The oligosaccharides located on the membrane proximal domains of CD2 and CD48 provide a scaffold to orient the binding faces, which leads to increased affinity. In the next step, recruitment of the peptide major histocompatibility complex (pMHC) by the T-cell receptors (TCRs) requires mobility on the membrane surface. The TCR sugars are located such that they could prevent non-specific aggregation. Importantly, the sugars limit the possible geometry and spacing of TCR/MHC clusters which precede cell signalling. We postulate that, in the final stage, the sugars could play a general role in controlling the assembly and stabilisation of the complexes in the synapse and in protecting them from proteolysis during prolonged T-cell engagement.     

Membrane lipid order of sub‐synaptic T cell vesicles correlates with their dynamics and function

During an immune response, T cells survey antigen presenting cells for antigenic peptides via the formation of an interface known as an immunological synapse. Among the complex and dynamic biophysical phenomena occurring at this interface is the trafficking of sub‐synaptic vesicles carrying a variety of proximal signalling molecules. Here, we show that rather than being a homogeneous population, these vesicles display a diversity of membrane lipid order profiles, as measured using the environmentally sensitive dye di‐4‐ANEPPDHQ and multi‐spectral TIRF microscopy. Using live‐cell imaging, vesicle tracking and a variety of small molecule drugs to manipulate components of the actin and tubulin cytoskeleton, we show that the membrane lipid order of these vesicles correlate with their dynamics. Furthermore, we show that the key proximal signalling molecule Linker for Activation of T cells (LAT) is enriched in specific vesicle populations as defined by their higher membrane order. These results imply that vesicle lipid order may represent a novel regulatory mechanism for the sorting and trafficking of signalling molecules at the immunological synapse, and, potentially, other cellular structures.      

Lipid rafts and regulation of the cytoskeleton during T cell activation

The ability of polarized cells to initiate and sustain directional responses to extracellular signals is critically dependent on direct communication between spatially organized signalling modules in the membrane and the underlying cytoskeleton. Pioneering work in T cells has shown that the assembly of signalling modules critically depends on the functional compartmentalization of membrane lipids into ordered microdomains or lipid rafts. The significance of rafts in T cell activation lies not only in their ability to recruit the signalling partners that eventually assemble into a mature immunological synapse but also in their ability to regulate actin dynamics and recruit cytoskeletal associated proteins, thereby achieving the structural polarization underlying stability of the synapse-a critical prerequisite for activation to be sustained. Lipid rafts vary quite considerably in size and visualizing the smallest of them in vivo has been challenging. Nonetheless it is now been shown quite convincingly that a surprisingly large proportion-in the order of 50%-of external membrane lipids (chiefly cholesterol and glycosphingolipids) can be dynamically localized in these liquid ordered rafts. Complementary inner leaflet rafts are less well characterized, but contain phosphoinositides as an important functional component that is crucial for regulating the behaviour of the actin cytoskeleton. This paper provides an overview of the interdependency between signalling and cytoskeletal polarization, and in particular considers how regulation of the cytoskeleton plays a crucial role in the consolidation of rafts and their stabilization into the immunological synapse.     

Live-cell dynamics and the role of costimulation in immunological synapse formation

Using transfected fibroblasts expressing both wild-type I-E(k) and green fluorescent protein-tagged I-E(k) with covalently attached antigenic peptide, we have monitored movement of specific MHC:peptide complexes during CD4(+) T cell-APC interactions by live-cell video microscopy. Ag recognition occurs within 30 s of T cell-APC contact, as shown by a sharp increase in cytoplasmic calcium ion concentration. Within 1 min, small MHC:peptide clusters form in the contact zone that coalesce into an immunological synapse over 3-20 min. When T cells conjugated to APC move across the APC surface, they appear to drag the synapse with them. This system was used to examine the role of costimulation in the formation of the immunological synapse. Blocking CD80/CD28 or ICAM-1/LFA-1 interactions alters synapse morphology and reduces the area and density of accumulated complexes. These reductions correlate with reduced T cell proliferation, while CD69 and CD25 expression and TCR down-modulation remain unaffected. Thus, costimulation is essential for normal mature immunological synapse formation.     

F-actin flow drives affinity maturation and spatial organization of LFA-1 at the immunological synapse

Integrin-dependent interactions between T cells and antigen-presenting cells are vital for proper T cell activation, effector function, and memory. Regulation of integrin function occurs via conformational change, which modulates ligand affinity, and receptor clustering, which modulates valency. Here, we show that conformational intermediates of leukocyte functional antigen 1 (LFA-1) form a concentric array at the immunological synapse. Using an inhibitor cocktail to arrest F-actin dynamics, we show that organization of this array depends on F-actin flow and ligand mobility. Furthermore, F-actin flow is critical for maintaining the high affinity conformation of LFA-1, for increasing valency by recruiting LFA-1 to the immunological synapse, and ultimately for promoting intracellular cell adhesion molecule 1 (ICAM-1) binding. Finally, we show that F-actin forces are opposed by immobilized ICAM-1, which triggers LFA-1 activation through a combination of induced fit and tension-based mechanisms. Our data provide direct support for a model in which the T cell actin network generates mechanical forces that regulate LFA-1 activity at the immunological synapse.     

Lipid Rafts & Co.: an integrated model of membrane organization in T cell activation

The model of membrane compartmentalization by self-organizing functional lipid microdomains, named lipid rafts, has been a fruitful concept resulting in great progress in understanding T cell signal transduction. However, due to recent results it has become clear that lipid rafts describe only one out of several membrane organizing principles crucial for T cell activation besides fences and pickets and protein-protein interactions that take part in the formation of the immunological synapse as a highly organized structure at the T cell contact site to the antigen-presenting cell. This review describes the concepts of lipid rafts and other membrane organizing principles to evolve a novel integrated model on the functional role of microdomains in immunological synapse formation and T cell activation. Further research has to elucidate the relative contribution and interrelation of different modes of membrane organization in productive T cell activation.     

Fish oil disrupts MHC class II lateral organization on the B-cell side of the immunological synapse independent of B-T cell adhesion

Fish oil-enriched long chain n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids disrupt the molecular organization of T-cell proteins in the immunological synapse. The impact of fish oil derived n-3 fatty acids on antigen-presenting cells, particularly at the animal level, is unknown. We previously demonstrated B-cells isolated from mice fed with fish oil-suppressed naïve CD4⁺ T-cell activation. Therefore, here we determined the mechanistic effects of fish oil on murine B-cell major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecular distribution using a combination of total internal reflection fluorescence, Förster resonance energy transfer and confocal imaging. Fish oil had no impact on presynaptic B-cell MHC II clustering. Upon conjugation with transgenic T-cells, fish-oil suppressed MHC II accumulation at the immunological synapse. As a consequence, T-cell protein kinase C theta (PKCθ) recruitment to the synapse was also diminished. The effects were independent of changes in B-T cell adhesion, as measured with microscopy, flow cytometry and static cell adhesion assays with select immune ligands. Given that fish oil can reorganize the membrane by lowering membrane cholesterol levels, we then compared the results with fish oil to cholesterol depletion using methyl-B-cyclodextrin (MβCD). MβCD treatment of B-cells suppressed MHC II and T-cell PKCθ recruitment to the immunological synapse, similar to fish oil. Overall, the results reveal commonality in the mechanism by which fish oil manipulates protein lateral organization of B-cells compared to T-cells. Furthermore, the data establish MHC class II lateral organization on the B-cell side of the immunological synapse as a novel molecular target of fish oil.     

Semaphorins in interactions between T cells and antigen-presenting cells

Although semaphorins were identified originally as guidance cues for developing neuronal axons, accumulating evidence indicates that several semaphorins are expressed also in the immune system. SEMA4D (CD100), which is expressed constitutively by T cells, enhances the activation of B cells and dendritic cells (DCs) through its cell-surface receptor, CD72. SEMA4A, which is expressed by DCs, is involved in the activation of T cells through interactions with TIM2. So, these semaphorins seem to function in the reciprocal stimulation of T cells and antigen-presenting cells (APCs). Emerging evidence indicates that additional semaphorins and related molecules are involved in T-cell-APC interactions also.     

Cell adhesion molecules regulating astrocyte–neuron interactions

A tripartite synapse comprises a neuronal presynaptic axon and a postsynaptic dendrite, which are closely ensheathed by a perisynaptic astrocyte process. Through their structural and functional association with thousands of neuronal synapses, astrocytes regulate synapse formation and function. Recent work revealed a diverse range of cell adhesion–based mechanisms that mediate astrocyte–synapse interactions at tripartite synapses. Here, we will review some of these findings unveiling a highly dynamic bidirectional signaling between astrocytes and synapses, which orchestrates astrocyte morphological maturation and synapse development. Moreover, we will discuss the roles of these newly discovered molecular pathways in brain physiology and function both in health and disease.     

Cell adhesion molecules and actin cytoskeleton at immune synapses and kinapses

The immunological synapse is a stable adhesive junction between a polarized immune effector cell and an antigen-bearing cell. Immunological synapses are often observed to have a striking radial symmetry in the plane of contact with a prominent central cluster of antigen receptors surrounded by concentric rings of adhesion molecules and actin-rich projections. There is a striking similarity between the radial zones of the immunological synapse and the dynamic actinomyosin modules employed by migrating cells. Breaking the symmetry of an immunological synapse generates a moving adhesive junction that can be defined as a kinapse, which facilitates signal integration by immune cells while moving over the surface of antigen-presenting cells.