C-DNA may facilitate homologous DNA pairing

Recombination-independent homologous pairing represents a prominent yet largely enigmatic feature of chromosome biology. As suggested by studies in the fungus Neurospora crassa, this process may be based on the direct pairing of homologous DNA molecules. Theoretical search for the DNA structures consistent with those genetic results has led to an all-atom model in which the B-DNA conformation of the paired double helices is strongly shifted toward C-DNA. Coincidentally, C-DNA also features a very shallow major groove that could permit initial homologous contacts without atom–atom clashes. The hereby conjectured role of C-DNA in homologous pairing should encourage the efforts to discover its biological functions and may also clarify the mechanism of recombination-independent recognition of DNA homology.     

Inhibition of protein-mediated homologous pairing by a DNA helicase.

Protein-mediated exchange of homologous DNA strands is a central reaction in general genetic recombination and the mechanism by which proteins mediate this process in vivo is a topic of keen interest. The dda protein of the bacteriophage T4 is a DNA helicase that has been shown to accelerate branch migration catalyzed by the phage uvsX and gene 32 proteins in vitro (Kodadek, T., and Alberts, B.M. (1987) Nature 326, 312-314). This study did not address the potential role of the helicase in protein-mediated homologous pairing, the first phase of the overall strand-exchange reaction. It is shown here that the dda protein inhibits uvsX protein-mediated pairing between homologous single and double-stranded DNAs. Experiments using deproteinized heteroduplex joints demonstrate that the dda helicase is capable of unwinding these structures to some extent and suggests that this activity may be responsible for the observed inhibition of pairing. It is found that the helicase also reduces the level of uvsX protein-mediated, single-stranded DNA-dependent ATP hydrolysis in the strand-exchange reactions, suggesting that the helicase may also act to destabilize the uvsX protein-DNA filaments that are important intermediates in the pairing reaction. Three other helicases are found to have no effect on the uvsX protein-mediated pairing reaction. A model rationalizing the ability of the dda protein to both inhibit homologous pairing and stimulate branch migration is presented and possible in vivo roles for this interesting activity are discussed.     

An overview of homologous pairing and DNA strand exchange proteins.

Processes fundamental to all models of genetic recombination include the homologous pairing and subsequent exchange of DNA strands. Biochemical analysis of these events has been conducted primarily on the recA protein of Escherichia coli, although proteins which can promote such reactions have been purified from many sources, both prokaryotic and eukaryotic. The activities of these homologous pairing and DNA strand exchange proteins are either ATP-dependent, as predicted based on the recA protein paradigm, or, more unexpectedly, ATP-independent. This review examines the reactions promoted by both classes of proteins and highlights their similarities and differences. The mechanistic implications of the apparent existence of 2 classes of strand exchange protein are discussed.     

T4 phage gene uvsX product catalyzes homologous DNA pairing.

Gene uvsX of phage T4 controls genetic recombination and the repair of DNA damage. We have recently purified the gene product, and here describe its properties. The protein has a single-stranded DNA-dependent ATPase activity. It binds efficiently to single- and double-stranded DNAs at 0 degrees C in a cooperative manner. At 30 degree C the double-stranded DNA-protein complex was stable, but the single-stranded DNA-protein complex dissociated rapidly. The instability of the latter complex was reduced by ATP. The protein renatured heat-denatured double-stranded DNA, and assimilated linear single-stranded DNA into homologous superhelical duplexes to produce D-loops. The reaction is stimulated by gene 32 protein when the uvsX protein is limiting. With linear double-stranded DNA and homologous, circular single-stranded DNA, the protein catalyzed single-strand displacement in the 5' to 3' direction with the cooperation of gene 32 protein. All reactions required Mg2+, and all except DNA binding required ATP. We conclude that the uvsX protein is directly involved in strand exchange and is analogous to the recA protein of Escherichia coli. The differences between the uvsX protein and the recA protein, and the role of gene 32 protein in single-strand assimilation and single-strand displacement are briefly discussed.     

Identification of two types of homologous DNA pairing activity in mouse cells.

We have identified two types of homologous DNA pairing activity in mouse cell extracts by a strand-transfer assay. Both activities are separated from each other by anion-exchange chromatography; neither of them needs ATP. One requires magnesium ion and is stimulated by Escherichia coli single-stranded DNA binding protein, whereas the other does not require the ion and shows a higher affinity for a left-handed Z-DNA.     

Networks of DNA and RecA protein are intermediates in homologous pairing

Partial coating of single-stranded DNA by recA protein causes its aggregation, but conditions that promote complete coating inhibit independent aggregation of single strands and, instead, cause the mutually dependent conjunction of single- and double-stranded DNA in complexes that sediment at more than 10 000 S. This coaggregation is independent of homology but otherwise shares key properties of homologous pairing of single strands with duplex DNA: both processes require ATP, MgCl2, and stoichiometric amounts of recA protein; both are very sensitive to inhibition by salt and ADP. Coaggregates are closed domains that are intermediates in homologous pairing: they form faster than joint molecules, they include virtually all of the DNA in the reaction mixture, and they yield joint molecules nearly an order of magnitude faster than they exchange DNA molecules with the surrounding solution. The independent aggregation of single-stranded DNA differs in all respects except the requirement for Mg2+, and its properties correlate instead with those associated with the renaturation of complementary single strands by recA protein.     

Recombination of homologous DNA fragments transfected into mammalian cells occurs predominantly by terminal pairing.

The mechanism by which double-strand cleavages stimulate the joining of plasmid DNA fragments introduced into cultured mammalian cells was investigated by cotransfecting pairs of plasmids encoding deletion mutations in a dominant selectable gene into LMtk- cells. Plasmid recombination substrates were produced by creating deletions of different sizes within the neo coding region of the pSV2neo plasmid. Complementing pairs of deleted plasmid DNAs were linearized at specific unique sites before cotransfection into mouse LMtk- cells by the calcium phosphate precipitation method. Cleaving one donor plasmid produced a 4- to 10-fold stimulation in the production of colonies able to survive in medium containing G-418. The linearization of the second plasmid further increased the efficiency by another factor of 6 to 15 when the cut was made on the opposite side of the homology, approximately equidistant from the center of the overlap. Fifty-seven individual G-418-resistant colonies representing the products of individual crosses were isolated, and the genomic DNAs containing the presumably integrated, functional recombinant neo genes were analyzed on Southern blots. A band consistent with the exchange of markers flanking the neo gene was present in 90% of the DNAs examined. In only one case was the pattern indicative of either a double crossover or a gene conversion event. These results support the idea that homologous extrachromosomal DNA fragments are joined through annealing of overlapping single-stranded ends. This DNA-joining phenomenon may represent the activity of cellular DNA repair enzymes; its relationship to genetic recombination occurring at the chromosomal level remains to be determined.     

RecA protein-promoted homologous pairing and strand exchange between intact and partially single-stranded duplex DNA.

In the pairing reaction between circular gapped and fully duplex DNA, RecA protein first polymerizes on the gapped DNA to form a nucleoprotein filament. Conditions that removed the formation of secondary structure in the gapped DNA, such as addition of Escherichia coli single-stranded DNA binding protein or preincubation in 1 mM-MgCl2, optimized the binding of RecA protein and increased the formation of joint molecules. The gapped duplex formed stable joints with fully duplex DNA that had a 5' or 3' terminus complementary to the single-stranded region of the gapped molecule. However, the joints formed had distinct properties and structures depending on whether the complementary terminus was at the 5' or 3' end. Pairing between gapped DNA and fully duplex linear DNA with a 3' complementary terminus resulted in strand displacement, symmetric strand exchange and formation of complete strand exchange products. By contrast, pairing between gapped and fully duplex DNA with a 5' complementary terminus produced a joint that was restricted to the gapped region; there was no strand displacement or symmetric strand exchange. The joint formed in the latter reaction was likely a three-stranded intermediate rather than a heteroduplex with the classical Watson-Crick structure. We conclude that, as in the three-strand reaction, the process of strand exchange in the four-strand reaction is polar and progresses in a 5' to 3' direction with respect to the initiating strand. The present study provides further evidence that in both three-strand and four-strand systems the pairing and strand exchange reactions share a common mechanism.     

Flexibility of nucleosomal DNA

In this study transient electric birefringence (TEB) has been used to investigate the molecular flexibility of short fragments of DNA. Nucleosomal DNA always exhibits negative birefringence and Kerr behavior was observed up to high field strengths (6 KV/cm). The value of the Kerr constant is 3.5 10^?2 e.s.u.. Birefringence decays were single exponentials and a field dependence of the molecular orientational relaxation time τ was found: it is explained by an inherent flexibility of the DNA molecule. A 20 % decrease in the calculated length was observed with fields applied as low as 2 KV/cm. The results obtained at very low fields establish TEB as a method well suited to calculate accurate values for the length of small fragments of DNA: the τ value of 4.3 μsec corresponds to a DNA length of 660 Å.     

Methylation of nucleosomal and nuclease sensitive DNA.

The proportion of cytosines methylated in the DNA of nucleosome oligomers and of core particles appears indistinguishable from that of total nuclear DNA from CHO cells. However the DNA in nucleoprotein which is initially released from nuclei by treatment with very low levels of micrococcal nuclease and the first 10% of material rendered acid soluble by treatment of nuclei with DNase I are enriched 2 fold in their content of 5 methylcytosine. (Cessation of hydrolysis by nuclease occurs concomitantly with precipitation of nucleosomal core particles).     

Genetic recombination: recA protein promotes homologous pairing between duplex DNA molecules without strand unwinding.

The recA protein of Escherichia coli promotes pairing in vitro between covalent circular duplex DNA and homologous circular duplex DNA containing a single stranded region. We have used a filter binding assay to investigate the frequency of homologous pairing between gapped and intact duplex DNA when unwinding of the free 3' and 5' ends of the gapped molecules was blocked. In order to obtain DNA without free ends, the gapped DNA was treated with trimethylpsoralen and 360 nm light so as to introduce about 6 crosslinks per DNA molecule and the double stranded regions on either side of the gaps were then digested up to the first crosslinks with exonuclease III and lambda exonuclease. This treatment did not diminish the frequency of homologous pairing, an observation which is difficult to reconcile with models for recombination requiring strand unwinding before pairing.     

Tailed duplex DNA is the preferred substrate for Rad51 protein-mediated homologous pairing

The repair of potentially lethal DNA double-stranded breaks (DSBs) by homologous recombination requires processing of the broken DNA into a resected DNA duplex with a protruding 3'-single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) tail. Accordingly, the canonical models for DSB repair require invasion of an intact homologous DNA template by the 3'-end of the ssDNA, a characteristic that the bacterial pairing protein RecA possesses. Unexpectedly, we find that for the eukaryotic homolog, Rad51 protein, the 5'-end of ssDNA is more invasive than the 3'-end. This pairing bias is unaffected by Rad52, Rad54 or Rad55-57 proteins. However, further investigation reveals that, in contrast to RecA protein, the preferred DNA substrate for Rad51 protein is not ssDNA but rather dsDNA with ssDNA tails. This important distinction permits the Rad51 proteins to promote DNA strand invasion using either 3'- or 5'-ends with similar efficiency.     

Superhelicity-driven homologous DNA pairing by yeast recombination factors Rad51 and Rad54

Yeast Rad51 recombinase has only minimal ability to form D loop. Addition of Rad54 renders D loop formation by Rad51 efficient, even when topologically relaxed DNA is used as substrate. Treatment of the nucleoprotein complex of Rad54 and relaxed DNA with topoisomerases reveals dynamic DNA remodeling to generate unconstrained negative and positive supercoils. DNA remodeling requires ATP hydrolysis by Rad54 and is stimulated by Rad51-DNA nucleoprotein complex. A marked sensitivity of DNA undergoing remodeling to P1 nuclease indicates that the negative supercoils produced lead to transient DNA strand separation. Thus, a specific interaction of Rad54 with the Rad51-ssDNA complex enhances the ability of the former to remodel DNA and allows the latter to harvest the negative supercoils generated for DNA joint formation.     

Yeast Rad54 promotes Rad51-dependent homologous DNA pairing via ATP hydrolysis-driven change in DNA double helix conformation.

Saccharomyces cerevisiae RAD54 gene functions in the formation of heteroduplex DNA, a key intermediate in recombination processes. Rad54 is monomeric in solution, but forms a dimer/oligomer on DNA. Rad54 dimer/oligomer alters the conformation of the DNA double helix in an ATP-dependent manner, as revealed by a change in the DNA linking number in a topoisomerase I-linked reaction. DNA conformational alteration does not occur in the presence of non-hydrolyzable ATP analogues, nor when mutant rad54 proteins defective in ATP hydrolysis replace Rad54. Accordingly, the Rad54 ATPase activity is shown to be required for biological function in vivo and for promoting Rad51-mediated homologous DNA pairing in vitro. Taken together, the results are consistent with a model in which a Rad54 dimer/oligomer promotes nascent heteroduplex joint formation via a specific interaction with Rad51 protein and an ability to transiently unwind duplex DNA.     

Anisotropic flexibility of DNA and the nucleosomal structure.

Potential energy calculations of the DNA duplex dimeric subunit show that the double helix may be bent in the direction of minor and major grooves much more easily than in other directions. It is found that the total winding angle of DNA decreases upon such bending. A new model for DNA folding in the nucleosome is proposed on the basis of these findings according to which the DNA molecule is kinked each fifth base pair to the side of the minor and major grooves alternatively. The model explains the known contradiction between a C-like circular dichroism for the nucleosomal DNA and the nuclease digestion data, which testify to the B-form of DNA.     

Specific defects in double-stranded DNA unwinding and homologous pairing of a mutant RecA protein

The DNA molecules bound to RecA filaments are extended 1.5-fold relative to B-form DNA. This extended DNA structure may be important in the recognition of homology between single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) and double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). In this study, we show that the K286N mutation specifically impaired the dsDNA unwinding and homologous pairing activities of RecA, without an apparent effect on dsDNA binding itself. In contrast, the R243Q mutation caused defective dsDNA unwinding, due to the defective dsDNA binding of the C-terminal domain of RecA. These results provide new evidence that dsDNA unwinding is essential to homology recognition between ssDNA and dsDNA during homologous pairing.