A note on inoculum reproducibility: a comparison between solid and liquid culture

The level of reproducibility for replicate determinations of drug sensitivity was significantly greater for liquid than for solid cultures and decreased markedly with the density of colonies upon seeded agar plates. Inocula of Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa were significantly less sensitive towards chlorhexidine when derived from liquid rather than solid culture. We therefore suggest that only liquid cultures be used for the preparation of challenge inocula for regulatory tests of antimicrobial activity.     

Comparative study of amylolytic enzymes production byAspergillus niger in liquid and solid-state cultivation

Summary Amylolytic enzymes produced by a strain ofAspergillus niger cultivated on cassava starch in liquid or solid culture were found to be mainly glucoamylases. For the same initial amount of substrate, the glucoamylase activity increased even after 60 h of culture on solid medium whereas it decreased in liquid culture. Some characteristics of the amylases produced in both culture conditions were compared. The pH optima for enzymes produced in solid and liquid cultures were 4.5 and 5.0 respectively. Glucoamylase synthetized in solid cultures was significantly more thermostable than that from liquid culture and was maximally active at 70°C compared to 50°C for the enzyme from liquid cultures. The Km values expressed as mg soluble starch/100 ml were 0.1% for crude enzyme from solid culture and 0.057% for crude enzyme from liquid culture.     

Comparative Removal of Bentazon by Ganoderma lucidum in Liquid and Solid State Cultures

Bentazon removal by Ganoderma lucidum cultured in liquid and solid state conditions was compared in this work. In solid state cultures, the fungus produced both ligninolytic enzymes, namely laccase and Mn peroxidase. In liquid cultures, the main ligninolytic enzyme produced was laccase. In both types of cultures bentazon improved the production of laccase without significant alteration in the production of Mn peroxidase. In solid state cultures, where high levels of both laccase and Mn peroxidase activities were found, the fungus was more resistant to the action of the herbicide (50 mM in solid state cultures against 20 mM in liquid cultures) and more efficient in removing bentazon (90% removal against 55% in liquid cultures after 10 days of cultivation). Furthermore, the solid state culture filtrates were more efficient in the in vitro degradation of bentazon than the liquid culture filtrates. These observations suggest that both enzymes, laccase and Mn peroxidase, are involved in bentazon degradation. The results further suggest that solid state cultures of Ganoderma lucidum could be useful in strategies designed to reduce environmental contamination by bentazon.     

Artemisia judaica L.: micropropagation and antioxidant activity

Artemisia judaica L., an Egyptian medicinal plant used in the treatment of gastrointestinal disorders, was mass-propagated and grown using solid, paper-bridge-support liquid, liquid-flask and bioreactor cultures. The liquid-flask culture using 50 ml MS liquid medium in 250 ml flask yielded significantly greater shoot proliferation than either solid cultures or paper-bridge-support liquid cultures. Increasing flask capacity from 100 to 500 ml improved shoot proliferation and growth. Mass-propagation efficiencies of various bioreactor systems, viz. temporary immersion reactors and bubble column reactors, were also compared. The temporary immersion bioreactor was found to have significant advantages for A. judaica shoot proliferation. The shoot cultures from the temporary immersion reactor formed complete plantlets when subcultured onto a medium containing 1 micromoll(-1) indole-3-butyric acid (IBA), and mature plants were established, acclimatized and thrived in standard greenhouse conditions. Assays of antioxidant activity and total flavonoid content of in vitro and in vivo grown tissues were evaluated as gross parameters of medicinal efficacy. Significantly higher antioxidant activity and flavonoid contents were observed in the tissues of mature greenhouse-grown plants. The efficient in vitro production systems developed in this study provided sterile, consistent tissues for investigation of bioactivity and germplasm conservation of A. judaica.     

Assay and Characteristics of Circadian Rhythmicity in Liquid Cultures of Neurospora crassa

Previous work on circadian rhythms of Neurospora crassa has been done almost exclusively with cultures expressing rhythmic conidiation and growing on solid agar medium. Such conditions severely restrict the kinds of biochemical experiments that can be carried out. We have now developed systems which allow indirect assay of circadian rhythmicity in liquid culture. Neurospora was grown in glucose and acetate liquid media under conditions which result in a range of growth rates and morphologies. Liquid media were inoculated with conidia and the cultures were grown in constant light for 33 or 48 hours, by which time floating mycelial pads had formed. Experimental pieces of mycelium then were cut and placed in fresh new liquid medium. As controls, other pieces of mycelium were cut and put directly on solid agar medium in race tubes. All cultures were transferred to constant darkness at this time. This light-to-dark transition set the phase of the circadian clock of both the liquid and solid cultures. At various times after the light-to-dark transition, the mycelial pieces in the liquid were transferred in the dark to solid medium in race tubes, where they grew normally and conidiated rhythmically. Comparison of the phase of the rhythm in these race tubes to the controls demonstrated that, under appropriate conditions, the circadian clock of the liquid cultures functions normally for at least two cycles in constant conditions. Using these culture systems, a significantly greater variety of biochemical studies of circadian rhythmicity in Neurospora is now possible.     

β-Glucosidase production in agitated solid fermentation,study of its properties

Summary -Glucosidase production by Aspergillus phoenicis was studied in dynamic solid fermentation, on sugar beet pulps. The assays were conducted in agitated tank reactor which allowed for the homogenization of the medium and the regulation of essential parameters: temperature, aeration, pH and humidity.In order to compare some properties of the -glucosidase produced in both liquid and solid cultures, A. phoenicis was also grown on starch in submerged culture. The enzymes produced in solid and liquid cultures have the same optimum pH of about 4.5. -Glucosidase synthetized in solid culture is significantly more thermostable than that from liquid culture and is maximally active at 65°C compared to 60°C for enzyme from liquid culture.     

Xylanase production in solid-state fermentation: a study of its properties

Summary Xylanase production by Aspergillus niger van Tieghem was studied in solid-state cultivation. The screening of substrates was carried out in column incubators aerated with humidified air at 30°C. Results of physiological studies showed that the best yield of xylanase was 2500 U/g dry matter on a mixture of straw+bran 1:1 at 70% of moisture content.In order to compare some properties of the xylanase produced in both liquid and solid cultures, A. niger was also grown on xylan in submerged cultures. The enzymes produced in solid and liquid cultures have an optimum pH of about 3.8 and 4.5, respectively. Xylanase synthetized in solid fermentation is a little more thermostable than that from liquid culture and is maximally active at 50° C, compared to 45° C for enzyme from liquid culture.     

Production of sterigmatocystin by Aspergillus versicolor and Bipolaris sorokiniana on semisynthetic liquid and solid media.

Higher yields of sterigmatocystin were obtained with Aspergillus versicolor than with Bipolaris sorokiniana both in liquid and on solid media. The optimum temperature for sterigmatocystin production by A. versicolor was 27 to 29 degrees C and 23 degrees C for B. sorokiniana. In liquid shake cultures, production of sterigmatocystin by B. sorokiniana was negligible, whereas maximal production by A. versicolor was 210 mg/liter. On solid substrates, the highest yields (8 g/kg) were obtained with A. versicolor on still cultures of whole corn supplemented with Soytone.     

The kinetics of Lagenidium giganteum growth in liquid and solid cultures

AIMS: Production of the mosquito biolarvacide Lagenidium giganteum in solid culture has been proposed as an economic alternative to production in liquid culture because of observations of improved shelf life and efficacy upon storage. Understanding the differences between these production systems and estimating growth rate in solid culture are important for commercialization. In order to address these needs a logistic model was developed to describe the growth kinetics of L. giganteum produced in solid and liquid cultures. METHODS AND RESULTS: Kinetic parameters in the logistic model were estimated by nonlinear regression of CO2 evolution rate (CER) and biomass data from solid and liquid cultivation experiments. Lagenidium giganteum biomass was measured using DNA extracted directly from samples. The logistic model was fit to experimental biomass and CER data with low standard errors for parameter estimates. The model was validated in two independent experiments by examining prediction of biomass using on-line CER measurements. CONCLUSIONS: There were significant differences between maximum biomass density, maintenance coefficients, and specific growth rates for liquid and solid cultures. The maximum biomass density (mg dw ml-1) was 11 times greater for solid cultivation compared with liquid cultivation of L. giganteum; however, the maintenance coefficient (mg CO2 h-1 (mg dw)-1) was six times greater for liquid cultivation than in solid cultivation. The specific growth rate at 30 degrees C was approximately 30% greater in liquid cultivation compared with solid cultivation. Slower depletion of substrate and lower endogenous metabolism may explain the longer shelf life of L. giganteum produced in solid culture. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: A simple logistic model was developed which allows real-time estimation of L. giganteum biomass from on-line CER measurements. Parameter estimates for liquid and solid cultivation models also elucidated observations of longer shelf life for production in solid culture.     

Nutritional requirements of Pochonia chlamydospora and ARF18, fungal parasites of nematode eggs

Twenty carbohydrates (C), 18 nitrogen compounds (N), and 9 vitamins were examined for their effects on the growth and conidiation of the nematode-egg-parasitic fungi Arkansas Fungus 18 (ARF18, isolate 908) and Pochonia chlamydospora var. chlamydospora in solid and liquid cultures. Glycogen was the best, and inulin, D-(+)-galactose, and soluble starch were good C sources for the growth of ARF18 in both solid and liquid cultures. ARF18 could not utilize alpha-cellulose in liquid; alpha-lactose and D-mannitol in solid; and D-(+)-xylose, L-(-)-sorbose, and D-(-)-ribose in both solid and liquid cultures. Casein was the best N source for ARF18 growth in both solid and liquid cultures and L-aspartic acid, DL-glutamic acid, peptone, and L-histidine were good in solid culture. ARF18 could not utilize L-cystine and L-tyrosine in solid culture, and L-cystine, DL-methionine, peptone, L-proline, and ammonium nitrate in liquid culture. Supplement of vitamins appeared to be unnecessary for ARF18 to grow. For P. chlamydospora var. chlamydospora growth, all test C sources, except L-(-)-sorbose, alpha-cellulose, citric acid, and D-(+)-glucose, were good in both solid and liquid cultures. Most N compounds were good for P. chlamydospora var. chlamydospora growth with casein and peptone the best. Vitamins had limited effect on P. chlamydospora var. chlamydospora growth. P. chlamydospora var. chlamydospora conidiation was well supported by D-(-)-ribose, D-(-)-fructose, melibiose, and D-(+)-galactose as C sources and by L-aspartic acid, DL-glutamic acid, and L-arginine as N sources. Excluding myo-inositol from the medium containing all other test vitamins increased P. chlamydospora var. chlamydospora conidiation, while excluding pyridoxine appeared to reduce its conidiation.     

Comparative study of aflatoxins M1 and B1 production in solid-state and shaking liquid cultures

Production of aflatoxins M1 (AFM) and B1 (AFB) by Aspergillus flavus NRRL 3251 in solid-state and shaking liquid cultures using rice as the carbon source was compared. In general, solid-state cultures produced more aflatoxins than shaking liquid cultures on an equal rice weight basis. Solid-state cultures with continuous shaking yielded higher levels of toxins than those with intermittent shaking. However, intermittent shaking is a feasible replacement for the continuous shaking method for AFM production. A typical solid rice culture supplemented with yeast extract produced 30 and 2600 mg per kg rice of AFM and AFB, respectively, in 8 days at 29 degrees C. The optimal culture conditions for toxin production in a shaking liquid culture were also studied. Parameters under consideration included the amount of carbon (rice) and nitrogen source, initial medium pH, and aeration rate. At optimum conditions, a representative shaking liquid culture produced 18 and 1680 mg per kg rice of AFM and AFB, respectively, in 5 days at 29 degrees C. This shaking liquid culture appears feasible for scaling up and routine production of AFM and AFB for toxicological investigations.     

Mass Production Potential of the Bacto-Helminthic Biocontrol Complex Heterorhabditis indica - Photorhabdus luminescens

Heterorhabditis indica is a potential agent for the biological control of grubs in sugarcane fields in India. The type strain LN 2 was transferred to monoxenic cultures on its symbiont Photorhabdus luminescens and successfully produced on solid media. In liquid cultures, a mean dauer juvenile yield of 457 000 was obtained with a maximum of 648 000 per ml. Comparatively high yields have not been reported before. Therefore, costs related to the liquid culture production of H. indica will be lower than for other entomopathogenic nematodes currently used in biocontrol. Different bacterial clones had no significant influence on the dauer juvenile yields in liquid media. The exit from the dauer juvenile stage (recovery) after inoculation and the number of hermaphrodites significantly decreased when culture temperature was increased from 25-30 ° C; the dauer juvenile yields were not affected. The cell density of P. luminescens in batch cultures was higher at 25 and 30 ° C than at growth temperatures of 35 and 37 ° C. In continuous culture, the bacterial growth was inhibited when the growth temperature reached 38 ° C. After approximately 60 h, the bacteria adapted to higher temperature and the growth rate increased again. When the temperature was further increased to 40 ° C, the bacterial growth was inhibited.     

Biotransformation of (R)-(+)- and (S)-(-)-limonene by fungi and the use of solid phase microextraction for screening

The biotransformation of (R)-(-)- and (S)-(-)-limonene by fungi was investigated. More than 60 fungal cultures were screened for their ability to bioconvert the substrate, using solid phase microextraction as the monitoring technique. After screening, the best fungal strains were selected for further study and were grown as sporulated surface cultures in conical flasks and as submerged liquid cultures. It was found that (+)- and (-)-limonene were converted by Penicillium digitatum to alpha-terpineol (main metabolite), cis- and trans-p-menth-2-en-1-ol, neodihydrocarveol and limonene oxide (minor metabolites) using liquid cultures. The bioconversion of (R)-(-)- and (S)-(-)-limonene by Corwespora cassiicola yielded (1S,2S,4R)- and (1R,2R,4S)-limonene-1,2-diol respectively. The bioconversions by liquid cultures were also monitored by solid phase microextraction as a function of time. The optimum conversion of limonene to alpha-terpineol by Penicillium digitatum was obtained after 8 hours (yield up to 100%). Since an important pH-decrease was noticed in some liquid broths, the stability of limonene under acidic conditions was investigated. No acid catalysed conversion products were recovered after 8 days from control flasks at pH 3.5 containing limonene.     

Embryogenic suspension cultures of Pinus nigra Arn.: growth parameters and maturation ability

Suspension cultures have been established from embryogenic tissues of Pinus nigra initiated from immature zygotic embryos. The growth of tissues in liquid medium has been influenced by initial tissue weight used for the establishment of the cultures as well as by genotype. In most of the cases initial tissue weight 0.5 g was insufficient and the cultures showed poor growth and later degeneration. Higher amount of initial tissues (1 or 2.5 g) was more efficient for the establishment and proliferation of somatic embryos in liquid medium. The growth of suspension cultures was also cell line dependent. Somatic embryo maturation in liquid medium was very limited and no plantlet regeneration occurred. Cotyledonary somatic embryos developed and produced emblings when the suspension was plated on filter paper discs and cultured on solid maturation medium. Based on our experiments we can state that the embryogenic tissues are able to grow and proliferate in liquid medium but somatic embryo maturation and plantlet regeneration occur only on solid medium.     

Production of Fumonisins by Fusarium Verticillioides Strains on Solid and in a Defined Liquid Medium — Effects of L-Methionine and Inoculum

In order to evaluate the toxicological and carcinogenic effects of fumonisins, large amounts of fumonisins need to be purified, which requires optimal conditions for production in culture. Five strains of F. verticillioides were compared for their ability to produce fumonisins in solid and liquid media with and without the addition of methionine, a fumonisin precursor. Inoculations were made either with lyophilized cultures or a concentrated inoculum. Growth in liquid medium, measured by biomass, was directly correlated to total fumonisin production when a lyophilized inoculum was used. Fumonisin production was stimulated by the addition of 0.2% L-methionine to solid media for most strains. Levels ranged from 1500-3900 mg/kg in rice, and 2900-12500 mg/kg in maize cultures inoculated with lyophilized cultures; 200-4800 mg/kg in rice, and 1500-4200 mg/kg in maize cultures inoculated with concentrated inoculum. Strains that produced relatively high levels of fumonisins in solid media did not necessarily do so in liquid medium and vice versa. Total fumonisin levels in liquid medium ranged from 40-590 mg/l inoculated with lyophilized cultures and < 1-110 mg/l inoculated with concentrated inoculum, without adding the precursor. F. verticillioides strains therefore varied in their ability to produce fumonisins, and conditions for production need to be optimized individually for each strain.     

Effects of cultivation techniques and media on yields and morphology of the basidiomycete Armillaria mellea

Summary The yield of cell mass and the morphology of Armillaria mellea, strain ATCC 11114, was studied using a variety of cultivation methods: solid media, standing liquid culture, shake flasks, tower reactors and impeller-stirred reactors. Two different media, malt extract broth and a glucose/asparagine/peptone-medium, and the corresponding agar media, were used. Yields were higher in the malt extract media than in the glucose media. Generally the highest yields were obtained on solid media while agitated cultures gave the lowest yields. Morphological characteristics such as pellet formation, adhesion to surfaces and pigment production were significantly affected by culture conditions.     

Effect of bioreactor configuration on the growth and maturation of Picea sitchensis somatic embryo cultures

Somatic embryo suspension cultures of Picea sitchensis (Sitka spruce) derived from two cell lines, SS03 and SS10, were grown in shake flasks, air-lift, bubble, stirred tank and hanging stirrer bar bioreactors. Cell line SS03 yielded freely suspended and individual stage 1 embryos, while the embryos of SS10 were present in large aggregates. Compared to shake flasks, proliferation in bioreactors resulted in increased biomass; however, cell line morphology influenced the effect of different bioreactor configurations on growth and maturation of embryo cultures. Somatic embryos grown in shake flasks and bioreactors were matured on gelled solid medium and in submerged culture where gelled solid medium was covered with a layer of liquid medium. The number of stage 3 (mature) embryos produced from SS03 in the bubble bioreactor was significantly higher than those from stirred tank and hanging stirrer bar bioreactors with both solid medium and submerged culture. Submerged culture was unsuitable for SS10 embryo maturation. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Variability in maturation and germination from white spruce somatic embryos,as affected by age and use of solid or liquid culture

Summary The yield of morphologically normal Stage 3 somatic embryos of white spruce [Picea glauca (Moench) Voss], and subsequent germinability, was affected by culture age and use of solid and/or liquid culture growth conditions. Of the conditions that were compared, best results were obtained with cultures up to 3 yr old that had been continuously grown in liquid medium. Such material yielded up to 374 morphologically normal Stage 3 embryos per g f. wt. inoculum, when routinely pretreated using a 1 wk 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid-free period before maturation. By comparison the continual use of solid culture conditions resulted in lower yields (5/g f. wt. inoculum), and the use of solid medium in combination with liquid medium showed a greater affect of age on the production of normal Stage 3 embryos (348/g f. wt at 1.5 yr down to 19/g f. wt. at 3 yr) over the age range tested. In the absence of culture pretreatment, the oldest liquid cultures yielded only 44 normal Stage 3 embryos/g f. wt. inoculum, and the comparable solid to liquid cultures yielded 1.3/g f. wt. inoculum. The number of aberrant Stage 3 embryos in older cultures was reduced as a result of culture pretreatment; for example, in the oldest liquid cultures these represented 83% of the Stage 3 embryo population without pretreatment and 45% with pretreatment. Normal Stage 3 somatic embryo yield and germination characteristics (radicle and epicotyl development) were informative in distinguishing among the conditions studied. Germination characteristics were especially important when maturation responses were incapable of distinguishing among age classes. NRCC Contribution no. 38462.     

Vitrification of carnation in vitro: Changes in ethylene production,ACC level and capacity to convert ACC to ethylene

Carnation tissue was allowed to vitrify in liquid culture and ethylene production, ACC content and capacity to convert ACC to ethylene were measured in comparison to tissue developing normally on solid medium. Flask atmospheres of liquid cultures accumulated ethylene at a higher rate during the first four days. Daily ethylene production by vitrifying material decreased later. Ethylene emission by vitrifying tissues always remained above controls when subcultured daily to fresh medium. Explants and microsomal preparations from vitrifying carnations converted ACC to ethylene at a higher degree from the first day in liquid medium. ACC level markedly increased in vitrifying tissues during the first two days of liquid culture. Raising the level of ethylene in the atmosphere of solid cultures did not induce vitrification symptoms nor did use of inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis in liquid cultures prevent the process. The role of ethylene in vitrification is reappraised.