Specific inhibition of estrogen receptor alpha function by antisense oligodeoxyribonucleotides

We have tested the effect of a range of antisense oligodeoxyribonucleotides (ODN) directed against the human estrogen receptor alpha (ERalpha) on ERalpha protein expression and function. Antisense ERalpha ODN transfected into the ERalpha-positive human breast carcinoma cell line MCF7-K2 showed variable responses dependent on the oligo used. The most active antisense ODN (oligo 7) decreased the levels of ERa protein by 61% as measured by Western blot analysis. Exogenous 17beta-estradiol (17beta-E2), but not 17alpha-E2, augmented this effect, with a threshold effect at 10(-8) M 17beta-E2. The inhibitory effect of antisense ERa oligo 7 was confirmed by measurement of functional ERalpha protein. 3H-17beta-E2 binding to MCF7 cell extracts was inhibited to approximately 40% of control values in the presence of oligo 7. Antisense-transfected MCF7-K2 cell cultures produced a further 30% binding reduction in the presence of exogenous 17beta-E2. An inhibitory effect on 17beta-E2-dependent cell function was confirmed by the demonstration that ERalpha oligo 7-transfected MCF7-K2 cells failed to exhibit 17beta-E2-stimulated cell proliferation. Exogenous 17beta-E2 enhanced the inhibitory effect of the antisense ODN by increasing ODN transfection efficiency but without ERalpha catabolism via the proteosomal pathway, suggesting an effect of 17beta-E2 on the plasma membrane and the existence of different ERalpha degradation pathways in the MCF7-K2 cell subclone. As 17beta-E2 had no effect on ERalpha protein degradation, we conclude that the observed reduction of ERalpha protein levels is due solely to the presence of the antisense ERalpha ODN. Antisense ERalpha ODN molecules, therefore, may form the basis of effective therapies against ERalpha-dependent malignancies.     

Comparative inhibition of rabbit globin mRNA translation by modified antisense oligodeoxynucleotides.

We have studied the translation of rabbit globin mRNA in cell free systems (reticulocyte lysate and wheat germ extract) and in microinjected Xenopus oocytes in the presence of anti-sense oligodeoxynucleotides. Results obtained with the unmodified all-oxygen compounds were compared with those obtained when phosphorothioate or alpha-DNA was used. In the wheat germ system a 17-mer sequence targeted to the coding region of beta-globin mRNA was specifically inhibitory when either the unmodified phosphodiester oligonucleotide or its phosphorothioate analogue were used. In contrast no effect was observed with the alpha-oligomer. These results were ascribed to the fact that phosphorothioate oligomers elicit an RNase-H activity comparable to the all-oxygen congeners, while alpha-DNA/mRNA hybrids were a poor substrate. Microinjected Xenopus oocytes followed a similar pattern. The phosphorothioate oligomer was more efficient to prevent translation than the unmodified 17-mer. Inhibition of beta-globin synthesis was observed in the nanomolar concentration range. This result can be ascribed to the nuclease resistance of phosphorothioates as compared to natural phosphodiester linkages, alpha-oligomers were devoid of any inhibitory effect up to 30 microM. Phosphorothioate oligodeoxyribonucleotides were shown to be non-specific inhibitors of protein translation, at concentrations in the micromolar range, in both cell-free systems and oocytes. Non-specific inhibition of translation was dependent on the length of the phosphorothioate oligomer. These non-specific effects were not observed with the unmodified or the alpha-oligonucleotides.     

RNase H is responsible for the non-specific inhibition of in vitro translation by 2'-O-alkyl chimeric oligonucleotides: high affinity or selectivity, a dilemma to design antisense oligomers.

Ribonuclease H (RNase H) which recognizes and cleaves the RNA strand of mismatched RNA-DNA heteroduplexes can induce non-specific effects of antisense oligonucleotides. In a previous paper [Larrouy et al. (1992), Gene, 121, 189-194], we demonstrated that ODN1, a phosphodiester 15mer targeted to the AUG initiation region of alpha-globin mRNA, inhibited non-specifically beta-globin synthesis in wheat germ extract due to RNase H-mediated cleavage of beta-globin mRNA. Specificity was restored by using MP-ODN2, a methylphosphonate-phosphodiester sandwich analogue of ODN1, which limited RNase H activity on non-perfect hybrids. We report here that 2'-O-alkyl RNA-phosphodiester DNA sandwich analogues of ODN1, with the same phosphodiester window as MP-ODN2, are non-specific inhibitors of globin synthesis in wheat germ extract, whatever the substituent (methyl, allyl or butyl) on the 2'-OH. These sandwich oligomers induced the cleavage of non-target beta-globin RNA sites, similarly to the unmodified parent oligomer ODN1. This is likely due to the increased affinity of 2'-O-alkyl-ODN2 chimeric oligomers for both fully and partly complementary RNA, compared to MP-ODN2. In contrast, the fully modified 2'-O-methyl analogue of ODN1 was a very effective and highly specific antisense sequence. This was ascribed to its inability (i) to induce RNA cleavage by RNase H and (ii) to physically prevent the elongation of the polypeptide chain.     

Covalently attached oligodeoxyribonucleotides induce RNase activity of a short peptide and modulate its base specificity

New artificial ribonucleases, conjugates of short oligodeoxyribonucleotides with peptides containing alternating arginine and leucine, were synthesized and characterized in terms of their catalytic activity and specificity of RNA cleavage. The conjugates efficiently cleave different RNAs within single-stranded regions. Depending on the sequence and length of the oligonucleotide, the conjugates display either G–X>>Pyr–A or Pyr–A>>G–X cleavage specificity. Preferential RNA cleavage at G–X phosphodiester bonds was observed for conjugate NH₂-Gly-[ArgLeu]₄-CCAAACA. The conjugates function as true catalysts, exhibiting reaction turnover up to 175 for 24 h. Our data show that in the conjugate the oligonucleotide plays the role of a factor which provides an ‘active‘ conformation of the peptide via intramolecular interactions, and that it is the peptide residue itself which is responsible for substrate affinity and catalysis.     

Studies on antisense inhibition of translation in vitro. Anomalies and re-evaluation.

Experiments were carried out to better characterize antisense control of translation. Results in an E. coli system confirmed specific inhibition of poly(U) translation. At low concentrations, certain homopolymers (including poly(rA)) stimulated translation. Oligo(dA(n)) was inhibitory at n less than or equal to 8. Translation of globin mRNA in reticulocyte lysates indicated that ssDNA 15-mers targeted at beta-globin mRNA inhibited both alpha- and beta-globin production. Sequences targeted immediately downstream of the AUG were the least effective in inhibition. These and other anomalies are discussed here in relation to those of others, emphasizing caution in performing antisense experiments.     

alpha-DNA. VI: Comparative study of alpha- and beta-anomeric oligodeoxyribonucleotides in hybridization to mRNA and in cell free translation inhibition.

alpha and beta-anomeric d(G2T12G2) oligodeoxyribonucleotides were compared for their hybridization to rA12: the observed melting temperatures are 27 degrees C for beta-oligodeoxyribonucleotide/RNA hybrid and 53 degrees C for alpha-oligodeoxyribonucleotide/RNA. alpha-oligonucleotides with the four bases, complementary to natural mRNAs, were synthesized for the first time, labeled at their 5'-end with [32P] and used as probes in Northern blot experiments. In spite of these higher affinities for their target RNA's, they were unable to block translation of natural or synthetic mRNA's in rabbit reticulocyte lysate. We have studied the RNase H activity on model rA12:alpha- or beta-d(G2T12G2) hybrids or on mRNA:alpha- or beta-oligonucleotides hybrids. Specific hybridization protects RNA strech when using alpha-oligonucleotides but not beta-oligonucleotides. Thus, our results show the inability of RNase H to degrade RNA in alpha-oligodeoxyribonucleotides:RNA duplexes.     

Glycation of amino groups in protein. Studies on the specificity of modification of RNase by glucose

Ribonuclease A has been used as a model protein for studying the specificity of glycation of amino groups in protein under physiological conditions (phosphate buffer, pH 7.4, 37 degrees C). Incubation of RNase with glucose led to an enhanced rate of inactivation of the enzyme relative to the rate of modification of lysine residues, suggesting preferential modification of active site lysine residues. Sites of glycation of RNase were identified by amino acid analysis of tryptic peptides isolated by reverse-phase high pressure liquid chromatography and phenylboronate affinity chromatography. Schiff base adducts were trapped with Na-BH3CN and the alpha-amino group of Lys-1 was identified as the primary site (80-90%) of initial Schiff base formation on RNase. In contrast, Lys-41 and Lys-7 in the active site accounted for about 38 and 29%, respectively, of ketoamine adducts formed via the Amadori rearrangement. Other sites reactive in ketoamine formation included N alpha-Lys-1 (15%), N epsilon-Lys-1 (9%), and Lys-37 (9%) which are adjacent to acidic amino acids. The remaining six lysine residues in RNase, which are located on the surface of the protein, were relatively inactive in forming either the Schiff base or Amadori adduct. Both the equilibrium Schiff base concentration and the rate of the Amadori rearrangement at each site were found to be important in determining the specificity of glycation of RNase.     

Selective modification of cytosines in oligodeoxyribonucleotides.

A single deoxycytidine residing in an oligodeoxyribonucleotide which also contains 5-methyldeoxycytidines can be selectively derivatized with various alkylamines by sodium bisulfite-catalyzed transamination. Selective transamination results because 5-methylcytosine, unlike cytosine, does not form a bisulfite adduct. When the reaction is carried out at pH 7.1, transamination in the oligomer appears to occur to greater than 95% with little or no deamination. This procedure has been used to introduce aminoalkyl or carboxyalkyl side chains at the N4-position of a deoxycytidine in oligonucleotides. These side chains contain potentially reactive amine or carboxy groups which could serve as a sites for further conjugation of the oligomer with a variety functional groups. Oligonucleotides which carry these side chain form duplexes and triplexes with appropriate complementary single-stranded or double-stranded oligodeoxyribonucleotide target molecules. The stabilities of the duplexes are similar to those formed by unmodified oligomers, whereas the stability of the triplexes is approximately 18 degrees C lower than that formed by unmodified oligomers.     

Increased specificity for antisense oligodeoxynucleotide targeting of RNA cleavage by RNase H using chimeric methylphosphonodiester/phosphodiester structures.

One of the inherent problems in the use of antisense oligodeoxynucleotides to ablate gene expression in cell cultures is that the stringency of hybridization in vivo is not subject to control and may be sub-optimal. Consequently, phosphodiester or phosphorothioate antisense effectors and non-targeted cellular RNA may form partial hybrids which are substrates for RNase H. Such processes could promote the sequence dependent inappropriate effects recently reported in the literature. We have attempted to resolve this problem by using chimeric methylphosphonodiester/phosphodiester oligodeoxynucleotides. In contrast to the extensive RNA degradation observed with all-phosphodiester oligodeoxynucleotides, highly modified chimeric antisense effectors displayed negligible, or undetectable, cleavage at non-target sites without significantly impaired activity at the target site. We also note that all of the all-phosphodiester oligodeoxynucleotides tested demonstrated inappropriate effects, and that such undesirable activity could vary widely between different sequences.     

Inhibition of plasminogen activator inhibitor release in endothelial cell cultures by antisense oligodeoxyribonucleotides with a 5'-end lipophilic modification

A series of conjugates containing residues of lipophilic alcohols covalently bound to 5' end of oligodeoxyribonucleotides targeted against human plasminogen activator inhibitor (PAI-1) mRNA was synthesized via the oxathiaphospholane approach. The highest anti-PAI-1 activity in EA.hy 926 endothelial cell cultures was found for conjugates containing menthyl or heptadecanyl groups linked with an oligonucleotide complementary to a segment of human PAI-1 mRNA. The phosphodiester antisense oligonucleotides, which otherwise exhibit only limited anti-PAI-1 activity, were found to be more active than phosphorothioate oligonucleotides when conjugated to lipophilic alcohol residues. For menthyl conjugates an evidence of antisense mechanism of inhibition was found.     

A theoretical approach to select effective antisense oligodeoxyribonucleotides at high statistical probability.

Up to now, out of approximately 20 antisense oligodeoxyribonucleotides (as ODN) selected and tested against a given target gene, only one species shows substantial suppression of target gene expression. In part, this seems to be related to the general assumption that the structures of local target sequences or antisense nucleic acids are unfavorable for efficient annealing. Experimental approaches to find effective as ODN are extremely expensive when including a large number of antisense species and when considering their moderate success. Here, we make use of a systematic alignment of computer-predicted secondary structures of local sequence stretches of the target RNA and of semi-empirical rules to identify favorable local target sequences and, hence, to design more effective as ODN. The intercellular adhesion molecule 1 (ICAM-1) gene was chosen as a target because it had been shown earlier to be sensitive to antisense-mediated gene suppression. By applying the protocol described here, 10 ICAM-1-directed as ODN species were found that showed substantially improved inhibition of target gene expression in the endothelial cell line ECV304 when compared with the most effective published as ODN. Further, 17 out of 34 antisense species (50%) selected on the theoretical basis described here showed significant (>50%) inhibition of ICAM-1 expression in mammalian cells.     

The cleavage specificity of RNase III.

We determined sites in lambda cII mRNA that are cleaved by RNase III in the presence of lambda OOP antisense RNA, using a series of OOP RNAs with different internal deletions. In OOP RNA-cII mRNA structures containing a potential region of continuous double-stranded RNA bounded by a non-complementary unpaired region, RNase III cleaved the cII mRNA at one or more preferred sites located 10 to 14 bases from the 3'-end of the region of continuous complementarity. Cleavage patterns were almost identical when the presumptive structure was the same continuously double-stranded region followed by a single-stranded bulge and a second short region of base pairing. The sequences of the new cleavage sites show generally good agreement with a consensus sequence derived from thirty-five previously determined cleavage sequences. In contrast, four 'non-sites' at which cleavage is never observed show poor agreement with this consensus sequence. We conclude that RNase III specificity is determined both by the distance from the end of continuous pairing and by nucleotide sequence features within the region of pairing.     

Target-specific arrest of mRNA translation by antisense 2'-O-alkyloligoribonucleotides.

We describe a novel experimental approach to investigate mRNA translation. Antisense 2'-O-allyl oligoribonucleotides (oligos) efficiently arrest translation of targeted mRNAs in rabbit reticulocyte lysate and wheat germ extract while displaying minimal non-specific effects on translation. Oligo/mRNA-hybrids positioned anywhere within the 5' UTR or the first approximately 20 nucleotides of the open reading frame block cap-dependent translation initiation with high specificity. The thermodynamic stability of hybrids between 2'-O-alkyl oligos and RNA permits translational inhibition with oligos as short as 10 nucleotides. This inhibition is independent of RNase H cleavage or modifications which render the mRNA untranslatable. We show that 2'-O-alkyl oligos can also be employed to interfere with cap-independent internal initiation of translation and to arrest translation elongation. The latter is accomplished by UV-crosslinking of psoralen-tagged 2'-O-methyloligoribonucleotides to the mRNA within the open reading frame. The utility of 2'-O-alkyloligoribonucleotides to arrest translation from defined positions within an mRNA provides new approaches to investigate mRNA translation.     

The translation start codon region is sensitive to antisense PNA inhibition in Escherichia coli

Antisense peptide nucleic acids (PNA) can inhibit bacterial gene expression with gene and sequence specificity. Using attached carrier peptides that aid cell permeation, the antisense effects when targeting essential genes are sufficient to prevent growth and even kill bacteria. However, many design uncertainties remain, including the difficult question of target sequence selection. In this study, we synthesized 90 antisense peptide-PNAs to target sequences in a head to tail manner across the entire length of the mRNA encoding beta-lactamase. The results from this scan pointed to the start codon region as most sensitive to inhibition. To confirm and refine the result, a higher-resolution scan was conducted over the start codon region of the beta-lactamase gene and the essential Escherichia coli acpP gene. For both genes, the start codon region, including the Shine-Dalgarno motif, was sensitive, whereas antisense agents targeted outside of this region were largely ineffective. These results are in accord with natural antisense mechanisms, which typically hinder the start codon region, and the sensitivity of this region should hold true for most bacterial genes as well as for other RNase H-independent antisense agents that rely on a steric blocking mechanism. Therefore, although other design parameters are also important, the start codon region in E. coli mRNA is the most reliable target site for antisense PNAs.