Mitochondrial DNA mutations as a fundamental mechanism in physiological declines associated with aging

The hypothesis that mitochondrial DNA damage accumulates and contributes to aging was proposed decades ago. Only recently have technological advancements, which facilitate microanalysis of single cells or portions of cells, revealed that mtDNA deletion mutations and, perhaps, single nucleotide mutations accumulate to physiologically relevant levels in the tissues of various species with age. Although a link between single nucleotide mutations and physiological consequences in aging tissue has not been established, the accumulation of deletion mutations in skeletal muscle fibres has been associated with sarcopenia. Different, and apparently random, deletion mutations are specific to individual fibres. However, the mtDNA deletion mutation within a phenotypically abnormal region of a fibre is the same, suggesting a selection, amplification and clonal expansion of the initial deletion mutation. mtDNA deletion mutations within a muscle fibre are associated with specific electron transport system abnormalities, muscle fibre atrophy and fibre breakage. These data point to a causal relationship between mitochondrial DNA mutations and the age-related loss of muscle mass.     

Mitochondrial DNA deletion mutations: a causal role in sarcopenia.

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) deletion mutations accumulate with age in tissues of a variety of species. Although the relatively low calculated abundance of these deletion mutations in whole tissue homogenates led some investigators to suggest that these mutations do not have any physiological impact, their focal and segmental accumulation suggests that they can, and do, accumulate to levels sufficient to affect the metabolism of a tissue. This phenomenon is most clearly demonstrated in skeletal muscle, where the accumulation of mtDNA deletion mutations remove critical subunits that encode for the electron transport system (ETS). In this review, we detail and provide evidence for a molecular basis of muscle fiber loss with age. Our data suggest that the mtDNA deletion mutations, which are generated in tissues with age, cause muscle fiber loss. Within a fiber, the process begins with a mtDNA replication error, an error that results in a loss of 25-80% of the mitochondrial genome. This smaller genome is replicated and, through a process not well understood, eventually comprises the majority of mtDNA within the small affected region of the muscle fiber. The preponderance of the smaller genomes results in a dysfunctional ETS in the affected area. As a consequence of both the decline in energy production and the increase in oxidative damage in the region, the fiber is no longer capable of self-maintenance, resulting in the observed intrafiber atrophy and fiber breakage. We are therefore proposing that a process contained within a very small region of a muscle fiber can result in breakage and loss of muscle fiber from the tissue.     

Construction of transgenic mice with tissue-specific acceleration of mitochondrial DNA mutagenesis

Transgenic mice having rapid accumulation of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations specifically in the heart were created. These mice contained a transgene encoding a proofreading-deficient, mouse mitochondrial DNA polymerase (pol gamma) driven by the promoter for the cardiac-specific alpha-myosin heavy chain. Starting shortly after birth greater than 95% of all pol gamma mRNA in the heart was transgene derived; expression in other tissues was low or absent. Mutations in cardiac mtDNA began to accumulate by 7 days after birth. At 1 month of age the frequency of point mutations was 0.014% as determined by DNA sequencing of cloned mtDNA. By long-extension PCR multiple different deletion mutations that had removed several thousand basepairs of genomic sequence were also detected. Sequencing of two deletion molecules showed that one was flanked at the breakpoint by direct repeat sequences. The expression of proofreading-deficient pol gamma had no apparent deleterious effect on mitochondrial DNA and protein content, gene expression, or respiratory function. However, associated with the rise in mtDNA mutation levels was the development of cardiomyopathy as evidenced by enlarged hearts in the transgenic mice. These mice may prove to be useful models to study the pathogenic effects of elevated levels of mitochondrial DNA mutations in specific tissues.     

Mitochondrial DNA deletion mutations in adult mouse cardiac side population cells

We investigated the presence and potential role of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) deletion mutations in adult cardiac stem cells. Cardiac side population (SP) cells were isolated from 12-week-old mice. Standard polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was used to screen for the presence of mtDNA deletion mutations in (a) freshly isolated SP cells and (b) SP cells cultured to passage 10. When present, the abundance of mtDNA deletion mutation was analyzed in single cell colonies. The effect of different levels of deletion mutations on SP cell growth and differentiation was determined. MtDNA deletion mutations were found in both freshly isolated and cultured cells from 12-week-old mice. While there was no significant difference in the number of single cell colonies with mtDNA deletion mutations from any of the groups mentioned above, the abundance of mtDNA deletion mutations was significantly higher in the cultured cells, as determined by quantitative PCR. Within a single clonal cell population, the detectable mtDNA deletion mutations were the same in all cells and unique when compared to deletions of other colonies. We also found that cells harboring high levels of mtDNA deletion mutations (i.e. where deleted mtDNA comprised more than 60% of total mtDNA) had slower proliferation rates and decreased differentiation capacities. Screening cultured adult stem cells for mtDNA deletion mutations as a routine assessment will benefit the biomedical application of adult stem cells.     

Contribution of common deletion to total deletion burden in mitochondrial DNA from inner ear of d-galactose-induced aging rats

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations, especially deletions, have been suggested to play an important role in aging and degenerative diseases. In particular, the common deletion in humans and rats (4977bp and 4834bp deletion, respectively) has been shown to accumulate with age in post-mitotic tissues with high energetic demands. Among numerous deletions, the common deletion has been proposed to serve as a molecular marker for aging and play a critical role in presbyacusis. However, so far no previous publication has quantified the contribution of common deletion to the total burden of mtDNA deletions in tissues during aging process. In the present study, we established a rat model with various degrees of aging in inner ear induced by three different doses of d-galactose (d-gal) administration. Firstly, multiple mtDNA deletions in inner ear were detected by nested PCR and long range PCR. In addition to the common deletion, three novel mtDNA deletions were identified. All four deletions, located in the major arc of mtDNA, are flanked by direct repeats and involve the cytochrome c oxidase (COX) subunit III gene, encoded by mtDNA. Additionally, absolute quantitative real-time PCR assay was used to detect the level of common deletion and total deletion burden of mtDNA. The quantitative data show that the common deletion is the most frequent type of mtDNA deletions, exceeding 67.86% of the total deletion burden. Finally, increased mtDNA copy number, reduced COX activity and mosaic ultrastructural impairments in inner ear were identified in d-gal-induced aging rats. The increase of mtDNA replication may contribute to the accelerated accumulation of mtDNA deletions, which may result in impairment of mitochondrial function in inner ear. Taken together, these findings suggest that the common deletion may serve as an ideal molecular marker to assess the mtDNA damage in inner ear during aging.     

Latent mitochondrial DNA deletion mutations drive muscle fiber loss at old age

With age, somatically derived mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) deletion mutations arise in many tissues and species. In skeletal muscle, deletion mutations clonally accumulate along the length of individual fibers. At high intrafiber abundances, these mutations disrupt individual cell respiration and are linked to the activation of apoptosis, intrafiber atrophy, breakage, and necrosis, contributing to fiber loss. This sequence of molecular and cellular events suggests a putative mechanism for the permanent loss of muscle fibers with age. To test whether mtDNA deletion mutation accumulation is a significant contributor to the fiber loss observed in aging muscle, we pharmacologically induced deletion mutation accumulation. We observed a 1200% increase in mtDNA deletion mutation‐containing electron transport chain‐deficient muscle fibers, an 18% decrease in muscle fiber number and 22% worsening of muscle mass loss. These data affirm the hypothesized role for mtDNA deletion mutation in the etiology of muscle fiber loss at old age.     

The low abundance of clonally expanded mitochondrial DNA point mutations in aged substantia nigra neurons

Clonally expanded mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) deletions accumulate with age in human substantia nigra (SN) and high levels cause respiratory chain deficiency. In other human tissues, mtDNA point mutations clonally expand with age. Here, the abundance of mtDNA point mutations within single SN neurons from aged controls was investigated. From 31 single cytochrome c oxidase normal SN neurons, only one clonally expanded mtDNA point mutation was identified, suggesting in these neurons mtDNA point mutations occur rarely, whereas mtDNA deletions are frequently observed. This contrasts observations in mitotic tissues and suggests that different forms of mtDNA maintenance may exist in these two cell types.     

Oxidative damage elicited by imbalance of free radical scavenging enzymes is associated with large-scale mtDNA deletions in aging human skin

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations and impaired respiratory function have been demonstrated in various tissues of aged individuals. We hypothesized that age-dependent increase of ROS and free radicals production in mitochondria is associated with the accumulation of large-scale mtDNA deletions. In this study, we first confirmed that the proportion of mtDNA with the 4977 bp deletion in human skin tissues increases with age. We then investigated the 8-hydroxy-2'-deoxyguanosine (8-OH-dG) content in skin tissues and lipid peroxides content of the skin fibroblasts from subjects of different ages. The results showed an age-dependent increase of 8-OH-dG level in the total DNA of skin tissues of the subjects above the age of 60 years. The specific content of malondialdehyde, an end product of lipid peroxidation, was also found to increase with age. On the other hand, we examined the enzyme activities of Cu, Zn-superoxide dismutase (Cu,Zn-SOD), Mn-superoxide dismutase (Mn-SOD), catalase, and glutathione peroxidase (GPx) in the skin fibroblasts. The activities of Cu,Zn-SOD, catalase and glutathione peroxidase were found to decrease with age. However, the activity of Mn-SOD was increased with age before 60 years but was decreased thereafter. Moreover, the activity ratios of Mn-SOD/catalase and Mn-SOD/GPx exhibited the same pattern of change with age. This indicates that free radical scavenging enzymes can effectively dispose of ROS and free radicals before 60 years of age. However, elevated oxidative stress caused by an imbalance between the production and removal of ROS and free radicals occurred in skin fibroblasts after 60 years of age. Taken together, we suggest that the functional decline of free radical scavenging enzymes and the elevation of oxidative stress may play an important role in eliciting oxidative damage and mutation of mtDNA during the human aging process.     

Detection of mitochondrial DNA deletions in the cochlea and its structural elements from archival human temporal bone tissue

Large-scale deletions of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) have been associated with aging and disease in post-mitotic tissues. These post-mitotic tissues, including skeletal muscle, heart and brain, are heavily dependent on intact functional mitochondria. The cochlear tissues are known to contain an abundance of mitochondria. This observation stimulated a search for mtDNA deletions in the cochlea and its elements using a sensitive nested PCR methodology and long range PCR to explain the functional deficits observed in age-related hearing loss. The presence of the so-called “common” deletion (CD) was detected in cochlear tissue from two individuals with age-related hearing loss, 73 and 78 years of age. Three additional deletions, that to our knowledge have not been previously reported, were also identified in these two individuals, including a 5354 bp deletion flanked with a 3 bp repeat, a 9682 bp deletion flanked by a 10 bp repeat and a 5142 bp deletion without a flanking repeat. The 9682 and 5142 bp deletions were also detected in an individual 39 years of age with normal hearing, however, these two deletions were not detected in a normal hearing individual 9 years of age. In contrast, the 5354 bp deletion was detected in all four of the individuals studied. To localize the deletions within the cochlea, the cochlear elements were removed by laser capture microdissection (LCM) and the mtDNA from these tissues was studied. The 5142 and 5354 bp deletions were detected in the organ of corti, spiral ligament, and ganglion cells, but not in the stria vascularis. These findings correlate with the reduction in the number of spiral ganglion cells and outer hair cells, and the normal stria vascularis volume observed in this individual. All four of these deletions involve the cytochrome c oxidase (COX) subunit III gene, encoded by mtDNA. These observations suggest that multiple mtDNA deletions may contribute to a deficit in mitochondrial function in the cochlea and result in hearing loss if a level of physiological significance is reached.     

Age-associated oxygen damage and mutations in mitochondrial DNA in human hearts.

Some mutations in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) causing a number of neuromuscular diseases are suggested to arise spontaneously during the life of an individual. To substantiate the extent and the rate of these somatic mutations, mtDNA specimens from post-mortem human heart muscles of subjects in differing age groups were hydrolyzed. 8-Hydroxy-deoxyguanosine (8-OH-dG), a hydroxyl-radical adduct of deoxyguanosine, in mtDNA, was quantitatively determined using a micro high-performance liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry system. In each specimen, the mtDNA with a 7.4 kilo base-pair deletion was quantified by the kinetic polymerase chain reaction method. In association with age, the 8-OH-dG content accumulated exponentially up to 1.5% with a correlative increase in the content of the deleted mtDNA up to 7%. Clear correlation between the 8-OH-dG content in mtDNA and the population of mtDNA with a deletion (r = 0.93, P < 0.01) gives insight into the mechanism for the generation of a large deletion. These results indicate that accumulation of somatically acquired oxygen damage together with age-associated mutations in mtDNA which lead to bioenergetic deficiency and the heart muscle weakness are inevitable in human life.     

Nucleotide sequence identity of mitochondrial DNA from different human tissues

Recombinant DNA techniques have been used to search for mitochondrial (mt) nucleotide (nt) sequence differences between human tissues within an individual. mtDNA isolated from brain, heart, liver, kidney, and skeletal muscle of two different individuals was cleaved with SacI and XbaI, and then cloned in bacteriophage M13. Partial nt sequence determination of 121 independently isolated recombinant M13 clones containing either the cytochrome oxidase subunit III gene or the D-loop region of human mtDNA revealed base substitution differences between individuals, and between each individual and the published human mtDNA sequence. A majority of these base substitutions were transitions. No systematic nt sequence differences were identified between tissues within an individual, however. These results suggest that mtDNA sequence alterations do not accompany organogenesis, and that somatic mutations do not accumulate in the mtDNA of different human tissues to a level of greater than one nt substitution per molecule.     

Mitochondrial DNA alterations as ageing-associated molecular events.

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) is a naked double-stranded circular extrachromosomal genetic element continuously exposed to the matrix that contains great amounts of reactive oxygen species and free radicals. The age-dependent decline in the capability and capacity of mitochondria to dispose these oxy-radicals will render mtDNA more vulnerable to mutations during the ageing process. During the past 3 years, more than 10 different types of deletions have been identified in the mtDNA of various tissues of old humans. Some of them were found only in a certain tissue but some others appeared in more than one organ or tissue. The 4977-bp deletion is the most prevalent and abundant one among these deletions. Skeletal muscle is the target tissue of most ageing-associated mtDNA deletions and has often been found to carry multiple deletions. The onset age of the various deletions in mtDNA varies greatly with individual and type of the deletion. The 4977-bp deletion has been independently demonstrated to occur in the mtDNA of various tissues of the human in the early third decade of life. However, the 7436-bp deletion was only detected in the heart mtDNA of human subjects in their late thirties. The others appeared only in older humans over 40 years old. No apparent sex difference was found in the onset age of these ageing-associated mtDNA deletions. The various ageing-associated deletions could be classified into two groups. Most of the deletions belong to the first group, in which the 5'- and 3'-end breakpoints of the deletion are flanked by 4-bp or longer direct repeats. The deletion in the second group occurs less frequently and shows no distinct repeat sequences flanking the deletion sites. These two groups of mtDNA deletions may occur by different mechanisms. The first group is most probably caused by internal recombination or slippage mispairing during replication of mtDNA by the D-loop mechanism. The deleted mtDNA and the deleted DNA fragment may be further degraded or escape from the mitochondria and get translocated into the nucleus. The latter route has been substantiated by many observations of inserted mtDNA sequences in the nuclear DNA. Thus, the fragments of migrating mtDNA may change the information content and expression level of certain nuclear genes and thereby promote the ageing process or cause cancer. Similar ageing-associated alterations of mtDNA have also been observed in aged animals and plants. I suggest that mtDNA deletions and other mutations to be discovered are molecular events generally associated with the ageing process.     

Nanopore sequencing identifies a higher frequency and expanded spectrum of mitochondrial DNA deletion mutations in human aging

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) deletion mutations cause many human diseases and are linked to age-induced mitochondrial dysfunction. Mapping the mutation spectrum and quantifying mtDNA deletion mutation frequency is challenging with next-generation sequencing methods. We hypothesized that long-read sequencing of human mtDNA across the lifespan would detect a broader spectrum of mtDNA rearrangements and provide a more accurate measurement of their frequency. We employed nanopore Cas9-targeted sequencing (nCATS) to map and quantitate mtDNA deletion mutations and develop analyses that are fit-for-purpose. We analyzed total DNA from vastus lateralis muscle in 15 males ranging from 20 to 81 years of age and substantia nigra from three 20-year-old and three 79-year-old men. We found that mtDNA deletion mutations detected by nCATS increased exponentially with age and mapped to a wider region of the mitochondrial genome than previously reported. Using simulated data, we observed that large deletions are often reported as chimeric alignments. To address this, we developed two algorithms for deletion identification which yield consistent deletion mapping and identify both previously reported and novel mtDNA deletion breakpoints. The identified mtDNA deletion frequency measured by nCATS correlates strongly with chronological age and predicts the deletion frequency as measured by digital PCR approaches. In substantia nigra, we observed a similar frequency of age-related mtDNA deletions to those observed in muscle samples, but noted a distinct spectrum of deletion breakpoints. NCATS-mtDNA sequencing allows the identification of mtDNA deletions on a single-molecule level, characterizing the strong relationship between mtDNA deletion frequency and chronological aging.     

Mitochondrial DNA mutations in the parotid gland of cigarette smokers and non-smokers

It has previously been demonstrated that mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations accumulate in the lung and increase in frequency with age. It has also been shown that the level of mtDNA mutations including deletions and base substitutions are elevated in lung tissue of smokers relative to non-smokers. We have previously shown that the 'common' 4977 bp mtDNA deletion is present in the parotid (salivary) gland of smokers and non-smokers and that there is a significant increase in the level of this deletion in Warthins tumour, an oncocytoma of the parotid gland. In this study we used semi-quantitative PCR to confirm the presence of 4977 bp mtDNA deletion in the parotid gland of non-smokers and smokers. Importantly, we show that the deletion accumulates with age regardless of smoking status and that there was no significant difference in the level of the 4977 bp deletion in parotid tissue of smokers and non-smokers. Using strand conformational polymorphism (SSCP) and direct sequencing we also found 5/23 smokers had parotid tissue specific base substitutions: either an A/T to G/C transition at A4767 or a G/C to A/T transition at G4853. These results are evidence of age related increase in the 4977 bp deletion and a higher level of mutations, probably due to oxidative damage, in the parotid gland of smokers.     

Evidence that specific mtDNA point mutations may not accumulate in skeletal muscle during normal human aging.

It is unclear at present whether specific mtDNA point mutations accumulate during normal human aging. In order to address this question, we used quantitative PCR of total DNA isolated from skeletal muscle from normal individuals of various ages to search for the presence and amount of spontaneous mtDNA point mutations in two small regions of the human mitochondrial genome. We observed low levels of somatic mutations above background in both regions, but there was no correlation between the amount of mutation detected and the age of the subject. These results contrasted with our finding of an age-related increase in the amount of the mtDNA "common deletion" in these very samples. Thus, it appears that both somatic mtDNA point mutations and mtDNA deletions can arise at low frequency in normal individuals but that, unlike deletions, there is no preferential amplification or accumulation of specific point mutations in skeletal muscle over the course of the normal human life span.     

Multi-organ characterization of mitochondrial genomic rearrangements in ad libitum and caloric restricted mice show striking somatic mitochondrial DNA rearrangements with age.

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) rearrangements have been shown to accumulate with age in the post-mitotic tissues of a variety of animals and have been hypothesized to result in the age-related decline of mitochondrial bioenergetics leading to tissue and organ failure. Caloric restriction in rodents has been shown to extend life span supporting an association between bioenergetics and senescence. In the present study, we use full length mtDNA amplification by long-extension polymerase chain reaction (LX-PCR) to demonstrate that mice accumulate a wide variety of mtDNA rearrangements with age in post mitotic tissues. Similarly, using an alternative PCR strategy, we have found that 2-4 kb minicircles containing the origin of heavy-strand replication accumulate with age in heart but not brain. Analysis of mtDNA structure and conformation by Southern blots of unrestricted DNA resolved by field inversion gel electrophoresis have revealed that the brain mtDNAs of young animals contain the traditional linear, nicked, and supercoiled mtDNAs while old animals accumulate substantial levels of a slower migrating species we designate age-specific mtDNAs. In old caloric restricted animals, a wide variety of rearranged mtDNAs can be detected by LX-PCR in post mitotic tissues, but Southern blots of unrestricted DNA reveals a marked reduction in the levels of the age- specific mtDNA species. These observations confirm that mtDNA mutations accumulate with age in mice and suggest that caloric restriction impedes this progress.     

Mitochondrial DNA4977 deletion in brain of newborns died after intensive care

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) deletion affecting 4977 base pairs (mtDNA4977), the most common mtDNA mutation in humans, was analysed in brain specimens (frontal, temporal, and cerebellar cortices, caudate nucleus, thalamus, and hippocampus) and in other tissues (blood clot, liver, kidney, heart, and muscle) taken at autopsy of deceased neonates. mtDNA4977 deletion determined by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) could be demonstrated in each neonatal sample, however, quantity of mtDNA4977 deletion was less in the newborn samples than in those of the elderlies. Results obtained suggest that contrary to certain data mtDNA4977 deletion can be present in neonates. The mtDNA4977 deletion could be generated by perinatal hypoxia or temporary oxygen oversaturations during the intensive care of the neonates, as the mtDNA is sensitive to oxidative damage. In combination with other factors an additional causative role of mtDNA4977 deletion reported here cannot be ruled out in development of cerebral palsy or mental retardation of unknown origin often seen in neonates underwent neonatal intensive care procedures.     

Twinkle and POLG defects enhance age-dependent accumulation of mutations in the control region of mtDNA

Autosomal dominant and/or recessive progressive external ophthalmoplegia (ad/arPEO) is associated with mtDNA mutagenesis. It can be caused by mutations in three nuclear genes, encoding the adenine nucleotide translocator 1, the mitochondrial helicase Twinkle or DNA polymerase γ (POLG). How mutations in these genes result in progressive accumulation of multiple mtDNA deletions in post- mitotic tissues is still unclear. A recent hypothesis suggested that mtDNA replication infidelity could promote slipped mispairing, thereby stimulating deletion formation. This hypothesis predicts that mtDNA of ad/arPEO patients will contain frequent mutations throughout; in fact, our analysis of muscle from ad/arPEO patients revealed an age-dependent, enhanced accumulation of point mutations in addition to deletions, but specifically in the mtDNA control region. Both deleted and non-deleted mtDNA molecules showed increased point mutation levels, as did mtDNAs of patients with a single mtDNA deletion, suggesting that point mutations do not cause multiple deletions. Deletion breakpoint analysis showed frequent breakpoints around homopolymeric runs, which could be a signature of replication stalling. Therefore, we propose replication stalling as the principal cause of deletion formation.     

MtDNA mutations in aging and apoptosis

There is considerable evidence that the oxidative phosphorylation capacity of human mitochondria declines in various tissues with aging. However, the genetic basis of this phenomenon has not yet been clarified. The occurrence of large deletions in mtDNA from brain, skeletal, and heart muscles and other tissues of old subjects at relatively low levels has been well documented. We discuss their possible functional relevance for the aging processes. On the contrary, until very recently, only inconclusive and often discordant evidence was available for the accumulation of mtDNA point mutations in old individuals. In the past few years, however, an aging-dependent large accumulation of mtDNA point mutations has been demonstrated in the majority of individuals above a certain age. These mutations occur in the mtDNA main control region at critical sites for mtDNA replication in fibroblasts and skeletal muscles. The extraordinary tissue specificity and nucleotide selectivity of these mutations strongly support the idea of their being functionally relevant. Evidence in agreement with this conclusion has been provided by the very recent observation that an mtDNA mutation occurring in blood leukocytes near an origin of replication, which causes a remodeling of this origin, occurs at a strikingly higher frequency in centenarians and monozygotic and dizygotic twins than in the control populations, strongly pointing to its survival value. The present article reviews another area of active research and discussion, namely, the role of pathogenic mtDNA mutations in causing programmed cell death. The available evidence has clearly shown that mtDNA and respiration are not essential for the process of apoptosis. However, the limited and sometimes contradictory data indicate that the absence or impaired function of mtDNA can influence the rate of this process, most probably by regulating the production of reactive oxygen species or the lack thereof.