Characterisation of channels induced in planar bilayer membranes by detergent solubilised Escherichia coli porins

Purified OmpF, OmpC, NmpC, PhoE and Lc (Protein 2) porins from the Escherichia coli outer membrane were incorporated into planar phospholipid bilayer membranes and the permeability properties of the pores studied. Triton X-100 solubilised porin samples showed large and reproducible increases in membrane conductivity composed of discreet single-channel events. The magnitude of the cation selectivity found for the porins was in the order OmpC greater than OmpF greater than NmpC = Lc; PhoE was anion selective. For the cation selective porins the cation/anion permeability ratios in a variety of solutes ranged from 6 to 35. Further information on the internal structure of the porins was obtained by examination of the single-channel conductance and this was used to interpret macroscopic observations and to estimate single-channel diameters. The same porins solubilised in SDS exhibited slight conductance increase with no observable single-channel activity. Use of on-line microcomputer techniques confirmed the ohmic current vs. voltage behaviour for all the single porin channels examined.     

E.coli PhoE porin has an opposite voltage-dependence to the homologous OmpF.

We used patch clamp analysis to compare the electrophysiological behavior of two related porins from Escherichia coli, the anion-specific PhoE and the cation-selective OmpF. Outer membrane fractions were obtained from strains expressing just one of these porin types, and the channels were reconstituted into liposomes without prior purification. We show that the orientation of the reconstituted channels is not random and is the same for both PhoE and OmpF. Like cation-selective porins, PhoE shows fast and slow gating to closed levels of various amplitudes, testifying that the channels visit multiple functional states and behave as cooperative entities. The voltage-dependence of PhoE closure is asymmetric, but strikingly, occurs at voltages of inverse polarity from those promoting closures of OmpC and OmpF. Both slow kinetics and inverse voltage-dependence are removed when 70 amino acids from the N-terminal of OmpF are introduced into the homologous region of PhoE. This novel observation regarding the voltage-dependence of the two channel types, along with published results on PhoE and OmpF mutants, allows us to propose a molecular mechanism for voltage sensing and sensor charge movements in bacterial porins. It also offers new cues on the possible physiological relevance in bacteria of this common form of channel modulation.     

Outer Membrane Protein PhoE Takes the Place of OmpC/OmpF in Maintenance of the Surface Structure of Escherichia coli Cells

OmpC and OmpF, outer membrane porin proteins, are important in the maintenance of the cell surface structure of Escherichia coli cells [T. Nogami and S. Mizushima, J. Bacteriol., 156, 402 (1983)]. Mutants lacking both proteins are unstable and frequently revert or mutate to strains which either have regained one or both of the proteins or constitutively produce PhoE, another porin protein. In the present work, the structural importance of PhoE was studied in relation to OmpC. and OmpF. The strain devoid of both OmpC and OmpF was highly susceptible to Tris-HCl buffer at a concentration of 120 mm in terms of viability and cell structure. This strain was also susceptible to osmotic shock. In contrast, the strain possessing PhoE in place of OmpC/OmpF was as stable as the strain possessing OmpC/OmpF against these treatments. PhoE, like OmpC and OmpF, was assembled into a hexagonal lattice with lipopolysaccharide that covered the peptidoglycan sacculus. These results suggest that PhoE can take the place of OmpC/OmpF in the maintenance of the cell surface structure. The importance of porins in general in the maintenance of the cell structure is discussed.     

Role of lysines in ion selectivity of bacterial outer membrane porins

The epsilon-amino groups of available lysine residues of the OmpC, OmpF and PhoE porin proteins of Escherichia coli and of the protein P porin of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, were modified by the bulky reagent trinitrobenzenesulphonic acid. Approximately 78% of the lysines of the anion-selective protein P and PhoE porins were modified whereas only 40-50% of the lysines of the cation selective OmpF and OmpC porins were altered. After modification, the three E. coli porins had very similar high selectivities for cations over anions, in contrast to the native porins which varied 86-fold in ion selectivity. Despite the large size of the trinitrophenyl group attached to modified lysines (i.e., a disc of approx. 0.86 nm diameter X 0.36 nm high) relative to the reported size of the constrictions of the E. coli porins (1.0-1.2 nm diameter), only the anion-selective PhoE porin was substantially blocked after trinitrophenylation. The protein P porin channel was relatively unaffected by trinitrophenylation, in contrast to previous data showing dramatic effects of acetylation of lysines on protein P conductance and selectivity. This favoured a model in which the critical lysines involved in anion binding by protein P were present in a constriction of the channel that was too small for trinitrobenzenesulphonic acid to enter. Overall, the data suggest that both the number and relative position of charged lysines are major determinants of ion selectivity.     

Porins OmpC and PhoE of Escherichia coli as specific cell-surface targets of human lactoferrin. Binding characteristics and biological effects.

The binding of lactoferrin, an iron-binding glycoprotein found in secretions and leukocytes, to the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria is a prerequisite to exert its bactericidal activity. It was proposed that porins, in addition to lipopolysaccharides, are responsible for this binding. We studied the interactions of human lactoferrin with the three major porins of Escherichia coli OmpC, OmpF, and PhoE. Binding experiments were performed on both purified porins and porin-deficient E. coli K12 isogenic mutants. We determined that lactoferrin binds to the purified native OmpC or PhoE trimer with molar ratios of 1.9 +/- 0.4 and 1.8 +/- 0.3 and Kd values of 39 +/- 18 and 103 +/- 15 nM, respectively, but not to OmpF. Furthermore, preferential binding of lactoferrin was observed on strains that express either OmpC or PhoE. It was also demonstrated that residues 1-5, 28-34, and 39-42 of lactoferrin interact with porins. Based on sequence comparisons, the involvement of lactoferrin amino acid residues and porin loops in the interactions is discussed. The relationships between binding and antibacterial activity of the protein were studied using E. coli mutants and planar lipid bilayers. Electrophysiological studies revealed that lactoferrin can act as a blocking agent for OmpC but not for PhoE or OmpF. However, a total inhibition of the growth was only observed for the PhoE-expressing strain (minimal inhibitory concentration of lactoferrin was 2.4 mg/ml). These data support the proposal that the antibacterial activity of lactoferrin may depend, at least in part, on its ability to bind to porins, thus modifying the stability and/or the permeability of the bacterial outer membrane.     

A comparative study on the genes for three porins of the Escherichia coli outer membrane. DNA sequence of the osmoregulated ompC gene

The DNA sequence of the ompC gene which encodes one of the outer membrane porins has been determined. The gene appears to encode a secretory precursor of OmpC protein consisting of a total of 367 amino acid residues with a signal peptide of 21 amino acid residues at its NH2-terminal end. The 5' end noncoding region including the promoter of the ompC gene is extremely [A-T]-rich, and the codon usage in the ompC gene is unusual as are those in genes for other abundant outer membrane proteins. The promoter sequence of the ompC gene was compared with that of the ompF gene, both of which are controlled by the osmoregulatory operon, ompB. The deduced amino acid sequence of the OmpC protein showed extensive homology with that of the other porins (OmpF and PhoE proteins). The homology in the primary amino acid sequences, as well as the coding DNA sequences among the porins, indicates that the structural genes for the three porins evolved from a common ancestral gene. Comparison of the amino acid sequences among the OmpC, OmpF, and PhoE porins will be discussed with regard to structure and function.     

Porin channels in Escherichia coli: studies with liposomes reconstituted from purified proteins.

Rates of diffusion of uncharged and charged solute molecules through porin channels were determined by using liposomes reconstituted from egg phosphatidylcholine and purified Escherichia coli porins OmpF (protein 1a), OmpC (protein 1b), and PhoE (protein E). All three porin proteins appeared to produce channels of similar size, although the OmpF channel appeared to be 7 to 9% larger than the OmpC and PhoE channels in an equivalent radius. Hydrophobicity of the solute retarded the penetration through all three channels in a similar manner. The presence of one negative charge on the solute resulted in about a threefold reduction in penetration rates through OmpF and OmpC channels, whereas it produced two- to tenfold acceleration of diffusion through the PhoE channel. The addition of the second negatively charged group to the solutes decreased the diffusion rates through OmpF and OmpC channels further, whereas diffusion through the PhoE channel was not affected much. These results suggest that PhoE specializes in the uptake of negatively charged solutes. At the present level of resolution, no sign of true solute specificity was found in OmpF and OmpC channels; peptides, for example, diffused through both of these channels at rates expected from their molecular size, hydrophobicity, and charge. However, the OmpF porin channel allowed influx of more solute molecules per unit time than did the equivalent weight of the OmpC porin when the flux was driven by a concentration gradient of the same size. This apparent difference in "efficiency" became more pronounced with larger solutes, and it is likely to be the consequence of the difference in the sizes of OmpF and OmpC channels.     

TolA central domain interacts with Escherichia coli porins.

TolA is an inner membrane protein with three domains: a transmembrane N-terminus and periplasmic central and C-terminal domains. The interaction of TolA with outer membrane porins of Escherichia coli was investigated. Western blot analyses of cell extracts with anti-TolA antibodies indicated that TolA forms high molecular weight complexes specifically with trimeric OmpF, OmpC, PhoE and LamB, but not with OmpA. The interaction of purified TolA domains with purified porins was also studied. TolA interacted with OmpF, PhoE and LamB porins via its central domain, but not with either their denatured monomeric forms or OmpA. Moreover, the presence or absence of lipopolysaccharides associated with trimeric porins did not modify the interactions. These results suggest that the specific interaction of TolA with outer membrane porins might be relevant to the function of Tol proteins.     

Involvement of histidine-21 in the pH-induced switch in porin channel size.

Porin is a channel-forming protein in the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria. In the previous paper (Todt et al., 1992), we showed that the pH induced a switch in the channel size in vitro for the porins OmpF, OmpC, and PhoE. In the results presented here, His21 of OmpC and OmpF from Escherichia coli was chemically modified with diethyl pyrocarbonate. Functional analysis of these modified porins at different pHs suggested that this histidine is involved in the pH-induced switch in channel size. Secondary structure analysis of porins at various pHs using Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy indicated that there was no global change in structure accompanying the pH-induced switch in channel size.     

Porin channels in Escherichia coli: studies with beta-lactams in intact cells

Wild-type Escherichia coli K-12 produces two porins, OmpF (protein 1a) and OmpC (protein 1b). In mutants deficient in both of these "normal" porins, secondary mutants that produce a "new" porin, protein PhoE (protein E), are selected for. We determined the properties of the channels produced by each of these porins by measuring the rates of diffusion of various cephalosporins through the outer membrane in strains producing only one porin species. We found that all porin channels retarded the diffusion of more hydrophobic cephalosporins and that with monoanionic cephalosporins a 10-fold increase in the octanol-water partition coefficient of the solute produced a 5- to 6-fold decrease in the rate of penetration. Electrical charges of the solutes had different effects on different channels. Thus, with the normal porins (i.e., OmpF and OmpC proteins) additional negative charge drastically reduced the penetration rate through the channels, whereas additional positive charge significantly accelerated the penetration. In contrast, diffusion through the PhoE channel was unaffected by the presence of an additional negative charge. We hypothesize that the relative exclusion of hydrophobic and negatively charged solutes by normal porin channels is of ecological advantage to E. coli, which must exclude hydrophobic and anionic bile salts in its natural habitat. The properties of the PhoE porin are also consistent with the recent finding (M. Argast and W. Boos, J. Bacteriol. 143:142-150, 1980; J. Tommassen and B. Lugtenberg, J. Bacteriol. 143:151-157, 1980) that its biosynthesis is derepressed by phosphate starvation; the channel may thus act as an emergency pore primarily for the uptake of phosphate and phosphorylated compounds.     

Structural relatedness of enteric bacterial porins assessed with monoclonal antibodies to Salmonella typhimurium OmpD and OmpC.

The immunochemistry and structure of enteric bacterial porins are critical to the understanding of the immune response to bacterial infection. We raised 41 monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) to Salmonella typhimurium OmpD and OmpC porin trimers and monomers. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays, immunoprecipitations, and/or Western immunoblot techniques indicated that 39 MAbs (11 anti-trimer and 28 anti-monomer) in the panel are porin specific and one binds to the lipopolysaccharide; the specificity of the remaining MAb probably lies in the porin-lipopolysaccharide complex. Among the porin-specific MAbs, 10 bound cell-surface-exposed epitopes, one reacted with a periplasmic epitope, and the remaining 28 recognized determinants that are buried within the outer membrane bilayer. Many of the MAbs reacting with surface-exposed epitopes were highly specific, recognizing only the homologous porin trimers; this suggests that the cell-surface-exposed regions of porins tends to be quite different among S. typhimurium OmpF, OmpC, and OmpD porins. Immunological cross-reaction showed that S. typhimurium OmpD was very closely related to Escherichia coli NmpC and to the Lc porin of bacteriophage PA-2. Immunologically, E. coli OmpG and protein K also appear to belong to the family of closely related porins including E. coli OmpF, OmpC, PhoE, and NmpC and S. typhimurium OmpF, OmpC, and OmpD. It appears, however, that S. typhimurium "PhoE" is not closely related to this group. Finally, about one-third of the MAbs that presumably recognize buried epitopes reacted with porin domains that are widely conserved in 13 species of the family Enterobacteriaceae, but apparently not in the seven nonenterobacterial species tested. These data are evaluated in relation to host immune response to infection by gram-negative bacteria.     

Osmotic regulation of PhoE porin synthesis in Escherichia coli.

In Escherichia coli, adaptation to hyperosmotic conditions alters the expression of the outer membrane porins OmpF and OmpC. The amount of PhoE porin, which is normally induced by phosphate deprivation, was greatly reduced in cells adapted to high-osmolarity conditions. Osmoregulation of PhoE operated independently of the activity of the PhoR phosphate sensor and did not involve cross-talk from the homologous osmosensor EnvZ. PhoE synthesis was partially restored by additional copies of the positive regulator phoB+ and by the osmoprotectant glycine betaine.     

Utilization by Escherichia coli of a high-molecular-weight, linear polyphosphate: roles of phosphatases and pore proteins.

We observed that wild-type Escherichia coli utilized a linear polyphosphate with a chain length of 100 phosphate residues (poly-P100) as the sole source of phosphate in growth medium. A mutation in the gene phoA of alkaline phosphatase or phoB, the positive regulatory gene, prevented growth in this medium. Since no alkaline phosphatase activity was detected outside the wild-type cells, the periplasmic presence of the enzyme was necessary for the degradation of polyphosphate. A 90% reduction in the activity of periplasmic acid phosphatase with a pH optimum of 2.5 (delta appA mutants) did not affect polyphosphate utilization. Of the porins analyzed (OmpC, OmpF, and PhoE), the phoB-inducible porin PhoE was not essential since its absence did not prevent growth. To study how poly-P100 diffused into the cells, we used high-resolution 31P nuclear magnetic resonance (31P NMR) spectroscopy. The results suggest that poly-P100 entered the periplasm and remained in equilibrium between the periplasm and the medium. When present individually, porins PhoE and OmpF facilitated a higher permeability for poly-P100 than porin OmpC did. The degradation of polyphosphate by intact cells of E. coli observed by 31P NMR showed a time-dependent increase in cellular phosphate and a decrease in polyphosphate concentration.     

PhoE protein pore of the outer membrane of Escherichia coli K12 is a particularly efficient channel for organic and inorganic phosphate

This study was undertaken to investigate the proposed in vivo pore function of PhoE protein, an Escherichia coli K12 outer membrane protein induced by growth under phosphate limitation and to compare it with those of the constitutive pore proteins OmpF and OmpC. Appropriate mutant strains were constructed containing only one of the proteins PhoE, OmpF or OmpC, or none of these proteins at all. By measuring rates of nutrient uptake at low solute concentrations, the proposed pore function of PhoE protein was confirmed as the presence of the protein facilitates the diffusion of Pi through the outer membrane, such as a pore protein deficient strain behaves as a Km mutant. Comparison of the rates of permeation of Pi, glycerol 3-phosphate and glucose 6-phosphate through pores formed by PhoE, OmpF and OmpC proteins shows that PhoE protein is the most effective pore in facilitating the diffusion of Pi and phosphorus-containing compounds. The three types of pores were about equally effective in facilitating the permeation of glucose and arsenate. Possible reasons for the preference for Pi and Pi-containing solutes are discussed.     

Phosphate starvation affects the synthesis of outer membrane proteins in Thiobacillus ferrooxidans

The outer membrane protein (omp40) component from the chemolithoautotrophic acidophilic Thiobacillus ferrooxidans is apparently regulated by the external pH and the concentration of phosphorus. Its amino-terminal sequence showed little identity with the Escherichia coli OmpC, OmpF or PhoE porins, but was 38.5% identical to the outer membrane channel-forming protein NosA from Pseudomonas stutzeri, whose expression is also regulated environmentally. In addition, the partial amino acid sequence of T. ferrooxidans omp40 showed between 34 and 38% identity with the amino-terminal end of the small outer membrane proteins Rck and PagC from Salmonella typhimurium and OmpX from Enterobacter cloacae.     

Characterization of ompF domains involved in Escherichia coli K-12 sensitivity to colicins A and N.

Various ompF-ompC, ompC-ompF, and ompF-ompC-ompF chimeric genes were used to locate the domains of the OmpF protein involved in cellular sensitivity to colicins. Various parts of the porin participate in the entry of colicins. Colicin N receptor activity was found to require three regions: RN1, located between residues 1 and 63; RN2, located between residues 115 and 262; and RN3, located between residues 279 and 297. The central domain from residues 143 to 262 is involved during the translocation step after the binding step. A large region, including residues 1 to 262, is necessary during colicin A entry. The locations and interactions between these domains specifically required for the uptake of colicins to occur are described and discussed with regard to the homology and topology of the OmpC, OmpF, and PhoE porins.     

The impact of length variations in the L2 loop on the structure and thermal stability of non-specific porins: The case of OmpCs from the Yersinia pseudotuberculosis complex

Porins are integral proteins of the outer membranes of gram-negative bacteria. In membranes, they exist as homotrimers and the L2 loops contribute to their stability. Comparison of OmpC porins of the Yersinia pseudotuberculosis complex with other enterobacterial porins demonstrated L2 loop length diversity, which is caused by varying numbers of dipeptide/tripeptide repeats. The OmpC porins are highly homologous to each other, and they can be subdivided into five isoforms based on their L2 loop structure. Optical spectroscopy and SDS-PAGE experiments revealed that particularities of the L2 loops affected the structure and thermal stability of the porins. Thermal denaturation studies showed that porins with shorter loops, compared to porins with longer loops, had more stable tertiary and less stable secondary and quaternary structures. According to our comparative modeling results, the L2 loops differ in their structure by adopting different spatial positions and forming different polar bonds with a neighbor monomer. The replacement of asparagine with arginine at the C-terminus of the L2 loop shifts the loop upwards and causes the loss of contacts with the arginine clusters within the pores. The increase in the length of these loops ensures that they shift down toward the pore and restore their contacts with arginines on the channel wall, as is the case in classical nonspecific porins. Despite the fact that the surface charge density varies considerably among the OmpC porins, the L2 loops form a typical negatively charged region in the center of the trimer.     

Effects of pore mutations and permeant ion concentration on the spontaneous gating activity of OmpC porin

Porins are trimers of beta-barrels that form channels for ions and other hydrophilic solutes in the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria. The X-ray structures of OmpF and PhoE show that each monomeric pore is constricted by an extracellular loop that folds into the channel vestibule, a motif that is highly conserved among bacterial porins. Electrostatic calculations have suggested that the distribution of ionizable groups at the constriction zone (or eyelet) may establish an intrinsic transverse electrostatic field across the pore, that is perpendicular to the pore axis. In order to study the role that electrostatic interactions between pore residues may have in porin function, we used spontaneous mutants and engineered site-directed mutants that have an altered charge distribution at the eyelet and compared their electrophysiological behavior with that of wild-type OmpC. We found that some mutations lead to changes in the spontaneous gating activity of OmpC porin channels. Changes in the concentration of permeant ions also altered this activity. These results suggest that the ionic interactions that exist between charged residues at the constriction zone of porin may play a role in the transitions between the channel's closed and open states.     

PhoE protein pore of the outer membrane of Escherichia coli K12 is a particularly efficient channel for organic and inorganic phosphate

This study was undertaken to investigate the proposed in vivo pore function of PhoE protein, an Escherichia coli K12 outer membrane protein induced by growth under phosphate limitation, and to compare it with those of the constitutive pore proteins OmpF and OmpC. Appropriate mutant strains were constructed containing only one of the proteins PhoE, OmpF or OmpC, or none of these proteins at all. By measuring rates of nutrient uptake at low solute concentrations, the proposed pore function of PhoE protein was confirmed as the presence of the protein facilitates the diffusion of P_i through the outer membrane, such that a pore protein deficient strain behaves as a K_m mutant. Comparison of the rates of permeation of P_i, glycerol 3-phosphate and glucose 6-phosphate through pores formed by PhoE, OmpF and OmpC proteins shows that PhoE protein is the most effective pore in facilitating the diffusion of P_i and phosphorus-containing compounds. The three types of pores were about equally effective in facilitating the permeation of glucose and arsenate. Possible reasons for the preference for P_i and P_i-containing solutes are discussed.     

Homology model of surface antigen OmpC from Salmonella typhi and its functional implications

Homology based 3D structural model of the immunodominant major surface antigen OmpC from Salmonella typhi, an obligatory human pathogen, was built to understand the possible unique conformational features of its antigenic loops with respect to other immunologically cross reacting porins. The homology model was built based on the known crystal structures of the E. coli porins OmpF and PhoE. Structure based sequence alignment helped to define the structurally conserved regions (SCRs). The SCR regions of OmpC were modelled using the coordinates of corresponding regions from reference proteins. Surface exposed variable regions were modelled based on the sequence similarity and loop search in PDB. Structural refinement based on symmetry restrained energy minimization resulted in an agreeable model for the trimer of OmpC. The resulting model was compared with other porin structures, having b-barrel fold with 16 transmembrane beta-strands, and found that the variable regions are unique in terms of sequence and structure. A ranking of the loops taking into account the antigenic index, the sequence variability, the surface accessibility in the context of the trimer, and the structural variability suggests that loop 4 (151-172), loop 5 (194-218) and loop 6 (237-264) are the best ranked B-cell epitopes. The model provides possible explanations for the functional and unique immunological properties associated with the surface exposed regions and outlines the implications for structure based experimental design.