Understanding the transition states of phosphodiester bond cleavage: insights from heavy atom isotope effects

The nucleotides of DNA and RNA are joined by phosphodiester linkages whose synthesis and hydrolysis are catalyzed by numerous essential enzymes. Two prominent mechanisms have been proposed for RNA and protein enzyme catalyzed cleavage of phosphodiester bonds in RNA: (a) intramolecular nucleophilic attack by the 2'-hydroxyl group adjacent to the reactive phosphate; and (b) intermolecular nucleophilic attack by hydroxide, or other oxyanion. The general features of these two mechanisms have been established by physical organic chemical analyses; however, a more detailed understanding of the transition states of these reactions is emerging from recent kinetic isotope effect (KIE) studies. The recent data show interesting differences between the chemical mechanisms and transition state structures of the inter- and intramolecular reactions, as well as provide information on the impact of metal ion, acid, and base catalysis on these mechanisms. Importantly, recent nonenzymatic model studies show that interactions with divalent metal ions, an important feature of many phosphodiesterase active sites, can influence both the mechanism and transition state structure of nonenzymatic phosphodiester cleavage. Such detailed investigations are important because they mimic catalytic strategies employed by both RNA and protein phosphodiesterases, and so set the stage for explorations of enzyme-catalyzed transition states. Application of KIE analyses for this class of enzymes is just beginning, and several important technical challenges remain to be overcome. Nonetheless, such studies hold great promise since they will provide novel insights into the role of metal ions and other active site interactions.     

Metal ion-dependent hydrolysis of RNA phosphodiester bonds within hairpin loops. A comparative kinetic study on chimeric ribo/2'-O-methylribo oligonucleotides.

Several chimeric ribo/2'- O -methylribo oligonucleotides were synthesized and their hydrolytic cleavage studied in the presence of Mg2+, Zn2+, Pb2+and the 1,4,9-triaza-cyclododecane chelate of Zn2+(Zn2+[12]aneN3) to evaluate the importance of RNA secondary structure as a factor determining the reactivity of phosphodiester bonds. In all the cases studied, a phosphodiester bond within a 4-7 nt loop was hydrolytically more stable than a similar bond within a linear single strand, but markedly less stable than that in a double helix. With Zn2+and Zn2+[12]aneN3, the hydrolytic stability of a phosphodiester bond within a hairpin loop gradually decreased on increasing the distance from the stem. A similar but less systematic trend was observed with Pb2+. Zn2+- and Pb2+-promoted cleavage was observed to be considerably more sensitive to the secondary structure of the chain than that induced by Zn2+[12]aneN3. This difference in behaviour may be attributed to bidentate binding of uncomplexed aquo ions to two different phosphodiester bonds. Mg2+was observed to be catalytically virtually inactive compared with the other cleaving agents studied.     

Polycationic catalysts for phosphodiester bond cleavage on the basis of 1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane

A number of tetracationic compounds capable of phosphodiester bond cleavage within a 21-membered ribooligonucleotide were designed and synthesized. The artificial ribonucleases represent two residues of quaternized 1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane bearing alkyl substituents of various lengths and connected with a rigid linker. The efficiency of cleavage of phosphodiester bonds in an RNA target depends on the linker structure and the length of alkyl substituent.     

An RNA sequence determines the speed of its cleavage by artificial ribonucleases

Phosphodiester bonds in RNA situated between similar nucleotides but in different sequences (context) were cleaved under the action of artificial and natural ribonucleases with different speeds, and the reason for this phenomenon has not yet been fully revealed. In this study, the influence of one-nucleotide substitution on the sensitivity to cleavage of the phosphodiester bonds in linear and structured RNA with homologous sequences is studied for the first time. It is indicated that the introduction of one-nucleotide substitution in the RNA sequence significantly (up to 10 times) changes the speed of the cleavage of the bonds that are separated from the substitution point not only by 1–3, but also 6–8 nucleotides, by artificial ribonucleases. The observed regularities may be explained by the fact that the introduction of a one-nucleotide substitution significantly changes the stacking interactions and the net of hydrogen bonds in the RNA molecule. The applied value of this study consists of the ability of using low-molecular artificial ribonucleases with the aim of choosing the region of the binding of the oligonucleotide in the construction of a conjugate for the site-directed cutting of RNA, because the choice of a phosphodiester bond (motif) easily subjected to cleavage significantly determines the efficacy of artificial ribonucleases of directed action.     

Metal ion requirements and other aspects of the reaction catalyzed by M1 RNA, the RNA subunit of ribonuclease P from Escherichia coli

M1 RNA, the RNA subunit of ribonuclease P from Escherichia coli, can under certain conditions catalytically cleave precursors to tRNA in the absence of C5, the protein moiety of RNase P. M1 RNA itself is not cleaved during the reaction, nor does it form any covalent bonds with its substrate. Only magnesium and, to a lesser extent, manganese ions can function at the catalytic center of M1 RNA. Several other ions either inhibit the binding of magnesium ion at the active site or function as structural counterions. The reaction rate of cleavage of precursors to tRNAs by M1 RNA is enhanced in the presence of poly-(ethylene glycol) or 2-methyl-2,4-pentanediol. Many aspects of the reaction catalyzed by M1 RNA are compatible with a mechanism in which phosphodiester bond cleavage is mediated by metal ion.     

Hybridase cleavage of RNA. I. Oligonucleotide probes for regiospecific RNA cleavage]

New oligonucleotide probes for regiospecific cleavage of RNA molecules by hybridase (RNase H) are suggested. RNase H from E. coli is shown to site-specifically split eight phosphodiester bonds in RNA in the heteroduplex, formed by 5S rRNA and d(ACCACCGCGCT). The partial substitution of deoxycytidines in position 5, 6, 8, 10 of the probe by 2'-O-methylcytidines leads to unique (regiospecific) RNA cleavage between U25 and C26.     

Chemical ribonucleases: VII. Effect of positively charged RNA-binding domains and hydrophobic fragments of the conjugates based on 1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane and imidazole on their ribonuclease activity

The effect of the total positive charge in the RNA-binding domain of chemical ribonucleases that are conjugates of bisquaternary salts of 1,4-diazabicylo[2.2.2]octane and imidazole on the cleavage of an HIV-1 RNA fragment was studied. An increase in the positive charge from +2 to +4 was shown to result in a significant growth in the ribonuclease activity. Possible mechanisms of the interactions between structural moieties of chemical ribonucleases and RNA that enable an effective catalysis of the cleavage of phosphodiester bonds are discussed.     

Chemical models for ribozyme action

Mechanistic studies of the action of catalytic ribonucleic acids, ribozymes, are highly challenging, because even a slight structural change can dramatically affect the chain folding. This, in turn, alters the binding properties of the catalytic core, making identification of the real origin of the observed influence on rate difficult. Unambiguous structure-reactivity correlations based on studies with structurally simplified chemical models may help to distinguish between alternative mechanistic interpretations. The results of such model studies are reviewed. The topics include intramolecular cleavage of RNA phosphodiester bonds by solvent-derived species, general acids/bases and metal ions, effect of molecular environment on their hydrolytic stability and trinucleoside monophosphates as models for large ribozymes.     

Ribonuclease activity of cationic structures conjugated to lipophilic groups

Cationic compounds containing benzene ring substituted with the bis-quaternary salt of diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane (DABCO) bearing a polymethylene fragment at the bridge positions display ribonuclease activity. Efficacy of the catalysis is affected by geometry of the cationic structures and the size of the attached aliphatic fragment. The cleavage occurs primarily within CA sequences. The compounds do not possess tradition groups participating in the transesterification step of RNA cleavage reaction, therefore a speculative mechanism of cleavage could be inducing a conformational stress on the RNA sugar phosphate backbone providing fragility to phosphodiester bonds.     

Oligonucleotide-Peptide Conjjugates for RNA Cleavage

Abstract

Directed cleavage of RNA phosphodiester bonds by peptidyloligodeoxyribonucleotide containing the peptide residues with the alternated hydrophobic and basic amino acids was demonstrated.     

Ribonuclease Activity of Cationic Structures Conjugated to Lipophilic Groups

Cationic compounds containing benzene ring substituted with the bis‐quaternary salt of diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane (DABCO) bearing a polymethylene fragment at the bridge positions display ribonuclease activity. Efficacy of the catalysis is affected by geometry of the cationic structures and the size of the attached aliphatic fragment. The cleavage occurs primarily within CA sequences. The compounds do not possess tradition groups participating in the transesterification step of RNA cleavage reaction, therefore a speculative mechanism of cleavage could be inducing a conformational stress on the RNA sugar phosphate backbone providing fragility to phosphodiester bonds.     

A Comparative Study on the Cleavage of Stereoisomeric Uridylyl (3',5')Uridines [D,D-, D,L- and L,D-UPU] by Acid,Base and Metal Ion Catalysts

Stereoisomeric uridylyl(3',5')uridines D,L-UpU andL,D-UpU were synthesised. Their cleavage was followed in thepresence of acid, base and metal ion catalysts to studywhether the stereochemistry affects the inherent reactivity ofthe internucleosidic phosphodiester bond, and whether the lowmolecular weight catalysts can distinguish between thesubstrates. The rate constants obtained were compared to thoseof D,D-UpU. The comparison shows that the stability of thephosphodiester bond does not depend on the stereochemistry ofthe sugar rings. In contrast slight reactivity differences areobserved in the presence of metal ion catalysts, whichsuggests that selective cleavage of stereoisomeric substrateseven by small molecular weight chemical catalysts may bepossible.     

Enhanced RNA cleavage within bulge-loops by an artificial ribonuclease

Cleavage of phosphodiester bonds by small ribonuclease mimics within different bulge-loops of RNA was investigated. Bulge-loops of different size (1–7 nt) and sequence composition were formed in a 3′ terminal fragment of influenza virus M2 RNA (96 nt) by hybridization of complementary oligodeoxynucleotides. Small bulges (up to 4 nt) were readily formed upon oligonucleotide hybridization, whereas hybridization of the RNA to the oligonucleotides designed to produce larger bulges resulted in formation of several alternative structures. A synthetic ribonuclease mimic displaying Pyr–Pu cleavage specificity cleaved CpA motifs located within bulges faster than similar motifs within the rest of the RNA. In the presence of 10 mM MgCl₂, 75% of the cleavage products resulted from the attack of this motif. Thus, selective RNA cleavage at a single target phosphodiester bond was achieved by using bulge forming oligonucleotides and a small ribonuclease A mimic.     

Specific phosphorothioate substitutions probe the active site of Bacillus subtilis ribonuclease P

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribonucleoprotein that requires magnesium ions to catalyze the 5' maturation of transfer RNA. To identify interactions essential for catalysis, the properties of RNase P containing single sulfur substitutions for nonbridging phosphodiester oxygens in helix P4 of Bacillus subtilis RNase P were analyzed using transient kinetic experiments. Sulfur substitution at the nonbridging oxygens of the phosphodiester bond of nucleotide U51 only modestly affects catalysis. However, phosphorothioate substitutions at A49 and G50 decrease the cleavage rate constant enormously (300-4,000-fold for P RNA and 500-15,000-fold for RNase P holoenzyme) in magnesium without affecting the affinity of pre-tRNA(Asp), highlighting the importance of this region for catalysis. Furthermore, addition of manganese enhances pre-tRNA cleavage catalyzed by B. subtilis RNase P RNA containing an Sp phosphorothioate modification at A49, as observed for Escherichia coli P RNA [Christian et al., RNA, 2000, 6:511-519], suggesting that an essential metal ion may be coordinated at this site. In contrast, no manganese rescue is observed for the A49 Sp phosphorothioate modification in RNase P holoenzyme. These differential manganese rescue effects, along with affinity cleavage, suggest that the protein component may interact with a metal ion bound near A49 in helix P4 of P RNA.     

Characterization of structure and metal ions specificity of Co2+-binding RNA aptamers

Studies on RNA motifs capable of binding metal ions have largely focused on Mg(2+)-specific motifs, therefore information concerning interactions of other metal ions with RNA is still very limited. Application of the in vitro selection approach allowed us to isolate two RNA aptamers that bind Co(2+) ions. Structural analysis of their secondary structures revealed the presence of two motifs, loop E and "kissing" loop complex, commonly occurring in RNA molecules. The Co(2+)-induced cleavage method was used for identification of Co(2+)-binding sites after the determination of the optimal cleavage conditions. In the aptamers, Co(2+) ions seem to bind to N7 atoms of purines, inducing cleavage of the adjacent phosphodiester bonds, similarly as is the case with yeast tRNA(Phe). Although the in vitro selection experiment was carried out in the presence of Co(2+) ions only, the aptamers displayed broader metal ions specificity. This was shown by inhibition of Co(2+)-induced cleavages in the presence of the following transition metal ions: Zn(2+), Cd(2+), Ni(2+), and Co(NH(3))(6)(3+) complex. On the other hand, alkaline metal ions such as Mg(2+), Ca(2+), Sr(2+), and Ba(2+) affected Co(2+)-induced cleavages only slightly. Multiple metal ions specificity of Co(2+)-binding sites has also been reported for other in vitro selected or natural RNAs. Among many factors that influence metal specificity of the Co(2+)-binding pocket, chemical properties of metal ions, such as their hardness as well as the structure of the coordination site, seem to be particularly important.     

Autolytic processing of a phosphorothioate diester bond.

A small satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus replicates in tissues infected with tobacco ringspot virus and accumulates in virus capsids, forming virus-like particles. Previous research showed that multimeric forms of this satellite RNA have tandem repeats of the "monomeric" satellite RNA sequence of 359 or 360 nucleotide residues. The multimeric RNAs undergo autolytic processing at a specific CpA phosphodiester bond, the junction, to generate the monomeric RNA. We substituted phosphorothioate diester bonds for various sets of phosphodiester bonds, in dimeric and truncated forms of the satellite RNA. The degree of reduction in autolytic cleavage varied both with the sites of substitution and the size of the RNA molecules. Analyses of a product of the autolysis reaction suggest that one phosphorothioate diester bond most strongly interferes with processing, the one introduced at the CpA junction during its synthesis from adenosine-5'-0-(1-thiotriphosphate). However, extensive introduction of phosphorothioate diester bonds elsewhere in the molecule also decreased processing, possibly by altering conformation.     

Base cleavage specificity of angiogenin with Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Escherichia coli 5S RNAs

The base cleavage specificity of angiogenin toward naturally occurring polyribonucleotides has been determined by using rapid RNA sequencing technology. With 5S RNAs from Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Escherichia coli, angiogenin cleaves phosphodiester bonds exclusively at cytidylic or uridylic residues, preferably when the pyrimidines are followed by adenine. However, not all of the existent pyrimidine bonds in the 5S RNAs are cleaved, likely owing to elements of structure in the substrate. Despite the high degree of sequence homology between angiogenin and ribonuclease A (RNase A), which includes all three catalytic as well as substrate binding residues, the cleavage patterns with natural RNAs are unique to each enzyme. Angiogenin significantly hydrolyzes certain bonds that are not appreciably attacked by RNase A and vice versa. The different cleavage specificities of angiogenin and RNase A may account for the fact that the former is angiogenic while the latter is not.     

Mutational analysis of an RNA internal loop as a reactivity epitope for Escherichia coli ribonuclease III substrates

The enzymatic cleavage of double-stranded (ds) RNA is an obligatory step in the maturation and decay of many cellular and viral RNAs. The primary agents of dsRNA processing are members of the ribonuclease III (RNase III) superfamily, which are highly conserved in eukaryotic and bacterial cells. Escherichia coli RNase III participates in the maturation of the ribosomal RNAs and in the maturation and decay of cellular and phage mRNAs. E. coli RNase III-dependent cleavage events can regulate gene expression by controlling mRNA stability and translational activity. RNase III recognizes its substrates and selects the scissile phosphodiester(s) by recognizing specific RNA sequence and structural elements, termed reactivity epitopes. Some E. coli RNase III substrates contain an internal loop, in which is located the single scissile phosphodiester. The specific features of the internal loop that establish the pattern of single-strand cleavage are not known. A mutational analysis of the asymmetric [4 nt/5 nt] internal loop of the phage T7 R1.1 substrate reveals that cleavage reactivity is largely independent of internal loop sequence. Instead, the [4/5] asymmetry per se is the primary determinant of cleavage of a single bond within the 5 nt strand of the internal loop. The T7 R1.1 internal loop lacks elements of local tertiary structure, as revealed by sensitivity to cleavage by terbium ion and by the ability of the internal loop to destabilize a small model duplex. The internal loop functions as a discrete structural element in that the pattern of cleavage can be controlled by the specific type of asymmetry. The implications of these findings are discussed in light of RNase III substrate function as a gene regulatory element.     

Accessibility of phosphodiester bonds in the yeast ribosomal 5 S RNA protein complex

The tertiary structure of the protein-associated yeast ribosomal 5 S RNA was examined using ethylnitrosourea reactivity as a probe for phosphodiester bonds. A reduced reactivity was consistently observed in at least nine residues within four distinct regions of the RNA sequence. Seven of these were also observed in three regions of the free RNA molecule while two, A27 and G30, were only present in the ribonucleoprotein complex. The results strongly suggest that the tertiary structure of the free eukaryotic 5 S RNA is largely conserved in the 5 S RNA-protein complex although it appears to be further stabilized in interaction with the ribosomal protein.     

RNA recognition and cleavage by sequence-specific endoribonucleases

Inactivation of RNA molecules by sequence-specific endoribonucleolytic cleavage is a subtle mechanism by which cells regulate gene expression. Sequence-specific endoribonucleases can recognize and cleave particular phosphodiester bonds confined within hundreds/thousands of chemically similar bonds. Here, we present a comparative analysis of the mechanisms used by endoribonucleases to select and cleave their target RNA molecules. This analysis is based on the very recent molecular details obtained from the structural and/or biochemical studies of nine sequence-specific ribonucleases that target messenger, ribosomal, and transfer RNA molecules. This analysis shows that despite the absence of sequence homologies and the wide diversity of biological sources (prokaryotes, archaea and eukaryotes), the sequence-specific ribonucleases studied here adopt limited structural folds, catalyze their cleavage reactions using a common chemistry and involve a very limited set of amino acids for both RNA binding and processing.