Reconstitution of membrane proteolysis by FtsH

Escherichia coli FtsH is a membrane-bound and ATP-dependent protease responsible for degradation of several membrane proteins. The FtsH action is processive and presumably involves dislocation of the substrate from the membrane to the cytosol. Although elucidation of its molecular mechanism requires an in vitro reaction system, in vitro activities of this enzyme against membrane protein substrates have only been assayed using detergent-solubilized components. Here we report on the construction of in vitro reaction systems for FtsH-catalyzed membrane protein degradation. A combination of two inverted membrane vesicles or of two proteoliposomes, one bearing the enzyme and the other bearing a substrate, was fused by polyethylene glycol 3350 treatment. Addition of ATP then resulted in degradation of the substrate. It was shown that FtsH can function in the process of membrane proteins degradation without aid from any other cellular factors.     

The thylakoid FtsH protease plays a role in the light-induced turnover of the photosystem II D1 protein

The photosystem II reaction center D1 protein is known to turn over frequently. This protein is prone to irreversible damage caused by reactive oxygen species that are formed in the light; the damaged, nonfunctional D1 protein is degraded and replaced by a new copy. However, the proteases responsible for D1 protein degradation remain unknown. In this study, we investigate the possible role of the FtsH protease, an ATP-dependent zinc metalloprotease, during this process. The primary light-induced cleavage product of the D1 protein, a 23-kD fragment, was found to be degraded in isolated thylakoids in the dark during a process dependent on ATP hydrolysis and divalent metal ions, suggesting the involvement of FtsH. Purified FtsH degraded the 23-kD D1 fragment present in isolated photosystem II core complexes, as well as that in thylakoid membranes depleted of endogenous FtsH. In this study, we definitively identify the chloroplast protease acting on the D1 protein during its light-induced turnover. Unlike previously identified membrane-bound substrates for FtsH in bacteria and mitochondria, the 23-kD D1 fragment represents a novel class of FtsH substrate-functionally assembled proteins that have undergone irreversible photooxidative damage and cleavage.     

Flavodoxin, a new fluorescent substrate for monitoring proteolytic activity of FtsH lacking a robust unfolding activity

Escherichia coli FtsH, which belongs to the ATPases associated with diverse cellular activities (AAA) family, is an ATP-dependent and membrane-bound protease. FtsH degrades misassembled membrane proteins and a subset of cytoplasmic regulatory proteins. To elucidate the molecular mechanisms of the proteolysis, a system for precisely monitoring substrate degradation is required. We have exploited E. coli flavodoxin containing non-covalently bound flavin mononucleotide (FMN) as a model substrate for monitoring protein degradation. It was found that FtsH degrades FMN-free apo-flavodoxin but not holo-flavodoxin. However, degradation of a mutant flavodoxin carrying a substitution of Tyr94 to Asp with a lower affinity for FMN could be monitored by fluorimetry. This newly developed monitoring system will also be applicable for proteolysis by other ATP-dependent proteases.     

The E3 ligase AtCHIP ubiquitylates FtsH1, a component of the chloroplast FtsH protease, and affects protein degradation in chloroplasts

The Arabidopsis E3 ligase AtCHIP was found to interact with FtsH1, a subunit of the chloroplast FtsH protease complex. FtsH1 can be ubiquitylated by AtCHIP in vitro, and the steady-state level of FtsH1 is reduced in AtCHIP-over-expressing plants under high-intensity light conditions, suggesting that the ubiquitylation of FtsH1 by AtCHIP might lead to the degradation of FtsH1 in vivo. Furthermore, the steady-state level of another subunit of the chloroplast FtsH protease complex, FtsH2, is also reduced in AtCHIP-over-expressing plants under high-intensity light conditions, and FtsH2 interacts physically with AtCHIP in vivo, suggesting the possibility that FtsH2 is also a substrate protein for AtCHIP in plant cells. A substrate of FtsH protease in vivo, the photosystem II reaction center protein D1, is not efficiently removed by FtsH in AtCHIP-over-expressing plants under high-intensity light conditions, supporting the assumption that FtsH subunits are substrates of AtCHIP in vivo, and that AtCHIP over-expression may lead to a reduced level of FtsH in chloroplasts. AtCHIP interacts with cytosolic Hsp70 and the precursors of FtsH1 and FtsH2 in the cytoplasm, and Hsp70 also interacts with FtsH1, and these protein-protein interactions appear to be increased under high-intensity light conditions, suggesting that Hsp70 might be partly responsible for the increased degradation of the substrates of Hsp70, such as FtsH1 and FtsH2, in AtCHIP-over-expressing plants under high-intensity light conditions. Therefore, AtCHIP, together with Hsp70, may play an important role in protein quality control in chloroplasts.     

Light-stimulated degradation of an unassembled Rieske FeS protein by a thylakoid-bound protease: the possible role of the FtsH protease.

Unassembled subunits of the cytochrome b6f complex as well as components of other unassembled chloroplastic complexes are rapidly degraded within the organelle. However, the mechanisms involved in these proteolytic processes are obscure. When the Rieske FeS protein (RISP) is imported into isolated chloroplasts in vitro, some of the protein does not property assemble with the cytochrome complex, as determined by its sensitivity to exogenous protease. When assayed in intact, lysed, or fractionated chloroplasts, the imported RISP was found to be sensitive to endogenous proteases as well. The activity responsible for degradation of the unassembled protein was localized to the thylakoid membrane and characterized as a metalloprotease requiring zinc ions for its activity. The degradation rate was stimulated by light, but no involvement of ATP or redox control was observed. Instead, when the RISP that was attached to thylakoid membranes was first illuminated on ice, degradation proceeded in either light or darkness at equal rates suggesting a light-induced conformational change making the protein prone to degradation. Antibodies raised against native FtsH, a bacterial, membrane-bound, ATP-dependent, zinc-stimulated protease, effectively inhibited degradation of the unassembled RISP, suggesting a role for the chloroplastic FtsH in this process.     

Roles of homooligomerization and membrane association in ATPase and proteolytic activities of FtsH in vitro.

Escherichia coli FtsH is a membrane-bound and ATP-dependent protease which degrades some soluble and integral membrane proteins. The N-terminal region of FtsH mediates membrane association as well as homooligomeric interaction of this enzyme. Previously, we studied in vivo functionality of FtsH derivatives, in which the N-terminal membrane region was either deleted (FtsH(DeltaTM)), replaced by a leucine zipper (Zip-FtsH(DeltaTM)), or replaced by a lactose permease transmembrane segment (LacY-FtsH). It was indicated that homooligomerization is required for the minimum proteolytic activity, whereas a transmembrane sequence is required for membrane protein degradation. Here we characterized these proteins in vitro. Although these mutant enzymes were very low in their activities, they were significantly stimulated by dimethyl sulfoxide, which enabled us to characterize their activities. LacY-FtsH degraded both soluble and membrane proteins, but Zip-FtsH(DeltaTM) only degraded soluble proteins. These proteins also exhibited significant ATPase activities. However, FtsH(DeltaTM) remained inactive both in ATPase and in protease activities even in the presence of dimethyl sulfoxide. The monomeric FtsH(DeltaTM) was able to bind ATP and a denatured protein. These results indicate that subunit association is important for the enzymatic catalysis by FtsH and that the additional presence of the transmembrane sequence is required for this enzyme to degrade a membrane protein even under detergent-solubilized conditions.     

Hexameric ring structure of the ATPase domain of the membrane-integrated metalloprotease FtsH from Thermus thermophilus HB8

FtsH is a cytoplasmic membrane-integrated, ATP-dependent metalloprotease, which processively degrades both cytoplasmic and membrane proteins in concert with unfolding. The FtsH protein is divided into the N-terminal transmembrane region and the larger C-terminal cytoplasmic region, which consists of an ATPase domain and a protease domain. We have determined the crystal structures of the Thermus thermophilus FtsH ATPase domain in the nucleotide-free and AMP-PNP- and ADP-bound states, in addition to the domain with the extra preceding segment. Combined with the mapping of the putative substrate binding region, these structures suggest that FtsH internally forms a hexameric ring structure, in which ATP binding could cause a conformational change to facilitate transport of substrates into the protease domain through the central pore.     

Resolving individual steps in the operation of ATP-dependent proteolytic molecular machines: from conformational changes to substrate translocation and processivity

Clp, Lon, and FtsH proteases are proteolytic molecular machines that use the free energy of ATP hydrolysis to unfold protein substrates and processively present them to protease active sites. Here we review recent biochemical and structural studies relevant to the mechanism of ATP-dependent processive proteolysis. Despite the significant structural differences among the Clp, Lon, and FtsH proteases, these enzymes share important mechanistic features. In these systems, mechanistic studies have provided evidence for ATP binding and hydrolysis-driven conformational changes that drive translocation of substrates, which has significant implications for the processive mechanism of proteolysis. These studies indicate that the nucleotide (ATP, ADP, or nonhydrolyzable ATP analogues) occupancy of the ATPase binding sites can influence the binding mode and/or binding affinity for protein substrates. A general mechanism is proposed in which the communication between ATPase active sites and protein substrate binding regions coordinates a processive cycle of substrate binding, translocation, proteolysis, and product release.     

FtsH proteases in chloroplasts and cyanobacteria

FtsH is a membrane-bound ATP-dependent metalloprotease complex found in prokaryotes and organelles of eukaryotic cells. It consists of one or two trans -membrane helices at its amino-terminus, a highly conserved ATPase domain, which relates it to the AAA protein family, and a zinc-binding domain towards its carboxy-terminus that serves as the proteolytic site. Most bacteria contain a single FtsH gene, but the cyanobacterium Synechocystis has four. The Arabidopsis thaliana genome contains 12 genes encoding FtsH proteins, nine of them can be targeted to chloroplasts, whereas the other three are mitochondrial. Chloroplast FtsH protease is located in the thylakoid membrane, where it forms complexes, most likely hexamers, whose ATPase and proteolytic domains are exposed to the stroma. It is involved in the degradation of the D1 protein of photosystem II reaction centre during its repair from photoinhibition, as well as in the degradation of unassembled proteins in the thylakoid and the stroma. In Arabidopsis , FtsH2 is the most abundant isomer, followed by FtsH5, 8 and 1. This hierarchy is well reflected in the severity of the variegated phenotype of mutants in these genes.     

Self-processing of FtsH and its implication for the cleavage specificity of this protease.

FtsH, a membrane-bound and ATP-dependent protease of Escherichia coli, is involved in degradation of some of uncomplexed integral membrane proteins and short-lived cytoplasmic proteins. It is composed of an N-terminal membrane-spanning region and a following large cytoplasmic domain that contains ATPase and protease active sites. In the present study, it was found that FtsH undergoes C-terminal processing in vivo. The processing was blocked by loss of function mutations of FtsH. Purified FtsH-His(6)-Myc, a C-terminally tagged derivative of FtsH, was self-processed in vitro. This in vitro processing was observed only in the presence of ATP and not in the presence of adenosine 5'-(beta,gamma-imino)triphosphate (AMP-PNP). Moreover, such processing did not occur in the case of the ATPase motif mutant protein. These results indicated that this processing is a self-catalyzed reaction that needs ATP hydrolysis. Mutations in the hflKC genes that encode a possible modulator of FtsH, and the growth phase of the cells as well, affected the processing. Complementation experiments with genetically constructed variants suggested that both the processed and the unprocessed forms of FtsH are functional. The cleavage was found to occur between Met-640 and Ser-641, removing a heptapeptide from the C-terminus of FtsH. Systematic mutational analyses of Met-640 and Ser-641 revealed preferences for positively charged and hydrophobic amino acid residues at these positions for processing. This cleavage specificity may be shared by the self-cleavage and the substrate-cleavage reactions of this protease.     

Analysis of degradation of bacterial cell division protein FtsZ by the ATP-dependent zinc-metalloprotease FtsH in vitro

The identity of protease(s), which would degrade bacterial cell division protein FtsZ in vivo, remains unknown. However, we had earlier demonstrated that Escherichia coli metalloprotease FtsH degrades E. coli cell division protein FtsZ in an ATP- and Zn(2+)-dependent manner in vitro. In this study, we examined FtsH protease-mediated degradation of FtsZ in vitro in detail using seven different deletion mutants of FtsZ as the substrates, which lack different extents of specific regions at the N- or C-terminus. FtsH protease assay in vitro on these mutants revealed that FtsH could degrade all the seven deletion mutants irrespective of the deletions or the extent of deletions at the N- or C-terminus. These observations indicated that neither the N-terminus nor the C-terminus was required for the degradation of FtsZ, like already known in the case of the FtsH substrate sigma(32) protein. The recombinant clones expressing full-length FtsZ protein and FtsZ deletion mutant proteins would be useful in investigating the possibility of FtsZ as a potential in vivo substrate for FtsH in ftsH-null cells carrying ftsH suppressor function and ectopically expressed FtsH protease.     

Escherichia coli requires the protease activity of FtsH for growth

FtsH protease, the product of the essential ftsH gene, is a membrane-bound ATP-dependent metalloprotease of Escherichia coli that has been shown to be involved in the rapid turnover of key proteins, secretion of proteins into and through the membrane, and mRNA decay. The pleiotropic effects of ftsH mutants have led to the suggestion that FtsH possesses an ATP-dependent chaperone function that is independent of its protease function. When considering FtsH as a target for novel antibacterials, it is necessary to determine which of these functions is critical for the growth and survival of bacteria. To address this, we constructed the FtsH mutants E418Q, which retains significant ATPaseactivity but lacks protease activity, and K201N, which lacks both protease and ATPase activities. These mutants were introduced into an E. coli ftsH knockout strain which has wild-type FtsH supplied from a plasmid under control of the inducible araBAD promoter. Since neither mutant would complement the ftsH defect produced in the absence of arabinose, we conclude that the protease function of FtsH is required for bacterial growth.     

Escherichia coli FtsH (HflB) degrades a membrane-associated TolAI-II-beta-lactamase fusion protein under highly denaturing conditions

TolAI--II--beta-lactamase, a fusion protein consisting of the inner membrane and transperiplasmic domains of TolA followed by TEM--beta-lactamase associated with the inner membrane but remained confined to the cytoplasm when expressed at high level in Escherichia coli. Although the fusion protein was resistant to proteolysis in vivo, it was hydrolyzed during preparative SDS-polyacrylamide electrophoresis and when insoluble cellular fractions unfolded with 5 M urea were subjected to microdialysis. Inhibitor profiling studies revealed that both a metallo- and serine protease were involved in TolAI--II--beta-lactamase degradation under denaturing conditions. The in vitro degradation rates of the fusion protein were not affected when insoluble fractions were harvested from a strain lacking protease IV, but were significantly reduced when microdialysis experiments were conducted with material isolated from an isogenic ftsH1 mutant. Adenine nucleotides were not required for degradation, and ATP supplementation did not accelerate the apparent rate of TolAI--II--beta-lactamase hydrolysis under denaturing conditions. Our results indicate that the metalloprotease active site of FtsH remains functional in the presence of 3--5 M urea and suggest that the ATPase and proteolytic activities of FtsH can be uncoupled if the substrate is sufficiently unstructured. Thus, a key role of the FtsH AAA module appears to be the net unfolding of bound substrates so that they can be efficiently engaged by the protease active site.     

ATP-dependent FtsH and Lon chloroplast proteases

Arabidopsis thaliana proteome contains 667 proteases; some tens of them are chloroplast-targeted proteins, encoded by genes orthologous to the ones coding for bacterial proteolytic enzymes. It is thought that chloroplast proteases are involved in chloroplasts' proteins turnover and quality control (maturation of nucleus-encoded proteins and removal of nonfunctional ones). Some ATP-dependent chloroplast proteases belonging to FtsH family (especially FtsH2 and FtsH5) are considered to be involved in numerous aspects of chloroplast and whole plant maintenance under non-stressing as well as stressing conditions. This notion is supported by severe phenotype appearance of mutants deficient in these proteases. In contrast to seemingly high physiological importance of chloroplast members of FtsH protease family, only a few individual proteins have been identified so far as their physiological targets (i.e. Lhcb1, Lhcb3, PsbA and Rieske protein). Our knowledge regarding structure and molecular mechanisms of these enzymes' action is limited when compared with what is known about FtsHs of bacterial origin. Equally limited is the knowledge about ATP-dependent Lon4 protease being the single known chloroplast-targeted ortholog of Lon protease of Escherichia coli.