HLA-binding regions of HIV-1 proteins. II. A systematic study of viral proteins.

To detect HLA-binding peptides in 10 HIV-1 proteins (Rev, Tat, Vif, Vpr, Vpu, Gag p18, Gag p24, Gag p15, Env gp120 and Env gp41), the peptide binding assay (PBA) has been performed using three HLA class I molecules. Correlations have been searched between the PBA results and the peptide competitor activity in a functional test using HLA-A2-restricted CTL and target cells. A correlation between the data found in the PBA and well-defined CTL epitopes could be attempted only for the three Gag proteins. For these proteins, our results are in agreement with the known existence of epitopes reacting with human CD8+ CTL, with some exceptions. Together with the results reported with a panel of Nef peptides, these experiments showed that at least 18/20 of the already reported CTL epitopes from HIV-1 Gag, Nef, and Env proteins could be detected by the PBA, most (17/18) corresponding to strong reactivities. Perhaps more important, the regions of HIV-1 Gag p24 or Nef proteins that contain multiple associated CTL epitopes, with different HLA restrictions, were clearly identified by the reactivities in the PBA of several overlapping peptides and the major practical interest of the PBA might be the detection of such polyepitopic regions. Prediction are proposed in this report for 10 proteins, including several proteins for which CTL epitopes remain presently unknown.     

Broad recognition of cytotoxic T cell epitopes from the HIV-1 envelope protein with multiple class I histocompatibility molecules.

A few cases have been described of antigenic determinants that are broadly presented by multiple class II MHC molecules, especially murine I-E or human DR, in which polymorphism is limited to the beta chain, and the alpha chain is conserved. However, no similar cases have been studied for presentation by class I MHC molecules. Because both domains of the MHC peptide binding site are polymorphic in class I molecules, exploring permissiveness in class I presentation would be of interest, and also such broadly presented antigenic determinants would clearly be useful for vaccine development. We had defined an immunodominant determinant, P18, of the HIV-1 gp160 envelope protein recognized by human and murine CTL. To determine the range of class I MHC molecules that could present this peptide and to determine whether two HIV-1 gp160 Th cell determinants, T1 and HP53, could also be presented by class I MHC molecules, we attempted to generate CTL specific for these three peptides in 10 strains of B10 congenic mice, representing 10 MHC types, and BALB/c mice. P18 was presented by at least four different class I MHC molecules from independent haplotypes (H-2d, p, u, and q to CD8+ CTL. In H-2d and H-2q the presentation was mapped to the D-end class I molecule, and for Dd, a requirement for both the alpha 1 and alpha 2 domains of Dd, not Ld, was found. HP53 was also presented by the same four different class I MHC molecules to CD8+ CTL although at higher concentrations. T1 was presented by class I molecules in three different strains of distinct MHC types (B10.M, H-2f; B10.A, H-2a; and B10, H-2b) to CTL. The CTL specific for P18 and HP53 were shown to be CD8+ and CD4- and to kill targets expressing endogenously synthesized whole gp160 as well as targets pulsed with the corresponding peptide. To compare the site within each peptide presented by the different class I molecules, we used overlapping and substituted peptides and found that the critical regions of each peptide are the similar for all four MHC molecules. Thus, antigenic sites are broadly or permissively presented by class I MHC molecules even without a nonpolymorphic domain as found in DR and I-E, and these sequences may be of broad usefulness in a synthetic vaccine.     

Characterization of a conserved T cell epitope in HIV-1 gp41 recognized by vaccine-induced human cytolytic T cells.

A human CTL epitope located in a region of the HIV-1 envelope protein gp41 that is highly conserved among various HIV-1 strains was identified. This epitope was recognized by CD4+ CTL clones that were induced in seronegative humans by immunization with recombinant gp160. Fusion proteins carrying portions of the HIV-1 env gene and synthetic peptides were used to localize this epitope to amino acids 584-595 of the HIV-1 BRU env sequence. Only two positions within this epitope showed variation among North American HIV-1 isolates, and the substitutions were conservative in nature. The Lys to Arg substitution at position 593 abolished recognition, probably by interfering with the peptide-MHC interactions. This epitope was recognized in association with at least one subtype of the widely distributed human class II MHC specificity DPw4, namely DPw4.2. The relatively high frequency of this allele (27.2% among Caucasians) makes it likely that a larger fraction of the population would generate a response directed at this epitope than would be the case for epitopes recognized in the context of gene products of most other class II and class I loci. Interestingly, the closely related DP beta-chain allele types 4.1 and 2.1, which differ from 4.2 by 3 and 1 amino acids, respectively, were unable to present this gp41 peptide to DPw4.2-restricted clones. Comparison of the structure of this epitope with that of other peptides recognized in the context of DPw4.2 led to the identification of a consensus sequence for DPw4.2 binding peptides. Because the gp41 CTL epitope 584-595 identified here is highly conserved and is recognized in the context of a common DP allele, it may represent an important target region for vaccine development. Our results indicate that vaccines containing this epitope may induce in a significant fraction of those immunized CTL active against at least half of all HIV-1 strains.     

Induction of cytotoxic T cells to a cross-reactive epitope in the hepatitis C virus nonstructural RNA polymerase-like protein.

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) have been found to mediate protection in vivo against certain virus infections. CTL also may play an important role in control of infection by hepatitis C virus (HCV), but no CTL epitopes have yet been defined in any HCV protein. The nonstructural protein with homology to RNA polymerase should be a relatively conserved target protein for CTL. To investigate the epitope specificity of CTL specific for this protein, we used 28 peptides from this sequence to study murine CTL. Mice were immunized with a recombinant vaccinia virus expressing the HCV nonstructural region corresponding to the flavivirus NS5 gene (RNA polymerase), and the primed spleen cells were restimulated in vitro with peptides. CTL from H-2d mice responded to a single 16-residue synthetic peptide (HCV 2422 to 2437). This relatively conserved epitope was presented by H-2d class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules to conventional CD4- CD8+ CTL but was not recognized by CTL restricted by H-2b. Moreover, exon shuffle experiments using several transfectants expressing recombinant Dd/Ld and Kd demonstrated that this peptide is seen in association with alpha 1 and alpha 2 domains of the Dd class I MHC molecule. This peptide differs from the homologous segments of this nonstructural region from three other HCV isolates by one residue each. Variant peptides with single amino acid substitutions were made to test the effect of each residue on the ability to sensitize targets. Neither substitution affected recognition. Therefore, these conservative mutations affected peptide interaction neither with the Dd class I MHC molecule nor with the T-cell receptor. Because these CTL cross-react with all four sequenced isolates of HCV in the United States and Japan, if human CTL display similar cross-reactivity, this peptide may be valuable for studies of HCV diagnosis and vaccine development. Our study provides the first evidence that CD8+ CTL can recognize an epitope from the HCV sequence in association with a class I MHC molecule.     

Characteristics of HIV-1 Nef regions containing multiple CD8+ T cell epitopes: wealth of HLA-binding motifs and sensitivity to proteasome degradation

First and foremost among the many factors that influence epitope presentation are the degradation of Ag, which results in peptide liberation, and the presence of HLA class I molecules able to present the peptides to T lymphocytes. To define the regions of HIV-1 Nef that can provide multiple T cell epitopes, we analyzed the Nef sequence and determined that there are 73 peptides containing 81 HLA-binding motifs. We tested the binding of these peptides to six common HLA molecules (HLA-A2, -A3, -A24, -B7, -B8, and -B35), and we showed that most of them were efficient binders (54% of motifs), especially peptides associating with HLA-A3, -B7/35, and -B8 molecules. Nef peptides most frequently recognized by T cells of HIV-1-infected individuals were 90-97, 135-143, 71-81, 77-85, 90-100, 73-82, and 128-137. The frequency of T cell recognition was not directly related to the strength of peptide-HLA binding. The generation of Nef epitopes is crucial; therefore, we investigated the digestion by the 20S proteasome of a large peptide, Nef(66-100). This fragment was efficiently cleaved, and NH(2)-terminally extended precursors of epitope 71-81 were recognized by T cells of an HIV-1-infected individual. These results suggest that a high frequency of T cell recognition may depend on proteasome cleavage.     

Antigen presentation of a modified tumor-derived peptide by tumor infiltrating lymphocytes

CD8+ T-lymphocytes recognize peptides in the context of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I antigens. Upon activation, these cells differentiate into effector cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) and no longer require formal antigen presentation by professional antigen presenting cells (APC). Subsequently, any cell expressing MHC class I/cognate peptide can stimulate CTL. Using TIL specific for a melanoma antigen-derived peptide, IMDQVPFSV (g209 2M), we sought to determine whether these CTL could present peptide to each other. Our findings demonstrate that peptide presentation of the g209 2M peptide epitope by TIL is comparable to conventional methods of using T2 cells as APC. We report here that CTL are capable of self-presentation of antigenic peptide to neighboring CTL resulting in IFN-gamma secretion, proliferation, and lysis of peptide-loaded CTL. These results demonstrate that human TIL possess both APC functions as well as cytotoxic functions and that this phenomenon could influence CTL activity elicited by immunotherapy.     

HIV p24-specific helper T cell clones from immunized primates recognize highly conserved regions of HIV-1.

We have investigated Th cell recognition of the HIV core protein p24 by using CD4+ T cell clones derived from cynomolgus macaques immunized with hybrid HIV p24: Ty virus-like particles (VLP). T cell lines from two immunized animals responded to p24: Ty-VLP, control Ty-VLP, purified p24, and whole inactivated HIV, indicating the presence of T cells specific for p24 as well as the Ty carrier protein. The HIV determinants recognized by the T cell lines were identified by using a series of overlapping peptides synthesized according to the sequence of p24. Both T cell lines recognized peptide 11 (amino acids 235-249) and peptide 14 (amino acids 265-279). In addition, one T cell line also responded to peptide 9 (amino acids 215-229). Definitive identification of two T cell epitopes on p24 was confirmed at the clonal level: from a total of four T cell clones generated from one of the T cell lines, two respond specifically to peptide 11 and two to peptide 14. The T cell clones were CD4+ and MHC class II-restricted and secreted IL-2 in response to stimulation with purified p24, inactivated HIV or a single synthetic peptide. The specificity of the Th clones for variant peptides demonstrated cross-reactivity with two simian immunodeficiency virus isolates, but only limited responses to HIV-2 sequences. However, the Th cell epitopes identified on p24 are highly conserved between 12 HIV-1 isolates and were recognized by both of the immunized primates. These sequences may therefore be useful for priming a broadly reactive immune response to HIV-1.     

Induction of CD4+, human T lymphotropic virus type-1-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes from patients with HAM/TSP. Recognition of an immunogenic region of the gp46 envelope glycoprotein of human T lymphotropic virus type-1.

Although the humoral response to human T lymphotropic virus type-1 (HTLV-I) has been well characterized in patients with HTLV-I-associated neurologic disease (HAM/TSP), little is known about a functional HTLV-I-specific human T cell response, such as CTL, in these patients. To define both the phenotype of the responding CTL and the fine specificity of this response, long term T cell lines were generated from two HAM/TSP patients who were from two different countries. Patient's peripheral blood lymphocytes were repeatedly stimulated in vitro with an HTLV-I expressing autologous T cell line. The resultant long term T cell culture was shown to be CD4+ and cytotoxic for targets expressing HTLV-I Ag. Using a panel of synthetic peptides that span hydrophilic regions of the HTLV-I gp46 envelope glycoprotein, the CTL lines generated from both patients were shown to recognize the same region of the HTLV-I envelope between amino acids 196-209 as defined by the synthetic peptide sp4a1. Interestingly, this sequence overlaps a region of HTLV-I envelope that had also been shown to elicit a strong B cell response in HAM/TSP patients (amino acids 190-203). One CTL line recognized this HTLV-I epitope in the context of HLA DQ5 whereas the other CTL line was restricted by HLA DRw16. The generation of two independent CTL lines from two HAM/TSP patients from different geographic areas that recognize the same region of the HTLV-I envelope glycoprotein highlights the immunogenic nature of this envelope region.     

Defining MHC class II T helper epitopes for WT1 tumor antigen

The product of Wilms‘ tumor gene 1 (WT1) is overexpressed in diverse human tumors, including leukemia, lung and breast cancer, and is often recognized by antibodies in the sera of patients with leukemia. Since WT1 encodes MHC class I-restricted peptides recognized by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL), WT1 has been considered as a promising tumor-associated antigen (TAA) for developing anticancer immunotherapy. In order to carry out an effective peptide-based cancer immunotherapy, MHC class II-restricted epitope peptides that elicit anti-tumor CD4⁺ helper T lymphocytes (HTL) will be needed. In this study, we analyzed HTL responses against WT1 antigen using HTL lines elicited by in vitro immunization of human lymphocytes with synthetic peptides predicted to serve as HTL epitopes derived from the sequence of WT1. Two peptides, WT1_124–138 and WT1_247–261, were shown to induce peptide-specific HTL, which were restricted by frequently expressed HLA class II alleles. Here, we also demonstrate that both peptides-reactive HTL lines were capable of recognizing naturally processed antigens presented by dendritic cells pulsed with tumor lysates or directly by WT1+ tumor cells that express MHC class II molecules. Interestingly, the two WT1 HTL epitopes described here are closely situated to known MHC class I-restricted CTL epitopes, raising the possibility of stimulating CTL and HTL responses using a relatively small synthetic peptide vaccine. Because HTL responses to TAA are known to be important for promoting long-lasting anti-tumor CTL responses, the newly described WT1 T-helper epitopes could provide a useful tool for designing powerful vaccines against WT1-expressing tumors.     

Tumor-associated antigen human chorionic gonadotropin beta contains numerous antigenic determinants recognized by in vitro-induced CD8+ and CD4+ T lymphocytes

The beta subunit of human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG beta) is markedly overexpressed by neoplastic cells of differing histological origin including those present in colon, breast, prostate and bladder tumors. We have previously shown that some patients with hCG beta-producing urothelial tumors have circulating T cells that proliferate in response to hCG beta. To make a comprehensive study of hCG beta as a potential target for cancer immunotherapy, we investigated whether hCG beta peptides could induce CD4+ or CD8+ T-cell responses in vitro. By stimulating peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) from three donors with mixtures of overlapping 16-mer synthetic peptides analogous to portions of either the hCG beta 20-71 or the hCG beta 102-129 region, we established six CD4+ T-cell lines that proliferated specifically in response to five distinct determinants located within these two hCG beta regions. Three antigenic determinants (hCG beta 52-67, 106-121 and 114-125) were presented by HLA-DR molecules, while the two other antigenic determinants (hCG beta 48-63 and 56-67) were presented by HLA-DQ molecules. Interestingly, one T-cell line specific for peptide hCG beta 106-121 recognized hCG beta peptides comprising, at position 117, either an alanine or an aspartic acid residue, with the latter residue being present within the protein expressed by some tumor cells. In addition, three other hCG beta-derived peptides that exhibited HLA-A*0201 binding ability were able to stimulate CD8+ cytotoxic T cells from two HLA-A*0201 donors. These three immunogenic peptides corresponded to regions hCG beta 40-48, hCG beta 44-52 and hCG beta 75-84. Our results indicate that the tumor-associated antigen hCG beta possesses numerous antigenic determinants liable to stimulate CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphocytes, and might thus be an effective target antigen for the immunotherapy of hCG beta-producing tumors.     

Affinity enhancement and transmembrane signaling are associated with distinct epitopes on the CD8 alpha beta heterodimer.

CD8 is a heterodimeric membrane glycoprotein on MHC class I-restricted T lymphocytes that cooperates with the alpha beta CD3 TCR in the recognition of MHC class I molecules presenting antigenic peptides. Co-operation has two components: enhancement of the affinity of MHC/peptide-TCR interaction, and signal transduction through the T cell membrane. The cytolytic function of CTL is primarily dependent on the affinity-enhancement component of CD8-TCR cooperation whereas activation of resting CD8+ T cells is primarily dependent on transmembrane signaling. Using a panel of mAb, two to the alpha-chain and three to the beta-chain of CD8, we investigated the relationships between epitopes and functional regions of the CD8 molecule. Two of the antibodies, one to the alpha-chain and one to the beta-chain of CD8, inhibit the cytolytic function of CTL but not the generation of CTL from resting T cells. Another two antibodies, also one to the alpha- and one to the beta-chain, inhibited the generation of CTL while enhancing the cytolytic function of CTL. These results suggest that both the alpha- and beta-chain of CD8 possess two distinct regions, one involved in affinity enhancement and the other in transmembrane signaling. The former may be the MHC class I-binding region whereas the latter may associate with the alpha beta CD3 TCR. The data can explain the apparent functional equivalence of CD8 alpha alpha homodimers and alpha beta heterodimers.     

In vitro induction of HLA-A2402-restricted and carcinoembryonic-antigen-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes on fixed autologous peripheral blood cells

HLA-A2402-restricted and carcinoembryonic-antigen(CEA)-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) were induced by culturing human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) on formalin-fixed autologous adhesive PBMC that had been loaded with CEA-bound latex beads. The CTL killed the CEA-producing HLA-type matched cancer cells, but not the non-producers of CEA, at an effector/target ratio of 10 within 24 h. On the basis of available HLA-A24-binding peptides, we have also attempted to identify the epitope peptide recognized by the CTL. The peptide CEA652(9), TYACFVSNL, stimulated the CTL most strongly when pulsed on HLA-A2402-expressing target cells. The other nine peptides so far tested were also active, but less efficient in their effect on CTL. The CTL failed to kill target cells pulsed with the HLA-A2-binding CEA peptide, CAP-1. The CTL were also generated on the fixed adherent cells previously pulsed with the peptide CEA652(9). Cytotoxic activity of the CTL was inhibited by monoclonal antibodies against CD3, CD8, and MHC class I molecules. These results suggest that human autologous CTL will be inducible on the autologous fixed PBMC without use of the cultured target cancer cells if tumor antigenic protein is available. Received: 31 December 1997 / Accepted: 4 May 1998     

Presence of a helix in human CD4 cytoplasmic domain promotes binding to HIV-1 Nef protein

The Nef proteins of simian and human immunodeficiency viruses are known to directly bind and downregulate the CD4 receptor of infected cells. Recent results suggest that residues forming an alpha-helix N-cap in the CD4 cytoplasmic domain play a role in binding of CD4 to human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Nef protein. We determined the dissociation constants between Nef and several CD4 peptides that contain or do not contain the respective alpha-helix N-cap. Further, we compared helical secondary structure content of these CD4 peptide variants by circular dichroism spectroscopy. We conclude that presence of an alpha-helix in CD4 cytoplasmic domain increases CD4 affinity to Nef. In addition, the amino acid sequence of residues forming the helix N-cap influences CD4 affinity to Nef, too. Finally, the structural changes induced in Nef and CD4 upon binding to each other are investigated.     

Increased breadth and depth of cytotoxic T lymphocytes responses against HIV-1-B Nef by inclusion of epitope variant sequences

Different vaccine approaches cope with HIV-1 diversity, ranging from centralized^1–4 to variability-encompassing^5–7 antigens. For all these strategies, a concern remains: how does HIV-1 diversity impact epitope recognition by the immune system? We studied the relationship between HIV-1 diversity and CD8⁺ T Lymphocytes (CTL) targeting of HIV-1 subtype B Nef using 944 peptides (10-mers overlapping by nine amino acids (AA)) that corresponded to consensus peptides and their most common variants in the HIV-1-B virus population. IFN-γ ELISpot assays were performed using freshly isolated PBMC from 26 HIV-1-infected persons. Three hundred and fifty peptides elicited a response in at least one individual. Individuals targeted a median of 7 discrete regions. Overall, 33% of responses were directed against viral variants but not elicited against consensus-based test peptides. However, there was no significant relationship between the frequency of a 10-mer in the viral population and either its frequency of recognition (Spearman''s correlation coefficient ρ = 0.24) or the magnitude of the responses (ρ = 0.16). We found that peptides with a single mutation compared to the consensus were likely to be recognized (especially if the change was conservative) and to elicit responses of similar magnitude as the consensus peptide. Our results indicate that cross-reactivity between rare and frequent variants is likely to play a role in the expansion of CTL responses, and that maximizing antigenic diversity in a vaccine may increase the breadth and depth of CTL responses. However, since there are few obvious preferred pathways to virologic escape, the diversity that may be required to block all potential escape pathways may be too large for a realistic vaccine to accommodate. Furthermore, since peptides were not recognized based on their frequency in the population, it remains unclear by which mechanisms variability-inclusive antigens (i.e., constructs enriched with frequent variants) expand CTL recognition.     

Poliovirus-specific major histocompatibility complex class I-restricted cytolytic T-cell epitopes in mice localize to neutralizing antigenic regions.

A major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I-restricted cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) response is induced in BALB/c mice upon immunization with poliovirus serotype 1 (Mahoney strain). A similar class I-restricted response is also induced upon immunization with purified VP1 capsid proteins. Thus, poliovirus-specific MHC class I CTL responses can be induced independently of viral infection in murine hosts. In experiments using recombinant vaccinia virus vectors expressing different segments of the poliovirus capsid proteins and synthetic peptides, two regions of the VP1 capsid protein appear to contain epitopes recognized by this bulk CTL population. These epitope regions contain a Kd-restricted peptide-binding motif. Interestingly, each of these CTL epitopes is located near previously defined neutralizing antigenic sites.     

A CD4+ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte clone to a conserved epitope on human immunodeficiency virus type 1 p24: cytotoxic activity and secretion of interleukin-2 and interleukin-6.

A CD4+ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) clone, established from the peripheral blood of a human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-seropositive donor, lysed autologous target cells that were infected with a recombinant vaccinia virus containing the gag gene of HIV type 1 and target cells pulsed with p24gag construct expressed in Escherichia coli. The recognition of the HLA-DQ-restricted epitope by this clone was further defined by using overlapping synthetic peptides. The epitope recognized by this CD4+ CTL clone (amino acids 140 to 148) overlaps with a CD8+ epitope and is highly conserved among all isolates of HIV type 1 that have been sequenced. Production and secretion of lymphokines such as interleukin-2 and interleukin-6 after specific antigenic stimulation were demonstrated by this gag-specific CD4+ CTL clone.     

Three epitopic peptides of the simian immunodeficiency virus Nef protein recognized by macaque cytolytic T lymphocytes.

In 8 of 12 experimentally infected macaques, the Nef SIVmac 251 protein was recognized by cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) and appeared strongly immunogenic. Here, we report experiments which have been performed by using synthetic peptides to precisely determine the epitopes recognized by macaque CTL. Three epitopes of the Nef protein have been defined as CTL targets in three macaques. The epitopic peptides are located in the central region of the protein, and all of them show high homology with peptides of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Nef protein recognized by human CTL in association with several human leukocyte antigen molecules. These results suggest that (i) the Nef protein is a good candidate for vaccination not only because of its early expression but also because of its high immunogenicity for CTL, (ii) long peptides covering the central region of this protein could be used as vaccines and could cross the major histocompatibility complex barrier in a large variety of individuals, and (iii) the rhesus macaque is a good animal model in which to test for protection by CTL.     

Recognition of a sequestered self peptide by influenza virus-specific CD8+ cytolytic T lymphocytes

The Ag receptors on CD8+ CTL recognize foreign antigenic peptides associated with cell surface MHC class I molecules. Peptides derived from self proteins are also normally presented by MHC class I molecules. Here we report that an H-2Kd-restricted murine CD8+ CTL clone directed to an influenza hemagglutinin epitope can recognize a peptide derived from the murine mitochondrial aconitase enzyme in association with H-2Kd molecules. Surprisingly, this self peptide is not normally displayed on the cell surface associated with the restricting MHC class I molecule. Several lines of evidence suggest that this self peptide, although requiring association with the Kd molecule for CTL recognition, is not associated with this or other MHC class I allele under physiologic conditions in intact cells. Rather, it is sequestered in the cytoplasm associated with a carrier protein and is released only upon cell disruption. These results suggest a means of restricting the entry of self peptide into the class I pathway. In addition, this finding raises the possibility that self peptides sequestered within the cell can, after release from damaged cells, interact with MHC class I molecules on bystander cells and trigger autoimmune injury by virus-specific CTLs during viral infection.