Plasmid deletion formation between short direct repeats in Bacillus subtilis is stimulated by single-stranded rolling-circle replication intermediates

Summary The effects of the rolling-circle mode of replication and the generation of single-stranded DNA (ss DNA) on plasmid deletion formation between short direct repeats in Bacillus subtilis were studied. Deletion units consisting of direct repeats (9, 18, or 27 bp) that do or do not flank inverted repeats (300 bp) were introduced into various plasmid replicons that generate different amounts of ss DNA (from 0% to 40% of the total plasmid DNA). With ss DNA-generating rolling-circle-type plasmids, deletion frequencies between the direct repeats were 3- to 13-fold higher than in plasmids not generating ss DNA. When the direct repeats flanked inverted repeats the deletion frequencies in ss DNA-generating plasmids were increased by as much as 20- to 140-fold. These results support models for deletion formation based on template-switching errors during complementary strand synthesis of rolling-circle-type plasmids. The structural instability (deletion formation between short direct repeats) of the ss DNA-generating plasmid pTA1060 in B. subtilis was very low in the presence of a functional initiation site for complementary strand synthesis (minus origin). This observation suggests that it will be possible to develop stable host-vector cloning systems for B. subtilis.     

Molecular mechanisms of deletion formation in Escherichia coli plasmids. I. Deletion formation mediated by long direct repeats.

Summary Derivatives of plasmid pBR327 with the tet gene interrupted by 165 pb or 401 by direct repeats were constructed. In cells harboring these plasmids, deletions which restored the wild-type tet gene gave rise to tetracycline-resistant colonies, thereby allowing a simple phenotypic test for deletion formation. The frequencies of deletions in these plasmids were measured in Escherichia coli strains proficient or deficient in general recombination. The structure of plasmid DNA isolated from tetracycline-resistant transformants was analyzed by agarose gel electrophoresis, restriction mapping and sequencing. The data presented here demonstrate that deletion formation is always associated with dimerization of plasmid DNA. Dimeric plasmids were of two types. Those which carried both a deletion and a compensating duplication were the major type in a Rec⁺ background and were rare in recA, recF, recJ and recO backgrounds. Dimers of the second type contained deletions, but no compensating duplications, and their formation was RecA-independent. The data presented demonstrate that deletion formation mediated by long direct repeats is mainly the result of unequal crossing-over between two plasmid molecules.     

Plasmid control of recombination in E. coli K 12

Summary The recombination proficiency of three recipient strains of Escherichia coli K 12 carrying different plasmids was investigated by conjugal mating with Hfr Cavalli. Some plasmids (e.g. R1drd 19, R6K) caused a marked reduction in the yield of recombinants formed in crosses with Hfr but did not reduce the ability of host strains to accept plasmid F104. The effect of plasmids on recombination was host-dependent. In Hfr crosses with AB1157 (R1-19) used as a recipient the linkage between selected and unselected proximal markers of the donor was sharply decreased. Plasmid R1-19 also decreased the yield of recombinants formed by recF, recL, and recB recC sbcA mutants, showed no effect on the recombination proficiency of recB recC sbcB mutant, and increased the recombination proficiency of recB, recB recC sbcB recF, and recB recC sbcB recL mutants. An ATP-dependent exonuclease activity was found in all tested recB recC mutants carrying plasmid R1-19, while this plasmid did not affect the activity of exonuclease I in strain AB1157 and its rec ^– derivatives. The same plasmid was also found to protect different rec ^– derivatives of the strain AB1157 against the lethal action of UV light. We suppose that a new ATP-dependent exonuclease determined by R1-19 plays a role in both repair and recombination of the host through the substitution of or competition with the exoV coded for by the genes recB and recC.     

Recombination between repeats in Escherichia coli by a recA-independent, proximity-sensitive mechanism

We have examined the influence of proximity on the efficiency of recombination between repeated DNA sequences in Escherichia coli. Our experiments have employed a plasmid-based assay to detect deletions between direct repeats of 100 bp. The rate of deletion of the juxtaposed direct repeats was reasonably high at 6 × 10^–5 per cell. A comparison of recA+ and recA mutant strains showed that these deletion events are primarily the result of recA-independent recombination at these homologous sequences. Random restriction fragments of yeast or E. coli genomic DNA were used to separate the two repeats. Deletion rates decreased over two orders of magnitude with increasing separation of up to 7 kb. There was a surprisingly strong effect of even short sequence separations, with insertions of a few hundred base pairs exhibiting 10-fold reductions of deletion rates. No effect of recA on the efficiency of deletion was observed at any distance between repeats.     

Molecular aspects of genetic instability of an artificial 68 bp perfect palindrome in Escherichia coli

Summary An artificial 68 bp perfect palindrome carried on a plasmid (pAS807) is genetically unstable. An increase in the population of cells harbouring palindrome-deleted pAS807 derivatives (pAS807-) is observed as the number of cell generations increases. The calculated frequency of palindrome excision events per cell generation and per plasmid replication round in Escherichia coli is 0.95x10^-4. Sequence analysis of eight independent isolates of palindrome-deleted molecules, reveals two symmetrical deletion types (three of type I and five of type II). The two types of pAS807- molecules retain 19 bp of the original sequence of the 68 bp palindrome but differ in the content of the central 3 bp. The generation of the two deletion types is best explained by formation of intermediate cruciform structures. Following the fate of the palindrome in various bacterial mutants, we find that the excision events depend on functional polA1, polA(ex1), lig, texA343(recC343) and texA344(recB344) gene products. However, recB21 recC22 mutations do not affect palindrome excision.     

The origin of transfer (oriT) of the conjugative plasmid R46: characterization by deletion analysis and DNA sequencing

Summary The origin of transfer (oriT) is the sequence within which conjugal transfer of plasmid DNA is initiated, and is absolutely required in cis for plasmid mobilization. We have cloned oriT from the 52 kb IncN plasmid R46 on a 600 bp fragment, and mapped the limits of the relevant sequence by deletion analysis and transposon mutagenesis. The nucleotide sequence of the oriT region contains 13 direct repeats of an 11 bp consensus sequence, 3 different pairs of 10 bp inverted repeats, and a segment that is extremely A-T rich. The direct repeats are within a region required for high frequency transfer and their sequence is such that their periodic alignment along the helix may induce curvature of the DNA. Analysis of Tn1725 insertions within the sequenced fragment of R46 revealed that, unlike most other transposons, transposition of Tn1725 can cause target sequence duplications of three different sizes.     

Structural plasmid instability in Bacillus subtilis: Effect of direct and inverted repeats

Summary Using precise excision as a model system, we have quantified the effect of direct repeats, inverted repeats and the size of the spacer between the repeats in the process of deletion formation in Bacillus subtilis. Both in the presence and absence of inverted repeats, the frequency of precise excision was strongly dependent on the direct repeat length. By increasing the direct repeat length from 9 bp to 18 and 27 bp, the precise excision frequency was raised by 3 and 4 orders of magnitude, respectively. In addition, irrespective of the direct repeat length, the presence of flanking inverted repeats enhanced the excision frequency by 3 orders of magnitude. Varying the inverted repeat length and the spacer size over a wide range did not significantly affect the excision frequencies. These results fit well into a model for deletion formation by slipped mispairing during replication of single-stranded plasmid DNA.     

Replication of the broad-host-range plasmid RK2: isolation and characterization of a spontaneous deletion mutant that can replicate in Agrobacterium tumefaciens but not in Escherichia coli

Two spontaneous deletions of a derivative of the broad-host-range plasmid RK2 were isolated from Agrobacterium tumefaciens. The two deletions have lost 56 and 505 bp, respectively, near the origin of replication (oriV). Of the eight 17-bp repeats present in the RK2 oriV, the smaller deletion has lost the first two while the larger one has lost the first three. The deletions led to a significant increase (3- to 7-fold) in plasmid copy number in A. tumefaciens, indicating their importance in copy number control. While the smaller deletion could replicate in Escherichia coli, the larger one could not. The role of the oriV sequences in the replication of pRK2 in A. tumefaciens and in E. coli is discussed.     

Mechanism of sbcB-suppression of the recBC-deficiency in postreplication repair in UV-irradiated Escherichia coli K-12

Summary The mechanism by which an sbcB mutation suppresses the deficiency in postreplication repair shown by recB recC mutants of Escherichia coli was studied. The presence of an sbcB mutation in uvrA recB recC cells increased their resistance to UV radiation. This enhanced resistance was not due to a suppression of the minor deficiency in the repair of DNA daughter-strand gaps or to an inhibition of the production of DNA double-strand breaks in UV-irradiated uvrA recB recC cells; rather, the presence of an sbcB mutation, enabled uvrA recB recC cells to carry out the repair of DNA double-strand breaks. In the uvrA recB recC sbcB background, a mutation, at recF produced a huge sensitization to UV radiation, and it rendered cells deficient in the repair of both DNA daughter-strand gaps and DNA double-strand breaks. Thus, an additional sbcB mutation in uvrA recB recC cells restored their ability to perform the repair of DNA double-strand breaks, but the further addition of a recF mutation blocked this repair capacity.     

Sequence analysis of the family of penicillinase-producing plasmids of Neisseria gonorrhoeae

The exact nature of the sequence differences between the medically important family of gonococcal penicillinase-producing plasmids has been ascertained. The entire DNA sequence of the Asia-type plasmid, pJD4, demonstrated that it is 7426 bp and contains two direct repeats (DR30) that are implicated in the formation of deletion variant plasmids, such as the Africa-type plasmid. We have identified putative DnaA and IHF binding sites, various open reading frames that are thought to specify functional proteins, and some important DNA sequences involved with conjugative transfer of gonococcal beta-lactamase plasmids. The deletion in the Africa-type plasmid is 1827 bp and one of the DR30 repeats is also missing. The deletion in the Rio-type plasmid and several Toronto-type plasmids was determined to be 2273 bp and the sequence spanning the deletion was identical irrespective of geographic or temporal origin. The &Ncirc;imes-type plasmid is an Africa-type plasmid and also contains an IS5 insertion sequence. Since IS5 has not been identified in gonococcal isolates, we suggest that this sequence may have been inserted after the original gonococcal plasmid was transformed into Escherichia coli. The New Zealand plasmid is an Asia-type plasmid that contains an endogenous tandem duplication of 1883 bp and the direct DR2 is implicated in this duplication. The nature of the defined truncation of Tn2 present in the various plasmids is also discussed.     

Frequency of deletion formation decreases exponentially with distance between short direct repeats

The effect of distance between 18 bp direct repeats on deletion formation has been examined in Bacillus subtilis. The deletion frequency decreased exponentially by more than 1000-fold as the distance increased from 33 to 2313 bp. This decrease occurred in two distinct phases, which may be determined by DNA-duplex flexibility. A similar relationship between deletion formation and distance was observed in a θ-replicating plasmid and in the chromosome, indicating that this relationship might have a general validity.     

The Influence of Primary and Secondary DNA Structure in Deletion and Duplication between Direct Repeats in Escherichia Coli

We describe a system to measure the frequency of both deletions and duplications between direct repeats. Short 17- and 18-bp palindromic and nonpalindromic DNA sequences were cloned into the EcoRI site within the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene of plasmids pBR325 and pJT7. This creates an insert between direct repeated EcoRI sites and results in a chloramphenicol-sensitive phenotype. Selection for chloramphenicol resistance was utilized to select chloramphenicol resistant revertants that included those with precise deletion of the insert from plasmid pBR325 and duplication of the insert in plasmid pJT7. The frequency of deletion or duplication varied more than 500-fold depending on the sequence of the short sequence inserted into the EcoRI site. For the nonpalindromic inserts, multiple internal direct repeats and the length of the direct repeats appear to influence the frequency of deletion. Certain palindromic DNA sequences with the potential to form DNA hairpin structures that might stabilize the misalignment of direct repeats had a high frequency of deletion. Other DNA sequences with the potential to form structures that might destabilize misalignment of direct repeats had a very low frequency of deletion. Duplication mutations occurred at the highest frequency when the DNA between the direct repeats contained no direct or inverted repeats. The presence of inverted repeats dramatically reduced the frequency of duplications. The results support the slippage-misalignment model, suggesting that misalignment occurring during DNA replication leads to deletion and duplication mutations. The results also support the idea that the formation of DNA secondary structures during DNA replication can facilitate and direct specific mutagenic events.     

Single Strand Annealing Plays a Major Role in RecA-Independent Recombination between Repeated Sequences in the Radioresistant Deinococcus radiodurans Bacterium

The bacterium Deinococcus radiodurans is one of the most radioresistant organisms known. It is able to reconstruct a functional genome from hundreds of radiation-induced chromosomal fragments. Our work aims to highlight the genes involved in recombination between 438 bp direct repeats separated by intervening sequences of various lengths ranging from 1,479 bp to 10,500 bp to restore a functional tetA gene in the presence or absence of radiation-induced DNA double strand breaks. The frequency of spontaneous deletion events between the chromosomal direct repeats were the same in recA+ and in ΔrecA, ΔrecF, and ΔrecO bacteria, whereas recombination between chromosomal and plasmid DNA was shown to be strictly dependent on the RecA and RecF proteins. The presence of mutations in one of the repeated sequence reduced, in a MutS-dependent manner, the frequency of the deletion events. The distance between the repeats did not influence the frequencies of deletion events in recA ⁺ as well in ΔrecA bacteria. The absence of the UvrD protein stimulated the recombination between the direct repeats whereas the absence of the DdrB protein, previously shown to be involved in DNA double strand break repair through a single strand annealing (SSA) pathway, strongly reduces the frequency of RecA- (and RecO-) independent deletions events. The absence of the DdrB protein also increased the lethal sectoring of cells devoid of RecA or RecO protein. γ-irradiation of recA ⁺ cells increased about 10-fold the frequencies of the deletion events, but at a lesser extend in cells devoid of the DdrB protein. Altogether, our results suggest a major role of single strand annealing in DNA repeat deletion events in bacteria devoid of the RecA protein, and also in recA ⁺ bacteria exposed to ionizing radiation.     

On the Deletion of Inverted Repeated DNA in Escherichia Coli: Effects of Length, Thermal Stability, and Cruciform Formation in Vivo

We have studied the deletion of inverted repeats cloned into the EcoRI site within the CAT gene of plasmid pBR325. A cloned inverted repeat constitutes a palindrome that includes both EcoRI sites flanking the insert. In addition, the two EcoRI sites represent direct repeats flanking a region of palindromic symmetry. A current model for deletion between direct repeats involves the formation of DNA secondary structure which may stabilize the misalignment between the direct repeats during DNA replication. Our results are consistent with this model. We have analyzed deletion frequencies for several series of inverted repeats, ranging from 42 to 106 bp, that were designed to form cruciforms at low temperatures and at low superhelical densities. We demonstrate that length, thermal stability of base pairing in the hairpin stem, and ease of cruciform formation affect the frequency of deletion. In general, longer palindromes are less stable than shorter ones. The deletion frequency may be dependent on the thermal stability of base pairing involving approximately 16-20 bp from the base of the hairpin stem. The formation of cruciforms in vivo leads to a significant increase in the deletion frequency. A kinetic model is presented to describe the relationship between the physical-chemical properties of DNA structure and the deletion of inverted repeats in living cells.     

A plasmid sequence from Rhizobium leguminosarum 300 contains homology to sequences near the octopine TL-DNA right border

Summary The DNA sequence from a Rhizobium leguminosarum 300 (RL300) plasmid that contains homology to the T_c-DNA of Agrobacterium tumefaciens is described. The RL300 sequence has 78% homology to a 359 bp sequence in the T_c-DNA of pTi15955. The RL300 homology starts approximately 100 bp from the 24 bp border sequence of the T_L-DNA and ends approximately 3 bp from an IS66 homolog in the T_c-DNA. An unusual feature of the RL300 homology is the presence of 81 bp direct repeats with T_c-DNA homology, separated by 201 bp. One end of each direct repeat has a 12 bp palindrome. Four cloned sequences of RL300 with homology to the T DNA region were hybridized to plasmid lysates of RL300 derivatives to determine the source of each plasmid. The sequenced homolog, originally on pRH228, was isolated from pRL7JI; the other 3 homologs were isolated from the transmissable plasmids pRL7JI (pRH235) and pRL8JI (pRH235 and pRH236).     

Asymmetric crossing over in the spontaneous formation of large deletions in the tonB-trp region of the Escherichia coli K-12 chromosome.

The chromosomal tonB gene of Escherichia coli was used as a target for the detection of spontaneous deletion mutations. The deletions were isolated in both recA ⁺ and recA ⁻ cells, and mutants carrying large deletions were identified because they also lacked part or all of the trp operon. The frequencies of tonB-trp deletion were 1.79 × 10⁻⁹ and 1.09 × 10⁻⁹ for recA ⁺ and recA ⁻ cells, respectively. We analyzed 12 deletions from recA ⁺ and 10 from recA ⁻ cells by cloning and direct sequencing. The deletions ranged in size from 5612 bp to 15142 bp for recA ⁺ and from 5428 bp to 13289 for recA ⁻ cells. Three deletions from recA ⁺ cells and five deletions from recA ⁻ cells were found to have occurred between short sequence repeats at the termini of the deletion, leaving one copy of the repeat in the mutant sequence. Seven deletions from recA ⁺ cells and three deletions from recA ⁻ cells did not have repeats at their termini; in these cases, the DNA sequences that are adjacent to the deletion termini in the wild-type are characterized by short (2–4 bp) repeats. From these results, a model is presented for the generation of deletion mutations which involves formation of an asymmetric crossover mediated by repeated sequences of 2- to 4-bp. Received: 14 September 1998 / Accepted: 22 December 1998     

Recombination between short direct repeats in a RecA host

Summary Spontaneous deletion derivitives of plasmid pHV14, a recombinant of pBR322, have been isolated in the recA strain HB101. About 2.5 kilobases (Kb) of DNA has been lost in each of the four plasmids described including, in two cases the region involved in control of copy number and the initiation of replication.Sequence analysis of each deletion junction has revealed that in 3 out of 4 cases the deletion event occured by recombination between short direct repeats of as little as 7 base pairs (bp).     

High Frequency Plasmid Recombination Mediated by 28 bp Direct Repeats

The stability in Escherichia coli of a mammalian expression vector (pCIneo) and its derivative candidate DNA vaccine (pGPV-PV) is described. These multicopy pMB1-type plasmids were found to recombine in several recA E. coli strains due to the presence of two 28 bp direct repeats flanking intervening sequences of 1.6 kb (pCIneo) and 3.2 kb (pGPV-PV). In this recombination event, one of the direct repeats and the intervening sequence were deleted or duplicated, originating monomeric or/and hetero-dimeric plasmid forms, respectively. Additionally, the plasmid rearrangement led to the acquisition of a kanamycin resistance phenotype. Recombination frequencies between 7.8 × 10⁻⁷ and 3.1 × 10⁻⁵ were determined for DH5α and JM109(DE3) strains, respectively. Higher recombination frequencies were found in cells previously grown up to stationary growth phase being the monomeric plasmid form the prevalent one. Real-time PCR quantification revealed the presence of approximately 1.5 × 10⁴ recombined molecules per 2 × 10⁵ cells pre-kanamycin exposure. Under selective pressure of this antibiotic, the number of recombined molecules increased approximately 2,000-fold in a 48-h period replacing the original plasmid form. The high frequency, at which deletion-duplication occurred in the absence of kanamycin selective pressure, should be regarded as a safety concern. This work highlights the impact of mutational hot spots on expression and cloning plasmid vectors and the need to carefully design plasmid vectors. Sofia C. Ribeiro and Pedro H. Oliveira contributed equally to this work.     

Direct repeat sequences are essential for function of the cis-acting locus of transfer (clt) of Streptomyces phaeochromogenes plasmid pJV1

The functionality of direct and inverted repeat sequences inside the cis acting locus of transfer (clt) of the Streptomyces plasmid pJV1 was determined by testing the effect of different deletions on plasmid transfer. The results show that the single most important element for pJV1 clt function is a series of evenly spaced 9 bp long direct repeats which match the consensus CCGCACA(C/G)(C/G), since their deletion caused a dramatic reduction in plasmid transfer. The presence of these repeats in the absence of any other clt sequences allowed plasmid transfer to occur at a frequency that was at least two orders of magnitude higher than that obtained in the complete absence of clt. A database search revealed regions with a similar organization, and in the same position, in Streptomyces plasmids pSN22 and pSLS, which have transfer proteins homologous to those of pJV1.     

Palindromy and the Location of Deletion Endpoints in Escherichia Coli

The contributions of direct and inverted repeats to deletion formation were studied by characterizing Ampr revertants of plasmids with a series of insertion mutations at a specific site in the pBR322 ampicillin resistance (amp) gene. The inserts at this site are palindromic, variable in length, and bracketed by 9- or 10-bp direct repeats of amp sequence. There is an additional direct repeat composed of 4 bp within the insert and 4 bp of adjoining amp sequence. DNA sequencing and colony hybridization of Ampr revertants showed that they contained either the parental amp sequence, implying deletion endpoints in the flanking 9- or 10-bp repeats, or a specific 1-bp substitution, implying endpoints in the 4-bp repeats. Although generally direct repeats seem to be used as deletion endpoints with a frequency proportional to their lengths, we found that with uninterrupted palindromes longer than 32 bp, the majority of deletions ended in the 4 bp, not the 9- or 10-bp repeats. This preferential use of the shorter direct repeats associated with palindromes is interpreted according to a DNA synthesis-error model in which hairpin structures formed by intrastrand pairing foster the slippage of nascent strands during DNA synthesis.