Gene interactions and epigenetic variation in transgenic plants

Unusual gene interactions were observed in several doubly transformed tobacco plants which were obtained following sequential transformation steps using two T-DNAs encoding different selection and screening markers. The expression of T-DNA-I, which encoded kanamycin resistance (Kan^r) and nopaline synthase (NOS), was suppressed in some, but not all, of the double transformants after the introduction of T-DNA-II, which encoded hygromycin resistance (Hyg^r) and octopine synthase (OCS). Double transformants in which T-DNA-I had been inactivated could produce Kan^rNOS⁺ progeny, but these were shown to lack T-DNA-II, thus establishing the role of this T-DNA in the suppression of T-DNA-I. Reversible cytosine methylation of the promoters of T-DNA-I genes was shown to correlate with their activation/inactivation cycle. In this paper we pursue further the questions of the mechanism of suppression of T-DNA-I genes by T-DNA-II, and also the timing and extent of demethylation of T-DNA-I promoters in Kan^r progeny following the loss of T-DNA-II. We propose that the suppression is due to the competition between homologous regions on each T-DNA for binding to nuclear sites with fixed locations. We further suggest that incomplete demethylation patterns of T-DNA-I promoters in Kan^r progeny reflect the existence in the shoot apex meristem of two cell populations, which have either methylated or unmethylated T-DNA-I promoters, respectively. Thus, Kan^r progeny are epigenetic chimeras with respect to the expression of T-DNA-I genes.     

Analysis of the T-DNA structure in a large number of transgenic petunias generated by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation

Southern hybridisation was performed on ninety-six transgenic petunias that had been selected for resistance to kanamycin. Just over half of the plants contained intact copies of the T-DNA. The most common rearrangements (at least 24 plants out of 96) were simple deleted derivatives that had lost one or both ends of the T-DNA. T-DNAs lacking the left border occurred at a frequency of 20%, and estimates of the frequency of T-DNAs lacking the right border were at least this high. Three plants contained grossly rearranged T-DNAs, of which all expressed the kanamycin resistance gene but only one transmitted the gene to progeny. Two plants lacked T-DNA homology altogether and did not express kanamycin resistance in their leaves or their progeny. Circumstantial evidence suggests that plants containing a chimaeric kanamycin resistance gene driven by the ocs promoter do not root efficiently in the presence of kanamycin. There was no correlation between intactness of the T-DNA and Mendelian inheritance of the kanamycin-resistance phenotype. However, a disproportionate number of plants showing non-Mendelian inheritance had a high copy number of their T-DNA.     

A large-scale study of rice plants transformed with different T-DNAs provides new insights into locus composition and T-DNA linkage configurations

Transgenic locus composition and T-DNA linkage configuration were assessed in a population of rice plants transformed using the dual-binary vector system pGreen (T-DNA containing the bar and gus genes)/pSoup (T-DNA containing the aphIV and gfp genes). Transgene structure, expression and inheritance were analysed in 62 independently transformed plant lines and in around 4,000 progeny plants. The plant lines exhibited a wide variety of transgenic locus number and composition. The most frequent form of integration was where both T-DNAs integrated at the same locus (56% of loci). When single-type T-DNA integration occurred (44% of loci), pGreen T-DNA was preferentially integrated. In around half of the plant lines (52%), the T-DNAs integrated at two independent loci or more. In these plants, both mixed and single-type T-DNA integration often occurred concurrently at different loci during the transformation process. Non-intact T-DNAs were present in 70–78% of the plant lines causing 14–21% of the loci to contain only the mid to right border part of a T-DNA. In 53–66% of the loci, T-DNA integrated with vector backbone sequences. Comparison of transgene presence and expression in progeny plants showed that segregation of the transgene phenotype was not a reliable indicator of either transgene inheritance or T-DNA linkage, as only 60–80% of the transgenic loci were detected by the expression study. Co-expression (28% of lines) and backbone transfer (53–66% of loci) were generally a greater limitation to the production of marker-free T₁ plants expressing the gene of interest than co-transformation (71% of lines) and unlinked integration (44% of loci).     

Segregation of genes transferred to one plant cell from two separate Agrobacterium strains

Agrobacterium tumefaciens and Agrobacterium rhizogenes are soil bacteria which transfer DNA (T-DNA) to plant cells. Two Agrobacterium strains, each with a different T-DNA, can infect plants and give rise to transformed tissue which has markers from both T-DNAs. Although marker genes from both T-DNAs are in the tissue, definitive proof that the tissue is a cellular clone and that both T-DNAs are in a single cell is necessary to demonstrate cotransformation. We have transferred two distinguishable T-DNAs, carried on binary vectors in separate Agrobacterium rhizogenes strains, into tomato cells and have recovered hairy roots which received both T-DNAs. Continued expression of marker genes from each T-DNA in hairy roots propagated from individual root tips indicated that both T-DNAs were present in a single meristem. Also, we have transferred the two different T-DNAs, carried on identical binary vector plasmids in separate Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains, into tobacco cells and recovered plants which received both T-DNAs. Transformed plants with marker genes from each T-DNA were outcrossed to wild-type tobacco plants. Distribution of the markers in the F1 generation from three cotransformed plants of independent origin showed that both T-DNAs in the plants must have been present in the same cell and that the T-DNAs were genetically unlinked. Cotransformation of plant cells with T-DNAs from two bacterial strains and subsequent segregation of the transferred genes should be useful for altering the genetic content of higher plants.     

Rapid and accurate early-stage detection of T-DNA/plant flanking sequences of resistant kumquats

Agrobacterium-mediated genetic transformation is a widely applied tool in plant biotechnology. In this process, genes of interest are integrated into plant genomes via T-DNAs present on plasmids in Agrobacteria. Classical and standard methods for screening transformants, such as Southern blot, are inconvenient for most woodland plants because of extremely low transformation efficiency. For the purpose of identifying transgenic woody lines at early selection stages, a right-border T-DNA/plant conjunction sequence analysis was carried out. By analyzing these sequences, 15 out of 17 kanamycin-resistant kumquats were found to be integrated with foreign genes, and two or more copies were present in 33.3% of the transgenic lines, which is completely concordant with Southern blots. Moreover, T-DNA integration into plant nuclear DNA was random without any sequence hotspots, and cleavage sites are any base of the sequence ‘TGAC’. These results showed that this screening method could not only detect resistant woodland plants rapidly at the early selection stage, but unequivocally detect copy numbers. Compared with other screening technique, this method could save time and effort for conducting genetic transformation in woody plants, and also provides accurate integration information for transgenic plants.     

A novel double T-DNA system for producing stack and marker-free transgenic plants

This study aimed to develop a new vector system to remove selection genes and to introduce two or more genes of interest into plants in order to express them in a coordinated manner. A multigene expression vector was established based on pCamBIA2300 using a selectable marker gene (SMG)-free system based on the combination of the isocaudamer technique and double T-DNA. The vector DT7 containing seven target genes was constructed and introduced into tobacco using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. Twenty-one of 27 positive transgenic plants contained both T-DNA regions. The co-transformation frequency was 77.8 %. The frequency of unlinked integration of two intact T-DNAs was 22.22 % (6/27). The frequency of removal of SMG from transgenic T1 plants was 19.10 %. These results suggest that this vector system was functional and effective for multigene expression and SMG-free transgenic plant cultivation. At least seven target genes can be co-expressed using this system. Overall, these findings provide a new and highly effective platform for multigene and marker-free transgenic plant production.     

Organization and functional analysis of three T-DNAs from the vitopine Ti plasmid pTiS4

Summary The vitopine Ti plasmid pTiS4 of Agrobacterium vitis has an unusual T-DNA organization. The pTiS4 oncogenes, localized by screening selected pTiS4 clones for growth-inducing activity, are localized on three T-DNAs, whereas in all other characterized Ti plasmids one or two T-DNAs are found. The nucleotide sequences and predicted amino acid sequences of the pTiS4 oncogenes set them apart from the corresponding genes from other Ti or Ri plasmids. The oncogenes induce the same type of reaction on various test plants as the well-known pTiAch5 oncogenes but the pTiS4 ipt gene induces considerably more shoots than its Ach5 homologue. We have also identified the gene coding for vitopine synthase as well as a vitopine synthase pseudogene. Both sequences show homology to the octopine synthase gene. In terms of both nucleotide sequence and overall organization, the pTiS4 T-DNAs appear to be only distantly related to previously characterized T-DNAs.Abbreviations Ap ampicillin - IS insertion sequence - iaaH indole acetamide hydrolase - iaaM tryptophan monooxygenase - ipt isopentenyl transferase - Km kanamycin - LB Luria broth - m/a mannopine/agropine - o/c octopine/cucumopine - ocs octopine synthase     

Reduced variation in transgene expression from a binary vector with selectable markers at the right and left T-DNA borders

A new binary vector for Agrobacterium-mediated plant transformation was constructed, in which two selectable markers, for kanamycin and hygromycin resistance, were placed next to the right and left T-DNA borders, respectively, and a CaMV 35S promoter-driven β-glucuronidase (GUS) gene was placed between these markers as a reporter gene (transgene). Using double antibiotic selection, all transgenic tobacco plants carrying at least one intact copy of the T-DNA expressed the transgene, and this population exhibited reduced variability in transgene expression as compared with that obtained from the parent vector pBI121. Absence of the intact transgene was the major reason for transgenic plants with little or no transgene expression. Integration of truncated T-DNAs was also observed among transgenic plants that expressed the transgene and carried multiple T-DNA inserts. The copy number of fully integrated T-DNAs was positively associated with transgene expression levels in R₀ plants and R₁ progeny populations. Variability due to position effect was determined among 17 plants carrying a single T-DNA insert. The coefficient of variability among these plants was only 35.5%, indicating a minor role for position effects in causing transgene variability. The new binary vector reported here can therefore be used to obtain transgenic populations with reduced variability in transgene expression.     

Transposition-based plant transformation

Agrobacterium T-DNAs were used to deliver transposable Dissociation (Ds) elements into the nuclei of potato (Solanum tuberosum) cells. A double-selection system was applied to enrich for plants that only contained a transposed Ds element. This system consisted of a positive selection for the neomycin phosphotransferase (nptII) gene positioned within Ds followed by a negative selection against stable integration of the cytosine deaminase (codA) gene-containing T-DNA. Sixteen of 29 transgenic plants were found to contain a transposed element while lacking any superfluous T-DNA sequences. The occurrence of this genotype indicates that Ds elements can transpose from relatively short extrachromosomal DNA molecules into the plant genome. The frequency of single-copy Ds transformation was determined at 0.3%, which is only about 2.5-fold lower than the potato transformation frequency for backbone-free and single-copy T-DNAs. Because of the generally high expression levels of genes positioned within transposed elements, the new transformation method may find broad applicability to crops that are accessible to Agrobacterium T-DNA transfer.     

Gene silencing in transgenic tobacco hybrids: frequency of the event and visualization of somatic inactivation pattern

We have investigated the stability of the expression of different T-DNA-borne genes in hybrid tobacco lines. These lines were constructed to rescue rolC-induced male sterility in kanamycin-resistant P_35s-rolC transgenic tobacco plants by expression of rolC antisense genes. Using five different tester lines, a total of 158 hybrids was obtained. We observed inactivation of transgene expression in 20% of the F₁ progeny and in 35% of the backcrossed F₂ progeny, as indicated by the loss of kanamycin resistance. In 3% of all crosses complete loss of antibiotic resistance was noted, while in most affected hybrid progeny only part of the population became kanamycin sensitive. Single genes could be selectively inactivated on T-DNAs harboring several genes. Gene inactivation was not restricted to one of the two T-DNAs examined. Somatic silencing, visualized by a cell-specific 35SGUSINT marker gene, occurred in a random fashion or exhibited an inherited specific pattern. The type of somatic silencing pattern observed indicated developmental control of the process. Two phenotypic classes could be distinguished with respect to frequency and timing of the inactivation process. Rapid gene inactivation, occurring within a few weeks after germination of hybrid seedlings, was characterized by complete methylation of restriction sites in the promoter of the silenced gene, resetting of gene expression during meiosis, heridity of the developmentally controlled program of gene silencing in subsequent generations, and rapid reactivation of gene expression after genetic separation of the different T-DNAs. In contrast, a slow type of gene inactivation was of a more stochastic nature and was recognized only in hybrids of the backcrossed F₂ generation. In this case the degree of promoter methylation, which could extend beyond the T-DNA borders, was not correlated with the reduction in steady-state poly(A)⁺ mRNA levels, the silenced state was transmitted through meiosis and reactivation lasted several generations. The implications of the observations for our understanding of the gene inactivation process are discussed.     

T-DNA tagging in the model legume Medicago truncatula allows efficient gene discovery

The annual legume Medicago truncatula has been proposed as a model plant to study various aspects of legume biology including rhizobial and mycorrhizal symbiosis because it is well suited for the genetic analysis of these processes . To facilitate the characterization of M. truncatula genes participating in various developmental processes we have initiated an insertion mutagenesis program in this plant using three different T-DNAs as tags. To investigate which type of vector is the most suitable for mutagenesis we compared the behavior of these T-DNAs. One T-DNA vector was a derivative of pBin19 and plant selection was based on kanamycin resistance. The two other vectors carried T-DNA conferring Basta resistance in the transgenic plants. For each T-DNA type, we determined the copy number in the transgenic lines, the structure of the T-DNA loci and the sequences of the integration sites. The T-DNA derived from pBin19 generated complex T-DNA insertion patterns. The two others generally gave single copy T-DNA inserts that could result in gene fusions for the pGKB5 T-DNA. Analysis of the T-DNA borders revealed that several M. truncatula genes were tagged in these transgenic lines and in vivo gus fusions were also obtained. These results demonstrate that T-DNA tagging can efficiently be used in M. truncatula for gene discovery.     

Molecular analysis of Arabidopsis endosperm and embryo promoter trap lines: reporter-gene expression can result from T-DNA insertions in antisense orientation, in introns and in intergenic regions, in addition to sense insertion at the 5' end of genes

Random insertions of promoterless reporter genes in genomes are a common tool for identifying marker lines with tissue-specific expression patterns. Such lines are assumed to reflect the activity of endogenous promoters and should facilitate the cloning of genes expressed in the corresponding tissues. To identify genes active in seed organs, plant DNA flanking T-DNA insertions (T-DNAs) have been cloned in 16 Arabidopsis thaliana GUS-reporter lines. T-DNAs were found in proximal promoter regions, 5' UTR or intron with GUS in the same (sense) orientation as the tagged gene, but contrary to expectations also in inverted orientation in the 5' end of genes or in intergenic regions. RT-PCR, northern analysis, and data on expression patterns of tagged genes, compared with the expression pattern of the reporter lines, suggest that the expression pattern of a reporter gene will reflect the pattern of a tagged gene when inserted in sense orientation in the 5' UTR or intron. When inserted in the promoter region, the reporter-gene expression patterns may be restricted compared with the endogenous gene. Among the trapped genes, the previously described nitrate transporter gene AtNRT1.1, the cyclophilin gene ROC3, and the histone deacetylase gene AtHD2C were found. Reporter-gene expression when positioned in antisense orientation, for example, in the SLEEPY1 gene, is indicative of antisense expression of the tagged gene. For T-DNAs found in intergenic regions, it is suggested that the reporter gene is transcribed from cryptic promoters or promoters of as yet unannotated genes.     

Transgene behaviour in populations of rice plants transformed using a new dual binary vector system: pGreen/pSoup

Transgene integration, expression level and stability have been studied, across two generations, in a population of rice plants transformed using a new dual binary vector system: pGreen/pSoup. pGreen is a small Ti binary vector unable to replicate in Agrobacterium without the presence of another binary plasmid, pSoup, in the same strain. We engineered both pGreen and pSoup to contain each a different T-DNA. Transformation experiments were conducted using a pGreen vector containing the bar and gusA expression units (no transgene in pSoup) or with a pSoup vector containing an aphIV and gfp expression units (no transgene in pGreen). High plant transformation frequencies (up to 40%) were obtained using herbicide resistance ( bar) or antibiotic resistance ( aphIV) genes. Around 80% of the independently transformed plants expressed unselected reporter genes ( gusA or gfp) present in the vectors. Backbone sequences transfer was frequent (45% of lines) and occurred often in multicopy lines. Around 15-20% of the rice plant lines contained a single T-DNA integration without backbone. Integration of additional transgene copies did not improve expression levels in either T(0) plants or T(1) progenies. Nearly all multicopy lines contained transgenes integrated at several loci in the plant genome, showing that T-DNAs from either pGreen or pSoup frequently integrated at unlinked loci. Precise determination of loci number required the analysis of transgene presence in progeny. Segregation of transgene phenotype was generally misleading and tended to underestimate the real number of transgenic loci. The contribution of this new dual-binary vector system to the development of high-throughput rice transformation systems and to the production of marker-free transgenic rice plants is discussed.     

Two unlinked T-DNAs can transform the same tobacco plant cell and segregate in the F1 generation

Summary The 200 kb Agrobacterium Ti-plasmid pTiT37 carries a 25 kb segment of T-DNA which it transfers to plant cells during crown-gall tumorigenesis. We have previously engineered into this T-DNA a pBR322-derived cloning vector which enabled us to rescue-clone full length T-DNA from the Ti-plasmid into a 36 kb MINI-Ti plasmid. We report here the deletion of oncogenes from MINI-Ti to produce Micro-Ti containing the nopaline synthase gene and the ampicillin resistance gene and origin of replication of pBR322, flanked by left and right T-DNA borders. Micro-Ti was recloned into the wide host range plasmid pRK290 and transformed into an A. tumefaciens strain carrying a helper plasmid that could supply Virulence (VIR) genes in trans. Using the octopine Ti-plasmid pTiB6-806 as a helper, transformed tobacco cells were obtained which produced both nopaline and octopine. Two cloned cell lines producing both opines were found to be hormone dependent and to produce fertile tobacco plants. We selfed one of these plants and found that the two opine markers segregated in the F1 progeny in a Mendelian fashion. This showed that the T-DNAs were not linked in the transformed plant genome. Southern blot analysis of the genomic DNA from the regenerated plant showed that only part of the (oncogenic) octopine T-DNA was present indicating that it had suffered a deletion in the auxin producing locus (tms region). Presence of the cytokinin autonomy locus presumably accounts for the abnormal rooting behavior of the F1 progeny seedlings containing this T-DNA.Abbreviations NAA Naphtalene acetic acid - IAA Indole-3-acetic acid - BA 6-benzylaminopurine - pCPA para-chlorophenoxyacetic acid Part of this work was presented for her doctoral thesis by A. JdF at the National Institute of Agronomy of Paris-Grignon, January 1983     

Localization of Ds-transposon containing T-DNA inserts in the diploid transgenic potato: linkage to the R1 resistance gene against Phytophthora infestans (Mont.) de Bary.

The Dissociation transposable element (Ds) of maize containing NPTII was introduced into the diploid potato (Solanum tuberosum) clone J91-6400-A16 through Agrobacterium tumefaciens mediated transformation. Genomic DNA sequences flanking the T-DNAs from 312 transformants were obtained with inverse polymerase chain reaction or plasmid rescue techniques and used as probes for RFLP linkage analysis. The RFLP map location of 60 T-DNAs carrying Ds-NPTII was determined. The T-DNA distribution per chromosome and the relative distance between them appeared to be random. All 12 chromosomes have been covered with Ds-containing T-DNAs, potentially enabling tagging of any gene in the potato genome. The T-DNA insertions of two transformants, BET92-Ds-A16-259 and BET92-Ds-A16-416, were linked in repulsion to the position of the resistance gene R1 against Phytophthora infestans. After crossing BET92-Ds-A16-416 with a susceptible parent, 4 desired recombinants (Ds carrying T-DNA linked in coupling phase with the R1 gene) were discovered. These will be used for tagging the R1 gene. The efficiency of the pathway from the introduction to localization of T-DNAs is discussed. Key words : Solanum tuberosum, Phytophthora infestans, Ds element, transposon tagging, R genes, euchromatin.     

利用双T-DNA载体系统培育无选择标记转基因烟草

建立了一种利用双T-DNA载体培育无选择标记转基因植物的方法.通过体外重组构建了双T-DNA双元载体pDLBRBbarm.载体中,选择标记nptⅡ基因和另一代表外源基因的bar基因分别位于2个独立的T-DNA.利用农杆菌介导转化烟草(Nicotiana tabacum L.),在获得的转化植株中,同时整合有nptⅡ基因和bar基因的频率为59.2%.对4个同时整合有nptⅡ和bar基因植株自交获得的T1代株系进行检测分析,发现在3个T1代株系2个T-DNA可以发生分离,其中约19.5%的转基因T1代植株中只存在bar基因而不带选择标记nptⅡ.这一结果说明双T-DNA载体系统能有效地用于培育无选择标记的转基因植物.研究还利用位于2个不同载体上的nptⅡ基因与 bar基因通过农杆菌介导共转化烟草,获得共转化植株的频率为20.0%～47.4%,低于使用双T-DNA转化的共转化频率.     

Selectable marker-free transgenic plants without sexual crossing: transient expression of cre recombinase and use of a conditional lethal dominant gene

Transgenic tobacco plants were produced that contained single-copy pART54 T-DNA, with a 35S-uidA gene linked to loxP-flanked kanamycin resistance (nptII) and cytosine deaminase (codA) genes. Retransformation of these plants with pCre1 (containing 35S transcribed cre recombinase and hygromycin (hpt) resistance genes) resulted in excision of the loxP-flanked genes from the genome. Phenotypes of progeny from selfed-retransformed plants confirmed nptII and codA excision and integration of the cre-linked hpt gene. To avoid integration of the hpt gene, and thereby generate plants totally free of marker genes, we attempted to transiently express the cre recombinase. Agrobacterium tumefaciens (pCre1) was cocultivated with leaf discs of two pART54-transformed lines and shoots were regenerated in the absence of hygromycin selection. Nineteen of 773 (0.25%) shoots showed tolerance to 5-fluorocytosine (5-fc) which is converted to the toxic 5-fluorouracil by cytosine deaminase. 5-fc tolerance in six shoots was found to be due to excision of the loxP-flanked region of the pART54 T-DNA. In four of these shoots excision could be attributed to cre expression from integrated pCre1 T-DNA, whereas in two shoots excision appeared to be a consequence of transient cre expression from pCre1 T-DNA molecules which had been transferred to the plant cells but not integrated into the genome. The absence of selectable marker genes was confirmed by the phenotype of the T₁ progeny. Therefore, through transient cre expression, marker-free transgenic plants were produced without sexual crossing. This approach could be applicable to the elimination of marker genes from transgenic crops which must be vegetatively propagated to maintain their elite genotype.     

T-DNA integration patterns in co-transformed plant cells suggest that T-DNA repeats originate from co-integration of separate T-DNAs

Nicotiana protoplasts and Arabidopsis leaf discs or roots were co-cultivated with two Agrobacterium strains each carrying a different T-DNA. Co-transformed plants were selected and the integration of the different T-DNAs was analysed at the genetic and genomic level. Genetic analysis showed that the T-DNAs derived from different bacteria were frequently integrated at the same locus, independent of the plant species or transformation method used. Southern analysis revealed that 12 out of 27 Arabidopsis transformants contained the co-transferred T-DNAs linked to each other in all possible configurations but with a preference for those with at least one right border involved in linkage. Overall, our data support the hypothesis that ligation of separate T-DNAs is a dominant mechanism in formation of the frequently observed repeats of identical T-DNAs. We propose a scheme which could explain the formation of T-DNA repeats and the preferential involvement of right borders in T-DNA linkages.