Assessment of the effects on growth of porous hydroxyapatite granule cranioplasty in the immature guinea pig craniofacial skeleton

The immature guinea pig was used to study the effects on growth of porous granular hydroxyapatite used as an onlay cranioplasty and inlay cranioplasty to reconstruct full-thickness cranial defects in a growing craniofacial skeleton. Forty Hartley guinea pigs, 20 immature animals and 20 mature animals, were divided into four groups each containing five mature and five immature animals. The mature animals served as controls. Group I underwent elevation and replacement of the parietal periosteum. Group II underwent placement of hydroxyapatite between periosteum and parietal bone. Group III underwent elevation and replacement of autogenous bone flap after the formation of a 1 x 1-cm craniectomy defect in the parietal skull. Group IV underwent elevation of a 1 x 1-cm parietal craniectomy and reconstruction of the defect with hydroxyapatite granules placed between the dura and periosteum. Immature animals were killed at maturity at 3.5 months and mature animals were killed 2.5 months postoperatively. Macroscopic examination of the operative field, transverse and longitudinal cephalometric measurements, and histological sections encompassing the operative sites were compared. Macroscopically, all reconstructed operative sites were fully incorporated into the cranium. Histological staining of the sectioned operative site revealed no hydroxyapatite migration through the cranial bone or dura. No inflammatory or foreign body reaction was evident in the subcutaneous tissue, periosteum, or dura. No statistically significant cephalometric intergroup or intragroup differences were found at the conclusion of the study. The results of this study indicate that a granular porous form of hydroxyapatite may be used as an onlay or inlay cranioplasty in the immature guinea pig craniofacial skeleton without evidence of dural inflammation, granule migration, or growth restriction or retardation.     

The rate of vascularization of coralline hydroxyapatite

Coralline hydroxyapatite (CHAP) is a porous, biocompatible bone-graft substitute manufactured by the Replamineform process. The use of this material in the experimental and clinical settings for maxillofacial onlay grafting has been recently described. This study was designed to quantitate the rate of vascularization of coralline hydroxyapatite when used in an onlay application to membranous bone in an animal model. Sixteen onlay grafts of coralline hydroxyapatite (0.5 X 0.5 X 1.0 cm Interpore 200) were placed in a subperiosteal location on the nasal dorsum of 2- to 3-kg male New Zealand white rabbits. The grafts and nasal bones were harvested en bloc at 1, 2, 3 and 4 weeks after onlay. Prior to harvest, injectable silicone visualizing agent (Microfil*) was injected by means of carotid artery cutdown. The decalcified specimens were examined on a digitizing pad to count the number of vessels appearing in the blocks of hydroxyapatite. Counting was summed and integrated by an Apple IIe microcomputer. A significant difference (p less than 0.05) was noted in both the number of vessels and the fraction of implants infiltrated by vessels between 1 and 4 weeks. The usefulness of these previously undescribed data may be in their extrapolation to onlay grafts of coralline hydroxyapatite in maxillofacial reconstruction in humans.     

Surgical correction of the vertically deficient chin

Surgical correction of the vertically deficient chin has received relatively little attention. This paucity of information is most likely related to the failure to diagnose vertical microgenia and the questionable stability of its surgical correction utilizing autogenous bone grafts. This paper reports on eight patients who have undergone vertical augmentation genioplasty utilizing a transverse symphyseal osteotomy and interpositional implantation of porous, block hydroxyapatite. All patients had preoperative measured decreases in lower face height. Mean vertical lengthening of the chin was 5.3 mm. Seven of the eight patients had class II occlusions and underwent simultaneous sagittal advancement of the chin. Follow-up at a mean time of 11.1 months revealed complete stability of the vertically repositioned symphyseal segment. Mean ratio of the vertical soft to hard tissue augmentation was 0.89:1. There were no instances of operative complications. Vertical facial aesthetics and their application in the evaluation and treatment of patients with vertically deficient lower faces and chins are reviewed.     

Enhanced bone regeneration with a synthetic cell-binding peptide--in vivo results

This in vivo study compared the regenerative processes within defined defects of the porcine skull after delivery of a porous algae-derived hydroxyapatite (adHA), a similar, experimental adHA carrying the cell binding peptide P-15, used solely and in combination with 25% autogenous bone (AB). Particulated AB served as a control group. During an observation period of 26 weeks, microradiography and histology were performed at four specific times. Significantly higher mineralization rates (p=0.008) were found 4 weeks after application of the bioactive material in combination with AB. At 12 weeks there was a significantly higher mineralization (p=0.036) following the application of the bioactive form alone. This study showed significantly higher mineralization after use of a P-15 bioactivated material at early stages. Thus, it can be concluded that the application of the P-15 sequence to an hydroxyapatite accelerates the process of early bone formation, whereas no long-term effect was traced.     

Augmentation rhinoplasty: dorsal onlay grafting using shaped autogenous septal cartilage

We describe our experience with autogenous septal cartilage onlay grafts for augmentation of the nasal dorsum in primary and secondary rhinoplasty cases. After careful nasofacial analysis, the grafts are custom-shaped into inverted-V-frame, A-frame, or inverted-U-frame grafts, depending on the type and degree of augmentation desired. The dorsal elevation is thus tailored to fit the imperfection at hand, resulting in a smooth, natural-looking nasal contour. The indications for each type of graft are reviewed, and the surgical technique of graft harvesting and carving is detailed and illustrated.     

The induction of bone by an osteogenic protein and the conduction of bone by porous hydroxyapatite: a laboratory study in the rabbit.

The influence of the addition of an osteoinductive protein, capable of inducing extraskeletal ossification, on bone ingrowth into coralline porous hydroxyapatite was evaluated in the rabbit using a calvarium onlay model. Twenty-three rabbits received hydroxyapatite implants (10 x 10 x 2 mm) prepared with and without osteoinductive protein. These were implanted on the frontal bone and secured by wire fixation after 0.25 mm of the cortical surface was abraded. The implants were harvested at 3 and 4 months and analyzed for percentage of bone ingrowth by histologic examination of decalcified H&E sections and by scanning electron microscope backscatter image analysis. The osteoinductive protein-treated implants demonstrated significantly greater amounts of bone ingrowth at both 3 (52.0 versus 10.3 percent; p less than 0.001) and 4 months (66.1 versus 39.2 percent; p less than 0.005) than the untreated implants. The type of bone found in all osteoinductive protein-treated implants was predominantly lamellar. Untreated implants contained mostly woven bone at 3 months, with increasing amounts of lamellar bone appearing at 4 months. These results suggest that the combination of a bone-inducing protein and a suitable osteoconductive matrix may provide an alternative to bone grafting.     

Cyclooxygenase-2 inhibition does not impair block bone grafts healing in rabbit model

Success of alveolar reconstructions using onlay autogenous block bone grafts depends on their adequate integration to the recipient bed influenced by a number of local molecules. Considering the fundamental role of cyclooxygenase (COX-2) in bone repair, the aim of this study was to analyze the effect of its inhibition in the integration of endochondral (EC) iliac crest, and intramembranous (IM) calvaria bone grafts. Thirty-two rabbits were divided into 4 groups: Calvaria Control (CC) and Iliac Control—treated with oral 0.9 % saline solution, and Calvarial-NSAID (C-NSAID) and Iliac-NSAID (I-NSAID) groups—treated with oral 6 mg/Kg non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug etoricoxib. After 7, 14, 30 and 60 days the animals were euthanized and the specimens removed for histological, histomorphometric and immunohistochemistry analysis. At day 60, a tight integration of IM blocks could be seen with the presence of remodeling bone, whereas integration of EC grafts was mainly observed at the edges of the grafts. A significant higher percentage of bone matrix in the interface region of the CC grafts in comparison to C-NSAID only at day 14, whereas no differences were detected comparing the EC grafts. No differences were observed in Runx-2 and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) immunolabeling when comparing CC and C-NSAID groups, while a significant weaker Runx-2 and VEGF labeling was detected in I-NSAID group at day 60. Although some influence was detected in osteogenesis, it is concluded that drug induced inhibition of COX-2 does not impair onlay bone grafts’ healing of both embryologic origins in rabbits.     

Orthognathic surgery in cleft patients treated by early bone grafting

For the past 25 years at Children's Memorial Hospital in Chicago a protocol has been followed for complete clefts that involves placement of an infant maxillary orthopedic appliance prior to lip closure, surgical closure of the lip, autogenous split-rib grafts to the alveolus to stabilize maxillary segments, and palatal closure, generally within the first year of life. The oldest 36 patients whose skeletal growth was for all practical purposes finished have been followed to determine the need for and type of orthognathic surgery. Of the total sample, 8 patients (22.2 percent) required some type of sagittal orthognathic surgery (1 patient in this group also required vertical maxillary alignment) and 2 patients required maxillary augmentation only in the form of an onlay graft. This report may serve as a baseline for others who wish to report on the incidence and type of orthognathic surgery in their cleft palate centers.     

Porous hydroxyapatite as a bone graft substitute in cranial reconstruction: a histometric study

To assess the potential of a porous hydroxyapatite matrix to serve as a bone graft substitute, bilateral 15 X 20 mm craniectomy defects were reconstructed in 17 dogs with blocks of implant and split-rib autografts. Specimens were retrieved at 3, 6, 12, 24, and 48 months, and undecalcified sections were prepared for microscopy and histometry. The implant and graft cross-sectional areas did not change with time, documenting their equivalent ability to maintain cranial contour. Bone ingrowth extended across the implant from one cranial shelf to the other in 15 specimens. Little apparent bone ingrowth was seen in most graft specimens. Two implants and three grafts were nonunited, possibly due to lack of fixation or the orientation of the histology sections. The implant specimens were composed of 39.3 percent hydroxyapatite matrix, 17.2 percent bone ingrowth, and 43.5 percent soft-tissue ingrowth. The graft specimens were composed of 43.7 percent bone and 56.3 percent soft tissue. This study supported the thesis that a porous hydroxyapatite matrix may function in part as a bone graft substitute. The brittle hydroxyapatite matrix undoubtedly became stronger with bone ingrowth, but the degree of cranial protection achieved was not measured in this study. The size of the cranial defect used in this study did not permit estimation of the distance over which bone ingrowth may be reliably expected. There remains a need for greater understanding of the causes of nonunion, the extent of predictable ingrowth depth, and the strength of the resultant implant-bone composite.     

The angiogenic potential of autogenous free omental graft in experimental tibial defects in rabbit: Short-term preliminary histopathological study

This study was designed to evaluate the role of free autogenous greater omentum in vasculogenesis during the process of bone healing. The study was carried out on 15 male adult white New Zealand rabbits in the same condition. Both tibiae of the animals were exposed medially and a 2 mm hole was drilled at proximal diaphysis. A small piece of greater omentum, obtained from a 1 cm mid-abdominal incision was secured on left tibial hole. The animals were euthanized 14 days after operation and the bones removed for histopathological and immunohistochemical (anti-CD31 application for endothelial cell labeling) studies. In histopathological sections, the soft callus area in treatment legs was significantly more than the control legs. Also, the hole diameter in treatment group was significantly less than the control group. The number of capillary buds in treatment legs was significantly more than the control group. This study showed that an autogenous free greater omentum graft can influence bone healing through augmentation of vasculogenesis, as an essential element for proper bone healing.     

Nasal augmentation with split calvarial grafts in Orientals

This study reports on my experience with autogenous split calvarial grafts in nasal augmentation in 62 Orientals. In 78 percent of patients, the procedure was performed under local anesthesia in an outpatient setting. Total operating time for harvesting of split calvarial grafts ranged from 20 to 55 minutes, with a mean of 32 minutes. Patients ranged in age from 16 to 48 years, with a mean of 27 years. Follow-up was from 6 months to 8 years, with an average of 3.1 years. Intraoperative discomfort was uniformly low and well tolerated when local anesthesia was used. The complication rate was 8.0 percent, with three cases of minor seroma-hematoma formation at the bone-graft donor site. These were treated with aspiration. There were two recipient-site complications, with one case of complete bone resorption that occurred in a densely fibrotic nose with preexisting septal perforation and a case of overcorrection that was successfully rasped 1 year later. Because of their easy accessibility beneath the scalp, split calvarial grafts to the nose are useful in various types of nasal augmentation, and the technique is offered as a practical alternative to the use of alloplastic materials.     

Experimental hydroxyapatite cement cranioplasty.

Hydroxyapatite cement is a calcium phosphate-based material that when mixed with water forms a dense paste that sets within 15 minutes and isothermically converts in vivo to a microporous hydroxyapatite implant. This cement was used to reconstruct bilateral 2.5-cm-diameter full-thickness critical-sized parietal skull defects in six cats. One side was reconstructed with 100 percent hydroxyapatite cement, and the other with a mixture of 50 percent hydroxyapatite cement and 50 percent ground autogenous bone by weight. These animals were sacrificed at 6 and 12 months after implantation. Positive and negative controls also were prepared. The anatomic contour of the soft tissue overlying all hydroxyapatite cement implants was well maintained, there were no wound infections or structural failures, and the implants were well tolerated histologically. None of the negative (unreconstructed) control defects was completely filled with repair bone, and all positive (methyl methacrylate) controls demonstrated foreign-body giant-cell formation and fibrous encapsulation of the implants. Examination of decalcified and undecalcified sections revealed progressive but variable replacement of the cement by new bone and soft tissue without a change in the shape or volume of the hydroxyapatite cement-reconstructed areas. New bone comprised 77.3 and 64.7 percent of the tissue replacing the hydroxyapatite cement and hydroxyapatite cement-bone implants, respectively. Replacement of the hydroxyapatite cement implants by new bone is postulated to occur by a combination of osteoconduction and implant resorption. These results indicate that further experimental research leading to the possible application of hydroxyapatite cement for full-thickness calvarial defect reconstruction in humans is warranted.     

Osteogenin, a bone morphogenetic protein, adsorbed on porous hydroxyapatite substrata, induces rapid bone differentiation in calvarial defects of adult primates.

Osteogenin, a bone morphogenetic protein, in conjunction with insoluble collagenous bone matrix initiates local endochondral bone differentiation by induction in vivo. This study, by exploiting the affinity of native osteogenin for hydroxyapatite, was designed to construct a delivery system for the expression of the biologic activity of osteogenin in nonhealing calvarial defects of adult primates. After exposure of the calvaria, 64 cranial defects, 25 mm in diameter, were prepared in 16 adult male baboons (Papio ursinus). Defects were implanted with disks of porous nonresorbable and resorbable hydroxyapatite substrata obtained after hydrothermal conversion of calcium carbonate exoskeletons of corals. In each animal, one disk of each hydroxyapatite preparation was treated with osteogenin isolated and purified from baboon bone matrix after sequential chromatography on heparin-Sepharose, hydroxyapatite, and Sephacryl S-200 gel filtration columns. The remaining two defects were implanted with one disk of each hydroxyapatite preparation without osteogenin as control. Histomorphometry on decalcified sections prepared on days 30 and 90 showed superior osteogenesis in osteogenin-treated nonresorbable hydroxyapatite specimens as compared with controls. On day 90, substantial bone formation also had occurred in control nonresorbable hydroxyapatite specimens. On day 90, but not on day 30, significantly greater amounts of bone had formed in osteogenin-treated resorbable specimens as compared with resorbable controls. Overall, resorbable substrata performed poorly when compared with nonresorbable substrata, perhaps due to a premature dissolution of the implants. These results provide evidence that the biologic activity of osteogenin can be restored and delivered by a substratum other than the organic collagenous matrix, inducing rapid bone differentiation in calvarial defects of adult nonhuman primates. The adsorption strategy of osteogenin on porous inorganic nonimmunogenic substrata may help to design appropriate osteogenic delivery systems for craniofacial and orthopedic applications in humans.     

A comparative analysis of the microarchitecture of cortical membranous and cortical endochondral onlay bone grafts in the craniofacial skeleton

Previous work in this laboratory established that an onlay bone graft's survival is determined primarily by its relative cortical and cancellous composition rather than its embryologic origin. A volumetric analysis of external bone graft resorption, however, does not explain the internal microarchitectural changes that may be occurring as these grafts become incorporated. To expand the knowledge of bone graft dynamics beyond volumetric parameters, a better understanding of the internal processes of bone graft remodeling is needed. In this comparative study of cortical onlay bone graft microarchitecture, the authors propose to show that cortical onlay bone grafts undergo measurable internal microarchitectural changes as they become incorporated into the surrounding craniofacial skeleton. In addition, the authors propose to further demonstrate similarities between the internal microarchitecture of cortical onlay bone grafts of different embryologic origin over time. Twenty-five adult New Zealand White rabbits were used for this study. They were divided into two groups of eight animals and one group of nine. The groups were killed at 3, 8, and 16 weeks. Cortical membranous and endochondral bone grafts were placed subperiosteally onto each rabbit's cranium. In addition, five ungrafted cortical endochondral and membranous bone specimens were used as controls. Microcomputed tomography (MCT) scanning and histomorphometric analysis were performed on all of the specimens to obtain detailed information regarding the microarchitecture of the cortical bone grafts. The parameters of bone volume fraction, bone surface area to volume, mean trabecular number, and anisotropy were used to give quantitative information about a bone's micro-organization. The results showed that there is no statistically significant difference between the cortical endochondral and the cortical membranous bone grafts for bone volume fraction, bone surface to volume, mean trabecular number, and anisotropy measurements for all time points. There were, however, statistically significant differences when comparing the control and 3-week groups to the 16-week group for all parameters. The advanced MCT technology and histomorphometric techniques proved to be effective in providing a qualitative and quantitative ultrastructural comparison of cortical endochondral and membranous onlay bone grafts over time. In this study, a statistically significant change in the internal microarchitecture of cortical onlay bone grafts of different embryologic origins was seen as they were remodeled and resorbed at all time points. Specifically, the onlay cortical bone grafts developed a less dense, more trabecular, and less organized internal ultrastructure. In addition, no difference in the three-dimensional ultrastructure of cortical endochondral and membranous bone was found. These results challenge some of the currently accepted theories of bone-graft dynamics and may eventually lead to a change in the way clinicians approach bone-graft selection for craniofacial surgery.     

Viability of maxillary bone harvesting by using different osteotomy techniques. A pilot study

The use of autogenous grafts is still considered in bone regeneration surgeries. However, the bone cell viability of such grafts after being harvested from donor sites remains a matter of debate. The aim of the present study is to evaluate particulated and block bone cell viability, in terms of presence or absence of apoptosis and necrosis, obtained from different maxillary intra-oral harvesting methods: bone scraper, rotary carbide burs and piezoelectric device. Five healthy patients were enrolled in the study. The patients required sinus augmentation by lateral window approach. The bone was harvested by the bone scraper, piezoelectric device and rotary surgical instrument. The samples were processed with the Annexin V/FITC (fluorescein isothiocyanate stain) kit and were analyzed by means of Fluoresence-Activated Cell Sorted (FACS) technique. Within the limitations of this pilot study, the results indicated that autogenous bone chips collected from the three harvesting methods presented a large percentage of apoptotic cells, although large scale production of necrotic cells was not detected. In summary, although rotary surgical instrument and piezoelectric devices are frequently used instruments for oral osteotomy, fresh autogenous bone chips collected from them did not present a viable bone cell source.     

CAD–CAM prosthetically guided bone regeneration using preformed titanium mesh for the reconstruction of atrophic maxillary arches

The protocol presented here is intended to minimise the intervention in bone reconstruction surgery when severe atrophy or deformity is present in the maxillary arches. A patient underwent augmentation of an atrophic maxillary arch using titanium mesh and particulate autogenous plus bovine demineralised bone. After computed tomography data elaboration, computer-aided design and computer-aided machining were used to plan the augmentation of bone volume to improve the implant position needed to support the final dental prosthesis. The augmented maxilla was rapidly prototyped in plastic, and the titanium mesh was tested on this model before the surgical intervention. Then, the preformed titanium mesh was implanted in the maxillary arch with bone grafting. The bone was augmented relative to the position of the implants for the definitive fixed implant-supported rehabilitation. The protocol presented here is a viable, reproducible way to determine the correct bone augmentation for the final implant-supported prosthetic rehabilitation.     

Effects of combined hydroxyapatite and human platelet rich plasma on bone healing in rabbit model: radiological, macroscopical, hidtopathological and biomechanical evaluation

Hydroxyapatite is an osteoconductive material used as a bone graft extender and exhibits excellent biocompatibility with soft tissues such as skin, muscle and gums, making it an ideal candidate for orthopedic and dental implants or components of implants. Synthetic hydroxyapatite has been widely used in repair of hard tissues, and common uses include bone repair, bone augmentation, as well as coating of implants or acting as fillers in bone or teeth. On the other hand, human platelet rich plasma (hPRP) has been used as a source of osteoinductive factor. A combination of hPRP and hydroxyapatite is expected to create a composite with both osteoconductive and osteoinductive properties. This study examined the effect of a combination of hydroxyapatite and hPRP on osteogenesis in vivo, using rabbit model bone healing. A critical size defect of 10?mm long was created in the radial diaphysis of 36 rabbit and either supplied with hydroxyapatite-human PRP or hydroxyapatite or was left empty (control group). Radiographs of each forelimb were taken postoperatively on 1st day and then at the 2nd, 4th, 6th and 8th weeks post injury to evaluate bone formation, union and remodeling of the defect. The operated radiuses of half of the animals in each group were removed on 56th postoperative day and were grossly and histopathologically evaluated. In addition, biomechanical test was conducted on the operated and normal forearms of the other half of the animals of each group. This study demonstrated that hydroxyapatite-humanPRP, could promote bone regeneration in critical size defects with a high regenerative capacity. The results of the present study demonstrated that hydroxyapatite-hPRP could be an attractive alternative for reconstruction of the major diaphyseal defects of the long bones in animal models.     

Induction of bone in composites of osteogenin and porous hydroxyapatite in baboons.

A major goal of the combined effort of basic scientists and plastic and reconstructive surgeons is the development of novel bone substitutes based on osteogenic growth and differentiation factors with optimal delivery systems for skeletal repair. Osteogenin is a protein initiator of bone differentiation. The present study examined the osteogenic potential of osteogenin in combination with porous hydroxyapatite replicas obtained after hydrothermal conversion of calcium carbonate exoskeletons of corals. Bovine osteogenin, with an apparent molecular weight of 28 to 42 kDa, purified by hydroxyapatite-Ultrogel adsorption chromatography, heparin-Sepharose affinity chromatography, and HR Sephacryl S-200 molecular sieve chromatography, was delivered into rods of nonresorbable and resorbable hydroxyapatite replicas with an average porosity of 600 microns. A total of 48 rods were bioassayed for osteogenic activity by intramuscular implantation into eight adult baboons (Papio ursinus) as a prerequisite for clinical trials in humans. Bovine osteogenin fractions reconstituted with baboon insoluble collagenous bone matrix were implanted in an additional four adult baboons. Specimens were harvested at 30 and 90 days after implantation and subjected to histomorphometry and alkaline phosphatase activity determination. Differentiation of bone occurred in nonresorbable hydroxyapatite rods, both osteogenin-treated and controls. However, no bone formation was observed in resorbable rods, even in the presence of osteogenin. These results demonstrate that the surface and chemical characteristics of the substratum, independent of the osteogenic stimulus, have a profound influence on the morphogenesis of bone. The demonstration of bone induction in nonhuman primates with porous nonresorbable hydroxyapatite replicas and baboon insoluble collagenous bone matrix reconstituted with bovine osteogenin establishes the therapeutic potential of the principle of bone induction in craniofacial, periodontal, and orthopedic reconstructive surgery.     

Posterolateral spinal fusion with ostegenesis induced BMSC seeded TCP/HA in a sheep model

Autogenous bone graft is the gold standard for fusion procedure. However, pain at donor site and inconsistent outcome have left a surgeon to venture into some other technique for spinal fusion. The objective of this study was to determine whether osteogenesis induced bone marrow stem cells with the combination of ceramics granules (HA or TCP/HA), and fibrin could serve as an alternative to generate spinal fusion. The sheep's bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (BMSCs) were aspirated form iliac crest and cultured for several passages until confluence. BMSCs were trypsinized and seeded on hydroxyapatite scaffold (HA) and tricalcium phosphate/hydroxyapatite (TCP/HA) for further osteogenic differentiation in the osteogenic medium one week before implantation. Six adult sheep underwent three-level, bilateral, posterolateral intertransverse process fusions at L1–L6. Three fusion sites in each animal were assigned to three treatments: (a) HA constructs group/L1–L2, (b) TCP/HA constructs group/L2–L3, and (c) autogenous bone graft group/L5–L6. The spinal fusion segments were evaluated using radiography, manual palpation, histological analysis and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) 12 weeks post implantation. The TCP/HA constructs achieved superior lumbar intertransverse fusion compared to HA construct but autogenous bone graft still produced the best fusion among all.