False-negative Papanicolaou smears from women with cancerous and precancerous lesions of the uterine cervix

The occurrence from 1980 to 1989 of false-negative Papanicolaou smears in women with cancerous and precancerous lesions of the uterine cervix was studied. The 4,781 cases of cancer (2,814 invasive carcinomas and 593 carcinomas in situ) and precancerous lesions (418 severe dysplasias, 748 moderate dysplasias and 208 mild dysplasias) included 70 cases (1.5%) with false-negative smears. These 70 cases included 43 invasive carcinomas (61.4%), 17 carcinomas in situ and adenocarcinomas in situ (24.2%), and 10 dysplasias (14.4%); all were diagnosed histologically. The mean age of women with false-negative smears was 44.1 +/- 13.7 years. Review of the original cytologic samples showed a screening error in 41 cases (58.5%), an interpretation error in 2 cases (2.9%) and a sampling error in 27 cases (38.6%). Methods for eliminating false-negative smears are discussed.     

Adenoma malignum. Report of a case with cytologic and colposcopic findings and immunohistochemical staining with antimucin monoclonal antibody HIK-1083

BACKGROUND: Adenoma malignum of the uterine cervix was first described by Gusserow. We report here a case with cytologic, histologic and colposcopic findings and immunohistochemistry for HIK-1083. CASE: A 42-year-old female was noted to have a probable adenoma malignum due to the detection of atypical cells classified as V. On colposcopy, comma-shaped, atypical vessels spread over the entire cervical area. Histologic findings were characteristic of tumor invasion beyond the layer of cervical glandular ducts. Immunohistochemical detection of CEA was negative, but HIK-1083, which recognizes gastric glandular mucous cells, was positive. CONCLUSION: For a definitive diagnosis of adenoma malignum of the cervix, immunohistochemical examination for an appropriate marker, such as HIK-1083, should be added to the routine gynecologic examination, cytologic and histopathologic examination, and colposcopy.     

Acantholytic cells exfoliated from pemphigus vulgaris of the uterine cervix. A case report

BACKGROUND: Pemphigus vulgaris of the uterine cervix is rare and almost always associated with cutaneous or mucosal lesions elsewhere on the body. Without a history of pemphigus, acantholytic cells in cervical smears may be misdiagnosed as malignant ones. CASE: A 52-year-old female presented with a vaginal discharge, and a routine cervical smear was collected for cytology. The smear displayed atypical cells lying singly and in loose clusters, having vesicular nuclei, a thin nuclear membrane, prominent nucleoli and well-defined cytoplasmic margins. These were labeled atypical glandular cells of undetermined significance, and colposcopic examination and biopsy were advised. On colposcopy vesicular lesions and erosions were noticed on the cervix. The biopsy revealed typical intact as well as denuded suprabasal bullae of pemphigus vulgaris. On reevaluation of the cytologic smear, the cytomorphologic features correlated well with the acantholytic cells of pemphigus. Thorough reexamination of the patient revealed 2 tiny vesicles on the oral mucosa that, on biopsy, confirmed the diagnosis of pemphigus vulgaris. CONCLUSION: Cytopathologists should be aware of the typical cytomorphologic features of pemphigus vulgaris and, in an appropriate clinical setting, should be able to diagnose or at least suspect this entity in even rare sites like the cervix. A false positive diagnosis of malignancy can be avoided if the cytologic findings are judiciously correlated with the history and with clinical and colposcopic examinations.     

Comparison of suspicious and positive colposcopic, cytologic and histologic findings in the uterine cervix

One hundred thirty-five cases of suspicious or positive colposcopic or cytologic findings were histologically analyzed. In cases of colposcopically detectable atypical changes or suspicious findings as well as of cytologic dysplasias or carcinomas, the histologic diagnoses were almost the same. The results demonstrated that colposcopy and cytology with a quick staining method are of value. Biopsy can quickly follow in cases of suspicious findings.     

The cytologic diagnosis of adenocarcinoma in situ of the cervix uteri and related lesions. III. Pitfalls in diagnosis

Potential pitfalls in the cytologic diagnosis of adenocarcinoma in situ (AIS) of the cervix are illustrated by the presentation of three cases of benign cervical lesions initially diagnosed as AIS: cervical endometriosis, tubal metaplasia of the endocervix and changes due to a previous biopsy. The differential diagnosis of endocervical glandular abnormalities is discussed.     

Human papillomavirus infection of the cervix: the atypical condyloma

We report on 162 cases of human papillomavirus (HPV) infection of the cervix seen in a two-year period in which the cell sample showed such marked atypia that errors of interpretation could easily have been made. These atypical condylomata are difficult to diagnose cytologically as well as histologically because they mimic dysplasia or carcinoma in situ and, on smears, even invasive squamous carcinoma. HPV particles associated with fibrillar material were found within nuclei of these lesions; their nature was further proved by the immunoperoxidase test. This new form of HPV infection of the cervix showed a 9.1% rate of progression to more advanced cervical lesions. The cytologic finding of atypical condylomata is an indication for colposcopy, confirmative biopsy and appropriate treatment.     

Improving the sensitivity of cervical cytologic screening. A comparison of duplicate smears and colposcopic examination of patients with cytologic inflammatory epithelial changes

During a ten-month period, 264 cervical cytologic specimens were submitted in duplicate to two separate cytology laboratories. An attempt was made to perform colposcopy on all 45 patients reported as having an abnormality by either laboratory. All but one patient with a cytologic diagnosis of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) underwent colposcopy, as did 68% of the patients with a diagnosis of nondysplastic atypia (inflammatory epithelial changes [IEC]). Five cases of histologically verified CIN were found by colposcopic study of patients with a cytologic diagnosis of CIN; two additional cases were found by colposcopic study of patients with a cytologic diagnosis of IEC. On the assumption that patients not colposcoped were not systematically different from the others with IEC, the screening sensitivities for both laboratories and for cytology followed by colposcopy of IEC cases were estimated. A statistically significant improvement in screening sensitivity was achieved by colposcopic examination of patients with IEC. This conclusion was tempered by a Bayesian analysis that suggested that some of the apparent improved sensitivity could be due to falsely positive biopsy reports. Despite potential benefits, it is premature to recommend universal colposcopic examination of patients with cytologic reports of inflammatory epithelial changes.     

DNA-cytometric diagnosis of prospective malignancy in borderline lesions of the uterine cervix

Interactive DNA cytometry was used for the diagnosis of prospective malignancy in 48 smears with borderline lesions (mild and moderate dysplasias) of the uterine cervix. In addition, 183 smears with benign squamous epithelia, 38 with carcinoma in situ and 7 with invasive squamous carcinoma were also measured. Nuclear Feulgen-DNA measurements were performed using various methods, and the resulting data were analyzed by an algorithm for a DNA-cytophotometric diagnosis of malignancy. The results were compared with the data on follow-up and subsequent histologic studies in these cases. There was no false-positive diagnosis in the 183 benign smears and only 1 false-negative diagnosis in the 76 histologically proven squamous-cell carcinomas, which yields a specificity of 100% and a sensitivity of 98.6%. The sensitivity for the detection of subsequent histologically proven malignancy in cases with cytologically mild or moderate dysplasia amounted to 97%. In 13 borderline cases, there was a mean interval of 21 months between the taking of the cytologic smear on which the DNA diagnosis of malignancy was made and the date on which the histologic confirmation of malignancy was made. In 17% of the cytologically dysplastic cases, the DNA diagnosis of malignancy was not verified by subsequent histologic investigation. These results indicate that interactive DNA cytometry is able to detect prospective malignancy in smears from borderline lesions of the uterine cervix with a high sensitivity.     

Clinical value of repeat Pap smear at the time of colposcopy

OBJECTIVE: To determine the clinical value of a repeat (second) Pap smear at the time of colposcopy in the management of patients with recent cytologic abnormalities. STUDY DESIGN: A study of paired Pap smears and their corresponding cervical biopsies during a two-year period, commencing in June 1996, was undertaken. Pap smears and cervical biopsies from 614 patients were evaluated in the Department of Pathology, Royal Darwin Hospital, Northern Territory, Australia. To maintain uniformity, the cytologic and histologic findings were assessed according to the Bethesda System. RESULTS: The original (first) Pap smears included 288 high grade and 326 low grade lesions. The second smears showed 200 high grade, 221 low grade, 167 normal and 26 unsatisfactory cases. Punch biopsies revealed 242 high grade, 300 low grade and 72 inflammatory/reactive lesions. The changes noted in the second Pap smears and in the punch biopsies in the group originally diagnosed as having high grade disease were generally less advanced. The second Pap smears and corresponding cervical punch biopsies showed more advanced changes in the group originally diagnosed as having low grade disease. Removal of part of the abnormal epithelium during the first Pap smear and the desire of the colposcopist not to damage the surface epithelium prior to performing a cervical biopsy may account for some of these findings. Sampling errors and morphological misinterpretation may explain some of the findings. CONCLUSION: In the second smears, new cases of high grade abnormality were discovered mainly in patients with low grade changes on the first smears. Therefore, a second Pap smear at the time of colposcopy is justifiable in the group with low grade changes on the first smear.     

Pemphigus vulgaris and microinvasive squamous-cell carcinoma of the uterine cervix

Although patients with disseminated pemphigus vulgaris may have involvement of the uterine cervix, such involvement is often detected only after vaginal discharge or bleeding. When a cervical smear is obtained, distinctive cytologic abnormalities may be observed; these may be attributed to the changes of pemphigus or to an associated reparative/inflammatory reaction. This study documents the first two cases of microinvasive squamous-cell carcinoma of the uterine cervix developing in association with uterine cervical pemphigus. The gross pathologic, cytologic and histologic features of these lesions are illustrated. The cytologic criteria that may be helpful in distinguishing between cells derived from microinvasive squamous-cell carcinoma and pemphigus of the uterine cervix are described.     

Lipomatous lesions of the parotid gland. Potential pitfalls in fine needle aspiration biopsy diagnosis

Nine cases of benign fatty tumors of the parotid studied initially by fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy and subsequently diagnosed by open biopsy were reviewed. All lesions presented as enlargements of the parotid gland. The cytologic diagnoses were correct in only five of the nine cases. While four of six FNA samples from lipomas were correctly diagnosed by cytology, the other two samples were classified as inadequate. Three cases of diffuse infiltration of the parotid by mature-appearing adipose tissue were cytologically characterized as "no diagnostic change" in two cases and sialosis in one case. The clinical, radiologic, cytologic and histologic features of these tumors are described to increase the familiarity of cytologists with these lesions, which may prevent unnecessary surgical intervention in some patients.     

"Nonclassic" cytologic signs of cervical condyloma. A case-control study

The association between "nonclassic" cytologic signs of condyloma and human papillomavirus (HPV) infection in women with negative Papanicolaou smears was analyzed via a case-control study. The cytologic signs considered were mild koilocytosis, mild dyskeratosis, binucleation or multinucleation, cleared cytoplasm and nuclear hyperchromatism. The Papanicolaou smears of 166 cases that showed colposcopic and histologic evidence of HPV infection (but whose smears lacked the classic cytologic signs of condyloma) and 166 controls that were negative colposcopically were randomly admixed and blindly reviewed by a panel of cytologists. A significant association to HPV infection was observed for all of the nonclassic signs studied, but multivariate analysis showed a weakly independent association only for mild koilocytosis. The sensitivity (0.46) and the specificity (0.87) of these nonclassic signs were not satisfactory. The utility of selecting women with negative Papanicolaou smears for colposcopy on the basis of these signs is discussed.     

Earliest detection of oral cancer using non-invasive brush biopsy including DNA-image-cytometry: report on four cases.

OBJECTIVE: We describe four patients presenting early oral cancers, detected cytologically on non-invasive brush biopsies including DNA-image cytometry as an adjunctive method before histology on scalpel biopsies confirmed the evidence of malignancy. METHODS: Brush biopsies were performed and smears thereof investigated cytologically. After Feulgen restaining, DNA-measurements were performed using a DNA-Image-Cytometer. CASE REPORTS: Oral squamous cell carcinomas were diagnosed cytologically in macroscopically suspicious lesions and malignancy confirmed by DNA-cytometry. The initially performed scalpel biopsies did neither supply evidence of oral cancer nor of severe dysplasia. After at least one to 15 months the occurrence of cancer was finally proven histologically on a second scalpel biopsy each (three microinvasive and one in situ carcinoma). CONCLUSION: Non-invasive brush biopsies are a suitable instrument for early cytologic detection of cancer of the mouth. DNA-image-cytometry, as an adjunctive method, can be used to confirm the cytologic diagnosis or suspicion of cancer in patients with doubtful lesions (dysplasias). DNA-aneuploidy is a marker for (prospective) malignancy in smears of the oral cavity, which may detect malignancy months prior to histology. In future this method could be used as a mass screening tool in dentists practice.     

Human papillomavirus infection. Frequency and association with cervical neoplasia in a young population

One million, six hundred thirty-two thousand, eight hundred forty-seven women from two independent populations in the United States received cytologic screening during a two-year period. Condylomatous lesions (human papillomavirus [HPV] infections) were the most frequent cytologic abnormality in women in both the Planned Parenthood and private sector groups (prevalence rates of 18.6 to 19.0 in women between ages 15 to 19). The prevalence rates of mild-to-moderate dysplasia were also similar in both populations, with the highest frequencies being between ages 25 to 29. Severe dysplasia and carcinoma in situ were most frequent between ages 35 to 39. In both populations, women with condylomatous changes coexisting with dysplastic changes were about ten years younger, grade-for-grade of severity of the lesion, than women without evidence of HPV infection. Since HPV infection is believed to represent the soil from which neoplasm develops, both the frequency of condyloma and the occurrence of dysplasia and cancer in young women suggest that women should begin regular screening programs while in their teens or after they become sexually active.     

Acute myelogenous leukemia relapsing as granulocytic sarcoma of the cervix. A case report

BACKGROUND: Granulocytic sarcoma of the uterine cervix is an unusual manifestation of acute myeloid leukemia, representing soft tissue masses of leukemic myeloblasts. An often misdiagnosed entity, it is often confused with other inflammatory or neoplastic conditions, including large cell lymphoma. CASE: A 67-year-old female presented with acute myelogenous leukemia and a normal karyotype. After eight years in complete remission, abdominal pain and an ulcerated mass in the uterine cervix developed, with a normal peripheral blood smear. Vaginal cytology examination revealed myeloid blasts, which, on subsequent cervical biopsy, stained positive for leukocyte common antigen, Kp-1 (CD68), antimyeloperoxidase, lysozyme and chloroacetate esterase, confirming the cytologic diagnosis. K-ras was not mutated at codon 12 or 13. Chemotherapy induced a complete remission, followed nine months later by central nervous system and then systemic relapse. The patient died 13 months after being diagnosed with granulocytic sarcoma of the cervix. CONCLUSION: This case illustrates the value of vaginal cytology and histologic biopsy evaluation in patients with acute myelogenous leukemia, including those without evidence of systemic disease. The characteristic cytologic features of granulocytic sarcoma led to the correct diagnosis. Histologic biopsy evaluation, including immunohistochemistry for myeloid markers, proved of value in confirming the diagnosis.     

Comparative study of cytology and punch biopsy in cervical intraepithelial neoplasia during pregnancy. A preliminary report

To elucidate the accuracy of cytology in diagnosing cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) during pregnancy, cytologic screenings for uterine cervical cancer in pregnant women were reviewed for a five-year period. Of the 967 pregnant women screened, abnormal cytologic findings were recorded for 15 (1.6%). Only nine of these were subsequently examined by colposcopy and punch biopsy, which demonstrated CIN in all cases, for an incidence of documented CIN during pregnancy of 0.93%. Including two referral cases also examined by colposcopy and biopsy, cytology and histology agreed on the degree of CIN in four cases and disagreed by one degree in four cases, by two degrees in two cases and by three degrees (mild dysplasia versus carcinoma in situ) in one case. Review of the specimens from these cases did not readily explain the poor concordance between cytology and punch biopsy; some findings suggest that overestimation of the punch biopsy sample may be the explanation.     

ASCUS-LSIL Triage Study. Design, methods and characteristics of trial participants

OBJECTIVE: To describe the design and methods of the ASCUS-LSIL Triage Study (ALTS), a multicenter, randomized clinical trial designed to evaluate three alternative methods of managing low grade (LSIL) and equivocal (ASCUS) cervical cytologic diagnoses. STUDY DESIGN: Nonpregnant women, 18+ years old, with ASCUS or LSIL, no prior hysterectomy or ablative therapy to the cervix, were referred to one of four clinical centers around the United States. Eligible and consenting participants were administered a risk-factor questionnaire and underwent a pelvic examination, collection of cervical specimens for liquid-based cytology and human papillomavirus (HPV) testing and Cervicography (National Testing Laboratories, Fenton, Missouri, U.S.A.). Patients were randomized to one of three arms: (1) immediate referral for colposcopy at enrollment, (2) follow-up with cytology only, and (3) use of HPV DNA testing to triage to colposcopy. All women are followed every six months for two years with pelvic examinations, cytologic and masked HPV testing, and masked Cervicography. Digital cervical images and cytology and histology slides are externally reviewed to maximize patient safety. RESULTS: We enrolled and randomized 3,488 eligible women with ASCUS and 1,572 women with LSIL. CONCLUSION: The successful enrollment, randomization and high rates of follow-up are encouraging. The study will help clarify the optimal strategies for managing low grade cervical abnormalities.     

Implications of inflammatory changes on cervical cytology.

OBJECTIVE--To assess premenopausal women with inflammatory changes on cervical cytology for genital infections and cervical abnormalities. DESIGN--Prospective study of women attending general practice and family planning clinics who had a recent cervical cytology result with inflammatory changes. SETTING--Department of genitourinary medicine. PATIENTS--102 Premenopausal women with recent cytology result showing inflammatory changes and with no history of antibiotic or antifungal treatment since their smear. INVESTIGATIONS--Genital examination and microbiological screening for genital infections; colposcopic examination about six weeks later. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES--Detection of genital infections, particularly those sexually acquired, and abnormalities on colposcopy. RESULTS--Genital infections were isolated in 77 patients, and one or more sexually acquired infections were found in 22. Prevalence of sexually acquired infections was significantly correlated with younger age (particularly being under 25), being single, separated, or divorced; using non-barrier contraception; and recent change of sexual partner. An abnormality on colposcopy was found in 36 women. There was a strong correlation of a sexually acquired infection with an abnormality at colposcopy; hence younger women were more likely to have a colposcopic abnormality. CONCLUSIONS--Inflammatory changes on cytology are often associated with the presence of a sexually acquired infection and premalignant disease of the cervix, particularly in younger, single women using non-barrier contraception.