Microscopy of a cytoplasmic male-sterile soybean from an interspecific cross between Glycine max and G. soja (Leguminosae)

Cytoplasmic male sterility has been found independently in soybean three times since 1995, but no microscopic investigation has been published. The purpose of this microscopic study was to establish the developmental sequence leading to sterility in a cytoplasmic male-sterile soybean line that has been found to be stable under all environmental conditions tested and to demarcate the temporal and spatial parameters that result in degeneration of the microspores and pollen grains. Light microscopy showed an abnormal development and/or premature degeneration of the tapetum after meiosis II, but some pollen grains persisted until after microspore mitosis. The pollen grains never completely filled with reserves. Premature formation of the endothecium also was evident. Histochemical staining for water-insoluble carbohydrates revealed an abnormal pattern of starch deposition in anther walls that coincided with lack of pollen filling. Electron microscopy showed degeneration of the inner mitochondrial membrane in the tapetal cells as the first detectable change leading to cell degeneration. Subsequently, the tapetal endoplasmic reticulum exhibited atypical concentric rings. Pollen grains displayed mitochondria with unusually enlarged inner mitochondrial spaces, degraded plastids, a rudimentary intine, and no starch or lipid reserves. Results link mitochondrial degeneration, premature formation of the endothecium, and energy deprivation to male sterility.     

Ultrastructural study of rice tapetum under low-temperature stress

The development of male reproductive organs in rice is very sensitive to various environmental stresses. For example, exposing plants to low temperatures during the heading stage leads to a reduction in grain yield. Here, we grew rice under normal conditions and also at three different temperatures -- 16, 18, and 20°C. Treatment at a low temperature significantly decreased pollen viability and grain production. Cytological observations of the anther showed that the tapetum was the most sensitive to low-temperature stress, resulting in male sterility due to functional loss of the tissue. Detailed observations by transmission electron microscopy suggested that this abnormality was restricted primarily to the ER structures. The endoplasmic reticulum, a highly vulnerable sub-cellular organelle, showed two typical morphological aberrations, one in its pattern of arrangement, the other in the formation of ER bodies. Of our three experimental chilling temperatures, the most severe abnormalities were observed in tapetal cells exposed to 16°C.     

Ultrastructural aspects and programmed cell death in the tapetal cells of Lathyrus undulatus Boiss

Programmed cell death (PCD) in the tapetum of Lathyrus undulatus L. was analyzed based on light, fluorescence and electron microscopy to characterize its spatial and temporal occurrence. Development and processes of PCD in secretory tapetal cells of Lathyrus undulatus L. were correlated with the sporogenous cells and pollen grains. At early stages of development the tapetal cells appeared similar to pollen mother cells, structurally. Concurrent with meiosis, tapetum expanded both tangentially and radially as vacuoles increased in size. Tapetal cells most fully developed at young microspore stage. However, tapetum underwent substantial changes in cell organization including nucleus morphology monitored by DAPI. The TUNEL staining confirmed the occurrence of intra-nucleosomal DNA cleavage. In addition to nuclear degeneration which is the first hallmark of PCD other diagnostic features were observed at vacuolated microspore stage intensely; such as chromatin condensation at the periphery of the nucleus, nuclear membrane degeneration, chromatin release to the cytoplasm, vacuole collapse according to tonoplast rupture, shrinkage of the cytoplasm, the increase and enlargement of the endoplasmic reticulum cisternae and disruption of the plasma membrane. After vacuole collapse due to possible release of hydrolytic enzymes the cell components degraded. Tapetal cells completely degenerated at bicellular pollen stage.     

Ultrastructural observations on anther tapetum development of freeze-fixed Ledebouria socialis Roth (Hyacinthaceae)

The tapetal ultrastructure of high-pressure-frozen, freeze-substituted Ledebouria socialis Roth (Hyacinthaceae) is described from the tetrad stage up to microspore mitosis. Cytoplasmic degeneration of the tapeturn occurs after microspore mitosis. During the tetrad stage and the early free-microspore stage the tapetum cells appear to be meristematic; after callose dissolution they show an intense exocytosis of polysaccharides into the anther locule. Later, the tapetum cells are characterized by abundant endoplasmic reticulum (ER). Highly osmiophilic pollenkitt precursor substances accumulate within distinct, partly irregular shaped cytoplasmic domains (“osmiophilic bodies”), which are intimately associated with the ER. It remains to be verified whether or not these bodies are derived from the ER. Because of their preservation and staining patterns the contents of these bodies are tentatively interpreted as flavonoids, one of the main pollenkitt pigments in angiosperms. Apart from these pigment bodies, there exist four other kinds of lipophilic inclusion within the anther (cells). The general aspects of lipid preservation in freeze-substituted samples are discussed. Staining with hot alcoholic phosphotungstic acid yielded good contrast of the ER and other membranes, which are often difficult to visualize in freeze-substituted, resin-embedded samples.     

Microsporogenesis and tapetal development in fertile and cytoplasmic male-sterile sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.)

Summary The development of sporogenous and tapetal cells in the anthers of male-fertile and cytoplasmic male-sterile sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.) plants was studied using light and transmission electron microscopy. In general, male-sterile anthers showed a much greater variability in developmental pattern than male-fertile anthers. The earliest deviation from normal anther development was observed to occur in sterile anthers at meiotic early prophase: there was a degeneration or irregular proliferation of the tapetal cells. Other early aberrant events were the occurrence of numerous small vesicles in the microspore mother cells (MMC) and a disorganized chromatin condensation. Deviations that occurred in sterile anthers at later developmental stages included: (1) less distinct inner structures in the mitochondria of both MMC and tapetal cells from middle prophase onwards. (2) dilated ER and nuclear membranes at MMC prophase, in some cases associated with the formation of protein bodies. (3) breakdown of cell walls in MMCs and tapetal cells at late meiotic prophase. (4) no massive increase in tapetal ER at the tetrad stage. (5) a general dissolution of membranes, first in the MMC, then in the tapetum. (6) abortion of microspores and the occurrence of a plasmodial tapetum in anthers reaching the microspore stage. (7) no distinct degeneration of tapetal cells after microspore formation. Thus, it seems that the factors that lead to abortive microsporogenesis are structurally expressed at widely different times during anther development. Aberrant patterns are not restricted to the tetrad stage but occur at early prophase.     

Abnormal anther development and high sporopollenin synthesis in benzotriazole treated male sterile Helianthus annuus L

Foliar application of 1.5% benzotriazole induced 100% pollen sterility in H. annuus. Pollen abortion in treated plants was mainly associated with abnormal behaviour of tapetum. A limited number of anther locule showed early degeneration of tapetum followed by disintegration of sporogenous tissues. On the other hand, some locules showed normal development of tapetum at initial stages. However, this tapetum exhibited degenerated and non-functional cell organelles. In both these situations tapetum failed to provide proper nourishment to developing microspores. The ultrastructure of both tapetum and microspores is different from that of control material with irregularities of exine deposition, endopolyploidy of tapetal nuclei and an alteration of organelle composition being correlated with sterility. Pollen grains thus developed were devoid of nucleus and cell organelles and were complete sterile.     

The loculus content and tapetum during pollen development in Lilium

 The ratio of loculus volume to the volume of the entire anther began to increase from the microspore mother cell stage and reached 32.3% at anthesis. The content of the loculus was examined in Lilium during pollen development and two waves could be distinguished. From the premeiotic stage until the vacuolated microspore stage, the loculus consisted of neutral polysaccharides, pectins and proteins. These substances originated from tapetal activity from the premeiotic stage until the young microspore stage. Dictyosomes and rough endoplasmic reticulum seemed to be involved in tapetal secretion, although, in some mitochondria, vesicles progressively developed as early as premeiosis and increased until the young microspore stage, which could reveal their involvement in the secretion process. At this stage, numerous cytoplasmic vesticles containing material similar to the locular material fused with the plasma membrane of the tapetum so that vesicle content was in contact with the loculus. It seems that tapetal and callose wall degradation at the late tetrad stage may also have contributed to the production of material in the loculus. From pollen mitosis to anthesis, the anther loculus contained mainly the pollenkitt which was synthesized in the tapetum between the young microspore stage and the vacuolated microspore stage. At the young microspore stage, proplastids divided and developed into elaioplasts and smooth endoplasmic reticulum (SER) increased dramatically. Pollenkitt had a double origin: some droplets were extruded directly from the plastid stroma through the plastid envelopes; the others were unsaturated lipid globules, which presumably derived from the interaction between SER saccules and plastids. Received: 2 September 1997 / Revision accepted: 12 March 1998     

A comparative light and electron microscopic analysis of microspore and tapetum development in fertile and cytoplasmic male sterile radish

To gain further insight into the abortive stages and ultrastructural changes leading to pollen degeneration of a novel cytoplasmic male sterile radish 805A, we compared differences of cellular and subcellular structure of sterile anther with fertile anther by light and electron microscopy analysis. Two types of locule degeneration in sterile anther were detected, of which the time of degeneration occurred and completed was different. In type I, abnormality of pollen mother cells (PMCs) and tapetal cells, including condensation of cytoplasm and large vacuoles within tapetal cells, was shown at PMC stage. In type II, meiosis and early tetrad stage progressed normally except for large vacuoles that appeared in tapetal cells. Ultrastructural alterations of the cellular organization were observed in the type II locules, such as chromatin condensation at the periphery of the nucleus and degeneration of the karyotheca, compared with normal pollen development. The results suggested that the cytoplasmic male sterility anther degeneration was probably caused by dysfunctions of tapetum and vacuolation of tapetum, PMCs, and microspores. Thus, the identical factors, which induced CMS in the same cytoplasmic and nuclear genetic background, might affect development of tapetum and microspore at different stages during the cytoplasmic male sterile 805A anther development.     

A Comparative Study of Anther and Pollen Development in Male Fertile and Male. Sterile Green Onion (Allium fistulosum L.)

Anther and pollen development in male-fertile and male-sterile green onions was studied. In the male-fertile line, both meiotic microspore mother ceils and tetrads have a callose wall. Mature pollen grains are 2-celled. The elongated generative cell with two bended ends displays a PAS positive cell wall. The tapetum has the character of both secretory and invasive types. From microspore stage onwards, many oil bodies or masses accumulate in the cytoplasm of the tapetal cells. The tapetum degenerates at middle 2-celled pollen stage. In male-sterile line, meiosis in microspore mother cells proceeds normally to form the tetrads. Pollen abortion occurs at microspore with vacuole stage. Two types of pollen abortion were observed. In type I, the protoplasts of the microspores contract and gradually disintegrate. At the same time the cytoplasm of microspores accumulates oil bodies which remain in the empty pollen. The tapetal cells behave normally up to the microspore stage and early stage of microspore abortion, but contain fewer oil bodies or masses than those in the male-fertilt line. At late stage of microspore abortion, three forms of the tapetal ceils can be observed: (1) the tapetal cells with degenerating protoplasts become flattened, (2) the tapetal cells enlarge but protoplasts retractor, (3) the cells break down and tile middle layer enlarges. In type Ⅱ, the cytoplasm degenerates earlier than the nucleus of the microspores and no protoplast is found in the anther locule. There are fibrous thickenings iii the endothecium of both types. It is difficult to verify whether the tapetum behavior and pollen abortion is the cause or the effect.     

S351┐1西瓜雄性不育的细胞学研究

西瓜Ｓ３５１－１雄性不育材料的细胞学观察表明：与对照的同系可育株相比,败育发生在次级造孢细胞到小孢子母细胞或小孢子四分体阶段,多数不育雄花花药中绒毡层始终未分化,药壁常由７－８层细胞组成,少数不育花药中出现绒毡层徒长现象;次级造孢细胞败育不同步,出现多核及多核仁现象,败育后期,药壁细胞逐渐解体,药室瓦解,花粉囊收缩变形。由此可见：其雄性不育与绒毡层的发育异常有直接联系。     

MALE STERILITY IN SOYBEAN (GLYCINE MAX). I. PHENOTYPIC EXPRESSION OF THE ms2 MUTANT

The effects of a nuclear male-sterile mutant (ms2) of soybean, Glycine max (L.) Merr., on anther development were analyzed by means of light- and electron-microscopy. The structure of microspore mother cells (MMCs) in male-sterile plants was identical to that of male-fertile plants. Meiosis was completed, and tetrads of microspores formed. Microspores degenerated after the deposition of primexine and probacullae. The sheath of callose surrounding microspores did not dissolve. No structural abnormalities of the microspores were detected before the onset of degeneration. The tapetal and anther wall layers were characterized by aberrant development. Tapetal abnormalities included premature vacuolation, a persistent inner tangential cell wall, failure to differentiate normal concentrations of endoplasmic reticulum and dictyosomes, disruption of plastids, and premature degeneration. Malfunction of the tapetal layer preceded, and may have induced, microspore degeneration. Gross anther morphology was not influenced until advanced stages of development.     

Ultrastructure of microsporogenesis and microgametogenesis inArabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh. ecotype Wassilewskija (Brassicaceae)

Summary The process of microsporogenesis and microgametogenesis was studied at the ultrastructural level in wild-typeArabidopsis thaliana ecotype Wassilewskija to provide a basis for comparison with nuclear male-sterile mutants of the same ecotype. From the earliest stage studied to mature pollen just prior to anther dehiscence, microsporocyte/microspore/pollen development follows the general pattern seen in most angiosperms. The tapetum is of the secretory type with loss of the tapetal cell walls beginning at about the time of microsporocyte meiosis. Wall loss exhibits polarity with the tapetal protoplasts becoming located at a distance from the inner tangential walls first, followed by an increase in distance from the radial walls beginning at the interior edge and progressing outward. The inner tangential and radial tapetal walls are completely degenerated by the microspore tetrad stage. Unlike other members of the Brassicaceae that have been studied, the tapetal cells ofA. thaliana Wassilewskija also lose their outer tangential walls, and secretion occurs from all sides of the cells. Exine wall precursors are secreted from the tapetal cells in a process that appears to involve dilation of individual endoplasmic reticulum cisternae that fuse with the tapetal cell membrane and release their contents into the locule. Following completion of the exine, the tapetal cell plastids develop membranebound inclusions with osmiophilic and electron-transparent regions. The plastids undergo ultrastructural changes that suggest breakdown of the inclusion membranes followed by release of their contents into the locule prior to the complete degeneration of the tapetal cells.     

Ultrastructure of tapetal cell ontogeny inBeta

Summary Tapetal cell development and degeneration in anthers ofBeta vulgaris L. were studied with the electron microscope. Tapetal cells become differentiated from sporogenous cells early in anther ontogeny. The tapetal nuclei divide mitotically; binucleate tapetal cells contain relatively little endoplasmic reticulum and otherwise resemble meristematic cells of higher plants. There follows an increase in endoplasmic reticulum and by the time the sporogenous tissue has entered meiotic prophase, the tapetal cells have differentiated the usual characteristics of secretory cells. Degenerative changes begin to appear in tapetal cells after meiosis of the sporogenous tissue. Such changes include loss of inner tangential and anticlinal walls, degeneration of tapetal nuclear envelopes, disruption of the plasmalemma, and changes in the cytoplasmic organelles. Coated tubules are associated with tapetal nucleoli during degenerative stages and the tubules persist after tapetal nuclei have degenerated. Tapetal cell cytoplasm disappears completely by the stage of microspore mitosis.     

Isolation,sorting, and characterization of uni- and binucleate tapetal protoplasts from anthers of normal and Texas cytoplasmic male-sterileZea mays L.

Summary A cytological study of Texas cytoplasmic male sterile (Tcms) and normal (N) anther tapetal protoplasts ofZea mays was undertaken to determine whether there were any differences prior to Tcms male cell abortion not noted in previous published studies. Squash preparations, tapetal protoplast separation via flow cytometry, image analysis, and electron microscopy were utilized. Chemically preserved tapetal protoplasts from both lines were prominently angular in shape and typically smaller than any other cell type in the anthers. The tapetum from both lines consisted of a mixture of uninucleate and binucleate protoplasts. The Tcms tapetum consistently had a higher proportion of binucleate protoplasts during all stages of microsporogenesis prior to abortion. The size of Tcms uniand binucleate tapetal protoplasts was more variable than the N tapetal protoplasts and was largest during the microspore stage when male cells abort. Tapetal nuclear size in both lines was less variable. Uni- and binucleate tapetal protoplasts from each line could be separated from the other anther cells and from each other by filtration and then by flow cytometry, based on intensity of nuclear fluorescence. These results suggest that Tcms uninucleate tapetal protoplasts have a higher level of DNA than N uninucleate tapetal protoplasts. Both fluorescence microscopy and electron microscopy confirmed pure populations of intact uni- and binucleate tapetal protoplasts using flow cytometry. The results from this study indicate that the methodology presented here could be used for a variety of further studies to better understand the cellular and molecular basis of male sterility in maize, and in other taxa, where the tapetum is the primary target that leads to male sterility.Abbreviations AO acridine orange - Bi binucleate protoplast - D dyad - DAPI 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole - FC flow cytometry - M meiocyte - MI microspore - MMC mithramycin - N normal anther tapetal protoplast - PI propidium iodide - PS protoplast sorting - RT room temperature - SM sporogenous mass - Tems Texas cytoplasmic male sterile anther tapetal protoplast - Uni uninucleate protoplast     

Development of the pollen grain and tapetum of wheat (Triticum aestivum) in untreated plants and plants treated with chemical hybridizing agent RH0007

Summary A study of pollen development in wheat was made using transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Microspores contain undifferentiated plastids and mitochondria that are dividing. Vacuolation occurs, probably due to the coalescence of small vacuoles budded off the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). As the pollen grain is formed and matures, the ER becomes distended with deposits of granular storage material. Mitochondria proliferate and become filled with cristae. Similarly, plastids divide and accumulate starch. The exine wall is deposited at a rapid rate throughout development, and the precursors appear to be synthesized in the tapetum. Tapetal cells become binucleate during the meiosis stage, and Ubisch bodies form on the plasma membrane surface that faces the locule. Tapetal plastids become surrounded by an electron-translucent halo. Rough ER is associated with the halo around the plastids and with the plasma membrane. We hypothesize that the sporopollenin precursors for both the Ubisch bodies and exine pollen wall are synthesized in the tapetal plastids and are transported to the tapetal cell surface via the ER. The microspore plastids appear to be involved in activities other than precursor synthesis: plastid proliferation in young microspores, and starch synthesis later in development. Plants treated with the chemical hybridizing agent RH0007 show a pattern of development similar to that shown by untreated control plants through the meiosis stage. In the young microspore stage the exine wall is deposited irregularly and is thinner than that of control plants. In many cases the microspores are seen to have wavy contours. With the onset of vacuolation, microspores become plasmolyzed and abort. The tapetal cells in RH0007-treated locules divide normally through the meiosis stage. Less sporopollenin is deposited in the Ubisch bodies, and the pattern is less regular than that of the control. In many cases, the tapetal cells expand into the locule. At the base of one of the locules treated with a dosage of RH0007 that causes 95% male sterility, several microspores survived and developed into pollen grains that were sterile. The conditions at the base of the locule may have reduced the osmotic stress on the microspores, allowing them to survive. Preliminary work showed that the extractable quantity of carotenoids in RHOOO7-treated anthers was slightly greater than in controls. We concluded that RH0007 appears to interfere with the polymerization of carotenoid precursors into the exine wall and Ubisch bodies, rather than interfering with the synthesis of the precursors.     

麻疯树小孢子发育的研究

用透射电镜观察了麻疯树(Jatropha curcas L.)小孢子发育的超微结构。小孢子母细胞时期内质网和质体较多;减数分裂和四分体时期,细胞处于明显的代谢活跃状态,细胞器丰富,主要有内质网、线粒体、质体、高尔基体和球状体;在小孢子发育早期和晚期,线粒体和内质网仍较丰富;小孢子经过高度的不对称分裂后,形成较大的营养细胞和较小的生殖细胞,营养细胞中细胞器数量明显减少,含大量的淀粉和脂类物质,生殖细胞中脂类物质丰富;表皮、药室内壁和中层细胞在小孢子母细胞和四分体时期淀粉粒丰富,小孢子时期明显减少,绒毡层从小孢子母细胞至小孢子发育晚期的细胞器都很丰富,主要为内质网、质体和线粒体,为二胞花粉发育奠定基础。     

POLLEN WALL AND TAPETAL ORBICULAR WALL DEVELOPMENT IN SORGHUM BICOLOR (GRAMINEAE)

Pollen wall development in Sorghum bicolor is morphologically and temporally paralleled by the formation of a prominent orbicular wall on the inner tangential surface of the tapetum. In the late tetrad stage, a thin, nearly uniform primexine forms around each microspore (except at the pore site) beneath the intact callose; concurrently, small spherical bodies (pro-orbicules) appear between the undulate tapetal plasmalemma and the disappearing tapetal primary wall. Within the primexine, differentially staining loci appear, which only develop into young bacula as the callose disappears. Thus, microspore walls are devoid of a visible exine pattern when released from tetrads. Afterwards, sporopollenin accumulates simultaneously on the primexine and bacula, forming the exine, and on the pro-orbicules, forming orbicules. Channels develop in the tectum and nexine, and both layers thicken to complete the microspore exine. Channeled sporopollenin also accumulates on the orbicules. A prominent sporopollenin reticulum interconnects the individual orbicules to produce an orbicular wall; this wall persists even after the tapetal protoplasts degenerate and after anthesis. While the pollen grains become engorged with reserves, a thick intine, containing conspicuous cytoplasmic channels, forms beneath the exine. Fibrous material collects beneath the orbicular wall. The parallel development and morphological similarities between the tapetal and pollen walls are discussed.     

荔枝雄花性别决定过程中细胞超微结构的变化

荔枝雄花雌蕊原基在大孢子母细胞减数分裂后开始衰退.内质网历经增生扩展,穿壁相连,同心缠绕,多条平行弯曲,不规则堆叠.内质网和高尔基体产生许多囊泡,囊泡在细胞内含物的降解和运输过程中起着重要的作用.线粒体在雌蕊原基细胞衰败的前、中期数量增加,后期分批降解.过氧化物酶体在雌蕊原基细胞衰败的中期紧挨核短暂出现.细胞核的染色质凝集断裂;核周腔扩大,形成胀泡;染色质趋边,外泄.细胞原生质表现出有序的、在膜包裹下的降解,首先是核糖体,而后依次是:过氧化物酶体、内质网、高尔基体、线粒体、核.雌蕊原基的衰败历程可能是一种程序性细胞死亡的过程.     

Early signs of disruption of wheat anther development associated with the induction of male sterility by meiotic-stage water deficit

 Water deficit during meiosis in microspore mother cells of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) induces male sterility, which reduces grain yield. In plants stressed during meiosis and then re-watered, division of microspore mother cells seems to proceed normally, but subsequent pollen development is arrested. Stress-affected anthers generally lack starch. We employed light microscopy in conjunction with histochemistry to compare the developmental anatomy of water-stress-affected and normal anthers. The earliest effects of stress, detectable between meiosis and young microspore stages, were the degeneration of meiocytes, loss of orientation of the reproductive cells, and abnormal vacuolization of tapetal cells. Other effects observed during subsequent developmental stages were deposition of starch in the connective tissue where it is normally not present, hypertrophy of the middle layer or endothecial cells, and deposition of sporopollenin-like substances in the anther loculus. The resulting pollen grains lacked both starch and intine. These results suggest that abnormal degeneration of the tapetum in water-stressed anthers coupled with a loss of orientation of the reproductive cells could be part of early events leading to abortion of microspores. Received: 19 July 1996 / Revision accepted: 6 November 1996