Bayesian multilocus association mapping on ordinal and censored traits and its application to the analysis of genetic variation among Oryza sativa L. germplasms

Association mapping can be a powerful tool for detecting quantitative trait loci (QTLs) without requiring line-crossing experiments. We previously proposed a Bayesian approach for simultaneously mapping multiple QTLs by a regression method that directly incorporates estimates of the population structure. In the present study, we extended our method to analyze ordinal and censored traits, since both types of traits are common in the evaluation of germplasm collections. Ordinal-probit and tobit models were employed to analyze ordinal and censored traits, respectively. In both models, we postulated the existence of a latent continuous variable associated with the observable data, and we used a Markov-chain Monte Carlo algorithm to sample the latent variable and determine the model parameters. We evaluated the efficiency of our approach by using simulated- and real-trait analyses of a rice germplasm collection. Simulation analyses based on real marker data showed that our models could reduce both false-positive and false-negative rates in detecting QTLs to reasonable levels. Simulation analyses based on highly polymorphic marker data, which were generated by coalescent simulations, showed that our models could be applied to genotype data based on highly polymorphic marker systems, like simple sequence repeats. For the real traits, we analyzed heading date as a censored trait and amylose content and the shape of milled rice grains as ordinal traits. We found significant markers that may be linked to previously reported QTLs. Our approach will be useful for whole-genome association mapping of ordinal and censored traits in rice germplasm collections.     

The quadratic cumulative odds regression model for scored ordinal outcomes: application to alcohol dependence

In this paper, we develop new regression models for the analysis of scored ordinal data (i.e. ordinal outcomes where the categories are assigned numeric values). The novel feature of these models is that they enable one to capture and identify nonlinear aspects of the relationship between an ordinal clinical measurement (used for disease diagnosis) and risk factors. These nonlinearities may be useful in generating hypotheses about the risk factor's role in the etiologic process as well as suggesting how to design future studies of the risk factor. We apply our model to study the effects of race, gender, and family history on alcohol dependence among a cohort of lifetime drinkers from the 1992 National Longitudinal Alcohol Epidemiologic Survey.     

Prediction in censored survival data: a comparison of the proportional hazards and linear regression models.

Although the analysis of censored survival data using the proportional hazards and linear regression models is common, there has been little work examining the ability of these estimators to predict time to failure. This is unfortunate, since a predictive plot illustrating the relationship between time to failure and a continuous covariate can be far more informative regarding the risk associated with the covariate than a Kaplan-Meier plot obtained by discretizing the variable. In this paper the predictive power of the Cox (1972, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B 34, 187-202) proportional hazards estimator and the Buckley-James (1979, Biometrika 66, 429-436) censored regression estimator are compared. Using computer simulations and heuristic arguments, it is shown that the choice of method depends on the censoring proportion, strength of the regression, the form of the censoring distribution, and the form of the failure distribution. Several examples are provided to illustrate the usefulness of the methods.     

Median Regression Model with Interval Censored Data

Quantile regression methods have been used to estimate upper and lower quantile reference curves as the function of several covariates. Especially, in survival analysis, median regression models to the right‐censored data are suggested with several assumptions. In this article, we consider a median regression model for interval‐censored data and construct an estimating equation based on weights derived from interval‐censored data. In a simulation study, the performances of the proposed method are evaluated for both symmetric and right‐skewed distributed failure times. A well‐known breast cancer data are analyzed to illustrate the proposed method.     

Additive risk models for survival data with high-dimensional covariates

As a useful alternative to Cox's proportional hazard model, the additive risk model assumes that the hazard function is the sum of the baseline hazard function and the regression function of covariates. This article is concerned with estimation and prediction for the additive risk models with right censored survival data, especially when the dimension of the covariates is comparable to or larger than the sample size. Principal component regression is proposed to give unique and numerically stable estimators. Asymptotic properties of the proposed estimators, component selection based on the weighted bootstrap, and model evaluation techniques are discussed. This approach is illustrated with analysis of the primary biliary cirrhosis clinical data and the diffuse large B-cell lymphoma genomic data. It is shown that this methodology is numerically stable and effective in dimension reduction, while still being able to provide satisfactory prediction and classification results.     

On the use of the substitution method in left-censored environmental data

In risk assessment and environmental monitoring studies, concentration measurements frequently fall below detection limits (DL) of measuring instruments, resulting in left-censored data. The principal approaches for handling censored data include the substitution-based method, maximum likelihood estimation, robust regression on order statistics, and Kaplan-Meier. In practice, censored data are substituted with an arbitrary value prior to use of traditional statistical methods. Although some studies have evaluated the substitution performance in estimating population characteristics, they have focused mainly on normally and lognormally distributed data that contain a single DL. We employ Monte Carlo simulations to assess the impact of substitution when estimating population parameters based on censored data containing multiple DLs. We also consider different distributional assumptions including lognormal, Weibull, and gamma. We show that the reliability of the estimates after substitution is highly sensitive to distributional characteristics such as mean, standard deviation, skewness, and also data characteristics such as censoring percentage. The results highlight that although the performance of the substitution-based method improves as the censoring percentage decreases, its performance still depends on the population's distributional characteristics. Practical implications that follow from our findings indicate that caution must be taken in using the substitution method when analyzing censored environmental data.     

Calculating Ordinal Regression Models in SAS and S‐Plus

Although a number of regression models for ordinal responses have been proposed, these models are not widely known and applied in epidemiology and biomedical research. Overviews of these models are either highly technical or consider only a small part of this class of models so that it is difficult to understand the features of the models and to recognize important relations between them. In this paper we give an overview of logistic regression models for ordinal data based upon cumulative and conditional probabilities. We show how the most popular ordinal regression models, namely the proportional odds model and the continuation ratio model, are embedded in the framework of generalized linear models. We describe the characteristics and interpretations of these models and show how the calculations can be performed by means of SAS and S‐Plus. We illustrate and compare the methods by applying them to data of a study investigating the effect of several risk factors on diabetic retinopathy. A special aspect is the violation of the usual assumption of equal slopes which makes the correct application of standard models impossible. We show how to use extensions of the standard models to work adequately with this situation.     

Regression analysis of doubly censored failure time data using the additive hazards model

Doubly censored failure time data arise when the survival time of interest is the elapsed time between two related events and observations on occurrences of both events could be censored. Regression analysis of doubly censored data has recently attracted considerable attention and for this a few methods have been proposed (Kim et al., 1993, Biometrics 49, 13-22; Sun et al., 1999, Biometrics 55, 909-914; Pan, 2001, Biometrics 57, 1245-1250). However, all of the methods are based on the proportional hazards model and it is well known that the proportional hazards model may not fit failure time data well sometimes. This article investigates regression analysis of such data using the additive hazards model and an estimating equation approach is proposed for inference about regression parameters of interest. The proposed method can be easily implemented and the properties of the proposed estimates of regression parameters are established. The method is applied to a set of doubly censored data from an AIDS cohort study.     

Regression modeling of ordinal data with nonzero baselines

This paper develops regression models for ordinal data with nonzero control response probabilities. The models are especially useful in dose-response studies where the spontaneous or natural response rate is nonnegligible and the dosage is logarithmic. These models generalize Abbott's formula, which has been commonly used to model binary data with nonzero background observations. We describe a biologically plausible latent structure and develop an EM algorithm for fitting the models. The EM algorithm can be implemented using standard software for ordinal regression. A toxicology data set where the proposed model fits the data but a more conventional model fails is used to illustrate the methodology.     

Statistical methods for describing developmental milestones with censored data: effects of birth weight status and sex in neonatal pigtailed macaques

Neurobehavioral tests are used to assess early neonatal behavioral functioning and detect effects of prenatal and perinatal events. However, common measurement and data collection methods create specific data features requiring thoughtful statistical analysis. Assessment response measurements are often ordinal scaled, not interval scaled; the magnitude of the physical response may not directly correlate with the underlying state of developmental maturity; and a subject's assessment record may be censored. Censoring occurs when the milestone is exhibited at the first test (left censoring), when the milestone is not exhibited before the end of the study (right censoring), or when the exact age of attaining the milestone is uncertain due to irregularly spaced test sessions or missing data (interval censoring). Such milestone data is best analyzed using survival analysis methods. Two methods are contrasted: the non-parametric Kaplan-Meier estimator and the fully parametric interval censored regression. The methods represent the spectrum of survival analyses in terms of parametric assumptions, ability to handle simultaneous testing of multiple predictors, and accommodation of different types of censoring. Both methods were used to assess birth weight status and sex effects on 14 separate test items from assessments on 255 healthy pigtailed macaques. The methods gave almost identical results. Compared to the normal birth weight group, the low birth weight group had significantly delayed development on all but one test item. Within the low birth weight group, males had significantly delayed development for some responses relative to females.     

A quantile‐slicing approach for sufficient dimension reduction with censored responses

Sufficient dimension reduction (SDR) that effectively reduces the predictor dimension in regression has been popular in high‐dimensional data analysis. Under the presence of censoring, however, most existing SDR methods suffer. In this article, we propose a new algorithm to perform SDR with censored responses based on the quantile‐slicing scheme recently proposed by Kim et al. First, we estimate the conditional quantile function of the true survival time via the censored kernel quantile regression (Shin et al.) and then slice the data based on the estimated censored regression quantiles instead of the responses. Both simulated and real data analysis demonstrate promising performance of the proposed method.     

Testing the correlation for clustered categorical and censored discrete time-to-event data when covariates are measured without/with errors

In the analysis of clustered categorical data, it is of common interest to test for the correlation within clusters, and the heterogeneity across different clusters. We address this problem by proposing a class of score tests for the null hypothesis that the variance components are zero in random effects models, for clustered nominal and ordinal categorical responses. We extend the results to accommodate clustered censored discrete time-to-event data. We next consider such tests in the situation where covariates are measured with errors. We propose using the SIMEX method to construct the score tests for the null hypothesis that the variance components are zero. Key advantages of the proposed score tests are that they can be easily implemented by fitting standard polytomous regression models and discrete failure time models, and that they are robust in the sense that no assumptions need to be made regarding the distributions of the random effects and the unobserved covariates. The asymptotic properties of the proposed tests are studied. We illustrate these tests by analyzing two data sets and evaluate their performance with simulations.     

Multiple censored data in dentistry: A new statistical model for analyzing lesion size in randomized controlled trials

Caries infiltration is a novel treatment option for proximal caries lesions. The idea is to build a diffusion barrier inside the lesion to slow down or stop the caries progression. If a lesion still reaches a critical size, restorative treatment is required. Clinical trials investigating caries infiltration thus produce multiple censored ordinal data. Standard statistical models do not take into account this censoring, and we therefore propose the Multiple Ordered Tobit (MOT) model. The model is implemented in R and compared with standard approaches. Simulation studies demonstrate that for all sample sizes and scenarios the MOT model has the largest statistical power among all methods compared, and it is robust against heteroscedasticity to some extent. Finally, a comparison with dichotomous and ordinal scaled models shows that the use of metric data for the lesion size reduces the required sample size considerably.     

A Partitioning Deletion/Substitution/Addition Algorithm for Creating Survival Risk Groups

Summary Accurately assessing a patient’s risk of a given event is essential in making informed treatment decisions. One approach is to stratify patients into two or more distinct risk groups with respect to a specific outcome using both clinical and demographic variables. Outcomes may be categorical or continuous in nature; important examples in cancer studies might include level of toxicity or time to recurrence. Recursive partitioning methods are ideal for building such risk groups. Two such methods are Classification and Regression Trees (CART) and a more recent competitor known as the partitioning Deletion/Substitution/Addition (partDSA) algorithm, both of which also utilize loss functions (e.g., squared error for a continuous outcome) as the basis for building, selecting, and assessing predictors but differ in the manner by which regression trees are constructed. Recently, we have shown that partDSA often outperforms CART in so‐called “full data” settings (e.g., uncensored outcomes). However, when confronted with censored outcome data, the loss functions used by both procedures must be modified. There have been several attempts to adapt CART for right‐censored data. This article describes two such extensions for partDSA that make use of observed data loss functions constructed using inverse probability of censoring weights. Such loss functions are consistent estimates of their uncensored counterparts provided that the corresponding censoring model is correctly specified. The relative performance of these new methods is evaluated via simulation studies and illustrated through an analysis of clinical trial data on brain cancer patients. The implementation of partDSA for uncensored and right‐censored outcomes is publicly available in the R package, partDSA .     

Nonparametric models and methods for designs with dependent censored data: part I

We consider a nonparametric (NP) approach to the analysis of repeated measures designs with censored data. Using the NP model of Akritas and Arnold (1994, Journal of the American Statistical Association 89, 336-343) for marginal distributions, we present test procedures for the NP hypotheses of no main effects, no interaction, and no simple effects. This extends the existing NP methodology for such designs (Wei and Lachin, 1984, Journal of the American Statistical Association 79, 653-661). The procedures do not require any modeling assumptions and should be useful in cases where the assumptions of proportional hazards or location shift fail to be satisfied. The large-sample distribution of the test statistics is based on an i.i.d. representation for Kaplan-Meier integrals. The testing procedures apply also to ordinal data and to data with ties. Useful small-sample approximations are presented, and their performance is examined in a simulation study. Finally, the methodology is illustrated with two real life examples, one with censored and one with missing data. It is indicated that one of the data sets does not conform to any set of assumptions underlying the available methods and also that the present method provides a useful additional analysis even when data sets conform to modeling assumptions.     

Cox regression model with randomly censored covariates

This paper deals with a Cox proportional hazards regression model, where some covariates of interest are randomly right‐censored. While methods for censored outcomes have become ubiquitous in the literature, methods for censored covariates have thus far received little attention and, for the most part, dealt with the issue of limit‐of‐detection. For randomly censored covariates, an often‐used method is the inefficient complete‐case analysis (CCA) which consists in deleting censored observations in the data analysis. When censoring is not completely independent, the CCA leads to biased and spurious results. Methods for missing covariate data, including type I and type II covariate censoring as well as limit‐of‐detection do not readily apply due to the fundamentally different nature of randomly censored covariates. We develop a novel method for censored covariates using a conditional mean imputation based on either Kaplan–Meier estimates or a Cox proportional hazards model to estimate the effects of these covariates on a time‐to‐event outcome. We evaluate the performance of the proposed method through simulation studies and show that it provides good bias reduction and statistical efficiency. Finally, we illustrate the method using data from the Framingham Heart Study to assess the relationship between offspring and parental age of onset of cardiovascular events.     

Modeling longitudinal data with ordinal response by varying coefficients

This paper presents a smooth regression model for ordinal data with longitudinal dependence structure. A marginal model with cumulative logit link is applied to cope with the ordinal scale and the main and covariate effects in the model are allowed to vary with time. Local fitting is pursued and asymptotic properties of the estimates are discussed. In a second step, the longitudinal dependence of the observations is considered. Cumulative log odds ratios are fitted locally, which allows investigation of how the longitudinal dependence of the ordinal observations changes with time.     

Distribution-free regression analysis of grouped survival data

Methods based on regression models for logarithmic hazard functions, Cox models, are given for analysis of grouped and censored survival data. By making an approximation it is possible to obtain explicitly a maximum likelihood function involving only the regression parameters. This likelihood function is a convenient analog to Cox's partial likelihood for ungrouped data. The method is applied to data from a toxicological experiment.     

A Multiple Imputation Approach to Regression Analysis for Doubly Censored Data with Application to AIDS Studies

Sun, Liao, and Pagano (1999) proposed an interesting estimating equation approach to Cox regression with doubly censored data. Here we point out that a modification of their proposal leads to a multiple imputation approach, where the double censoring is reduced to single censoring by imputing for the censored initiating times. For each imputed data set one can take advantage of many existing techniques and software for singly censored data. Under the general framework of multiple imputation, the proposed method is simple to implement and can accommodate modeling issues such as model checking, which has not been adequately discussed previously in the literature for doubly censored data. Here we illustrate our method with an application to a formal goodness-of-fit test and a graphical check for the proportional hazards model for doubly censored data. We reanalyze a well-known AIDS data set.     

Novel Statistical Approaches for Non-Normal Censored Immunological Data: Analysis of Cytokine and Gene Expression Data

Background

For several immune-mediated diseases, immunological analysis will become more complex in the future with datasets in which cytokine and gene expression data play a major role. These data have certain characteristics that require sophisticated statistical analysis such as strategies for non-normal distribution and censoring. Additionally, complex and multiple immunological relationships need to be adjusted for potential confounding and interaction effects.

Objective

We aimed to introduce and apply different methods for statistical analysis of non-normal censored cytokine and gene expression data. Furthermore, we assessed the performance and accuracy of a novel regression approach in order to allow adjusting for covariates and potential confounding.

Methods

For non-normally distributed censored data traditional means such as the Kaplan-Meier method or the generalized Wilcoxon test are described. In order to adjust for covariates the novel approach named Tobit regression on ranks was introduced. Its performance and accuracy for analysis of non-normal censored cytokine/gene expression data was evaluated by a simulation study and a statistical experiment applying permutation and bootstrapping.

Results

If adjustment for covariates is not necessary traditional statistical methods are adequate for non-normal censored data. Comparable with these and appropriate if additional adjustment is required, Tobit regression on ranks is a valid method. Its power, type-I error rate and accuracy were comparable to the classical Tobit regression.

Conclusion

Non-normally distributed censored immunological data require appropriate statistical methods. Tobit regression on ranks meets these requirements and can be used for adjustment for covariates and potential confounding in large and complex immunological datasets.