DNA methylation and tissue culture-induced variation in plants

Summary Plant cells growing in an artificial culture environment make numerous genetic mistakes. These alterations are manifested as increased frequencies of single-gene mutations, chromosome breakages, transposable element activations, quantitative trait variations, and modifications of normal DNA methylation patterns. Evidence is presented that indicates a high frequency of DNA hypomethylation as the result of the tissue culture process. Fifteen percent of the methylation changes appear to have been homozygous in the original regenerated plants. A hypothesis is advanced that relates DNA methylation to the variety of genetic alterations found among maize tissue culture regenerants and their progenies. The epigenetic nature of DNA methylation raises questions concerning the stability of tissue culture-induced changes in self-pollinations and crosses. Presented in the Session-in-Depth Exploitation of Plant Cell Culture Variants at the 1992 World Congress on Cell and Tissue Culture, Washington, DC, June 20–25, 1992.     

Tissue culture‐induced genomic alteration in maize (Zea mays) inbred lines and F1 hybrids

Genomic alteration is a common phenomenon associated with plant tissue culture, which often encompasses genetic changes and epigenetic modifications (e.g. cytosine methylation). Here, we studied genomic alteration in maize by assessing calli and regenerated plants derived from three inbred lines (M17, J7 and JC) and two pairs of reciprocal F1 hybrids (pair I: M17/J7 and J7/M17 and pair II: M17/JC and JC/M17). By employing two molecular markers, the amplified fragment length polymorphism and methylation‐sensitive amplified polymorphism, we found that both types of genomic alterations occurred in calli and regenerated plants of all the studied maize inbred lines and F1 hybrids, but the extent and pattern of changes varied substantially across the genotypes. Among the three inbred lines, M17 showed markedly higher frequencies of both genetic (from 2.1% to 3.8%) and methylation alterations (from 6.5% to 9.9%, by adding up the various patterns) than the other two lines which showed similar frequencies for both types of alterations (genetic: 0.5–1.8%, methylation: 2.1–3.7%). Of the two F1 hybrid pairs, while pair I showed genetic variation frequencies similar to that of the inbred parent with lower changing frequency and pair II was intermediate of those of the parents, both pairs showed frequencies of methylation alteration more or less intermediate of those of their inbred parental lines. Parent‐of‐origin effects in both genetic and methylation changes were detected in only one of the hybrid pairs (primarily pair II) for a given changing pattern. Statistical testing confirmed the genotypic difference in both genetic and methylation (hypomethylation) alterations among the regenerants. Taken together, it could be concluded that the frequency and pattern of both genetic and cytosine methylation alterations in maize tissue culture were largely genetic context‐dependent traits, but stochasticity also played an important part. F1 hybrids were not significantly more stable than their inbred parental lines under tissue culture conditions.     

Genetic and epigenetic relationship in rye, Secale cereale L., somaclonal variation within somatic embryo-derived plants

In vitro regenerated plants of rye, Secale cereale L., Ailés and Merced cultivars, were studied to verify if genetic and/or epigenetic changes were promoted by in vitro conditions. Inter-simple sequence repeat (ISSR) fingerprints on HpaII/MspI-digested and uncut DNA were generated. DNA digested with methylation-sensitive isoschizomers revealed epigenetic modifications, while modification of ISSR patterns obtained with undigested DNA indicated genetic changes. With this technique, it was possible to study both genetic and/or epigenetic changes within the same DNA sequences. The frequency of plants with at least one variation was high: 73% and 30% of rye plants showed at least one genetic change, and 50% and 73% carried at least one methylation change, in the Ailés and Merced cultivars, respectively. Further analyses revealed that a considerable number of variable markers showed both types of modifications, indicative of both genetic and epigenetic changes. Moreover, genetic variation was related to the presence of the CCGG target in the analyzed bands. These results indicate the possible existence of a common mechanism connecting both types of variation.     

岩白菜属植物规模化繁殖及遗传稳定性

根据市场需求和野生资源现存状况, 筛选厚叶岩白菜(Bergenia crassifolia)、秦岭岩白菜(B. scopulosa)和岩白菜(B. purpurascens)进行规模化繁殖, 并利用ISSR分子标记对组培苗进行遗传稳定性分析。以顶芽为外植体, 筛选出MS+0.5 mg·L^-1 6-BA+0.01 mg·L^-1 NAA+2.0 mg·L^-1 V_C为最佳增殖培养基, 3种岩白菜属植物增殖系数分别为3.10、2.50和2.10; 在1/2MS+1.0 mg·L^-1 IBA+2.0 mg·L^-1 V_C培养基上, 3种岩白菜属植物生根率分别为85%、80%和75%; 在腐殖土:黄沙:珍珠岩=2:1:1 (v/v/v)的混合基质中, 移栽成活率分别为90%、85%和80%。规模化繁殖厚叶岩白菜20万株, 秦岭岩白菜2万株, 岩白菜1万株, 目前还在持续生产中。ISSR分子标记结果表明, 岩白菜后代遗传变异较大, 秦岭岩白菜后代遗传变异较小, 3个种在继代至第20代时出现了遗传变异; 岩白菜和秦岭岩白菜的平均遗传变异率随继代次数的增加而增加, 厚叶岩白菜的平均遗传变异率随继代次数的增加呈现不规律变化。     

Isozyme Variability in Plants Regenerated from Calli of Cereus peruvianus (Cactaceae)

Morphological and isozyme variation was observed among plants regenerated from callus cultures of Cereus peruvianus. Different morphological types of shoots (68%) were observed in 4-year-old regenerated plants, while no distinct morphological variants were observed in plants grown from germinated seeds. Isozyme patterns of 633 plants regenerated from calli and of 261 plants grown from germinated seeds showed no variation in isocitrate dehydrogenase isozyme, and the differential sorbitol dehydrogenase, alcohol dehydrogenase, malate dehydrogenase, acid phosphatase, and peroxidase isozyme patterns observed in regenerated plants were attributed to nonallelic variation. Allelic variation was detected at three isoesterase loci. The proportion of polymorphic loci for both populations was 13.6% and the deviation from Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium for the Est-1 and Est-7 loci observed in somaclones was attributed to the manner in which the regenerant population was established. The high values for genetic identity among regenerant and seed-grown plant populations are in accordance with the low levels of interpopulation genetic divergence. In somaclones of C. peruvianus, morphological divergence was achieved within a short time but was not associated with any isozyme changes and also was not accompanied by biochemical genetic divergence.     

Tissue culture-induced DNA methylation polymorphisms in repetitive DNA of tomato calli and regenerated plants

The propagation of plants through tissue culture can induce a variety of genetic and epigenetic changes. Variation in DNA methylation has been proposed as a mechanism that may explain at least a part of these changes. In the present study, the methylation of tomato callus DNA was compared with that of leaf DNA, from control or regenerated plants, at MspI/HpaII sites around five middle-repetitive sequences. Although the methylation of the internal cytosine in the recognition sequence CCGG varied from zero to nearly full methylation, depending on the probe used, no differences were found between callus and leaf DNA. For the external cytosine, small differences were revealed between leaf and callus DNA with two probes, but no polymorphisms were detected among DNA samples of calli or DNA samples of leaves of regenerated plants. When callus DNA cut with HindIII was studied with one of the probes, H9D9, most of the signal was found in high-molecular-weight DNA, as opposed to control leaf DNA where almost all the signal was in a fragment of 530 bp. Also, an extra fragment of 630 bp was found in the callus DNA that was not present in control leaf DNA. Among leaves of plants regenerated from tissue culture, the 630-bp fragment was found in 10 of 68 regenerated plants. This 630-bp fragment was present among progeny of only 4 of these 10 plants after selfing, i.e. it was partly inherited. In these cases, the fragment was not found in all progeny plants, indicating heterozygosity of the regenerated plants. The data are interpreted as indicating that a HindIII site becomes methylated in callus tissue, and that some of this methylation persists in regenerated plants and is partly transmitted to their progeny.     

Stability of potato (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Solanum tuberosum</Emphasis> L.) plants regenerated via somatic embryos,axillary bud proliferated shoots,microtubers and true potato seeds: a comparative phenotypic,cytogenetic and molecular assessment

The stability, both genetic and phenotypic, of potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) cultivar Desiree plants derived from alternative propagation methodologies has been compared. Plants obtained through three clonal propagation routes—axillary-bud-proliferation, microtuberisation and a novel somatic embryogenesis system, and through true potato seeds (TPS) produced by selfing were evaluated at three levels: gross phenotype and minituber yield, changes in ploidy (measured by flow cytometry) and by molecular marker analysis [measured using AFLP (amplified fragment length polymorphism)]. The clonally propagated plants exhibited no phenotypic variation while the TPS-derived plants showed obvious phenotypic segregation. Significant differences were observed with respect to minituber yield while average plant height, at the time of harvesting, was not significantly different among plants propagated through four different routes. None of the plant types varied with respect to gross genome constitution as assessed by flow cytometry. However, a very low level of AFLP marker profile variation was seen amongst the somatic embryo (3 out of 451 bands) and microtuber (2 out of 451 bands) derived plants. Intriguingly, only AFLP markers generated using methylation sensitive restriction enzymes were found to show polymorphism. No polymorphism was observed in plants regenerated through axillary-bud-proliferation. The low level of molecular variation observed could be significant on a genome-wide scale, and is discussed in the context of possible methylation changes occurring during the process of somatic embryogenesis.     

A genetic analysis of a tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) genotype with a high frequency of twin spots

Among pale-green tomato plants heterozygous for the xanthophyllic2 (xa-2) mutation that were transformed with a T-DNA harbouring the NPTII and GUS gene, a plant with a high frequency of green/white twin spots was found. The genetic analysis of this plant indicated that the occurrence of these twin spots was caused by a genetic defect located at the distal end of chromosome 10S, where xa-2 also is located. The genetic analysis of green plants regenerated from leaf expiants of this twin-spot plant revealed that the green sectors derive from non-disjunction of the xa-2 ⁺ allele. In an analysis of mitotic chromosome behaviour bridges were observed in approximately 5% of the anaphases, providing arguments that a breakage-fusion-bridge cycle caused by a tissue culture-induced genomic instability is the most likely cause of this aberrant behaviour of chromosome 10.     

Comprehensive molecular characterization of tissue-culture-derived Hordeum marinum plants

Summary Scuttelar calli of Hordeum marinum readily and efficiently regenerate functional plants. In order to assess genetic variability among the regenerants we employed multiple analytic tools, which included molecular and biochemical assays. Total DNA extract from regenerated plants was digested with at least two restriction enzymes and hybridized to four nuclear and six mitochondrial coding sequences, in addition to one nuclear and three mitochondrial noncoding probes. SDS-PAGE analyses of hordein extracted from seeds of regenerated plants and activity assays of -amylase were also performed. The nuclear and mitochondrial genomes of 50 regenerated plants demonstrated relative stability when assessed with coding sequences and by biochemical analyses. However, the mitochondrial noncoding probes revealed one qualitative somaclonal variant characterized by a loss of a hybridizing fragment. Moreover, changes in the methylation patterns of the rRNA genes and the nontranscribed spacer were revealed in another regenerated plant. The albino plant regenerated was characterized by a loss of three chloroplast DNA BamHI fragments.     

Genetic and epigenetic instability of amplification-prone sequences of a novel B chromosome induced by tissue culture in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Plantago lagopus</Emphasis> L.

Gene amplification is prevalent in many eukaryotes and has been found linked to various phenomena such as ontogenesis, carcinogenesis, in vitro culturing, neoplasia and drug resistance. Earlier, we reported a novel B chromosome in Plantago lagopus L., which was found to have arisen as a result of massive amplification of 5S rDNA. In addition, the chromosome is also composed of 45S rDNA and transposable elements. While the importance of gene amplification cannot be underestimated, its mechanism of origin is still unclear. Therefore, the aim of the present study was to determine whether amplification can be reactivated in the novel B chromosome. For this purpose, in vitro culture was used as stress. Three modes of tissue culture, i.e., direct, indirect and somatic embryogenesis were used for raising in vitro cultures. The variations due to genetic and epigenetic mechanisms were assessed in regenerants using molecular techniques, namely, PCR-RFLP, SSAP and MSAP. The retrotransposon-based molecular markers were applied to detect the polymorphism within transposable elements of in vitro regenerated and mother plants. We detected the variations that may be due to genetic changes either because of element recombination or activation of transposable elements which can lead to increase in the copy number. MSAP analysis revealed the differences in the DNA methylation pattern of the regenerants derived from novel chromosome bearing mother plants. Some regenerated plants were associated with increase and decrease in DNA methylation of both internal and external cytosine of the CCGG sequence.     

An evaluation of a new approach to the regeneration of Helichrysum italicum (Roth) G. Don, and the molecular characterization of the variation among sets of differently derived regenerants

A protocol for the induction of regeneration from leaves of Helichrysum italicum was established. Calli were found to form on the basal medium only when it was supplemented with thidiazuron (TDZ) alone or in combination with naphthalene acetic acid (NAA), with a percentage ranking of at least 80%. The hormone-free medium showed the highest percentage of shoot regeneration (62%) even though no callus formed. AFLP markers were employed to verify tissue culture-induced variation in the regenerated plantlets obtained by direct shoot regeneration or the indirect shoot regeneration process (callus formation). Seven out of the eleven AFLP primer pairs yielded polymorphic patterns. The average number of fragments per primer pair was 64.1. Singletons were represented by 12 (2.7%) fragments. Student’s T-test was performed both on the average number of shared fragments and on the nucleotide diversity, and no significant statistical difference was observed between the two regeneration treatments. These authors contributed equally to this work.     

Multi‐omics analyses reveal epigenomics basis for cotton somatic embryogenesis through successive regeneration acclimation process

Plant regeneration via somatic embryogenesis is time‐consuming and highly genotype‐dependent. The plant somatic embryogenesis process provokes many epigenetics changes including DNA methylation and histone modification. Recently, an elite cotton Jin668, with an extremely high regeneration ability, was developed from its maternal inbred Y668 cultivar using a Successive Regeneration Acclimation (SRA) strategy. To reveal the underlying mechanism of SRA, we carried out a genome‐wide single‐base resolution methylation analysis for nonembryogenic calluses (NECs), ECs, somatic embryos (SEs) during the somatic embryogenesis procedure and the leaves of regenerated offspring plants. Jin668 (R4) regenerated plants were CHH hypomethylated compared with the R0 regenerated plants of SRA process. The increase in CHH methylation from NEC to EC was demonstrated to be associated with the RNA‐dependent DNA methylation (RdDM) and the H3K9me2‐dependent pathway. Intriguingly, the hypomethylated CHH differentially methylated regions (DMRs) of promoter activated some hormone‐related and WUSCHEL‐related homeobox genes during the somatic embryogenesis process. Inhibiting DNA methylation using zebularine treatment in NEC increased the number of embryos. Our multi‐omics data provide new insights into the dynamics of DNA methylation during the plant tissue culture and regenerated offspring plants. This study also reveals that induced hypomethylation (SRA) may facilitate the higher plant regeneration ability and optimize maternal genetic cultivar.     

Facilitating the recovery of phenotypically normal transgenic lines in clonal crops: a new strategy illustrated in potato

Transgenic plants frequently exhibit altered phenotypes, unrelated to transgene expression, which are attributed to tissue culture-induced variation and/or insertional mutagenesis. Distinguishing between these possibilities has been difficult in clonal crops such as potato, due to their highly heterozygous background and the resulting inherent phenotypic variability associated with segregation. This study reports the use of transgene integration as a molecular marker to trace the clonal origin of single cells in tissue culture. Following transformation, multiple shoots have been regenerated from cell colonies of potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) and Southern analysis used to confirm their derivation from a single transformed cell. Analysis of phenotypic variation in field trials has demonstrated marked differences between these multiple regeneration events, the origin of which must have occurred after T-DNA insertion, and consequently during the tissue culture phase. This result unequivocally demonstrates that somaclonal variation occurs during tissue culture and independent of transgene insertion. Furthermore, the first shoots recovered do not necessarily exhibit less somaclonal variation, since later regeneration events can give rise to plants that are more phenotypically normal. Therefore, when developing transgenic lines for genetic improvement of clonal crops, multiple shoots should be regenerated and evaluated from each transformation event to facilitate the recovery of phenotypically normal transgenic lines.     

Morphological and molecular analysis of genetic stability in micropropagated Fragaria×Ananassa cv. pocahontas

Summary Micropropagated strawberry plants (Fragaria×ananassa L.) grown on 5 μM and 15 μM BA medium or cold-stored were grown in the field to examine morphological variation. Except for plant height, morphological characteristics did not differ for field-grown plants micropropagated on 5 μM and 15 μM BA medium. Cold-stored plants were less vigorous, both vegetatively and reproductively, than BA-treated plants. Random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers were used to determine if cold storage or supraoptimal levels of N⁶-benzyladenine (BA) in the culture medium caused genetic changes leading to somaclonal variation. No mutations were observed in 246 loci amplified by the 29 primers tested. Possible changes in methylation patterns of ribosomal DNA genes of strawberries were also examined. Changes in methylation patterns were observed in only one DNA sample from plants grown on 15 μM BA medium and in one of the cold-stored plants. Length polymorphism was observed in two samples from plantlets derived from one explant. The low levels of RAPD variation and methylation observed, and the apparently epigenetic changes in morphological characteristics in plants used in this study, indicated that mutations had not occurred. Part of a thesis submitted by M. B. K. in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the MS degree. The use of trade names in this publication does not imply endorsement by the U.S. Department of Agriculture or Oregon State University.     

Inter Simple Sequence Repeat Analysis to Confirm Genetic Stability of Micropropagated Plantlets in Three Grape (Vitis spp) Rootstock Genotypes

Three grape rootstock genotypes — Dogridge (Vitis champini), SO4 (V. beriandieri × V. rupestris) and H-144 (V. vinifera × V. labrusca), and their 30 in vitro regenerated plantlets were subjected to Inter Simple Sequence Repeat (ISSR) analysis in order to ascertain the genetic stability of micropropagated plantlets. Out of 35 primers screened initially with three mother plants, 10 were finally selected based on sufficient polymorphism and appearance of clear and scorable banding patterns. Each primer generated a unique set of amplification products ranging in size from 100 to 1800 bp. These ten ISSR primers produced 81 distinct and scorable band classes with an average of 8.1 bands per primer. Based on similarity matrix and cluster analysis the rootstock genotypes and their tissue culture derivatives formed three distinct genetic groups indicating their genetic relationships. Furthermore, no variation was detected among in vitro regenerated grape plantlets and their field-grown mother plants corroborating the high level of clonal fidelity of the in vitro regenerated plantlets and supporting the multiplication protocol utilizing nodal segments as in vitro culture initiation material.     

Detection of microsatellite instability during somatic embryogenesis of oak (Quercus robur L.)

Five microsatellite loci (QpZAG1/5, QpZAG9, QpZAG36, MSQ4, MSQ13) were used to test for genetic stability of three somatic embryogenic culture lines of Quercus robur L. and plantlets derived therefrom. DNA variation was detected among somatic embryos within all embryogenic lines, whereas no genetic instability was found among the regenerated plants. Two microsatellite loci revealed variation, and a locus-dependent instability was observed. The most polymorphic and useful microsatellite locus for detecting genetic variation was QpZAG9, with 28.5% of the investigated loci being variable.     

Evaluation of Genetic and Epigenetic Modification in Rapeseed （Brassica napus） Induced by Salt Stress

Salinity is an important limiting environmental factor for rapeseed production worldwide. In this study, we assessed the extent and pattern of DNA damages caused by salt stress in rapeseed plants. Amplified fragment length polymorphism （AFLP） analysis revealed dose-related increases in sequence alterations in plantlets exposed to 10-1000 mmol/L sodium chloride. In addition, individual plantlets exposed to the same salt concentration showed different AFLP and selected region amplified polymorphism banding patterns. These observations suggested that DNA mutation in response to salt stress was random in the genome and the effect was dose-dependant. DNA methylation changes in response to salt stress were also evaluated by methylation sensitive amplified polymorphism （MSAP）. Three types of MSAP bands were recovered. Type Ⅰ bands were observed with both isoschizomers Hpa Ⅱ and Msp Ⅰ, while type Ⅱ and type Ⅲ bands were observed only with Hpa Ⅱ and Msp Ⅰ, respectively. Extensive changes in types of MSAP bands after NaCI treatments were observed, including appearance and disappearance of type Ⅰ, Ⅱ and Ⅲ bands, as well as exchanges between either type Ⅰand type Ⅱ or type Ⅰ and type Ⅲ bands. An increase of 0.2-17.6% cytosine methylated CCGG sites were detected in plantlets exposed to 10- 200 mmol/L salt compared to the control, and these changes included both de novo methylation and demethylation events. Nine methylation related fragments were also recovered and sequenced, and one sharing a high sequence homology with the ethylene responsive element binding factor was identified. These results demonstrated clear DNA genetic and epigenetic alterations in planUets as a response to salt stress, and these changes may suggest a mechanism for plants adaptation under salt stress.     

Gynogenesis in gentians (Gentiana triflora, G. scabra): production of haploids and doubled haploids

Gynogenesis was investigated on gentian (Gentiana triflora, G. scabra and their hybrids), which is an important ornamental flower. When unfertilized ovules were cultured in 1/2 NLN medium containing a high concentration of sucrose (100 g/l), embryo-like structures (ELS) were induced. Although genotypic variation was observed in ELS induction, all four genotypes produced ELSs ranging from 0.93 to 0.04 ELSs per flower bud. The ovules collected from flower buds of later stages (just before anthesis or flower anthesis) tended to exhibit higher response. The dark culture condition produced more than four times as many ELSs than in 16-h light condition. A significant number of plantlets were directly regenerated from ELSs on MS regeneration medium. The ploidy levels of 179 regenerated plants were determined by flow cytometry, revealing that the majority of them were diploid (55.9%) and haploid (31.3%). When a total of 54 diploid plants were examined by molecular genetic markers, 52 (96.3%) were considered as doubled haploids (DHs). This is the first report showing successful gynogenesis in gentian. The production of haploids and DHs by unfertilized ovule culture opens a novel prospect in gentian F1 hybrid breeding.     

Detection of somaclonal variation of cotton (Gossypium hirsutum) using cytogenetics, flow cytometry and molecular markers

Two protocols of plant regeneration for cotton were adopted in this study, namely, 2, 4-D and kinetin hormone combination and IBA and kinetin hormone combination. Twenty-eight embryogenic cell lines via somatic embryogenesis and 67 regenerated plants from these embryogenic calli were selected and used for random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD), simple sequence repeat (SSR), chromosomal number counting, and flow cytometric analysis. The roles of RAPD and SSR markers in detecting somaclonal variation of cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) were evaluated. Two cluster analyses were performed to express, in the form of dendrograms, the relationships among the hormone combinations and the genetic variability. Both DNA-based techniques were able to amplify all of the cell clones and regenerated plantlets genomes and relative higher genetic variation could be detected in the culture type with 2, 4-D and kinetin hormone combination. The result suggested that 2, 4-D and kinetin hormone combination could induce relative high somaclonal variation and RAPD and SSR markers are useful in detecting somaclonal variation of regenerated cotton plants via somatic embryogenesis. Chromosome number counting and flow cytometry analysis revealed that the number of chromosomes and ploidy levels were nearly stable in all regenerated plants except two regenerated plantlets (lost 4 and 5 chromosomes, respectively) which meant that cytological changes were not correlated with the frequency of RAPD and SSR polymorphisms. This result also might mean that the cell lines with variation of chromosome numbers were difficult to regenerate plants.