The formation of supernumerary structures after grafting anterior quail wing bud mesoderm of various ages into chick wing buds

Wedges of anterior quail mesoderm grafted into posterior slits in the wing buds of chick embryo hosts result in the formation of rods and nodules of supernumerary cartilage in a high percentage of cases. Identifiable digits do not form unless the ectoderm is allowed to remain on the grafts. Control experiments have shown that wedges of anterior or posterior wing mesoderm placed into homologous locations of host wing buds produce few or no supernumerary skeletal structures. Anterior-to-posterior grafts of stage 17 mesoderm evoke a 71.4% incidence of supernumerary cartilage. This percentage increases to 100% with stage 22 donor mesoderm. The percentage of supernumerary structures formed declines markedly with donor mesoderm of stages 24-30. By stages 35-36, only 10% of the grafts result in the formation of supernumerary structures. The period of decline coincides with the onset of overt cytodifferentiation within the donor mesoderm.     

Retinoic acid respecifies limb bud cells in vitro.

Retinoic acid (RA) is known to have dramatic effects on limb pattern formation and has been shown to exert its effects on limbs by converting anterior limb bud cells into cells with posterior positional properties. In this study we find that dissociated posterior limb bud cells from chick and mouse embryos cultured at high density (micromass cultures) are able to stimulate the formation of supernumerary digits when grafted into developing wing buds and that the positional identity of both chick and mouse limb bud cells can be maintained for finite periods of time in vitro. Furthermore, using this assay system we have tested whether anterior cells from mouse and chick limb buds can be converted into cells with posterior identity by exposure to RA in vitro. We find that anterior limb bud cells acquire posterior properties after culture in the presence of RA.     

Temporal pattern of posterior positional identity in mouse limb buds

This study describes the temporal pattern of posterior positional identity in mouse limb bud cells. To do this wedges of tissue from the posterior edge of mouse limb buds at various stages (limb stages: Wanek et al., 1989b. J. Exp. Zool. 249, 41-49) were grafted to the anterior edge of a host chick embryo wing bud. Grafts of mouse posterior cells are able to induce the formation of supernumerary digits every time when they are taken from buds from stage 3 through stage 6. At stage 7, the frequency declines and by stage 8 the chick cells no longer respond. The results indicate a change in tissue properties at stage 7, which progresses by stage 8 to the point at which posterior positional identity is no longer detectable by this assay. These temporal changes in this aspect of limb pattern formation can be used as an additional criterion to guide the identification of genes involved in the specification of posterior positional identity.     

Stability of positional identity of axolotl blastema cells in vitro

Summary Previous grafting experiments have demonstrated that cells from non-contiguous positions within developing and regenerating limbs differ in a property referred to as positional identity. The goal of this study was to determine how long the positional identity of axolotl limb blastema cells is stable during culture in vitro. We have developed an assay for posterior positional properties such that blastema cells can be cultured and then grafted into anterior positions in host blastemas, to determine if they can stimulate supernumerary digit formation. We report that posterior blastema cells are able to maintain their positional identities for at least a week in culture. In addition, we observed that blastema cells are able to rapidly degrade collagenous substrates in vitro, a property that apparently distinguishes them from limb cells of other vertebrates. These results provide information regarding the time boundaries within which the positional properties of blastema cells can be studied and manipulated in vitro. Correspondence to: S.V. Bryant     

Intercalation and the cellular origin of supernumerary limbs in Xenopus

The hypothesis that a specialized polarizing zone controls the pattern of the anterior-posterior axis during limb development in Xenopus has been tested by analysing the cellular contribution to supernumerary limbs. Supernumerary limbs were generated by grafting hindlimb buds contralaterally between X. borealis and X. laevis to appose anterior and posterior limb tissues. Cells derived from these two species of Xenopus are readily identified by staining with quinacrine. The analysis of cellular contribution showed that supernumerary limbs consist of approximately half anterior-derived (57%) and half posterior-derived (43%) cells. These data are not consistent with the polarizing zone theory but are consistent with the hypothesis that both supernumerary limbs and normally developing limbs arise from intercalary interactions between limb bud cells with different positional values.     

A test of positional properties of avian wing-bud mesoderm

Supernumerary wing structures are readily produced by grafting pieces of wing-bud mesoderm into different locations of host wing buds, but the mechanism underlying their formation remains obscure. The major aim of this study was to examine the ability of posterior quail wing-bud mesoderm, cultured in vitro long enough to lose ZPA (zone of polarizing activity) activity, to stimulate or participate in the formation of supernumerary structures when grafted into anterior slits of host chick wing buds. Small pieces of anterior and posterior quail wing-bud mesoderm (HH stages 21-23) were placed in in vitro culture for up to 3 days. After 2 days, ZPA activity of cultured mesoderm was lost. After the grafting of 2- to 3-day cultured anterior quail wing-bud mesoderm into posterior slits of host chick wing-buds, a consistently high percentage (70%-90%) of grafts result in formation of supernumerary cartilage; in this experiment, however, only a low percentage of grafts resulted in supernumerary cartilage when 2- to 3-day cultured posterior mesoderm was grafted into anterior slits. Taken with controls, these results show that positional differences exist between cultured anterior and posterior wing-bud mesoderm. Serial-section analysis of numerous operated wings has shown several patterns of contribution to supernumerary structures by cells of graft and host. Single supernumerary digits induced by grafts of ZPA mesoderm into anterior slits were normally composed entirely of host cells, but graft cells regularly contributed to skeletal elements of more complex supernumerary structures. Cartilage rods produced by anterior-to-posterior grafts were composed mostly of graft cells, but cartilage nodules and the bases of some rods were often mosaics of chick and quail cells. The results support the proposition that mesodermal cells of the quail wing-bud possess a form of anteroposterior positional memory, but its nature and the means by which the memory of grafted cells interacts with host mesoderm are still not clear.     

Evidence that regenerative ability is an intrinsic property of limb cells in Xenopus

Xenopus laevis exhibits an ontogenetic decline in the ability to regenerate its limbs: Young tadpoles can completely regenerate an amputated limb, whereas post metamorphic froglets regenerate at most a cartilagenous "spike." We have tested the regenerative competence of normally regenerating limb buds of stage 52-53 Xenopus tadpoles grafted onto limb stumps of postmetamorphic froglets. The limb buds become vascularized and innervated by the host and, when amputated, regenerate limbs with normal or slightly less than normal numbers of tadpole hindlimb digits. Reciprocal grafts of froglet forelimb blastemas onto tadpole hindlimb stumps resulted in either autonomous development of tadpole hindlimb structures and/or formation of a cartilaginous spike typical of froglet forelimb regeneration. Our results suggest that the Xenopus froglet host environment is completely permissive for regeneration and that the ability to regenerate a complete limb pattern is an intrinsic property of young tadpole limb cells, a property that is lost during ontogenesis.     

Cellular contribution to supernumerary limbs resulting from the interaction between developing and regenerating tissues in the axolotl

The relationship between limb development and limb regeneration is considered with regard to the mechanisms by which pattern is established during limb outgrowth. In a previous paper (Muneoka, K. and Bryant, S. V. 1982 Nature (London) 298, 369-371) the interaction between cells from the developing limb bud and the regenerating limb blastema was found to result in the production of organized supernumerary limb structures. In this paper the relative cellular contribution from developing and regenerating cells to supernumerary limbs resulting from contralateral grafts between limb buds and blastemas has been analyzed using the triploid cell marker in the axolotl. Results show that there is substantial participation from both developing and regenerating limb cells to all supernumerary limbs analyzed. These data lend further support to the hypothesis that developing and regenerating limbs utilize the same patterning mechanisms during limb outgrowth. This conclusion is discussed in terms of patterning models for developing and regenerating limbs and it is proposed that the rules of the polar coordinate model can best explain the behavior of cells during limb development as well as limb regeneration.     

Role of the chicken homeobox-containing genes GHox-4.6 and GHox-8 in the specification of positional identities during the development of normal and polydactylous chick limb buds.

During early stages of normal chick limb development, the homeobox-containing (HOX) gene GHox-4.6 is expressed throughout the posterior mesoderm of the wing bud from which most of the skeletal elements including the digits will develop, whereas GHox-8 is expressed in the anterior limb bud mesoderm which will not give rise to skeletal elements. In the present study, we have examined the expression of GHox-4.6 and GHox-8 in the wing buds of two polydactylous mutant chick embryos, diplopodia-5 and talpid2, from which supernumerary digits develop from anterior limb mesoderm, and have also examined the expression of these genes in response to polarizing zone grafts and retinoic acid-coated bead implants which induce the formation of supernumerary digits from anterior limb mesoderm. We have found that the formation of supernumerary digits from the anterior mesoderm in mutant and experimentally induced polydactylous limb buds is preceded by the ectopic expression of GHox-4.6 in the anterior mesoderm and the coincident suppression of GHox-8 expression in the anterior mesoderm. These observations suggest that the anterior mesoderm of the polydactylous limb buds is "posteriorized" and support the suggestion that GHox-8 and GHox-4.6, respectively, are involved in specifying the anterior non-skeletal and posterior digit-forming regions of the limb bud. Although the anterior mesodermal domain of GHox-8 expression is severely impaired in the mutant and experimentally induced polydactylous limb buds, this gene is expressed by the prolonged, thickened apical ectodermal ridges of the polydactylous limb buds that extend along the distal anterior as well as the distal posterior mesoderm.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Interactions between irradiated and unirradiated tissues during supernumerary limb formation in the newt.

The interactions between irradiated and unirradiated blastemas and stumps in the newt forelimb were studied. Irradiated right blastemas at the stage of early digits were grafted to unirradiated left stumps and unirradiated left blastemas were grafted to irradiated right stumps. Grafts were oriented with their anterior-posterior axes opposed to that of the stumps. Supernumerary limbs ranging in completeness from one to four digits were found to arise predominantly on the anterior or posterior sides of the host limb. The graft developed well when the blastema was unirradiated and had reversed handedness with respect to the stump. Irradiated grafts developed poorly. On occasions, limbs with two supernumerary structures were found. The results are discussed in terms of the origin of the cells which comprise the supernumerary limbs and their bearing on a recently presented model concerned with pattern specification and regulation in epimorphic fields.     

Hensen's node,but not other biological signallers,can induce supernumerary digits in the developing chick limb bud

Summary The purpose of this study was to determine whether the organizer regions of early avian and amphibian embryos could induce supernumerary (SN) wing structures to develop when they were grafted to a slit in the anterior side of stage 19–23 chick wing buds. Supernumerary digits developed in 43% of the wings that received anterior grafts of Hensen's node from stage 4–6 quail or chick embryos; in addition, 16% of the wings had rods of SN cartilage, but not recognizable SN digits. The grafted quail tissue did not contribute to the SN structures. When tissue anterior or lateral to Hensen's node or lateral pieces of the area pellucida caudal to Hensen's node were grafted to anterior slits, the wings usually developed normally. No SN structures developed when Hensen's nodes were grafted to posterior slits in chick wing buds. Wings developed normally when pieces of the dorsal lip of the blastopore from stage 10–11.5 frog (Xenopus laevis and Rana pipiens) embryos were grafted to anterior slits. No SN digits developed when other tissues that have limb-inducing activity in adult urodele amphibians [chick otic vesicle, frog (Rana pipiens) lung and kidney] or that can act as heteroinductors in neural induction (rat kidney, lung, submaxillary gland and urinary bladder; mouse liver and submaxillary gland) were grafted to anterior slits in chick wing buds. SN digits also failed to develop following preaxial grafts of chick optic vesicles. These results suggest that although the anteroposterior polarity of the chick wing bud can be influenced by factors other than the ZPA (e.g., Hensen's node, retinoids), the wing is not so labile that it can respond to a wide variety of inductively-active tissues.     

Organization of positional information in the axolotl limb

We have used the phenomenon of position-dependent growth stimulation, brought about by the confrontation of cells with dissimilar positional values, to reveal the organization of positional information in the center of the upper and lower arms of axolotls. When either humerus or radius was transplanted into either dorsal or posterior positions, extra growth leading to the formation of supernumerary digits occurred following amputation through the graft. However, transplants of humerus or radius into anterior or ventral positions did not lead to the formation of any additional digits. The ulna by contrast was capable of stimulating supernumerary digit formation when transplanted into anterior, posterior, dorsal, or ventral positions. We interpret these results to indicate that the humerus and radius are surrounded by symmetrically arranged anterior and ventral positional values, whereas the ulna is surrounded by a complete asymmetrical set of angular positional values. We use our proposed arrangement for the positional information in the limb center to explain a number of previous experimental findings. In addition, we provide an explanation, in terms of the underlying positional information, for the structural and developmental relationships between the different skeletal elements of the vertebrate limb, and in particular for the anatomical pattern known as Gregory's pyramid.     

Preservation of the ability of dissociated quail wing bud mesoderm to elicit a position-related differentiative response

Previous studies showed that grafting wedges of fresh or cultured anterior quail wing mesoderm into posterior slits in chick wing buds resulted in the formation of supernumerary cartilage in a high percentage of cases. When anterior quail mesoderm, which had been dissociated into single cells and pelleted by centrifugation, was grafted into posterior slits of host chick wing buds, supernumerary rods or nodules of cartilage formed in 74.3% of the cases. Few supernumerary skeletal structures formed following control operations in which pelleted dissociated anterior or posterior mesoderm was grafted into homologous locations in host chick wing buds. When pelleted, dissociated anterior mesoderm was cultured in vitro for 1 or 2 days prior to being implanted in posterior locations, the incidence of supernumerary cartilage formation increased to 95.5% and 93.8%, respectively. The incidence of supernumerary cartilage formation following control orthotopic grafts of cultured mesoderm was 11.8% for 1-day and 31% for 2-day cultured anterior mesoderm; for 1- and 2-day cultured posterior mesoderm, the incidence of supernumerary cartilage formation was 20% and 41.7%, respectively. Longer-term culture resulted in a substantial decrease in the percentage of supernumerary cartilage after anterior to posterior grafts and an increase in the incidence of supernumerary cartilage from control grafts. The results demonstrate that quail anterior wing bud mesodermal cells do not need to maintain constant contact with one another in order to retain the ability to form or stimulate the formation of supernumerary cartilage after being grafted into a posterior location in a host wing bud. This ability is retained when the pelleted dissociated mesoderm is cultured in vitro outside the limb field for at least 1 to 2 days.     

Neurotrophin-independent attraction of growing sensory and motor axons towards developing Xenopus limb buds in vitro

The mechanisms for directing axons to their targets in developing limbs remain largely unknown though recent studies in mice have demonstrated the importance of neurotrophins in this process. We now report that in co-cultures of larval Xenopus laevis limb buds with spinal cords and dorsal root ganglia of Xenopus and axolotl (Ambystoma mexicanum) axons grow directly to the limb buds over distances of up to 800 microm and in particular to sheets of epidermal cells which migrate away from the limb buds and also tail segments in culture. This directed axonal growth persists in the presence of trk-IgG chimeras, which sequester neurotrophins, and k252a, which blocks their actions mediated via trk receptors. These findings indicate that developing limb buds in Xenopus release diffusible factors other than neurotrophins, able to attract growth of sensory and motor axons over long distances.     

Behavior of cells in artificially made cell aggregates and tissue fragments after grafting to developing hind limb buds in Xenopus laevis

During vertebrate limb development, the limb bud grows along the proximo-distal (P-D) direction, with the cells changing their adhesiveness. To know whether the position-related differences in cell adhesiveness are actually utilized by morphogenesis to constitute limb structures, we grafted cell aggregates made of dissociated cells derived from different positions and stages of developing hind limb buds into developing hind limb buds and observed the behavior of the cells. Cell aggregates made of dissociated mesenchymal cells from two different origins were implanted in different positions and stages of limb buds or grafted on limb stumps made by cutting. The two grafted cell populations in the aggregate always sorted out from each other, but their patterning of sorting-out was quite different according to the transplanted regions. In summary, cells in the aggregate that have closer positional identity to the transplanted site were always situated at the boundary between host and donor cells. The pattern of sorting-out seemed to be determined by the relative adhesiveness of surrounding cells to the constituent cells of the aggregates. We also transplanted fragments dissected out from different regions along the P-D axis into st. 50 limb buds. The descendants of grafted cells moved distally to the region corresponding to their positional identity and participated in the formation of more distal structures from that point. These results suggest that the difference in cell adhesiveness may probably play a role in arranging cells along the P-D axis of a developing limb bud.     

Cyclopamine induces digit loss in regenerating axolotl limbs

Axolotls, with their extensive ability to regenerate as adults, provide a useful model for studying the mechanisms of regeneration in a vertebrate, in hopes of understanding why other vertebrates cannot regenerate. Although the expression of many genes has been described in regeneration, techniques for gain and loss of function analyses have been limited. We demonstrated in a previous study that gain of function for secreted proteins was possible in the axolotl using the vaccinia virus to drive expression of the transgene. In this study, we used a pharmacological approach made possible by the existence of a naturally occurring compound that specifically blocks shh signaling, cyclopamine. The treatment of axolotls with cyclopamine during the process of limb regeneration caused a loss of digits similar to that described for the shh knockout mouse. Our results further demonstrate that shh signaling and function are conserved during limb regeneration in urodeles as in limb development in other vertebrates.     

Studies on the mechanism of retinoid-induced pattern duplications in the early chick limb bud: temporal and spatial aspects

All-trans-retinoic acid causes striking digit pattern changes when it is continuously released from a bead implanted in the anterior margin of an early chick wing bud. In addition to the normal set of digits (234), extra digits form in a mirror-symmetrical arrangement, creating digit patterns such as a 432234. These retinoic acid-induced pattern duplications closely mimic those found after grafts of polarizing region cells to the same positions with regard to dose-response, timing, and positional effects. To elucidate the mechanism by which retinoic acid induces these pattern duplications, we have studied the temporal and spatial distribution of all-trans-retinoic acid and its potent analogue TTNPB in these limb buds. We find that the induction process is biphasic: there is an 8-h lag phase followed by a 6-h duplication phase, during which additional digits are irreversibly specified in the sequence digit 2, digit 3, digit 4. On average, formation of each digit seems to require between 1 and 2 h. The tissue concentrations, metabolic pattern, and spatial distribution of all- trans-retinoic acid and TTNPB in the limb rapidly reach a steady state, in which the continuous release of the retinoid is balanced by loss from metabolism and blood circulation. Pulse-chase experiments reveal that the half-time of clearance from the bud is 20 min for all-trans- retinoic acid and 80 min for TTNPB. Manipulations that change the experimentally induced steep concentration gradient of TTNPB suggest that a graded distribution of retinoid concentrations across the limb is required during the duplication phase to induce changes in the digit pattern. The extensive similarities between results obtained with retinoids and with polarizing region grafts raise the possibility that retinoic acid serves as a natural "morphogen" in the limb.     

How trematodes cause limb deformities in amphibians

We used trematode cyst infestation to induce limb deformities in two species of frogs of the genus Rana and compared them to deformities induced by surgical limb bud rotations. The specific deformities produced by both treatments closely resemble those of wild-caught deformed amphibians and are consistent with a known developmental response to disruption of the spatial organization of cells in developing limb buds. Histological analysis showed that trematode cysts cause massive disruption and abnormal cellular growth involving the limb buds of infected individuals. Our results indicate that trematode cyst infestation causes deformities in frogs by perturbation of the positional relationships of cells in developing limb buds. The crippling effects of cyst-infection on frogs may reflect complex co-evolutionary interactions among trematodes, frogs, and other hosts in the trematode's life cycle.     

Hox-4 gene expression in mouse/chicken heterospecific grafts of signalling regions to limb buds reveals similarities in patterning mechanisms.

The products of Hox-4 genes appear to encode position in developing vertebrate limbs. In chick embryos, a number of different signalling regions when grafted to wing buds lead to duplicated digit patterns. We grafted tissue from the equivalent regions in mouse embryos to chick wing buds and assayed expression of Hox-4 genes in both the mouse cells in the grafts and in the chick cells in the responding limb bud using species specific probes. Tissue from the mouse limb polarizing region and anterior primitive streak respecify anterior chick limb bud cells to give posterior structures and lead to activation of all the genes in the complex. Mouse neural tube and genital tubercle grafts, which give much less extensive changes in pattern, do not activate 5'-located Hox-4 genes. Analysis of expression of Hox-4 genes in mouse cells in the grafted signalling regions reveals no relationship between expression of these genes and strength of their signalling activity. Endogenous signals in the chick limb bud activate Hox-4 genes in grafts of mouse anterior limb cells when placed posteriorly and in grafts of mouse anterior primitive streak tissue. The activation of the same gene network by different signalling regions points to a similarity in patterning mechanisms along the axes of the vertebrate body.